View
219
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
1/25
D’Agostino Complaint
1
!"#$
&'((#)* +, (-.$!#/ ,#!0& 1 !+2!-)2&
.3456 7899:9;< )9:=;>? 1 (9@4A35 "4?>=;6 7B9>9;4C3;6< )9:=;>?
(36 DEF GHDI J K3C EHF GHDL
#:;45 LF GHDL
+!M )-N+)0& '&-. ,+) 0"$& )-B$-OP
+Q; ;9R49S 4? T3?9@ =C ;9A=;@? :;=R4@9@ T6 >U9 +V53U=W3 !4>6 M== 4C ;9?:=C?9 >= :QT54A
@4?A5=?Q;9 ;9XQ9?>?Y
• 899:9; )9A=;@? Z #C4W35 #;93 .3456 [899:9;\ )9:=;>?
• (9@4A35 )9A=;@? Z (9@4A35 "4?>=;6 [B9>9;4C3;6\ )9:=;> ]=; #55 )9A=;@ 06:9?
• &:9A4W9C )9:=;>
• -W345?
•
&>3C@3;@ -59:U3C> .=SC N;=>=A=5 K3C GHDL• N;9?? )9593?9?
• B4@9= )9A=;@4C^
+'0/$2-
#Y $C>;=@QA>4=C
_Y (3`=; NU6?4A35 0;3QW3?a!=C@4>4=C?
!Y --"B 09?>4C^
.Y (9@4A3>4=C?a&Q::59W9C>?
-Y O94^U> /=??
,Y .43^C=?>4A _5==@ 09?>?
bY
0;3QW3>4A /9?4=C? 1 #T?A9??9?"Y 29A;=:?6 )9?Q5>?
$Y .9C>35 #C=W3549?
KY !=CA5Q?4=C
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
2/25
D’Agostino Complaint
2
#Y $20)+.'!0$+2
.; K9CC4]9; .c#^=?>4C= 4? _=3;@ !9;>4]49@ T6 >U9 #W9;4A3C !=559^9 =] B9>9;4C3;6
M==5=^4A35 (9@4A4C9F 3C@ 4? >U9 .4;9A>=; =] B9>9;4C3;6 &9;R4A9? 4C 3C #??=A43>4=C =] M==?
1 #XQ3;4QW? 7#M#< 3AA;9@4>9@ ]3A454>6 J >U9 +V53U=W3 !4>6 M== 7+!MY<
#]>9; !"#$ S3? ]=QC@ @93@ =C DaEHaDLF .; .c#^=?>4C= W3@9 >U9 ]=55=S4C^ 9C>;6 4C >U9
(9@4A35 )9A=;@?P d0U9;9 S9;9 C= :;9R4=Q? ?4^C? =] 455C9??Ye
0U9 +V53U=W3 !4>6 M== N;9?? )9593?9 =C DaEHaDL 3CC=QCA4C^ !"#$c? @93>U ?>3>9?F d!U34
;9A94R9@ ;9^Q53; [R9>9;4C3;6\ S955C9?? AU9AVQ:?f3C@ ?99W9@ >= T9 U935>U6Ye
03;3 "9C?=CF ?:=V9?S=W3C ]=; >U9 +!M S3? XQ=>9@ 4C R3;4=Q? W9@43 =Q>59>? ?364C^P
d0U9;9 U3@Cc> T99C 3C6>U4C^ >U3> ;34?9@ 3 ;9@ ]53^Y &U9 U3@ T99C 4C ^==@ U935>Ue J
4C]=;W3>4=C ?U9 QC@=QT>9@56 =T>34C9@ 4C A=C?Q5>3>4=C S4>U >U9 .4;9A>=; =] B9>9;4C3;6
&9;R4A9?F .; .c#^=?>4C=Y
"=S9R9;F >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? 3C@ 899:9; )9A=;@? :34C> 3C 9C>4;956 @4]]9;9C> :4A>Q;9Y
N;9A4:4>=Q? S94^U> 5=??F 9W3A43>4=CF ?U9@@4C^ U4^U 59R95? =] --"BF @4]]4AQ5>6 ^9>>4C^ Q:
=C g ?9:3;3>9 =AA3?4=C? 7G ;9XQ4;4C^ 3 W9AU3C4A35 U=4?>9C> >=h4A U9>9;=:U45?F GI
A593;56 R4?4T59 3T?A9??9? i 355 S9;9 7=; ?U=Q5@ U3R9 T99C< d;9@ ]53^?e >U3> ?=W9>U4C^ S3?
?9;4=Q?56 S;=C^ S4>U !"#$F 3C@ >U3> .; .c#^=?>4C= ?U=Q5@ U3R9 ;9A=^C4j9@ 3? 3 54A9C?9@
R9>9;4C3;43CY
.; .c#^=?>4C= S3? 94>U9; =T54R4=Q? >= !"#$c? @9>9;4=;3>4=C 3C@ ?Q]]9;4C^F +) ?U9 VC9S
3T=Q> 4> TQ> AU=?9 >= 4^C=;9 4>F +) ?U9 ]3459@ >= :;=R4@9 :;=:9; W=C4>=;4C^F A3;9F 3C@
>;93>W9C> T9A3Q?9 =] ^9C9;35 4CA=W:9>9CA9 4C U9; ;=59 3? .4;9A>=; =] B9>9;4C3;6&9;R4A9? 3C@ 3? 3 54A9C?9@ R9>9;4C3;43C 4C >U9 &>3>9 =] +V53U=W3Y
0U9 ]=55=S4C^ 4? 3 ?QWW3;6 =] >U9 W9@4A35 ]3A>?F 3C@ =Q; A=CA9;C? =R9; >U9 A3;9 3C@
>;93>W9C> 7=; 53AV >U9;9i=]< >U3> !"#$ ;9A94R9@ ];=W .; .c#^=?>4C=Y
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
3/25
D’Agostino Complaint
3
_Y (#K+) N"*&$!#/ 0)#'(#&a!+2.$0$+2&
&'NN+)0$2b .+!'(-20& #00#!"-.P
• GEY+!M (9@4A35 )9A=;@? DE(36DI J GE,9TDL
• GgY+!M 899:9; )9A=;@? DE(36DI J D,9TDL
,#!0&P
IaDEaDI b9C9;354j9@ :;Q;4>Q? 73V3 4>AU4C^ 9R9;6SU9;9<
LaDkaDI N;9A4:4>=Q? @;=: 4C S94^U> =] IIH /_&
lakiDHaGaDI &U9@@4C^ U4^U 59R95? =] --"BiD# 7U9;:9? R4;Q?<
laGlaDI #C 3@@4>4=C35 @;=: 4C S94^U> =] GHD /_&
DDaLaDI "93@iTQ>>9@ T6 3 A=C?:9A4]4A 3C@ VC=AV9@ =R9; =C>= U9; ;4^U> ?4@9F ?5=S
>= ^9> Q:
DDaDmaDI #C 3@@4>4=C35 @;=: 4C S94^U> =] GkL /_&
DGaLaDI !=C>Q?4=C 7T;Q4?9< =C ];=C> ;4^U> ?U=Q5@9; ];=W QCVC=SC >;3QW3
DGaDDaDI #T;3?4=C? 7?A;3:9?< =C 59]> ?4@9 =] ]3A9F =R9; 969F 3C@ =C 59]> ?4@9 =] T=@6
];=W 3C 35>9;A3>4=C S4>U 3 A=C?:9A4]4A T5=AV4C^ 3 @==;S36
DGaDgaDI (9AU3C4A35 U=4?> ;9XQ4;9@ >= ;34?9 U9; ];=W U9; ;4^U> ?4@9 @Q;4C^ T3>U
DGaDIaDI N==; _=@6 !=C@4>4=C &A=;9
DGaDlaDI (9AU3C4A35 U=4?> ;9XQ4;9@ >= ;34?9 U9; ];=W U9; ;4^U> ?4@9 ];=W =R9;C4^U>
DGaDlaDI +?>9=3;>U;4>4? =] ;4^U> A3;:Q? 7S;4?>< 3C@ >3;?Q? 73CV59< =C ;3@4=^;3:U?
DGaGDaDI ,=QC@ @=SC 4C W=;C4C^F S3? 9R9C>Q3556 3T59 >= ^9> Q: QC3??4?>9@
DGaGGaDI &S9554C^ 79@9W3< =R9; :;9??Q;9 :=4C> =] ;4^U> ?A3:Q53 7?U=Q5@9; T53@9<
DGaGgaDI &S9554C^? 79@9W3< =R9; T=C6 :;=W4C9CA9? =] ;4^U> ]=;9 3C@ U4C@ 59^?
DGaDlaDI 0=h4A U9>9;=:U45? :9;?4?>9C> =C ;9:93> !_!c? DGaDlaDI J DGaGmaDI
A=C?4?>9C> S4>U 4C]53WW3>4=C =; 4C]9A>4=C 4C >U9 T=@6
DaEaDL #T?A9??9? =C ;4^U> ?U=Q5@9;F ;4^U> ]53CVF 35=C^ ;4^U> ?4@9DaEHaDL .93>U ];=W 9W3A43>4=C 3C@ ?9:?4? 7T3A>9;435 4C]9A>4=C 4C T5==@!?9:>4A
?U=AV!]345Q;9 =] WQ5>4:59 =;^3C?!@93>U<
!+2!-)2&P
• 29^54^9CA9 4C >U9 :;3A>4A9 =] R9>9;4C3;6 W9@4A4C9
• &QT?>3C@3;@ A3;9
• !3;959?? @4?;9^3;@ ]=; U935>UF S95]3;9F =; ?3]9>6
• $C3@9XQ3>9 ;9A=;@ V99:4C^
!"#$ U3@ WQ5>4:59 >;3QW3>4A 9R9C>?a4C`Q;49? 4C 2=R9WT9; 3C@ .9A9WT9; GHDIF 3C@ 69>C= N53C ]=; A=W:;9U9C?4R9 =; 9CU3CA9@ A3;9 9h4?>? 4C U9; (9@4A35 )9A=;@?Y
2= ?>9:? S9;9 :;9?A;4T9@ T6 .; .c#^=?>4C= >= 9C?Q;9 U9; @3456 ?3]9>6F C=> =C56 ];=W
3^^;9??4R9 9CA=QC>9;? S4>U >U9 =>U9; 959:U3C>?F TQ> 35?= T9A3Q?9 ?U9 U3@ ;9:93>9@
@4]]4AQ5>6 4C ;4?4C^ ];=W U9; ;4^U> ?4@9Y
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
4/25
D’Agostino Complaint
4
2=>U4C^ 4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? 4C@4A3>9? >U3> .; .c#^=?>4C= U3@ 3 54?> =] ;Q59i=Q>?F =; 3
N53C >= ^= ]=;S3;@ >= ]4C@ =Q> SU3> S3? A3Q?4C^ U9; =C^=4C^ ?>3>9 =] 455iU935>U J =; 9R9C
>U3> !"#$ S3? 4C 3 ?>3>9 =] 455iU935>U 7S94^U> 5=??F --"BiD# R4;35 ?U9@@4C^F :==; _=@6
!=C@4>4=C &A=;9F S93VC9?? 593@4C^ >= @=SC9; E >4W9? S4>U ;9?Q5>3C> ?S9554C^?F >;3QW3>4A
59?4=C?F 3T?A9??9?F >=h4A U9>9;=:U45?F 9>AY< &U9 @4@Cc> ]4C@ 3 dW3;V9@ 4WWQC9 ;9?:=C?9e
4C !"#$c? T5==@ S=;VF ?= ?U9 @4@Cc> 5==V 3C6 ]Q;>U9;Y
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
5/25
D’Agostino Complaint
5
!Y --"B 0-&0$2b
&'NN+)0$2b .+!'(-20& #00#!"-.P
• GEY+!M (9@4A35 )9A=;@? DE(36DI J GE,9TDL
• GgY+!M 899:9; )9A=;@? DE(36DI J D,9TDL
• GY0;QCViS3?U 03T59
•
EY--"B 09?> )9?Q5>? ];=W (9@4A35 )9A=;@?• gY--"B &U9@@4C^ )9?Q5>? -W345 DDaEaDI
•
IY--"B .2# )9?Q5>?F (9@4A35 )9A=;@? EalaDL
• LY&93>>59 04W9? #;>4A59 =C --"B )9?Q5>? EaGEaDL
,#!0&P
--"B 4? =] 4C>9;9?> T9A3Q?9 !"#$ S3? 9h:=?9@ >= --"B 3> >U9 .4AV9;?=C N3;V M== 4C (+F
3C@ 3> >U9 O==@53C@ N3;V M== SU9;9 3 A=C?:9A4]4A @49@ =] --"BY $C 3@@4>4=CF ?9R9;35
959:U3C>? 3> >U9 +!M U3R9 T99C 9h:=?9@ >=F ;9A=R9;9@ ];=WF =; @49@ ];=W --"BY
0U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? 3C@ >U9 899:9; )9A=;@? :;=R4@9 4CA=W:59>9 4C]=;W3>4=C S4>U
;9^3;@? >= --"B ?3W:59 A=559A>4=CF ?3W:59 >9?>4C^F 3C@a=; >9?> ;9?Q5>?Y
• -59:U3C> -C@=>U954=>;=:4A "9;:9?R4;Q? 7--"B< S3? >9?>9@ ]=; 3> 593?> Dm >4W9?
