View
3
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
ABSTRACT
Objectives: Biopsy quality is an essential factor for successful diagnosis of canine liver disease.
Several minimally invasive methods to obtain diagnostic liver biopsies have been described. The aim
of this study was to compare weight and volume of the samples, surgical time required, possible
complications and histological quality between liver biopsies obtained laparoscopically with a pre-tied
ligating loop (PLL) and cup biopsy forceps (CBF).
Materials and Methods: Fifteen client owned dogs underwent laparoscopic liver biopsies for
diagnosis of liver disease. Biopsies were obtained from the same liver lobe using a PLL and CBF. The
resulting biopsies were evaluated for; weight, volume, histological value and the surgical time
required and compared. Any surgical complications were recorded.
Results
Samples obtained with the PLL were significantly heavier and larger in volume than those obtained
with CBF. Samples obtained with the PLL contained significantly more portal tracts and less crush
and fragmentation artefact than the ones obtained with CBF. The duration required to obtain a liver
biopsy with the PLL was approximately double of that of the CBF.
Clinical significance
The use of a PLL is a good alternative technique to the CBF when performing laparoscopic liver
biopsies in dogs.
KEYWORDS: Soft Tissue-General, Laparoscopy, Pre-tied ligating loop, Liver biopsy, Hepatic
biopsy.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
INTRODUCTION
Liver biopsy is integral in the diagnosis, treatment and assessment of prognosis of hepatic disease
(Rockey et al. 2009, Rothuizen and Twedt 2009). However, each available liver biopsy method
presents with specific limitations and risks. The main methods available are fine needle aspiration,
ultrasound guided core needle biopsies, laparoscopy, and open abdominal surgery.
Fine needle aspiration and core needle biopsy are the less invasive and inexpensive options available.
Fine needle aspiration can be diagnostic in some neoplastic processes and vacuolar disorders,
however, cytology does not allow appreciation of structural changes in the liver (Rothuizen and
Twedt 2009). Furthermore, agreement between histopathological diagnosis obtained with needle
biopsy and cytological diagnosis was only found in 30.3% of canine cases and 51.2% of feline cases
in one study (Wang et al. 2004).
Ultrasound guided core needle biopsies are minimally invasive and are usually performed without the
need of general anaesthesia or specialised equipment other than the needle. A study comparing needle
biopsies with surgical wedge biopsies identified agreement in morphological diagnosis in 56-67% of
the paired samples. This study concluded that needle biopsy specimens of the liver of dogs and cats
must be interpreted with caution (Cole et al. 2002). Transjugular liver biopsy is a technique
commonly used in human patients but only one cadaveric study has been published in dogs with a
high complications rates reported (Levien et al. 2014).
Laparoscopy is a minimally invasive method which allows direct visualisation of the liver whilst
obtaining biopsies and resulting in less postoperative pain (Devitt et al. 2005) and a faster return to
normal activity (Culp et al. 2009) in comparison to an open approach. The traditional sampling
instrument used in laparoscopic liver biopsies are the cup biopsy forceps (CBF), which provide a
sample of a maximum volume depending on the size of the forceps. The size of the collected sample
is important and recommendations in the human literature state that it should contain a representative
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
amount of parenchyma including more than 11 portal tracts (Rockey et al. 2009). Furthermore, a
study in human patients showed a correlation between fragment size and number of portal tracts and
found that advanced fibrosis was linked to the representation of less than 11 portal tracts (Coral et al.
2016).
Biopsy quality is an essential factor for successful diagnosis of liver biopsies. In the veterinary
literature, two previous studies looking at the quality of canine hepatic biopsies reported only 8-13
portal tracts in one study (Petre et al. 2012) and a mean of 3.4 portal tracts in another (Kemp et al.
2015b) in biopsies obtained with CBF. The latter study also compared methods and found no
statistical significant difference in the number of portal tracts between samples taken with the CBF
and with core needle biopsy (Kemp et al. 2015b). The size of the sample has also shown to affect the
concentration of metal detected and being statistically significantly lower in the core needle biopsy
method in comparison to wedge biopsy specimens in canine livers due to the smaller size of core
needle biopsies (Johnston et al. 2009). Therefore, there are limitations with all the techniques
available and there is scope for better techniques.
A pre-tied ligating loop (PLL) has been previously used to perform liver lobectomies and liver
biopsies in open surgery with low perioperative complications (Cuddy et al. 2013, Goodman and
Casale 2014). This technique allows collection of a biopsy sample of variable size depending on the
amount of tissue incorporated in the loop. PLLs are available for use in laparoscopy and have been
previously used for laparoscopic ovariectomy in horses (Boure et al. 1997) and sheep (Barros et al.
