Running order: space, power and mobile subjectivities

BISR PG 2014Inside/Outside/

In-Between

Running Order: Space, Power and Mobile Subjectivities

Simon Cook

10 May 2014 Birkbeck, London

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

2

In-Place, Belonging and Citizenship

• Discursive relationship

• Have to feel in place …

• … and be accepted by others

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

3

Physical Exclusion

• ‘Within cities, [groups] have been discursively and physically excluded from the city’

(Till, 2012: p.8)

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

4

Physical Exclusion – Anti homeless benches

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

5

Everyday Actions of Power

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

6

Mobile Encounters

7

Training Diaries

Go-Along

Mobile-Video-Ethnography-

Elicitation

Interpreted from interviews

Running Routes

Negotiating Space

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

9

The Street and Codes of Conduct

• There are no natural conventions or codes of conduct for sharing the same spaces.

• Runners are often deemed responsible

Hockey and Allen-Collinson, 2007; 2013

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

10

Perspectives on Mobile Social Order

Encounters with responsibility:

• Runners

• Pedestrians

• Shared duty

Responsible Runners

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

12

Runners as Minority …

“No, I see it as my responsibility. I think everybody else is trying to use the environment in a relaxing way and there is me trying to use it in a more, probably productive but personal way so I think it is my job to not interrupt their free time in the way that because, because I can do that but I wouldn't expect a hundred people to move out of their way to avoid me and my free time … I think that would be selfish because clearly there aren't as many runners as there are dog walkers for example … we are probably inconveniencing their space.”

John – Go Along

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

13

… but NOT deviant

Author: “So do you think you're misusing space as a runner- using it for something it wasn't built for perhaps?”

John: “No, because I think these places where built for it! I think these days, perhaps not originally, obviously this is a manor house park, but at some point somebody went - 'we'll turn that into a public park' and they must have known that people that want to go for a run are gonna use that; and if they didn't - they weren't thinking.”

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

14

Speed

• “I think I would take responsibility because I’m the one moving faster”

Herbert – Go Along

• “It my responsibility to make sure we don’t hit each other because I’m going faster.”

Ben – Video Ethnography

Responsible Pedestrians

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

16

Speed

• “Because they’re walking and I’m running, they can get out of my way.”

Dan – Video Ethnography

Shared Duty

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

18

The Diplomatic Viewpoint

• “I always think it is our responsibility as much as anyone else’s.”

Ed – Go Along

• “Well it [the responsibility] would be both of ours”

Jackie – Video Ethnography

Passing Pedestrians

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

20

Spatial Tactics

• Choosing a side

• Stepping Down

• Slaloming

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

21

Choosing a Side

“I kind of like duck to one side as an indication saying I’m leaving you space to get past this side – kind of take the hint or I will run into you”

Steve – Video Ethnography

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

22

Choosing a Side

A) Approaching pedestrian on the right-hand side

B.Notice pedestrian is heading for runner’s line of movement

C) On a collision course

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

23

Choosing a Side

D) Choosing a side E. Pedestrian noticing the switch

F) Space successfully negotiated

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

24

Stepping Down

A) Approaching pedestrian and dog from behind. Weighing up unpredictability of the dog with the empty road

B.Deciding to step down C) Stepping back up after accomplishing passing by

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

25

Stepping Down

• “I would much rather be the person who got in the road than move somebody else into the road because I would feel like that would be my responsibility. I mean they are not going to die but say if something happened in that second, that would be my fault.”

John – Go Along

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

26

Slaloming

A) Approaching from behind

b) Aiming to pass by on the left

C) On a collision course

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

27

Slaloming

D) Change in direction E. Overtaking on the right

F) Return to original position

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

28

Slaloming

“I saw it from a while off. I just squeezed through, it would take less time to squeeze through than go round to the left and I won’t have to go back on myself.”

Dan – Video Ethnography

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

29

Passing Pedestrians

• No consensus

• Solutions are made momentarily and on the run

• Not random or mindless choices (although often unreflexive)

• There is a value-action gap

Mobile Citizenship

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

31

Right to Space and Mobile Citizenship

• Physical movement would suggest runners subordinate to pedestrians

• But what else affects being ‘in place’?

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

32

Developing the Research

• ‘Within cities, [groups] have been discursively and physically excluded from the city’

(Till, 2012: p.8)

• ‘The idea of ordinariness … fuses legal structures, normative orders and the experiences of individuals, social groups and communities’

(Staeheli et al, 2012: p.628)

BISR PG 2014Inside/

Outside/In-Between

33

Questions?

Simon Cook

Royal Holloway University of London

Simon.Cook.2013@live.rhul.ac.uk

@SimonIanCook