The association between burning mouth syndrome and sleep ... final version.pdf · portunity for...

Oral Diseases. 2018;1–12.  | 1wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/odi

Received:7August2017  |  Revised:7November2017  |  Accepted:8November2017DOI: 10.1111/odi.12807

O R I G I N A L A R T I C L E

The association between burning mouth syndrome and sleep disturbance: A case–control multicentre study

D Adamo1  | A Sardella2 | E Varoni2 | C Lajolo3 | M Biasotto4 | G Ottaviani4 |  P Vescovi5 | T Simonazzi5 | M Pentenero6  | M Ardore6 | F Spadari7 |  G Bombeccari7 | L Montebugnoli8 | DB Gissi8 | G Campisi9 | V Panzarella9 |  M Carbone10 | L Valpreda10 | M Giuliani11 | M Aria12 | L Lo Muzio11† | MD Mignogna1†

1OralMedicineComplexUnit,Head&NeckClinicalSection,DepartmentofNeurosciences,ReproductiveandOdontostomatologicalSciences,“FedericoII”UniversityofNaples,Naples,Italy2UnitofOralPathology,OralMedicineandGerodontology,DepartmentofBiomedical,SurgicalandDentalSciences,AOSanPaoloHospitalofMilan,UniversityofMilan,Milan,Italy3OralPathologyandMedicine,SchoolofDentistry,CatholicUniversityofRome,Rome,Italy4OralMedicineandPathologyUnit,DepartmentofMedical,SurgicalandHealthSciences,UniversityofTrieste,Trieste,Italy5UnitofOralPathology,MedicineandLaserSurgery,DepartmentofBiomedical,BiotechnologicalandTranslationalSciences,UniversityofParma,Parma,Italy6OralMedicineandOralOncologyUnit,DepartmentofOncology,UniversityofTurin,Turin,Italy7UnitofOralPathologyandMedicine,DepartmentofBiomedical,SurgicalandDentalSciences,UniversityofMilan,OspedaleMaggiorePoliclinicoIRCCSCa’GrandaFoundation,Milan,Italy8UnitofOralPathologyandMedicine,DepartmentofBiomedicalandNeuromotorSciences,UniversityofBologna,Bologna,Italy9DepartmentofSurgical,Oncological,andOralSciences,SectorofOralMedicine“ValerioMargiotta”,UniversityofPalermo,Palermo,Italy10OralMedicineSection,DepartmentofSurgicalSciences,CIRDentalSchool,UniversityofTurin,Turin,Italy11DepartmentofClinicalandExperimentalMedicine,UniversityofFoggia,Foggia,Italy12LaboratoryandResearchGroupSTADStatistics,Technology,DataAnalysisDepartmentofEconomicsandStatistics,“FedericoIIUniversityofNaples”,Naples,Italy

©2017JohnWiley&SonsA/S.PublishedbyJohnWiley&SonsLtd.Allrightsreserved

CorrespondenceDanielaAdamo,OralMedicineComplexUnit,Head&NeckClinicalSection,DepartmentofNeurosciences,ReproductiveandOdontostomatologicalSciences,“FedericoII”UniversityofNaples,Naples,Italy.Email:danielaadamo.it@gmail.com

Funding informationTheworkwassupportedbytheDepartmentofNeurosciences,ReproductiveandOdontostomatologicalSciences,OralMedicineUnit,ofthe“FedericoIIUniversityofNaples,”Italy.

Objectives:ToinvestigatethequalityofsleepandthepsychologicalprofilesofalargecohortofItalianpatientswithburningmouthsyndrome(BMS)andtoclarifytherela-tionshipsbetweenthesevariablesandpain.Methods: Inthiscase–controlstudy,200patientswithBMSvsanequalnumberofage-andsex-matchedhealthycontrols,recruitedin10universities,wereenrolled.ThePittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI), Epworth Sleepiness Scale (ESS), HamiltonRatingScale forDepression (HAM-D),HamiltonRatingScale forAnxiety (HAM-A),NumericPainIntensityScale(NRS)andTotalPainRatingIndex(T-PRI)wereadminis-tered. Descriptive statistics, including the Mann–Whitney U test and hierarchicalmultiplelinearregressionanalysis,wereused.Results:Poorsleepquality(PSQI≥5)waspresentin78.8%(160)patientswithBMS.BMSpatientshadstatisticallyhigherscoresinallitemsofthePSQIandESSthanthehealthycontrols(p<.001).Adepressedmoodandanxietycorrelatedpositivelywithsleep disturbance. The Pearson correlations were 0.570 for the PSQI vs HAM-D(p<.001)and0.549for thePSQIvsHAM-A (p<.001).Pain intensity (NRS)poorly

†Thelasttwoauthorscontributedequallytothepaper.

2  |     ADAMO et Al.

1  | INTRODUCTION

Burningmouthsyndrome(BMS)isanidiopathic,chronicorofacialpaindisorderinwhichthepatientpresentswiththesensationofburningandpain in theoralmucosa (Grushka,Epstein,&Gorsky,2002), al-thoughthisisnotassociatedwithclinicalmucosalalterationsandlab-oratorytests(Scala,Checchi,Montevecchi,Marini,&Giamberardino,2003;Sunetal.,2013).

Theprevalenceis0.7%–4.6%,withmiddle-agedwomenafterthemenopausemorecommonlyafflicted(Charleston,2013;Spanemberg,RodríguezdeRiveraCampillo,Salas,&LópezLópez,2014).

Theoraldiscomfortsmaybevariableinintensityandcausewith,in severecases, a serious impairment in thepatient’squalityof life.ThesymptomsofBMSusuallycontinueforaminimumof4–6months,remainingconsistentandbilateral,onlyalleviatedatmealtimes;paintendstoincreaseinthelateafternoonorintheevening(Scalaetal.,2003).

Anoral andperi-oralburning sensation is themost frequentlyreportedsymptom,withpatientsoftendescribingthepainasscald-ing,tingling,ornumbing(Grushka,Epstein,&Gorsky,2003).Othersubjective oral symptoms, such as dysgeusia, xerostomia, sialor-rhea,and intra-oral roughnessorgranularitysensation,havebeenreported (Adamo etal., 2015). Commonly, there are no obviousprovoking factors, although in some casesBMSpatients have re-portedantecedentdentalprocedures,theinitiationofnewmedicaltreatment,orstressfullifeevents(Frutos,Rodríguez,Miralles-Jorda,&Machuca,2002).

There is no consensus concerning the etiopathogenesis ofBMSwith conflicting opinions reported in the literature. Some researchstudiesfocusingontheperipheralalterationsindicatethatBMScouldresultfromaneuropathictrigeminalcondition(Jääskeläinen&Woda,2017). In other studies, a central brain dysfunction, such as an im-pairedendogenousdopaminesystem,hasbeenidentified(Hagelbergetal.,2004).Inaddition,severalstudieshaveshownahighprevalenceofpsychiatricdisordersorofpsychologicalproblems(Abetz&Savage,2009;Maina,Albert,Gandolfo,Vitalucci,&Bogetto,2005;Schiavoneetal.,2012)andsleepdisturbance(SD)inBMSpatients(Adamoetal.,2013;Lopez-Jornetetal.,2015).

Sleep is increasingly being recognized as essential to maintainmentalandphysicalhealthwithpoorsleepacknowledgedtocontrib-utetoareducedqualityoflife.

Sleep disturbance includes those disease conditions in whichsleepingpatternsaredisturbedwithasignificantandnegativeimpactonpatienthealth.SDisfrequentlyreportedinthegeneralpopulation,withagreater incidenceamongwomenandpeoplewithpsychiatricdiseases(Morinetal.,2011;Roy&Smith,2010).InsomniaisthemostcommonSD.According toDSM-5,adiagnosisof insomnia isdeter-minedaccordingtothefollowingcriteria:(i)dissatisfactionwithsleepquantityorquality,includingdifficultyinitiatingandmaintainingsleepandwakingup intheearlymorning; (ii)anSDthatcausesaseriousreductioninnormaldaytimeactivity(e.g.,cognitiveimpairment,mooddisturbance, impairedwork function); (iii) an SD that arises at leastthreenightsperweekandhasbeenoccurringforatleast3months;and(iv)asleep impairmentthatariseseven ifthere issufficientop-portunity for sleep [American Psychiatric Association (APA), 2013].Estimatesoftheprevalenceofinsomniadifferaccordingtothecrite-rionunderconsideration.Ingeneral,35%–50%ofthegeneralpopula-tionreportthattheyareaffectedbyoneormoreofthesymptomsofinsomnia(Walsh,Salkeld,Knowles,Tasker,&Hunneyball,2010).

