Stewardship is Green Dr. Alan Hoback, PE Rev. Steven Archer

Stewardship is Green

Dr. Alan Hoback, PE

Rev. Steven Archer

OutlineOutline

Welcome and OverviewPerspectives on the EnvironmentEnergy ImprovementsWork Session

PresentersPresentersDr. Alan Hoback, PE

Director of Architectural Engineering at UDMUniversity of Detroit Mercy: a Catholic Inst.Architectural Engineering: building energy systems

Rev. Steven ArcherTrinity St. Mark’s United Church of ChristSouthwest Detroit Neighborhood

Overview of Trinity St. Mark’s Overview of Trinity St. Mark’s UCCUCC

Urban Southwest Detroit

Booming middle class neighborhoods in early 1900’s

Work done at TSMUCC Work done at TSMUCC 2008 2008 Electric:

Update tube lightingReplace incandescent bulbs with CFL’sExit signs

Heat:Eliminate draftsSupplemental heat system

Utilities Expenses¼ savings in heat and eletrical

Work still to be doneWork still to be doneElectrical: Replace dimming

bulbs in large fixtures.Supplement insulation in attic

and office.Parsonage

OutlineOutline

Welcome and OverviewPerspectives on the Environment

Energy ImprovementsWork Session

Perspectives on the Perspectives on the EnvironmentEnvironmentEngaging the CongregationUrban ContextMaking the Problem LocalMaking the Problem Global

Making the Problem LocalMaking the Problem LocalProblem is too big for most

people.Break it down to the village.

Urban ContextUrban Context

tennessee.gov

HealthHealth6,000 deaths in Ontario from

Asthma caused by US smog.

Ontario CAN◦13 M people◦Of 92,000 total deaths per year.

Making the Problem Making the Problem GlobalGlobalWhy?

How?

Glaciers

Glacier runoff year-round

Causes productive ecosystems that would otherwise be less productive.

Glaciers Ecosystems

Abundant Ecosystems cause high density of population.

1/3 of world population!

Glaciers Ecosystems Population.

Glaciers Ecosystems Population.

Global Climate change is partial cause of the glaciers melting.

No longer a year long supply of water.

Glaciers Ecosystems Population.

What is going to happen to 1/3 of the world population?

That’s why

The world is one living organism.

•All organisms share the same DNA structure. We are the same organism just divided, changed, and recombined.

Making Global RelevantMaking Global RelevantAfrican American High School

Students

America.gov

Engaging the Engaging the congregationcongregationGeneration Y

Start small?

Sewing a seed

Starting smallStarting smallforms

Recycling / CompostingRecycling / CompostingTrash trucks get 2 mpg.1.5 lbs of air pollution (smoke &

carbon monoxide & carbon dioxide) to haul away and bury 1.0 lbs of trash.

No immediate economic payback to congregation, unless you pay for trash by weight.

OutlineOutline

Welcome and OverviewPerspectives on the EnvironmentEnergy Improvements -strategies -specific improvements

Work Session

Outline-Energy Outline-Energy ImprovementsImprovementsUnique strategies.Finding technical advice and labor.Paying for it.Improvements:Electrical improvements.Heating & A/C improvements.Water.Misc.

Unique StrategiesUnique StrategiesVariation in use patterns.

Sanctuary use. Office use.

Climate regionsBuilding age

Avoiding MistakesAvoiding MistakesInsulating the wrong way can

cause mold growth.Putting in the wrong product can

cost you more.Look past product claims that

“may save up to 50%.”Environmental Problems: Radon

RadonRadon

Finding technical advice and Finding technical advice and laborlabor

Energy Audits ($100-200)Energy ConsultantsVolunteers / DIY

Paying for itPaying for it“Pay back”

simple analysis, example:

TSMUCC $6,000 lighting upgrades 2008

Net savings $1,260 / yrCash flow

$6k

’08 ‘09 ‘10 ‘11 ‘12 ‘13 ‘14 ‘15

$1.2kPaid off in ‘12

ExampleExampleHeating Season

Outlay Effect on energy bills

Running Total

2011-2012 $4,000 cost

$10,000 savings

Net $6,000

2012-2013 0 $10,000 savings

Total: $16,000

2013-2014 0 $10,000 savings

Total: $26,000

2014-2015 0 $10,000 savings

Total: $36,000

Paying for itPaying for itLoansPrivate consultants

$6k

$1.2k

Cash flow

debt

Strategies for Paying for itStrategies for Paying for itGrantsDeep pocketsReinvestment of savingsRising costs

$6k

OutlineOutline

Welcome and OverviewPerspectives on the EnvironmentEnergy Improvements

-strategies -specific improvements

Work Session

Electrical ImprovementsElectrical ImprovementsInterior LightingExterior LightingAir ConditioningAppliances

Variability in ratesVariability in rates

In Michigan each watt continuously running is $1 per year.

Interior LightingInterior LightingChurch lighting atmosphere:

◦Light color and focus.

Interior LightingInterior LightingCompact Fluorescent Light bulbs

(CFL)

www.doe.gov

Paying for:

In the right fixture:

CFL IssuesCFL IssuesProper disposalLast 4X incandescentEnergy Star & Power ratioCircuit stabilitySpecial dimmer switchesWarm up & Loss of brightnessQuick StartCold Cathode (dimmable, instant

on, cold climate)

Tube LightingTube LightingOld Magnetic BallastsEfficient electronic ballasts (25%)Light levelsEnergy Consultants vs.

Volunteers

www.cpsc.gov

Light LevelsLight LevelsADEQUATE LIGHT LEVELS FOR YOUR WORKING OR AT YOUR WORK AREAS

FT-CANDLE(lx)LOCATIONS 1,000

500

300

200

150

100 75 50 30 20 15 10 7.5 5 3 2

FACTORY

ELECTRONIC PARTS ASSEMBLY LINE

DRAFTING

TYPESETTING AT PRINTING SHOP

INSPECTION WORK

VISUAL WORK AT PRODUCTION LINE

PACKING WORK

EXIT

ENTRANCE

PASSAGE

INDOOR EMERGENCY STAIRS

WAREHOUSE

LOADING OR UNLOADING WORK

OFFICE

TYPING

DRAFTING

CLERICAL WORK

CONFERENCE ROOM

DINNIG ROOM

RECEPTION ROOM

READING

HALLWAYS

STAIRS

ENTRANCE

WARE-HOUSE

AUDITORIUM

INDOOR EMERGENCY STAIRS

HOUSE

SEWING READING

STUDY

KITCHEN

MAKE-UP

GROOM-ING

DINNING TABLE

RECREA-TIONAL ACTIVITIES

WASHING

LAVATORY

STORE

FOREFRONT OF SHOW WINDOW

SHOW WINDOW

PACKING TABLE

ELEVATOR

DISPLAY STAND

RECEP-TION ROOM

CORRIDOR

STAIRS

INDOORS PARKING

HOSPITAL

EYE INS-PECTION OPERATING ROOM

EMERGENCY TREATMENT

MEDICAL EXAMINATION ROOM

DINNING ROOM

WAITING ROOM

SICK ROOM

WARE-HOUSE

STAIRS

EMERGENCY STAIRS

SCHOOL

DRAFTING ROOM

LABORATORY

LIBRARY

CLASS ROOM INDOOR GYMNASIUM GENERAL

AUDITORIUM

WASH ROOM

EMERGENCY STAIRS

BASKET BALL

RESTAURANT

SHOW WINDOW

COOKING ROOM

DINNING TABLE

ENTRANCE

WASH ROOM

CORRIDOR

STAIRS

BARBERBEAUTYPARLOR

HAIR DYEING

MAKE UP

HAIR DRESSING

SHAVING

HAIR WASHING

DRESSING

COMPUTER LAB

READING MONITOR

KEYBOARD

SensorsSensorsOn tubes or CFLs

One Exterior lighting

Exit signsExit signs

Incandescent yearly electrical cost: $50 - 100

/fixture 1 or 2 bulbs

Fluorescent: $14 - 30

LED $ 1 - 2

replacement: $17 + labor

EXIT

Exterior LightsExterior LightsCFL (need

many)

High Intensity Discharge

LED ($$$)Sensors?

Air-conditioningAir-conditioningWindow and Central UnitsEfficiency is SEER (Seasonal

Energy Efficiency Ratio)Knowing energy consumption,

you could find potential savings from upgrading to newer units.

See similar points in Heating discussion.

ShadingShading

torontohistory.org

AppliancesAppliancesRefrigerators

How much electricity does it use?

Watt Meter~$25

Appliances - otherAppliances - otherMost used for very short timeContinuously running appliances:

Refrigerators 16 cu. Ft 725 W (when compressor on)

Dorm sized 100 W

Clock radio = 10 WFans

Ceiling = 65–175 WWindow = 55–250 WFurnace = 750 WWhole house = 240–750 W

VCR / DVD Player on / off 20 W / 5WPersonal computer

CPU - awake / asleep = 270 / 60 W or less

Laptop = 50 W

Heat (and A/C)Heat (and A/C)DraftsProgrammable ThermostatsInsulatingZoningSupplementary Heat SystemsReplacement furnace (high

efficiency or geothermal)

DraftsDrafts

Trinity St. Mark’s UCCCaulkingVents:

Replacement WindowsReplacement WindowsIf very drafty:

pay back in 4-8 years.

If aluminum frame: (single pane or older double pane.)

pay back in 10-20 years.

Or Window Film could save ~18% energy

WindowsWindowsLead

Outer protective windows.

Draft sealing: CostsDraft sealing: CostsProfessionals:

About $300Volunteers: less than $100 in materials

Savings: 5-25% of heating & cooling costs.

InsulatingInsulatingIce dams

www.noaa.gov

InsulatingInsulatingCost:

$0.50 / sq. ft. (w/ volunteer labor)$1.00 / sq. ft. (professional)

Savings:Air conditioning load reduced or comfort improved

Heat: Payback ~2 years depending on climate zone and current insulation.

Instrumentation & Instrumentation & ControlsControlsProgrammable ThermostatsZoning

Use PatternsUse PatternsProgrammable Thermostats:Can control days by day and hour by

hr.If building is unoccupied during

night:Turn back at night by 10-15 degrees.Savings: 10%

If building is unoccupied during week:Savings: 20-30%

Use PatternsUse Patterns

Zoning:Controls split forced air or steam

to needed areas only.

Sanctuary55o M-S

Office and classrooms 68-70o M-S

Sanctuary72o Su

Office and classrooms 72o Su

ZoningZoningCosts:

$2,000-$5,000 per building.Savings:

Up to 30% based on portion of building zoned.

Use patternsUse patternsTrinity Saint Mark’s UCC

Trinity St. Mark’s UCCTrinity St. Mark’s UCC

Pipe Organ. Constant 68o

Sanctuary70o Su and events

Office and meeting. 68o M-Su daytime

Fellowship Hall. (Secondary users)68o M-S daytime

Supplementary Heat Supplementary Heat SystemSystemSecondary furnace.Ties to existing exhaust.Independent boiler system.

Longer payback.

Updating FurnaceUpdating FurnaceHigh Efficiency Furnace installed:

$20,000-$100,000Up to 50% improvement in heating

costs.

Geothermal Heat Pump (similar $’s)

works best in saturated soils or ponds

WaterWaterHot waterWatering Lawn

Hot WaterHot WaterBuilding use 2

hours?

On-demand warms as needed.

Satellite on-demand systems.

Kitchen and baths

Bathroom

bathroom

Water Shortages / Price Water Shortages / Price increaseincrease

Lawn & Garden WateringLawn & Garden WateringNative Species

Rain Sensors

Misc. –Energy Misc. –Energy ImprovementsImprovementsRenewable Energy

New Construction

Renewable EnergyRenewable EnergyWindmillsPhotovoltaic SolarHot water Solar

WindmillsWindmills$8,000-$20,00012+ year payback (in white)8 years in orange

Photovoltaic SolarPhotovoltaic Solar$16,000+

Hot water solarHot water solarSupplement water heater.

Store heat until winter.

New ConstructionNew ConstructionLeadership in Energy &

Environmental Design. (LEED)Silver, Gold, Platinum ratings

Get points for Energy and Environment(Internal environment: air quality)(External environment: impact on nature.)

OutlineOutline

Welcome and OverviewPerspectives on the EnvironmentEnergy ImprovementsWork Session

Work SessionWork SessionPrioritizing based on unique

situation

Your unique situationYour unique situation

See provided sheet.

Building use

Climate

High wind or solar region?

Find the billsFind the billsWhat is the annual heating cost

and all-inclusive rate? (by month)

What is the annual electrical cost and all-inclusive rate? (by month)

What is the annual water & sewer cost and all-inclusive rate? (by month)

See also: Light bulb See also: Light bulb programprogramSample sheet created couple

years ago. Costs and savings have both likely gone up.

Use for your church buildings or for home use.

Solar RegionsSolar Regions

Wind RegionsWind Regions

Electrical RatesElectrical Rates

Climate RegionsClimate Regions

www.energycodes.gov

Water shortage areasWater shortage areas