The International Communications Industries Association, Inc. ® Trends In Display Technologies The...

Preview:

Citation preview

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Trends In Display Technologies The Wild Ride Continues…

Peter H. Putman, CTS

President, ROAM Consulting Inc.Founder, HDTVexpert.com

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

The Next Big Thing Is…

2004 was the year of intelligent displays 2005 is the year of “HD” (1080p) displays

• 1920x1080 front and rear projection• 1920x1080 flat panel monitors• 1400x1050, 1600x1200, 2048x1536 displays

16:9 aspect ratios more and more popular 1920x1080 is a shared TV / PC resolution

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

The Next Big Thing Is…

Most significant display products shown at CES, CeBIT, and NAB were HD 1080p displays• Sharp 65-inch LCD TV = 1920x1080• Samsung 82-inch LCD TV = 1920x1080• Samsung 102-inch plasma TV = 1920x1080• JVC 48-inch LCoS RP monitor = 1920x1080• Sony 70-inch LCoS RPTV = 1920x1080

Get the picture?

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Higher Resolution Displays:Boon or Pandora’s Box?

Be Careful What You Ask For

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Gimme Those Pixels!

Everyone wants HDTV imaging resolution But there are trade-offs, as usual

• Decoding and deinterlacing SD/HD video• Image scaling vs. native pixel resolution• Bandwidth and image detail• Accurate grayscales and color shading

None of these are “easy” to do!

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Analog Video Is Still Around

Converting SD video:• Decode composite to component • Convert interlaced to progressive• Correct for intraframe motion artifacts• Eliminate scan line artifacts• Preserve image detail without ringing• Detect and correct for different frame/field cadences

(3:2, 2:3:3:2, 2:2:2:4, etc)

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

The Ideal Decoded Signal

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

The Sad Reality

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Deinterlacing SD Video

With 480p CRT displays, it’s not as much of an issue (resolution limits of spot size)

With 720p/768p FP displays, scan line and motion artifacts are more visible

With 1080p FP displays, problem is severe as all SD artifacts are revealed

Is 1080p native resolution a good thing, or is it Pandora’s Box?

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Deinterlacing Video

480i source deinterlacing not as intense for processors as 1080i

Most 1080i processors do not convert both fields, only one

Result: 540p scaled to 720p (fudging) This trick doesn’t work when using a native

1080p display

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Deinterlacing Video

Quality deinterlacing and motion correction applied here

Inferior deinterlacing and motion correction applied here

Both frames enlarged 4X

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Image Scaling for HD Displays

Two ways to do it:• UP in resolution (interpolation of add’l. pixels)• DOWN in resolution (decimation of pixels)• The greater the difference in total pixels, the more difficult

either process becomes 480p to 600p: +25%, not too bad… 1080i to 600p: -56%, a pretty good leap! Composite video to 1080p HD: +88% (Uh-oh…)

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Going Up In Resolution

480p source image

600p scaled image

Not difficult to pull off while maintaining

good image quality

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Going Down In Resolution

1920x1080p source image

1024x600p scaled imagePicture detail is thrown away, but overall image

quality is tolerable

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Flat-Out Asking For Trouble

480i source image

1920x1080 scaled image

You don’t realize how bad SD video looks

until you try this trick!

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Image Scaling Headaches

Garbage in, garbage out• Noise reduction (analog, digital MPEG ‘mosquitoes’)• Field vs. frame conversion (1080i to 540p)• Color space errors (601 or 709 to RGB)

Higher resolution fixed-pixel projection systems clearly show scaling defects

Poor SD video performance is #1 cause of consumer returns on fixed-pixel TVs

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Bandwidth and Detail Problems

A little known ‘secret’: Many expensive fixed-pixel displays are short on HD bandwidth• Desire to save $$ on components• Inclusion of ‘video sharpness’ circuits• Obsession with edge enhancement• Designing display for 480p sources

Mostly seen on YPbPr (analog) inputs

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

The Ideal Bandwidth Response

Full bandwidth signal processing (>18 MHz)

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

The Sad Reality

Clipped bandwidth signal processing (<12 MHz)

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

I Want My Money Back

Luminance detail more important than chrominance detail

In MPEG, luminance samples at twice chrominance or more (4:2:2, 4:2:0, etc)

Clipped BW not an issue with SD displays, but a big issue with HD displays

With many HD displays, you are not getting the performance you paid for!