Sleepdisturbance is a complexphenomenonand the subjectofmuchdebate.SomeresearchersconsiderSDtobeaclinicalconditioninitselfbutforothersitisonlyasymptomofanothermentaldisorder(Billiard&Bentley,2004;Leeetal.,2013;Ohayon,2007).Indeed,pa-tientswithSD, frequently,presentwithotherchronic illnessessuchashypertension,diabetes,obesity,depression,andanxiety.Moreover,SDhasafrequentassociationwithsomaticandpainsymptoms(Chung&Tso,2010).

Sleepdisturbance,somaticchronicpain,andmooddisordersareclosely connected (Finan&Smith, 2013;Ohayon, 2009). Sleep andpainhaveareciprocalrelationshipandlongitudinalpopulationstudieshavehighlightedthatSDcanprovokeanincreasedsensitivitytopainleadingtoanexacerbationofothersymptoms.Furthermore,patientsaffectedby chronic pain suffer froman inadequate quality of sleepincluding sleep latency, sleep inefficiency, andawakeningsafter theonsetofsleep(deTommasoetal.,2014).

Various researchstudieshavesuggested thatbetween67%and88% of patients suffering from chronic pain disorders report sleepcomplaints (Morin etal., 2011; Smith & Haythornthwaite, 2004)andthatapproximately50%ofpeopleaffectedbyinsomniapresentchronicpain(Tayloretal.,2007).

The association of SD with a negative mood, particularly withanxiety and depression, has, frequently, been described in relation

correlated tosleepquality; thePearsoncorrelationwas0.162for thePSQIvsNRS(p =.021).Conclusions:TheBMSpatientsshowedapoorsleepquality,anxietyanddepression,as comparedwith the controls, highlighting the relationshipsbetweenoralburning,sleepandmood.

K E Y W O R D S

anxiety,burning,insomniasymptoms,mooddisorders,pain,sleep

     |  3ADAMO et Al.

to common underlying pathophysiological mechanisms (Benca &Peterson, 2008; Cox & Olatunji, 2016; Rumble, White, & Benca,2015).Indeed,depressionandanxietyareregardedbymanycliniciansas risk factors forSD (Smagula,Stone,Fabio,&Cauley,2016)whilepoorsleep,inturn,maybeaprecursorofmooddisordersthatsubse-quentlyarise(Leeetal.,2013;Neckelmann,Mykletun,&Dahl,2007).Moreover, persistent insomnia is frequently reported by depressedpatients,contributingtonon-remission(Ohayon,2007).

Sleep disturbance in BMS is poorly documented, but recentlytherehasbeenincreasingattentiondevotedtothetopic;afewsin-glecenterstudieshaveevaluatedthecomorbiditybetweenmoodandsleepimpairmentsinBMS(Adamoetal.,2013;Chainani-Wu,Madden,&Silverman,2011;Lopez-Jornetetal.,2015).

The aims of the presentmulticenter study have been to ana-lyze the prevalence of insomnia, daytime sleepiness, anxiety, anddepressioninanextensivecohortofItalianpatientswithBMS,com-pared toacontrolgroupofhealthy individuals, and to investigatetherelationshipsbetweenthesevariablesandpaintohaveagreaterawarenessoftheimportanceofSDinthemanagementandtherapyofBMSpatients.

2  | MATERIALS AND METHODS

2.1 | Study design

This observational and descriptive case–control study was carriedoutbetweenMarch2014and January2015.Ten ItalianUniversityOralMedicineUnitsacrossthecountryparticipatedinthestudy.ItiscompliantwiththeethicalprinciplesoftheWorldMedicalAssociationDeclarationofHelsinki.All patients andcontrols gave theirwritteninformedconsent.TheEthicsCommitteeoftheFedericoIIUniversityofNaplesapprovedthestudy(No.222/14).

The reporting of data followed the guidelines of the STROBEstatement.

2.2 | Participants

TwentyBMSpatientsand20healthycontrolsubjectswererecruitedand randomly selected with IBM SPSS software (version 19; IBMcorporationArmonkNY,USA)in10OralMedicineUnitsofdifferentItalianUniversities(sevennorthern,onecentralandtwosouthernuni-versities)makingatotalof200BMSpatientsand200healthycontrolsubjects.

Theidentificationofthesetwogroupswascarriedouttakingintoaccounttheinclusion/exclusioncriteriareportedbelow(Figure1).

The BMS group inclusion criteria were, in accordance withthe International Classification of Headaches (the InternationalClassificationofHeadacheDisorders:3rdedition,2013):

1. Male or female, aged at least 18.2. Continuoussymptomsoforalburningorpainpersistingforatleast2hr/day,lastingforlongerthan3months,withnoparoxysmandnotfollowinganyunilateralnervetrajectory.

3. Noclinicalmucosalalterations.4. Normalbloodtestfindings (includingbloodcount,bloodglucose,serumiron,ferritinandtransferrin,folicacid,andvitB-12levels).

5. Abodymassindex(BMI)lessthan30.

TheBMSgroupexclusioncriteriawereasfollows:

1. Patients with diseases that could be recognized as a causativefactor of BMS.

2. Patientsintreatmentwithanxiolytics,antidepressants,anticonvul-santsand/orpsychotropicdrugs.

F IGURE  1 Flowchartofthestudy

Subjects assessed for eligibility (n = 406)

Patients with BMS(n = 204)

BMS patients included(n = 200)

BMS patients excluded (n = 4):• 2 patients treated with

psychotropic drug• 2 patients with oral symptoms

lasting for less than 3 months

Healthy patients(n = 202)

Healthy patients included(n = 200)

Healhty patients excluded (n = 2):• 1 patient treated with psychotropic

drug• 1 patient with metastatic breast

cancer

4  |     ADAMO et Al.

3. ABMIgreaterthan30.4. Historyordiagnosisofobstructivesleepapnea(OSA).5. Heavysmokers(≥20cigarettes/day)andheavydrinkers(14units/week).

Thecontrolgroupincludedarandomizedclusterofpatientspresent-ingattheUniversityexclusivelyfordentalcare,duringthestudyperiod.

Thehealthysubjectgroupinclusioncriteriawereasfollows:

1. Male or female, aged at least 18.2. Nooralmucosallesions.3. Norecordofpsychiatricillness.4. ABMIlessthan30.

Theexclusioncriteriaencompassed:

1. Patients with debilitating medical conditions.2. Patientsintreatmentwithanxiolytics,antidepressants,anticonvul-sants,and/orpsychotropicdrugs.

3. ABMIgreaterthan30.4. Historyordiagnosisofobstructivesleepapnea(OSA).5. Heavysmokers(≥20cigarettes/day)andheavydrinkers(14units/week).

Body mass index in kg/m2 was calculated from self-reportedweight andheight. Short sleepduration and impaired sleepqual-ityarepositivelyassociatedwithaBMIgreaterthan30.Therefore,wedecidedtoexcludethesesubjectsfromthestudy(Patel&Hu,2008).

Datarelatingtosociodemographicfactorswereanalyzedforeachgroup.

Duringhospitalization,eachsubjectunderwentacarefulmedicalanamnesis,ageneralmedicalexamination,anintra-oralandextra-oralexamination,laboratorytests,andENT(ear,noseandthroat)andpsy-chiatricevaluation.

Thedatacollectionwasperformedbystandardizedclinicalinter-view,conductedbyanindividualinterviewerateachUniversity.

The patients responded to the following evaluation battery scale:

1. The Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI) and the EpworthSleepiness Scale (ESS) for the evaluation of quality of sleep anddaytime sleepiness.

2. The Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression (HAM-D) and theHamiltonRatingScaleforAnxiety (HAM-A)fortheevaluationofdepressionandanxiety.

3. TheNumericPainIntensityScale(NRS)andtheTotalPainRatingIndex(T-PRI)theNRSandT-PRIfromtheshortformoftheMcGillPainQuestionnaire (SF-MPQ) for the assessment of discomfort,painintensity,andquality.

Allthesescaleswereexaminedforcompletenessandwereadminis-teredintheirItalianversion.

2.3 | Assessment of sleep

ThePSQIisastandardizedself-reportquestionnaireevaluatingsleepqualityanddisturbance.Itconsistsof19items,relatingtosevendo-mains:subjectivesleepquality,sleeplatency,sleepduration,habitualsleepefficiency,sleepdisturbance,theuseofsleepmedication,anddaytime dysfunction. For each domain, a direct score is assigned,ranging from0 to3according to thedegreeofseverity (ascoreofzero indicatesnoproblemwhile three indicates a seriousproblem).Thescoresareaddedtogethertoproduceaglobalscorerangingfrom0to21.Globalscoresabovefiveindicatepoorsleepers,suchafindingbeingreportedtohaveahighsensitivity (90%–99%)andspecificity(84%–87%)(Carpenter&Andrykowski,1998).

TheESSisasimple,self-administeredquestionnaireusedtoeval-uatedaytimesleepinessbymeansofeightitems.Thesubjectisaskedtoassesstheprobabilityoffallingasleepineightcommonsituationsthatmostpeopleexperienceindailylife.TheESSscoresforeachitemrangefrom1to3,3indicatingthegreatestprobability.ThetotalESSscoreisthesumoftheseitems,themaximumscorethereforebeing24withacutoffvalueof10.Scoresintherangeof0–9areconsiderednormal,andthose intherangeof10–24indicatea levelofdaytimesleepinessthatwarrantsmedicaladvice(Johns,1991,1992).

2.4 | Assessment of the level of depression and anxiety

TheHAM-Disaratingscaleusedtoevaluatetheseverityofdepres-sivesymptoms.Itincludesaconsiderationof21itemswiththescorerangingfrom0to54.Ascoregreaterthan10indicatesimpairment.Scoresbetween10and17indicatemilddepression,scoresbetween18and24indicatemoderatedepression,andscoresover24indicateseveredepression(Hamilton,1960).

TheHAM-Aisaratingscaledevelopedtomeasuretheseverityofanxietysymptoms.Itevaluates14items,eachdefinedbyaseriesofsymptoms.Scorescanrangefrom0to56.Ascorebelow17indicatesmildanxiety,scoresinthe18-24rangeindicatemildtomoderateanxi-ety,andscoresfrom25to30indicatemoderatetosevereanxiety.Thetestprovidesanassessmentofthedegreeofoverallanxiety,psychicanxiety,andsomaticanxiety.It isalsousedtoassesstheefficacyofanxiolyticandotherpsychotropicdrugsinimprovinglevelsofanxiety(Hamilton,1958).

2.5 | Assessment of pain

Thenumericalratingscale(NRS-11)isusedforanassessmentoftheintensityofpain(painandburning).Thetestisadministeredbymeansofaninterviewperformedbyaclinicianwhoasksthepatienttogivearatingtoreflectthedegreeofpain.Thescalerangesfrom0to10,with0indicatingtheabsenceofanyoralsymptomsand10indicatingtheworstimaginablesymptomintensity.TheNRSisawell-validatedinstrument,whichiseasytoadminister.Itisthereforefrequentlyrec-ommendedforpainassessment,particularlyforanevaluationofthedegreeofanalgesiainresponsetotreatment.

     |  5ADAMO et Al.

TheT-PRIoftheShortformoftheMcGillPainQuestionnaire(SF-MPQ) ofMelzack is a validatedmultidimensional test of perceivedpain.Itgivesusefulinformationonthesensoryandaffectivedimen-sionsoftheexperienceofpain.Itisaself-reportquestionnaireconsist-ingof15descriptors[11sensory(descriptors1–11)andfouraffective(descriptors12–15)].Eachdescriptor is rankedonan intensityscalerangingfrom0to3,0 indicatingtheabsenceofanydiscomfortand3indicatingseverepain.ThetotalT-PRIscoreiscalculatedbyaddingtogethertheitemscores(thetotalscorethereforerangingfrom0to45).Thereisnoestablishedcriticalcutpointforscoreinterpretationbutobviously,asfortheMPQ,thehigheristhescoretheworseisthepain(Hawker,Mian,Kendzerska,&French,2011).

2.6 | Statistical analysis

Demographicandclinicalparametersandscaleshavebeensummarizedusingclassicdescriptivestatistics.DifferencesbetweenBMSpatientsandcontrolshavebeentestedbythetwo-samplesttest,fornormaldis-tributions,andbytheMann–Whitneyprocedurefornon-normaldata.

Thesignificanceoftherelationshipbetweenanyqualitativevari-ableshasbeenmeasuredbythePearsonchi-squaretest.Differencesassociatedwithpvalues less than .05or .01havebeen consideredmoderatelyorstronglysignificant,respectively.

Theoddsofsleepdisturbance,sociodemographiccharacteristics,andconfoundingfactorsamongBMSpatientsandcontrolshavebeencalculatedusingunconditionallogisticregression.Theinternalconsis-tencyofthePSQIhasbeenmeasuredbytheCronbach’salphatesttoestimatethereliabilityofthescores.

The importance of disease-related and psychological factors asdeterminantsofsleepqualityhasbeenmeasuredwithmultipleregres-sionanalysesconsidering,atthesametime,theeffectofdemographiccharacteristics.

3  | RESULTS

Thedemographicandclinicalfindingsrelatingtothepatientsandcon-trolsaresummarizedinTable1.

TABLE  1 SociodemographicandclinicalcharacteristicsofBMSpatientsandcontrolsubjects

Demographic variablesBMS patients, n = 200 Control patients, n = 200

p- ValueMean ± SD Mean ± SD

Age 61.92 ± 12.16 53.91 ± 9.81 <.001**

Yearsofeducation 9.23 ± 4.00 10.20 ± 4.24 .019*

Gender

Male 37(18.5%) 64(32.0%) .002**

Female 163(81.5%) 136(68.0%)

Familystatus

Married 153(76.5%) 147(73.5%) .565

Single 17(8.5%) 21(10.5%)

Divorced 11(5.5%) 23(11.5%)

Widowed 19(9.5%) 9(4.5%)

Employmentstatus

Employed 57(28.5%) 123(61.5%) <.001**

Retired 89(44.5%) 28(14.0%)

Unemployed 54(27.0%) 49(24.5%)

Clinical parameters Median—IQR Median—IQR p- Value

PSQI 9[6–12] 4[2–5] <.001**

HAM-D 13[8–20] 4[2–6] <.001**

HAM-A 16[9–22] 5[2–6] <.001**

ESS 5[2–9] 3[2–4] <.001**

NRS 7[4–8] 0[0–0] <.001**

T-PRI 9[5–14] 0[0–0] <.001**

IQR,interquartilerange;BMS,burningmouthsyndrome;PSQI,PittsburghSleepQualityIndex;HAM-D,HamiltonRatingScaleforDepression;HAM-A,HamiltonRatingScaleforAnxiety;ESS,EpworthSleepinessScale;NRS,NumericPainIntensityScale;T-PRI,TotalPainRatingIndex.ThesignificanceoftherelationshipbetweenthequalitativevariableswasmeasuredbythePearsonchi-squaretest.Thesignificanceofthedifferencebetweenthemeanswasmeasuredbythetwo-samplesttest.ThesignificanceofthedifferencebetweenthemedianswasmeasuredbytheMann–WhitneyU test.*Moderatelysignificant.01<p≤.05.**Stronglysignificantp≤.01.

6  |     ADAMO et Al.

TheBMSpatientsandcontrolsshowedsignificantdifferencesinage,education,gender,andemploymentstatus.ThemeanageoftheBMSpatientsandcontrolswas61.92±12.16and53.91±9.81years,respectively.Themeanofyearsofeducationwas9.23±4.00forthepatientsand10.20±4.24forthecontrols.Thecontrolsarecharacter-izedbyasignificantlyhigherpercentageofemploymentandahigherproportionofmalesthantheBMSpatients.

Inourstudy,thepatientsandcontrolsarenotmatchedduetothelarge sample size. Case–controlmatching isvery difficult to obtain,especiallywhen the matching is related to several factors (Song &Chung,2010).

Therefore,weevaluatedtheeffectofconfoundingfactorsthroughanunconditionallogisticregression.TheresultsareshowninTable2.