2015), orchiectomy in abdominal cryptorchidism in dogs (Oviedo Peñata and Hernandez Lopez 2013)
and horses (Fischer and Vachon 1998) and also for thoracoscopic and thoracoscopic-assisted lung
lobectomy in dogs (Faunt et al. 1998, Pramatwinai et al. 2006) and horses (Relave et al. 2008).
However, the use of a PLL to obtain laparoscopic liver biopsies has never been reported in dogs.
In the authors’ experience, the sample obtained with CBF can contain less than 11 portal tracts and
show marked crush and fragmentation artefact, making histological diagnosis challenging.
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
Furthermore, the amount of tissue obtained in one cup is often insufficient for copper analysis and
extra biopsies need to be obtained for this purpose.
We hypothesise that the PLL is a method as safe as the CBF to obtain laparoscopic liver biopsies in
dogs with similar complication rates than previously reported. In addition, we hypothesise the volume
and weight of the samples collected with the PLL will be statistically significantly larger and of better
histological quality (i.e. higher number of portal tracts and reduced frequency of sampling artefacts),
than biopsies obtained with CBF from the same liver lobeThe aim of this study was to compare the
surgical time, weight and volume of the biopsies, possible complications and histological quality of
the samples obtained between laparoscopic PLL and CBF.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Animals and inclusion criteria
Based on a power of 0.80 and an alpha error of 0.05 to detect an estimated difference of 25% in tissue
sample volume, the target sample size was a minimum of 14 cases. Seventeen dogs with suspected
diffuse hepatopathy were originally recruited in the study; however, two dogs were excluded because
a large solitary liver mass was identified on laparoscopy and the procedure was converted to an open
coeliotomy and liver lobectomy. Finally, fifteen privately owned dogs undergoing laparoscopic liver
biopsies for suspected diffuse liver disease between January 2016 and December 2016 were enrolled
in the study. Informed consent was obtained from the owners and the project was accepted by the
Veterinary Ethical Research Committee (VERC 68/15). Seven of the 15 cases underwent gallbladder
bile aspiration as an additional procedure at the time of surgery.
Previous investigations
All cases underwent diagnostic tests prior to the procedure including haematology, serum
biochemistry, coagulation panel, endocrine disease screening tests, abdominal ultrasound and fine
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
needle aspiration. All dogs had a platelet count, prothrombin time (PT) and partial thromboplastin
time (PTT) performed within two weeks prior to the procedure.
Anaesthetic protocol
Dogs were premedicated according to the anaesthetist preference. Induction was performed with
either propofol (Propoflo Plus, Zoetis) or alfaxolone (Alfaxan, Jurox) to effect. General anaesthesia
was maintained with isoflurane (IsoFlo, Abbott) or sevoflurane (SevoFlo, Abbott) in oxygen. Intra-
operative analgesia was selected according to the preferences of the attending anaesthetist.
Perioperative intravenous antibiotics were administered at induction or after obtaining a biopsy for
bacterial culture using cefuroxime (Zinacef, GlaxoSmithKline) (20 mg/kg).
Surgical technique
Dogs were placed in dorsal recumbency and the ventral abdominal hair was clipped from the xiphoid
to the pubis. The area was aseptically prepared and draped as for a ventral midline coeliotomy. In all
cases, the surgical procedure was performed by the main author as the primary surgeon. Surgical
assistance was provided by either a board-certified surgeon (n=3), another surgical resident (n=10) or
an undergraduate veterinary student (n=2).
A modified Hasson technique (Humphrey and Najmaldin 1994) was used to introduce a 6-mm trocar-
cannula (Storz) assembly 1-1.5cm caudal to the umbilicus. If ascites was present, a Poole suction tip
was introduced through the incision and the peritoneal fluid was suctioned prior to insufflation. The
abdomen was insufflated to 8 to 12 mm Hg with carbon dioxide by means of a pressure regulating
mechanical insufflator (Storz). A 5 mm 0 or 30 telescope (Storz) was introduced. A second 6 mm
blunt trocar-cannula assembly was placed under direct visualisation through an incision, also
performed with an 11 scalpel blade, in the left or right cranial abdominal quadrant. A third, 11 mm
blunt trocar-cannula assembly was placed on the contralateral side under direct visualisation through
an incision performed with an 11 scalpel blade. The abdomen and liver were explored with the aid of
a blunt probe and any abnormalities were recorded. Selection of the liver lobes from which biopsies
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
were collected was based upon; the presence of local or diffuse macroscopic abnormalities, the
available access and the potential risks associated with the localisation of the lesion within the liver. A
cup biopsy sample and a wedge biopsy, performed with the PLL, were obtained from the same liver
lobe as detailed below. The order in which the biopsies were obtained was randomised using a toss of
a coin online programme (https://www.random.org/coins/).
