Preview:
DESCRIPTION
Abu Muhammad Aasim al-Maqdisi Language: English | Format: PDF | Pages: 553| Size: 6.5 MB Collection of the most Important subjects about the Islamic Religion in 375 Chapters. Book One- The Book of Good Manners Book Two- The Book about the Etiquette of Eating Book Three- The Book of Dress Book Four- The Book of the Etiquette of Sleeping, Lying and Sitting, etc. Book Five- The book of Greetings Book Six- The Book of Visiting the Sick Book Seven- The Book of Etiquette of Traveling Book Eight- The Book of Virtues Book Nine- The Book of I’tikaf Book Ten- The Book of Hajj Book Eleven- The Book of Jihad Book Twelve- The Book of Knowledge Book Thirteen- The Book of Praise and Gratitude to Allah Book Fourteen- The Book of Supplicating Allah to Exalt the Mention of Allah’s Messenger (phuh) Book Fifteen- The Book of the Remembrance of Allah Book Sixteen- The Book of Du’a (Supplications) Book Seventeen- The Book of the Prohibited Actions Book Eighteen- The Book of Miscellaneous Adadith of Significant values Book Nineteen- The Book of Forgiveness
Citation preview
- 1. 7+(%22.2)0,6&(//$1< &+$37(5
6,1&(5,7$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@&RPPHQWDU
$FFRUGLQJWRVRPH$KDGLWKWKHUHDVRQIRUWKLV+DGLWK
LVWKDWDSHUVRQVHQWDSURSRVDORIPDUULDJHWRDZRPDQQDPHG8PP4DLVZKLFKVKHWXUQHGGRZQVDLQJWKDWKHVKRXOGKDYHWRHPLJUDWHWR$O0DGLQDKIRU
LW$FFRUGLQJOKHGLGLWIRUWKLVVSHFLILFSXUSRVHDQGWKHWZRZHUHPDUULHGWKHUH2QDFFRXQWRIWKLVHYHQWWKHPDQFDPHWREHNQRZQDPRQJWKH&RPSDQLRQVDV0XKDMLU8PP4DLV2QWKHEDVLVRIWKLV+DGLWK8ODPDDUHRIWKHXQDQLPRXVRSLQLRQWKDWWKHUHDOEDVLVRIRQHVDFWLRQVLV1LDKLQWHQWLRQ
- 11.
DQGHYHURQHZLOOEHUHTXLWHGDFFRUGLQJWRKLV1LDK,WLVWUXHWKDW1LDKLVIRXQGHGLQRQHVKHDUWWKDWLVWRVDRQHKDVILUVWWRPDNHXSRQHVPLQGIRUZKDWKHLQWHQGVWRGRDQGKHVKRXOGQRWH[SUHVVLWYHUEDOO,QIDFWWKHODWWHULVD%LGCDKLQQRYDWLRQLQUHOLJLRQ
- 12.
EHFDXVHQRSURRIRILWLVIRXQGLQ6KDULDK7KHSRLQWZKLFKEHFRPHVHYLGHQWIURPWKLV+DGLWKLVWKDW,NKODVVLQFHULW
- 13. LVDPXVWIRUHYHUDFWLRQ,QRWKHUZRUGVLQHYHUULJKWHRXV
GHHGRQHVKRXOGVHHNRQOWKH3OHDVXUHRI$OODKRWKHUZLVHLWZLOOQRWEHDFFHSWHGE$OODK1DUUDWHG$CLVKDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKHU
- 14. UHSRUWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 15. VDLG $QDUPZLOOUDLGWKH.DCEDKDQGZKHQLWUHDFKHVDGHVHUWODQG
DOORIWKHPZLOOEHVZDOORZHGXSEWKHHDUWK 6KHDVNHG
20HVVHQJHURI$OODK:KDOORIWKHP"+HDQVZHUHG$OORIWKHPZLOOEHVZDOORZHGEWKHHDUWKEXWWKHZLOOEHUDLVHGIRU-XGJHPHQWDFFRUGLQJWRWKHLULQWHQWLRQV>$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@&RPPHQWDU
(YHURQHZLOOEHUHZDUGHGRUSXQLVKHGDFFRUGLQJWRKLVDLPDQGLQWHQWLRQ7KLV+DGLWKDOVRSURYHVWKDWWKHFRPSDQRIGHSUDYHGSHUVRQVLVH[WUHPHOGDQJHURXV:KRVHDUPZRXOGLWEHZKLFKKDVEHHQUHIHUUHGWRLQWKH+DGLWKDQGZKHQZLOOLWLQYDGH.DCEDKLVDPDWWHUNQRZQWR$OODK$ORQH6XFKSURSKHFLHVDUHDSDUWRIWKH8QVHHQZRUOG6LQFHWKHFRPHLQWKHFDWHJRURIWKHPLUDFOHV
- 16. RIWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 17.
LWLVQHFHVVDUWREHOLHYHLQWKHLUYHUDFLWDQGRFFXUUHQFH%HOLHYLQJLQVXFKSURSKHVLHVLVDOVRHVVHQWLDOEHFDXVHWKHZHUHUHYHDOHGE$OODK
- 18. $CLVKDK 0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKHU
- 19. QDUUDWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 20. VDLG 7KHUHLVQRHPLJUDWLRQDIWHUWKHFRQTXHVWRI0DNNDK
- 21. EXWRQO-LKDG>VWULYLQJDQGILJKWLQJLQWKHFDXVHRI$OODK
- 22.
ZLOOFRQWLQXH@DQGJRRGLQWHQWLRQ6RLIRXDUHVXPPRQHGWRILJKWJRIRUWK>$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@,QWHQWLRQDFFRUGLQJWR$Q1DZDZL,WPHDQVWKDWJRRGQHVVZKLFKFHDVHGWRFRQWLQXHEWKHFHVVDWLRQRIHPLJUDWLRQFDQVWLOOEHREWDLQHGE-LKDG
DQGELQWHQGLQJDFFRPSOLVKLQJJRRGGHHGV&RPPHQWDU:KHQDFRXQWURUDUHJLRQLVUHJDUGHGDVDUXO,VODP
ODQGRI,VODP
- 23.
LWLVQRWQHFHVVDUWRPLJUDWHIURPLWWRVRPHRWKHUSODFH,WLVKRZHYHUREOLJDWRUWRHPLJUDWHIURPVXFKUHJLRQVZKLFKDUHDUXO.XIUODQGRILQILGHOV
- 24.
DQGZKHUHLWLVGLIILFXOWWRDGKHUHWR,VODPLFLQMXQFWLRQV,WLVDOVRHYLGHQWIURPWKLV+DGLWKWKDWZKHQLWLVQRWQHFHVVDUWRPLJUDWHIURPRQH,VODPLFFRXQWUWRDQRWKHUWKHQLWLVDOVRQRWSHUPLWWHGEWKH6KDULCDKWROHDYHDQ,VODPLFFRXQWUWRVHWWOHSHUPDQHQWOLQDUXO.XIURQOIRUWKHUHDVRQWKDWWKHODWWHUKDVSOHQWRIZHDOWKDQGVRFLDOZHOIDUH8QIRUWXQDWHO0XVOLPVWRGDDUHDIIOLFWHGZLWKWKLVGLVHDVH7KHWUDQVIHURIWKHLUFDSLWDODQGWDOHQWWRDUXO.XIULV
LQGHHGYHUGLVWXUELQJEHFDXVHRQRQHVLGHWKHVHWZRIDFWRUVDUHOHQGLQJVXSSRUWWRWKHHFRQRPRI
%LODGXO.XIUFRXQWULHVRILQILGHOV
- 25.
DQGRQWKHRWKHUREVFHQLWDQGLQGHFHQFWKDWDUHFRPPRQLQVXFKFRXQWULHVDUHEHFRPLQJLQFUHDVLQJOFRPPRQDPRQJWKH0XVOLPVWRR$QRWKHUKLJKOLPSRUWDQWUHDVRQIRUWKHSURKLELWLRQRIPLJUDWLRQRI0XVOLPVWRDUXO.XIULVWKDWLWJRHVDJDLQVWWKHVSLULWDVZHOODVWKHLUUHDGLQHVVIRU-LKDGILVDELOLOODKVWULYLQJDQGILJKWLQJLQWKHZDRI$OODK
- 26.
7KLVVSLULWDQGUHDGLQHVVPXVWEHNHSWDOZDVDOLYHVRWKDWWKH0XVOLPVPDUHVSRQGDWRQFHWRWKHFDOORI-LKDGZKHQHYHUWKHQHHGIRULWDULVHVDQZKHUH
-DELUELQ$EGXOODK$O$QVDUL0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHP
- 27. UHSRUWHG:HDFFRPSDQLHGWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 28. LQDQH[SHGLWLRQZKHQKHVDLG
7KHUHDUHVRPHPHQLQ$O0DGLQDKZKRDUHZLWKRXZKHUHYHURXPDUFKDQGZKLFKHYHUYDOOHRXFURVV7KHKDYHQRWMRLQHGRXLQSHUVRQEHFDXVHRIWKHLULOOQHVV
,QDQRWKHUYHUVLRQKHVDLG 7KHVKDUHWKHUHZDUG
ZLWKRX>0XVOLP@,WLVQDUUDWHGE%XNKDULIURP$QDVELQ0DOLN0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 29. :HZHUHFRPLQJEDFNIURPWKHEDWWOHRI7DEXNZLWKWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 30. ZKHQKHUHPDUNHG
7KHUHDUHSHRSOHZKRPZHOHIWEHKLQGLQ$O0DGLQDKZKRDFFRPSDQLHGXVLQVSLULWLQHYHUSDVVDQGYDOOHZHFURVVHG7KHUHPDLQHGEHKLQGIRUDYDOLGH[FXVH&RPPHQWDU
:KDWZHOHDUQIURPWKLV+DGLWKLVWKDWLIWKHLQWHQWLRQDQGVSLULWRI-LKDGDUHSUHVHQWLQWKHKHDUWRID0XVOLPEXWSKVLFDOOKHLVXQDEOHWRWDNHSDUWLQLWIRUYDOLGUHDVRQVKHZLOOJHWWKHUHZDUGRI-LKDGZLWKRXWHYHQKLVDFWXDOSDUWLFLSDWLRQLQLW
0DCQELQ
- 31. KHKLVIDWKHUDQGKLVJUDQGIDWKHUDOOZHUH&RPSDQLRQV
- 32.
UHSRUWHG0IDWKHUVHWDVLGHVRPHGLQDUVIRUFKDULWDQGJDYHWKHPWRDPDQLQWKHPRVTXH,ZHQWWRWKDWPDQDQGWRRNEDFNWKRVHGLQDUV+HVDLG,KDGQRWLQWHQGHGRXWREHJLYHQ6RZHZHQWWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 33. DQGSXWIRUWKWKHPDWWHUEHIRUHKLP+HVDLGWRPIDWKHU
$O%XNKDUL@&RPPHQWDU7KLV+DGLWKOHDGVXVWRWKHFRQFOXVLRQWKDWLI6DGDTDKFKDULW
- 34.
JRHVWRDQHHGVRQRID0XVOLPWKHUHLVQRQHHGWRWDNHLWEDFNIURPKLPIRUWKHUHDVRQWKDWWKHIDWKHUKDGLQWHQGHGWRJLYHLWWRDGHVHUYLQJSHUVRQ7KHIRUPHUJHWVWKHUHZDUGIRULWRQDFFRXQWRIKLV1LDKLQWHQWLRQ
- 35. 7KLVKRZHYHUZLOOEHUHFNRQHGDV1DIOL6DGDTDKYROXQWDUFKDULW
- 36. EHFDXVHWKHREOLJDWRU=DNDW6DGDTDK
- 37. FDQQRWEHJLYHQWRWKHGRQRUVRZQGHSHQGHQWV
- 38. ,WLVSHUPLVVLEOHLQ6KDULCDKWRPDNHVRPHRQHD:DNLO
DWWRUQHRUDJHQW
- 39.
IRU6DGDTDK,WGRHVQRWDPRXQWWRGLVREHGLHQFHRQWKHSDUWRIDVRQWRWDNHKLV
IDWKHUWRDFRPSHWHQWDXWKRULWRUVFKRODUWRNQRZWKHOHJDOSRVLWLRQRQDQLVVXHLQWKHVDPHZDDVPXWXDOGLVFXVVLRQDQGGHEDWHRQPDWWHUVRI6KDULCDKGRHVQRWDPRXQWWRLQVROHQFH)DWK$O%DULFKDSWHURQ=DNDW
- 40. $EX,VKDT6DCGELQ$EX:DTTDV0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 41.