Q?4C^ >;QCViS3?U ?3W:59?F T3?9@ =C Dm 3R3453T59 >;QCViS3?U >9?> ;9?Q5>?Y +]
>U=?9 Dm >9?> ;9?Q5>?F =C56 l 3;9 9C>9;9@ 4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@?Y 0U9 =>U9; DD
>9?> ;9?Q5>? S9;9 ]=QC@ 4C 3C 9W345 @3>9@ DDaEaDIY
• "=S9R9; >U9;9 3;9 EI >;QCViS3?U A=559A>4=C 9C>;49? 4C >U9 899:9; )9A=;@?Y +]
>U=?9 EIF =C56 G U3R9 A=;;9?:=C@4C^ A=559A>4=C 9C>;49? 4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@?F
3C@ =] >U=?9 GF =C56 =C9 U3? >9?> ;9?Q5>? ;9A=;@9@Y Gg =] >U9 EI U3R9 C= ;9?Q5>?
3C6SU9;9F =; 3C6 9C>;6 3C6SU9;9 3? >= SU3> S3? @=C9 S4>U >U9 ?3W:59?Y
• +C9 >;QCViS3?U ;9?Q5> ]=QC@ 4C >U9 DDaEaDI 9W345 U3? C= A=;;9?:=C@4C^
A=559A>4=C 9C>;6 4C 94>U9; >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? =; >U9 899:9; )9A=;@?Y• --"B S3? >9?>9@ ]=; DH >4W9? Q?4C^ T5==@ ?3W:59?F T3?9@ =C DH 3R3453T59 T5==@
>9?> ;9?Q5>?F 3C@ =C E @4]]9;9C> >4??Q9? A=559A>9@ 3> C9A;=:?6Y 0U9?9 3;9 9C>9;9@
4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@?Y
• +C9 ?354R3 ?S3T >3V9C =C DHaGaDI 4? C=>9@ 4C >U9 899:9; )9A=;@?F TQ> >U9;9 4? C=
A=;;9?:=C@4C^ 9C>;6 4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@?F 3C@ C= ;9?Q5>? S9;9 ]=QC@Y
#C 9hU3Q?>4R9 ?93;AU ]=; U9;:9?R4;Q? A955Q53; 4CA5Q?4=C? S3? @=C9 T6 >U9 "4?>=i
N3>U=5=^4?> 3> C9A;=:?6F 3C@ C= 9R4@9CA9 =] U9;:9?R4;Q? 4CA5Q?4=C? S9;9 ]=QC@ 4C 3C6
A955?Y 0U4? S=Q5@ 593@ =C9 >= A=CA5Q@9 >U3> --"B S3? C=> >U9 A3Q?9 =] !"#$c? @93>UY
"=S9R9; >;QCViS3?U >9?> ;9?Q5>? ];=W >U9 DDaEaDI 9W345F ?U=S >U3> !"#$F QC54V9 3C6 =]
>U9 =>U9; 959:U3C>?F S3? 3A>4R956 ?U9@@4C^ ?4^C4]4A3C>56 U4^U 59R95? =] --"BiD# R4;35
:3;>4A59? @Q;4C^ >U9 W=C>U? =] #Q^Q?>F &9:>9WT9;F 3C@ 4C>= +A>=T9; GHDIY N93V
?U9@@4C^ =AAQ;;9@ =C laGHaDIY 0U4? S3? 4WW9@43>956 T9]=;9F 3C@ 3> >U9 >4W9 >U9
A=C?:9A4]4A (#/-- @49@ ];=W --"BiD#Y
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
6/25
D’Agostino Complaint
6
+C EalaDL 3C 9C>;6 S3? W3@9 4C !"#$c? (9@4A35 )9A=;@? >U3> >U9;9 S3? C= .2#
?9XQ9CA4C^ @4]]9;9CA9? T9>S99C !"#$c& --"BiD# ?QT>6:9F 3C@ (#/--c? --"BiD#
?QT>6:9Y 0U9 ;9?Q5>? S9;9 @9]4C4>4R9 >U3> >U96 T=>U S9;9 4C]9A>9@ S4>U >U9 !"#"$%&'(()
%+"#$%&'( R4;Q? ?QT>6:9F 593@4C^ >= >U9 A=CA5Q?4=C >U3> SU9C !"#$ S3? ?U9@@4C^ 53;^9
CQWT9;? =] R4;Q? :3;>4A59? 4C #Q^Q?> 3C@ &9:>9WT9; GHDIF ?U9 W=?> 54V956 :;=R4@9@ 3C
=R9;SU95W4C^ 9h:=?Q;9 >= (#/-- SU= >U9C @49@ =C DHaDaDIY
!+2!-)2&P
• $C3@9XQ3>9 ;9A=;@ V99:4C^
• &QT?>3C@3;@ A3;9
0U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? 3C@ >U9 899:9; )9A=;@? :;=R4@9 =C56 ?A3>>9;9@ 4C]=;W3>4=C S4>U
;9^3;@? >= --"B ?3W:59 A=559A>4=CF ?3W:59 >9?>4C^F 3C@a=; >9?> ;9?Q5>?Y
0U9 0;QCViS3?U 03T59 :;=R4@9? 3 R4?Q35 ?QWW3;6 =] >U9 W4??4C^ 9C>;49?Y Gg >;QCViS3?U
A=559A>4=C 9C>;49? U3R9 C= ;9?Q5>? ;9A=;@9@ 3C6SU9;9Y
)9?Q5>? ];=W SU9C !"#$ S3? 3A>4R956 ?U9@@4C^ R4;Q? :3;>4A59?F 3C@ >U9;9]=;9 W=?> 3> ;4?V
>= =>U9; W9WT9;? =] >U9 U9;@F S9;9 C9R9; 9C>9;9@ 4C>= >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@?F 3C@ S9;9
=C56 ]=QC@ 4C >U9 9W345 @3>9@ DDaEaDIY
"9;:9? =Q>T;93V? 3C@ ?U9@@4C^ 3;9 VC=SC >= =AAQ; 3> >4W9? =] ?>;9??Y $C >U9 E W=C>U?
:;4=; >= U9; --"BiD# R4;35 ?U9@@4C^F !"#$ U3@ 5=?> kHD /_&Y &=W9>U4C^ S3? S;=C^ 3C@
U9; T=@6 S3? ?>;9??9@F TQ> C=>U4C^ S3? 9R9; 9C>9;9@ 4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@?Y
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
7/25
D’Agostino Complaint
7
.Y (-.$!#0$+2&a&'NN/-(-20&
&'NN+)0$2b .+!'(-20& #00#!"-.P
• GEY+!M (9@4A35 )9A=;@? DE(36DI J GE,9TDL
• GgY+!M 899:9; )9A=;@? DE(36DI J D,9TDL
,#!0&P# ;9A=;@ =] 355 >U9 N;9?A;4:>4=C?a0;93>W9C>? =;@9;9@ ]=; !"#$ 4? 4W:=;>3C> >= ;9R49S
T9A3Q?9 !"#$ ?Q]]9;9@ 3 CQWT9; =] >;3QW3>4A 9R9C>? 3C@ 4C`Q;49? @Q;4C^ U9; >9CQ;9 3>
>U9 +!M 7A=C>Q?4=CF 3T;3?4=C?F ?S9554C^?a9@9W3?F 3T?A9??9?F U93@iTQ>>9@ =]] U9; ]99>F
@=SC9; E >4W9?Y<
• O4>U4C >U9 ]4;?> E S99V? 3]>9; U9; 3;;4R35F ?U9 U3@ 3 :;=^;9??4R956 S=;?9C4C^
3559;^4A ;93A>4=C >= ?=W9>U4C^ 4C U9; 9CR4;=CW9C>F 3C@ T9A3W9 ?9R9;956 :;Q;4>4A
73V3 4>AU6Y< 0U4? S3? ?QAA9??]Q556 >;93>9@ S4>U 3 LiS99V A=Q;?9 =]
3C>4U4?>3W4C9?Y
• 2Q>;4>4=C35 ?Q::59W9C>? 3C@ 3 ̀ =4C>iU935>U ?Q::59W9C> S9;9 ?>3;>9@ 3> R3;4=Q?
>4W9?Y 0U4? S=Q5@ ?99W :;Q@9C> =C ^9C9;35 :;4CA4:35F TQ> >U9 ?>3;>i@3>9? 3::93;
>= T9 ;3C@=WF 3C@ >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? @= C=> 9h:534C SU6 >U9?9 @9A4?4=C? S9;9
W3@9 SU9C >U96 S9;9 W3@9Y
• #]>9; U9; ?9A=C@ W9AU3C4A35 U=4?> =C DGaDlaDI ?U9 S3? ?>3;>9@ =C 3 ki@36
A=Q;?9 =] 3C>4i4C]53WW3>=;6 W9@4A3>4=CF SU4AU S3? 9h>9C@9@ >= DG @36? 3]>9; 59^
?S9554C^ S3? @4?A=R9;9@ =C DGaGgaDIY
• #C>4T4=>4A? 7>=:4A35 3C@a=; ?6?>9W4A< S9;9 C9R9; :;9?A;4T9@ ]=; 3C6 =] U9;
S=QC@?a4C`Q;49?F 3C@ C= 3C>4?9:>4Aa3C>4T4=>4A ]5Q?U =] 3C6 V4C@ S3? 9R9;
:;9?A;4T9@ >= >;93> U9; 3T?A9??9? 7899:9; &>3]] S9;9 4C?>93@ 4C?>;QA>9@ >= ]5Q?U
=CA9 3 @36 S4>U >U9 T3>U4C^ U=?9Y<
N;9?A;4:>4=C?a0;93>W9C>? 4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@?PIaDEaDI (4C9;35 +45 :;=:U653A>4A3556 ]=; A=C?>4:3>4=C Q:=C 3;;4R35
LagaDI J kaDgaDI .4:U9CU6@;3W4C9 73C>4U4?>3W4C9< ]=; ?9R9;9 :;Q;4>Q? 74>AU6 ?V4C<
kaDIaDI J .3456 )-. !-// 7B4>3W4Ca(4C9;35a$;=C &Q::59W9C><
DGaDlaDI J DGaGmaDI ,4;=A=h4T 72$.< 3]>9; ?9A=C@ W9AU3C4A35 U=4?> =C DGaDlaDI
DGaGHaDI J .3456 !=?9XQ4C -XQ4C9 7`=4C> U935>U ?Q::59W9C><
DakaDL J .3456 -WA9559 0=A=:U9;=5 7B4>3W4C - &Q::59W9C><
!+2!-)2&P
• 29^54^9CA9 4C >U9 :;3A>4A9 =] R9>9;4C3;6 W9@4A4C9
•
&QT?>3C@3;@ !3;9
0U9 ?>3;> @3>9? ]=; CQ>;4>4=C35 ?Q::59W9C>? 3;9 4C>;=@QA9@ S4>U=Q> 9h:53C3>4=C 4C >U9
(9@4A35 )9A=;@?Y 0U9;9 4? C= A=W:;9U9C?4R9 N53C ]=; @49>3;6 ?Q::59W9C>3>4=C >=
:;=W=>9 S94^U> W34C>9C3CA9 3C@ ̂ 9C9;35 U935>UY
$> S3?Cc> QC>45 3]>9; >U96 U=4?>9@ U9; >= U9; ]99> ]=; >U9 ?9A=C@ >4W9 =C DGaDlaDI >U3>
3C>4i4C]53WW3>=;6 W9@4A3>4=C? S9;9 :;9?A;4T9@Y +>U9; >U3C U9; 93;56i=C 3559;^4A
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
8/25
D’Agostino Complaint
8
:;Q;4>Q?F >U4? S3? >U9 =C56 =>U9; >4W9 ?:9A4]4A W9@4A35 >;93>W9C> S3? :;=R4@9@ ]=; 3C6 =]
U9; WQ5>4:59 345W9C>?Y
K=4C>iU935>U ?Q::59W9C>? S9;9 35?= C=> ?>3;>9@ QC>45 G @36? 3]>9; U9; ?9A=C@ W9AU3C4A35
U=4?>F 9R9C >U=Q^U 4> 4? S955 QC@9;?>==@ >U3> R4;>Q3556 355 959:U3C>? 4C A3:>4R4>6 ?Q]]9;
];=W ?=W9 @9^;99 =] =?>9=3;>U;4>4? 4C >U94; ]99> 3C@ 59^?F 3C@ S=Q5@ T9C9]4> ];=W ?QAU?Q::59W9C>? ];=W @36 =C9Y
#C>4T4=>4A? 7>=:4A35 3C@a=; ?6?>9W4A< S9;9 C=> :;9?A;4T9@ ]=; >U9 >;93>W9C> =] U9;
3T?A9??9?Y $C ]3A> ?U9 ;9A94R9@ 2+ @9]4C4>4R9 >;93>W9C> ]=; U9; 3T?A9??9? J >U96 S9;9
355=S9@ >= ?A3T =R9; 3C@ ]9?>9;Y
0U9;9 4? C= @=AQW9C>3>4=C 3C6SU9;9 >U3> >U9 899:9;? 3A>Q3556 +, 3C6 =] >U9 >;93>W9C>?
