SYNTHETIC DIAMOND AND ITS IDENTIFICATION - De · PDF fileSYNTHETIC DIAMOND AND ITS...

Confidential

GemFest Basel

22nd March 2015

SYNTHETIC DIAMOND AND ITS IDENTIFICATION

Dr Simon Lawson, De Beers Technologies UK

Confidential

1

The De Beers Group of Companies

RESEARCH RESOURCES

• De Beers Group

– Over 65 years of fundamental research on diamond

• De Beers Technologies UK

– 30 years of Consumer Confidence Technical

Research (CCTR)

– Contract synthesis and treatment research at

specialist laboratories

• De Beers Technologies supports

– Diamond research at UK universities

– Centre for Doctoral Training in Diamond Science &

Technology

– Annual Diamond Conference

• 65th De Beers Diamond Conference was held at Warwick

University 7-10 July 2014

Confidential

2

The De Beers Group of Companies

DE BEERS CONSUMER CONFIDENCE PROGRAMME

maintaining & enhancing consumer confidence in the mystique & integrity of diamonds

consumer

confidence

Differentiation Disclosure

Detection

Confidential

3

The De Beers Group of Companies

TRADE DEFINITION OF DIAMOND & TERMINOLOGY

“A diamond is a natural mineral consisting essentially of pure carbon crystallised with a cubic structure.”

– Source: FTC & CIBJO

What is a synthetic diamond?

– A diamond that has been either partially or wholly crystallised or re-crystallised artificially in a laboratory

What are its properties

– Synthetic diamonds have the same chemical and physical properties as natural diamonds, but have different

growth structures and impurities which enable rapid identification using specialist equipment

• ‘Synthetic’ is from the Greek ‘Sunthetikos’ meaning ‘expert in putting together’ and is applied to ‘a substance or

material made artificially by chemical reaction’

• This entirely appropriate term was applied by the scientists who first synthesised diamond in the 1950’s

– General Electric in the US and ASEA in Sweden

• Using the term ‘grown diamonds’ is ambiguous and potentially deceptive since it does not clearly differentiate natural

diamonds from synthetic

– Natural diamonds are ‘grown’ by mother nature

Confidential

4

The De Beers Group of Companies

DIAMOND FORMATION

• Formed in the earth’s mantle at depths of 150 - 200 km and temperatures of 900 – 1200oC

• Formed 0.9 – 3.5 billion years ago (from isotopic analysis of inclusions)

• Stored under cratons at least 110 km below the earth’s surface

• Until brought up in Kimberlite / lamproite eruptions

Confidential

5

The De Beers Group of Companies

SCHEMATIC DIAGRAM: HPHT SYNTHESIS

ANVIL

ANVIL

Heater

Graphite powder

Metal solvent/

catalyst

Seed

T1

T2

T1 > T2

Temperature-

gradient method

Metal

solvent/catalyst

Nickel/Iron

Cobalt/Iron

• Temperature = 1300 – 1500oC

• Pressure = 50 - 60 kbar

Confidential

6

The De Beers Group of Companies

DIFFERENT GROWTH CONDITIONS LEAD TO DIFFERENCES IN SHAPE

• Octahedral/dodecahedral

Natural diamonds HPHT Synthetics

• Mainly cubo-octahedral

• Minor facets present

Confidential

7

The De Beers Group of Companies

IDENTIFICATION FEATURES - INCLUSIONS

• Metallic inclusions

― From solvent/catalyst

• Rod-shaped

• May be attracted to a magnet

Confidential

8

The De Beers Group of Companies

HPHT SYNTHESIS V. NATURAL FORMATION

• HPHT synthesis relative to natural growth

– Uses a different chemical environment

• Metallic inclusions: visual inspection

– Takes place at a higher temperature

• Different crystal shape: DiamondView

– Uses an engineered temperature gradient

• Different crystal shape and development: DiamondView

• Synthetics have not been at high T for hundreds of millions of years

• Less/different aggregation of nitrogen impurity

• The DiamondSure screening instrument makes use of this difference

Confidential

9

The De Beers Group of Companies

Confidential

10

The De Beers Group of Companies

Confidential

11

The De Beers Group of Companies

Confidential

12

The De Beers Group of Companies

Confidential

13

The De Beers Group of Companies

Confidential

14

The De Beers Group of Companies

Confidential

15

The De Beers Group of Companies

Confidential

16

The De Beers Group of Companies

Confidential

17

The De Beers Group of Companies

POLISHED HPHT-GROWN SYNTHETIC DIAMONDVIEW WITH VISIBLE

ILLUMINATION

Confidential

18

The De Beers Group of Companies

POLISHED HPHT-GROWN SYNTHETIC UV ILLUMINATION:

FLUORESCENCE

Confidential

19

The De Beers Group of Companies

DIAMONDVIEW IMAGES

Colourless

Diamond

Colourless

HPHT

Synthetic

Confidential

20

The De Beers Group of Companies

DIAMONDVIEW IMAGES - FLUORESCENCE

Colourless

Diamond

Colourless

HPHT

Synthetic

Confidential

21

The De Beers Group of Companies

DIAGRAM OF MICROWAVE CVD REACTOR

Plasma

To pump

Gases in

Observation

window

Substrates

Microwaves

Vacuum

window

Pressure ~ 0.1- 0.2 bar

Gases: typically methane and hydrogen

Pressure ~ 0.1- 0.2 bar

Gases: typically methane and hydrogen

Confidential

22

The De Beers Group of Companies

CVD SYNTHETICS IN A CVD REACTOR DURING GROWTH

Image from Scio Diamond – Built in America:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iQXVya-HAOk

Confidential

23

The De Beers Group of Companies

EXAMPLES OF PART-PROCESSED CVD SYNTHETICS

Approx. 5 mm x 5 mm x 3 mm

(after removal of low quality

edge material by laser sawing)

IIa Technologies CVD synthetics

after laser sawing

Confidential

24

The De Beers Group of Companies

KEY FEATURE: INCLUSIONS

Inclusions in CVD synthetics can be strikingly similar to natural inclusions.

Microscopy is insufficient for identification of CVD synthetics.

Examples of dark and light

inclusions observed in

heat treated CVD

synthetics

Confidential

25

The De Beers Group of Companies

INFRARED SPECTROSCOPY

1332

1344

3123

• Near-colourless CVD synthetics are nominally type II

(DiamondSure & IR)

• 1332 and 1344 cm-1 (NS)

• 3123 cm-1 Not present after annealing

Confidential

26

The De Beers Group of Companies

PHOTOLUMINESCENCE SPECTROSCOPY

0743817 initial

PL(LabramHR): lex=458 nm(Ar) T=77K

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

460 470 480 490 500 510 520 530 540 550 560

wavelength (nm)

PL

in

ten

sit

y

467.6

477

482

R

3H

534

633 nm Excited PL 0743817 initial

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000

8000

9000

10000

635 685 735 785 835 885 935 985

Wavelength (nm)

PL

In

ten

sit

y

737

840

637R

• 468 and 533 nm lines

• Commonly shown by as-grown CVD synthetics

• 737 nm line is caused by impurity silicon

• difficult to eliminate / remove

Confidential

27

The De Beers Group of Companies

KEY FEATURES: FLUORESCENCE / STRIATIONS

Micrograph of the surface of

an unprocessed CVD synthetic

Growth model

In as-grown CVD synthetics, the orange fluorescence is caused by

nitrogen-vacancy defects

Striations result from the differential uptake of defects on

different surfaces (risers versus terraces) during growth

DiamondView of a polished cross section of an as-grown

CVD synthetic

Confidential

28

The De Beers Group of Companies

As-grown Treated

• This CVD synthetic gemstone was high temperature treated in an HPHT press (temperatures

>1600°C).

• There is a very noticeable colour improvement from P-T colour to I colour.

Confidential

29

The De Beers Group of Companies

DIAMONDVIEW FLUORESENCE IMAGES OF CVD SYNTHETICS

As-grown Treated

Orange fluorescence

Striations normally present

Sometimes zoning observed (caused by growth

events)

Orange luminescence replaced by green or greenish

blue fluorescence

Phosphorescence generated

Striations / zoning remain

Confidential

30

The De Beers Group of Companies

APOLLO / SCIO CVD SYNTHETICS

EXAMPLES SEEN 2007-2010

Colourless material

• Moderate size

• Orange fluorescence & striations

• Relatively high purity

• Not heat treated

Confidential

31

The De Beers Group of Companies

GEMESIS CVD SYNTHETICS

Birefringence indicates relatively low strain

Bluish green fluorescence and blue

phosphorescence

Fine-to-medium striations, and sometimes

zoning in DiamondView images

Confidential

32

The De Beers Group of Companies

DIAMONDVIEW (DV3F)