RQHRIWKHWHQZKRKDGEHHQJLYHQWKHJODGWLGLQJVRIHQWULQWR-DQQDK
- 42. QDUUDWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 43.
YLVLWHGPHLQPLOOQHVVZKLFKEHFDPHVHYHUHLQWKHHDURI+DMMDWXO:DGDC)DUHZHOO3LOJULPDJH
- 44.
,VDLG20HVVHQJHURI$OODKRXFDQVHHWKHSDLQZKLFK,DPVXIIHULQJDQG,DPDPDQRIPHDQVDQGWKHUHLVQRQHWRLQKHULWIURPPHH[FHSWRQHGDXJKWHU6KRXOG,JLYHWZRWKLUGVRIPSURSHUWLQFKDULW"+H3%8+
- 45. VDLG 1R ,DVNHGKLP7KHQKDOI"+HVDLG 1R
7KHQ,DVNHG&DQ,JLYHDZDRQHWKLUG+HVDLG
*LYHDZDRQHWKLUGDQGWKDWLVVWLOOWRRPXFK,WLVEHWWHUWROHDYHRXUKHLUVZHOORIIWKDQWROHDYHWKHPSRRUEHJJLQJSHRSOH
- 46. DQGKDUPIXOWRRWKHUVWKHHQHPLHVRI,VODP
- 47.
- 48. IXUWKHUVDLG
2$OODKFRPSOHWHIRUP&RPSDQLRQVWKHLUHPLJUDWLRQDQGGRQRWFDXVHWKHPWRUHWUDFW
6DCGELQ.KDXODKZDVXQIRUWXQDWH 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 49.
ODPHQWHGKLVGHDWKDVKHGLHGLQ0DNNDK>$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@&RPPHQWDU
,QVSLWHRIDOOWKHLUORYHIRULWWKH&RPSDQLRQVRIWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 50.
GLGQRWOLNHWRGLHLQDFLWIURPZKLFKWKHHPLJUDWHGIRUWKHVDNHRI$OODK)RUWKLVUHDVRQ6DCG0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 51. ZDVDIUDLGRIGLQJLQ0DNNDK7KH3URSKHW3%8+
- 52.
SUDHGIRUWKHDFFRPSOLVKPHQWRI6DCGVHPLJUDWLRQDQGH[SUHVVHGUHJUHWRYHUWKHPLVIRUWXQHRI
6DCGELQ.KDXODK7KHODWWHUGLHGLQ0DNNDK&RQFOXVLRQ7KH+DGLWKODVGRZQWKDWLQWKHFRXUVHRIDGLVHDVHZKLFKVHHPVWRSURYHIDWDORQHFDQQRWJLYHPRUH
WKDQRQHWKLUGRIWKHSURSHUWLQFKDULW,WLVDOVRHPSKDVL]HGWKDWRQHJHWVUHZDUGHYHQIRUZKDWKHVSHQGVRQKLVZLIHDQGFKLOGUHQ2QHFDQUHSRUWWRRWKHUVKLVDLOPHQWRUWRVHHNWUHDWPHQWDQGDVNWKHPWRVXSSOLFDWHIURPKLP,QWKHPDWWHURI6DGDTDKFKDULW
- 53.
ZKLFKRQHJLYHVWRVHHNWKH3OHDVXUHRI$OODKKLVFORVHVWUHODWLYHVVKRXOGDOZDVKDYHSULRULWDQGSUHIHUHQFHRYHURWKHUV
$EX+XUDLUDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 54. QDUUDWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 55. VDLG $OODKGRHVQRW
ORRNDWRXUILJXUHVQRUDWRXUDWWLUHEXW+HORRNVDWRXUKHDUWVDQGDFFRPSOLVKPHQWV>0XVOLP@&RPPHQWDU
7KLV+DGLWKKLJKOLJKWVWKHLPSRUWDQFHRIVLQFHULWDQGJRRGLQWHQWLRQ,WLVWKHUHIRUHHVVHQWLDOWKDWHYHUQREOHDFWLRQVKRXOGEHEDVHGRQWKHVHWZRYLUWXHVDQGKHDUWVKRXOGEHIUHHIURP
DOOVXFKWKLQJVWKDWGHVWURQREOHGHHGV+SRFULVRVWHQWDWLRQJUHHGIRUZHDOWKULFKHVDQGRWKHUZRUGOWKLQJVIDOOLQWKHFDWHJRURIVXFKHYLOV6LQFHWKHWUXHFRQGLWLRQRIKHDUWLVNQRZQWR$OODKDORQHWKHWUXHSRVLWLRQRIRQHVDFWLRQVZLOOEHNQRZQRQWKHDRI
5HVXUUHFWLRQZKHQRQHZLOOEHUHTXLWHGIRUWKHPE$ODK,QWKLVZRUOGRQHZLOOEHWUHDWHGDFFRUGLQJWRKLVDSSDUHQWFRQGLWLRQZKLOHKLVLQVLJKWZLOOEHOHIWWR$OODK
$EX0XVD$O$VKCDUL0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 56. UHSRUWHGWKDW0HVVHQJHURI$OODK 3%8+
- 57. ZDVDVNHGDERXWZKRILJKWVLQWKH EDWWOHILHOGRXWRIYDORXURURXWRI
]HDORURXWRI
KSRFULVZKLFKRIWKLVLVFRQVLGHUHGDVILJKWLQJLQWKHFDXVHRI$OODK"+HVDLG +H
ZKRILJKWVLQRUGHUWKDWWKH:RUGRI$OODKUHPDLQVWKHVXSUHPHLVFRQVLGHUHGDVILJKWLQJLQWKHFDXVHRI$OODK>$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@
- 58. &RPPHQWDU
6LQFHRQHVDFWLRQZLOOEHHYDOXDWHGLQWHUPVRILQWHQWLRQVRKHDORQHZRXOGEHD0XMDKLG
ZDUULRULQWKHFDXVHRIHHQ
- 59. ZKRILJKWVWRJORULIWKH1DPHRI$OODK
$EX%DNUDK$WK7KDTDIL0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 60. UHSRUWHG7KH3URSKHW3%8+
- 61.
VDLG:KHQWZR0XVOLPVDUHHQJDJHGLQDFRPEDWDJDLQVWHDFKRWKHUZLWKWKHLUVZRUGVDQGRQHLVNLOOHGERWKDUHGRRPHGWR+HOO
,VDLG20HVVHQJHURI$OODK$VWRWKHRQHZKRNLOOVLWLVXQGHUVWDQGDEOHEXWZKWKHVODLQRQH"+H3%8+
- 62. UHSOLHG
+HZDVHDJHUWRNLOOKLVRSSRQHQW>$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@&RPPHQWDU
7KLV+DGLWKOHDGVWRWKHFRQFOXVLRQWKDWRQHZRXOGEHSXQLVKHGIRUVXFKVLQIXOLQWHQWLRQIRUZKLFKKHKDVPDGHDILUPGHWHUPLQDWLRQDQGIRUWKHFRPPLWPHQWRIZKLFKKHKDVDGRSWHGQHFHVVDUPHDVXUHVHYHQLIKHGRHVQRWVXFFHHGLQFRPPLWWLQJLWEHFDXVHRIFHUWDLQREVWUXFWLRQ7KXVGHWHUPLQDWLRQLVGLIIHUHQWIURPDVXJJHVWLRQRIWKHGHYLO7KHODWWHULVH[FXVDEOHZKLOHRQHLVDFFRXQWDEOHIRUKLVGHWHUPLQDWLRQ+RZHYHUZKDWLVPHQWLRQHGLQWKH+DGLWKZLOOKDSSHQZKHQ0XVOLPV
ILJKWDPRQJWKHPVHOYHVIRUZRUOGOKRQRXUDQGSUHMXGLFHVDQGQRUHOLJLRXVLVVXHZRXOGEHWKHFDXVHRIWKHLUFRQIOLFWEHFDXVHLQWKHODWWHUFDVHLWLVSRVVLEOHWKDWERWKPLJKWEHGHSHQGLQJRQWKHLURZQ,MWLKDGH[HUFLVHRIRSLQLRQ
- 63. IRUZKLFKWKHPDEHH[FXVHG
$EX+XUDLUDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 64. UHSRUWHGWKDW7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 65. VDLG
7KHUHZDUGIRU6DODWSHUIRUPHGEDSHUVRQLQFRQJUHJDWLRQLVPRUHWKDQWLPHVJUHDWHUWKDQWKDWRIWKH6DODWSHUIRUPHGLQRQHVKRXVHRUVKRS:KHQRQHSHUIRUPV:XGXSHUIHFWODQGWKHQSURFHHGVWRWKHPRVTXHZLWKWKHVROHLQWHQWLRQRISHUIRUPLQJ6DODWWKHQIRUHYHUVWHSKHWDNHVWRZDUGVWKHPRVTXHKHLVXSJUDGHGRQHGHJUHHLQUHZDUGDQGRQHRIKLVVLQVLVHOLPLQDWHGXQWLOKHHQWHUVWKHPRVTXHDQGZKHQKHHQWHUVWKHPRVTXHKHLVFRQVLGHUHGDVSHUIRUPLQJ6DODWDVORQJDVLWLVWKH6DODWZKLFKSUHYHQWVKLPIURPOHDYLQJWKHPRVTXH
- 66.
DQGWKHDQJHOVNHHSRQVXSSOLFDWLQJ$OODKIRUKLPDVORQJDVKHUHPDLQVLQKLVSODFHRISUDHU7KHVD2$OODKKDYHPHUFRQKLP2$OODKIRUJLYHKLVVLQV2$OODKDFFHSWKLVUHSHQWDQFH7KLVZLOOFDUURQDVORQJDVKHGRHVQRWSDVVZLQG>$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@&RPPHQWDU
7KLV+DGLWKVKRZVWKDWDOWKRXJKLWLVSHUPLVVLEOHWRSHUIRUP6DODWLQGLYLGXDOOLQPDUNHWSODFHVDQGKRXVHVEXWLWVFROOHFWLYHSHUIRUPDQFHLQWKHPRVTXHLVRUWLPHVPRUHPHULWRULRXVDVPHQWLRQHGLQRWKHU$KDGLWK
C$EGXOODKELQC$EEDV0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHP
- 67. UHSRUWHG 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 68. VDLGWKDW$OODKWKH*ORULRXVVDLG 9HULO$OODK6:7
- 69.
KDVRUGHUHGWKDWWKHJRRGDQGWKHEDGGHHGVEHZULWWHQGRZQ7KHQ+HH[SODLQHGLWFOHDUOKRZWRZULWH
- 70.
+HZKRLQWHQGVWRGRDJRRGGHHGEXWKHGRHVQRWGRLWWKHQ$OODKUHFRUGVLWIRUKLPDVDIXOOJRRGGHHGEXWLI
KHFDUULHVRXWKLVLQWHQWLRQWKHQ$OODKWKH([DOWHGZULWHVLWGRZQIRUKLPDVIURPWHQWRVHYHQKXQGUHGIROGVDQGHYHQPRUH%XWLIKHLQWHQGVWRGRDQHYLODFWDQGKDVQRWGRQHLWWKHQ$OODKZULWHVLWGRZQZLWK+LPDVDIXOOJRRGGHHGEXWLIKHLQWHQGVLWDQGKDVGRQHLW$OODKZULWHVLWGRZQDVRQHEDGGHHG>$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@&RPPHQWDU
:KDWWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 71. UHODWHVWR$OODKLVFDOOHG+DGLWK4XGVL 6DFUHG7UDGLWLRQ
- 72. 6XFK+DGLWKLVUHYHDOHGWRWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 73. EPHDQVRI,OKDP LQVSLUDWLRQ
- 74.