=; 3@W4C4?>9; 3C6 =] >U9 W9@4A3>4=C? >U3> 3;9 :;9?A;4T9@ T6 >U9 B9>9;4C3;6 &>3]]F 3C@ >U9
d!359C@3; $>9W?e ]93>Q;9 =] >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? 4? =C56 ?:=;3@4A3556 Q?9@ >= >;3AV >U9
@Q;3>4=C =] >U9 W9@4A3>4=C? :;9?A;4T9@Y
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
9/25
D’Agostino Complaint
9
-Y O-$b"0 /+&&
&'NN+)0$2b .+!'(-20& #00#!"-.P
• GEY+!M (9@4A35 )9A=;@? DE(36DI J GE,9TDL
• GgY+!M 899:9; )9A=;@? DE(36DI J D,9TDL
• kYONM &:9A4W9C )9:=;> 7O94^U>?< DHaEDaDg J IaDgaDI
•
lY+!M &:9A4W9C )9:=;> 7O94^U>?< IaDEaDI J DaEHaDL• mYO94^U> "4?>=;6 03T59
•
DHYNU=>= .Q;4C^ "=4?> &U=S4C^ &:4C9 DGaDlaDI
• DDY+!M N;9?? )9593?9 =C 29A;=:?6 GaGHaDL
• DGY&93>>59 04W9? #;>4A59i$C>9;R49S .; .c#^=?>4C= EaDmaDL
,#!0&P
O94^U> W93?Q;9W9C>? 3;9 =] 4C>9;9?> T9A3Q?9 !"#$ S3? 9W3A43>9@ S4>U 3 ?9R9;9 5=?? =]
T=@6 ]3> 3> >U9 >4W9 =] U9; @93>UF 3C@ >U4? @4@ C=> U3::9C =R9;C4^U>Y &U9 A3W9 >= >U9
+!M S94^U4C^ lFDIH /_&Y #> >U9 >4W9 =] U9; @93>U ?U9 S3? @=SC >= =C56 kFHmm /_&F
U3R4C^ 5=?> DEn =] U9; =;4^4C35 T=@6 S94^U>Y
0U9 &:9A4W9C )9:=;>? ];=W >U9 ONM 3C@ +!M ?U=S 3 :;9A4:4>=Q? @;=: 4C S94^U> =] IIH
/_& 4C (36aKQC9 GHDIF ]=55=S9@ T6 3 @;=: =] 3C 3@@4>4=C35 GHD /_& T6 >U9 9C@ =] #Q^Q?>
GHDIY 2= S94^U>? S9;9 >3V9Ca;9A=;@9@ @Q;4C^ 355 =] &9:>9WT9;a+A>=T9; GHDIF TQ> T6
W4@i2=R9WT9; ?U9 U3@ 5=?> 3C 3@@4>4=C35 GkL /_& 3C@ S3? T6 >U9C @=SC >= kFDGE /_&Y
&U9 S3? C9h> S94^U9@ =CA9 4C .9A9WT9; GHDIF >U9C 3^34C 4C K3CQ3;6 GHDLF 3C@ U9;
S94^U> ;9W34C9@ 3;=QC@ kFDHH /_& QC>45 ?U9 @49@ 4C 3 ?>3>9 =] 9W3A43>4=CY
294>U9; 899:9; C=; B9>9;4C3;6 &>3]] C=>9@aA=WW9C>9@ =C 3C6 =] >U4? :;=^;9??4R9
S94^U> 5=?? 4C >U94; )9A=;@?F 9R9C >U=Q^U >U9;9 3;9 DI 54R9 S94^U>? ;9A=;@9@ 4C >U9 +!M
&:9A4W9C )9:=;>Y #C@ 69> 4C >U94; GaGHaDL N;9?? )9593?9 >U9 +!M A593;56 ?>3>9@ >U3>>U96 S9;9 3S3;9 >U3> !"#$ U3@ T99C ?5=S56 5=?4C^ S94^U>Y
2=>3T56 >U;=Q^U=Q> !"#$c? 9C>4;9 lYIiW=C>U >9CQ;9 3> >U9 +!MF .; .c#^=?>4C= 9C>9;9@
3C@ Q?9@ =Q>@3>9@ S94^U>? >= :;9?A;4T9 W9@4A3>4=C? 3C@ >;93>W9C>? =C 355 TQ> G
=AA3?4=C?Y ,=; >U9 ]4;?> W=C>U 3C@ 3 U35]F ?U9 Q?9@ >U9 S94^U> ];=W >U9 ONM =] lFDIH
/_&Y _9^4CC4C^ LaEHaDIF .; .c#^=?>4C= A=CR9;>9@ !"#$c? LaDkaDI 54R9 S94^U> =] kFLHL
/_& >= V45=^;3W?F 3C@ :;=A99@9@ >= Q?9 >U3> CQWT9; =] EFgIH 8b& A=C?4?>9C>56 QC>45 U9;
@93>UY 70U4? 4? 93?456 R4?Q354j9@ 4C >U9 O94^U> "4?>=;6 03T59Y<
_3?9@ =C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@?F .; .c#^=?>4C= @4@ _=@6 !=C@4>4=C &A=;4C^ =C56 ,#" >4W9=C DGaDIaDIY
_=@6 !=C@4>4=C &A=;4C^ Q?9? 3 CQW9;4A ?A359 >= 9R35Q3>9 U935>U 3C@ CQ>;4>4=C35 ?>3>Q?Y
$C 53;^9; 3C4W35? 4> 4? @=C9 T6 A3;9]Q5 R4?Q35 9h3W4C3>4=C 7?W3559; 3C4W35? W36 35?=
4CA5Q@9 U3C@?i=C :35:3>4=CY< OU9C 3??4^C4C^ 3 _=@6 !=C@4>4=C &A=;9F 9R35Q3>=;? 5==V 3>
>U9 3W=QC> =] WQ?A59 :;9?9C>F ?V959>35 ]93>Q;9?F 3C@ ]3>iA=R9; 3> 4W:=;>3C> 3C@ ?:9A4]4A
3C3>=W4A35 :=4C>?Y 0U9?9 4CA5Q@9 >U9 ;4T?F 5QWT3; R9;>9T;39F :95R4A T=C9?F ?U=Q5@9;?F
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
10/25
D’Agostino Complaint
10
3C@ 355 T=@6 :;=W4C9CA9?Y $> 4? 3 ?QT`9A>4R9 :;3A>4A9F TQ> 4> 4? Q?Q3556 XQ4>9 3AAQ;3>9
SU9C :9;]=;W9@ T6 3 >;34C9@ 9R35Q3>=;Y
_=@6 !=C@4>4=C &A=;4C^ 4? @=C9 =C 3 Ii:=4C> =; 3 mi:=4C> ?A359 J W=;9 A=WW=C56 mi:=4C>
4C 53;^9 3C4W35?Y +C 3 mi:=4C> ?A359 73? S3? Q?9@ U9;9< 3 ?A=;9 =] E Z d>U4Ce 3C@ 3 ?A=;9
=] g Z dW=@9;3>956 >U4CYe $C T=>U 3 ?A=;9 =] E =; gF >U9 ;4T? '-" ?U=S4C^Y
+C DGaDIaDI 3 C=>9 S3? W3@9 4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@?P
• _=@6 A=C@4>4=C 4? ?54^U>56 >U4C 3C@ ?A=;9? T9>S99C EigamY
• N53C 4? >= ]99@ W=;9 >= 4CA;93?9 U9; T=@6 S94^U> T6 3::;=h4W3>956 EHHigHH /_&Y
#> >U9 >4W9 .; .c#^=?>4C= @4@ >U4? _=@6 !=C@4>4=C &A=;4C^F !"#$ S94^U9@ =C56 kFHll /_&
J ;9A=;@9@ `Q?> >U9 @36 T9]=;9 4C >U9 &:9A4W9C )9:=;>Y 0U4? S3? >U9 .'/" 0""1 >U3>
?U9 S9C> @=SC E >4W9?F 3C@ U3@ >= T9 W9AU3C4A3556 U=4?>9@ >= U9; ]99> >S4A9Y
!+2!-)2&P
• 29^54^9CA9 4C >U9 :;3A>4A9 =] R9>9;4C3;6 W9@4A4C9
• &QT?>3C@3;@ A3;9
• !3;959?? @4?;9^3;@ ]=; U935>UF S95]3;9F =; ?3]9>6
• $C3@9XQ3>9 ;9A=;@ V99:4C^
• 0U9 Q?9 =] ]35?9 =; @9A9:>4R9 ?>3>9W9C>? 4C 3C6 @=AQW9C> A=CC9A>9@ S4>U >U9
:;3A>4A9 =] R9>9;4C3;6 W9@4A4C9
• !=C@QA> 54V956 >= W4?593@ >U9 :QT54A
-R9C >U=Q^U !"#$c? ;9A=;@9@ S94^U> ?>93@456 @;=::9@ ];=W >U9 >4W9 ?U9 3;;4R9@ 3> >U9
+!MF >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? 3;9 @9R=4@ =] 3C6 ;9A=^C4>4=C =] >U3> ]3A>Y
!"#$ 3;;4R9@ 3> >U9 +!M S94^U4C^ 3 U935>U6 lFDIH /_&F 3C@ lYI W=C>U? 53>9; ?U9 @49@ 4C 3
?>3>9 =] 9W3A43>4=C 3> kFHmm /_& S4>U=Q> .; .c#^=?>4C= 9R9; 9R9C C=>4A4C^ >U9 AU3C^9
73? 9R4@9CA9@ T6 >U9 ]3A> >U3> ?U9 A=C?4?>9C>56 Q?9@ =Q>@3>9@ S94^U>? SU9C :;9?A;4T4C^
W9@4A3>4=C?Y<
0U9 &93>>59 04W9? #;>4A59i$C>9;R49S ];=W EaDmaDL ?>3>9? >U3> .; .c#^=?>4C= ?34@ >U3> ?U9
;9549@ =C 3 ?>3C@3;@F R4?Q35 ?A=;4C^ ?6?>9W >= 9R35Q3>9 !"#$c? T=@6 A=C@4>4=CF 3C@ T6
>U3> 63;@?>4AV ?U9 @4@Cc> 3::93; >= T9 @3C^9;=Q?56 QC@9;S94^U>Y _Q> 4C lYI W=C>U? ?U9
@4@ =C56 ,#" _=@6 !=C@4>4=C &A=;4C^F 3C@ >U3> S3?Cc> QC>45 DGaDIaDIY
