View
0
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
DRAFT
1
1. Basic Information Name of the Project Promoting sustainable transboundary inland navigation in the Sundarban
Region: A Bangladesh-India Initiative Location The project will be implemented in the Sundarban Region of Bangladesh and
India.
Time Span The project will be implemented over a period of three years.
Budget To be developed
2. Introduction
2.1 Background
The shared Sundarban Region, comprising Sundarban Reserve Forests (SRF)1 and Sundarban Impact
Zone (SIZ)2 in Bangladesh and Sundarban Biosphere Reserve (SBR)3 in India, presents a strong
opportunity for strategic cooperation and joint actions between Bangladesh and India, resulting in
simultaneous poverty reduction and sustainable ecosystem management. It houses a total population of
about 7.5 million and suffers from several and similar dimensions of poverty in both the countries. Given
that each country’s portion of this Region is essentially part of the same ecosystem, it would be better
managed if both countries developed a co-management policy aimed at conservation and development,
or at least collaborated together to adopt a coordinated policy and activities that could be implemented
by each country individually or jointly. A special focus is needed for facilitating joint, sustainable
development of the shared Sundarban Region with stress on realizing economic growth and enhancing
climate resilience.
The spirit of the bilateral cooperation in the Sundarban Region that is reflected in several MoUs,
agreements and joint statements issued at the highest level in Bangladesh and India. There are the 2011
MoUs on (i) management of the Sundarban Landscape, (ii) management of tigers, (iii) fisheries, and (iv)
exchange and sharing of relevant information and programs between the respective national televisions
(MEA-India.2011). During the June 2015 visit of the Indian Prime Minister to Bangladesh, the two
countries renewed the Protocol on Inland Water Transit and Trade, and also inked two separate pacts
on coastal shipping allowing the use of Bangladesh’s Chittagong and Mongla ports by Indian merchant
vessels. A separate MoU on “blue economy and maritime cooperation in the Bay of Bengal and the
Indian Ocean” is expected to support cooperation in regional waters between Bangladesh and India.
This proposal of Joint program for revival of inland navigation route includes the sustainable
development of transboundary inland navigation between the two countries to enhance regional
communication, socioeconomic development and biodiversity conservation. The project is looking to
1 The core part of Bangladeshi Sundarbans is declared as Sundarbans Reserve Forest (SRF) during the British period in 1875, area is 6,017 sq. km
2 An area within 20 km from the boundary of the SRF (to its north and east) is termed as the Sundarbans Impact Zone (SIZ). 3 Indian Sundarban as a whole is declared as Sundarbans Biosphere Reserve (9630 sq. km) in 1989, comprising a human habitat area of about 5367 sq. km and a Reserve Forest area of 4263 sq. km
Prepar
ed fo
r and on
behalf
of BIS
RCI
Discussi
on D
raft
DRAFT
2
support the Protocol on Inland Water Transit & Trade (PIWT&T) between Bangladesh and India and the
2011 Bangladesh-India MoU for joint sustainable management of the Sundarban Region.
The South Asia Water Initiative (SAWI) has been facilitating multi-stakeholder consultations to facilitate
dialogue and confidence building activities for strategic cooperation and joint actions between
Bangladesh and India. The International Water Association (IWA) being part of the Bangladesh-India
Sundarban Region Cooperation Initiative (BISRCI) a consortium supported by the SAWI has developed
this project proposal Promoting sustainable transboundary inland navigation in the Sundarban Region:
A Bangladesh-India Initiative through literature review and consultative multi-stakeholder process in
Bangladesh and India. Over the period of January 2015 - August 2016, IWA in collaboration with BISRCI
consortium members, organized these meetings and consultations involving the participation and
contribution of civil society organizations, research organizations, government officials, private sector
representatives and local inhabitants from in Khulna and Dhaka, Bangladesh and Kolkata, Kakdwip and
New Delhi, India.
The proposed project ‘Revival of the river routes for transboundary inland navigation bypassing the
Sundarban: A Bangladesh-India Initiative’ was conceived and developed through literature review and
consultative multi-stakeholder process in Bangladesh and India involving the participation and
contribution of civil society organizations, research organizations, government officials, private sector
representatives and local inhabitants i.e. BISRCI consortium meetings; field-level consultation with key
stakeholders; in Khulna and Dhaka, Bangladesh and Kolkata, Kakdwip and New Delhi, India. The
consultations were carried out during November 2015 to March 2016.