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

I Want My Money Back

In a typical HD display:• Inferior scaling of low-rez video• Poor de-interlacing and motion correction• Poor noise reduction (digital and analog)• Clipped bandwidth above 12 MHz• Too much edge enhancement with SD + HD

Result: An expensive HD display no better than a cheaper SD display

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Grayscale – Color Purity

Perhaps the two hardest things for any HD display to handle well

Digital systems have it tougher (PWM) Shadow detail always difficult to render Expansive grayscales are problematic

• Industry obsessed with contrast ratio• White detail crush very common

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Grayscale Problems

False contouring and white crush are seen

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Color Purity Problems

Color purity across HD image is a must Color shifts can be caused by:

• Poorly designed mirrors, integrators• Refraction in imaging devices• Inconsistency in color filter materials• Low-cost optics and lenses• Uneven spectral output of illuminants

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Projector Color Shifts

Projector was set to ‘Middle’ or ‘Normal’ WB in each case

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Projector Color Shifts

Not as noticeable with business graphics (saturated colors go pastel)

More noticeable with mid/high gray tones Definitely noticeable with flesh tones! A difficult problem with short-arc lamps

• Fix with filtering, but lose light• Move to xenon imaging? Cost issues?

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Contenders and Pretenders

Everyone’s Got a Better Mousetrap

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

E M I S S I V E

transmissive

Reflective

?

???

????????

?

????

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Contenders for the ThroneContenders for the Throne

Emissive - You view the light source directly• CRT, plasma, SED, FED, LED, O-LED

Transmissive - You view shuttered light• TFT LCD monitors, HTPS LCD projectors

Reflective - You view reflected light• DLP, LCoS and variations (D-ILA, SXRD, etc)

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

E M I S S I V E

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Emissive ContendersEmissive Contenders

CRT (cathode-ray tube) technology the oldest and best-known variation

Limitations in brightness and physical size

Resolution always tied to brightness

High voltages required Power consumption issues

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Emissive ContendersEmissive Contenders

Plasma display panels (PDPs) are a step forward

Resolution and brightness link is broken

Higher native resolutions, high brightness and contrast

Saturated phosphors, wide viewing angles

Light weight, thin profile Power still an issue

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Emissive ContendersEmissive Contenders

Light-emitting diodes (LEDs) are a step further

Lower operating voltages for luminous energy

Thinner profile, high brightness and contrast

Resolution still coarse High current consumption Modular and durable display

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Emissive ContendersEmissive Contenders

Organic light-emitting diodes (O-LEDs) push the envelope farther out

Super-thin, low-voltage technology

High contrast, brightness Bright colors and wide

viewing angles Current consumption and

uniformity are problems

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Emissive ContendersEmissive Contenders

Surface-conducting Electron-emitting Displays (SEDs) have promise, but…

Super-thin technology with CRT-like image quality

High contrast, brightness Bright colors and wide

viewing angles Can Canon and Toshiba

actually deliver it?

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

transmissive

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Transmissive “Threats”Transmissive “Threats”

Liquid-crystal displays (LCDs) are mature

Link between brightness and resolution broken

Low voltage technology, scalable over various sizes

Viewing angles and black levels are issues

Color filter imaging not as intense as phosphors

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Transmissive “Threats”Transmissive “Threats”

High-temperature polysilicon (HTPS)

Enabled the portable projector market

Low-cost imaging technology at high resolution

Monochrome, requires outboard color filters

Questions as to durability of panels and filters

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Reflective

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Reflective ChallengersReflective Challengers

Digital light processing (DLP) High resolutions possible Efficient technology, lightweight

projectors Monochrome, needs color

filters / wheels Black levels good, high

brightness / contrast 100% digital system,

unaffected by analog stimuli

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Reflective ChallengersReflective Challengers

Liquid-crystal on silicon (LCoS)

High resolutions possible Efficient technology,

lightweight projection systems

High resolution to 4K Black level / contrast issues Manufacturing issues - yields

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Never A Dull Moment

Significant Display News - 2005

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Significant News - 2005Significant News - 2005

So Far This Year:• Fujitsu exits plasma and LCD fab businesses• The LCD – plasma “war” continues• LCoS fights for respectability, market share• HTPS projection engines strike back• LEDs are used as -- projection lamps?• “1080p” is the latest display buzzword• ELVs, iMods, P-OLEDs grab attention at SID

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Significant News - 2005Significant News - 2005

Plasma: FUJITSU CRIES “UNCLE!”• Falling prices, declining profit margins in both PDP

and TFT LCD manufacturing to blame• Competitive advantage to Korean, Chinese fabs• Sells all but 19% of FHP interest to Hitachi• Sells all IP and patents outright to Hitachi• Sells LCD fabs, IP outright to Sharp• Just another OEM now…….