After the biopsies were obtained, the biopsy sites were immediately observed for haemorrhage.
Haemorrhage associated with each procedure was recorded as none, mild, moderate or severe. Mild
haemorrhage was defined as not needing any intervention, moderate haemorrhage was recorded when
a collagen haemostatic agent (Lyostypt, B. Braun Medical Ltd) or a second PLL was needed and
severe haemorrhage was recorded when the procedure was converted to an open coeliotomy or when
blood products were administered as a result of haemorrhage.
The abdomen was actively deflated prior to closure. All wounds were closed in three layers using
monofilament absorbable suture material (PDS, Ethicon). The skin was sutured with an intradermal
pattern using monofilament absorbable suture (Monocryl, Ethicon).
The total surgery time was recorded, as well as specific times for: time to establish the two 6 mm
ports, time to establish the 11 mm port, time for observation of the abdomen, time to obtain the
gallbladder bile aspirate (n=7), time to harvest biopsies using CBF, time to harvest a wedge biopsy
with the PLL, time to observe for haemorrhage, time for closure of the two 6 mm wounds and time for
closure of the 11 mm wound.
Cup biopsy technique (CBF)
Five mm CBF (Storz) were used to obtain biopsies from different liver lobes. The number of biopsies
depended on the estimated tissue required for diagnosis. The biopsy forceps were introduced into the
liver with the jaws in the open position. The liver lobe was lifted ventrally, away from the other
abdominal organs with the bottom jaw. The forceps were advanced towards the liver and closed to
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
grasp the biopsy. The forceps were held in this locked position for approximately 15 seconds (Twedt
and Monnet, 2003) before the laparoscopic cannula was advanced over the forceps until contacting
the liver. At this point, the forceps were withdrawn, pulling the tissue sample from the liver. This
technique prevented tearing of the liver tissue adjacent to the biopsy site.
All the biopsies obtained were weighed and measured in three dimensions (length, width and height)
in a sterile manner by the main author (NF) with the same scales and ruler. One of the samples from
the same liver lobe as the PLL sample was always submitted for histological analysis. Any remaining
cup biopsies were submitted for bacterial culture or added for mineral analysis depending on the
analytical requirements of the case.
Pre-tied Ligating Loop wedge biopsy technique (PLL)
A 3-0 polydiaxonone pre-tied suture loop (Endoloop, Ethicon) was introduced through the lateral
6mm cannula. A pair of endoscopic Babcock (Storz) forceps were introduced from the contralateral
side (11mm cannula) and passed through the pre-tied loop (Figure 1). The liver lobe was grasped and
lifted ventrally with the endoscopic Babcock forceps. The pre-tied loop was passed around the end of
the liver lobe and the suture was pulled tight whilst advancing the plastic applicator to create a wedge
biopsy using the suture fraction or ‘guillotine’ technique. The suture end was then cut with
endoscopic scissors through the same cannula by which it was introduced and then the scissors were
used to cut the liver parenchyma approximately 5 mm distal to the suture to allow a decent cuff of
tissue to prevent suture slipping. The biopsy was followed with the camera to ensure it could be safely
retrieved through the 11mm cannula.
All the biopsies obtained were weighed and measured in the same way as described for the CBF
biopsies. The wedge obtained with the PLL was divided with a scalpel blade in two portions
macroscopically similar in size and the two portions were weighed and measured again. One of the
portions was submitted for histological analysis and the other for mineral analysis.
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
Histological preparation for analysis
The samples for histopathology were fixed in 10% neutral buffered formalin for at least 24 hours. All
samples were trimmed in the same manner (i.e. longitudinally to a slice thickness of 2-3mm), and then
processed for histology and haematoxylin and eosin staining using standard protocols. The sections
were then assessed for total cut area of tissue available, number of portal tracts, degree of crush and
fragmentation artefacts, subjective diagnostic value and histological diagnosis. The score used for
both crushing and fragmentation artefacts had four values, ranging from 0-absent to 3-severe (Figure
2).
Postoperative period and follow-up
Postoperative analgesia was provided with intravenous methadone (Comfortan, Eurovet Animal
Health) boluses (0.1-0.2 mg/kg) every 4 hours for the first 8h and intravenous buprenorphine
(Buprecare, Animalcare) boluses (20 µg/kg) q 8 hours until discharge.
All dogs were hospitalised for a minimum of 12 hours and the hospitalisation time was recorded.
Dogs discharged from the hospital were prescribed a five to seven-day course of oral tramadol
(Bristol Laboratories Ltd) (2-3 mg/kg, p.o., q 8-12h). Dogs requiring a change in the analgesia plan
were recorded. An Elizabethan collar was placed at time of recovery from anaesthesia, and all dogs
were discharged with it.