7KLV+DGLWKPHQWLRQVWKHPDJQLWXGHRILYLQHEOHVVLQJVZKLFK+HEHVWRZVXSRQ+LVIDLWKIXOVODYHVRQWKHDRI
5HVXUUHFWLRQ
C$EGXOODKELQC8PDUELQ$O.KDWWDE0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHP
- 75. QDUUDWHGWKDW+HKHDUG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 76. DVVDLQJ
7KUHHPHQDPRQJVWWKRVHZKRFDPHEHIRUHRXVHWRXWXQWLOQLJKWFDPHDQGWKHUHDFKHGDFDYHVRWKHHQWHUHGLW$URFNIHOOGRZQIURPWKHPRXQWDLQDQGEORFNHGWKHHQWUDQFHRIWKHFDYH7KHVDLGC1RWKLQJZLOOVDYHRXIURPWKLVXQOHVVRXVXSSOLFDWHWR$OODKEYLUWXHRIDULJKWHRXVGHHGRXKDYH
GRQH7KHUHXSRQRQHRIWKHPVDLGC2$OODK,KDGSDUHQWVZKRZHUHROGDQG,XVHGWRRIIHUWKHPPLONEHIRUHDQRIPFKLOGUHQRUVODYHV2QHGD,ZHQWIDUDZDLQVHDUFKRIJUD]LQJDQGFRXOGQRWFRPHEDFNXQWLOWKHKDGVOHSW:KHQ,PLONHGDVXVXDO
DQGEURXJKWWKHGULQN,IRXQGWKHPERWKDVOHHS,KDWHGWRGLVWXUEWKHPDQGDOVRGLVOLNHGWRJLYHPLONWRPFKLOGUHQEHIRUHWKHP0FKLOGUHQZHUHFULQJRXWRIKXQJHUDWPIHHWEXW,DZDLWHGZLWKWKHERZOLQPKDQGIRUWKHPWRZDNHXS:KHQWKHDZRNH
DWGDZQWKHGUDQNPLON2$OODK,I ,GLGVRWRVHHN
- 77. WKDQDQRQHHOVHLQDQRWKHUYHUVLRQKHVDLGDVDPDQFDQORYHDZRPDQ
- 78.
,ZDQWHGWRKDYHVH[XDOLQWHUFRXUVHZLWKKHUEXWVKHUHIXVHG+DUGSUHVVHGLQDHDURIIDPLQHVKHDSSURDFKHGPH,JDYHKHURQHKXQGUHGDQGWZHQWGLQDUVRQFRQGLWLRQWKDWVKHZRXOGLHOGKHUVHOIWRPH6KHDJUHHGDQGZKHQZHJRWWRJHWKHUIRUVH[XDOLQWHUFRXUVH
- 79.
VKHVDLG)HDU$OODKDQGGRQRWEUHDNWKHVHDOXQODZIXOO,PRYHGDZDIURPKHULQVSLWHRIWKHIDFWWKDW,ORYHGKHUPRVWSDVVLRQDWHODQG,OHWKHUNHHSWKHPRQH,KDGJLYHQKHU2
$OODK,I,GLGWKDWWRVHHN$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@&RPPHQWDU,WLVSHUPLVVLEOHWRSUDWKURXJKRXUYLUWXRXVGHHGV%XWWRPDNHVRPHRQHDPHGLXPIRULWLVDQLQQRYDWLRQLQHHQZKLFKVKRXOGEHDYRLGHGIRUWZRPDMRUUHDVRQV)LUVWOWKHUHLVQRHYLGHQFHLQ6KDULCDKWRVXSSRUWWKLV6HFRQGOLWLVDJDLQVWWKHSUDFWLFHRI.KDLUXO4XUXQWKHEHVWRIJHQHUDWLRQV7KLVWHUPLVXVHGIRUWKHILUVWWKUHHJHQHUDWLRQVRI0XVOLPVWKHRQHLQZKLFKWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 80. OLYHGDQGWKHWZRIROORZLQJ
- 81.
3UHIHUHQFHVKRXOGEHJLYHQWRWKHVHUYLFHRISDUHQWVHYHQRYHUWKHVHUYLFHRIRQHVRZQZLIHDQGFKLOGUHQ7RDEVWDLQIURPVLQVRXWRIIHDURI$OODKLVDKLJKOPHULWRULRXVDFW/DERXUHUVVKRXOGDOZDVEHWUHDWHGIDLUO,IVRPHRQHKDVSDLGWRDODERXUHUOHVVWKDQKLVGXHLWVKRXOGEHSDLGWRKLPLQDGHFHQWPDQQHU$QVXSSOLFDWLRQZKLFKLVPDGHVLQFHUHODQGZLWKUHDOVHQVHRIKXPEOHQHVVLVJUDQWHGE$OODK$OODKVRPHWLPHVKHOSV+LVSLRXVPHQHYHQLQDQXQXVXDOPDQQHUZKLFKLVWHUPHGDV.DUDPDWZRQGHURUPDUYHO
- 82.
7KXVOLNHWKHPLUDFOHVRIWKH3URSKHWVZRQGHUVRIWKHULJKWHRXVSHRSOHDUHDOVRWUXH%XWPLUDFOHVDQGZRQGHUVERWKDSSHDUZLWKWKH:LOORI$OODK
&+$37(5
5(3(17$1&(6FKRODUVVDLG,WLVQHFHVVDUWRUHSHQWIURPHYHUVLQ,IWKHRIIHQVHLQYROYHVWKH5LJKWRI$OODKQRWDKXPDQWKHQWKHUHDUHWKUHHFRQGLWLRQWREHPHWLQRUGHUWKDWUHSHQWDQFHEHDFFHSWHGE$OODK
7RGHVLVWIURPFRPPLWWLQJLW 7RIHHOVRUUIRUFRPPLWWLQJLW
7RGHFLGHQRWWRUHFRPPLWLW$QUHSHQWDQFHIDLOLQJWRPHHWDQRIWKHVHWKUHHFRQGLWLRQVZRXOGQRWEHVRXQG%XWLIWKHVLQLQYROYHVDKXPDQVULJKWLWUHTXLUHVDIRXUWKFRQGLWLRQLHWRDEVROYHRQVHOIIURPVXFKULJKW,ILWLVDSURSHUWKHVKRXOGUHWXUQ
LWWRLWVULJKWIXORZQHU,ILWLVVODQGHULQJRUEDFNELWLQJRQHVKRXOGDVNWKHSDUGRQRIWKHRIIHQGHG
- 83.
2QHVKRXOGDOVRUHSHQWIURPDOOVLQV,IKHUHSHQWVIURPVRPHKLVUHSHQWDQFHZRXOGVWLOOEHVRXQGDFFRUGLQJWRWKHSHRSOHRIVRXQGNQRZOHGJH+HVKRXOGKRZHYHUUHSHQWIURPWKHUHVW
6FULSWXUDOSURRIVIURPWKH%RRNDQGWKH6XQQDKDQGWKHFRQVHQVXVRIWKHVFKRODUVVXSSRUWWKHLQFXPEHQFRIUHSHQWDQFH$OODKWKH([DOWHGVDV$QGDOORIRXEHJ$OODKWRIRUJLYHRX2EHOLHYHUVWKDWRXPDEHVXFFHVVIXO
- 84. 6HHNWKHIRUJLYHQHVVRIRXU5XEEDQGWXUQWR+LPLQUHSHQWDQFH
- 85. 2RXZKREHOLHYH7XUQWR$OODKZLWKVLQFHUHUHSHQWDQFH
- 86. $EX+XUDLUDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 87. UHSRUWHG,KHDUG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 88. VDLQJ %$OODK,VHHN$OODKV
IRUJLYHQHVVDQGUHSHQWWR+LPPRUHWKDQVHYHQWWLPHVDGD>$O%XNKDUL@&RPPHQWDU,WLVDQLQGXFHPHQWIRUVHHNLQJSDUGRQDQGIRUJLYHQHVV7KH3URSKHW3%8+
- 89. ZKRVHSDVWDQGIXWXUHVLQVZHUHIRUJLYHQDVNHG$OODKVIRULJYHQHVV
WKHQKRZDERXW
XVZKRFRPPLWVLQVRQUHJXODUEDVLVQRWWRVHHNSDUGRQDQGIRUJLYHQHVVIURP$OODK"6LQFHUHDQGFHDVHOHVVSUDHUIRUSDUGRQLVHVVHQWLDOVRWKDWVLQVFRPPLWWHGEXVXQLQWHQWLRQDOODUHDOVRIRUJLYHQ7KHDERYH+DGLWKODVJUHDWHPSKDVLVRQVHHNLQJSDUGRQ
$O$JKDUUELQ
- 90. QDUUDWHGWKDW7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 91. VDLG 7XUQRXSHRSOHLQUHSHQWDQFHWR$OODKDQGEHJSDUGRQRI
+LP,WXUQWR+LPLQUHSHQWDQFHDKXQGUHGWLPHVDGD>0XVOLP@
$QDVELQ0DOLN$O$QVDUL0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 92.
WKHVHUYDQWRIWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKQDUUDWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 93. VDLG
9HULO$OODKLVPRUHGHOLJKWHGZLWKWKHUHSHQWDQFHRI+LVVODYHWKDQDSHUVRQZKRORVWKLVFDPHOLQDGHVHUWODQGDQGWKHQILQGVLWXQH[SHFWHGO
- 94. >$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ ,QDQRWKHUYHUVLRQRI0XVOLPKHVDLG
9HULO$OODKLVPRUHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHUHSHQWDQFHRI+LVVODYHWKDQDSHUVRQZKRKDVKLVFDPHOLQDZDWHUOHVVGHVHUWFDUULQJKLVSURYLVLRQRIIRRGDQGGULQNDQGLWLVORVW+HKDYLQJORVWDOOKRSHVWRJHWWKDWEDFN
- 95.
OLHVGRZQLQVKDGHDQGLVGLVDSSRLQWHGDERXWKLVFDPHOZKHQDOORIDVXGGHQKHILQGVWKDWFDPHOVWDQGLQJEHIRUHKLP+HWDNHVKROGRILWVUHLQVDQGWKHQRXWRIERXQGOHVVMREOXUWVRXW2$OODK
- 96. UHSRUWHG7KH3URSKHW3%8+
- 97.
VDLG$OODKWKH([DOWHGZLOOFRQWLQXHWRVWUHWFKRXW+LV+DQGLQWKHQLJKWVRWKDWWKHVLQQHUVRIWKHGDPDUHSHQWDQGFRQWLQXHWRVWUHWFK+LV+DQGLQWKHGDWLPHVRWKDWWKHVLQQHUVRIWKHQLJKWPDUHSHQWXQWLOWKHVXQULVHVIURPWKHZHVW>0XVOLP@
- 98. &RPPHQWDU
7KLV+DGLWKFRQILUPVDQHVVHQWLDO$WWULEXWHRI$OODKLHWKH+DQGZKLFK+HVWUHWFKHVRXWDQWLPH+HZLVKHVZLWKRXWGUDZLQJVLPLODULWWRLWQRULQWHUSUHWDWLRQ6XFKZDVWKHDWWLWXGHRIWKHSLRXVSUHGHFHVVRUVZLWKUHJDUGVWRDOORIWKHHVVHQWLDO$WWULEXWHVRI$OODK,WLVGHGXFHGIURPWKLV+DGLWKWKDWLIRQHFRPPLWVDVLQGXULQJDQKRXURIGDRUQLJKWKHVKRXOGLPPHGLDWHOVHHNWKHIRUJLYHQHVVRI$OODKDVDUHVXOW
$EX+XUDLUDK 0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 99. QDUUDWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 100. VDLG
+HZKRUHSHQWVEHIRUHWKHVXQULVHVIURPWKHZHVW$OODKZLOOIRUJLYHKLP>0XVOLP@&RPPHQWDU
7DXEDKPHDQVUHWXUQLQJWR$OODKIURPVLQV:KHQDSHUVRQFRPPLWVDVLQKHJRHVDZDIURP$OODK:KHQKHUHSHQWVKHUHWXUQVWR$OODKDQGGHVLUHVIRUEHLQJSDUGRQHGE+LPDQGJHWWLQJQHDU+LP7KLVUHWXUQLQJWRZDUGV+LPLV7DXEDK:KHQLWLVVDLGWKDWC$OODKWXUQVWRZDUGVKLPLWPHDQVWKDW$OODKDFFHSWVKLVUHSHQWDQFH
C$EGXOODKELQC8PDU ELQ$O.KDWWDE 0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHP
- 101. UHSRUWHGWKDW7KH3URSKHW3%8+
- 102. VDLG
$OODKDFFHSWVDVODYHVUHSHQWDQFHDVORQJDVWKHODWWHULVQRWRQKLVGHDWKEHGWKDWLVEHIRUHWKHVRXORIWKHGLQJSHUVRQUHDFKHVWKHWKURDW
- 103. >$W7LUPLGKLZKRFDWHJRULVHGLWDV+DGLWK+DVDQ@&RPPHQWDU
7KHZRUG*KDUJKDUDKPHDQVWKHVWDJHZKHQVRXOLVDERXWWROHDYHWKHERGDQGUHDFKHVWKHWKURDW,QRWKHUZRUGVWKHWLPHZKHQRQHVXIIHUVWKHDJRQRIGHDWK
+DGLWK+DVDQPHDQVWKDW+DGLWKWKHDXWKHQWLFLWRIZKLFKLVFRQQHFWHGZLWKRXWDQWHFKQLFDOGHIHFW7KHLUQDUUDWRUVKRZHYHUDUHQH[WWRWKRVHRI+DGLWK6DKLK,QWKHRSLQLRQRI0XKDGGLWKLQ
+DGLWKVFKRODUV
- 104. +DGLWK+DVDQLVDOVRUHOLDEOHDV+DGLWK6DKLK
=LUUELQ+XEDLVKUHSRUWHG,ZHQWWR6DIZDQELQC$VVDO
0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 105.