$C >U3> ?3W9 4C>9;R49SF .; .c#^=?>4C= 4? 35?= XQ=>9@ 3? ?364C^ d*=Q A=Q5@Cc> ?99 U9; ;4T?F
C=>U4C^ >U3> S=Q5@ 4C@4A3>9 >U9 @9^;99 =] ]3> 5=?? >U3> S3? ^=4C^ =CFe 3C@ C=>4C^ >U3>
gHH J IHH /_& @=9?Cc> ;9:;9?9C> 3 ?4^C4]4A3C> 5=?? ]=; 3C 3C4W35 >U9 ?4j9 =] 3C 959:U3C>Y
d$> S3?Cc> 3 UQ^9 ;9@ ]53^ ]=; Q?e ?U9 ?34@Y
_Q> 3> >U9 >4W9 =] >U9 _=@6 !=C@4>4=C &A=;4C^ 4C .9A9WT9; GHDIF !"#$ U3@ '(-"'+) (,.$
23456 789F SU4AU .) .c#^=?>4C= S=Q5@ U3R9 VC=S 4] ?U9 U3@ 5==V9@ 3> >U9 &:9A4W9C
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
11/25
D’Agostino Complaint
11
)9:=;> =; 3> !"#$Y #C@ 3 &A=;9 =] Eigam S=Q5@ W93C >U9 ;4T? S9;9 W=?> A9;>34C56
?U=S4C^F 3? S3? U9; ?:4C9 3C@ =>U9; T=@6 :;=W4C9CA9?Y 7&99 :U=>= >3V9C @Q;4C^ >U9
W9AU3C4A35 U=4?> =C DGaDlaDIY<
!"#$ S3? A54C4A3556 4C 3 S93V9C9@ ?>3>9 4C .9A9WT9; GHDIY #C@ 69> >U9;9 4? C= ;9A=;@ =]
3 W9@4A35 N53C >= A;93>9 3 54?> =] ;Q59i=Q>?F >= ?93;AU ]=; 3 A3Q?9F >= 4CA;93?9 U9; A35=;4A4C>3V9 =; :;=R4@9 ]99@i?>Q]]? >U3> S=Q5@ T9 W=;9 @4^9?>4T59F >= ;9R49S =; 4CA;93?9 U9;
S94^U> W=C4>=;4C^F >= AU9AV U9; >99>U S4>U >U94; d:5QWT9;c? A3W9;3Fe >= A=C@QA> 3
A=W:;9U9C?4R9 :U6?4A35 9h3WF >= ?AU9@Q59 3 ]=55=SiQ: 9h3WF >= @= 3C6>U4C^ @9]4C4>4R9
'$ '(( >= :;=W=>9 S94^U> ^34C =; 4W:;=R9 U9; T=@6 A=C@4>4=CY
0U9 =C56 ;9A=WW9C@3>4=C .; .c#^=?>4C= W3@9 S3? >= d]99@ W=;9Ye
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
12/25
D’Agostino Complaint
12
,Y .$#b2+&0$! _/++. 0-&0&
&'NN+)0$2b .+!'(-20& #00#!"-.P
• GEY+!M (9@4A35 )9A=;@? DE(36DI J GE,9TDL
• GgY+!M 899:9; )9A=;@? DE(36DI J D,9TDL
• DEY!_! 2=>9? 0=h4A "9>9;=:U45?
•
DGY&93>>59 04W9? #;>4A59i$C>9;R49S .; .c#^=?>4C= EaDmaDL
,#!0&P
.43^C=?>4A _5==@ >9?>? S9;9 ;QC =C !"#$ DD >4W9? T9>S99C IaDEaDI 3C@ DGaGmaDIY 0U4?
4? C=>9S=;>U6 T9A3Q?9 ?>3;>4C^ 4C .9A9WT9; GHDIF ?U9 U3@ d>=h4A U9>9;=:U45?e 4C U9;
T5==@Y 0U9?9 3::93;9@ 3]>9; ?U9 T9^3C U3R4C^ @4]]4AQ5>6 ^9>>4C^ Q: ];=W U9; ;4^U> ?4@9F
3C@ >S4A9 U3@ >= T9 3??4?>9@ >= U9; ]99> S4>U 3 W9AU3C4A35 U=4?>Y 0U9 >=h4A U9>9;=:U45?
:9;?4?>9@ >U;=Q^U .9A9WT9;F 3C@ S9;9 ?>455 :;9?9C> =C DGaGmaDI i >U9 @3>9 =] >U9 53?>
!_! @=C9 =C !"#$ T9]=;9 U9; @93>U EG @36? 53>9;Y
• $C 959:U3C>?F C9Q>;=:U45? 3;9 W=;9 3AAQ;3>956 @9?A;4T9@ 3? dU9>9;=:U45?e
T9A3Q?9 =] >U9 :;9?9CA9 =] ;9@@4?U ^;3CQ59? 4C?4@9 >U9 A955?Y /4V9 C9Q>;=:U45?F
U9>9;=:U45? 3;9 3 >6:9 =] SU4>9 T5==@ A955 7O_!< >U3> 4C^9?> 3C@ V455
W4A;==;^3C4?W?F 3C@ 3;9 C=;W3556 ]=QC@ 4C >U9 T5==@?>;93WY
• OU9C 3C 4C]53WW3>=;6 :;=A9?? T9^4C? 4C >U9 T=@6F 9?:9A43556 3? 3 ;9?Q5> =] 3
T3A>9;435 4C]9A>4=CF U9>9;=:U45? 3;9 =C9 =] >U9 ]4;?> O_!? >= A=C^;9^3>9 3> >U9
?4>9 =] >U9 4C`Q;6Y 0U96 3;9 ;9A;Q4>9@ S4>U4C W4CQ>9? ]=55=S4C^ >;3QW3F 3C@ 3;9
>U9 U355W3;V =] 3AQ>9 4C]53WW3>4=CY "9>9;=:U45? 3;9 >U9 :;9@=W4C3C> A955?
]=QC@ 4C :Q?F 3AA=QC>4C^ ]=; 4>? SU4>4?Ua6955=S4?U 3::93;3CA9Y
• "9>9;=:U45? 9hU4T4> >=h4A AU3C^9? 4C ;9?:=C?9 >= ?9R9;9 ?6?>9W4A 455C9??F 3C@ 3;9
A=WW=C56 ]=QC@ S4>U ?9:?4? 73V3 T3A>9;435 4C]9A>4=C 4C >U9 T5==@?>;93WY<
!+2!-)2&P• 29^54^9CA9 4C >U9 :;3A>4A9 =] R9>9;4C3;6 W9@4A4C9
• &QT?>3C@3;@ A3;9
• $C3@9XQ3>9 ;9A=;@ V99:4C^
&9R9C !_!? S9;9 @=C9 >U;=Q^U=Q> >U9 W=C>U =] .9A9WT9; GHDIF TQ> >U9C >U96 `Q?>
?>=::9@F 9R9C >U=Q^U >=h4A U9>9;=:U45? S9;9 ?>455 :;9?9C> 4C ?4^C4]4A3C> CQWT9;?Y +C
DGaGmaDIF >U9 @3>9 >U9 53?> !_! S3? @=C9F >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? ?>3>9 d)9AU9AV ?54@9
9R35Q3>4=C :9;]=;W9@ 3C@ >=h4A AU3C^9? 3;9 ?>455 ;9:=;>9@Ye
0U9 9C>;6 ^=9? =C >= ?36 dS455 9R35Q3>9 53T=;3>=;6 W9>U=@? >= 9C?Q;9 A=;;9A> ]4C@4C^?Ye_Q> >U9C >U9;9 4? C=>U4C^ >= A=C]4;W SU9>U9; >U4? S3? @=C9F =; SU3> >U9 =Q>A=W9 S3?Y
$C?>93@F >=h4A U9>9;=:U45? 3;9 S955 @=AQW9C>9@ 3C@ A3>9^=;4j9@ g >4W9? 4C >U9 (9@4A35
)9A=;@? @Q;4C^ >U9 W=C>U =] .9A9WT9; GHDIF 3C@ >U9C >U96 3;9 `Q?> @4?A3;@9@ ];=W
]Q;>U9; A=C?4@9;3>4=C S4>U=Q> 9h:53C3>4=CY
0=h4A U9>9;=:U45? S9;9 3 A593; 4C@4A3>4=C >U3> ?=W9>U4C^ ?=W9SU9;9 S3? ?9;4=Q?56
S;=C^F 9R9C 4] 3 A54C4A35 455C9?? S3? C=> ;93@456 3::3;9C> >= .; .c#^=?>4C=Y _Q> >U9;9
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
13/25
D’Agostino Complaint
13
S9;9 C= ]Q;>U9; @43^C=?>4A? =; 9]]=;>? >= 4CR9?>4^3>9 3 A3Q?9 ]=; >U9?9 >=h4A A955? 9Y^Y
_5==@ !Q5>Q;9F !1& =] >U9 3T?A9??9?F 3@@4>4=C35 !_!?F C=> 9R9C 3 A=W:;9U9C?4R9 =; 9R9C
T3?4A :U6?4A35 9h3WY 2= W=C4>=;4C^F C= 54?> =] )Q59i=Q>?F C= N53CF C=>U4C^Y !"#$ S3?
`Q?> A=C?4@9;9@ >= T9 dC=;W35Ye
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
14/25
D’Agostino Complaint
14
bY 0)#'(#0$! /-&$+2& 1 #_&!-&&-&
&'NN+)0$2b .+!'(-20& #00#!"-.P
• GEY+!M (9@4A35 )9A=;@? DE(36DI J GE,9TDL
• GgY+!M 899:9; )9A=;@? DE(36DI J D,9TDL
• DgY+!M &>3C@3;@ -59:U3C> .=SC N;=>=A=5 K3C GHDL
•
DIY29A;=:?6 )9:=;>F (9@4A35 )9A=;@? DaEHaDL• DGY&93>>59 04W9? #;>4A59i$C>9;R49S .; .c#^=?>4C= EaDmaDL
•
DLY(QC4A4:35 !=QC?95=; -W345 EaGEaDL
• DkY&3W:59? =] +!M (9@4A35 1 899:9; )9A=;@? >= !=W:3;9 Sa ONM )9A=;@?
• DlY&3W:59? =] ONM (9@4A35 1 899:9; )9A=;@? >= !=W:3;9 Sa +!M )9A=;@?
