TENTATIVE State of New York Supreme Court, Appellate...

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(1) 111255 PEOPLE v ASHA BURWELLAppellant - Frederick K. Brewington, Esq.(Asha Burwell)Respondent - Vincent Stark, Esq.P. David Soares, Albany County District Attorney

10

10

(2) 527424 BINGHAMTON PRECAST & SUPPLY CORP. v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INS.CO.Appellant - Christopher S. Finazzo, Esq.Finazzo Cossolini et al.(Liberty Mututal Fire Ins. Co.)Respondent - Albert J. Millus, Jr., Esq.Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP(Binghamton Precast & Supply Corp.)

10

10

(3) 527843/528359

MATTER OF VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT and VILLAGE OF ENDICOTT PBAAppellant - Paul J. Sweeney, Esq.Coughlin & Gerhart LLP(Village of Endicott)Respondent - James B. Tuttle, Esq.The Tuttle Law Firm(Village of Endicott PBA)

10

10

(4) 527053 LAI v MONTESAppellant - Stephen Montes [Pro se]Appellant - Pamela Montes [Pro se]Respondent - Terry D. Horner, Esq.Law Office of Terry D. Horner(George Lai et al.)

050510

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(5) 529330 MATTER OF SANTANDER CONSUMER USA v KOBI AUTO COLLISIONAND PAINT CTR.Appellant - Susan Civic, Esq.(Kobi Auto Collision and Paint Ctr.)Respondent - Rudolph J. Meola, Esq.Law Office of Rudolph J. Meola(Santander Consumer USA)

10

05

(6) 108511 PEOPLE v GEORGE S. CRANDALLAppellant - Kathy Manley, Esq. [Assigned](George S. Crandall, III.)Respondent - Lauren D. Konsul, Esq.New York State Prosecutors Training Institute

10

10

(7) 109014 PEOPLE v D'ANDRE JONESAppellant - Linda B. Johnson, Esq.Special Appellate Counsel(D'Andre Jones)Respondent - Spencer E. Lane, Esq.Mary Pat Donnelly, Rensselaer County District Attorney

10

10

(8) 108529/110947

PEOPLE v JARQUELL WILLIAMS SUB

(9) 527620 HOLDERMAN v HOLDERMAN SUB

(10) 526177 MATTER OF JEMAR H. v NEVADA I. SUB

(11) 528658 MATTER OF HIRSCHBECK v OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF MAJORLEAGUE BASEBALL

SUB

(12) 527366 MATTER OF WOOD v COUNTY OF CORTLAND SUB

(13) 529624 MATTER OF GREEN v DUTCHESS COUNTY BOCES SUB

TENTATIVE State of New YorkSupreme Court, Appellate Division

Third Judicial Department518-471-4777

SESSION CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2020

1:00 P.M. SESSION

GA CL D PR CO

BENCH POSITION: PRITZKER, J., CLARK, J., GARRY, P.J., DEVINE, J., COLANGELO, J.

Please notify the Clerk's Office at least 24 Hours PRIOR to argument of anychanges to this calendar, including submissions and attorney changes.

When a cause is argued or submitted to the court with four justices present,it shall, whenever necessary, be deemed submitted also to any other duly qualified

justice of the court, unless objection is noted at the time of argument or submission(Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, Rule 1250.1 [b]).

CalendarNo.

CaseNo.

TitleTime

Allocated

(14) 529057 MATTER OF GIMBER v EASTMAN KODAK CO. SUB

(15) 528379 MATTER OF NARINE v MONTEFIORE MED. CTR. SUB