Dogs that survived to hospital discharge were examined 10-14 days postoperatively. The wounds
were examined and a questionnaire was completed by the consulting veterinarian (ECVS resident)
(appendix 1). The questionnaire used was a modification from the questionnaire used for surveillance
of surgical site infections (SSI) in people, provided by the Centre of Disease Control and Prevention
(CDC) (www.cdc.gov).
Further follow-up was performed four to six weeks after the procedure by routine rechecks or by
telephone contact of the owners or referring veterinarian.
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
Complications during the follow-up period were recorded and classified as minor or major.
Complications treated with medical management or dressings were considered minor and
complications requiring a second intervention were considered major. Survival time after surgery was
also recorded for dogs that died or were euthanized in the study period.
Statistical analysis
Descriptive statistics were calculated for all recorded variables (categorical and continuous).
Statistical differences of continuous variables between groups were assessed with a paired t-test for
normally distributed variables and a 1-sample Wilcoxon Signed Rank test for ordinal variables. The
significance threshold was set at p<0.05. All the data was collated and described in Excel (2006,
Microsoft, US), and statistical analysis were conducted in Minitab Express statistical software
(version 1.5.0, Minitab).
RESULTS
Animals
The mean body weight of the dogs in the study was 21.5 (±11.3SD) Kg, and the breeds included
Mixed-breed dogs (n=4), Tibetan terriers (n=2), Labradors (n=2), and one of each Shih Tzu, Border
Collie, German Shepherd, West Highland White Terrier, Bichon Frisé, Dalmatian and Staffordshire
Bull Terrier. There were six males and nine female dogs and the mean age was 6.7 (±3.2) years.
Five (33.3%) of 15 dogs had a low platelet number (<200 x 109/l) with a mean platelet count of 142.0
(±33.7) x 109/l. Two different analysers were used to measure prothrombin time (PT) and activated
partial thromboplastin time (aPTT). Only one dog showed a mildly increased PT at 16.9 s (ref. 5-12 s)
and this dog received an intraoperative fresh frozen plasma transfusion.
Laparoscopy
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
The mean time to obtain 2-3 biopsies with CBF was 8.3 (±3.7) minutes, whereas the mean time to
obtain a biopsy with a PLL was 22.4 (±13.3) minutes. The time to obtain one biopsy with a PLL was
significantly longer than the time to obtain 2-3 biopsies with the CBF (Table 1). The mean total
surgery time was 78 (±24.1) minutes. Placement and closure of the first and second ports (6 mm) took
a mean time of 11.3 (±5.8) and 11.6 (±3.56) minutes respectively and placement and closure of the
third port (10mm) took a mean time of 2.8 (±1.6) and 5.2 (±1.57) minutes respectively. A mean time
of 5.4 (±2.3) minutes was used for initial observation of the abdomen and a mean time of 4.33 (±4.81)
minutes was used to observe for haemorrhage once the biopsies were obtained. Finally, gallbladder
bile aspiration was performed in a mean time of 14.1 (±10) minutes (n=7).
There were no major intraoperative or postoperative complications, and biopsies were successfully
obtained with the PLL and the CBF in all cases. The biopsies submitted for histopathology were
obtained from the left lateral liver lobe (n=6), left medial lobe (n=5), right medial lobe (n=2), right
lateral (n=1) and quadrate lobe (n=1). Three cases required a second PLL; in one case the ligature was
cut with scissors inadvertently whilst obtaining the biopsy and a second loop was used to control the
haemorrhage and in the two other cases the first loop was tightened before placing it around the liver
lobe and could not be re-used.
Only one of 15 dogs presented with ascites and the minimum amount of fluid needed was aspirated to
allow adequate visualisation. Mild haemorrhage was recorded in all biopsies obtained with CBF. No
haemorrhage was recorded in 14 of 15 biopsies obtained with the PLL, and moderate haemorrhage
was recorded in the case in which the PLL was cut inadvertently. No cases required conversion to
open approach.
The weight and volume of the biopsies obtained with the PLL were on average more than three times
higher than those obtained with CBF, irrespectively if considered total sample or sample submitted
for histology (p<0.001, Table 1).
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
A total of 13 of 15 dogs survived to hospital discharge. The mean hospitalisation time for the dogs
that survived was 1.2 (±0.4) days. Only one dog required rescue analgesia two days after surgery and
the frequency of administration of tramadol was increased to three times daily and subcutaneous
maropitant (Cerenia, Pfizer) (1mg/kg) was administered in case the clinical signs were secondary to
nausea rather than pain.