• GLYB4@9= =] ,4C35 NU3?9 =] (9AU3C4A35 "=4?> DGaDlaDI
,#!0&P
)9R49S4C^ !"#$c? A3;9 S4>U ;9^3;@ >= U9; >;3QW3>4A 59?4=C? 3C@ 3T?A9??9? 4? 4W:=;>3C>
T9A3Q?9 =C9 =] >U9 A3Q?9? ]=; U9; @93>U @9>9;W4C9@ 3> C9A;=:?6 S3? ?9:?4? 54V956
=;4^4C3>4C^ ];=W >U9?9 59?4=C? 4C U9; ?V4CY
!"#$ S3? W9AU3C4A3556 U=4?>9@ >= U9; ]99> >S4A9 J =CA9 =C DGaDgaDI 3C@ >U9C 3^34C g
@36? 53>9; =C DGaDlaDIY
• O9 S9;9 =C56 :;=R4@9@ S4>U 3 ?U=;> ?C4:i4> =] R4@9= ]==>3^9 ];=W @Q;4C^ >U9
DGaDlaDI W9AU3C4A35 U=4?>Y 0U9 ]==>3^9 4? ':$"- >U9 G 54]>4C^ ?>;3:? 73 ^4;>U ?>;3:
T9U4C@ U9; ];=C> 59^? 3C@ 3 ]53CV ?>;3: 4C ];=C> =] U9; U4C@ 59^?< S9;9 35;93@6 4C
:53A9 3;=QC@ !"#$ 3C@ 3>>3AU9@ =R9;U93@ >= >U9 U=4?>4C^ 3::3;3>Q?Y
• 0U9;9]=;9 S9 @= C=> VC=S SU3> :U6?4A35 >;3QW3 ?U9 W36 U3R9 ?Q]]9;9@ >= U9;
T=@6 @Q;4C^ >U9 :53A9W9C> =] >U=?9 ?>;3:?Y
• 0U9 +!M &>3C@3;@ -59:U3C> .=SC N;=>=A=5 K3C GHDL A355? ]=; >U9 Q?9 =] 3 _=TA3>
>= :Q?U 3 W9>35 ?>;3:i:Q554C^ T3; S4>U 3 U==V QC@9; >U9 959:U3C>Y• O4>U4C @36? 3]>9; U9; ?9A=C@ W9AU3C4A35 U=4?>F !"#$ S3? 9h3W4C9@ ]=; ;4^U>i
?4@9@ 9@9W3 =R9; >U9 :;9??Q;9 :=4C> =] U9; ?A3:Q53 7DGaGGaDIF< 3C@ =R9; >U9
T=C6 :;=W4C9CA9? =] T=>U U9; ]=;9 3C@ U4C@ 59^? 7DGaGgaDIY< 0U9?9 S9;9
3>>;4TQ>9@ >= U9; ;9A9C> =R9;C4^U> ;9AQWT9C> 9R9C>?Y
,;=W >U9 b;=?? 29A;=:?6 )9:=;> :;9:3;9@ T6 .; .c#^=?>4C=P
• 0U9;9 S9;9 3::;=h4W3>956 GI ]4;W ;34?9@ C=@Q59? 73T?A9??9?< 4C >U9 ?V4C 35=C^
>U9 ;4^U> ?4@9 =] >U9 T=@6F ];=W >U9 ?QTW3C@4TQ53; 3;93 73V3 5=S9; `3S< >= >U9
53>9;35 ]53CV 73V3 ;93; 59^Y<
•
&9R9;35 =] >U9?9 3T?A9??9? S9;9 ?9359@ A5=?9@ S4>U ?A3T W3>9;435F 3C@ A=C>34C9@A;93WiA=5=;9@ >U4AV :Q;Q59C> W3>9;435 73V3 :Q?Y<
• 0U9 3T?A9??9? 3::93;9@ >= T9 3??=A43>9@ S4>U >U9 4CA4@9C> 4C .9A9WT9; GHDI
SU9C !"#$ ;9XQ4;9@ 3??4?>3CA9 S4>U 3 W9AU3C4A35 U=4?> >= T9 54]>9@ >= U9; ]99>Y
•
d0U9 59?4=C? S9;9 T94C^ ]5Q?U9@ @3456 T6 [>U9 899:9; &>3]]F\ 3C@ S9;9 ?5=S56
;9?=5R4C^Ye
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
15/25
D’Agostino Complaint
15
,;=W >U9 "4?>=:3>U=5=^4A35 )9:=;> =] >U9 ?V4C 73T?A9??< :;9:3;9@ T6 >U9 B9>9;4C3;6
N3>U=5=^4?>P
7(4AU395 ( b3;C9;F .B(F 2=;>US9?> M==N3>UF (=C;=9 O#<
• 0U9;9 S3? d9h>9C?4R9 Q5A9;3>4=C =] >U9 9:4@9;W4? ?QT>9C@9@ T6 3 T;=3@ j=C9 =]
?Q::Q;3>4R9 4C]53WW3>4=C 3C@ C9A;=?4? >U3> 9h>9C@? @99: 4C>= >U9 QC@9;564C^
A=CC9A>4R9 >4??Q9?Ye• $C =>U9; S=;@?F >U9;9 S3? 3C 9h>9C?4R9 3;93 =] ?V4C >U3> S3? ?9R9;956 Q5A9;3>9@Y
'C@9; >U3> Q5A9;3>9@ ?V4C S3? 3 S4@9 3;93 =] 4C]9A>9@ 3C@ @93@ >4??Q9
AU3;3A>9;4j9@ T6 >U9 ]=;W3>4=C =] :Q?Y 0U4? 4C]53WW3>=;6 3C@ C9A;=>4A :Q?i
]=;W4C^ :;=A9?? U3@ 4CR3@9@ @99: @=SC 4C>= =>U9; T=@6 >4??Q9?Y
• d0U9 9:4@9;W4? 3@`3A9C> >= >U9 Q5A9;3>9@ ;9^4=C 4? U6:9;:53?>4A 3C@ 9@9W3>=Q?Ye
• $C =>U9; S=;@?F >U9 ?V4C C9h> >= 3C@ 3;=QC@ >U9 3;93? =] Q5A9;3>4=C S3? 9C53;^9@
3C@ ?S=559C S4>U ]5Q4@Y
$C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? EaIaDLF .; .c#^=?>4C= @9?A;4T9@ >U9?9 59?4=C? 3? d?4W:59 ?V4C
3T?A9??9?Ye $C >U9 EaDmaDL &93>>59 04W9? #;>4A59i$C>9;R49SF .; .c#^=?>4C= @4?W4??9@ >U9
?V4C 59?4=C? 3? >U9 9XQ4R359C> =] d:4W:59?Fe 3C@ A=C>;3;6 >= >U9 "4?>=:3>U=5=^4A35
29A;=:?6 ]4C@4C^?F ?34@ ?U9 S3? ?V9:>4A35 >U96 S9;9 >U9 3A>Q35 ?=Q;A9 =] !"#$c? T5==@
4C]9A>4=C?Y
!+2!-)2&P
• 29^54^9CA9 4C >U9 :;3A>4A9 =] R9>9;4C3;6 W9@4A4C9
• &QT?>3C@3;@ A3;9
• !3;959?? @4?;9^3;@ ]=; U935>UF S95]3;9F =; ?3]9>6
• $C3@9XQ3>9 ;9A=;@ V99:4C^
8C=S4C^ 9h3A>56 U=S >U96 3A>Q3556 ^=> >U9 54]>4C^ ?>;3:? 4C :53A9 QC@9; 3C@ 3;=QC@ !"#$FS=Q5@ :;=T3T56 9h:534C U=S ?U9 ^=> >U9 ;4^U>i?4@9@ 59?4=C? >U3> S9;9 3>>;4TQ>9@ 3>
C9A;=:?6 >= >U9 W9AU3C4A35 U=4?> :;=A9@Q;9Y
• "93R6 9XQ4:W9C> S3? =TR4=Q?56 4CR=5R9@Y
• 0U9 "4?>=:3>U=5=^4A35 ;9?Q5>? =] ?9R9;9 C9A;=>4A >4??Q9 @3W3^9 9h>9C@4C^ d@99:
4C>= >U9 QC@9;564C^ A=CC9A>4R9 >4??Q9?e 3;9 A=W:3>4T59 S4>U A=C?4@9;3T59
:U6?4A35 7T5QC> ]=;A9< >;3QW3 3C@ 4C`Q;6 >= U9; ;4^U> ?4@9Y
• B9>9;4C3;6 &>3]] 74CA5Q@4C^ .; .c#^=?>4C= =C DGaDgaDI< S9;9 :;9?9C> @Q;4C^ T=>U
W9AU3C4A35 U=4?>?F 3C@ W3@9 9C>;49? 4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@?F TQ> >U9;9 4? C=
W9C>4=C =] SU3> >6:9 =] 9XQ4:W9C> S3? Q?9@ =; U=S 4> S3? Q?9@ >= :Q> >U9
54]>4C^ ?>3:? 4C :53A9Y• -?:9A43556 U3R4C^ =T?9;R9@ >U9 W9AU3C4A35 U=4?> :;=A9@Q;9 U9;?95]F 3C@ >U9
:U6?4A35 >;3QW3 4CR=5R9@ S4>U 4>F .; .c#^=?>4C= ?U=Q5@ U3R9 3C>4A4:3>9@ >U9
4W:9C@4C^ >4??Q9 @3W3^9 3C@ W3@9 3 N53C >= ;9AU9AV 3C@ W=C4>=; A5=?956 ]=;
?4^C? =] 4C`Q;6 J C94>U9; S3? @=C9Y
+C DaEaDL >U9 899:9; &>3]] C=>9@ ,#" 3T?A9?? =C !"#$c? ;4^U> ?U=Q5@9;F SU4AU d;Q:>Q;9@
QC@9; 54^U> :;9??Q;9Ye
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
16/25
D’Agostino Complaint
16
.; .c#^=?>4C= @4@ C=> 9h3W4C9 !"#$ QC>45 G @36? 53>9; =C DaIaDLY #> >U3> >4W9 ?U9
C=>9@ >U9;9 S9;9 .";"-'( 3T?A9??9? 4C >U9 ?V4C =R9; >U9 ;4^U> ?U=Q5@9; 3C@ ]53CV 3;93?F
3C@ W=?> U3@ 35;93@6 ;Q:>Q;9@ 3C@ C=S d3::93;9@ >= T9 U9354C^ C=;W3556Ye
0U9?9 /U3> 9R9C>Q3556 A3Q?9@ ?9:?4? 3C@ 59@ >= U9; @93>UY
#C@ 3^34CF C= @=AQW9C>3>4=C 3C6SU9;9 >U3> >U9 899:9;? 3A>Q3556 +, 3C6 =] >U9
>;93>W9C>? 3? :;9?A;4T9@ T6 >U9 B9>9;4C3;6 &>3]]Y
#AA=;@4C^ >= >U9 (QC4A4:35 !=QC?95=;c? +]]4A9 EaGEaDL ;9?:=C?9 >= =Q; )9A=;@? )9XQ9?>
]=; :=>9C>43556 W4??4C^ (9@4A35 )9A=;@?F d4] >U9;9 4? C= W9@4A35 9C>;6F ?3W:59 =;
>;93>W9C> 54?>9@ ]=; 3 :3;>4AQ53; @36F >U9C C=>U4C^ W9@4A35 S3? @=C9 >U3> @36 3C@ >U9
3C4W35 S3? C=;W35Ye
&3W:59? =] ?959A> :3^9? ];=W >U9 (9@4A35 3C@ 899:9; )9A=;@? ];=W >U9 ONMF 3C@
?3W:59? =] :3^9? ];=W >U9 (9@4A35 3C@ 899:9; )9A=;@? ];=W >U9 +!MF 3;9 :;=R4@9@ 3?
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
17/25
D’Agostino Complaint
17
#>>3AU9@ &Q::=;>4C^ .=AQW9C>?Y _6 A=W:3;4C^ >U9 )9A=;@? ];=W >U9 >S= j==?F 4> 4?
:3>9C>56 =TR4=Q? >U3> .; .c#^=?>4C= C=> =C56 W34C>34C? ?QT?>3C@3;@ ;9A=;@?F TQ> 35?=
:;=R4@9? ?QT?>3C@3;@ A3;9Y
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
18/25
D’Agostino Complaint
18
"Y 2-!)+N&* )-&'/0&
&'NN+)0$2b .+!'(-20& #00#!"-.P
• GEY+!M (9@4A35 )9A=;@? DE(36DI J GE,9TDL
• GgY+!M 899:9; )9A=;@? DE(36DI J D,9TDL
• DIY29A;=:?6 )9:=;>F (9@4A35 )9A=;@? DaEHaDL
•
DDY+!M N;9?? )9593?9 =C 29A;=:?6 GaGHaDL• DGY&93>>59 04W9? #;>4A59i$C>9;R49S .) .c#^=?>4C= EaDmaDL
,#!0&P
#AA=;@4C^ >= >U9 29A;=:?6 )9:=;> ];=W >U9 "4?>=iN3>U=5=^4?>F !"#$ @49@ ];=W 3
A=WT4C3>4=C =] 9W3A43>4=C S4>U 3 ?9R9;9 3>;=:U6 =] T=@6 ]3>F 3C@ ?9:?4?Y 0U9 ?9:>4A
:;=A9?? 54V956 =;4^4C3>9@ ];=W >U9 3T?A9??9? 4C U9; ?V4CF 3C@ >U9;9 S3? W4A;=?A=:4A
9R4@9CA9 =] 9C@=>=h4A ?U=AV U3R4C^ =AAQ;;9@Y
&9:?4? 4? 3 ?9;4=Q? W9@4A35 A=C@4>4=C >U3> =AAQ;? SU9C 3C 4C]9A>4C^ 3^9C> ?QAU 3?
