View
225
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
1/121
THE ART OF
Puzzle Game DesignScott Kim & Alexey Pajitnov
March 15, 1999Game Developers Conference
These are presentation slides from an all-day tutorial given at the 1999 Game Developers Conference in San Jose. This copy of theslides was taken from www.scottkim.com/articles. All screen shots are copyrighted by the respective game publishers.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
2/121
Puzzles
j Part of many games.
j Adventure, education, action, web
j But how do you create them?
Whether you are designing levels for an cartridge-based action puzzle game, creating puzzle templates for a CD-ROM puzzle anthology,adding puzzles to an adventure game, or designing an educational game, you need to know how to design good puzzles.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
3/121
Good News / Bad News
Mental challenge Marketable?
Nonviolent Dr
Easy to program Hard to invent?
Growing market Small market?
The good news is that puzzles appeal widely to both males and females of all ages. Although the current market is small, it is rapidlyexpanding, as computers become a mass market commodity and players demand familiar family games.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
4/121
Outline
Types of Puzzle Games
Examples: Pipe Dream, Honey Way, Lineman
Examples: Fool, Incred Machine, Puzzle Zone
Case Study: Jesses Strips
Case Study: Charlie Blasts Territory
Case Study: Scott Kims Puzzle Box
Exercises: Idea Invention, Word Sokoban
Well start by surveying examples of outstanding puzzle games. Then Alexey and I will go into detail about some of our current projects.Ill describe the eight steps in the puzzle design process. Finally well split into groups of five people each and do projects.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
5/121
Types of Puzzle Games
What every puzzle
designer should know
Scott KimHere are four basic ways to categorize the types of possible puzzle games.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
6/121
Varieties of Play Activity
There are four types of play. Noninteractive experiences include books and movies. A Toy has no set goal. A Puzzle has a goal: find thesolution. The goal of a Game is to beat another player. Each type of play builds on the previous type: a puzzle should first be a good toy.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
7/121
Genres of Puzzle Games
Action puzzle games have time pressure and a way to fix mistakes. Story puzzle games have puzzles that advance the plot. Strategy puzzlegames are based on multiplayer games. Construction puzzle games let you build something. Pure puzzle games are just puzzles.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
8/121
Player Motivation
Different people play puzzls for different reasons. Some see puzzles as metaphors for spiritual journeys. Puzzle fans like the challenge offinding the answer. Tetris and Solitaire players use puzzles as light distractions. People buy Disney titles for the familiar characters.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
9/121
Modality
People who play puzzles tend to prefer one of three basic types: Word, Image or Logic puzzles. Each of these types of puzzle uses adifferent mode of thought. Of course some puzzles combine more than one mode. For instance, Hangman is a logical word game.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
10/121
EXAMPLES
Pipe Dream
One concept,
Three designs
Alexey PajitnovHere are some of our favorite puzzle games (other than ones we have designed). Wechose examples that cover the full range of issues that arise in designing puzzle games.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
11/121
Pipe Dream
j The simplest
construction on the
regular grid is the path
from one cell to
another
Although Pipe Dream could be classified as an action puzzle game, at its heart it is a construction game. Other examples of constructivepuzzles are: Lemmings, The Incredible Machine, Puyo-Puyo.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
12/121
Pipe Dream
j After obvious
straightening of the
path we realize that we
need a very simple set
of pieces:
To make the concept of constructing a path more suitable for a computer game we restrict lines to a square grid.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
13/121
Pipe Dream
j4 corners
j2 two lines
j
1 cross
Seven pieces is a magic number. Tetris has seven pieces. Psychologists have found the human short term memory can hold about seventhings (plus or minus two). That is why 7-digit telephone numbers are so much easier to remember than 10-digit numbers.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
14/121
Pipe Dream
CONCEPT:
j Build a path from one cell to another using
one-cell elements
So this is the concept.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
15/121
DESIGN ELEMENTS:
j Playing field Regular grid 7x10
j
Objects 4 corners, 2 lines, 1 crossj Rules Source of pieces: 5-cell stack
j User interface Click to place; replace takes time
j