WRLQTXLUHDERXWZLSLQJZLWKZHWKDQGVRYHUOLJKWERRWVZKLOHSHUIRUPLQJ:XGX+HDVNHGPH:KDWEULQJVRXKHUH=LUU",DQVZHUHG6HDUFKIRUNQRZOHGJH+HVDLG$QJHOVVSUHDGWKHLUZLQJVIRUWKHVHHNHURINQRZOHGJHRXWRI
MRIRUZKDWKHVHHNV,WROGKLP,KDYHVRPHGRXEWVLQPPLQGUHJDUGLQJZLSLQJRIZHWKDQGVRYHUOLJKWERRWVLQWKHFRXUVHRISHUIRUPLQJ:XGXDIWHUGHIHFDWLRQRUXULQDWLQJ1RZVLQFHRXDUHRQHRIWKH&RPSDQLRQVRIWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 106. ,KDYHFRPHWRDVNRXZKHWKHURXKHDUGDQVDLQJRIWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 107. FRQFHUQLQJLW"+HUHSOLHGLQWKHDIILUPDWLYHDQGVDLG+H3%8+
- 108.
LQVWUXFWHGXVWKDWGXULQJDMRXUQHZHQHHGQRWWDNHRIIRXUOLJKWERRWVIRUZDVKLQJWKHIHHWXSWRWKUHHGDVDQGQLJKWVH[FHSWLQFDVHRIPDMRULPSXULWDIWHUVH[XDOLQWHUFRXUVH
- 109.
,QRWKHUFDVHVVXFKDVVOHHSLQJUHOLHYLQJRQHVHOIRUXULQDWLQJWKHZLSLQJRIZHWKDQGVRYHUOLJKWERRWVZLOOVXIILFH,WKHQTXHVWLRQHGKLPLGRXKHDUKLPVDDQWKLQJDERXWORYHDQGDIIHFWLRQ"+HUHSOLHG:HDFFRPSDQLHGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 110.
LQDMRXUQHZKHQDEHGRXLQFDOOHGRXWLQDORXGYRLFHC20XKDPPDG7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 111. UHSOLHGKLPLQWKHVDPHWRQH C+HUH,DP,VDLGWRKLPWKHEHGRXLQ
- 112.
C:RHWRRXORZHURXUYRLFHLQKLVSUHVHQFHEHFDXVHRXDUHQRWDOORZHGWRGRVR+HVDLGC%$OODK,ZLOOQRWORZHUPYRLFHDQGWKHQDGGUHVVLQJWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 113.
KHVDLGC:KDWDERXWDSHUVRQZKRORYHVSHRSOHEXWKDVQRWIRXQGKLPVHOILQWKHLUFRPSDQ0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 114. UHSOLHG
C2QWKHDRI5HVXUUHFWLRQDSHUVRQZLOOEHLQWKHFRPSDQRIWKRVHZKRPKHORYHV7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKWKHQNHSWRQWDONLQJWRXVDQGLQWKHFRXUVHRIKLVWDONKHPHQWLRQHGDJDWHZDLQWKHKHDYHQWKH
ZLGWKRIZKLFKFRXOGEHFURVVHGEDULGHULQIRUWRUVHYHQWHDUV
6XIDQRQHRIWKHQDUUDWRUVRIWKLVWUDGLWLRQVDLG7KLVJDWHZDLVLQWKHGLUHFWLRQRI6ULD$OODKFUHDWHGLWRQWKHGD+HFUHDWHGWKHKHDYHQVDQGWKHHDUWK,WLVRSHQIRUUHSHQWDQFHDQGZLOOQRWEHVKXWXQWLOWKHVXQULVHVIURPWKDWGLUHFWLRQLHWKH:HVW
- 115. RQRRPVGD
- 116.
>$W7LUPLGKLZKRFDWHJRULVHGLWDV+DGLWK+DVDQ6DKLK@&RPPHQWDU:HOHDUQIURPWKLV+DGLWKWKDWLQDEOXWLRQLWLVSHUPLVVLEOHWRZLSHRYHUOLJKWERRWVUDWKHUWKDQZDVKLQJWKHIHHW,WLVFDOOHG0DVK7KHSHULRGLQZKLFK0DVKLVLQWDFW
LQFDVHRIWUDYHOOHUVLWLVWKUHHGDVDQGWKUHHQLJKWVZKLOHIRUWKHUHVLGHQWVLWLVRQHGDDQGRQHQLJKWRQO$SUHFRQGLWLRQIRULWLVWKDWOLJKWERRWVVKRXOGEHFOHDQDQGZRUQDIWHUIXOO:XGX$QNOHVVKRXOGDOVREHFRYHUHG,QFDVHRIEUHDFKRIDEOXWLRQWKHZLSLQJRYHUWKHVRFNVLVVXIILFLHQWDQGWKHUHLVQRQHHGIRUZDVKLQJWKHIHHW
- 117.
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
- 118. UHSRUWHG3URSKHWRI$OODK3%8+
- 119.
VDLG7KHUHZDVDPDQIURPDPRQJDQDWLRQEHIRUHRXZKRNLOOHGQLQHWQLQHSHRSOHDQGWKHQPDGHDQLQTXLUDERXWWKHPRVWOHDUQHGSHUVRQRQWKHHDUWK+HZDVGLUHFWHGWRDPRQN+HFDPHWRKLPDQGWROGKLPWKDWKHKDGNLOOHGQLQHWQLQHSHRSOHDQGDVNHGKLPLIWKHUHZDVDQFKDQFHIRUKLVUHSHQWDQFHWREHDFFHSWHG+HUHSOLHGLQWKHQHJDWLYHDQGWKHPDQNLOOHGKLPDOVRFRPSOHWLQJRQHKXQGUHG+HWKHQDVNHGDERXWWKHPRVWOHDUQHGPDQLQWKHHDUWK+HZDVGLUHFWHGWRDVFKRODU+HWROGKLPWKDWKHKDGNLOOHGRQHKXQGUHGSHRSOHDQGDVNHGKLPLIWKHUHZDVDQFKDQFHIRUKLVUHSHQWDQFHWREHDFFHSWHG+HUHSOLHGLQWKHDIILUPDWLYHDQGDVNHGC:KRVWDQGVEHWZHHQRXDQGUHSHQWDQFH"*RWRVXFKDQGVXFKODQGWKHUHRXZLOOILQG
- 120.
SHRSOHGHYRWHGWRSUDHUDQGZRUVKLSRI$OODKMRLQWKHPLQZRUVKLSDQGGRQRWFRPHEDFNWRRXUODQGEHFDXVHLWLVDQHYLOSODFH6RKHZHQWDZDDQGKDUGOKDGKHFRYHUHGKDOIWKHGLVWDQFHZKHQGHDWKRYHUWRRNKLPDQGWKHUHZDVDGLVSXWHEHWZHHQWKHDQJHOVRIPHUFDQGWKHDQJHOVRIWRUPHQW7KHDQJHOVRIPHUFSOHDGHG7KLVPDQKDVFRPHZLWKDUHSHQWLQJKHDUWWR$OODKDQGWKHDQJHOVRISXQLVKPHQWDUJXHG+HQHYHUGLGDYLUWXRXVGHHGLQKLVOLIH7KHQWKHUHDSSHDUHGDQRWKHUDQJHOLQWKHIRUPRIDKXPDQEHLQJDQGWKHFRQWHQGLQJDQJHOVDJUHHGWRPDNHKLPDUELWHUEHWZHHQWKHP+HVDLGC0HDVXUHWKHGLVWDQFHEHWZHHQWKHWZRODQGV+HZLOOEHFRQVLGHUHGEHORQJLQJWRWKHODQGWRZKLFKKHLVQHDUHU7KHPHDVXUHGDQGIRXQGKLPFORVHUWRWKHODQGODQGRISLHW
- 121.
ZKHUHKHLQWHQGHGWRJRDQGVRWKHDQJHOVRIPHUFFROOHFWHGKLVVRXO>$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@
,QDQRWKHUYHUVLRQ +HZDVIRXQGWREHQHDUHUWRWKHORFDOLWRIWKH
SLRXVEDFXELWDQGZDVWKXVLQFOXGHGDPRQJWKHP $QRWKHUYHUVLRQVDV
$OODKFRPPDQGHGWKHODQGZKLFKKHZDQWHGWROHDYH
- 122. WRPRYHDZDDQGFRPPDQGHGWKHRWKHUODQGKLVGHVWLQDWLRQ
- 123.
WRGUDZQHDUHUDQGWKHQ+HVDLG1RZPHDVXUHWKHGLVWDQFHEHWZHHQWKHP,WZDVIRXQGWKDWKHZDVQHDUHUWRKLVJRDOEDKDQGVVSDQDQGZDVWKXVIRUJLYHQ
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
$EGXOODKELQ.DCEZKRVHUYHGDVWKHJXLGHRI.DCEELQ0DOLN0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 124.
ZKHQKHEHFDPHEOLQGQDUUDWHG,KHDUG.DCEELQ0DOLN0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 125. QDUUDWLQJWKHVWRURIKLVUHPDLQLQJEHKLQGLQVWHDGRI
MRLQLQJ0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 126.
ZKHQKHOHIWIRUWKHEDWWOHRI7DEXN.DCEVDLG,DFFRPSDQLHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 127.
LQHYHUH[SHGLWLRQZKLFKKHXQGHUWRRNH[FHSWLQJWKHEDWWOHRI7DEXNDQGWKHEDWWOHRI%DGU$VIRUWKHEDWWOHRI%DGUQRERGZDVEODPHGIRUUHPDLQLQJEHKLQGDV0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 128.
DQGWKH0XVOLPVZKHQWKHVHWRXWKDGLQPLQGRQOWRLQWHUFHSWWKHFDUDYDQRIWKH4XUDLVK$OODKPDGHWKHPFRQIURQWWKHLUHQHPLHVXQH[SHFWHGO,KDGWKHKRQRXURIEHLQJZLWK0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 129.
RQWKHQLJKWRIC$TDEDKZKHQZHSOHGJHGRXUDOOHJLDQFHWR,VODPDQGLWZDVGHDUHUWRPHWKDQSDUWLFLSDWLQJLQWKHEDWWOHRI%DGUDOWKRXJK%DGUZDVPRUHZHOONQRZQDPRQJWKHSHRSOHWKDQWKDW$QGWKLVLVWKHDFFRXQWRIPVWDLQJEHKLQGIURPWKHEDWWOHRI7DEXN,QHYHUKDGEHWWHUPHDQVDQGPRUHIDYRXUDEOHFLUFXPVWDQFHVWKDQDWWKHWLPHRIWKLVH[SHGLWLRQ$QGE$OODK,KDGQHYHUEHIRUHSRVVHVVHGWZRULGLQJFDPHOVDV,GLGGXULQJWKHWLPHRIWKLVH[SHGLWLRQ:KHQHYHU0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 130.
GHFLGHGWRJRRQDFDPSDLJQKHZRXOGQRWGLVFORVHKLVUHDOGHVWLQDWLRQWLOOWKHODVWPRPHQWRIGHSDUWXUH
- 131. %XWRQWKLV
- 132.
H[SHGLWLRQKHVHWRXWLQH[WUHPHOKRWZHDWKHUWKHMRXUQHZDVORQJDQGWKHWHUUDLQZDVZDWHUOHVVGHVHUWDQGKHKDGWRIDFHDVWURQJDUPVRKHLQIRUPHGWKH0XVOLPVDERXWWKHDFWXDOSRVLWLRQVRWKDWWKHVKRXOGPDNHIXOOSUHSDUDWLRQIRUWKHFDPSDLJQ$QGWKH0XVOLPVZKRDFFRPSDQLHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 133.
DWWKDWWLPHZHUHLQODUJHQXPEHUEXWQRSURSHUUHFRUGRIWKHPZDVPDLQWDLQHG.DCEIXUWKHU
- 134.
VDLG)HZZHUHWKHSHUVRQVZKRFKRVHWRUHPDLQDEVHQWEHOLHYLQJWKDWWKHFRXOGHDVLOKLGHWKHPVHOYHVDQGWKXVUHPDLQXQGHWHFWHG
- 135.
XQOHVV5HYHODWLRQIURP$OODKWKH([DOWHGDQG*ORULRXVUHYHDOHGUHODWLQJWRWKHP
- 136. $QG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 137.