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Significant News - 2005Significant News - 2005

NO PRISONERS TAKEN IN LCD – PLASMA MARKET SHARE BATTLES• Average MSRP of 42” ED plasma TV ranges from

$1500 to $2500 - ED going away in favor of HD• 50-inch plasma TV now well under $5K SRP• LCD dominates to 32”, “no man’s land” at 37” size• 32” LCD under $1500, 37” at $2500• Average 42” ED plasma sold at $50 loss in 2004

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Significant News - 2005Significant News - 2005

LCOS JUST WANTS TO BE LOVED:• More companies pursuing LCoS as alternative

technology to DLP (multiple sources, cheaper)• Yields still a big problem for all LCoS types• Some companies just hanging on by fingernails• Sony, JVC continue battles at high end (2K, 4K)• Push in China and Korea to build LCoS TVs• “1080p” seen as tipping point for LCoS

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Significant News - 2005Significant News - 2005

HTPS LCD HAS A FEW TRICKS LEFT:• Sony, Panasonic, Sanyo all introduce new color

correction systems• Dynamic iris and gamma correction (Panasonic)• Adoption in more 720p RPTVs (Mitsubishi)• .9” 1920x1080 panels coming from Epson for front

and rear projection• Front projection systems (Fujitsu, Sanyo, Barco)

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Significant News - 2005Significant News - 2005

YOU’VE GOT TO BE KIDDING!:• LumiLEDs light engines (RGB stripes) now in

‘pocket’ projectors• Models from Mitsubishi, Samsung, BenQ, InFocus• Light output 30 – 50 lumens on small screens (12”)• Single chip DLP (800x600) designs• Question: Why not just use a laptop instead?

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Significant News - 2005Significant News - 2005

THROW OUT YOUR 720P DISPLAYS:• Industry becoming obsessed with 1080p imaging• Support across all display technologies

• DMDs – 2K professional, 960x1080 consumer• LCoS – 1920x1080 D-ILA, SXRD, others• HTPS – 1920x1080 panels• TFT LCD – now as small as 37” diagonally• Plasma – 71” screens to 102” screens

• Silicon Optix field / frame deinterlacing issues

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Significant News - 2005Significant News - 2005

HOW DID THEY EVER COME UP WITH - -• Electrowetting light valve (ELV)

• Uses oil and water• Simple monochrome light shutter

• Polymer organic light-emitting diodes (P-OLEDs)• Colors can be fluorescent, phosphorescent• Ink-jet printable

• Interferometric Modulator (IMod)• Bends light with refraction, reflection

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

OK, Back To Reality

The Rough Waters Ahead

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

The Battle Lines are DrawnThe Battle Lines are Drawn

Plasma vs. LCD• New plasma fabs coming on-line in Korea, China• Plasma has edge in price across competitive sizes

• 37” is current battleground, also 40 – 42”• LCD still limited in sizes above 46”

• Materials cost lower in plasma screens• Color rendering still better than LCD for now• Popular choice as consumer TV screen

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

The Battle Lines are DrawnThe Battle Lines are Drawn

Plasma vs. LCD• “Full court press” by plasma manufacturers to correct

misconceptions about panel life, burn-in, cost• New gas mixtures (xenon and neon) improve

phosphor life and brightness• Plasma ‘tube’ technology may allow larger sizes• Caveat: Plasma technology may be reaching the

limit of improvements!

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

PDP Technology EnhancementsPDP Technology Enhancements

Plasma Tube Structure• Breaks the link between

glass size and imaging elements

• Reduced costs in manufacturing

• May allow curved screen plasma displays

• Shown: Fujitsu tube demo

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

The Battle Lines are DrawnThe Battle Lines are Drawn

players / partners in PDPs: Japan – Panasonic, Hitachi, Pioneer

• Panasonic #1 WW in sales• May partner with Hitachi on PDP projects• Pioneer owns ex-NEC fabs, OEMs NEC glass• Hitachi now in charge of FHP factory• No new VC investment in plasma is likely

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

The Battle Lines are DrawnThe Battle Lines are Drawn

players / partners in PDPs: Korea – Samsung, LG

• Samsung #1 WW in PDP shipments (>200K/month)• LG and Samsung have both expanded fabs• Both companies make largest PDPs in world

China – Chungwha Picture Tube• Building 46-inch SD/HD panels (Mitsubishi design)

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

The Battle Lines are DrawnThe Battle Lines are Drawn

LCD vs. PLASMA• LCD is aggressively marketed across all channels• Many OEM partners selling into US market• LCD manufacturers working hard to address:

• Viewing angles (could be better)• Black levels (still 10x that of best plasma)• Color accuracy (needs to emulate CRT gamut)• Motion smear

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

LCD Technology EnhancementsLCD Technology Enhancements

Viewing angles• New polarizing films

being shown• Close to 170 degrees in

any axis possible• Improves off-axis color

and black levels• Scalable to any sizes• Shown: Nitto Denko

New Filter Old Filter

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

LCD Technology EnhancementsLCD Technology Enhancements

Color Gamut• Use of LEDs expanding• Color-corrected CCFL

and HCFL backlights• Hybrid LED / CCFLs also

shown• Power savings with

brighter whites• Shown: Philips Aptura

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

LCD Technology EnhancementsLCD Technology Enhancements

Color Gamut• Use of LEDs expanding• Color-corrected CCFL

and HCFL backlights• Hybrid LED / CCFLs exist• Power savings with

brighter whites• Shown: Samsung 46”

