Save Ganga Presentation By Mallika Bhanot

GangaThe national river – Now a disappearing river

A matter of concern

• One Ganga – a symbol of national pride • Meaning of Ganga – Free flow• Full natural flow• Last existing stretch of free flowing Ganga• Disastrous local impact – fragile Himalayan

ecosystem• Environmental violations• Existing projects – overall feasibility

What are these dams?These are hydropower projects, beginning from Gangotri, designed in a series, one following the other one, lined up bumper-to-bumper.

There would be no river- once these proposed projects are complete.

Dams on Ganga

Himalayan Environment under threat

• Earthquake prone zone – Seismic zone V.

• Retreating Gangotri glacier – stored water in reservoirs, raising temperatures in vicinity

• Himalayan snow trout - endangered – obstructed migration path

• Golden mahasheer – endangered – due to decreased water in Ganga

• Bear, goral, leopard, Himalayan Otter –being affected

• Disrupted biodiversity• Disturbed river ecosystem• Home to many migratory birds

History of dams on Ganga – Ignored impacts –Maneri Bhali 1

• Functioning since last 30 years• Loss of 6 to 7 water sources in village Sirod during construction• Complete loss of water close to cremation grounds • The irrigated & fertile fields that once grew many cash crops,

are now dry• Maximum death & casualties were reported from village

Jhamak, under which the tunnel for the Maneri Bhali runs.• The villages around have to submit an application for releasing

water in the river, during the important functions

History of dams on Ganga – Ignored impacts –Maneri Bhali 2

• Dried water sources:– 13 villages close to Maneri Bhali – 2 (Dhanari Patti )now

left dry– Dhungi & Singuni: have PAID government water supply,

which supplies untreated water causing various diseases

– There are hand-pumps installed at various places, where orange coloured rusted water is supplied.

– Total drying up of Kairi Gad stream, that further impacted 10 other villages that were dependent on it for irrigation water.

• Loads of cement was thrown into the fields, the fields are still incapable of growing anything.

• Breeding of malarial mosquitoes is now rampant due to the stored water of reservoirs.

• Dried water sources – Deoli • The fogging done to prevent the breeding of

mosquitoes is leading to respiratory disorders.

Cement deposited in the fields during the construction Maneri Bhali-2.

*The pictures are stills from our documentary Tripathagamini

Dried water sourcees – after effects of Maneri Bhali 2

These are dried water sources in Deoli

History of dams on Ganga – Ignored impacts – Tehri

• Extensive land-slide situations have been cited because of the reservoir.

• The water is so polluted, that the locals do not even step in it

• Many cracks in houses (nakot)

• Problems with rehabilitation• Increased case of health

problems – stored water• Destruction of forest area

One of the frequent land-slides in Tehri reservoir

*The pictures are stills from our documentary Tripathagamini

Case of Visnugad power project - Joshimath

Chai gaon - Joshimath

Feasibility of these projects• The existing Maneri-Bhali 1 hydro power project of just 90MW, is working

at almost half its efficiency since the last ten years. The reasons stated in the RTI are:

– Increased silt in the river during monsoons– Decreased flow during winters.

• The problem of silt is only going to increase in the near future owing to melting of the glaciers, how then can a upstream project of 600MW function when on the same river a 90MW is not running to its capacity.

• Dropping water levels: Ganga was flowing at half her normal capacity last year. The global climate change has already seen this in cases of several other rivers.

Decreased production of electricity

Loharinag – Pala dam

• Location: 45kms from Gangotri• Present status: Temporarily stopped

with orders from NGRBA. Proposed to start by the govt.

• Installed capacity: 600MW

Construction of tunnelMuck deposited at the bank of the river

Clearances given to NTPC

• The clearance given to the NTPC for the construction of Loharinag-Pala was given on grounds such as:• Water sustainability study• Earthquake prone area so construction should be in

consideration• To maintain the ecological balance during construction• Monitor the muck dumping etc.

• It is also stated that the MoEF has the power to revoke the clearance if clearance conditions are not complied with. (Environment Protection Act – 1986)

Violations – EIA Report• During the public hearing, the details of the

project were asked in Hindi by the locals

• No cumulative effect of dam study has been done for these projects.

• The Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) clearly states that “No monument of national importance are being impacted through these projects”.

Violations –EIA Report

• The Akwekon guidelines, officially accepted by the Government of India, wherein the EIA must consist the social impact of a proposed project, were completely ignored.