VHWRXWRQWKLVH[SHGLWLRQZKHQWKHIUXLWZHUHULSHDQGWKHLUVKDGHZDVVRXJKW,KDGDZHDNQHVVIRUWKHPDQGLWZDVGXULQJWKLVVHDVRQWKDW0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 138.
DQGWKH0XVOLPVPDGHSUHSDUDWLRQV,DOVRZRXOGVHWRXWLQWKHPRUQLQJWRPDNHSUHSDUDWLRQVDORQJZLWKWKHPEXWZRXOGFRPHEDFNKDYLQJGRQHQRWKLQJDQGVDLGWRPVHOI,KDYHPHDQVHQRXJKWRPDNHSUHSDUDWLRQV
- 139.
DVVRRQDV,OLNH$QG,ZHQWRQGRLQJWKLVSRVWSRQLQJPSUHSDUDWLRQV
- 140.
WLOOWKHWLPHRIGHSDUWXUHFDPHDQGLWZDVLQWKHPRUQLQJWKDW0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 141.
VHWRXWDORQJZLWKWKH0XVOLPVEXW,KDGPDGHQRSUHSDUDWLRQV,ZRXOGJRHDUOLQWKHPRUQLQJDQGFRPHEDFNEXWZLWKQRGHFLVLRQ,ZHQWRQGRLQJVRXQWLOWKHWKH0XVOLPV
- 142.
KDVWHQHGDQGFRYHUHGDJRRGGHDORIGLVWDQFH7KHQ,ZLVKHGWRPDUFKRQDQGMRLQWKHP:RXOGWKDW,KDGGRQHWKDW%XWSHUKDSVLWZDVQRWGHVWLQHGIRUPH$IWHUWKHGHSDUWXUHRI0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 143.
ZKHQHYHU,ZHQWRXW,ZDVJULHYHGWRILQGQRJRRGH[DPSOHWRIROORZEXWFRQILUPHGKSRFULWHVRUZHDNSHRSOHZKRP$OODKKDGH[HPSWHGIURPPDUFKLQJIRUWKIRU-LKDG
- 144. 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 145.
PDGHQRPHQWLRQRIPHXQWLOKHUHDFKHG7DEXN:KLOHKHZDVVLWWLQJZLWKWKHSHRSOHLQ7DEXNKHVDLG
C:KDWKDSSHQHGWR.DCEELQ0DOLN"
$SHUVRQIURP%DQX6DOLPDKVDLG20HVVHQJHURI$OODKWKHEHDXW
- 146. RIKLVFORDNDQGDQDSSUHFLDWLRQRI
KLVILQHUKDYHGHWDLQHGKLP8SRQWKLV0XCDGKELQ-DEDO0DW$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 147. DGPRQLVKHGKLPDQGVDLGWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 148.
%$OODKZHNQRZQRWKLQJDERXWKLPEXWJRRG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 149. KRZHYHUNHSWTXLHW$WWKDWWLPHKHWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 150. VDZDSHUVRQGUHVVHGLQZKLWHDQGVDLG
C%H$EX.KDLWKDPDK$QGZDV$EX.KDLWKDPDK$O$QVDULZDVWKHSHUVRQZKRKDGFRQWULEXWHGD6DCRIGDWHVDQGZDVULGLFXOHGEWKHKSRFULWHV.DCEELQ0DOLNIXUWKHUVDLG:KHQWKHQHZVUHDFKHGPHWKDW0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 151.
ZDVRQKLVZDEDFNIURP7DEXN,ZDVJUHDWOGLVWUHVVHG,WKRXJKWRIIDEULFDWLQJDQH[FXVHDQGDVNHGPVHOIKRZ,ZRXOGVDYHPVHOIIURPKLVDQJHUWKHQH[WGD,QWKLVFRQQHFWLRQ,VRXJKWWKHFRXQVHOVRIHYHUSUXGHQWPHPEHURIPIDPLO:KHQ,ZDVWROGWKDW0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 152. ZDVDERXWWRDUULYHDOOWKHZLFNHGLGHDVYDQLVKHGIURPPPLQG
- 153.
DQG,FDPHWRWKHFRQFOXVLRQWKDWQRWKLQJEXWWKHWUXWKFRXOGVDYHPH6R,GHFLGHGWRWHOOKLPWKHWUXWK,WZDVLQWKHPRUQLQJWKDW0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 154.
DUULYHGLQ$O0DGLQDK,WZDVKLVKDELWWKDWZKHQHYHUKHFDPHEDFNIURPDMRXUQHKHZRXOGILUVWJRWRWKHPRVTXHDQGSHUIRUPWZR5DNCDKRIRSWLRQDO
SUDHU
- 155.
DQGZRXOGWKHQVLWZLWKWKHSHRSOH:KHQKHVDWWKRVHZKRKDGUHPDLQHGEHKLQGKLPEHJDQWRSXWIRUZDUGWKHLUH[FXVHVDQGWDNHDQRDWKEHIRUHKLP7KHZHUHPRUHWKDQHLJKWLQQXPEHU0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 156.
DFFHSWHGWKHLUH[FXVHVRQWKHYHUIDFHRIWKHPDQGDFFHSWHGWKHLUDOOHJLDQFHDQGVRXJKWIRUJLYHQHVVIRUWKHPDQGOHIWWKHLULQVLJKWVWR$OODKXQWLO,DSSHDUHGEHIRUHKLP,JUHHWHGKLPDQGKHVPLOHGDQGWKHUHZDVDWLQJHRIDQJHULQWKDW+HWKHQVDLGWRPH
&RPHIRUZDUG ,ZHQWIRUZDUGDQG,VDWLQIURQWRIKLP+HVDLGWRPH
C:KDWNHSWRXEDFN"&RXOGRXQRWDIIRUGWRJRLQIRUDULGH"
,VDLG20HVVHQJHURI$OODKE$OODKLI,ZHUHWRVLWEHIRUHDQERGHOVHDPDQRIWKHZRUOG,ZRXOGKDYHGHILQLWHOVDYHGPVHOIIURPKLVDQJHU
RQRQHSUHWH[WRUWKHRWKHUDQG,KDYHDJLIWHGVNLOOLQDUJXPHQWDWLRQEXWE$OODK,DPIXOODZDUHWKDWLI,ZHUHWRSXWIRUZDUGEHIRUHRXDODPHH[FXVHWRSOHDVHRX$OODKZRXOGGHILQLWHOSURYRNHRXUZUDWKXSRQPH,QFDVH,VSHDNWKHWUXWKRXPDEHDQJUZLWKPHEXW,KRSHWKDW$OODKZRXOGEHSOHDVHGZLWKPHDQGDFFHSWPUHSHQWDQFH
- 157.
%$OODKWKHUHLVQRYDOLGH[FXVHIRUPH%$OODK,QHYHUSRVVHVVHGVRJRRGPHDQVDQG,QHYHUKDGVXFKIDYRXUDEOHFRQGLWLRQVIRUPHDV,KDGZKHQ,VWDHGEHKLQG7KHUHXSRQ0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 158. VDLG 7KLVPDQVSRNHWKHWUXWKVRJHWXSDQGZDLW
- 159. XQWLO$OODKJLYHVDGHFLVLRQDERXWRX ,OHIWDQGVRPHSHRSOHRI
%DQX6DOLPDKIROORZHGPH7KHVDLGWRPHC%$OODKZHGRQRWNQRZWKDWRXFRPPLWWHGDVLQEHIRUH
- 160.
OLNHWKRVHZKRVWDHGEHKLQGKLP,WZRXOGKDYHEHHQHQRXJKIRUWKHIRUJLYHQHVVRIRXUVLQWKDW0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 161.
ZRXOGKDYHVRXJKWIRUJLYHQHVVIRURX%$OODKWKHNHSWRQUHSURDFKLQJPHXQWLO,WKRXJKWRIJRLQJEDFNWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 162.
DQGUHWUDFWPFRQIHVVLRQ7KHQ,VDLGWRWKHP+DVDQRQHHOVHPHWWKHVDPHIDWH"7KHVDLG
- 163.
SURKLELWHGWKH0XVOLPVWRWDONWRWKHWKUHHRIXVIURPDPRQJVWWKRVHZKRKDGVWDHGEHKLQG7KHSHRSOHEHJDQWRDYRLGXVDQGWKHLUDWWLWXGHWRZDUGVXVFKDQJHGDQGLWVHHPHGDVLIWKHZKROHDWPRVSKHUHKDGWXUQHGDJDLQVWXVDQGLWZDVLQIDFWWKHVDPHDWPRVSKHUHRIZKLFK,ZDVIXOODZDUHDQGLQZKLFK,KDGOLYHGIRUDIDLUOORQJWLPH
- 164. :H
- 165.
VSHQWILIWQLJKWVLQWKLVYHUVWDWHDQGPWZRIULHQGVFRQILQHGWKHPVHOYHVZLWKLQWKHLUKRXVHVDQGVSHQWPRVWRIWKHLU
- 166.
WLPHZHHSLQJ$V,ZDVWKHRXQJHVWDQGWKHVWURQJHVW,ZRXOGOHDYHPKRXVHDWWHQGWKHFRQJUHJDWLRQDO6DODWPRYHDERXWLQWKHED]DDUVEXWQRQHZRXOGVSHDNWRPH,ZRXOGFRPHWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 167. DVKHVDWDPRQJVWSHRSOH
- 168.
DIWHUWKH6DODWJUHHWKLPDQGZRXOGDVNPVHOIZKHWKHURUQRWKLVOLSVPRYHGLQUHVSRQVHWRPJUHHWLQJV7KHQ,ZRXOGSHUIRUP6DODWQHDUKLPDQGORRNDWKLPVWHDOWKLO:KHQ,ILQLVKP6DODWKHZRXOGORRNDW
PHDQGZKHQ,ZRXOGFDVWDJODQFHDWKLPKHZRXOGWXUQDZDKLVHHVIURPPH:KHQWKHKDUVKWUHDWPHQWRIWKH0XVOLPVWRPHFRQWLQXHGIRUDFRQVLGHUDEOH
- 169.
OHQJWKRIWLPH,ZDONHGDQG,FOLPEHGXSRQWKHZDOORIWKHJDUGHQRI$EX4DWDGDKZKRZDVPFRXVLQDQG,KDGDJUHDWORYHIRUKLP,JUHHWHGKLPEXWE$OODKKHGLGQRWDQVZHUWRPJUHHWLQJ,VDLGWRKLPC2$EX4DWDGDK,DGMXUHRXLQWKH1DPHRI$OODKDUHRXQRWDZDUHWKDW,ORYH$OODKDQG+LV0HVVHQJHU3%8+
- 170.
",DVNHGKLPWKHVDPHTXHVWLRQDJDLQEXWKHUHPDLQHGVLOHQW,DJDLQDGMXUHGKLPZKHUHXSRQKHVDLGC$OODKDQG+LV0HVVHQJHU3%8+
- 171.
NQRZEHWWHU0HHVZHUHILOOHGZLWKWHDUVDQG,FDPHEDFNFOLPELQJGRZQWKHZDOO$V,ZDVZDONLQJLQWKHED]DDUVRI$O0DGLQDKDPDQIURPWKH6ULDQSHDVDQWVZKRKDGFRPHWRVHOOIRRGJUDLQVLQ$O0DGLQDKDVNHGSHRSOHWRGLUHFWKLPWR.DCEELQ0DOLN3HRSOHSRLQWHGWRZDUGVPH+HFDPHWRPHDQGGHOLYHUHGDOHWWHUIURPWKH.LQJRI*KDVVDQDQGDV,ZDVDVFULEH,UHDGWKDWOHWWHUZKRVHSXUSRUWZDV
C,WKDVEHHQFRQYHHGWRXVWKDWRXUIULHQGWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 172.
ZDVWUHDWLQJRXKDUVKO$OODKKDVQRWFUHDWHGRXIRUDSODFHZKHUHRXDUHWREHGHJUDGHGDQGZKHUHRXFDQQRWILQGRXUULJKWSODFHVRFRPHWRXVDQGZHVKDOOUHFHLYHRXJUDFLRXVO$V,UHDGWKDWOHWWHU,VDLG7KLVLVWRRDWULDOVR,SXWLWWRILUHLQDQRYHQ:KHQIRUWGDVKDGHODSVHGDQG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 173.
UHFHLYHGQR5HYHODWLRQWKHUHFDPHWRPHDPHVVHQJHURIWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKDQGVDLGC9HULO0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 174.