Scoring, levels Nothing special
Pipe Dream
To make a game, we need to specify these design elements.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
16/121
Pipe Dream (original)
CONCEPT: Build a path from one cell to anotherusing one-cell elements
j Playing field Regular grid 7x10
j Objects 4 corners, 2 lines, 1 crossj Rules Source of pieces: 5-cell stack
j User interface Click to place; replace takes time
j Scoring, levels Nothing special
For the original Pipe Dream, published by LucasFilm Games, these were the design decisions.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
17/121
Pipe Dream (Microsoft bonus level)
CONCEPT: Build a path from one cell to another
using one-cell elements
j Playing field Regular grid 7x10
j Objects 4 corners, 2 lines, 1 crossj Rules Sliding tiles
j User interface Click to slide, restriction on drawn path
j Scoring, levels Nothing special
But other games can be built based on the same concept. The Microsoft Entertainment Pack version of Pipe Dream includes a sliding tilevariation as its bonus level. Quite a good game.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
18/121
Pipe Dream (Lucasfilm bonus level)
CONCEPT: Build a path from one cell to anotherusing one-cell elements
j Playing field Regular grid 7x10
j Objects 4 corners, 2 lines, 1 crossj Rules Falling tiles (like Tetris)
j User interface Control while falling
j Scoring, levels Nothing special
The original Lucasfilm version includes a Tetris-like variation of Pipe Dream as its bonus level. Very hard game; it is almost impossible toconstruct paths of more than about five tiles.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
19/121
j Playing field Variable hexagonal grid
j Objects All corners and lines, 3 crossesj Rules Preset sources, crosses and obstacles
j User interface Drawing the path as freehand
j Scoring, levels Nothing special
Honey Way
CONCEPT: Build a path from one cell to anotherusing one-cell elements
For the Mind Aerobics daily puzzle on the Internet Gaming Zone, Alexey created a simpler game based on the same concept. The grid waschanged from square to hexagonal, the player could build paths freely by drawing lines, and sources, crosses and obstacles were given.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
20/121
Honey Way
The hexagonal grid suggested the theme: bees and honey.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
21/121
Honey Way
The player tries to construct a line of honey from one honey blob to another by drawing lines from one cell to another.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
22/121
Honey Way
The path must pass through every cell of the grid once, crossing over itself at the flowers in the directions indicated by the petals. Here is acomplete solution. It looks complicated, but the hexagonal grid is actually more forgiving for path construction than a square grid.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
23/121
Honey Way
Dangerous bees complicate some of the puzzles.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
24/121
j Playing field Regular grid 10x10
j Objects 4 corners, 2 lines, 1 crossj Rules Pieces appear on field; loops collapse
j User interface Click to rotate pieces in place
j Scoring, levels Nothing special
Lineman
CONCEPT: Build any cyclic pathusing one-cell elements
Lineman, from the Russian Six Pack (Interplay) uses the same seven objects but different rules. Pieces appear directly on the playing fieldand can only be rotated, not moved. The goal is construct loops, which collapse, not paths from one place to another. Excellent game.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
25/121
EXAMPLES
Fools Errand, Incredible
Machine, Puzzle ZoneThree games,
Three genres
Scott KimHere are other puzzle games that demonstrate some of the design challenges in other puzzle game genres.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
26/121
The Fools Errand
j Integrated story, puzzles, art
j Idiomatic puzzles
j Metapuzzle
Created solely by Cliff Johnson in the 80s, The Fools Errand is an integrated work of art. Each puzzle links with a tarot card and storysegment. The bold silhouette art style looks good on a small screen. Each puzzle unlocks part of a larger unifying meta-puzzle.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
27/121
The Incredible Machine
The Incredible Machine (TIM) is the best construction puzzle game. There are three important design decisions. Decision 1: allow the
player to build things. SimCity, shown above, allows construction, but does not give the player a fixed goal and is thus a toy, not a puzzle.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
28/121
The Incredible Machine
Decision 2. No realtime decision making. In contrast, Lemmings, shown above, requires players to solve the puzzle by repositioning
lemmings while they are walking around. In The Incredible Machine, building and running machines happen in separate modes.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
29/121
The Incredible Machine
