The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Successful Residential Sensing Deployments

1

The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Successful Residential Sensing

Deployments

Timothy W. Hnat, Vijay Shrinivasan, Jiakang Lu, Tamim I. Sookoor, Raymond

Dawson, John Stankovic, and Kamin Whitehouse

2

Sensing in Homes

MedicalMonitoring

HomeAutomation

EnergyManagement

People spend 65% of time in their homes

3

Sensing in Homes

Extreme Environments Indoors is hard too!

Photo courtesy of: Jan Beutel

4

Sensing in Homes

1200 sensors Over 20 homes Up to 1 year/home

Diffi

culty

#Sensors

#Sen

sors

< #Out

lets

#Sen

sors

> #Out

lets

5

Sensing in Homes

1200 sensors Over 20 homes Up to 1 year/home

Diffi

culty

#Sensors

#Hom

es <

#Res

earc

hers

#Hom

es >

#Res

earc

hers

#Homes

6

Sensing in Homes

1200 sensors Over 20 homes Up to 1 year/home

Diffi

culty

#Sensors

#Day

s < ~1

mon

th

#Day

s > ~1

mon

th

#Homes

#Days

7

Outline Deployment Overview Reliability and Failure Analysis A Hitchhiker’s Guide

8

Deployments Overview

9

Deployments Overview

10

Deployments Overview

11

Our DeploymentsDeployment

# Homes

Weeks

Motion

Object Use

Door Heights

Wearable Tracking

Light Switch

Power (Plugs)

Power (Circuits)

Power (Mains)

Water Mains

Custom Thermostat

Active Register

Light/Temp Humidity

A 11 1-2 25-30

12-20 - - - - - - - - - -

B 1 1 - - 12 12 - - - - - - - -

C 3 3-4 15-25 - - - - - - - - - - 12-

25

D 1 2 4 - - - - 2 - - - - - -

E 1 2 5 - - - - - 1 - - - - -

F 1 28 65 13 13 16 22 - - 1 1 1 12 86

G 1 44 54 7 31 14 22 8 37 1 1 1 12 29

H 1 39 15 7 14 - 11 4 - 1 1 - - -

I 1 32 25 10 30 - 31 3 48 1 1 - - 8

J 1 25 14 5 17 - 7 2 - 1 1 - - -

12

Outline Deployment Overview Reliability and Failure Analysis A Hitchhiker’s Guide

13

Fault Analysis

…

Time

Sens

ors

14

Failure Analysis

15

Fault Analysis Power Outage

Time

Sens

ors

…

Sensor-Days – down time × number of sensors

Fault Analysis

16

Reinstall

Hard drive failure

Sub-system failure Plug disconnections

17

Outline Deployment Overview Reliability and Failure Analysis A Hitchhiker’s Guide

18

Homes are Not a Power Panacea 30-40 outlets per house Long wires 2.3x more down time than

batteries More maintenance calls

19

Homes Have Poor Connectivity Wireless connectivity

Power line communications Wires 180bit/s 5 min polling rate Exploiting Home Automation Protocols

for Load Monitoring in Smart Buildings

20

Homes are Hazardous Environments

Children Mobile objects Roomba Guests and

cleaning services

21

Homes are Remote Environments Minimize installation time

Scout Lab assembly and

configuration Checklists

22

Expect Limited User Participation Button Tracking Wearable Tracking Self-reporting Surveys

22

23

Aesthetics Matter in Homes Disappear into the

woodwork Leave no trace No LEDS at night Noise

24

Simplify the Architecture

25

Similar Work Infrastructure-based

Neural Network House, Aware-Home, MavHome, PlaceLab

Infrastructure-less Tapia, Cook, Kasteren

Lessons Learned Edwards and Grinter – 7 challenges “Hitchhiker’s guides for WSN deployments”

26

Summary AC Power is not abundant or reliable Wireless connectivity is worse than expected Unexpected environmental hazards Houses are remote environments User participation is limited Aesthetics are important COTS are a double-edged sword

27

Thank You

Any questions?

28

Root FailuresRoot Cause House G House H House I House J

Sensing sub-system 4107 642 4757 274

Gateway Down 5596 0 3 136

Plug Disconnected 509 30 474 10

Battery Dead 452 17 168 0

Wireless Link Loss 410 0 122 1

Internet Down 251 97 178 9

Power Outage 21 0 87 2