KDVFRPPDQGHGRXWRNHHSDZDIURPRXUZLIH,VDLGC6KRXOG,GLYRUFHKHURUZKDWHOVHVKRXOG,GR"+HVDLGC1REXWRQONHHSDZDIURPKHUDQGGRQWKDYHVH[XDOFRQWDFWZLWKKHU7KHVDPHPHVVDJHZDVVHQWWRPFRPSDQLRQV6R,VDLGWR
PZLIH
- 175.
DQGVDLG20HVVHQJHURI$OODK+LODOELQ8PDLDKLVDVHQLOHSHUVRQDQGKDVQR
VHUYDQWRRXGLVDSSURYHLI,VHUYHKLP"+HVDLG
C1REXWGRQWOHWKLPKDYHDQVH[XDOFRQWDFWZLWKRX6KHVDLG%$OODKKHKDVQRVXFKGHVLUHOHIWLQKLP%$OODKKHKDVEHHQLQWHDUVVLQFHWKLVFDODPLW
- 176. VWUXFNKLP0HPEHUVRIPIDPLOVDLGWRPHC
- 177.
LQUHJDUGWRRXUZLIH+HKDVDOORZHGWKHZLIHRI+LODOELQ8PDLDKWRVHUYHKLP,VDLG,ZRXOGQRWVHHNSHUPLVVLRQIURP0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 178.
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
- 179. UHOLHIIRUPH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 180.
KDGLQIRUPHGWKHSHRSOHDERXWWKHDFFHSWDQFHRIRXUUHSHQWDQFHE$OODKDIWHUKH
KDGRIIHUHGWKH)DMUSUDHU6RWKHSHRSOHZHQWRQWRJLYHXVJODGWLGLQJVDQGVRPHRIWKHPZHQWWRPFRPSDQLRQVLQRUGHUWRJLYHWKHPWKHJODGWLGLQJV$PDQVSXUUHGKLVKRUVHWRZDUGVPHWRJLYHWKHJRRGQHZV
- 181.
DQGDQRWKHURQHIURPWKHWULEHRI$VODPFDPHUXQQLQJIRUWKHVDPHSXUSRVHDQGDVKHDSSURDFKHGWKHPRXQW,UHFHLYHGWKHJRRGQHZVZKLFKUHDFKHGPHEHIRUHWKHULGHUGLG:KHQWKHRQHZKRVHYRLFH,KDGKHDUGFDPHWRPHWRFRQJUDWXODWHPH,WRRNRIIPJDUPHQWVDQGJDYHWKHPWRKLPIRUWKHJRRGQHZVKHEURXJKWWRPH%$OODK,SRVVHVVHGQRWKLQJHOVHLQWKHIRUPRIFORWKHV
- 182.
H[FHSWWKHVHJDUPHQWVDWWKDWWLPH7KHQ,ERUURZHGWZRJDUPHQWVGUHVVHGPVHOIDQGFDPHWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 183. 2QPZD,PHWJURXSVRISHRSOHZKRJUHHWHGPHIRUWKHDFFHSWDQFHRI
- 184.
UHSHQWDQFHDQGWKHVDLG&RQJUDWXODWLRQVIRUDFFHSWDQFHRIRXUUHSHQWDQFH,UHDFKHGWKHPRVTXHZKHUH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 185.
ZDVVLWWLQJDPLGVWSHRSOH7DOKDKELQC8EDLGXOODKJRWXSDQGUXVKHGWRZDUGVPHVKRRNKDQGVZLWKPHDQGJUHHWHGPH%$OODKQRSHUVRQVWRRGXSWRJUHHWPH
- 186.
IURPDPRQJVWWKH0XKDMLUXQEHVLGHVKLP.DCEVDLGWKDWKHQHYHUIRUJRWWKLVJRRGJHVWXUHRI
- 187. 7DOKDK.DCEIXUWKHUVDLG,JUHHWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 188.
ZLWKC$VVDODPXCDODLNXPDQGKLVIDFHZDVEHDPLQJZLWKSOHDVXUH+H3%8+
- 189. VDLG
C5HMRLFHZLWKWKHEHVWGDRXKDYHHYHUVHHQVLQFHRXUPRWKHUJDYHRXELUWK
,VDLGC20HVVHQJHURI$OODK,VWKLVJRRGQHZV
- 190. IURPRXRUIURP$OODK"+HVDLG
C1RLWLVIURP$OODK$QGLWZDVFRPPRQZLWK0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 191.
WKDWZKHQHYHUKHZDVKDSSKLVIDFHZRXOGJORZDVLILWZHUHDSDUWRIWKHPRRQDQGLWZDVIURPWKLVWKDWZHUHFRJQL]HGLWKLVGHOLJKW
- 192.
$V,VDWEHIRUHKLP,VDLG,KDYHSODFHGDFRQGLWLRQXSRQPVHOIWKDWLI$OODKDFFHSWVP7DXEDK,ZRXOGJLYHXSDOORIPSURSHUWLQFKDULWIRUWKHVDNHRI$OODKDQG+LV0HVVHQJHU3%8+
- 193. 7KHUHXSRQ0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 194. VDLG C.HHSVRPHSURSHUWZLWKRXDVLWLVEHWWHU
- 195. IRURX
,VDLG,VKDOONHHSZLWKPHWKDWSRUWLRQZKLFKLVLQ.KDLEDU,DGGHG20HVVHQJHURI$OODK9HULO$OODKKDVJUDQWHGPHVDOYDWLRQEHFDXVHRIPWUXWKIXOQHVVDQGWKHUHIRUHUHSHQWDQFHREOLJHVPHWRVSHDNQRWKLQJEXWWKHWUXWKDVORQJDV,DPDOLYH.DCEDGGHG%$OODK,GRQRWNQRZDQRQHDPRQJWKH0XVOLPVZKRKDVEHHQJUDQWHGWUXWKIXOQHVVEHWWHUWKDQPHVLQFH,VDLGWKLVWRWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 196.
%$OODK6LQFHWKHWLPH,PDGHDSOHGJHRIWKLVWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 197.
,KDYHQHYHULQWHQGHGWRWHOODOLHDQG,KRSHWKDW$OODKZRXOGSURWHFWPHDJDLQVWWHOOLQJOLHV
- 198.
IRUWKHUHVWRIPOLIH$OODKWKH([DOWHGWKH*ORULRXVUHYHDOHGWKHVH9HUVHV$OODKKDVIRUJLYHQWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 199.
WKH0XKDMLUXQ0XVOLP(PLJUDQWVZKROHIWWKHLUKRPHVDQGFDPHWR$O0DGLQDK
- 200. DQGWKH$QVDU0XVOLPVRI$O0DGLQDK
- 201. ZKRIROORZHGKLP0XKDPPDG3%8+
- 202. LQWKHWLPHRIGLVWUHVV7DEXNH[SHGLWLRQ
- 203.
DIWHUWKHKHDUWVRIDSDUWRIWKHPKDGQHDUOGHYLDWHGIURPWKH5LJKW3DWK
- 204.
EXW+HDFFHSWHGWKHLUUHSHQWDQFH&HUWDLQO+HLVXQWRWKHPIXOORINLQGQHVV0RVW0HUFLIXO$QG
+HGLGIRUJLYHDOVR
- 205.
WKHWKUHHZKRGLGQRWMRLQ>WKH7DEXNH[SHGLWLRQDQGZKRVHFDVHZDVGHIHUUHGEWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 206.
IRU$OODKVHFLVLRQ@WLOOIRUWKHPWKHHDUWKYDVWDVLWLVZDVVWUDLWHQHGDQGWKHLURZQVHOYHVZHUHVWUDLWHQHGWRWKHPDQGWKHSHUFHLYHGWKDWWKHUHLVQRIOHHLQJIURP$OODKDQGQRUHIXJHEXWZLWK+LP7KHQ+HIRUJDYHWKHPDFFHSWHGWKHLUUHSHQWDQFH
- 207. WKDWWKHPLJKWEHJIRU+LV3DUGRQ>UHSHQWXQWR+LP
- 208.
@9HULO$OODKLVWKH2QH:KRIRUJLYHVDQGDFFHSWVUHSHQWDQFH0RVW0HUFLIXO2RXZKREHOLHYH%HDIUDLGRI$OODKDQGEHZLWKWKRVHZKRDUHWUXHLQZRUGDQGGHHGV
- 209.
- 210.
.DCEVDLG%$OODKVLQFH$OODKJXLGHGPHWR,VODPWKHUHKDVEHHQQREOHVVLQJPRUHVLJQLILFDQWIRUPHWKDQWKLVWUXWKRIPLQHZKLFK,VSRNHWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 211.
DQGLI,ZHUHWRWHOODOLH,ZRXOGKDYHEHHQUXLQHGDVZHUHUXLQHGWKRVHZKRKDGWROGOLHVIRU$OODKGHVFULEHGWKRVHZKRWROGOLHVZLWKWKHZRUVWGHVFULSWLRQ+HHYHUDWWULEXWHGWRDQERGHOVHDV+HVHQWGRZQWKH5HYHODWLRQ7KHZLOOVZHDUE$OODKWRRX0XVOLPV
- 212.
ZKHQRXUHWXUQWRWKHPWKDWRXPDWXUQDZDIURPWKHP6RWXUQDZDIURPWKHP6XUHOWKHDUH5LMVXQ>LH1DMDVXQLPSXUH
- 213. EHFDXVHRIWKHLUHYLOGHHGV@DQG+HOOLVWKHLUGZHOOLQJSODFH
DUHFRPSHQVHIRUWKDWZKLFKWKHXVHGWRHDUQ7KHWKHKSRFULWHV
- 214. VZHDUWRRX0XVOLPV
- 215.
WKDWRXPDEHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHPEXWLIRXDUHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHPFHUWDLQO$OODKLVQRWSOHDVHGZLWKWKHSHRSOHZKRDUH$O)DVLTXQUHEHOOLRXVGLVREHGLHQWWR$OODK
- 216.
- 217.
.DCEIXUWKHUDGGHG7KHPDWWHURIWKHWKUHHRIXVUHPDLQHGSHQGLQJIRUGHFLVLRQDSDUWIURPWKHFDVHRIWKRVHZKRKDGPDGHH[FXVHVRQRDWKEHIRUH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 218.
DQGKHDFFHSWHGWKRVHWRRNIUHVKRDWKVRIDOOHJLDQFHIURPWKHPDQGVXSSOLFDWHGIRUWKHLUIRUJLYHQHVV7KH3URSKHW3%8+
- 219. NHSWRXUPDWWHUSHQGLQJWLOO$OODKGHFLGHGLW
7KHWKUHHZKRVHPDWWHUZDVGHIHUUHGKDYHEHHQVKRZQPHUF
7KHUHIHUHQFHKHUHLVQRWWRRXUVWDLQJEDFNIURPWKHH[SHGLWLRQEXWWRKLVGHODLQJRXUPDWWHUDQGNHHSLQJLWSHQGLQJEHRQGWKHPDWWHURIWKRVHZKRPDGHWKHLUH[FXVHVRQRDWKZKLFKKHDFFHSWHG>$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@
$QRWKHUYHUVLRQDGGV0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 220.
VHWRXWIRU7DEXNRQ7KXUVGD+HXVHGWRSUHIHUWRVHWRXWRQMRXUQHRQ7KXUVGD$QRWKHUYHUVLRQVDV0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 221.
XVHGWRFRPHEDFNIURPDMRXUQHLQWKHHDUOIRUHQRRQDQGZHQWVWUDLJKWWRWKHPRVTXHZKHUHKHZRXOGSHUIRUPWZR5DNCDKSUDHU$IWHUZDUGVKHZRXOGVHDWKLPVHOIWKHUH&RPPHQWDU
7KLV+DGLWKFRQWDLQVPDQDVSHFWVRIZDUQLQJVDQGDGYLFHVVRPHRIZKLFKDUHJLYHQEHORZ$0XVOLPVKRXOGDOZDVVSHDNWKHWUXWKHYHQLIKHKDVWRIDFHWURXEOHVDQGWXUPRLOIRULWEHFDXVHWKH3OHDVXUHRI$OODKOLHVLQWUXWK2QHPXVWDYRLGDWDOOFRVWVWKHDWWLWXGHRIKSRFULWHVEHFDXVHHYHQWXDOORQHLVUXLQHGELW,QVSLWHRIKDUGVKLSDQGVWULQJHQFRQHPXVWWDNHSDUWLQ-LKDG)RUWKHDGPRQLWLRQDQGH[KRUWDWLRQRIRWKHUVLWJLYHVMXVWLILFDWLRQIRUWKHHFRQRPLFERFRWWRIHYHQVLQFHUH0XVOLPVZKRDGRSWZURQJPHWKRGV
- 222.