Table2showsthattheoddsratiosofthesociodemographicfac-torsbetweentheBMSpatientsandcontrols,exceptforage,donothavesignificantvalues.

TheratiooftheoddsofthePSQIamongthecasesandcontrols,adjustedforconfoundinganddemographicfactors,wassignificantlyhigherthan1(OR1.196).

3.1 | PSQI reliability

InTable3,wereportthereliabilityanalysisofthePSQIcomponentsintheBMSpatients.ACronbach’sαgreaterthan.7andanitem-scalecorrelationgreater than0.3 indicate a satisfactoryoverall reliabilityandagooditemcontributiontothescale,respectively.

3.2 | Sleep quality

TheglobalandcomponentscoresforthePSQIweresignificantlydif-ferentbetweenthepatientsandcontrols(Tables1and4).

Patientswith BMS had highermean PSQI scores, indicating apoorer sleep quality for these patients compared to the healthy

controls; 158 patients (79%) were poor sleepers with a PSQIglobal scoregreater than5.Among theBMSpatients, the clinicalparameters of good (PSQI<5) and poor (PSQI>5) sleeperswerecompared. Depression (HAM-D), anxiety (HAM-A) and daytimesleepiness (ESS)were found to be significantly different betweenthetwogroups(p<.001),while intensityandqualityofpainwerenot (p=.069) (Table5).However, thevalue of theESSwas lowerthan the cutoff of 10 in the poor (median 3) and good sleepers (median6).

3.3 | Dependence of sleep quality

Table6showsthepositivecorrelationbetweendepression(HAM-D)anxiety(HAM-A)andqualityofpain(T-PRI)withsleepquality,andthepoorcorrelationbetweenpainintensity(NRS)anddaytimesleepiness(ESS)withsleepquality.

In addition, in the analysis of the demographic characteristics,yearsofeducationcorrelatednegativelywithsleepqualityandmaritalstatusandjobstatuswerepoorlycorrelatedwithsleepquality.

3.4 | Association with sleep quality

The results of the simultaneousmultiple linear regression analysespredictingsleepqualityareshowninTable7.

Themodeltestingthecontributionofthedemographicvariablesandconfoundingfactorstosleepqualitywasfoundtobestatisticallysignificant(R2=44.5%p≤.001).

Considering demographic variables, only age and marital statusweresignificant.Inaddition,anxietyanddepressionwereconfirmedtohaveastrongeffectonsleepquality.

4  | DISCUSSION

Burningmouthsyndromeisacomplexdisorder,frequentlyassociatedwith extra-oral somatic comorbidity and psychiatric illnesses such

TABLE  2 OddsofPSQIandconfoundingfactorsamongBMSpatientsandcontrols

Variables OR p Value 95% CI for OR

PSQI 1.196 .002** 1.069–1.338

Age 1.042 .017** 1.007–1.077

Education 1.044 .323 0.958–1.137

Female 1.401 .358 0.683–2.872

Married 0.939 .858 0.474–1.861

Employed 0.549 .110 0.263–1.145

HAM-D 1.194 <.001** 1.086–1.313

HAM-A 1.116 .006** 1.032–1.207

ESS 0.982 .721 0.888–1.085

BMS, burning mouth syndrome; PSQI, Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index;HAM-D,HamiltonRatingScaleforDepression;HAM-A,HamiltonRatingScaleforAnxiety;ESS,EpworthSleepinessScale;OR,oddsratio.ORshavebeencalculatedusingunconditionallogisticregression.*Moderatelysignificant.01<p≤.05.**Stronglysignificantp≤.01.

TABLE  3 ReliabilityanalysisofthePittsburghSleepQualityIndex(PSQI)scaleinburningmouthsyndrome(BMS)patientsandcontrolsubjects

PSQI components

BMS cases Control cases

Item- scale correlation ρ

Subjectivesleepquality 0.55 0.41

Sleeplatency 0.56 0.37

Sleepduration 0.66 0.48

Habitualsleepefficiency 0.65 0.33

Sleepdisturbances 0.36 0.24*

Useofsleepmedications 0.22* 0.47

Daytimedysfunction 0.34 0.13*

Cronbach’salpha 0.76 0.65

*Poorcorrelationbetweenasingleitemandtheglobalscale(ρ<0.3).

     |  7ADAMO et Al.

asdepression, anxiety, andSD (Galli, Lodi, Sardella,&Vegni,2016;Mainaetal.,2005;Mignognaetal.,2011).

Previousresearcharticleshaveanalyzedtheroleofsleepdysfunc-tioninBMS;inourpreviousstudy,wefoundaprevalenceofSD,in-cludinginsomniaanddaytimesleepiness,in80%ofpatientswithBMS(Schiavone etal., 2012). In accordancewith our data, Lopez-Jornetetal.(2015)foundSDin67.1%ofpatientswithBMScomparedwith

acontrolgroupofhealthysubjects.Adamoetal. (2013)andArbabi-Kalati,Bakhshani,Tahmtan, andMovahedinejad (2015) foundSD in78%ofpatientswithBMSvs38.7%ofhealthysubjects.

Inaddition,arecentretrospectiveworkon47,941Taiwanesepa-tientswithSDhasdemonstratedthatpoorsleepincreasestheriskofBMS,highlightingtheimportanceofsleepimpairmentinthisdisease(Leeetal.,2014).

PSQI components

BMS cases Control cases

p- ValueMedian IQR Range Median IQR Range

Subjectivesleepquality

1 1–2 0–3 1 0–1 0–2 <.001**

Sleeplatency 1 0–2 0–3 0 0–1 0–3 <.001**

Sleepduration 1 0–2 0–3 1 0–1 0–3 <.001**

Habitualsleepefficiency

1 0–2 0–5 0 0–1 0–3 <.001**

Sleepdisturbances

1 1–2 0–3 1 1–1 0–3 <.001**

Useofsleepmedications

1 0–3 0–3 0 0–0 0–3 <.001**

Daytime dysfunction

1 0–3 0–3 0 0–0 0–2 <.001**

IQR,interquartilerange.BMS,burningmouthsyndrome;PSQI,PittsburghSleepQualityIndex.ThesignificanceofthedifferencebetweenthemedianswasmeasuredbytheMann–WhitneyU test.*Moderatelysignificant.01<p≤.05.**Stronglysignificantp≤.01.

TABLE  4 ComparisonofcomponentsofthePSQIinBMSpatientsandcontrolsubjects

TABLE  5 ComparisonbetweenBMSpatientgoodandpoorsleepers

PSQI components

PSQI ≤ 5 (n = 42, 21.0%) PSQI > 5 (n = 158, 79.0%)

p-ValueMedian IQR Range Median IQR Range

Depression(HAM-D) 6 2–11 0–22 16 10–21 6–36 <.001**

Anxiety(HAM-A) 8 3–16 0–25 18 13–22 12–56 <.001**

Daytimesleepiness(ESS) 3 0–6 0–12 6 3–9 0–17 <.001**

NRS 5 4–8 0–10 7 4–8 0–10 .069

T-PRI 7 4–11 0–36 9 6–15 0–40 .069

Frequencies (%) Frequencies (%) p-Value

Depression(HAM-D)

0–9 29(69.0%) 39(24.7%) <0.001**

10–17 11(26.2%) 53(33.5%)

18–24 2(4.8%) 45(28.5%)

>24 0(0%) 21(13.3%)

Anxiety(HAM-A)

0–17 34(81.0%) 76(48.1%) <0.001**

18–24 7(16.7%) 47(29.7%)

>24 1(2.4%) 35(21.5%)

IQR,interquartilerange;BMS,burningmouthsyndrome;PSQI,PittsburghSleepQualityIndex;HAM-D,HamiltonRatingScaleforDepression;HAM-A,HamiltonRatingScaleforAnxiety;ESS,EpworthSleepinessScale;NRS,NumericPainIntensityScale;T-PRI,TotalPainRatingIndex.ThesignificancedifferencebetweenthemedianswasmeasuredbytheMann–WhitneyU test.*Moderatelysignificant.01<p-value≤.05.**Stronglysignificantp-value≤.01.

8  |     ADAMO et Al.

In this present Italian multicenter study, in agreementwith thefindingsofotherstudiesreportedinliterature,wehavefoundaprev-alenceofSDin79%(158)ofBMSpatients.

Incontrastwithourpreviousstudy,wedidnotfindanydaytimesleepiness in the poor sleeper patientswith BMS. However, in theliterature,patientswith insomniareported,overtime,daytimefunc-tional impairment, with sleepiness, and concentration and memoryloss (Ancoli-Israel&Roth,1999).Therefore, thesedataarepossiblyrelatedtoamorerecentonsetofSDinoursampleofpatients.

RegardingtheassociationofmooddisorderswithchronicpainandwithBMS,itiswellknown,asseveralstudieshavedemonstrated,thatanxietyanddepressionmaybe importantcausativeandaggravatingfactors inBMS (Buljan, Savić,&Karlović, 2008). In a recent reviewarticle,Gallietal.(2016)confirmedthatpsychiatricfactorsplayaroleinBMSandthatanxietyanddepressionseemtobethemostcommoncomorbiddiseasesamongpatientswithBMS.

Inoursample,wefoundmilddepressionandmildanxietyinthepatientswithBMScomparedwiththehealthysubjects.InthepoorsleeperBMSpatients,we found a higher prevalence ofmoderateandseveredepression(41.8%),andahigherprevalenceofmoder-ate and severe anxiety (51.2%) suggesting also an important rela-tionshipbetweensleepandmood.ThesedataareconfirmedinthedependenceanalysisinTable7(pvalue<.001**)andremainsignif-icant in themultiple simultaneous regression analyses confirming

thatdepressionandanxietymaybeimportantriskfactorsofSDinBMSpatients.However,while in our previous study the standardmultipleregressionanalysisof thefinal fullmodel inwhichall thevariables were entered simultaneously could explain 62% of thevariance insleepquality, inthecurrentstudythemodelcouldex-plainonly44.5%ofthevariance.Thesedatahighlightthatanxietyand depression have an important role in sleep quality, but that,sometimes,poorsleepinBMSpatientsmaybeanindependentfac-torthatshouldbeanalyzedandtreatedseparately.Furthermore,asitisanindependentfactor,itcouldhaveanonsetbeforethatoftheBMSsymptoms.

Although it iswidely assumed that SD is a common comorbid-itywithpsychiatricdisorders,mostnotably inmajordepression,andshouldbeconsideredasanassociatesymptom(secondaryinsomnia),morerecentlyaccumulativeevidencehassuggestedthatinsomniaisnot necessarily an epiphenomenon, and should be considered as aseparatedisease/disorder(primaryinsomnia).

Theauthorsofsuchstudieshavehypothesizedthatinsomniahasbeenconsideredasaprimarydisorderonlyintheabsenceofanyclin-icallyrelevantpsychiatricdisease(Baglionietal.,2011;Harvey,2001).

Primary insomnia is also a predictor of depression; individ-ualswith SD, especiallywomen, have a higher risk of developingdepression (Baglioni etal., 2011; Riemann & Voderholzer, 2003).Timesequenceanalysisfromseveralstudiesshowsthattheonset

TABLE  6 DependenceofsleepqualitywithclinicalparametersanddemographiccharacteristicsforBMSpatients

Clinical parameters Pearson ρ coefficient p-Value

Depression(HAM-D) 0.570 <.001**

Anxiety(HAM-A) 0.549 <.001**

Daytimesleepiness(ESS) 0.159 .024*

NRS 0.162 .021*

T-PRI 0.191 .006**

Demographic characteristics Pearson ρ coefficient p-Value

Age 0.197 .005**

Yearsofeducation −0.099 .159

Median—IQR Median—IQR p-Value

Gender Male 9.0;[5.5–12.3]

Female 9.0;[6.0–12.0]

.613

Marital status Yes9.0;[6.0–13.0]

No 8.0;[4.3–9.8]

.030*

Employment Yes 8.0;[4.0–11.0]

No 9.0;[7.0–13.0]

.015*

IQR, interquartile range; BMS, burning mouth syndrome; HAM-D,HamiltonRatingScaleforDepression;HAM-A,HamiltonRatingScaleforAnxiety; ESS, Epworth Sleepiness Scale; NRS, Numeric Pain IntensityScale;T-PRI,TotalPainRatingIndex.For thenumerical variables, thep-valueswereobtainedby thePearsoncorrelationtest.Forthequalitativecharacteristics,thep- values were ob-tainedbytheMann–Whitneytest.*Moderatelysignificant.01 < p-value ≤.05.**Stronglysignificantp- value ≤.01.

TABLE  7 MultiplelinearregressionmodelpredictingsleepqualityinBMSpatients

Predictors Beta SE T statistics p- Value

Intercept −2.091 2.223 −0.941 .348

Age 0.080 0.025 3.223 .001**

Yearsofeducation

0.029 0.074 0.399 .691

Gender:female 0.268 0.630 0.426 .671

Marital status: married

1.495 0.566 2.643 .009**

Occupation:yes −0.004 0.679 −0.006 .995

Depression(HAM-D)

0.207 0.045 4.587 <.001**

Anxiety(HAM-A) 0.131 0.039 3.391 .001**

Daytime sleepiness(ESS)

0.082 0.067 1.234 .219

NRS −0.115 0.115 −1.002 .318

T-PRI −0.022 0.041 −0.552 .582

Modelgoodnessoffitstatistics

R2=41.4%;F statistics = 14.76; p-value < .001**

BMS, burning mouth syndrome; HAM-D, Hamilton Rating Scale forDepression; HAM-A, Hamilton Rating Scale for Anxiety; ESS, EpworthSleepiness Scale; NRS, Numeric Pain Intensity Scale; T-PRI, Total PainRatingIndex.SEarethestandarderrorsofthebetaestimates.Thep-values were ob-tainedbythehypothesistestonregressioncoefficients.*Moderatelysignificant.01 < p-value≤ .05.**Stronglysignificantp- value ≤ .01.

     |  9ADAMO et Al.

of insomnia canprecede, evenby severalyears, the firstonsetofdepressioninmanycases(Johnson,Roth,&Breslau,2006;Ohayon& Roth, 2003). Riemann and Voderholzer (2003) reported thatsymptomsof insomnia for aperiodof at least2weekspredict anincreasedriskofdevelopingdepressionwithinthefollowing3years.Itwould seem that insomnia has a higher predictivevalue for fu-turedepressionthananxiety(Jansson-Fröjmark&Lindblom,2008;Morphy,Dunn,Lewis,Boardman,&Croft,2007).

Inaddition,SDalsoplaysanimportantroleindepressionrelapseandthetransitioningofdepressionintoachronicstatebecauseitcanrepresentaresidualphaseofamajormooddisorder(Falussy,Balla,&Frecska,2014;Perlisetal.,2006).

In thiscontext, theearlydetectionandtreatmentofSD inBMSpatientswithoutanyhistoryofdepressionandanyevidenceofanxietyanddepression(HAM-DandHAM-A<7)canresultinbothasignifi-cantimprovementinthepatient’squalityoflifeandalsointhepreven-tionofsecondarymooddisorders.Inaddition,inpatientswithBMS,withanxietyanddepressionwithanSDcomorbidity,thetreatmentofresidualinsomniaisnecessarynotonlytoaidtheremissionofdepres-sionbutalsotopreventanyrelapse.

Moreover,changesinsleeppatternsareapartofthenormalagingprocessandincreasingageisassociatedwithinsomnia(Schubertetal.,2002);thesedatawereconfirmedinourstudybythemultiplesimul-taneousregressionanalyses inwhichage isan importantriskfactorofSD.

Inaddition,wefoundacorrelationbetweenmaritalstatusandSDinwhichmarriedpatientsarepronetodevelopinsomnia;thisispossi-bleconsideringthatanegativemaritalrelationshipincreasedtheriskofinsomniasymptomsthroughanincreaseinmooddisorders;thesedatawereconfirmedbyapreviousstudy(Chen,Waite,&Lauderdale,2015).

Regarding the relationshipsbetweenpainandSD inour samplepatientswithBMS,nostatisticallysignificantdifferencesinthequalityandintensityofpainbetweenthepoorandgoodsleeperswithBMSwerefound,becausetheNRSandT-PRIvalueswerehigher inbothgroups(themedianvaluesoftheNRSandT-PRIinthegoodsleeperswere5and7andinthebadsleepers7and9,respectively).Thisresultwasinaccordancewithourpreviousstudy(Schiavoneetal.,2012)butin contrastwith the studyof Lopez-Jornet etal. (2015)wherepoorsleeperBMSpatientswerepronetoincreasedpain.