• No water-sustainability study has been carried out in any of the EIA’s. • Through the RTI:• The water sustainability study was withdrawn later by MoEF• The NTPC had agreed to be in the process of conducting the study• Finally stated that the study had been withdrawn

The RTI’s enquiring the Glacier study

In 2006 – the study was given to NIHIn 2007 – it was not completed/ submitted by NIHIn 2009 – it was declared that the need for the study has been withdrawn long back

Violations – Local Impacts

• Cracks in houses• Drying up of drinking water

supplies• The routes to the villages

have collapsed/ sunken• Loss of crops in fields due to

the pollution with the ongoing construction

• Loss of grazing grounds• Increased case of health

problems

Excessive blasting – cracks – Therang – site for LHP Power house

Dried water sources – Loharinag-Pala

HURICompletely dried sources:

Pangraya khalNargad

There were 7 water mills that used to run in the village, now

only 1

SALANGOut of many

sources of water, only 1-2 are left

Dried water sources – Loharinag Pala

• Bhukki Village• All water sources have

dried up in the village, only 1 is left with meagre supply of water

• All crops have diminished. Only potatoes can be grown

Dried water sources – Loharinag-Pala

• Pala is one of the most affected places

• All water sources have dried

• People are paying 200-250/-mth for govt. water supplies

Dried water sources – - Kuryadi tok, -Ganala tok, -Dharmapani tok, -Uroronami tok, -Chauryanami tok, - Gangninami tok

Gangotri Rajmarg

•There have been several problems of frequent landslides on Gangotri rajmarg due to the blasting being carried out

•Due to the illegal dumping grounds, a lot of muck is deposited along the highway, thereby rendering the area extremely dangerous for travel

Violations –Environmental impact

• Decreased water flow in Ganga• Dried water sources – due to tunneling, spring

water sources have dried up• Muck dumping• The self-sufficient upstream villages have become

dependent on external sources• Destruction of forest• Cement spray on mountains to prevent the

landslides

Muck dumping in Ganga

Uncontrolled Blasting at Loharinag Pala & cracks in villages in vicinity

A case study of Kujjan• Total private land acquired by the NTPC: • 2.385 hectare +0.79 hectare (annexed NTPC office data)• Total: 3.175 hectares• Remaining land: 200 naalis * 0.020 = 4 hectares• Total loss of crops due to land loss: Rs.10,400/naali * • Total production of crops during the construction phase:

Rs.4,750/naali. Loss per naali = 10,400 – 4,750 = Rs.5,650

• It has been mentioned in the EIA, that during the construction phase of he project, the environment shall be polluted & there’ll be dust etc due to which the overall cultivation might be affected.

Based on the study it is pretty clear that the loss incurred by the entire village outweighs the projected gain by the NTPC. For the remaining many years the land that is lost to the project will bear the pain & the damage is irreparable & incomparable.

An overall trend with Hydro projects in Himalayas

• Several issues with Tehri – health hazards, landslides, cracks in houses, effect over villages even far from the reservoirs

• Problems after Maneri Bhali – 1 – the earthquake & casualities in Jhamak

• Problems after Maneri Bhali – 2 – Cement in their fields, complete loss of drinking water, diseases

• Vishnugad Tapovan – where 23-24 cusecs of water moved into the tunnel during construction

• Chai gaaon – where the houses are destroyed & the earth has sunken at many places

Similar trend in Loharinag-Pala – observed so far

• We are already seeing the dried water sources in the villages in vicinity

• We are already seeing cracks in the houses• The production has been severely affected• The cases of health problems have increased• There is cement deposited in the clean stretch of

Ganga• Mountains have become more fragile - Cement being

sprayed to keep the mountains intact

SUSTAINABILITY of LOHARI NAAG PALA

• Flawed cost benefit analysis – underrate cost & ignore many factors

• No valuation of the loss of natural habitat• Sustainability in light of ecological flow – cases

of fraud flow in Maneri Bhali every-time a committee came over for a visit

• Should we throw good money after bad money?

Environmental flow• Constant bargain for an environmental flow

• Environmental flow for A class rivers such as Ganga is actually her natural flow. On such rivers, no projects or construction should be proposed or executed, in order to maintain the special water quality of the river.

• Decreased water flow (since most it will be tunneled) means increased temperatures, loss of aquatic life & velocity.

• As has been seen in the case of Maneri-Bhali, under the banner of hydro power prjects, Ganga gets reduced into a mere rivulet.

Trickle of water Just After Maneri Bhali(I)

Stagnant Ganga Water and dry river bed up to 14 km. downstream of

Maneri bhali(I)

After Maneri Bhali(II)

Downstream of Maneri Bhali(II) up to 30 km. joins

Tehri Dam.

Conclusion• We vehemently oppose all dams on Ganga• All the projects (proposed & under construction) should be completely

scrapped – loharinag-pala, pala maneri, bhairon-ghati• A monitoring committee involving the locals & officials, to monitor atleast

50% of ecological flow from the already exisiting dams on Ganga & then in near future aim at their de-commissioning.

• A different view for himalayas.• The Gangotri valley should be developed as an ecologically sensitive zone

locals are given an incentive to protect the forests, the Ganga & the environment.

• Learn from the previous HEP’s & stop construction completely• If the flow of the river is not free then all efforts to keep it clean are futile