Biopsy evaluation
The PLL method resulted in a greater area available for histological analysis compared to the CBF
(median 108 vs 26 mm2, p=0.0004, Table 1) with a greater number of portal tracts obtained (median
69 vs 19, p <0.001, Table 1). Four of 15 (26.7%) of the samples obtained with the CBF contained ≤11
portal tracts and all the samples obtained with the PLL contained >11 portal tracts. In addition, there
was reduced crush and fragmentation artefact with PLL samples compared to CBF (p<0.038, Table
1).
All the samples, independent of the method used, were diagnostic. The diagnoses included chronic
hepatitis with fibrosis (n=6), chronic hepatitis (n=2), steroid hepatopathy (n=2), subacute hepatitis
(n=1), fibrosis and biliary hyperplasia (n=1), chronic cholestasis and biliary hyperplasia (n=1),
hepatocellular swelling (n=1) and normal liver (n=1).
Complications and follow-up
Eight dogs were presented to the scheduled recheck appointment 10-14 days after surgery. Three of
the eight dogs had minor wound complications. Two cases showed dehiscence of the 6 mm side
wound and one case showed dehiscence of the wounds on both sides (11 mm and 6 mm wounds).
None of the dogs that developed wound complications wore the Elizabethan collar given to the owner
at discharge. Bacterial culture was performed in two of the three cases which developed wound
complications. One yielded a mixed growth of E. coli and Pasteurella sp and no growth was reported
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
in the second one. Both cases received oral co-amoxiclav (15-20 mg/kg, q 12h) for 10 days. All three
cases were also managed with wound dressings.
Of the five remaining dogs, which were not presented to the scheduled recheck appointment, no
wound complication was reported by the owners on follow-up by telephone contact or on routine
recheck appointment with the Internal Medicine Service.
In total, four dogs (26.6%) were euthanased during the study period due to disease progression.
Follow-up time for the rest of the dogs was 26-254 days.
DISCUSSION
The results of the present study confirm that using a PLL is a feasible and safe method to obtain
laparoscopic liver biopsies. In addition, the hepatic sample obtained is significantly larger and
contains significantly more portal tracts and less artefacts than those obtained with CBF from the
same liver lobe.
The size of the sample obtained by traditional open coeliotomy is the largest of any of the methods
described in the literature, providing more than adequate tissue for histopathology, copper analysis
and culture (Rothuizen and Twedt 2009). The sample obtained with the PLL via laparoscopy shows
similar characteristics to biopsies obtained in open surgery with the guillotine technique with a sample
significantly larger than that obtained with CBF and enough tissue to perform histopathology,
bacterial culture and copper analysis for comprehensive evaluation of liver disease. Conversely, the
total amount of tissue obtained with CBF in this study would have not been enough to perform all the
tests required (i.e. quantitative copper analysis). However, for ethical reasons, a smaller number of
hepatic biopsies were obtained with CBF as the aim was not to remove more liver tissue than required
between the two methods.
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
The PLL technique for laparoscopic hepatic biopsies has been described previously in a surgical
textbook and in a review on diagnostic laparoscopic techniques in cats (Robertson et al. 2014a,
Robertson et al. 2014b). In both, its use is recommended for animals with increased risk of
haemorrhage such as advance hepatic failure, focal or highly vascular lesions and coagulopathies.
None of the dogs in the current study had a clinically significant coagulopathy and comparing the
degree of haemorrhage between the two methods in dogs with and without coagulopathy in detail was
beyond the scope of the study. However, less haemorrhage was noted when using the PLL in
comparison to the CBF.
In this study, both techniques were used in dogs of a wide range of body sizes and different
histological diagnoses. The PLL was easier to use in dogs with fibrosis as the tissues were more
resilient to handling. On the contrary, the technique was slightly more challenging in dogs with a
friable liver or those with rounded liver edges.
A recent study concluded that the likelihood of obtaining a sample that represents the predominant
histological diagnosis is increased when multiple liver lobes were biopsied. (Kemp et al. 2015a). They
reported that when one liver lobe was sampled, the sample would reflect the prevalent histologic
diagnosis in 92% of the cases, whereas when two liver lobes were sampled, the percentage increased
to 98%. The previous study was published after all the data collection had completed for the current
study with only one liver lobe sampled with the two different techniques. Therefore, we have not
included this circumstance in our experimental design.
Despite all samples being considered of diagnostic value, 33% of the biopsies obtained with the cup
forceps contained less than eleven portal tracts as recommended in the human literature (Rockey et al.
2009). Conversely, all the biopsies obtained with the PLL had more than 18 portal tracts and showed a
significantly less crush and fragmentation artefact making the PLL method a superior method to the
CBF in terms of histologic sample quality. Furthermore, the PLL method provided a total sample 3.23
times heavier and 4.33 times larger in volume than those obtained with CBF. Both weight and volume
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
were measured as different hepatopathies may affect weight and volume independently and they may
not increase or decrease together in a proportional fashion.
PLL sampling consistently required more surgical time than cup forceps biopsy. The PLL technique
requires more advanced laparoscopic skills when compared to the CBF and the learning curve is
probably steeper. All the procedures were performed by a resident in training as the primary surgeon
who had previous experience using CBF but had minimal experience with the PLL. This study is
likely to represent part of the learning curve for this procedure and this surgeon. All these reasons
may explain the longer duration required to obtain the necessary biopsies. Additionally, the PLL
method required a third port being placed for triangulation which also added a mean time of 2.8
minutes to the total surgical time.
An assistant was required in all the procedures included in this study. When an assistant is used, the
primary surgeon and the assistant should be able to coordinate their movements and therefore, the
assistant should also have previous laparoscopic experience. Following the study, the procedure has
been performed without a trained assistant, with them only stabilising the camera whilst the surgeon
was positioned at the caudal aspect of the dog between the hind limbs rather than on the side of the
dog.
In the case in which the PLL was cut inadvertently, a collagen sponge was used first to stop the
haemorrhage. However, this was not enough to control the haemorrhage and a second PLL was placed
around the liver parenchyma which immediately controlled the haemorrhage. This could provide an
additional use of the PLL in controlling haemorrhage in laparoscopic surgery.
None of the cases in this study required conversion to an open approach during surgery due to
uncontrolled haemorrhage or laceration of abdominal viscera. In a previous retrospective study
including 80 cases undergoing laparoscopic liver biopsies, the spleen was lacerated in one (1,3%) of
the cases and necessitated conversion to an open approach (Petre et al. 2012). In human laparoscopy,
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
the incidence of iatrogenic trauma to abdominal organs and vessels by trocars or Veress needle has
been reported to be as low as 0.18% (Schafer et al. 2001).
A total of 13 of 15 (86.6%) survived to hospital discharge. The two dogs that died or were euthanased
during the study period had a histologic diagnosis of chronic hepatitis with cirrhosis. Cirrhosis is a
poor prognosis indicator in canine liver disease associated to a median survival time of 1.3 months
(Favier et al. 2013).
Only four cases developed postoperative complications. One dog needed rescue analgesia 24 hours
after discharge and three dogs had wound related complications. Tramadol is considered an
unpredictable analgesic and oral tramadol alone provided an inadequate level of analgesia in a
significant number of dogs undergoing an orthopaedic procedure (Davila et al. 2013). Postoperative
wound complications was reported in 16% in a study on dogs undergoing laparoscopic ovariectomy
(Pope and Knowles 2014). In that study, they could not find a statistically significant difference in
wound complications between the wound of 6 mm ports and 11 mm ports. In the present study, three
(20%) cases developed wound related complications which is a similar to previously reported and
only one of the three showed a wound complication in the 10 mm wound.
The goal of this study was to describe the use of a PLL to perform laparoscopic liver biopsies and
compare it to the traditional cup biopsy forceps. The limitations of the present study include the
limited number of cases, the use of single liver lobe for histological diagnosis and the experience of
the primary surgeon. The number of cases that developed complications was too low to allow
meaningful comparison with previous studies. The mean total surgery time was 78 minutes and this
included cases in which gallbladder bile aspiration was performed. Given the steep learning curve for
performing laparoscopy, it is possible that the mean surgery time would have been shorter if the
procedures were performed by a more experienced surgeon.
Conclusion
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
The PLL is a successful and safe method to obtain laparoscopic liver biopsies. The resulting samples
were on average >3 times as heavy and larger in volume compared to samples obtained with cup
biopsy forceps. Although both methods resulted in biopsies of diagnostic value, the samples obtained
with the PLL showed superior quality in terms of number of portal tracts, crushing and fragmentation
artefacts.
We propose that obtaining laparoscopic hepatic biopsies with a PLL method can be considered a good
alternative method to the cup biopsy forceps method in dogs.
Conflict of interest
No conflicts of interest have been declared.
References
Barros, F. F. P. d. C., Teixeira, P. P. M., Silva, M. A. M., Coelho, C. M. M., Lopes, M. d. C. S., Kawanami, A. E., Chung, D. G., Coutinho, L. N., Ribeiro, R. B., Padilha, L. C. and Vicente, W. R. R. (2015) Single-port laparoscopic ovariectomy using a pre-tied loop ligature in Santa Ines ewes. Ciência Rural, 45, pp. 2033-2038.
Boure, L., Marcoux, M. and Laverty, S. (1997) Paralumbar fossa laparoscopic ovariectomy in horses with use of Endoloop ligatures. Vet Surg, 26(6), pp. 478-83.