The relationshipbetweenSDandpain iscomplexandnotcom-pletely understood; significant research studies report that thisrelationship is bidirectional (Fishbain, Hall, Meyers, Gonzales, &Mallinckrodt,2008).

Sleepdisturbance is frequently reportedbypatientsafflictedbychronicpain,butitisoftenseenasasecondarysymptomratherthananindependentsymptom.Becausepainmediatessleepproblems,ad-equatepainmanagementisthoughttoleadtoimprovedsleepinpa-tientswithchronicpain(Park,Yoon,Yoon,Moon,&Kim,2016;Power,Perruccio,&Badley,2005).

However,thispointofviewhasshiftedovertimewithnewev-idence suggesting insomnia as the primary disorder from whichchronicpainoftendevelops(Asih,Neblett,Mayer,Brede,&Gatchel,

2014); recently, Finan, Goodin, and Smith (2013) have found thatsleep impairments are a reliable predictor of the recurrence andworsening of chronic pain, to a greater extent than pain predictssleepimpairments.Inagreement,Walsh,Muehlbach,Lauter,Hilliker,and Schweitzer (1996) showed that benzodiazepine, by enhancingsleepquality, relievedthesubjectivesymptomsof jointpain inpa-tientswith rheumatoidarthritisevenwhen therewasnoobjectiveimprovement.

Thesedatahavebeenconfirmedbyresearchsuggestingthatmanypatients with chronic pain continue to experience sleep problemsevenwhen good pain control is achievedwhile an improvement ofinsomniaresultsinbetterpaintreatmentoutcomesinthesepatients(Gustavsson&vonKoch,2006;Tang,2008).

Fromabiophysiologicalperspective,insomniaislinkedtoahigherproduction of inflammatorymediators,which can potentially aggra-vatepain,causingahyperalgesicstatewithalowpainthreshold,andleadingtoaninabilitytosufficientlyactivatethepaininhibitorypath-ways(Haacketal.,2012).Thiseffectremainsevenaftertheotherpsy-chologicalsymptomsarecontrolled(Quartana,Finan,Page,&Smith,2015;Spiegel,Leproult,&VanCauter,1999).

Moreover,inpatientssufferingfromamajordepressivedisorder,insomniaisasignificantpredictorofpain,evenaftercheckingfortheseverityofanxietyanddepression(Ohayon,2007).

Inourstudy,aclearrelationshipbetweeninsomniaandpaincouldnotbeestablishedbecause the intensityofpainwashigher inbothgoodandpoorsleepers.Apossiblebiasofourstudycouldbethelackofanyanalysisofthedurationeitheroftheillnessortheinsomnia;itmaynotbeunlikelythatprolongedpain,overtime,maycauseSDaswellasthatpersistentinsomniamayworsentheperceptionofsymp-toms in patients with BMS, contributing to an exacerbation of thedisease.

This studyhashighlighted the complexityofBMS inwhich it isnecessarytoconsiderthepsychologicalprofileofBMSpatients,andthepresenceofpainandinsomnia,tohaveamorecompleteassess-ment. Anxiety, depression, and sleep are, in some cases, intercon-nected,eachaffectingeachother.SDandmooddisorders leadtoacontinuouslyperpetuatingcycleandcanaggravateBMSandpreventhealing.However,manypatientsmayhave a primary insomnia thatrequiresaspecificassessmentandtreatment.

Finally, the findings from this study lead to the conclusion thatsleep quality should also be considered in the treatment approachforBMSbecausethemanagementofSDmaynotonlyamelioratethesymptomsofBMSbutalsoaiddepressionremissionand/orpreventlate-lifedepression.

4.1 | Study limitations

Our study has several limitations that suggest directions for futureresearch.

First,ourfindingsarecross-sectionalinnature,limitingourabilityto identifyacausalrelationshipbetweenpsychologicalfactors,pain,and sleep disturbance. Prospective and longitudinal studies with acleartemporalprecedenceandcausalityareneededtoevaluatethe

10  |     ADAMO et Al.

influenceofpsychologicalsymptomsand insomniaonpain intensityinBMS.

Secondly, the sleep assessmentwas based on self-report ques-tionnaireswithout any confirmation by full-night polysomnographicstudies of poor sleeper patients. However, questionnaires could beconsideredasaninitialevaluationofSDandsubsequentlyintegratedwithotherdiagnosticinvestigationsinpatientswithimpairedsleep.

5  | CONCLUSIONS

Thisisthelargestmulticentrestudythathasconfirmedthecomorbid-ity of sleepdisturbances andmooddisorders in patientswithBMSsuggestingthatSDandmooddisordersareacommonproblemandanaggravatingfactorinBMS.Incontrast,painintensityandqualitydidnotcorrelatewithsleepquality.

Thesefindingsconfirmthenecessityofamultidisciplinaryteamap-proach inwhicha close collaborationbetweendentists, psychiatrists,psychologists,andneurologistsisrequiredfortheevaluationofcomor-biditiesandforasuitablyindividualizedsequentialtreatmentofpatients.

Clinicianscouldevaluatetherapiesnotonlytoreducepainbuttoimprovesleepandtoreducelevelsofanxietyanddepression,consid-eringantidepressant andanticonvulsants in themanagementofpa-tientswithBMS.Treatmentshouldbeindividualizedforeachpatientinrelationtothepatient’sage,gender,comorbidity,systemicdiseases,anddrugintake.

Future studies should try tobetterunderstand the relationshipsbetweenpain,SD,andmooddisorderstodeterminewhichoftheseconditionsoccursfirstand,accordingly,whichstrategyisthemostef-fectiveintermsofimprovingthetreatmentofBMS.

CONFLICT OF INTEREST

Alloftheauthorsdeclarethattheydonothaveanyconflictofinterest.

AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS

Allauthorshavecontributedintheresearchdesign,acquisition,analy-sisandinterpretationofdata.Allauthorshaveapprovedthefinalver-sionofthepaper.

ETHICAL APPROVAL

Thisstudyhasbeencarriedoutinaccordancewiththeethicalstand-ardsoftheinstitutionaland/ornationalresearchcommitteeandwiththe1964Helsinkideclarationanditslateramendmentsorcomparableethical standards. Informedconsentwasobtained fromall the indi-vidualparticipantsincludedinthestudy.

ORCID

D Adamo http://orcid.org/0000-0002-3784-4229

M Pentenero http://orcid.org/0000-0003-3972-1203

REFERENCES

Abetz,L.M.,&Savage,N.W.(2009).Burningmouthsyndromeandpsy-chological disorders.Australian Dental Journal, 54(2), 84–93. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1834-7819.2009.01099.x

Adamo,D.,Celentano,A., Ruoppo, E.,Cucciniello,C., Pecoraro,G.,Aria,M., & Mignogna, M. D. (2015). The relationship between sociode-mographiccharacteristicsandclinicalfeaturesinburningmouthsyn-drome. Pain Medicine (Malden, Mass.),16(11),2171–2179.https://doi.org/10.1111/pme.12808

Adamo,D.,Schiavone,V.,Aria,M.,Leuci,S.,Ruoppo,E.,Dell’Aversana,G.,&Mignogna,M.D.(2013).Sleepdisturbanceinpatientswithburningmouthsyndrome:Acase–controlstudy.Journal of Orofacial Pain,27(4),304–313.https://doi.org/10.11607/jop.1109

AmericanPsychiatricAssociation(2013).Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders,5thed.Washington,DC:APA.

Ancoli-Israel,S.,&Roth,T.(1999).CharacteristicsofinsomniaintheUnitedStates:Resultsofthe1991NationalSleepFoundationSurvey.I.Sleep,1(22Suppl2),S347–S353.

Arbabi-Kalati, F., Bakhshani,N.M.,Tahmtan, B., &Movahedinejad, F.(2015).Associationofimpairedsleepqualityinpatientswithburn-ing mouth syndrome: A case–control study. Health Scope, 4(2),e23795.