• New improved DiamondView

• Interchangeable filters

• Improves detection of CVD

synthetics

• Improved dislocations

imaging in natural diamonds

• Plan to make available from

beginning of H2, 2015

Confidential

33

The De Beers Group of Companies

DIAMONDVIEW – IMPROVED DETECTION WITH FILTERS

CVD Synthetic Natural

Confidential

34

The De Beers Group of Companies

DIAMONDVIEW – IMPROVED DETECTION WITH FILTERS

Natural

CVD Synthetic

Confidential

35

The De Beers Group of Companies

DIAMONDVIEW – IMPROVED DETECTION WITH FILTERS

No filter

GG475

No filter

OG550

No filter

OG550

No filter

Confidential

36

The De Beers Group of Companies

COMPARISON OF STANDARD MAG VS HIGHER MAG SYSTEM

• x1.6 higher optical magnification

• Further magnification possible digitally

• Useful for looking at fine detail

• Natural type II diamonds

• CVD-grown synthetics

• Higher mag system useful for AMS

referrals (smaller sizes)

Standard magnification Higher magnification

Natural type II diamond

CVD Synthetic

Standard magnification (0.03ct) Higher magnification (0.03ct)

Standard magnification (0.03ct) Higher magnification (0.03ct)

Confidential

37

The De Beers Group of Companies

DIAMONDVIEW – SAMPLE HOLDER DEVELOPMENT

Confidential

38

The De Beers Group of Companies

Instrument Screening Flow Chart

Natural type II

All synthetics/ simulants

+ ~2% of natural diamonds

~98% Pass

(No further testing required*)

DiamondView DiamondPLus

DiamondSure

*however, fancy colour type I Pass results will

need additional testing for HPHT treatment

(HPHT treatments test)

All polished

goods

Confidential

39

The De Beers Group of Companies

DIAMONDSURETM

Measures the way diamonds

absorb light

• Rapid screening instrument

• Very easy to operate

– Measurement time: 4 seconds

• ALL synthetics & simulants are referred for further

tests

– Type II diamond

– Synthetic Moissanite

• Mounted goods tested with extendable probe

– Auto-detect capability for initiating measurement

• Removable dish for testing melee goods

Confidential

40

The De Beers Group of Companies

DIAMONDVIEWTM

• All DiamondSure referrals are tested on

DiamondView

• Generates a surface fluorescence image from which

synthetics may be identified

• Loose and mounted goods

• Needs user interpretation

Confidential

41

The De Beers Group of Companies

AUTOMATED MELEE SCREENING (AMS)

• Designed for testing

– Colourless and near-colourless

– 0.01 – 0.20 ct

– Round brilliants

• Automatic feeding, testing and dispensing

– Speed: 360 stones/hr

• Can be left unattended

– One person can run many machines while carrying

out other tasks

– Overnight running is possible

Confidential

42

The De Beers Group of Companies

AMS OUTPUT CATEGORIES

• Pass

– not synthetic or simulant

• Refer

– Rare result: further testing required

• Refer Type II

– Low nitrogen. Could be synthetic. Further testing

required.

• Non diamond

– Simulant or synthetic

• Typical pass rates for natural diamond

– 10 pts: 98%

– 5 pts: 97%

– 1 pt: 96%

Confidential

43

The De Beers Group of Companies

SUMMARY

• Current synthetics can be detected using IIDGR diamond verification instruments used by key grading labs and

regarded as an industry standard

– Sold by IIDGR (https://www.iidgr.com/)

• Automated melee screening equipment is available for sale to De Beers Sightholders and a screening service has been

launched in China and will be launched in India from the beginning of H2 this year.

• Our forward looking research continues to probe potential weaknesses of the identification methods so that

improvements can be implemented if required

• Practical detection technology will be part of the solution to the challenge that the trade currently faces in maintaining

consumer confidence

Confidential

44

The De Beers Group of Companies

I would like to thank the consumer confidence technical research team in Technologies UK for carrying out the

research that has made this presentation possible.

In particular; Dr Brad Cann, Dr David Fisher, Dr Philip Martineau, Dr Nick Davies, Samantha Sibley, Dave Evans, Julia

Samartseva, Christina Martins, John Freeth and Hugh Leach.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS