Radar Palet e Home Dual Polarized Analysis & Diagnosis 1 Dual Polarized Radar What is...

Preview:

Citation preview

Analysis & Diagnosis 1Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Dual Polarized Radar

• What is polarimetric radar• Polarimetric products• Uses of these ‘raw’ outputs in forecasting• Winter precipitation field study• Particle ID algorithms• Etc – other topics• Dual Polarized Analysis and Diagnosis

(Important Material – linked to page 80)

Analysis & Diagnosis 2Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Dual Polarization Radar

Courtesy: http://cimms.ou.edu/~schuur/radar.html

- Particles have different shapes and orientations

-Horizontally and vertically polarized signals encounter different amounts of water mass and return different signals

- From these differences, you can infer some properties of the hydrometeors

Analysis & Diagnosis 3Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Polarization Products

• Radar Reflectivity Zh

• Differential Reflectivity ZDR

• Correlation coefficient ρHV

• Differential Phase φDP

• Specific differential phase KDP

Analysis & Diagnosis 4Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Radar Reflectivity Zh

• Conventional radar product• Depends on size (D6) and number density• Sensitive to calibration and partial beam

blocking• Prone to attenuation for shorter microwaves C-

band (5 cm)

Analysis & Diagnosis 5Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Differential Reflectivity (ZDR)

• Ratio of scattered H and V power returns (PHH/PVV)

• Function of the particle shape and orientation• Independent of absolute calibration and particle

concentration• Affected by differential attenuation

Analysis & Diagnosis 6Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Differential Reflectivity (ZDR)Drop shape as a function of size:

Analysis & Diagnosis 7Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Differential Reflectivity (ZDR

) H/V

•Good discriminator between heavy rain and hail.

•For hail ZDR~1 (hail is round and tumbling)

•For heavy rain ZDR is large since ZHH>>ZVV (big drops are Big Macs – large horizontally & smaller in the vertical)

•Low values for ground clutter (< 0) (buildings tend to be vertical…)•High values for biological scatters (> 3) (birds and bugs have winds – horizontally larger than vertical dimension…)•Intermediate values meteorological• ZDR > 0 H dim greater• ZDR < 0 V dim greater• ZDR ~ 0 spherical or randomly oriented

Analysis & Diagnosis 8Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Differential Reflectivity (ZDR

)

•Light rain (0.5 -1.0 dB)

•Moderate rain (1.5 - 2.0 dB)

•Heavy rain (2.5 - 3.0 dB)

•Rain/Hail (0.0 - 1.0 dB)

•Dry snow (0.0 - 0.3 dB)

•Wet snow (1.0 - 2.0 dB)

•Ice crystals (2.0 - 3.0 dB)

Analysis & Diagnosis 9Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Correlation Coefficient – ρHV

Correlation of the time series of H and V returns

Not quantitative measurement

Independent of calibration, attenuation and particle concentration

A measure of the variety of particle shapes and fall modes

Analysis & Diagnosis 10Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Correlation Coefficient – ρHV

For radar bins with single particle shape Zh/Zv is constant in series of pulses. No variance equals 1 on “rhoHV” display

Mixed particles.. Zh/Zv not constant and variance recorded as less than 1.Mixed particles.. Zh/Zv not constant and variance recorded as less than 1.

Analysis & Diagnosis 11Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Correlation Coefficient – ρHV

• ~ 1 for single type of hydrometeors in a preferred orientation (rain or snow)

• Decreases with increasing diversity of hydrometeor shapes and orientation

• More significant if particles wet or large and irregular

Analysis & Diagnosis 12Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

First Application of Dual Polarized Radar in Canada

Doppler Radar

Analysis & Diagnosis 13Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 14Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Rain with moderate northeast winds

It is OK to look out the window!

Analysis & Diagnosis 15Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Polarized Radar

Analysis & Diagnosis 16Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Sphereical

Flat

Flat

Sphereical

ZDR

Analysis & Diagnosis 17Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

New PolarizedRadar

Old DopplerRadar

These are not Stereo Radars

Analysis & Diagnosis 18Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Sphereical

More Blockage

Analysis & Diagnosis 19Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

SNOWSpherical

RAINFlat

Flat

Some ice pellets… snow and even rain at the office

Differential Phase is caused by compression of the microwaves in the hyrdometeor medium and the different horizontal and vertical presented by non spherical hydrometeors.

Analysis & Diagnosis 20Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

SNOWSpherical

RAINFlat

Analysis & Diagnosis 21Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Rain-Snow Boundary Case

Ground clutterGround clutter

Radome interference

snow

rain

Wet snow and

rain

Analysis & Diagnosis 22Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 23Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Bright band Case

Differential Reflectivity

Differential Phase

Reflectivity

Correlation Coefficient

Bright Band

Analysis & Diagnosis 24Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Icing Aloft

Differential Reflectivity

Differential Phase

Reflectivity

Correlation Coefficient

LGT-MDT MXD ICG @ 14KFT

Analysis & Diagnosis 25Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Another Day

December 23, 2004

Analysis & Diagnosis 26Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

ρHV

Unifo

rm S

now

Chang

e to

Fre

ezin

g Rai

n

Rain

Analysis & Diagnosis 27Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Particle Characteristics