2.2 Rationale
Transboundary inland navigation is increasingly playing an important role in regional connectivity
between Bangladesh and India thereby boosting regional integration; creating regional production and
distribution networks; facilitating trade and accelerating economic growth. A system of navigable canals
and rivers has provided the people in this region with slow but cheap transport between the various
remote parts of the country and has acted as the high roads for trade and commerce since ancient times
(Mishra and Hussain 2012). Due to its natural advantage, Inland Water transport (IWT) has proved more
accessible and cheaper than roads and railways and is more affordable for many people in the region
and IWT can contribute significantly to the government’s effort in growth, regional connectivity as well
as reduction of poverty (Mishra and Hussain 2012; World Bank 2007). Many regions of the world
including Europe, South East Asia, China, USA are considering inland navigation infrastructure as an
option for moving freight in an energy-efficient, environmentally friendly and safe way and are setting
ambitious targets for investments aimed at improvement of the waterways (World Bank, 2009;
ICPDR,2007). Inland navigation, however, can have potential harmful impacts on riverine habitats and
natural riverine environments thus ecological considerations need to be taken into account when
determining routes and corridors for navigation (ICPDR, 2007).
Inland water transport trade between India and Bangladesh is presently passing through an important
phase, the potential in this sector looks promising and is expected to experience substantial growth in
Prepar
ed fo
r and on
behalf
of BIS
RCI
Discussi
on D
raft
DRAFT
3
the next 15 years (Mishra and Hussain 2012). After formation of Bangladesh a trade agreement was
signed between the two countries in 1972, which led to the signing of the Indo-Bangladesh Protocol on
Inland Water Transit & Trade (PIWT&T) and since then it has been continuing without interruption.
The latest renewal was signed on June 6, 2015, and the time period being 5 years instead 2 years. This
was a big step in the revival of inland water transport in eastern and north-eastern India. From 1995
onwards, cement movement between India and Bangladesh under this protocol gained momentum.
From 2001 onwards, movement of fly ash to Bangladesh started taking place, and today has reached a
considerable volume.
Figure 1: Inland Navigation Route in Sundarban Region
Under the PIWT&T between Bangladesh and India, all transit vessels travelling to and from Kolkata
move through the Sundarban. Records show that shipping and navigation through the Sundarban is
increasing and is expected to grow further. In 2008-09, a total of 9,44,422 metric tons of cargo was
transported between India and Bangladesh under the arrangement of the PIWT&T and in the last fiscal
it was 19,12,526 metric tons. Data from the Bangladesh Inland Water Transport Authority shows a 102%
increase in cargo carrying between India and Bangladesh through Sundarban waterways over the past 8
years. The vessels range from ocean-going mother and feeder cargo ships, container carriers, tankers,
lighter age ships, mid-size bulk cargo and tankers from inland waterways, and trans-boundary cargo
ships (Mohammad Arju. 2016).
Most of these vessels use the navigable routes of Sundarban to access Mongla Port situated inside the
Sundarban Impact Zone and floating sea terminal located at Akram Point near Mongla. The main route
Prepar
ed fo
r and on
behalf
of BIS
RCI
Discussi
on D
raft
DRAFT
4
of travel for vessels reaching Mogla is the 31 km Mongla-Ghashiakhali navigation which started
operation 1973. This route serves as a linkage between Mongla Sea Port, Khulna and other parts of the
country. In addition, the Mongla-Ghoshiakhali route is also a part of the international navigation route in
the SIZ and is used by Indian and Bangladeshi water vessels under the Protocol on the PIWT&T between
Bangladesh and India. Recently, unauthorized navigation routes are expanding. In the first half of 2015,
on average of 228 vessels used these unauthorized routes monthly. This is because the de jure routes
have not been navigable since the late ’90s. On the other hand, data released by the Mongla Port
Authority shows a 172% increase in the number of ocean going vessels over the past eight years through
the Passur River. In the last fiscal, the total number of ocean-going vessels through this Sundarban
stream was 889, while it was only 326 in the year of 2008-09. Without any sort of environmental
management in place, this increasing navigation and shipping are multiplying the risk of accidents/spills
and regular pollution in the world’s largest mangrove forest (Mohammad Arju, 2016).
Similarly, in West Bengal, India service provision for regional and national inland navigation is
inadequate and has been worsening as a result of increasing waterway siltation, neglect of the system,
and shortfalls in service. The siltation problem is a major bottleneck. Dredging needs remain unmet due
to lack of budget allocation. The river vessels need to ply through alternative longer routes as siltation
has made many regular routes impassable (World Bank, 2014).
However, shipwrecks in the Sundarban are
increasing due to frequent movement of
vessels. Since 1984, the Mongla Port Authority
recorded nine shipwrecks, of those, four
occurred in just the last three years. The
increased shipping multiplies risks from oil spill,
the release of coal, chemical, fertilizer and fly
ash by accident; in course of routine operation,
vessels discharge ballast water, bilge water,
and there is cargo tank washing too. The
movement of vessels, mainly on the Passur
River channel of the Sundarban, is expected to
be increasing more than ever when the coal-
fired Rampal power plant goes into operation.
Citing from the coal power plant’s environment impact
assessment report (EIA), a latest media report4 says that the
Rampal Power Plant will require 4.7 million tonnes of coal and
limestone annually, which will be carried by at least 157
vessels with an average capacity of 30,000 tonnes. The
incidents of shipwrecks is undoubtedly putting the delicate
ecosystems of Sundarban at risk.
4http://archive.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/2017/jan/25/sundarbans-shipping-conundrum
Prepar
ed fo
r and on
behalf
of BIS
RCI
Discussi
on D
raft
DRAFT
5
Additionally, the impact of ship-induced waves on the mangrove ecosystem, disturbance to wildlife and
the risk of international wildlife trafficking spreading widely with regular vessel based pollution. The
moving and manoeuvring of vessels induce a variety of hydrodynamic changes and physical forces which
have an impact on the surrounding flow, alluvial banks and sediments of the rivers. These impacts
potentially harm the environment and can ultimately lead to environmental degradation. Without any
sort of environmental management in place, this increasing navigation and shipping are multiplying the
risk of accidents/spills and regular pollution in Sundarban.
For the preservation/conservation of the ecological integrity of the Sundarban, the basic needs are
(after ICPDR, 2007):
protection/conservation ecologically important river sections and aquatic habitats,
restoration of modified/impacted river sections and their adjacent landscapes,
maintenance of a dynamic and type-specific channel and floodplain environment (regarding in-
stream structures, shorelines, side arms and floodplains) supporting a dynamic equilibrium and
adequate connectivity conditions,
undisturbed longitudinal and lateral migration of all fish species and other water-related species
to ensure their natural and self-sustaining development.
As global economic growth has shifted eastward and as countries in the South Asia region are looking to
boost strategic regional integration and connectivity, the navigation routes of the PIWT&T are predicted
to play a pivotal role. It is thus essential to undertake efforts to develop an environmentally sound and
economically sustainable transboundary IWT between the two countries (Mishra and Hussain 2012). To
achieve this, according to different studies the specific needs and priorities are:
Improvement of navigability and introduction of limited container service in the existing
protocol route
Identification of the most economically efficient and environment friendly routes and network
Improvement of inter-modal transport connections at IWT ports;
Capacity building activities for personnel related to inland navigation.
2.3 Existing Inland Navigation Systems in India and Bangladesh
Inland Waterways Transport and communication in SIZ
IWT Sector in Bangladesh: Bangladesh has a large and vibrant Inland Water Transport sector. In total it carries over 50% of all Bangladesh’s cargo traffic and one quarter of all passenger traffic. IWT is now playing an increasingly important role in the social and economic development of the country by maintaining communication between various remote parts of the country which are inaccessible by other modes of transport; particularly during the periods of peak monsoon. It is also a reliable means of transport for importing and exporting cargo. The length of all of Bangladesh’s rivers is approximately 24,000 km. Of this, approximately 5,923km are currently navigable during the monsoon (wet) period, shrinking to about 3,865km in the dry periods (October to May). The rivers are mainly classed (Table 1) by the Bangladesh Inland Waterway Authority (BIWTA) according to the maximum draft limitations – which is the maximum depth a vessels hull may be immersed at certain places on the river (BIWTA, 2016).