2QHPXVWIDFHZLWKIRUEHDUDQFHWKHGLIILFXOWLHVZKLFKFRPHLQWKHZDRIHHQ,WLVQRWSUDLVHZRUWKWKDWRQHJLYHVLQFKDULWDOOWKHSURSHUWKHKDV2QHPXVWNHHSZKDWLVQHHGHGIRUWKHODZIXOQHHGV,WLVODZIXOWRJLYHVRPHWKLQJEZDRIJLIWDQGUHZDUGWRDSHUVRQZKRFRQJUDWXODWHVLQWKHHYHQWVRIKDSSLQHVV7KHDELOLWWRVHHNSDUGRQLVDJLIWIURP$OODKIRUZKLFKRQHPXVWH[SUHVVJUDWLWXGHWR+LP$QSURPLVHWKDWRQHPDNHVPXVWEHNHSWHWFHWF
,PUDQELQ$O+XVDLQ$O.KX]DCL0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 223.
UHSRUWHG$ZRPDQIURPWKHWULEH-XKDLQDKFDPHWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 224. ZKLOHVKHZDVSUHJQDQWIURP=LQD
- 225.
DGXOWHUDQGVDLGWRKLP20HVVHQJHURI$OODK,KDYHFRPPLWWHGDQRIIHQVHOLDEOHWR+DGGSUHVFULEHGSXQLVKPHQW
- 226. VRH[DFWWKHH[HFXWLRQRIWKHVHQWHQFH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 227. FDOOHGKHUJXDUGLDQDQGVDLGWRKLP
7UHDWKHUNLQGO%ULQJKHUWRPHDIWHUWKHGHOLYHURIWKHFKLOG
7KDWPDQFRPSOLHGZLWKWKHRUGHUV$WODVWWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 228.
FRPPDQGHGWRFDUURXWWKHVHQWHQFH+HUFORWKHVZHUHVHFXUHGDURXQGKHUDQGVKHZDVVWRQHGWRGHDWK7KH3URSKHW3%8+
- 229.
OHGKHUIXQHUDOSUDHUVC8PDUVXEPLWWHG20HVVHQJHURI$OODK6KHFRPPLWWHG=LQDDQGRXKDYHSHUIRUPHGIXQHUDOSUDHUIRUKHU"+HUHSOLHG
9HULOVKHPDGHUHSHQWDQFHZKLFKZRXOGVXIILFHIRUVHYHQWRIWKHSHRSOHRI$O0DGLQDKLILWLVGLYLGHGDPRQJWKHP&DQWKHUHEHDQKLJKHUGHJUHHRI
UHSHQWDQFHWKDQWKDWVKHVDFULILFHGKHUOLIHYROXQWDULOWRZLQWKH3OHDVXUHRI$OODKWKH([DOWHG">0XVOLP@&RPPHQWDU
7KLV+DGLWKKLJKOLJKWVWKHIROORZLQJILYHSRLQWV,WFRQILUPVWKHYDOLGLWRIWKHSXQLVKPHQWRI5DMPIRUWKHDGXOWHUHUWKDWLVWRVDWKDWKHVKRXOGEHVWRQHGWRGHDWK7KHPHULWRIVLQFHUHSDUGRQ7KHGHVFULSWLRQRI
IHDURI$OODKDVZHOODVRIDFFRXQWDELOLWRQWKHDRI5HVXUUHFWLRQEWKH3URSKHWV&RPSDQLRQVDQGWKHLUSUHIHUHQFHIRUSXQLVKPHQWRIVLQVLQWKLVZRUOGUDWKHUWKDQLQWKH+HUHDIWHU,WLVSHUPLVVLEOHWRSHUIRUPWKHIXQHUDOSUDHURIRQHZKRKDVEHHQJXLOWRIPDMRUVLQVSURYLGHGKHKDVQRWEHHQWDNLQJWKHPDVODZIXOEHFDXVHLQWKDWFDVHWKHUHLVGDQJHURIGLVEHOLHI$SUHJQDQWZRPDQFDQQRWEHSXQLVKHGZLWK5DMPXQWLOVKHJLYHVELUWKWRWKHFKLOGDQGWKHSHULRGVSHFLILHGIRUVXFNOLQJWKHEDE
LVFRPSOHWHG ,EQ$EEDVDQG$QDVELQ0DOLN0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHP
- 230. UHSRUWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 231. VDLG
,IDVRQRI$GDPZHUHWRRZQDYDOOHIXOORIJROGKHZRXOGGHVLUHWRKDYHWZR1RWKLQJFDQILOOKLVPRXWKH[FHSWWKHHDUWKRIWKHJUDYH
- 232.
$OODKWXUQVZLWKPHUFWRKLPZKRWXUQVWR+LPLQUHSHQWDQFH>$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@&RPPHQWDU
7KLV+DGLWKGHDOVZLWKPDQVJUHHGDQGKLVOXVWIRUPDWHULDOZHDOWK2QOWKHSHUVRQZKRKDVDSHUIHFW)DLWKFDQVDYHKLPVHOIIURPLW
$EX +XUDLUDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 233. UHSRUWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 234. VDLG
$OODKWKH([DOWHGVPLOHVDWWZRPHQRQHRIWKHPNLOOHGWKHRWKHUDQGERWKZLOOHQWHU-DQQDK7KHILUVWLVNLOOHGEWKHRWKHUZKLOHKHLVILJKWLQJLQWKH&DXVHRI$OODKDQGWKHUHDIWHU$OODKZLOOWXUQLQPHUFWRWKHVHFRQGDQGJXLGHKLPWRDFFHSW,VODPDQGWKHQKHGLHVDVD6KDKHHGPDUWU
- 235. ILJKWLQJLQWKH&DXVHRI$OODK>$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@
- 236. &RPPHQWDU
(YHQWKHJUHDWHVWVLQVLQFOXGLQJWKRVHZKLFKRQHKDVFRPPLWWHGEHIRUHHPEUDFLQJ,VODPDUHIRUJLYHQEUHSHQWDQFH6PLOLQJLVDOVRRQHRIWKH$WWULEXWHVRI$OODKDOWKRXJKZHDUHXQDZDUHRIWKHQDWXUHRILW
&+$37(5
3$7,(1&($13(56(9(5$1&($OODKWKH([DOWHGVDV2RXZKREHOLHYH(QGXUHDQGEHPRUHS
DWLHQW
- 237.
$QGFHUWDLQO:HVKDOOWHVWRXZLWKVRPHWKLQJRIIHDUKXQJHUORVVRIZHDOWKOLYHVDQGIUXLWVEXWJLYHJODGWLGLQJVWR$V6DELUXQWKHSDWLHQW
- 238.
- 239.
2QOWKRVHZKRDUHSDWLHQWVKDOOUHFHLYHWKHLUUHZDUGLQIXOOZLWKRXWUH
FNRQLQJ
- 240.
$QGYHULOZKRVRHYHUVKRZVSDWLHQFHDQGIRUJLYHVWKDWZRXOGWUXOEHIURPWKHWKLQJVUHFRPPHQGHGE$OODK
- 241. 6HHNKHOSLQSDWLHQFHDQG$V 6DODWWKHSUDHU
- 242. 7UXO$OODKLVZLWK$V 6DELUXQWKHSDWLHQW
- 243.
- 244.
$QGVXUHO:HVKDOOWURXWLOO:HWHVWWKRVHZKRVWULYHKDUGIRUWKH&DXVHRI$OODK
- 245. DQG$V 6DELUXQWKHSDWLHQW
- 246.
- 247.
7KHUHDUHQXPHURXV9HUVHVRIWKH1REOH4XUDQLQFXOFDWLQJSDWLHQFHDQGH[WROOLQJLW
$EX0DOLN$O+DULWKELQ$VLP$O$VKCDU0D $OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 248. UHSRUWHGWKDW7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 249. VDLG :XGXLVKDOIRI6DODKWKHXWWHUDQFHRI $OKDPGXOLOODK
DOOSUDLVHEHORQJVWR$OODK
- 250.
ILOOVWKH6FDOHVRIJRRGDFWLRQVWKHXWWHUDQFHRI6XEKDQ$OODKZD$OKDPGXOLOODK
- 251.
$OODKLVIDUUHPRYHGIURPHYHULPSHUIHFWLRQDQGDOOSUDLVHEHORQJVWR$OODK
- 252.
ILOOVWKHVSDFHEHWZHHQWKHKHDYHQVDQGWKHHDUWKDQG6DODWSUDHU
- 253.
LVOLJKWDQGFKDULWLVWKHSURRIRI)DLWKDQGHQGXUDQFHLVOLJKWDQGWKH4XUDQLVDSOHDLQRXUIDYRXU
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
- 254. 2QHVKRXOGQRWOHDYHRQHVHOILGOHEXWNHHSLWEXV
EXVLQVRPHQREOHZRUNRWKHUZLVHLWZRXOGWHQGWRHYLOZKLFKZLOOHYHQWXDOOUXLQKLP2QHVKRXOGVSHQGWKLVWUDQVLWRUHDUWKOOLIHLQWKHREHGLHQFHRI$OODK
$EX6DLG$O.KXGUL0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 255.
UHSRUWHGWKDW&HUWDLQSHRSOHRIWKH$QVDUDVNHGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 256.
DQGKHJDYHWKHPWKHQWKHDJDLQDVNHGKLPDQGKHJDYHWKHPXQWLODOOZKDWKHSRVVHVVHGZDVH[KDXVWHG7KHQWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 257. VDLG
:KDWHYHUZHDOWK,KDYH,ZLOOQRWZLWKKROGIURPRX:KRVRHYHUZRXOGEHFKDVWHDQGPRGHVW$OODKZLOONHHSKLPFKDVWHDQGPRGHVWDQGZKRVRHYHUZRXOGVHHNVHOIVXIILFLHQF$OODKZLOOPDNHKLPVHOIVXIILFLHQWDQGZKRVRHYHUZRXOGEHSDWLHQW$OODKZLOOJLYHKLPSDWLHQFHDQGQRRQHLVJUDQWHGDJLIWEHWWHUDQGPRUHFRPSUHKHQVLYHWKDQSDWLHQFH>$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@&RPPHQWDU
%HVLGHVGHVFULELQJJHQHURVLWNLQGQHVVPXQLILFHQFHDQGQRELOLWRIWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 258.
KHKDVEHHQRUGDLQHGE$OODKWRDGRSWSDWLHQFHFRQWHQWPHQWDQGVHOIUHVSHFWDQGWRDYRLGDQRQHVIDYRXU
$EX
- 259. UHSRUWHGWKDW7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 260. VDLG
+RZZRQGHUIXOLVWKHFDVHRIDEHOLHYHUWKHUHLVJRRGIRUKLPLQHYHUWKLQJDQGWKLVDSSOLHVRQOWRDEHOLHYHU,ISURVSHULWDWWHQGVKLPKHH[SUHVVHVJUDWLWXGHWR$OODKDQGWKDWLVJRRGIRUKLPDQGLIDGYHUVLWEHIDOOVKLPKHHQGXUHVLWSDWLHQWODQGWKDWLVEHWWHUIRUKLP>0XVOLP@&RPPHQWDU
$0XVOLPLVUHTXLUHGWREHKDYHLQSRYHUWDQGSURVSHULWDIIOXHQFHDQGKDUGVKLSLQWKHPDQQHUVWDWHGLQWKLV+DGLWK,WPHDQVWKDWWRIRUJHW$OODKLQSURVSHULW
UDWKHUWKDQEHLQJWKDQNIXOWR+LPIRU+LV)DYRXULVGHILDQFHRI+LV2UGHUV6LPLODUOLWLVXQEHFRPLQJRID0XVOLPWKDWLQWURXEOHVDQGWXUPRLOUDWKHUEHLQJSDWLHQWKHWHQGVWRZHHSLQJDQGFULQJJURXVLQJDQGJULHYLQJDJDLQVWWKH:LOORI$OODK
$QDV0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 261. UHSRUWHG:KHQWKHODVWLOOQHVVRI0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 262. PDGHKLPXQFRQVFLRXV)DWLPDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKHU
- 263. H[FODLPHG$KWKHGLVWUHVVRIPGHDUIDWKHU+H3%8+
- 264. VDLG
7KHUHZLOOEHQRGLVWUHVVIRURXUIDWKHUDIWHUWRGD:KHQKHGLHGVKHVDLG0IDWKHU$OODKKDVFDOOHGRXEDFNDQGRXKDYHUHVSRQGHGWR+LV&DOO2IDWKHU*DUGHQRI)LUGDXVLVRXUDERGH2IDWKHU:HDQQRXQFHWR-LEULORXUGHDWK:KHQKHZDVEXULHGVKHVDLG$UHRXVDWLVILHGQRZWKDWRXSXWHDUWKRYHUWKHJUDYHRI
- 265. 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 266. ">$O%XNKDUL@&RPPHQWDU
7KLV+DGLWKVKRZVWKDWLWLVSHUPLVVLEOHWRH[SUHVVWKHWURXEOHDQGUHVWOHVVQHVVZKLFKRQHIHHOVDWWKHWLPHRIGHDWK6LPLODUOH[SUHVVLRQRISDLQDQG
JULHILQDQDWXUDOZDLQWKHHYHQWRIVRPHRQHVGHDWKLVDOVRSHUPLVVLEOH7RUHPHPEHUWKHYLUWXHVRIWKHGHFHDVHGLVDOVRSHUPLWWHGEXWLWLVWREHIUHHIURPZDLOLQJDQGPRDQLQJODPHQWDWLRQDQGFULQJDQGWHDULQJRIIFORWKHVHWF7KHODVWZRUGVRI)DWLPDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKHU
- 267. DUHDOVRDZDRIH[SUHVVLQJJULHI
DQGVDGQHVVDQGQRWDFULWLFLVPRQWKHEXULDORIWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 268.