Asih,S.,Neblett,R.,Mayer,T.G.,Brede,E.,&Gatchel,R.J.(2014).Insomniainachronicmusculoskeletalpainwithdisability;populationisindepen-dentofpainanddepression.Spine Journal,14,2000–2007.

Baglioni, C., Battagliese, G., Feige, B., Spiegelhalder, K., Nissen, C.,Voderholzer,U.,…Riemann,D.(2011).Insomniaasapredictorofde-pression: A meta-analytic evaluation of longitudinal epidemiologicalstudies. Journal of Affective Disorders, 135(1–3), 10–19. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2011.01.011

Benca, R.M., & Peterson,M. J. (2008). Insomnia and depression. Sleep Medicine,9(Suppl1),S3–S9.https://doi.org/10.1016/S1389-9457(08) 70010-8

Billiard,M.,&Bentley,A.(2004).Isinsomniabestcategorizedasasymp-tom or a disease? Sleep Medicine, 5(Suppl 1), S35–S40. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1389-9457(04)90006-8

Buljan, D., Savić, I., & Karlović, D. (2008). Correlation between anxiety,depressionandburningmouthsyndrome.Acta Clinica Croatica,47(4),211–216.

Carpenter,J.S.,&Andrykowski,M.A.(1998).PsychometricevaluationofthePittsburghSleepQualityIndex.Journal of Psychosomatic Research,45,5–13.https://doi.org/10.1016/S0022-3999(97)00298-5

Chainani-Wu,N.,Madden, E., & Silverman, Jr, S. (2011).A case–controlstudyofburningmouthsyndromeandsleepdysfunction.Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, Oral Radiology and Endodontics,112(2),203–208.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tripleo.2011.03.014

Charleston, L. (2013). Burningmouth syndrome:A review of recent lit-erature. Current Pain and Headache Reports, 17(6), 336. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11916-013-0336-9

Chen, J. H.,Waite, L. J., & Lauderdale, D. S. (2015). Marriage, relation-shipquality, and sleepamongU.S.older adults. Journal of Health and Social Behavior,56(3),356–377.https://doi.org/10.1177/0022146515 594631

Chung, K. F., & Tso, K. C. (2010). Relationship between insomnia andpain in major depressive disorder: A sleep diary and actigraphystudy. Sleep Medicine, 11(8), 752–758. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sleep.2009.09.005

Cox,R.C.,&Olatunji,B.O. (2016).Asystematic reviewof sleepdistur-banceinanxietyandrelateddisorders.Journal of Anxiety Disorders,37,104–129.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.janxdis.2015.12.001

de Tommaso, M., Delussi, M., Vecchio, E., Sciruicchio, V., Invitto, S., &Livrea,P.(2014).Sleepfeaturesandcentralsensitizationsymptomsinprimaryheadachepatients.The Journal of Headache and Pain,15,64.https://doi.org/10.1186/1129-2377-15-64

     |  11ADAMO et Al.

Falussy, L., Balla, P., & Frecska, E. (2014). Relapse and insomnia in uni-polar major depression. Neuropsychopharmacologia Hungarica, 16(3),141–147.

Finan,P.H.,Goodin,B.R.,&Smith,M.T.(2013).Theassociationofsleepandpain:Anupdateandapath forward.The Journal of Pain,14(12),1539–1552.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpain.2013.08.007

Finan,P.H.,&Smith,M.T. (2013).Thecomorbidityof insomnia,chronicpain,anddepression:Dopamineasputativemechanism.Sleep Medicine Reviews,17,173–183.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.smrv.2012.03.003

Fishbain, D.A., Hall, J.,Meyers,A. L., Gonzales, J., &Mallinckrodt, C.(2008). Does painmediate the pain interferencewith sleep prob-lem in chronic pain? Findings from studies formanagement of di-abetic peripheral neuropathic painwith duloxetine. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management,36,639–647.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2007.12.012

Frutos, R., Rodríguez, S., Miralles-Jorda, L., &Machuca, G. (2002). Oralmanifestationsanddentaltreatmentinmenopause.Medicina Oral,7(1),26–30,31–5.

Galli, F., Lodi, G., Sardella, A., &Vegni, E. (2016). Role of psychologicalfactors in burningmouth syndrome:A systematic review andmeta-analysis. Cephalalgia,37(3),265–277.

Grushka,M.,Epstein,J.B.,&Gorsky,M.(2002).Burningmouthsyndrome.American Family Physician,65(4),615–620.

Grushka,M.,Epstein,J.B.,&Gorsky,M.(2003).Burningmouthsyndromeand other oral sensory disorders:A unifying hypothesis.Pain Resea-rch & Management,8(3), 133–135. https://doi.org/10.1155/2003/65 4735

Gustavsson, C., & von Koch, L. (2006). Applied relaxation in the treat-ment of long-lasting neck pain: A randomized controlled pilotstudy. Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine, 38, 100–107. https://doi.org/10.1080/16501970510044025

Haack, M., Scott-Sutherland, J., Santangelo, G., Simpson, N. S., Sethna,N.,&Mullington,J.M.(2012).Painsensitivityandmodulationinpri-mary insomnia. European Journal of Pain, 16, 522–533. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejpain.2011.07.007

Hagelberg, N., Jääskeläinen, S. K., Martikainen, I. K., Mansikka, H.,Forssell,H., Scheinin,H.,… Pertovaara,A. (2004). Striatal dopamineD2 receptors in modulation of pain in humans: A review. European Journal of Pharmacology, 500, 187–192. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejphar.2004.07.024

Hamilton,M. (1958).The assessment of anxiety states by rating.British Journal of Medical Psychology,32,50–55.

Hamilton,M. (1960).A rating scale for depression. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry, 23, 56–62. https://doi.org/10.1136/jnnp.23.1.56

Harvey, A. G. (2001). Insomnia: Symptom or diagnosis? Clinical Psychology Review, 221(7), 1037–1059. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0272-7358(00)00083-0

Hawker,G.A.,Mian,S.,Kendzerska,T.,&French,M.(2011).Measuresofadult pain:VisualAnalog Scale for Pain (VAS Pain), Numeric RatingScale for Pain (NRS Pain), McGill Pain Questionnaire (MPQ), Short-FormMcGillPainQuestionnaire(SF-MPQ),ChronicPainGradeScale(CPGS), Short Form-36 Bodily Pain Scale (SF-36 BPS), andMeasureof Intermittent and Constant Osteoarthritis Pain (ICOAP). Arthritis Care & Research, 63(Suppl 11), S240–S252. https://doi.org/10.1002/acr.20543

HeadacheClassificationCommitteeoftheInternationalHeadacheSociety(2013).TheInternationalclassificationofheadachedisorders,3rdedi-tion(betaversion).Cephalalgia,33,629–808.

Jääskeläinen,S.K.,&Woda,A.(2017).Burningmouthsyndrome.Cephalalgia,37(7),627–647.https://doi.org/10.1177/0333102417694883

Jansson-Fröjmark,M.,&Lindblom,K. (2008).Abidirectional relationshipbetweenanxietyanddepression,andinsomnia?Aprospectivestudyinthegeneralpopulation.Journal of Psychosomatic Research,64(4),443–449.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpsychores.2007.10.016

Johns,M.W.(1991).Anewmethodformeasuringdaytimesleepiness:TheEpworthsleepinessscale.Sleep,14,540–545.https://doi.org/10.1093/sleep/14.6.540

Johns,M.W.(1992).ReliabilityandfactoranalysisoftheEpworthSleepinessScale.Sleep,154,376–381.https://doi.org/10.1093/sleep/15.4.376

Johnson,E.O.,Roth,T.,&Breslau,N. (2006).Theassociationof insom-niawithanxietydisordersanddepression:Explorationofthedirectionof risk. Journal of Psychiatric Research, 40(8), 700–708. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpsychires.2006.07.008

Lee, E., Cho, H. J., Olmstead, R., Levin, M. J., Oxman,M. N., & Irwin,M. R. (2013). Persistent sleep disturbance: A risk factor for recur-rent depression in community-dwelling older adults. Sleep, 36(11),1685–1691.

Lee,C.F.,Lin,K.Y.,Lin,M.C.,Lin,C.L.,Chang,S.N.,&Kao,C.H.(2014).Sleepdisordersincreasetheriskofburningmouthsyndrome:Aretro-spectivepopulation-basedcohortstudy.Sleep Medicine,15(11),1405–1410.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sleep.2014.06.009

Lopez-Jornet, P., Lucero-Berdugo,M.,Castillo-Felipe,C., Zamora Lavella,C., Ferrandez-Pujante, A., & Pons-Fuster, A. (2015). Assessment ofself-reported sleep disturbance and psychological status in patientswith burning mouth syndrome. Journal of the European Academy of Dermatology and Venereology, 29(7), 1285–1290. https://doi.org/10.1111/jdv.12795

Maina, G., Albert, U., Gandolfo, S., Vitalucci, A., & Bogetto, F. (2005).Personality disorders in patients with burning mouth syndrome.Journal of Personality Disorders,19(1),84–93.https://doi.org/10.1521/pedi.19.1.84.62182

Mignogna,M.D.,Pollio,A.,Fortuna,G.,Leuci,S.,Ruoppo,E.,Adamo,D.,& Zarrelli, C. (2011). Unexplained somatic comorbidities in patientswithburningmouth syndrome:A controlled clinical study. Journal of Orofacial Pain,25(2),131–140.

Morin, C.M., LeBlanc,M., Bélanger, L., Ivers,H.,Mérette, C., & Savard,J. (2011). Prevalence of insomnia and its treatment in Canada.Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 56(9), 540–548. https://doi.org/10.1177/070674371105600905

Morphy,H.,Dunn,K.M.,Lewis,M.,Boardman,H.F.,&Croft,P.R.(2007).Epidemiology of insomnia: A longitudinal study in a UK population.Sleep,30(3),274–280.

Neckelmann,D.,Mykletun,A.,&Dahl,A.A. (2007).Chronic insomniaasariskfactorfordevelopinganxietyanddepression.Sleep,30(7),873–880.https://doi.org/10.1093/sleep/30.7.873

Ohayon,M.M. (2007). Insomnia:A ticking clock fordepression? Journal of Psychiatric Research, 41(11), 893–894. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpsychires.2007.07.008

Ohayon,M.M. (2009). Pain sensitivity, depression, and sleep depriva-tion: Links with serotoninergic dysfunction. Journal of Psychiatric Research, 43(16), 1243–1245. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpsychires. 2009.10.007

Ohayon,M.M.,&Roth,T.(2003).Placeofchronicinsomniainthecourseofdepressiveandanxietydisorders.Journal of Psychiatric Research,37(1),9–15.https://doi.org/10.1016/S0022-3956(02)00052-3

Park, S. J., Yoon, D.M., Yoon, K. B., Moon, J. A., & Kim, S. H. (2016).Factors associatedwithhigher reportedpain levels in patientswithchronic musculoskeletal pain: A cross-sectional. Correlational anal-ysis. PLoS ONE, 11(9), e0163132. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0163132

Patel, S. R.,&Hu, F. B. (2008). Short sleep duration andweight gain:Asystematic review. Obesity,16(3),643–653.https://doi.org/10.1038/oby.2007.118

Perlis, M. L., Smith, L. J., Lyness, J. M., Matteson, S. R., Pigeon,W. R.,Jungquist,C.R.,&Tu,X. (2006). Insomnia as a risk factor for onsetofdepressionintheelderly.Behavioral Sleep Medicine,4(2),104–113.https://doi.org/10.1207/s15402010bsm0402_3

Power, J. D., Perruccio,A.V., & Badley, E.M. (2005). Pain as amedi-ator of sleep problems in arthritis and other chronic conditions.

12  |     ADAMO et Al.

Arthritis and Rheumatism, 53, 911–919. https://doi.org/10.1002/(ISSN)1529-0131

Quartana,P.J.,Finan,P.H.,Page,G.G.,&Smith,M.T.(2015).Effectsofinsomniadisorderandkneeosteoarthritisonrestingandpain-evokedinflammatory markers. Brain, Behavior, and Immunity, 47, 228–237.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bbi.2014.12.010

Riemann,D.,&Voderholzer,U.(2003).Primaryinsomnia:Ariskfactortodevelopdepression?Journal of Affective Disorders,76(1–3),255–259.https://doi.org/10.1016/S0165-0327(02)00072-1

Roy,A.N.,&Smith,M.(2010).PrevalenceandcostofinsomniainastateMedicaid fee-for-service population based on diagnostic codes andprescription utilization. Sleep Medicine, 11(5), 462–469. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sleep.2009.09.012

Rumble,M.E.,White,K.H.,&Benca,R.M.(2015).Sleepdisturbancesinmood disorders. Psychiatric Clinics of North America,38(4), 743–759.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psc.2015.07.006

Scala,A.,Checchi,L.,Montevecchi,M.,Marini,I.,&Giamberardino,M.A.(2003). Update on burning mouth syndrome: Overview and patientmanagement. Critical Reviews in Oral Biology and Medicine,14(4),275–291.https://doi.org/10.1177/154411130301400405

Schiavone, V., Adamo, D., Ventrella, G., Morlino, M., De Notaris, E. B.,Ravel,M.G.,…Mignogna,M.D.(2012).Anxiety,depression,andpainin burning mouth syndrome: First chicken or egg?Headache, 52(6),1019–1025.https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1526-4610.2012.02171.x

Schubert,C.R.,Cruickshanks,K.J.,Dalton,D.S.,Klein,B.E.,Klein,R.,&Nondahl,D.M.(2002).Prevalenceofsleepproblemsandqualityoflifeinanolderpopulation.Sleep,25,889–893.

Smagula,S.F.,Stone,K.L.,Fabio,A.,&Cauley,J.A. (2016).Risk factorsfor sleep disturbances in older adults: Evidence from prospectivestudies. Sleep Medicine Reviews,25,21–30.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.smrv.2015.01.003

Smith,M.T.,&Haythornthwaite,J.A. (2004).Howdosleepdisturbanceand chronic pain inter-relate? Insights from the longitudinal andcognitive-behavioral clinical trials literature. Sleep Medicine Reviews,8(2),119–132.https://doi.org/10.1016/S1087-0792(03)00044-3

Song,J.W.,&Chung,K.C.(2010).Observationalstudies:Cohortandcase–control studies. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery,126(6),2234–2235.https://doi.org/10.1097/PRS.0b013e3181f44abc

Spanemberg,J.C.,RodríguezdeRiveraCampillo,C.,Salas,E.J.,&LópezLópez, J. (2014). Burningmouth syndrome:Update.Oral Health and Dental Management,13(2),418–424.

Spiegel,K.,Leproult,R.,&VanCauter,E.(1999).Impactofsleepdepriva-tion onmetabolic and endocrine function. Lancet,354, 1435–1439.https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(99)01376-8

Sun,A.,Wu,K.M.,Wang,Y.P.,Lin,H.P.,Chen,H.M.,&Chiang,C.P.(2013).Burningmouthsyndrome:Areviewandupdate.Journal of Oral Pathol-ogy and Medicine,42(9),649–655.https://doi.org/10.1111/jop.12101

Tang,N.K. (2008). Insomniaco-occurringwithchronicpain:Clinicalfea-tures, interaction,assessmentsandpossible interventions.Reviews in Pain,2,2–7.

Taylor,D.J.,Mallory,L.J.,Lichstein,K.L.,Durrence,H.H.,Riedel,B.W.,&Bush,A.J.(2007).Comorbidityofchronicinsomniawithmedicalprob-lems. Sleep,30(7),213–218.https://doi.org/10.1093/sleep/30.2.213

Walsh,J.K.,Muehlbach,M.J.,Lauter,S.A.,Hilliker,N.A.,&Schweitzer,P.K.(1996).Effectsoftriazolamonsleep,daytimesleepiness,andmorningstiffnessinpatientswithrheumatoidarthritis.Journal of Rheumatology,23(2),245–252.

Walsh,J.K.,Salkeld,L.,Knowles,L.J.,Tasker,T.,&Hunneyball,I.M.(2010).TreatmentofelderlyprimaryinsomniapatientswithEVT201improvessleep initiation, sleep maintenance, and daytime sleepiness. Sleep Medicine,11,23–30.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sleep.2009.07.012

How to cite this article:AdamoD,SardellaA,VaroniE,etal.Theassociationbetweenburningmouthsyndromeandsleepdisturbance: A case–control multicentre study. Oral Dis. 2018;00:1–12. https://doi.org/10.1111/odi.12807