Cole, T. L., Center, S. A., Flood, S. N., Rowland, P. H., Valentine, B. A., Warner, K. L. and Erb, H. N. (2002) Diagnostic comparison of needle and wedge biopsy specimens of the liver in dogs and cats. J Am Vet Med Assoc, 220(10), pp. 1483-90.
Coral, G. P., Antunes, A. D., Serafini, A. P., Araujo, F. B. and Mattos, A. A. (2016) Liver Biopsy: Importance of Specimen Size in the Diagnosis and Staging of Chronic Viral Hepatitis. Rev Inst Med Trop Sao Paulo, 58, pp. 10.
Cuddy, L. C., Risselada, M. and Ellison, G. W. (2013) Clinical evaluation of a pre-tied ligating loop for liver biopsy and liver lobectomy. J Small Anim Pract, 54(2), pp. 61-6.
Culp, W. T., Mayhew, P. D. and Brown, D. C. (2009) The effect of laparoscopic versus open ovariectomy on postsurgical activity in small dogs. Vet Surg, 38(7), pp. 811-7.
Davila, D., Keeshen, T. P., Evans, R. B. and Conzemius, M. G. (2013) Comparison of the analgesic efficacy of perioperative firocoxib and tramadol administration in dogs undergoing tibial plateau leveling osteotomy. J Am Vet Med Assoc, 243(2), pp. 225-31.
417
418
419
420
421
422
423
424
425
426
427
428
429
430431432433434435436437438439440441442443444445446447448449450451452453454455
Devitt, C. M., Cox, R. E. and Hailey, J. J. (2005) Duration, complications, stress, and pain of open ovariohysterectomy versus a simple method of laparoscopic-assisted ovariohysterectomy in dogs. J Am Vet Med Assoc, 227(6), pp. 921-7.
Faunt, K. K., Jones, B. D., Turk, J. R., Cohn, L. A. and Dodam, J. R. (1998) Evaluation of biopsy specimens obtained during thoracoscopy from lungs of clinically normal dogs. Am J Vet Res, 59(11), pp. 1499-502.
Favier, R. P., Poldervaart, J. H., van den Ingh, T. S. G. A. M., Penning, L. C. and Rothuizen, J. (2013) A retrospective study of oral prednisolone treatment in canine chronic hepatitis. Veterinary Quarterly, 33(3), pp. 113-120.
Fischer, A. T. and Vachon, A. M. (1998) Laparoscopic intra-abdominal ligation and removal of cryptorchid testes in horses. Equine Vet J, 30(2), pp. 105-8.
Goodman, A. R. and Casale, S. A. (2014) Short-term outcome following partial or complete liver lobectomy with a commercially prepared self-ligating loop in companion animals: 29 cases (2009-2012). J Am Vet Med Assoc, 244(6), pp. 693-8.
Johnston, A. N., Center, S. A., McDonough, S. P. and Warner, K. L. (2009) Influence of biopsy specimen size, tissue fixation, and assay variation on copper, iron, and zinc concentrations in canine livers. Am J Vet Res, 70(12), pp. 1502-11.
Kemp, S. D., Zimmerman, K. L., Panciera, D. L., Monroe, W. E. and Leib, M. S. (2015a) Histopathologic variation between liver lobes in dogs. J Vet Intern Med, 29(1), pp. 58-62.
Kemp, S. D., Zimmerman, K. L., Panciera, D. L., Monroe, W. E., Leib, M. S. and Lanz, O. I. (2015b) A comparison of liver sampling techniques in dogs. J Vet Intern Med, 29(1), pp. 51-7.
Levien, A. S., Weisse, C., Donovan, T. A. and Berent, A. C. (2014) Assessment of the efficacy and potential complications of transjugular liver biopsy in canine cadavers. J Vet Intern Med, 28(2), pp. 338-45.
Oviedo Peñata, C. A. and Hernandez Lopez, C. A. (2013) Laparoscopy versus parapreputial laparotomy for the treatment of abdominal cryptorchidism in dogs. CES Medicina Veterinaria y Zootecnia, 8(2), pp. 9.
Petre, S. L., McClaran, J. K., Bergman, P. J. and Monette, S. (2012) Safety and efficacy of laparoscopic hepatic biopsy in dogs: 80 cases (2004-2009). J Am Vet Med Assoc, 240(2), pp. 181-5.
Pope, J. F. and Knowles, T. G. (2014) Retrospective analysis of the learning curve associated with laparoscopic ovariectomy in dogs and associated perioperative complication rates. Vet Surg, 43(6), pp. 668-77.