1080p LCD TV with LED stripe backlights

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

LCD Technology EnhancementsLCD Technology Enhancements

Cleaner Motion• Scanning backlight• Black frame insertion• Effect is similar to a

motion picture shutter• Techniques can be

combined• Shown: LG Philips combo

scanning backlight and black frame insertion

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

The Battle Lines are DrawnThe Battle Lines are Drawn

Plasma OR LCD: WHO WINS?• LCD making huge jumps in image quality each year• LCD offers 1080p imaging in smaller screen sizes• Plasma will always be limited by brightness• Predictions:

• Plasma migrates to consumer TV market on lower price, competes with microdisplay RPTV

• LCD captures 37-inch “battleground” in 2005, becomes display of choice for DS, pro AV channels to 42 inches

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

The Battle Lines are DrawnThe Battle Lines are Drawn

DLP vs. LCOS:• DLP now shipping in two 1080p variations

• 2048x1080 for digital cinema, large venue• 960x1080 for consumer RPTVs, uses “wobbulation”

• LCoS panels all ship with full 2K resolution• Consumer RPTVs (JVC, Sony, eLCOS, LG)• Professional monitors (JVC)• Front projectors (Sony, JVC, Canon)

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

DLP AdvancementsDLP Advancements

More DLP at lower cost:• 1080p monitors• Uses single-chip engine• Expanded multi-segment

color wheels with faster sequencing

• Improved light sources and color correction

• Shown: Samsung 70-inch 1080p DLP RPTV

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

LCoS AdvancementsLCoS Advancements

Expanded use of LCOS:• 1080p monitors• Uses three-panel engine• Dichroic filters for wide

color gamut• No sequential color

wheels or scanning• Xenon light source• Shown: JVC 48-inch D-

ILA reference monitor

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

The Battle Lines are DrawnThe Battle Lines are Drawn

DLP OR LCOS: WHO WINS?• DLP yields are typically better than LCoS• More DLP product in production – it’s mainstream• LCoS has potentially lower costs, no IP issues• Many Asian manufacturers entering LCoS business• Predictions:

• LCoS needs more time before significant penetration• DLP will rule the lower-price “roost” for several years

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

The Battle Lines are DrawnThe Battle Lines are Drawn

DLP vs. HTPS LCD:• DLP has achieved 2K resolution, but only ‘full’ 2K

with professional displays• HTPS LCD has achieved full 2K resolution with .9”

panels for all types of displays• DLP limited to single-chip with color wheel in smaller

projection engines• HTPS LCD is three-chip with color filters in all

projection engines

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

HTPS LCD AdvancementsHTPS LCD Advancements

Visual Quality Issues:• ‘Screen door’ effect is being

minimized• Lower black levels due to

dynamic irising of content• Color gamut accuracy is

greatly improved• Shown: Panasonic PT-

AE700U front LCD projector

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

The Battle Lines are DrawnThe Battle Lines are Drawn

DLP OR HTPS LCD: WHO WINS?• HTPS LCD improvements for 2005 are dramatic!• HTPS LCD still has price advantage

• Typical 720p LCD projector is $2500• Lowest-cost 720p DLP projector is $4500

• Predictions:• LCD remains strong, affordable projection technology• DLP prices must drop to compete in 720p skew• Issues with full 1080p imaging will surface

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Oh, and By The Way…

Better Living Through Displays?

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Oh, and By the Way….Oh, and By the Way….

On-board OS• Integral piece of a

network• Faster LANs allow remote

file access• Maintenance and status

updates enabled• Diagnose and fix many

‘operator error’ issues

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Oh, and By the Way….Oh, and By the Way….

100% digital video interfaces• Smart set-up between

monitor and display card or video source

• Best match to pixel resolution and refresh rate

• DVI for pro markets• HDMI for consumer

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Oh, and By the Way….Oh, and By the Way….

Improved on-board video processing• More functions on one

chip set• Scaling, de-interlacing,

motion correction, cadence correction

• Enables a true resolution-independent display

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Oh, and By the Way…Oh, and By the Way…

Power Saving Modes• Larger displays consume

lots of electricity!• Need to improve luminous

efficiency (lumens/watt or nits/watt)

• Smart backlights• Pulsed backlights• Low power modes

The International Communications Industries Association, Inc.®

Trends In Display Technologies The Wild Ride Continues…

Peter H. Putman, CTS

President, ROAM Consulting Inc.Founder, HDTVexpert.com

Recommended