Decision 3: Player authoring. In contrast, Marble Drop, shown here, has separate build and run modes, but does not allow the player to
construct original puzzles. Instead, all the puzzles come preconstructed, which allows Marble Drop to have beautifully rendered screens.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
30/121
The Incredible Machine
In The Incredible Machine, players can build their own puzzles in a separate freeform construction mode, separate from puzzle mode. The
goal of this particular puzzle is to get all balls into all the aquariums using a motley collection of ropes, pulleys, ramps and other devices.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
31/121
The Incredible Machine
j Physical simulation
j Player authoring
j Integrated controls
The designers of TIM did a brilliant job of including a broad range of play elements that all interact with one another within a rich physics
model, while keeping the user interface simple and obvious.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
32/121
Puzzle Zone
The Puzzle Zone on America Online [editors note: now on boxerjam.com] is a good example of an online puzzle. Following the model of
newspaper puzzles, Puzzle Zone delivers four new puzzles every day. The puzzles add new twists to familiar word games.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
33/121
Puzzle Zone
Flexicon, shown above, is a twist on a crossword puzzle. The problem with crossword puzzles on computer is that the screen is too small to
hold a large puzzle. The solution here is to save space by overlapping four rectangular regions, only one of which is visible at a time.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
34/121
Puzzle Zone
Strip Search adds new twists to the familiar word search.: The theme here Joes was inspired by the topical event of Joe Dimaggios
death. Found words appear in order of length, giving the player a hint. When all words are found, the leftover letters form a witty phrase.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
35/121
Puzzle Zone
Finally, the Puzzle Zone also includes elements that build community and encourage players to keep coming back: message boards, high
score boards, and a place to buy branded merchandise.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
36/121
Puzzle Zone
j Familiar puzzles
j Daily editions
j Online community
The puzzles in Puzzle Zone are somewhat mundane and obvious, but that is not a bad thing. By using familiar puzzle types, the Puzzle
Zone lowers the barrier to entry. Furthermore, word games require very little data to be downloaded, so play is snappy.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
37/121
CASE STUDY
Jesses Strips
Recent design experience
with 3 ahas
Alexey PajitnovJesses Strips, designed by Alexey Pajitnov, is one of a number of image-based puzzles
from Pandoras Box, a forthcoming title from Microsoft.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
38/121
Jesses Strips
CONCEPT
j To make jigsaw puzzle using long narrow
pieces (strips)
One of the members of the Pandoras Box team suggested the concept.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
39/121
Jesses Strips
PROBLEM
j The playing field is too messy
The problem with long skinny pieces, however...
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
40/121
Is that the playing field quickly gets messy.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
41/121
j Stack the piecesj Separate picture and pieces in different windows
j Enlarge the space for more than one screen
Jesses Strips
Problem:The playing field is too messy
Solutions:
j Scroll the playing field
j Paginate the playing field
no
no
??
no
Yes!
I considered many possible solutions before hitting on the idea of spreading the pieces across several different pages.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
42/121
Jesses StripsFirst AHA:
To make multiple pages and repeat the picture in
progress on each of them, distributing the pieces.
This was the first Aha.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
43/121
j Change picture position
j Change background look (color, texture)
j
Use animation for changing pagesj Change the picture in progress.
Jesses Strips
Problem:Player does not understand what happens
when the pages switch
Solutions:no
no
noYes!
But this insight raised another problem...
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
44/121
Jesses StripsSecond AHA:
To emphasize certain color for the picture on each page;
to do the same with the pieces on the page.
Which in turn required a second Aha.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
45/121
j Work on UI
j Connect the piece movements with rotations
Jesses Strips
Problem:
We need to move the pieces from page to
page now and User Interface become too
complicated
Solutions:
Yes!Yes!
The final insight was motivated by wanting to keep the user interface simple. Instead of separate commands to rotate pieces and changes
pages...
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
46/121
Jesses StripsThird AHA:
To move the piece to the next page together with the 90
degrees rotation.