T3A>9;43 ^9>? 4C>= >U9 T5==@?>;93WY 0U9 4C]9A>4=C 3A>4R3>9? >U9 9C>4;9 4WWQC9 ?6?>9WF
SU4AU >U9C ?9>? =]] 3 AU34C ;93A>4=C =] 9R9C>? >U3> A3C 593@ >= QCA=C>;=559@
4C]53WW3>4=C 4C >U9 T=@6Y 0U9 SU=59iT=@6 ;9?:=C?9 >= >U4? 4C]9A>4=C :;=@QA9? AU3C^9?
4C >9W:9;3>Q;9F T5==@ :;9??Q;9F U93;> ;3>9F SU4>9 T5==@ A955 A=QC>F 3C@ T;93>U4C^Y
&9R9;9 ]=;W? =] ?9:?4? A3Q?9 ?9:>4A ?U=AVF SU4AU XQ4AV56 593@? >= >U9 ]345Q;9 =] WQ5>4:59
=;^3C? 3C@ @93>UY
#@4:=?9 >4??Q9F =; ]3>F 4? 3C 3C3>=W4A35 >9;W ]=; 5==?9 A=CC9A>4R9 >4??Q9 A=W:=?9@ =]
3@4:=A6>9?Y $>? W34C ;=59 4? >= ?>=;9 9C9;^6 4C >U9 ]=;W =] ]3>Y 0U9 W4A;=?A=:4A 3C356?4?
=] >U9 3@4:=?9 >4??Q9 ?3W:59? ;9R9359@ >U3> 3@4:=?9 ?>=;9? S9;9 ?9R9;956 3>;=:U4AF =;
S3?>9@ 3S36F 593@4C^ >= >U9 ?>3>9 =] 9W3A43>4=CY
!+2!-)2&P
• !=C@QA> 54V956 >= @9A94R9 >U9 :QT54A
• 0U9 Q?9 =] ]35?9 =; @9A9:>4R9 ?>3>9W9C> 4C 3C6 @=AQW9C> A=CC9A>9@ S4>U >U9
:;3A>4A9 =] R9>9;4C3;6 W9@4A4C9
• 29^54^9CA9 4C >U9 :;3A>4A9 =] R9>9;4C3;6 W9@4A4C9
• &QT?>3C@3;@ A3;9
#]>9; !"#$ S3? ]=QC@ @93@ =C DaEHaDLF .; .c#^=?>4C= W3@9 >U9 ]=55=S4C^ 9C>;6 4C >U9
(9@4A35 )9A=;@?P d0U9;9 S9;9 C= :;9R4=Q? ?4^C? =] 455C9??Ye &U9 35?= S;=>9 4C >U9 b;=??
29A;=:?6 )9:=;> d0U9 59?4=C? [3T?A9??9?\ S9;9 T94C^ ]5Q?U9@ @3456 T6 899:9;? 3C@ S9;9?5=S56 ;9?=5R4C^Ye 294>U9; S3? >;Q9Y
$C >U9 +!M N;9?? )9593?9 GaGHaDL ;9^3;@4C^ >U9 29A;=:?6 ;9?Q5>?F .; .c#^=?>4C= 4?
XQ=>9@ 3? ?364C^ d.9?:4>9 >U9 3>>9C>4R9 A3;9 :;=R4@9@F 3C4W35? 3;9 R9;6 ?V4559@ 3>
W3?V4C^ ?6W:>=W?Y $>c? 4CC3>9Ye
$> 4? >;Q9 >U3> 3C4W35? A3C W3?V ?6W:>=W?Y _Q> !"#$c? ?6W:>=W? S9;9 2+0 U4@@9CP
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
19/25
D’Agostino Complaint
19
• &U9 @49@ =] 9W3A43>4=C 7S94^U> 5=??< SU4AU S3? A593;56 @=AQW9C>9@ 4C U9;
&:9A4W9C )9:=;> =R9; >U9 lYI W=C>U? ?U9 S3? 3> >U9 +!MF 3C@ SU4AU S3? A593;56
3::3;9C> 4C >U9 =C9 _=@6 !=C@4>4=C &A=;4C^ >U3> S3? @=C9 DGaDIaDIF 3C@ SU4AU
S=Q5@ U3R9 T99C 9R9C W=;9 3::3;9C> U3@ >U9;9 T99C 3C6 V4C@ =] W9@4A35 N53C
>= @43^C=?9F W=C4>=;F 3C@ 3@@;9?? >U9 :;=T59WY
• &U9 35?= @49@ =] ?9:>4A9W43 ];=W U9; 3::;=h4W3>956 GI 7o< 9]]9A>4R956 QC>;93>9@
:Q?i]4559@F @99:56 :9C9>;3>4C^ 3T?A9??9? 7:9; >U9 "4?>=iN3>U=5=^4?>< SU4AU S9;9
A593;56 R4?4T59 355 35=C^ U9; ;4^U> ?4@9Y
$C U9; 4C>9;R49S ]=; 0U9 &93>>59 04W9? #;>4A59 =C EaDmaDLF .; .c#^=?>4C= 4? XQ=>9@ 3?
?364C^ d'C]=;>QC3>956F >U96 A3Cc> >955 Q? 4] >U96 @=Cc> ]995 S955Y O9 U3R9 >= ^= =C SU3>
S9 A3C @9>9A>Ye 0;Q9F TQ> .; .c#^=?>4C= @4@ C=> @9>9A> 3C6>U4C^ T9A3Q?9 ?U9 @4@ C=>
(,,1 F ?U9 @4@ C=> W3V9 3 >('# >= 5==VF ?U9 @4@ C=> /,#%$,- F ?U9 @4@ C=> '+;,&'$" ]=;
!"#$c? U935>U 4C 3C6 S36Y
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
20/25
D’Agostino Complaint
20
$Y .-20#/ #2+(#/$-&
&'NN+)0$2b .+!'(-"0& #00#!"-.P
• GEY+!M (9@4A35 )9A=;@? DE(36DI J GE,9TDL
• GgY+!M 899:9; )9A=;@? DE(36DI J D,9TDL
• DIY29A;=:?6 )9:=;>F (9@4A35 )9A=;@? DaEHaDL
•
DmY-59 #4@ .9C>4>4=C #;>4A59• GHY!=569; $C?>4>Q>9 .9C>4>4=C !3:>4R4>6 .4?=;@9;?
•
GDY)9:=;> =C &VQ55a099>UF (9@4A35 )9A=;@? EaGaDL
• GGY+!M N;9?? )9593?9 =C &VQ55i099>U EaDgaDL
• GIY/4CV >= 8+!+ 0B 29S? $C>9;R49S .; .c#^=?>4C= ;9 099>U EaDgaDL
• DGY&93>>59 04W9? #;>4A59i$C>9;R49S .; .c#^=?>4C= EaDmaDL
,#!0&P
!"#$c? @9C>35 3C=W3549? 3;9 =] :3;>4AQ53; 4C>9;9?> >= 5==V 3> 4C @9>345F T9A3Q?9 T3?9@ =C
+!M N;9?? )9593?9? 3C@ >U9 EaGaDL (9@4A35 )9A=;@?F .; .c#^=?>4C= U3? A=CA5Q@9@ >U3>
U9; @93>U S3? @4;9A>56 3C@ 9C>4;956 A3Q?9@ T6 U9; $""$?Y
# ;=Q>4C9 ]9A35 9h3W4C3>4=C S3? :9;]=;W9@ =C DGaDaDIF 3C@ >U9 ?3W:59 S3? ]=QC@ >= T9
3TC=;W3556 ?S99>i?W9554C^ S4>U >U9 U36 ?>9W? ?>455 R9;6 53;^9 3C@ C=> AU=::9@ Q:Y
0U4? 4? 4W:=;>3C> T9A3Q?9 =C >U9 54?> =] A3Q?9? ]=; 3TC=;W35 ]9A9? 3C@ 4CA=W:59>9
@4^9?>4=C =] U36F 4? >U9 :;9?9CA9 =] @9C>35 :;=T59W?Y
0S= @36? 53>9; =C DGaEaDIF B9>9;4C3;6 &>3]] A3W9 >= @4?AQ?? !"#$c? d3>6:4A35 ?>==5
3::93;3CA9e S4>U >U9 899:9; &>3]]F 3C@ ("'-#"+ :-,/ $?"/ >U3> !"#$ U3@ 3C 3TC=;W35
>==>UY ,=55=S4C^ 3C =::=;>QC4?>4A 9h3W4C3>4=C =] !"#$c? >99>UF 3 @9>3459@ 9C>;6 S3?
W3@9 4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@?F ?:9A4]4A3556 3T=Q> U9; Q::9; ;4^U> 3;A3@9P
•
0U9 899:9; &>3]] W9C>4=C9@ >U3> !"#$ U3@ 3C 3TC=;W35 ;4^U> Q::9; W=53; >==>UY• #@@4>4=C3556F >U4? >==>U 3TC=;W354>6 S3? VC=SC >= >U9 ONM 899:9; &>3]] SU=
?34@ 4> U3@ T99C >U3> S36 d]=; GH 693;?Ye
• B4?Q35 4C?:9A>4=C A=C]4;W9@ >U9 ;4^U> Q::9; W=53; S3? 3TC=;W35 J 4> S3? :53A9@
W=;9 ;=?>;3556 7]=;S3;@< 4C >U9 W=Q>U >U3C >U9 59]> Q::9; W=53;F 3C@ 4> @9R43>9@
W9@43556 7>=S3;@ >U9 A9C>9; =] >U9 W=Q>U< 3C@ U3@ 3 AQ;R3>Q;9Y
• 0U9 5=S9; ;4^U> >99>U S9;9 C=> R4?4T59 @Q;4C^ >U4? 4C?:9A>4=CF TQ> 4> S3?
?Q?:9A>9@ >U3> >U9 =AA5Q?35 ?Q;]3A9? @4@ C=> W3>AU >U=?9 =] >U9 Q::9; W=53;
>==>UY
• 0U9 >99>U =C >U9 59]> ?4@9 3::93;9@ C=;W35Y
•
O4>U W=53; 3>>;4>4=C 74Y9Y >U9 C=;W35 A6A59 =] >==>U 9;Q:>4=CaQ?9aS93;a5=?? >U3>4? ]=QC@ 4C 959:U3C>?< 4> 4? 54V956 >U3> 355 >99>U 4C >U9 Q::9; ;4^U> 3;A3@9 U3R9 T99C
3TC=;W35 >U;=Q^U=Q> U9; 54]9F 3C@ >U3> >U4? S455 A=C>4CQ9 >= =AAQ; S4>U
?QT?9XQ9C> >==>U 9;Q:>4=C?Y
•
2= ]Q;>U9; W=C4>=;4C^ =] >U9 >99>U 4? C99@9@ QC59?? &>3]] C=>4A9? 3 C9S :;=T59WY
+C9 S99V 53>9;F 3 ;9:93> ]9A35 ?3W:59 @4@ C=> U3R9 >U9 ?3W9 3TC=;W354>49? =] ?S99>i
?W9554C^ =; 53;^9 ?>9W?Y $C ]3A>F 355 :;4=; 3C@ 355 ?QT?9XQ9C> A=WW9C>? W3@9 3T=Q> ]9A35
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
21/25
D’Agostino Complaint
21
W3>9;435 3C@ ]9A35 >9?>? 4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? 7Dl 4C >=>35F< C=>9 >U3> U9; ]9A9? S3?