Prepar
ed fo
r and on
behalf
of BIS
RCI
Discussi
on D
raft
DRAFT
6
Class One routes include those between the country’s main seaports of Chittagong and Mongla to Dhaka and Narayanganj, extending as far as Ashuganj on the Surma-Meghna river system. (Table-1)
Table 1: Classification of IWT River Routes in Bangladesh
Class Max Vessel Draft (& Min
Advertised River Depths)
Minimum Channel Width
Minimum Vertical
Clearance
River
Length
% of total IWT km
I 3.65 m (3.96m) 76.22 m 18.30 m 683 km 11%
II 2.13 m (2.43m) 76.22 m 12.20 m 1,000 km 17%
III 1.52 m (1.82m) 30.46 m 7.62m 1,886 km 32%
IV <1.52 m 20.00m 5.00m 2,400 km 40% Source: BIWTA, 2016
The statistics from the Mongla Port Authority shows that navigation in the Sundarban waterways has
increased 236 percent in last 7 years (Mangroves for the Future, 2015). The waterways in the coastal
region are mainly through large rivers such as the Passur, Raimangal Mongla, Baleshwar and Bishkhali in
Bangladesh and Bangladesh Inland Water Transport Authority (BIWTA) currently maintains navigability
of only 14 rivers over a total length of about 326 km in SIZ. The BIWTA operates launch service at certain
intervals through very limited routes of the area only during monsoon (CEGIS, 2012). Along with
commercial vessels, engine boats also operate via different local routes for transporting passengers and
goods. Additionally, a few tourist boats also travel inside the Sundarban. Many of these remain inside
Sundarban for 3-5 days and since there are no accommodation facilities the tourists stay on board
during this period. Within the Sundarban Reserve Forest, navigation is permitted for certain economic
activities and during license issuance for fishermen, honey and other collectors, permission for country
boats are also collected.
Navigation in the Mongla-Ghasiakhali Canal
The navigability of the Mongla-Ghasiakhali route has rapidly decreased during the period 2010 to 2014
due to tidal asymmetry and increased sedimentation. As a result, the MoEF gave environmental
clearance for vessels to ply on an alternative route through the since 2011. However, according to
Bangladesh Forest Department more than 500 crafts every month, including large vessels and oil
tankers, have been navigating inside the Sundarban (Mongla-Joimonir Gol- Harintana-Supoti canal to
and from the Bay of Bengal) through the Sela River illegally since 2011.
Prepar
ed fo
r and on
behalf
of BIS
RCI
Discussi
on D
raft
DRAFT
7
The Sela River, which runs through the sanctuaries for endangered Irrawaddy and Ganges river dolphin
and along the northern edge of the Sundarban East Wildlife Sanctuary, is an ecologically important river.
Yet it has been under the spotlight since December 9, 2014, when a wrecked tanker released
approximately 94,000 gallons (78,271 imperial gallons) of heavy fuel. The Sela oil spill brought
devastating consequence for the mangrove habitat and wildlife. The navigation through the river was
suspended immediately after this accident. To strengthen conservation efforts in the Sela River and
wildlife sanctuaries, officials are diverting the Mongla-port bound domestic vessels to the original port
route – the Mongla-Ghashiakhali channel. But the agencies are failing to maintain the depth and
navigability of the channel (Mohammad Arju. 2016). As a result, vessels have been using unauthorized
routes and vessel movement deep inside the forest, on the Arpangasia, Jamuna and Malancha rivers and
even in the Sundarban West Wildlife Sanctuary – which is also a UNESCO world heritage site (Arju,
2016). While the Sela River is not a part of the protocol route, the example shows that regular
maintenance of prescribed routes is critical and needs due attention.
Inland Waterways Transport and communication in SBR
The Inland Waterways Authority of India (IWAI) is a statutory body under Ministry of Shipping, Govt. of
India. IWAI is primarily responsible for development, maintenance and regulation of Inland Water
Transport (IWT) in the country specifically on National waterways. It was set up in October 1986 vide IWAI
Act 1985. National Waterways (NW) declared through Acts of Parliament come under the purview of
Central Govt/IWAI and other waterways under the respective State Government. IWAI is mandated to
take up a) Infrastructure development & regulation on NWs; b)Techno- economic feasibility studies;
c)Advise the Central Govt on IWT matters; d) Assistance to States in IWT development.
Prepar
ed fo
r and on
behalf
of BIS
RCI
Discussi
on D
raft
DRAFT
8
In this context, the Ganga-Bhagirathi-Hooghly river system from Allahabad to Haldia has been declared as
National Waterway-I (NW-I). It is a natural waterway of about 1620 km in length and passes through the
states of Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Jharkhand and West Bengal.
The protocol route in between Bangladesh and India has directly connected with the NW-1. The protocol
route on West Bengal, India side passes around 110 km through covering the routes line from Haldia,
Namkhana to Goshaba, Hemilton Island and Hemnagar then the India and Bangladesh border. During
passing through the Sundarban Blocks, it crisscrosses the Indian River named Thakuran, Matla, Bidyadhari,
Gosaba and Harinbhanga.
The classification of IWT River routes in the India is stated below in the following table -2:
Table 2: Classification of IWT River Routes in India
National
Water
Way
Route System Established Length
(km)
Fixed Terminal Cargo
(million
tonnes)
NW 1 Allahabad–Haldia stretch of the Ganges–
Bhagirathi–Hooghly river
1986 1,620 Haldia, BISN
(Kolkata), Pakur,
Farrakka and Patna.
4
NW 2 Sadiya — Dhubri stretch of Brahmaputra
river
1988 891 Pandu
2
NW 3 Kottapuram-Kollam stretch of the West
Coast Canal, Champakara Canal and
Udyogmandal Canal
1993 205 Aluva, Vaikom,
Kayamkulam,Kottap
puram, Maradu,
Cherthala,
Thrikkunnapuzha,
1
Prepar
ed fo
r and on
behalf
of BIS
RCI
Discussi
on D
raft
DRAFT
9
National
Water
Way
Route System Established Length
(km)
Fixed Terminal Cargo
(million
tonnes)
Kollam and
Alappuzha
NW 4 Kakinada–Pondicherry stretch of canals
and the Kaluvelly Tank, Bhadrachalam –
Rajahmundry stretch of River Godavari
and Wazirabad – Vijayawada stretch of
River Krishna
2008 1,095
NW 5 Talcher–Dhamra stretch of the Brahmani
River, the Geonkhali - Charbatia stretch of
the East Coast Canal, the Charbatia–
Dhamra stretch of Matai river and the
Mangalgadi - Paradip stretch of the
Mahanadi Delta
2008 623
NW 6 In Assam, Lakhipur to Bhanga of river
Barak
2016 121
Source: Wikipedia
2.4 Protocol on Inland Water Transit & Trade (PIWTT) between Bangladesh & India
Under the Indo-Bangladesh Protocol on Inland Water Transit and Trade, specific routes for the passage
of inland vessels and ports of call for inter country trade have been clearly defined. The protocol routes
are:
Kolkata-Haldia-Raimongal-Chalna-Khulna-Mongla-Kaukhali-Barisal-Hizla-Chandpur-Narayanganj-
Aricha-Sirajganj-Bahadurabad-Chilmari-Dhubri-Pandu
Pandu-Dhubri-Chilmari-Bahadurabad-Sirajganj-Aricha-Narayanganj-Chandpur-Hizla-Barisal-
Kaukhali-Mongla-Khulna-Chalna-Raimongal-Haldia- Kolkata
Kolkata-Haldia-Raimongal-Mongla-Kaukhali-Barisal-Hizla-Chandpur-Narayanganj-Bhairab Bazar-
Ajmiriganj-Markuli-Sherpur-Fenchuganj-Zakiganj- Karimganj
Karimganj-Zakiganj-Fenchuganj-Sherpur-Markuli-Ajmiriganj-Bhairab Bazar-Narayanganj-
Chandpur-Hizla-Barisal/ Kaukhali- Mongla-Raimongal-Haldia-Kolkata
According to Article 11 of the Protocol some places of the respective countries are nominated as ‘Ports
of Call’ (Table 3). A total of 10 ports of call, 5 on each side are designated for loading/unloading of inter
country trade cargo. According to this provision vessels engaged in inter-country trade are allowed to
load/ unload only at the nominated ‘Port of Call’. If the cargo from Kolkata in India is destined for Barisal
or Chandpur in Bangladesh, the vessel will have to run to Narayanganj and after customs formalities the
vessel will have to come back again to the destination.
Prepar
ed fo
r and on
behalf
of BIS
RCI
Discussi
on D
raft
DRAFT
10
Table 3: List of Ports of Call in Bangladesh and India
Serial Number Bangladesh India
1 Narayanganj Kolkata
2 Mongla Haldia
3 Zokigonj Karimganj
4 Sirajganj Pandu
5 Ashuganj Silghat
This is contrary to the scenario prevailing in road transport. Cargo destined for any place in Bangladesh
comes to Benapole or to any road based land port and after customs formalities starts its journey to the
destination. As such cross-border trade by inland navigation loses its competitiveness to the roads. This
is because the ‘Ports of Call’ are far away from the entry/exit points.
Present inter country cargo transport
Cargoes that are exported to Bangladesh include fly ash, granulated slag, gypsum, clinker, cement,
manganese ore, food grains, wheat, rice, sugar, project cargo, and dried fish. The imported cargo from
Bangladesh includes crushed bone, hide, and return project cargo. The cargo moved during the year
2004–2005 along the protocol route was approximately 416,000 metric tons. Table 4 shows amounts of
cargoes moved in 2005 by category. Since April 2005 IWAI has been designated as the competent
authority from the Indian side for operation of the provisions of the protocol; prior to that the Central
Inland Water Transport Corporation held that responsibility.
2.5 Regional initiatives in the transport sector The accelerated momentum for regional transport connectivity in the countries South Asia and
Southeast Asia is increasingly being reflected in the national transport agenda. While the main focus of
the national development plans in the past was on in-country connectivity, South Asian governments
have recently given greater attention to regional and global linkages. Bangladesh has emphasized
regional connectivity in its latest 5 year plan, National Land Transport Policy, and also in the road master
plan and the railway investment plan. India has highlighted the need for strengthening both social and
physical infrastructure to promote close economic cooperation in South Asia and with countries of
Southeast Asia and East Asia. The Look East policy of India emphasizes connectivity and the as a vital
step forward in gaining easier access to India’s northeast and in the development of the region.
Additionally in November 2015 India signed a proposal for vehicular movement with Bangladesh, Bhutan
and Nepal (BBIN). Once this is operational there will be a 3200 km road link from Moreh (Manipur) to
Mae Sot (Thailand), making it one of the first sub-regional connectivity projects that will link South Asia
to Southeast Asia. Along with other sub-regional initiatives such as the BIMSTEC and the Ganga Mekong
Cooperation (GMC) the BBIN will also complement the existing sub-regional frameworks that will
eventually link up to the Indo-Pacific Economic Corridor.
Prepar
ed fo
r and on
behalf
of BIS
RCI
Discussi
on D
raft
DRAFT
11
2.6 Environmental protection of navigation routes in international agreements The International Commission for the Protection of the Danube River (ICPDR) has incorporated
ecological considerations on regional inland navigation routes. According to ICPDR inland navigation can
have significant negative influence on river ecosystems, jeopardizing the goals of the EU Water
Framework Directive, which aims for the “good ecological status” of all waters by 2015. Recognizing this
potential conflict in a number of new waterway projects along the Danube and the Sava River, ICPDR
has linked up with the Danube Navigation Commission, and the International Sava River Basin
Commission to conduct in 2007 an intense, cross-sectoral discussion process. As a result of
interdisciplinary workshops, a “Joint Statement on Guiding Principles on the Development of Inland
Navigation and Environmental Protection in the Danube River Basin” was agreed. The final document
was adopted in December 2007/January 2008 by the ICPDR, the Danube Commission and by the
International Sava River Basin Commission. The “Joint Statement” is a guiding document for the
maintenance of existing waterways and the development of future waterway infrastructure. It is
perceived as a milestone that leads to the integration of ecology into waterway development.
3. Overall Objective
The overall objective is to identify alternate river ways within the existing protocol routes in both
countries and integrate ecological considerations/recommendations into the Standard Operating
Procedure (SOP) (or policies) for inland navigation and livelihood protection of river-dependent
community.
4. Expected Outputs
The outputs are as follows:
Identification of route considering morphological characteristics basis bypassing ecologically
sensitive area;
Incorporation of ecological considerations in inland navigation and specification of commercial
vessels plying through protocol route into the Standard Operating Procedure (SOP)
Implementation of environmental security unit and proper monitoring.
5. Activities
Activity A- Identification of navigable routes in the Sundarban Region which will be connected with the
protocol routes through balancing navigation and ecological needs of the mangrove ecosystem
Activity B- Standardization of the existing and potential routes according to a joint regional standard
Activity C- Socio-Economic development of this region through communication network development
and figuring out the scopes created for livelihood activities related to livelihood activities, commercial
transportation, and sustainable tourism.
Prepar
ed fo
r and on
behalf
of BIS
RCI
Discussi
on D
raft
DRAFT
12
Detailed Activities:
Activity A- Identification of navigable routes in the Sundarban Region which will be connected with
the protocol routes through balancing navigation and ecological needs of the mangrove ecosystem
The following activities are:
1. Identify the potential routes for trans-boundary commercial transportation taking into account
the ecological aspects that is location of biodiversity hotspots, sanctuary etc.
2. Morphological assessment of identified navigation routes
3. Restoration and maintenance plan for maintenance of navigability in identified route
Restoration/ maintenance plans dependent on only dredging would not be feasible solution
for maintaining the navigability. Re-excavation and opening of adjacent tidal creeks and
creation of tidal basins at suitable locations could be able to reduce the siltation along with
ecological dredging. The plan should be based on the comprehensive morphological
assessment and understanding of tidal characteristics of the rivers.
Activity B- Standardization of the existing and potential routes according to a joint regional standard
The specific activities include:
1. Establish interdisciplinary planning teams involving key stakeholders, including Ministries
responsible for transport, for water management and environment, waterway administrations,
representatives of protected areas, local authorities, non-governmental organizations, tourism,
scientific institutions and independent (international) experts;
2. Provide guidelines for the regulation of navigation and traffic in the identified and restored
reaches;
3. Progressive introduction of vessel engine efficiency and emissions standards, while increasing its
efforts to ensure by provincial navigation authorities comply with all prevailing national
environmental, safety and competence standards for vessels and crews;
4. Set standards for vessels that will be using the navigation routes. Vessel design should be
modern, innovative and environment friendly and have minimal impact on river ecosystems and
dynamics. Moreover the design should also focus on low exhaust emissions and low fuel
consumption. Vessel design can be done concurrently in both countries;
5. Set standards for vessel loading and unloading methods;
6. Set standards for sound level, speed, waste discharge; and light usage during night navigation
within the Sundarban;
7. Design and implementation of joint programme on awareness raising of ecological issues;
8. Joint training on appropriate response measures in case of ecological disasters;
9. Design and conduct capacity building programme for the local authority to perform rescue
operation with quick response to reduce the immediate accident impact
Prepar
ed fo
r and on
behalf
of BIS
RCI
Discussi
on D
raft
DRAFT
13
Activity C- Support socio-economic development in the Sundarban region through navigation network
development and creating scope for livelihood activities.
The routes directly connected with the Sundarban Reserved forest (including sanctuaries) and core zone
in Sundarban Biosphere should be aligned with the socio-economic development activities in the region.
Population living in the peripheral region of the Sundarban should be given priority for livelihood
opportunities in this sector. Inter-modal transport connections at IWT ports, particularly connections
with railways, are generally superior in the USA and the EU than in China. The IWT industry in the EU in
particular has close links with wider logistics service suppliers such as freight forwarding and storage
functions. The specific activities include:
1. Carry out corridor studies in Bangladesh and India. These examine the uses and activities on and
alongside the river and integration of these activities into planning;
2. Plan for the integration of the identified inland navigation routes with regional spatial strategies
and local development frameworks.
Prepar
ed fo
r and on
behalf
of BIS
RCI
Discussi
on D
raft
DRAFT
14
6. Work Plan
No Activity Sub-activity Duration Remarks
1st Year 2nd Year 3rd Year
1st
quarter
2nd
quarter
3rd
quarter
4th
quarter
1st
quarter
2nd
quarter
3rd
quarter
4th
quarter
1st
quarter
2nd
quarter
3rd
quarter
4th
quarter
A Identification of navigable
routes in the Sundarban
Region which will be
connected with the
protocol routes through
balancing navigation and
ecological needs of the
mangrove ecosystem
a) Identify the potential routes
b) Morphological assessment of identified
navigation routes
c) Restoration and maintenance plan for
navigability
B Standardization of the
existing and potential
routes according to a joint
regional standard
Local and National level Stakeholder
Consultation
a) Establish interdisciplinary planning teams
b) Provide guidelines for the regulation of
navigation and traffic
c) Progressive introduction of vessel engine
efficiency and emissions standards,
d) Set standards for vessels that will be using the
navigation routes.
e) Set standards for sound level, speed, waste
discharge; and light usage
f) Design and implementation of joint programme
on awareness raising of ecological issues
g) Design capacity building programme for the
local authority to perform rescue operation with
quick response to reduce the immediate
accident impact
h) Joint training on appropriate response
measures in case of ecological disasters
Regional level Stakeholder Consultation
C Support socio-economic
development of the
Sundarban region through
navigation network
development and creating
scope for livelihood
activities.
a) Carry out corridor studies in Bangladesh and
India
b) The integration of the identified inland
navigation routes with regional spatial
strategies and local development frameworks
Submission of Report
Prepar
ed fo
r and on
behalf
of BIS
RCI
Discussi
on D
raft
DRAFT
15
Acronyms
BBIN Bangladesh, Bhutan India and Nepal
BIMSTEC The Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation
BISRCI Bangladesh-India Sundarban Region Cooperation Initiative
BIWTA Bangladesh Inland Water Transport Authority
EU European Union
ICPDR International Commission for the Protection of the Danube River
IWA International Water Association
IWT Inland Water transport
MoU Memorandum of Understanding
NW National Waterways
PIWT&T Protocol on Inland Water Transit & Trade
SAWI South Asia Water Initiative
SBR Sundarban Biosphere Reserve
SIZ Sundarban Impact Zone
SRF Sundarban Reserve Forests
UNESCO United Nations Education, Science and Cultural Organizations
USA United States of America
Prepar
ed fo
r and on
behalf
of BIS
RCI
Discussi
on D
raft
DRAFT
16
7. Reference BISRCI.2015. Bangladesh – India Sundarban Region Cooperation Initiative– Addressing extreme poverty
through sustainable development & ecosystem management. Multiplying benefits in Sundarban Region
through strategic bilateral cooperation between Bangladesh and India
BIWTA.2016.Bangladesh Regional Inland Water Transport Project 1(Chittagong-Dhaka-Ashuganj
Corridor)-Environmental and Social Assessment and Resettlement Policy Framework.
CEGIS.2012. Socio-Economic Sustainable Development in The Sundarbans Area Of Bangladesh
ICPDR.2007. Development of Inland Navigation and Environmental Protection in the Danube River Basin.
Mishra, D. K. and Hussain, S. M. (2012) Situation Analysis on Inland Navigation, Ecosystems for Life: A
Bangladesh-India Initiative, IUCN, International Union for Conservation of Nature.
Mohammad Arju. 2016. Dhaka Tribune- “Will Bangladesh and India turn the Sundarbans into a busy
shipping lane?” http://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/environment/2016/09/13/will-bangladesh-
india-turn-sundarbans-busy-shipping-lane-2/
Prasanth, G.N. 2012. Presentation on Indian Inland Waterways.
Rahman, M.M., M. Ahsan, S. K. Hore, M. H. Sarker and A. T. M. K. Hossain. 2013. Assessing the Causes of
Deterioration of the Mongla-Ghashiakhali Navigation Route For Restoration Of Navigability. Center for
Environmental and Geographic Information Services, Dhaka-1212, Bangladesh, e-mail:
mmrahman@cegisbd.com International Conference on Climate Change Impact and Adaptation (I3CIA-
2013).Center for Climate Change and Sustainability Research (3CSR), Department of Civil Engineering
DUET - Gazipur, Bangladesh.
Sinha. U., S. Gupta. 2016. The Daily Pioneer. Hope floats for India.http://www.dailypioneer.com/sunday-
edition/agenda/cover-story/hope-floats-for-india.html
World Bank. 2007. Revival of Inland Water Transport: Options and Strategies. Bangladesh Development Series. Paper No. 20
Prepar
ed fo
r and on
behalf
of BIS
RCI
Discussi
on D
raft
Recommended