EHFDXVHVXFKFULWLFLVPLVSURKLELWHGE6KDULCDKDQGQRRQHLVH[HPSWHGIURPLW
8VDPDKELQ=DLG0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHP
- 269. QDUUDWHG7KHGDXJKWHURIWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 270. VHQWIRUKLPDVKHUFKLOGZDVGLQJEXWWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 271. UHWXUQHGWKHPHVVHQJHUDQGVHQWKHUJRRGZLVKHVVDLQJ
:KDWHYHU$OODKWDNHVDZDRUJLYHVEHORQJVWR+LPDQGHYHUWKLQJZLWK+LPKDVDOLPLWHGIL[HGWHUPLQWKLVZRUOG
- 272. DQGVRVKHVKRXOGEHSDWLHQWDQGDQWLFLSDWH$OODKVUHZDUG
6KHDJDLQVHQWIRUKLPDGMXULQJKLPIRUWKHVDNHRI$OODKWRFRPH7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKDFFRPSDQLHGZLWK6DCGELQC8EDGDK0XCDGKELQ-DEDO8ED
ELQ.DCE=DLGELQ7KDELWDQGVRPHRWKHUPHQZHQWWRVHHKHU7KHFKLOGZDVOLIWHGXSWRWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKZKLOHKLVEUHDWKZDVGLVWXUEHGLQKLVFKHVW2QVHHLQJWKDWWKHHHVRIWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 273.
VWUHDPHGZLWKWHDUV6DCGVDLG20HVVHQJHURI$OODK:KDWLVWKLV"+HUHSOLHG
,WLVFRPSDVVLRQZKLFK$OODKKDVSODFHGLQWKHKHDUWVRI+LVVODYHV$OODKLV&RPSDVVLRQDWHRQOWRWKRVHDPRQJ+LVVODYHVZKRDUHFRPSDVVLRQDWH
WRRWKHUV
- 274.
- 275. $QRWKHUYHUVLRQVDV0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 276. VDLG
$OODKVKRZVFRPSDVVLRQRQOWRWKRVHDPRQJ+LVVODYHVZKRDUHFRPSDVVLRQDWH>$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@&RPPHQWDU*DWKHULQJRIDOOWKHUHODWLYHVLVQRWQHFHVVDUDWWKHWLPHRIVRPHRQHVGHDWK+RZHYHUWKHLUSDUWLFLSDWLRQLQWKHIXQHUDOSUDHULV0XVWDKDE)DUG.LIDDKDGHVLUDEOHFROOHFWLYHGXWXSRQDOO0XVOLPVEXWZKLFKLVVXIILFLHQWRUHTXLYDOHQWWRDOOKDYLQJSHUIRUPHGLWLILWLVSHUIRUPHGERQOVRPHRIWKHP
- 277.
7KHGHVLUHRIWKHUHODWLYHVWKDWDWWKHWLPHRIVRPHRQHVGHDWKVRPHSLRXVSHRSOHVKRXOGEHSUHVHQWLVTXLWHJHQXLQHVRWKDWWKHDJRQL]LQJSURFHVVRIGHDWKLVPDGHHDVEWKHLUSUDHUV,WLVODZIXOWKDWDWUXVWZRUWKSHUVRQLVPDGHWRWDNHDQRDWKDQGLWLVHVVHQWLDOIRUWKHWUXVWHHWRIXOILOOLWDVLWLQFUHDVHVWKHPXWXDOWUXVWDQGORYH7RVKHGWHDUVRQVRPHRQHVGHDWKDQGWRDGYLFHWKHUHODWLYHVRIWKHGHFHDVHGIRUSDWLHQFHDQGDFFRXQWDELOLWDUHSHUPLVVLEOHDFWV([SUHVVLRQRINLQGQHVVDQGORYHLVDJLIWIURP$OODKDQGPHDQVWRJDLQ+LV&RPSDVVLRQZKLOHGHSULYDWLRQIURPLWLVFDOORXVQHVV
6XKDLE0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 278. UHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 279. VDLG
7KHUHOLYHGDNLQJEHIRUHRXDQGKHKDGDFRXUWPDJLFLDQ$VKHWKHPDJLFLDQ
- 280. JUHZROGKHVDLGWRWKHNLQJC,KDYHJURZQROGVRVHQGPHD
RXQJERLQRUGHUWRWHDFKKLPPDJLF7KHNLQJVHQWKLPDRXQJERWRVHUYHWKHSXUSRVH$QGRQKLVZDWRWKHPDJLFLDQ
- 281.
WKHRXQJERPHWDPRQNWRZKRPKHOLVWHQHGWRDQGOLNHGLW,WEHFDPHKLVKDELWWKDWRQKLVZDWRWKHPDJLFLDQKHZRXOGPHHWWKHPRQNDQGVLWWKHUHDQGZRXOGFRPHWRWKHPDJLFLDQODWH
- 282.
7KHPDJLFLDQXVHGWREHDWKLPEHFDXVHRIWKLVGHOD+HFRPSODLQHGDERXWWKLVWRWKHPRQNZKRVDLGWRKLP:KHQRXIHHODIUDLGRIWKHPDJLFLDQVD0HPEHUVRIPIDPLOGHWDLQHGPH$QGZKHQRXIHDURXUIDPLOVD7KHPDJLFLDQGHWDLQHGPH,WVRKDSSHQHGWKDWWKHUHFDPHDKXJHEHDVWDQGLWEORFNHGWKHZDRIWKHSHRSOHDQGWKHRXQJERVDLG,ZLOONQRZWRGDZKHWKHUWKHPDJLFLDQRUWKHPRQNLVEHWWHU+HSLFNHGXSDVWRQHDQGVDLGC2
$OODKLIWKHZDRIWKHPRQNLVGHDUHUWR
- 283.
DQGWKDWRXQJERFDPHZDONLQJWRWKHNLQJ7KHNLQJVDLGWRKLPC:KDWKDSSHQHGWRRXUFRPSDQLRQV"+HVDLGC$OODKKDVVDYHGPHIURPWKHP
- 284.
+HDJDLQKDQGHGKLPWRVRPHRIKLVFRXUWLHUVDQGVDLGC7DNHKLPDQGFDUUKLPLQDERDWDQGZKHQRXUHDFKWKHPLGGOHRIWKHVHDDVNKLPWRUHQRXQFHKLVUHOLJLRQ,IKHGRHVQRWUHQRXQFHKLVUHOLJLRQWKURZKLPLQWRWKHZDWHU
- 285.
6RWKHWRRNKLPDQGKHVDLGC2$OODKVDYHPHIURPWKHP7KHERDWWXUQHGXSVLGHGRZQDQGWKHDOOGURZQHGH[FHSWWKHRXQJERZKRFDPHZDONLQJWRWKHNLQJ7KHNLQJVDLGWRKLPC:KDWKDSSHQHGWRRXUFRPSDQLRQV"+HVDLGC$OODKKDVVDYHGPHIURPWKHPDQGKHVDLGWRWKHNLQJC
- 286. UHOLJLRQ
WKURZKLPLQWKHILUHRUCKHZRXOGEHRUGHUHGWRMXPSLQWRLW7KHGLGVRWLOODZRPDQFDPHZLWKKHUFKLOG6KHIHOWKHVLWDQWLQMXPSLQJLQWRWKHILUH7KHFKLOGVDLGWRKHUC2PRWKHU(QGXUHWKLVRUGHDO
- 287.
IRURXDUHRQWKH5LJKW3DWK>0XVOLP@&RPPHQWDU7KHPRVWLPSRUWDQWOHVVRQRIWKLV+DGLWKLVWKDWZKDWHYHUGLIILFXOWLHVRQHKDVWRIDFHRQWKHSDWKRIHHQKHVKRXOGHQGXUHLWZLWKSDWLHQFHDQGGHWHUPLQDWLRQDQGLILQWHUHVWRIWKHHHQUHTXLUHVRQHVKRXOGVDFULILFHKLVOLIHIRULW7KHZRQGHUVGLVSODHGEULJKWHRXVSHRSOHDUHWUXH:KHQ$OODKV:LOODQG:LVGRPUHTXLUHV+HPDQLIHVWVWKHVHZRQGHUVWKURXJK+LVVODYHV,WLVDSURRIRIWKHWUXWKRIWKH4XUDQWKDWLWKDVUHWROGWKHJUHDWKLVWRULFDOHYHQWOLNH$VKDEXO8NKGXGZKLFKEXULHGLQWKHGXVWRIDJHVKDGORQJEHHQIRUJRWWHQ,WLVQRWSRVVLEOHWRH[SODLQDQGLQWHUSUHWWKH4XUDQZLWKRXWWKHKHOSRI$KDGLWK7KHHYHQWRI$VKVEXO8NKGXGPHQWLRQHGLQWKH4XUDQLVDQLQVWDQFHLQSRLQW,WLVWKH+DGLWKWKDWKDVEURXJKWLQWROLJKWWKHGHWDLOVRIWKHHYHQWDQGFODULILHGLWVDPELJXLW6XFKLQFLGHQWVDUHDVRXUFHRIVWUHQJWKIRU
WKHIDLWKRIWUXHEHOLHYHUV $QDV0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 288. UHSRUWHG7KH3URSKHW3%8+
- 289. SDVVHGEDZRPDQZKRZDVFULQJRYHUDJUDYHDQGVDLG
)HDU$OODKDQGEHSDWLHQW
6KHVDLG$ZDIURPPH0FDODPLWKDVQRWEHIDOOHQRXDQGRXDUH
QRWDZDUHRILW7KHZRPDQZDVODWHUWROGWKDWLWZDVWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 290. ZKRKDGDGYLVHGKHU
- 291.
6KHFDPHWRKLVGRRUZKHUHVKHIRXQGQRGRRUNHHSHU6KHVDLG,DPVRUU
- 292. ,GLGQRWNQRZRX0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 293. VDLG 3DWLHQFHLVEHFRPLQJ
- 294. RQODWWKHILUVWVWURNH
- 295.
RIJULHI>$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@$QRWKHUQDUUDWLRQLQ0XVOLPVDV7KHZRPDQZDVFULQJRYHUKHUVRQ&RPPHQWDU
7KLV+DGLWKLQGLFDWHVWKHH[FHOOHQFHRIWKH3URSKHWVFKDUDFWHU7KHZRPDQZKRPKHDGYLVHGWRKDYHSDWLHQFHGLGQRWEHKDYHSURSHUOEXWWKH3URSKHW3%8+
- 296.
ZDVQHLWKHUDQQRHGQRUGLGKHUHSURDFKKHU:KHQVKHDSSHDUHGEHIRUHKLPIRUWKHVHFRQGWLPHKHDJDLQUHSHDWHGKLVDGYLFHIRUSDWLHQFH7KLV+DGLWKKDVDJUHDWOHVVRQIRUWKRVHZKRFDOOSHRSOHWRWKH5LJKW3DWK2XUVFKRODUVDQGSUHDFKHUVVKRXOGIROORZWKLVH[FHOOHQWH[DPSOH
$EX+XUDLUDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
- 297. UHSRUWHG7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
- 298.
VDLG$OODKWKH([DOWHGVDV,KDYHQRUHZDUGRWKHUWKDQ-DQQDKIRUDEHOLHYLQJVODYHRI0LQHZKRUHPDLQVSDWLHQWIRU0VDNHZKHQ,WDNHDZDKLVEHORYHGRQHIURPDPRQJWKHLQKDELWDQWVRIWKHZRUOG>$O%XNKDUL@
- 299.