An Ontological View of Canonical Citations

An Ontological View of Canonical Citations

Matteo Romanello1 Michele Pasin1

1Department of Digital HumanitiesKing’s College London

Digital Humanities conference 2011Stanford, California

21 June 2011

Romanello, Pasin (DDH) HuCit DH2011 1 / 14

Project Context

PhD at the DDH, KCLdiscussion started during an internal Knowledge RepresentationseminarHuCit: ontology for the citations in the Humanitiespart of a domain ontology for Classicsapplication: knowledge base to support the automatic extraction ofcitations from text

Romanello, Pasin (DDH) HuCit DH2011 2 / 14

Related Work

Ontology EngineeringCiTO, Citation Typing OntologySWAN Ecosystem, esp. Scientific Discourse OntologyOpenCyc

Canonical CitationsCanonical Text Services (CTS), Harvard Univ.Classical Works Knowledge Base (CWKB), Cornell Univ.

Romanello, Pasin (DDH) HuCit DH2011 3 / 14

Canonical Citations

Motivation

precision of references to texts

persistency of citations

interoperability of citations across editions

Characteristics

are not tight to a specific edition of a text (loosely coupled)

canonical: result of an agreement within a specific community of practice

Examples

Hom. Il. 1.1

Athen. Deipn, X 412a

Arist. Poetics 1451a35-b6

Romanello, Pasin (DDH) HuCit DH2011 4 / 14

Citing Aristotle

Bekker numbersI derived from his edition (1831-1870) of Aristotle’s worksI used by all scholarly editions

citation structure:I 1451a35I page / column / lineI / [0-9]{4}[a-z]{1}[0-9]+ /

alternative citation structure:I eg: VIII 4 - IX 3I medieval systemI book / chapter / sentence

Similar systems:I Stephanus page (Plutarch)I Casaubon page (Athenaeus)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bekker_numbers

Romanello, Pasin (DDH) HuCit DH2011 5 / 14

Citations in a print environment

Butcher’s edition (1922) p. 34 and Bekker’s edition (1831) p. 184

Romanello, Pasin (DDH) HuCit DH2011 6 / 14

FRBR in a nutshell

FRBR: Functional Requirements for Bibliographic RecordsWork: the abstract content of a Work (substance is concepts)Expression: the text of a Work (substance is signs)Manifestation: the physical carrier of an Expression

ExampleWork: The abstract content of Homer’s IliadExpression: The text of Iliad in the Italian translation by the poetVincenzo Monti (XIX century)Manifestation: A copy of V. Monti, Iliad, Milano : Mondadori, 1995[isbn: 8804394846]

Romanello, Pasin (DDH) HuCit DH2011 7 / 14

HuCit’s Overview

Romanello, Pasin (DDH) HuCit DH2011 8 / 14

A Canonical Citation (macro level)

Romanello, Pasin (DDH) HuCit DH2011 9 / 14

Citation Styles

Romanello, Pasin (DDH) HuCit DH2011 10 / 14

Canonical Citation as resolvable pointer

Romanello, Pasin (DDH) HuCit DH2011 11 / 14

Citation Scheme and Textual Structure

Romanello, Pasin (DDH) HuCit DH2011 12 / 14

Textual Structure and Expressions

Romanello, Pasin (DDH) HuCit DH2011 13 / 14

Wrap up

Contributiona conceptual model of how canonical citations worka more abstract / application-independent model to encodesemantics of canon. citationsinteroperability with other standards/protocols for canonicalcitations (CTS, CWKB)small ontology but mapped to other ontologies (CIDOC-CRM andFRBRoo)

Ontology populationcitations extracted from texts (JSTOR, APh)textual structures to be extracted from TEI encoded texts(Perseus)reasoning over the KB to support automatic extraction

Romanello, Pasin (DDH) HuCit DH2011 14 / 14