Pramatwinai, C., Brahmasa, A., Chuthatep, S., Birksawan, P. and Komin, K. (2006) Thoracoscopic-guided Lung Biopsy in Dogs. The Thai Journal of Veterinary Medicine, 36(4), pp. 33-40.
Relave, F., David, F., Leclere, M., Alexander, K., Bussieres, G., Lavoie, J. P. and Marcoux, M. (2008) Evaluation of a thoracoscopic technique using ligating loops to obtain large lung biopsies in standing healthy and heaves-affected horses. Vet Surg, 37(3), pp. 232-40.
456457458459460461462463464465466467468469470471472473474475476477478479480481482483484485486487488489490491492493494495496497498499500501502503504505506
Robertson, E., Twedt, D. and Webb, C. (2014a) Diagnostic laparoscopy in the cat: 1. Rationale and equipment. J Feline Med Surg, 16(1), pp. 5-16.
Robertson, E., Webb, C. and Twedt, D. (2014b) Diagnostic laparoscopy in the cat: 2. Common procedures. J Feline Med Surg, 16(1), pp. 18-26.
Rockey, D. C., Caldwell, S. H., Goodman, Z. D., Nelson, R. C., Smith, A. D. and American Association for the Study of Liver, D. (2009) Liver biopsy. Hepatology, 49(3), pp. 1017-44.
Rothuizen, J. and Twedt, D. C. (2009) Liver biopsy techniques. Vet Clin North Am Small Anim Pract, 39(3), pp. 469-80.
Schafer, M., Lauper, M. and Krahenbuhl, L. (2001) Trocar and Veress needle injuries during laparoscopy. Surg Endosc, 15(3), pp. 275-80.
Wang, K. Y., Panciera, D. L., Al-Rukibat, R. K. and Radi, Z. A. (2004) Accuracy of ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration of the liver and cytologic findings in dogs and cats: 97 cases (1990-2000). J Am Vet Med Assoc, 224(1), pp. 75-8.
Figure 1. Laparoscopic Babcock forceps holding the liver lobe through the pre-tied ligating loop ready
to position the loop around the hepatic tissue (left). Cuff of liver tissue and visible ends of the PLL
(white asterisk) and biopsy sites from the CBF (white arrows) (right).
*
507508509510511512513514515516517518519520521522523524525526
527
528
529
530
Figure 2. Examples showing the different grades (0-3) of crush and fragmentation artefact in the
population of the study. 0 = none, 1 = mild, 2 = moderate, 3 = severe). Please note that grade 3
fragmentation was absent in this dataset. Stain: Haematoxylin and eosin. Bar: 1mm for fragmentation,
500um for crush.
Cup biopsy forceps
(CBF)
Pre-tied ligating loop
(PLL)
Statistical test and
significance
1. T bx (min) Mdn=7 (IQR = 4) Mdn=18 (IQR = 17) 1-s W, WS= 115, p
=0.0020
2. Total W (mg) M=184 (±56.9SD) M=595.8 (±313.2) P-t (>0), t=5.37,
p<0.001
3. W Histo (mg) M=62.87 (±15.57) M=340.00 (±144,98) P-t (>0), t=7.33,
p<0.0001
4. Total V (cm3) M=0.29 (±0.10) M=1.30 (±0.60) P-t (>0), t=6.82,
0.5mm
1mm
531
532
533
534
535
p<0.0001
5. V Histo (cm3) M=0.09 (±0.03) M=0.73 (±0.41) P-t (>0), t=6.03,
p<0.0001
6. A Histo (mm2) Mdn=26.30
(IQR=18.70)
Mdn=107.91
(IQR=137.40)
1-s W(>0), WS=120,
p=0.0004
7. PT (number) Mdn=19 (IQR=24) Mdn=69 (IQR=75) 1-s W(>0), WS=119,
p=0.0004
8. C artefact (0-3) Mdn=1 (IQR=2) Mdn=0 (IQR=1) 1-s W(<0),
WS=13.50,
p=0.0249
9. F artefact (0-3) Mdn=1 (IQR=1) Mdn=0 (IQR=1) 1-s W(<0),
WS=7.00, p=0.0378
Table 1. Summary of the differences between the CBF and the PLL techniques. 1. Time to obtain the
biopsies (minutes). 2. Total weight of the biopsy obtained at surgery. 3. Weight of the sample submitted
for histology. 4. Total volume of the biopsy obtained at surgery. 5. Volume of the sample submitted for
histology. 6. Total area of tissue available for histology. 7. Number of portal tracts. 8. Crush artefact (0-3).
9. Fragmentation artefact (0-3). †, mean (±SD). §, median (IQR). t, paired t-test. 1-s W, 1-sample
Wilcoxon test. Statistical significance <0.05.
536
537
538
539
540
541
542
Recommended