In Cross-Section

ρρHVHV

Uniform Snow

Less Uniform Melting Snow-Liquid Mix

More Uniform Liquid

High Correlation

Uniform ParticlesLower Correlation

Mixed Particles

High Correlation

Uniform Particles

Infer

Infer

Infe

r

FRLVL

Melting

Melted

Snow

Snow-ZR-

ZR-

Analysis & Diagnosis 28Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Precipitation Transition CaseJanuary 21, 2006

Analysis & Diagnosis 29Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Rain-snow transition at CAREVertiX radar:

• at ~0800Z, fall velocities show change from rain

• after 1030Z, light falling snow only

rain mix /melting / aggregation snow

Analysis & Diagnosis 30Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

0700-0710Z:Rain

Rain-snow transition at CARE

0730-0740Z:Rain/Snow

HVSD 10-minute analysis

Analysis & Diagnosis 31Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Rain-snow transition at CARE

1307-1317Z:Dry snow

HVSD 10-minute analysis

0800-0810Z:Wet Snow/ Dry Snow

Analysis & Diagnosis 32Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Z ZDR

ρHV

Round/tumblingH and V are similar

Sig Reflectivity

Correlated in Time

Dry Snow

Analysis & Diagnosis 33Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Heavy Wet Snow

Analysis & Diagnosis 34Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Uncorrelated RhoHV in a sea of correlationsSuggests a phase change line.

Analysis & Diagnosis 35Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Significant Reflectivity but not the sameAlong the entire length of the band

Analysis & Diagnosis 36Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Differential Reflectivity ZDR show a changeAlong the entire length of the band

ZDR > 0 H dim greaterZDR < 0 V dim greaterZDR ~ 0 spherical or randomly oriented

SNOW

RAIN

Wet SNOW

Wet SNOW – shaped like flatten badminton shuttlecocks

Analysis & Diagnosis 37Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

1120Z

ZDR

Vr

2006-01-21: Radome attenuation

• ZDR anomaly in northern sector of radar picture; > 3dB high• Rain-snow transition zone approaches and passes radar origin

• Note low level wind direction affects attenuated sector

1030Z

ZDR

50 minutes

Analysis & Diagnosis 38Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Snow Squall CaseFebruary 24, 2006

Analysis & Diagnosis 39Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Z ZDR

ρHV

Analysis & Diagnosis 40Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Polarimetric Radar and Snowsqualls

• Snowfall rates of 5-10 cm an hour are not uncommon in squalls although water equivalents may be only 20 or 30 to 1.

• Do these “big squalls” look any different with polarimetric radar?

• Feb 6 2006 a very strong snowsquall went though the Toronto area.

• 30 cm accumulation east of city.

Analysis & Diagnosis 41Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 42Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Differential Reflectivity ZDR is negative so the snow flake tend to be vertically larger

ZDR > 0 H dim greaterZDR < 0 V dim greaterZDR ~ 0 spherical or randomly oriented

Analysis & Diagnosis 43Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

RhoHV is nearly perfectly correlatedThe flakes are all the same

Analysis & Diagnosis 44Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Doppler shows a northwesterly flow at an angle to the long axis of the snowsquall.Is the snowsquall going to remain stationary?Is the snowsquall going to drift southward?

Analysis & Diagnosis 45Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Fuzzy Logic to Radar Interpretation

• Inputs (radar variables)

• Decision process (membership functions)

• Output classification (hydrometeor type)

Analysis & Diagnosis 46Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Types of Membership Functions

• Typical one-dimensional Trapezoid Membership Function

Analysis & Diagnosis 47Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

2D Trapezoid Membership Function

2-D TMF for Moderate Rain

Analysis & Diagnosis 48Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

“Simple” Membership Functions

Analysis & Diagnosis 49Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

King HCA (iParCA)

• IDL code emulating the NSSL algorithm• Three schemes of particle classification:

– Simple– Summer– Winter

Analysis & Diagnosis 50Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 51Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 52Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Radar and snow accumulation

• The Z-S relationship often produces poor results.• Can polarimetric parameters improve this situation

Analysis & Diagnosis 53Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

6 hour snowfall accumulation mapDecember 08, 2006

YXU London airport Exeter radar estimated 2-3 cm YXU observed 12 cm with water equivalent of 11 mm

Analysis & Diagnosis 54Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Radar and snow accumulation

• The Z-S relationship often produces poor results.• Can polarimetric parameters improve this situation• Yes… but the work isn’t completed yet…

Analysis & Diagnosis 55Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Dual Polarized Radar

• Doppler was started in Canada in research mode at King City in 1985

• It took 10 years to understand the power of the outputs

• It took 15 years to dopplerize the Canadian radar network

• Dual Polarized radar was started at King City in 2004…

Analysis & Diagnosis 56Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 57Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 58Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 59Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 60Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 61Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 62Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 63Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 64Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 65Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 66Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 67Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 68Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 69Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 70Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 71Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 72Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 73Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 74Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 75Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 76Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 77Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 78Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 79Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 80Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Dual Polarized Radar Analysis and Diagnosis Strategies

An operational guide to getting the most information from Dual Polarized radar:

• Under construction

Analysis & Diagnosis 81Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Analysis & Diagnosis 82Radar Palette Home Dual Polarized

Recommended