A=C?4?>9C>56 dC=;W35Fe 9R9C 3> >U9 >4W9 =] U9; @93>UY
+C EaGaDL 3 @9>3459@ 9C>;6 S3? W3@9 4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? ;9^3;@4C^ !"#$c? ?VQ55 3C@
>99>U ]=55=S4C^ :;=A9??4C^ 3> >U9 (Q?9QW =] +?>9=5=^6P
•
_=>U Q::9; ;4^U> 3C@ 59]> W=53;? 3;9 ?9R9;956 @9]=;W9@ 3C@ >S4?>9@ S4>U 54>>59 =;C= =AA5Q?35 ?Q;]3A9Y
•
0U9 5=S9; ;4^U> W=53; 4? 4W:3A>9@ A3Q?4C^ W3;V9@ @9]=;W3>4=C =] >U9 4CA=W4C^
W=53; 3? 4> S3? :;=^;9??4C^ ]=;S3;@Y
• 0U9 5=S9; 59]> W=53; 4? ^;=??56 C=;W35Y
• 0U9;9 4? ?=W9 T=C9 AU3C^9 3C@ @9]=;W3>4=C 35=C^ >U9 ;4^U> W3C@4T59F SU4AU
A=Q5@ T9 @Q9 >= AU;=C4A >==>U ;==> 4C]9A>4=C ];=W W=53; 4W:3A>4=C ,- ];=W
:;9??Q;9 ];=W >U9 4W:3A>9@ >==>UY
#C #@@9C@QW =C EaIaDL ;953>9? 3 :U=C9 A355 S4>U .; K4W +=?>9;UQ4? =] >U9 !=569;
$C?>4>Q>9 73 A9C>9; ]=; >U9 ?>Q@6 =] =;35 @4?93?9 3C@ CQ>;4>4=C 4C 9h=>4A 3C4W35?
S4?>9@Y
• 0U9 5=S9; ;4^U> W=53; 4? 4W:3A>9@ A3Q?4C^ @9]=;W4>6 =] >U9 :;=^;9??4C^ W=53;
T9U4C@Y
• "9 U3? ?99C @9]=;W4>49? 54V9 >U9?9 4C ?9R9;35 959:U3C>?F 9?:9A43556 >U=?9 >U3>
S9;9 S45@ T=;C 3C@ T;=Q^U> >= '& j==? 4C >U9 DmkHc?Y 0U9?9 3C4W35? 3;9 C=S
3::;=3AU4C^ gHigI 693;? =] 3^9 3C@ ?U=S4C^ ?4^C4]4A3C> @9C>35 3TC=;W354>49?Y
0U4? @4?93?9 54V956 U3? 3 ^9C9>4A A=W:=C9C>F SU4AU W36 T9 A=C]=QC@9@ T6 :==;
CQ>;4>4=C 93;56 4C >U94; 54]9 =] A3:>4R4>6Y $> 3::93;? >U3> =CA9 >U9 @3W3^9 U3? T99C
@=C9F >U9 >99>U :;=^;9??4R956 S=;?9C S4>U 3^9 3C@ S4>U 93AU C9S ?9> =] W=53;?Y
0U9 :;=A9?? AQ5W4C3>9? 4C 3C 4C3T454>6 >= W3?>4A3>9 ]==@ C=;W3556Y
•
$W:3A>9@ >99>U 3;9 =]>9C AU;=C4A3556 4C]9A>9@Y• $C >U4? A3?9F >U9;9 S3? C= W9@4A35 =; ?Q;^4A35 >;93>W9C> >= A=;;9A> >U9 A=C@4>4=CY
+C 0U9 !=569; $C?>4>Q>9 S9T?4>9 >U9;9 4? 3C 3;>4A59 =C !3:>4R4>6 .4?=;@9;? 4C -59:U3C>? T6
.; +=?>9;UQ4?Y d+C9 =] >U9 W=?> A=WW=C @9C>35 @4?=;@9;? =] 959:U3C>? 54R4C^ 4C
A3:>4R4>6 4? 4W:3A>9@ =; W35i:=?4>4=C9@ W=53; >99>UYe 0U9?9 A54C4A35 :;=T59W? d3;9
9h3A9;T3>9@ SU9C A=WT4C9@ S4>U 959W9C>? C=> AQ?>=W3;456 ]=QC@ 4C >U9 959:U3C>c?
C3>Q;35 9CR4;=CW9C>F ?QAU 3? ?>995 =; A=CA;9>9 9CA5=?Q;9? 3C@F ];=W 3 @49>3;6
:9;?:9A>4R9F 3 53AV =] 3T;3?4R4>6Ye
0U9;9 4? 35?= 3 ?9A>4=C >U3> @9>345? >U9 A54C4A35 ?4^C? =] W=53; W35=AA5Q?4=C 7W35i:=?4>4=C4C^ =; 4W:3A>4=CY< 0U9 ]4;?> 3C@ W=?> A=WW=C ?4^C =] 3 ]QCA>4=C3556 ?4^C4]4A3C>
W=53; W35=AA5Q?4=CF 3?4@9 ];=W >U9 R4?Q3556 =TR4=Q? W35i:=?4>4=C =] >U9 >99>UF 4? 3
AU3C^9 4C >U9 >9h>Q;9 3C@ A=3;?9C9?? =] >U9 3C4W35c? ]9A35 W3?? Q?Q3556 3??=A43>9@ S4>U
S94^U> 5=??Y .; +=?>9;UQ4? ?>3>9? d# AU3C^9 4C ]9A35 A=C?4?>9CA6 4? 3 @4;9A> 3C@ 3T?=5Q>9
4C@4A3>4=C =] 3 AU3C^9 4C >U9 W3?>4A3>=;6 9]]4A49CA6 =] >U9 3C4W35Ye
.; .c#^=?>4C= 35?= 3@@? 3C #??9??W9C>aN53C 4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@?P
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
22/25
D’Agostino Complaint
22
• $> 4? W=?> 54V956 >U3> !"#$ U3@ 3 A=C^9C4>35 3TC=;W354>6 4C U9; @9C>4>4=C >U3>
:;=^;9??4R956 S=;?9C9@ >U;=Q^U=Q> U9; 54]9Y
• 0U9 3TC=;W35 =AA5Q?35 ?Q;]3A9? =] U9; W=53;? :;9R9C>9@ U9; ];=W W3?>4A3>4C^
U9; ]==@ :;=:9;56F SU4AU 4C >Q;C 59@ >= >U9 4C3T454>6 >= 9h>;3A> A35=;4A A=C>9C>Y
• _=C6 AU3C^9? 4C >U9 ;4^U> W3C@4T59 ?Q^^9?> >U9 :=??4T454>6 =] 3 AU;=C4A >==>U ;==>
3T?A9??Y• 0U4? S=Q5@ T9 3 W=;9 54V956 ?=Q;A9 =] >U9 T3A>9;435 ?9:>4A9W43 C=>9@ =C
U4?>=:3>U=5=^6 >U3C >U9 d?4W:59 ?V4C 3T?A9??9?e C=>9@ 3> C9A;=:?6Y
• )3@4=^;3:U4A 4W3^4C^ =] 3C 959:U3C>c? >99>U 4? C=> :=??4T59 @Q9 >= >U9 ?4j9 3C@
@9C?4>6 =] >U9 ?VQ55Y
• 0U9 +!M @=9? U3R9 3 :5QWT9;c? A3W9;3 ?:9A4]4A3556 :Q;AU3?9@ >= 355=S 3
>U=;=Q^U 4C?:9A>4=C =] >U9 >99>UF TQ> >U96 C9R9; Q?9@ 4> =C !"#$Y
!+2!-)2&P
• 29^54^9CA9 4C >U9 :;3A>4A9 =] R9>9;4C3;6 W9@4A4C9
• &QT?>3C@3;@ A3;9
• !3;959?? @4?;9^3;@ ]=; U935>UF S95]3;9F =; ?3]9>6
• 0U9 Q?9 =] ]35?9 =; @9A9:>4R9 ?>3>9W9C>? 4C 3C6 @=AQW9C> A=CC9A>9@ S4>U >U9
:;3A>4A9 =] R9>9;4C3;6 W9@4A4C9
• !=C@QA> 54V956 >= @9A94R9 >U9 :QT54A
• $C3@9XQ3>9 ;9A=;@ V99:4C^
+C EaDgaDLF >U9 +!M :Q> =Q> 3 N;9?? )9593?9 SU9;9 >U96 ?>3>9@ !"#$ U3@ d?9R9;9 >==>U
3TC=;W354>49? >U3> S9;9 C=> @9>9A>3T59 :;4=; >= U9; @93>UFe >U9C S9C> =C >= @9?A;4T9
U9; Q::9; W=53;?Y #? =Q>54C9@ 3T=R9F >U4? S3? C=> >U9 A3?9 J 899:9; &>3]] S9;9 S955
3S3;9 =] U9; >==>U 3TC=;W354>49? ]=; dGH 693;?eF 3C@ B9>9;4C3;6 &>3]] @=AQW9C>9@ >U9W
4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? =C DGaEaDIY
#5?= =C EaDgaDLF .; .c#^=?>4C= S3? 4C>9;R49S9@ =C 8+!+ 0B 29S? 3C@ ?>3>9@P dOU9C
?U9 3;;4R9@ U9;9 3> >U9 M== ];=W &93>>59F S9 >U=Q^U> S=SF ?U9c? ^=> ?=W9 ]QCV6 5==V4C^
>99>UY 'WY O9 S9;9 3A>Q3556 U=:9]Q5 >U3> 3? >U=?9 >99>U S=Q5@ ?U9@ =Q> >U3> >U9 =C9?
T9U4C@ 4> S=Q5@ T9 C=;W35F 3C@ :;=T59W ?=5R9@Y 'C]=;>QC3>956 >U3> S3? C=> >U9 A3?9Ye
_Q> 3^34CF >U4? 4? A=W:59>956 A=C>;3;6 >= SU3> S3? S;4>>9C 4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? =C
DGaEaDIF SU4AU 3@@4>4=C3556 35?= C=>9? d2= ]Q;>U9; W=C4>=;4C^ =] >99>U C99@9@ QC59??
?>3]] C=>4A9? 3 C9S :;=T59WYe
$C >U3> ?3W9 0B 4C>9;R49SF .) .c#^=?>4C= ?>3>9@ d?=W9 =] >U9?9 959:U3C>? >U3> S9;9=;:U3C9@ 4C >U9 S45@ 4C >U9 pkHc? 3;9 ?>3;>4C^ >= U3R9 3 5=> =] >==>U :;=T59W?Ye &U9
4W:549@ >U3> !"#$c? >99>U S9;9 3 ;9?Q5> =] T94C^ d=;:U3C9@ 4C >U9 S45@e 3C@ C=> >U9
;9?Q5> U9; 54]9i>4W9 =] j== A3:>4R4>6 A=C]=QC@9@ T6 :==; CQ>;4>4=C 3? S3? 3??9;>9@ T6 .;
+=?>9;UQ4? C=> =C56 4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? EaGaDLF TQ> 35?= 4C U4? 3;>4A59 =C .9C>35
!3:>4R4>6 .4?=;@9;? ];=W U4? S9T ?4>9Y
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
23/25
D’Agostino Complaint
23
$C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? EaGaDLF .; .c#^=?>4C= 35?= @4?>=;>9@ .; +=?>9;UQ4?c? A=WW9C>?
T6 ?>3>4C^ !"#$c? A=C@4>4=C S3? dA=C^9C4>35e 4Y9Y ?U9 S3? T=;C S4>U 4> 3C@ >U9;9]=;9
C=>U4C^ A=Q5@ U3R9 T99C @=C9 >= :;9R9C> U9; :;=T59W?Y .; +=?>9;UQ4? 3A>Q3556 ?34@ >U9
@4?93?9 54V956 U3? 3 d^9C9>4A A=W:=C9C>e 7SU4AU 4? C=> >U9 ?3W9 3? dA=C^9C4>35e< 3C@ 4?
3 dA3:>4R4>6 @4?=;@9;e ];=W ?:9C@4C^ 3 54]9>4W9 4C 3 j==Y
.) .c#^=?>4C= 3@@4>4=C3556 ?>3>9@ >U3> !"#$c? >99>U d:;=^;9??4R956 S=;?9C9@ >U;=Q^U
=Q> U9; 54]9Ye (36T9F TQ> >U96 =C56 T9A3W9 ?=W9>U4C^ >= >35V 3T=Q> 3]>9; U9; @93>U
QC@9; >U9 A3;9 =] .; .c#^=?>4C=Y $C >U9 &93>>59 04W9? #;>4A59i$C>9;R49S ];=W EaDmaDLF
b4^4 #5543C4A ];=W >U9 ONM 4? XQ=>9@ 3? ?364C^ >U3> @Q;4C^ !"#$c? W=;9 >U3C E @9A3@9? 4C
&93>>59F !"#$ C9R9; U3@ :;=T59W? AU9S4C^ =; W34C>34C4C^ U9; T=@6 S94^U>Y d!"#$ U3@
=@@56 ?U3:9@ >99>UF TQ> ?U9 @4@Cc> U3R9 3C6 3TC=;W354>49? >U3> ;=?9 >= >U9 59R95 =] 3
W9@4A35 A=CA9;C >U3> ;9XQ4;9@ R9>9;4C3;6 4C>9;R9C>4=C =; @4?AQ??4=CYe
#5?= 4C >U9 &93>>59 04W9? #;>4A59i$C>9;R49S ];=W EaDmaDL .; .c#^=?>4C= 4? XQ=>9@ 3?
?364C^ d$ >U4CV U9; >99>U S9;9 ;93556 T3@ ]=; :9;4=@ =] >4W9 3C@ >U3> ?U9 S3?Cc> 3T59 >=
AU9S U9; ]==@ R9;6 S955F ?= ?U9 S3?Cc> 9h>;3A>4C^ WQAU A35=;4A A=C>9C> ];=W >U9 ]==@Ye
$] ?U9 S3? :;9R9C>9@ ];=W W3?>4A3>4C^ U9; ]==@ :;=:9;56 3C@ >U9;9]=;9 A=Q5@ C=> 9h>;3A>
A35=;4A A=C>9C>F >U9C SU6 @4@ >U9 ]9A9? A=W9 =Q> 355 AU=::9@ Q: 54V9 C=;W35 J SU9;9
S3? >U3> T94C^ @=C9 4] C=> 4C >U9 W=Q>U T6 >U9 >99>Uq
#C@ 3? .; +=?>9;UQ4? 4C U4? .9C>35 !3:>4R4>6 .4?=;@9;? 3;>4A59 @9>345?F :;=^;9??4R9
W3?>4A3>=;6 W35]QCA>4=C 4? ]34;56 93?6 >= W=C4>=; T6 ;=Q>4C9 =T?9;R3>4=C 3C@ R4?Q35
3C356?4? =] >U9 4C@4R4@Q35c? ]9A35 W3>9;435Y .=4C^ >U4? 4? 3C 9??9C>435 A=W:=C9C> >=
W=C4>=;4C^ >U9 W3?>4A3>=;6 9]]4A49CA6 =] 3C 959:U3C>c? @9C>4>4=CF 9?:9A43556 3? >U96 3^9Y
#C@ 69> >U9;9 4? C= 9R4@9CA9 4C >U9 )9A=;@? >U3> >U4? S3? 9R9; @=C9 3> >U9 +!MY
$C !"#$c? A3?9F ?U9 S3? :;=^;9??4R956 5=?4C^ S94^U>F TQ> 3AA=;@4C^ >= >U9 (9@4A35
)9A=;@?F U9; ]9A35 W3??F >9h>Q;9F 3C@ A=3;?9C9?? A=C?4?>9C>56 ;9W34C9@ C=;W35Y 0U4?
?U=Q5@ U3R9 59@ .; .c#^=?>4C= >= 5==V 95?9SU9;9 73C6SU9;9< ]=; U9; A=C?4@9;3T59
@9>9;4=;3>4=C 3C@ S94^U> 5=?? J U3@ ?U9 9R9C C=>4A9@ >U3> !"#$ S3? S3?>4C^ 3S36Y &U9
35?= ?U=Q5@ U3R9 A=C?4@9;9@ >U9 =TR4=Q? :=>9C>435 ]=; @9C>35 :;=T59W?F 3C@ 3A>Q3556
5==V9@ 4C U9; W=Q>U S4>U >U9 d:5QWT9;c?e A3W9;3Y
.; +=?>9;UQ4? A=CA5Q@9@ C=>U4C^ A=Q5@ U3R9 T99C @=C9 /"+%&'(() ,- .99>U U3R9 T99C W34C>34C9@ 3> 3 U935>U6 S94^U> T6
:;=R4@4C^ d:;=A9??9@e ]99@ ?>Q]]? 3C@ ?=]> ]==@? >U3> 355=S >U9W >= ^9> >U9 CQ>;4>4=C
>U96 C99@ 3C@ ?>455 U3R9 C=;W35 ^Q> ]5=;3 3C@ W=>454>6Y\
.; .c#^=?>4C= 59@ >U9 :QT54A >= T9549R9P
• &U9 S3? S955 4C]=;W9@ 3T=Q> !"#$c? >99>UY
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
24/25
D’Agostino Complaint
24
• !"#$c? @9C>35 3C=W3549? S9;9 A=C^9C4>35 7Z :;9?9C> 3> T4;>UY<
• !"#$ S3? d=;:U3C9@e 4C >U9 S45@ 3C@ >U9;9]=;9 C99@9@ 3 U=W9Y &U9 S3? C=>
=;:U3C9@ 7SU4AU W93C? U9; :3;9C>? S9;9 @93@F< ?U9 S3? $'1"# ];=W U9; W=>U9;
>= T9 ?=5@ 4C>= >U9 j== >;3@9 3> >U9 3^9 =] D 693; i S955 T9]=;9 ?U9 S3? 9R9C
S93C9@ 7959:U3C>? 3;9 W45Vi@9:9C@9C> QC>45 Eig 693;? =] 3^9Y<
•
!"#$ S3? C=> 3T59 >= AU9S U9; ]==@ >= 9h>;3A> A35=;4A A=C>9C>Y• 2=>U4C^ A=Q5@ T9 @=C9 T9A3Q?9 3C 959:U3C>c? ?VQ55 A3CC=> T9 hi;369@Y
•
2=>U4C^ A=Q5@ T9 @=C9 T9A3Q?9 >U9;9 S3? C= /"+%&'( ,- .
8/18/2019 Summary Medical Facts Concerns Chai
25/25
25
KY !+2!/'&$+2
.; .c#^=?>4C= C9R9; 9h:;9??9@ 3C6 A=CA9;C 7=; 9R9C 3::93;9@ >= C=>4A9< !"#$c?
?4^C4]4A3C> S94^U> 5=?? 3C@ 9W3A43>4=C SU4AU S3? 54?>9@ 4C >U9 C9A;=:?6 3? =C9 A3Q?9 =]
@93>UF 4C 3@@4>4=C >= ?9:?4?Y &U9 @4@ 3T?=5Q>956 #,$?%#! +":%#%$%;" >= 3@@;9?? >U9 ]3A>
>U3> !"#$ S3? S3?>4C^ 3S36Y $] ?U9 VC9S 3T=Q> U9; d]QCV6 5==V4C^ >99>Ue SU9C !"#$]4;?> 3;;4R9@ 4C +V53U=W3 3? ?U9 A534W?F >U9C SU6 S3? >U9;9 C=>U4C^ 4C >U9 (9@4A35
)9A=;@F 3C@ SU6 S3? AU9AV4C^ >U=?9 d]QCV6 5==V4C^ >99>Ue S4>U >U9 ?:9A435 d:5QWT9;c?e
A3W9;3 7?:9A4]4A3556 :Q;AU3?9@ ]=; >U3> :Q;:=?9< C=> 3> >U9 >=: =] U9; 54?> ]=; ]Q;>U9;
4CR9?>4^3>4=C >= ;Q59 >U9W 4C =; =Q> 3? 3 :=>9C>435 :;=T59WY
#? C=>9@F >U9 =>U9; A3Q?9 =] @93>U 54?>9@ 4C >U9 C9A;=:?6 S3? ?9:?4?Y 0U9 $0"#$)A:%;"
59?4=C? 35=C^ U9; ;4^U> ?4@9 S9;9 A593;56 R4?4T59 J .; .c#^=?>4C= A=QC>9@ >U9W 3>
C9A;=:?6 3C@ ?QTW4>>9@ 3 ?S3T >= >U9 53T ]=; 3 !Q5>Q;9 3C@ &9C?4>4R4>6 =C >U9 :Q?Y *9>
54V9 >U9 S94^U> 5=??F ?U9 C9R9; T=>U9;9@ >= >;93> >U9W 94>U9;F W9@4A3556 ,- ?Q;^4A3556Y
$C?>93@F ?U9 59]> >U3> >= >U9 899:9;? 3C@ 3 ^3;@9C U=?9Y
!"#$ @4@ U3R9 3TC=;W35 Q::9; W=53;? d]=; GH 693;?eF TQ> C= ?4^C? =] ^4C^4R4>4? =;
4C]9A>4=C S9;9 9R9; C=>9@ 4C >U9 ONM =; >U9 +!M (9@4A35 )9A=;@?F =; @Q;4C^ >U9 b;=??
29A;=:?6 SU9C U9; 9C>4;9 W=Q>U S3? 93?456 4C?:9A>9@ T6 .; .c#^=?>4C=Y
.; .c#^=?>4C= U3? C= 9hAQ?9 ]=; ]345Q;9 >= #,$%&" >U9 S94^U> 5=?? 3C@ 9W3A43>4=CF ]345Q;9
>= ."'-&? ]=; 3 A3Q?9F 3C@ >U9C ]345Q;9 >= $'1" +":%#%$%;" .$"=. >= ;9?=5R9 4>Y
&U9 U3? C= 9hAQ?9 ]=; ]345Q;9 >= =U9 >4??Q9 @3W3^9F ]345Q;9 >= A5=?956
/,#%$,- ]=; ?4^C? =] >;3QW3>4A 4C`Q;6F 3C@ >U9C ]345Q;9 >= Q5>4W3>956 $-"'$ >U9 9h>9C?4R9
>;3QW3>4A 59?4=C? 73T?A9??9?< >U3> S9;9 A3Q?9@ T6 T94C^ W9AU3C4A3556 U=4?>9@ Q: =C
DGaDgaDI 3C@ DGaDlaDIY
29^54^9CA9 4C >U9 :;3A>4A9 =] R9>9;4C3;6 W9@4A4C9F ?QT?>3C@3;@ A3;9F A3;959?? @4?;9^3;@
]=; !"#$c? U935>UF S95]3;9F 3C@ ?3]9>6F 4C3@9XQ3>9 ;9A=;@ V99:4C^F @9A9:>4R9 ?>3>9W9C>?
4C >U9 (9@4A35 )9A=;@? 3C@ >= >U9 :QT54A J 355 3;9 A=CA9;C? >U3> ?Q;;=QC@ >U9 >4W9 >U3>
!"#$ ?:9C> QC@9; .; .c#^=?>4C=c? A3;9Y
.; .c#^=?>4C= S3? ]4C3556 ]=;A9@ >= C=>4A9 >U9;9 S3? ?=W9>U4C^ S;=C^ SU9C !"#$ S3?
]=QC@ @93@ =C >U9 ^;=QC@fY3C@ >U9C ?U9 S;=>9 4C >U9 ;9A=;@P d0U9;9 S9;9 C= :;9R4=Q?
?4^C? =] 455C9??Ye
#? @9?A;4T9@ 4C >U4? &QWW3;6 =] (9@4A35 )9A=;@? 1 !=CA9;C?F ,;49C@? =] O==@53C@ N3;V
M== -59:U3C>? 3559^9? >U3> .; .c#^=?>4C= W36 U3R9 R4=53>9@ :;=R4?4=C? =] >U9 +V53U=W3
B9>9;4C3;6 N;3A>4A9 #A> 3C@ >U9;9]=;9 ?U=Q5@ T9 ?QT`9A> >= @4?A4:54C3;6 3A>4=CY
Recommended