The two things happen together. This is a good
example of how the difficulties in realizing a
particular puzzle concept can guide the designer
toward novel solutions. [Editors note: the final
published version in Pandoras Box works
differently.]
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
47/121
CASE STUDY
Charlie Blasts Territory
Adding action to a classic
computer puzzle game
Scott Kim
Charlie Blasts Territory is a game for the Nintendo 64 published by Kemco. Kemco hired Realtime
Associates to develop the game; they in turn hired Scott to assist in game design and level design for the
puzzles. This example highlights some of the techniques he used in level design.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
48/121
Sokoban
j Classic, widely copied
j Simple rules
j Deep puzzlesj Fits the medium
Charlie Blast is based on the classic puzzle game Sokoban, which is one of the most widely copied computer games. It has simple rules
that are easy to program, yet has deep gameplay. It works well on low-resolution displays with simple arrow controls, such as GameBoy.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
49/121
Changing Sokoban
j Pieces: Bombs, shapes, pictures
j Board: Breakaway, ice, bumper
j Moves: Push two, pull not pushj Goal: Push to hole, arrange bombs
j Play mode: Multiplayer, action
One of the most common ways to create a new game is to change an existing game. Here are some ways to change Sokoban.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
50/121
Charlie Blasts Territory
j Based on Sokoban
j For N64, American audience
j Uses 3D graphicsj Adds action elements
For Charlie Blasts Territory Kemco decided to pump up the 3D action elements of the game by using 3D perspective, moving camera,
animated main character (Charlie Blast), and adding action elements.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
51/121
Challenge: Add Action Features
j Jumping
j Autodetonator
j Moving platforms, spikesj Multiplayer competitive mode
j Not included:damage
We added common action game features like jumping, moving platforms, moving spikes, and a multiplayer competitive mode. We did not
include damage points, because that would have shifted the emphasis of gameplay too far in the direction of dexterity, not puzzle solving.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
52/121
Challenge: Add Other Features
j Bombs & Detonator
j Objects: TNT crates, blocks
j Tiles: breakaway, ice, trampolinesj Not included:enemy characters
Features like bombs, blocks and breakaway tiles add depth and variety to the underlying Sokoban game. Of course features interact with
each other. TNT crates and blocks were introduced specifically to complement the jumping ability.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
53/121
Bombs
Heres how bombs work. A 1 bomb blows up itself. A 2 bomb also blows up the four adjacent squares. A 3 bomb blows up a larger
diamond region. The detonator and TNT act like a 2 bomb. You can light pm;u a detonator, and you can jump only over TNT.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
54/121
Bombs
The goal of every puzzle is to arrange the bombs so that when Charlie lights the detonator, it triggers a chain reaction that blows up all the
bombs. Suppose Charlie lights the detonator in this configuration. Which bombs will not blow up?
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
55/121
Bombs
Heres the answer. The only bombs that dont blow up are the 1 bomb at right, which is too far away from a 2 bomb, and the 2 and TNT
bombs in the lower left, which touch another 2 bomb diagonally.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
56/121
Challenge: Design Levels
j 60 levels = 6 groups of 10
j Easy to hard within a group
j Each group features different devices
The bulk of my time was spent designing the 60 levels, structured as 6 ramps of 10 puzzles each. Puzzles within a ramp start easy and get
harder. Each ramp has a different visual theme and emphasizes a different mix of features, to keep the game from getting too repetitive.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
57/121
Building Levels
j Tell a Story
j Paint a Picture
j Create a Moodj Use Math
j Exploit features
j Lay a Trap
I used many different strategies for coming up with ideas for levels, so that there would be a wide variety of puzzle types. Here are six of
my strategies. Following are examples of how I used each strategy to design a particular level.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
58/121
Building Levels: Tell a Story
#17 Run Like Crazy
Some puzzles are structured as a linear sequence of events. For this puzzle, started by drawing a board that wraps a long narrow corridor
into a small space.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
59/121
Building Levels: Tell a Story
#17 Run Like Crazy
This puzzle features an autodetonator, shown in red here, which blows up automatically in a preset amount of time unless you touch it to
reset it. The basic drama of this puzzle is that you must run to the autodetonator, then push it back a long way so it blows up a bomb.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
60/121
Building Levels: Tell a Story
#17 Run Like Crazy
I then compounded the puzzle by adding obstacles along the three legs of the journey. Moving spikes that raise and lower out of the game
cause you to have to wait a bit before you can get to the autodetonator -- frustrating when you have to get there quickly.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
61/121
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
62/121
Building Levels: Tell a Story
#17 Run Like Crazy
I added one more spike in the right leg of the journey..
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
63/121
Building Levels: Tell a Story
#17 Run Like Crazy
Finally there is the end game. One bombs only blow up themselves, so the ending position must be an autodetonator surrounded by one
bombs. Because two of the 1 bombs are against walls they cannot be pushed away from, there is only one possible ending position.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
64/121
Building Levels: Paint a Picture
#48 Ice Rink. Initial pattern.
Another way to invent a puzzle is to start with a pretty pattern, then try playing it. Here are three opening positions I considered for the
puzzle Ice Rink. They look similar, but behave very differently. You cannot stop moving on ice until you hit a wall or reach solid ground.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
65/121
Building Levels: Paint a Picture
#49 Diamond. Initial pattern.
Here are three patterns I considered for a puzzle called Diamond, which features a patch of ice surrounded by solid ground. After drawing
the opening patterns I played them to see if they could be solved. If they were not solvable, I then had to decide how to modify the pattern.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
66/121
Building Levels: Paint a Picture
#60 The Final pattern.
For the final puzzle I decided to aim for a pretty final position that would spell the word End. This is what I originally hoped for..
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
67/121
Building Levels: Paint a Picture
#60 The Initial pattern.
The actual final puzzle required many modifications to the boards and pieces to make sure that the puzzle only had one solution. Shown
here is the final beginning position.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
68/121
Building Levels: Paint a Picture
#57 Pinball. Overall picture.
One of the features of Charlie Blast is bumpers, which rebound bombs pushed into them. Bumpers reminded me of pinball bumpers, so I
built this puzzle to look like a pinball machine, complete with a moving beltway for returning a queue of balls into play.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
69/121
Building Levels: Create a Mood
#16 Long Haul
Some puzzles create distinct moods. Long haul, for instance, creates a frantic suspenseful mood as you must run further and further away
from an autodetonator with a very short fuse in order to reposition bombs that are further and further away.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
70/121
Building Levels: Create a Mood
#16 Long Haul
It is easy to see that the autodetonator and 1 bomb cannot move, so the solution must be to create a chain of 3 bombs reaching from one
end to the other.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
71/121
Building Levels: Create a Mood
#16 Long Haul
Or is it really that easy? A bit of analysis will show that the previous solution cannot be achieved, so a modified chain like this is
necessary.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
72/121
Building Levels: Use Math
#39 Peninsula
Puzzle designers often mine mathematics for ideas. Shown above is a puzzle based on the mathematical idea of a tour. The goal is to draw
a closed path that visits every square once, using all the red lines. The unique solution is shown at right.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
73/121
Building Levels: Use Math
#39 Peninsula
I decided to make a puzzle for Charlie Blast that used the idea of a tour. Suppose the tiles above are all breakaway tiles, which means you
can only step on them once. How would you push all three one bombs off the bottom edge of the square? One solution is shown at right.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
74/121
Building Levels: Use Math
#39 Peninsula
After a bit of work I came up with this more difficult tour puzzle. The goal is to push all three 1 bombs off the bottom edge of the square
by walking a single path. The unique solution requires that you visit every square exactly once.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
75/121
Building Levels: Use Math
#39 Peninsula
Heres the final puzzle. The purple electric bombs act like 2 bombs, except if one electric bomb blows up, the other also blows up. Since
the electric bomb along the bottom edge cannot be pushed up toward the 1 bombs, the three 1 bombs must be pushed down to surround it.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
76/121
Building Levels: Exploit Features
#30 Moving Ground
Another strategy is to exploit a feature. Shown above are two states of the same board, built entirely of moving platforms. The tall
rectangles move left and right, while the wide rectangles move up and down. The green arrows show how the 2 bomb could be pushed.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
77/121
Building Levels: Exploit Features
#30 Moving Ground
Here is the final puzzle. The ground at the bottom is stable, while the ground at the top is moving. The goal is clear: build a chain of bombs
between the immovable detonator at left and 1 bomb at right. But getting there requires a hair-raising ride around the platforms.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
78/121
Building Levels: Exploit Features
#30 Moving Ground
This puzzle is easier to analyze if we collapse time and push all the platforms together so all adjacencies are present at the once. The green
arrows show all paths that bombs can follow as they move around the platforms. Removing the dead ends, we discover the loop at right.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
79/121
Building Levels: Lay a Trap
#58 Tadpole
Finally, puzzles can trick you into pursuing the wrong line of reasoning. For the puzzle Tadpole, I started by observing that a puzzle
involving a 2 bomb, detonator and six 1 bombs must end with the 2 bomb and detonator surrounded by the 1 bombs.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
80/121
Building Levels: Lay a Trap
#58 Tadpole
With that analysis in mind, this puzzle appears to be simple: push the autodetonator into the pocket, seal the opening with a 1 bomb, then
sit back and watch the fireworks.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
81/121
Building Levels: Lay a Trap
#58 Tadpole
By adding a couple of spikes I gave the puzzle a new wrinkle.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
82/121
Building Levels: Lay a Trap
#58 Tadpole
Now you can only push the autodetonator as far as shown above by the green line. You cannot push the autodetonator any further because
the spikes prevent you from getting to the square to the right of the final position of the autodetonator.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
83/121
Building Levels: Lay a Trap
#58 Tadpole
The real solution requires that you rebuild the entire hexagonal pattern of 1 bombs up and to the right one square.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
84/121
Building Levels: Lay a Trap
#58 Tadpole
To complete the puzzle, I added some blocks and breakaway tiles.. These complications add difficulty to the puzzle, but are not integral to
the central theme of the puzzle.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
85/121
CASE STUDY
Scott Kims Puzzle Box
Creating a monthly puzzle
for a childrens web site
Scott KimThe second case studies a monthly puzzle called Scott Kims Puzzle Box, which Scott created for the kids
online service Juniornet. This example highlights issues in designing puzzles for the web.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
86/121
JuniorNet
j Safe online place
j For kids 3-12
j Content partnersj Subscription
j CD-ROM
Juniornet is an online service that gives kids a safe, fun, rewarding, and ad-free experience. Content comes from such well known brands as
Highlights and Weekly Reader. Subscribers receive a CD-ROM, with more frequently updated content streamed across the internet.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
87/121
Scott Kims Puzzle Box
j Monthly, weekly
j Player authoring
j Fun, educationalj Learning styles
j Branded
My feature on Juniornet is an original content area called Scott Kims Puzzle Box, which delivers.a new collection of puzzles every month.
The type of puzzle changes from month to month. Players can create their own puzzles, some of which are posted on the site.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
88/121
Design Challenges
j Adapt existing physical puzzle
j Structure for efficient production
j Player authoring
Producing a rich puzzle experience on a monthly schedule posed several design challenges..
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
89/121
Challenge: Adapt Hiroimono
j Hiroimono =
Things Picked Up
j 500 years old
j From Japan
The puzzles are adapted from existing puzzles. For instance, the April puzzle is based on Hiroimono, a popular puzzle from Japan
traditionally played with Go stones.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
90/121
Changes to Hiroimono
j Animated characters
j Specify beginning
j Clear motivation
j Embody the rules
To make Hiroimono friendlier to kids I embodied the rules in the characters of a dog that is eating pet treats, and a cat that prevents the dog
from backing up in the direction it came. Even with words, kids could be attracted to the game and have a sense of what it is about.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
91/121
Challenge: Efficient Structure
FIXED FORMAT
j Monthly puzzles
j
Kids puzzlesj Letters
j Puzzling Times
j My Puzzles
In order to keep production costs reasonable, I planned a modular structure that would allow most of the site to stay the same from month
to month. These basic features are always the same.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
92/121
Structure
Pet Tricks
High FlyerHouse Painter
Tangrams
Patchwork T.Glass Tan.
Arrow Maze
Number MazeShape Maze
Drum Circle
Bell CircleRap Circle
4 TEMPLATES/YEAR, 3 VARIATIONS EACH
The type of puzzle changes every month. But instead of creating 12 different puzzle engines, I create only 4 engines for the year, then reuse
each engine 3 times with minor variations.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
93/121
Structure
15 MONTHLY PUZZLES, 24 KIDS PUZZLES
Every month I deliver 15 puzzles that I created, and 24 puzzles that kids create.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
94/121
Structure
Fixed Format
Puzzle engines
Variations
Month puzzles
Kids PuzzlesProduction is structured so that the most difficult pieces to build change the least often. Templates change only once every three months.
The monthly template variations require only art changes. Finally, puzzle specification requires only compact text files.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
95/121
Challenge: Player Authoring
j Simple pieces
j No interdependence
j
Random puzzles OKj Solve before submit
Players can create and submit their own puzzles. In order to keep puzzle creation kid friendly, I chose puzzles that are relatively easy to
author. And I require that players solve their puzzles before submitting them, so I dont receive puzzles that dont work.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
96/121
TECHNIQUE
Puzzle Game Design
In eight easy steps
Scott KimNow that weve seen two very different examples, what can we say about puzzle design in general?
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
97/121
The Eight Steps
1. Inspiration
2. Simplification
3. Construction Set
4. Rules
5. Puzzles
6. Testing7. Sequence
8. PresentationHere are the steps in designing any puzzle game. The first four steps sharpen the concept into a design specification; the last four steps
bring the concept into reality.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
98/121
1. Inspiration: Previous Game
Where do ideas come from? Here are six ways to get inspired. First, you can look to a previous game. Tetris was inspired by a
noncomputer game called pentaminoes, and in turn inspired Welltris and other Tetris spinoffs.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
99/121
1. Inspiration: Technology
1. Enable nonphysical moves (Tetris)
2. Algorithmic hint, create, analyze, enemy
3. Enforce the rules (Sokoban)
4. Undo, record moves (Solitaire)
5. Structure the experience (Lemmings)
6. Instruction (Chess)
7. Bells and whistles (Battle Chess)8. Online play (NY Times crossword)
If you are going to put a puzzle on computer, there should be some gain. Many computer puzzle games do things that could never be done
in a physical puzzle. But even if the puzzle is physically possible, there are many other ways the computer can enhance gameplay.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
100/121
1. Inspiration: Play Mechanic
Endorfun was inspired by the play mechanism of a colored cube rolling on a square grid.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
101/121
1. Inspiration: Subject matter
j Start with something you love
j Express it as if it mattered
j
Give each puzzle a memorable identityj Like a good song, a good puzzle has soul
Like songs, puzzles can be inspired by real life. Stephen Sondheim: A good clue can give you all the pleasures of being duped that a
mystery story can. It has surface innocence, surprise, the revelation of a concealed meaning, and the catharsis of solution.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
102/121
1. Inspiration: Story
Story puzzle games like Myst are built around story line, character, setting, and mood.
i i
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
103/121
1. Inspiration: Art
The story game Obsidian started as a series of concept sketches for characters and environments. Story and puzzles came later.
2 Si lifi i
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
104/121
2. Simplification
The second step is to whittle the concept down to manageable size. Say we wanted to make a puzzle based on the tricky core skill of
parking a car in a crowded lot. We eliminate irrelevant details and make pieces uniform by conforming them to a square grid.
3 C i S
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
105/121
3. Construction Set
j Programmer: reusable code
j Rule designer: tweak rules
j
Level designer: build levelsj Player: build levels
The only way to test a puzzle concept works is to play it. So the next step is to build a construction set that makes it easy to build puzzles
of a certain type. Sometimes a paper prototype is adequate. Once the rules are set, other people can use the construction set to build levels.
4 R l
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
106/121
4. Rules
j Board grid, network, irregular, none
j Pieces shape, image, attribute, supply
j
Moves sequential, side effect, primaryj Goal exact match, partial, condition
Now it is time to write a detailed design specification. Most puzzle game specs will describe puzzles in terms of board, pieces, moves and
goals. In addition a design spec may also cover the user interface, scoring, story, art, sound and other aspects of production.
5 P l
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
107/121
5. Puzzles
Schematically, a puzzle challenges the player to get from a problem to a solution.
5 P l
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
108/121
5. Puzzles
But of course the path is never simple. Every puzzle requires that the player make choices, some of which lead to dead ends.
5 P l
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
109/121
5. Puzzles
Puzzles in a game have a larger situation that gives the puzzle meaning. Applying the solution lets you move forward in the game.
5 P l
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
110/121
5. Puzzles
Good puzzles have require insight. The insight above is to walk around the outside of the maze. Obscure insights, however, feel unfair.
6 T ti
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
111/121
6. Testing
j Is it fun?
j How hard is it?
j
Are there simpler solutions?j Can it be improved?
The only way to find out whether a puzzle is fun is to watch someone play it. Often a puzzle you think is easy will turn out to be hard, or
vice versa. Sometimes players will find simpler solutions. Or you will realize that the puzzle needs some other improvement.
7 S
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
112/121
7. Sequence
Accelerating
Linear
Sawtooth
Semilinear
Ordered collection
Metapuzzle
Next you must put the levels into sequence. Linear is simplest, but can get tiring. A better organization is the sawtooth, which keeps going
back to easy puzzles, or to give players freedom to play puzzles out of order. Metapuzzles motivate players to complete the whole game.
7 S T iti
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
113/121
7. Sequence: Transitions
j Learning rules
j Within a puzzle: hints
j
From one puzzle to nextj From one section to next
j Ending
You also need to think about the transitions between puzzles. Whenever the player moves from one place to another in your game, there is
an opportunity to lose the players interest. How can you bridge these gaps?
8 P t ti
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
114/121
8. Presentation
Finally there are all the matters of presentation that turn an abstract puzzle into something people can see, hear and touch. I wont go into
detail on production for puzzle games.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
115/121
PROJECT
Inventing Ideas
Inventing ideas for puzzles
based on todays headlines
Scott Kim
The class divided up into teams of people each. Each team invented an idea for a puzzle game based on a
story or ad in todays San Jose Mercury News. Finally the groups pitched their ideas to the whole class.
T it C t l
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
116/121
Termite Control
j You are a termite
j Goal: eat a floor
j Obstacle: humans
Like most of the puzzles this is a character-driven action game that has been turned into a puzzle game by putting it onto a grid and turning
real time action into turn based strategy.
P i Sh ffl
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
117/121
Prison Shuffle
j Put prisoners in cells
j Avoid bad combos
j Can shuffle cells
A dynamic allocation puzzle. Prisoners are arriving at a jail. Allocate them to cells while avoiding certain bad combinations, such as an
escape artist plus someone who has a key. Shuffling prisoners between cells takes time.
C bicles
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
118/121
Cubicles
j Fit cubicles in floor
j Leave path to doors
j Dilbert license?A clever idea that falls naturally out of a real situation. Irregularly shaped cubicles made of square modules are to be fit within a floor of a
building. Additionally, every cubicle must have a clear path from its door to a building entrance.
Get Barbie Home
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
119/121
Get Barbie Home
j Bust Out Barbie
j Barbie Queue
j Kens MagneticPersonality
A story about homeless Barbie inspired the most ideas. Get Barbie Home had Barbie wandering through the back streets of a city. Bust Out
Barbie required chain smoking Malibu Barbie use Fashion Barbies hairspray to fashion a homemade bomb and stage a jail break.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
120/121
PROJECT
Rule Design
Turn Sokoban
into a word game
Alexey Pajitnov
Next, groups were asked to invent a game that combined Sokoban with some sort of
word game, then pitch the game to the group. The ideas were surprisingly varied, and
several were sufficiently developed to be implementable.
8/14/2019 utter bullshit
121/121
PROJECT
Level Design
Creating levels for a new
variation of Sokoban
Recommended