PiXL Gateway Progression - Politics AQA · 2020-03-24 · 6 Synoptic thinking Synoptic can be...

PiXLGateway:ProgressionPolitics

ForStudentsStudyingAQAALevel

1

ContentsIntroduction...........................................................................................................................................2

“Aweekisalongtimeinpolitics”..........................................................................................................3

Synopticthinking....................................................................................................................................6

10keyfactstolearnforthestartofthecourse......................................Error!Bookmarknotdefined.

©ThePiXLClubLtd.June2018...........................................................................................................11

2

IntroductionWelcometoALevelstudy!Youwillquicklylearnthatpowerisattheheartofpolitics.Itdetermineswhogetswhat,when,andhow.Politicsisthestruggleoverscarceresourcesandthemeansthroughwhichthestruggleisconducted.

1 2Debateanddisagreementlieattheheartofthissubject–evenwhencompetingpoliticiansseemtobesayingthesamething.Itisasubjectofrivalviewsandonewithoutanyabsoluteanswers,soyouneedtotakeonthechallengeofconsideringdifferentviewpoints,perspectives,andopinions–andtothinkforyourself–sothatyoucanformulatepowerfulargumentsandexpressthemconvincingly.Moreover,youwillstudypoliticsnotasaneutralobserverbutasanactiveparticipant,developingyourpersonalopinionsasyouacquireastrongunderstandingofthefactorsshapingboththeBritishandAmericansystemsofgovernmentandpolitics.Youwillalsogaininsightintosomeofthegreatpoliticalideasthathaveshapedtheworldwelivein.ThisbookletisdesignedtohelpyoutostartthinkingasanALevelPoliticsstudentandincludestaskswhichwillsupportyouthroughoutyourstudies,includingassistingyouinpreparingforyourfinalexams.

1http://bentelevision.com/prime-minister-theresa-may-speech-britain-after-brexit-2016-a-vision-of-a-global-britain/http://lybio.net/jeremy-corbyn-queens-speech-2017/people/2http://lybio.net/jeremy-corbyn-queens-speech-2017/people/

3

“Aweekisalongtimeinpolitics”

3Uniquely,Politicsisalivingsubjectsoyouwillseemuchofwhatyouarestudyinghappeninginthe‘realworld’.Itcanalsobeaveryfastmovingone,asWilson’sfamousquoteaboveindicates.Thismeansthatanytextbookis,tosomedegree,outofdatebythetimeitispublished.Thismaysounddaunting,especiallywhenthisispartofyourintroductiontothesubject,butitalsoprovidesyouwithagreatopportunity.Itispreciselybecausenobookcangiveyouthemostup-to-dateexamplesthatusingrecent/currentexampleseffectivelywillbehighlyrewardedbyexaminers.Consequently,youshouldbekeepinganeyeonAmericangovernmentandpoliticsduringYear1,whenyouarestudyingtheUK,andcontinuetofollowwhatishappeningintheUKduringYear2,whenthefocusofthecourseisontheUSA.Followingpoliticsinthemediashould,therefore,bearegularpartofyourindependentstudythroughoutthecourse.First,however,youneedtobeorganised.Onefileperexampaperisrecommended.Buyoruse‘homemade’dividersandlabelthemasfollows.Youwillthenbeabletofileyourexamplesintheappropriatesection.(Beawarethatsomeexampleswillberelevanttotwoormoretopics–moreonthislater.)Makeastartonthisnow,establishingagoodhabittocontinuethroughoutthecourse,sothatbytheendofthesummeryouwillhavefiledfiveexamplesplusyourreflectionsoneachone.Theexpectationisthatyouwillhavefiveexamplesintotal–i.e.itdoesnotmatterwhichtopicstheyrelateto.ThesummerisusuallyaquiettimeinthepoliticalworldbutBrexitissettoensurethatthisisnotthecasethissummer.Paper1o TheGovernmentoftheUK

Ø ThenatureandsourcesoftheBritishConstitutionØ ThestructureandroleofParliamentØ ThePrimeMinisterandcabinetØ Thejudiciary

3http://www.quotecounterquote.com/2016/04/a-week-is-long-time-in-politics.html

4

o ThepoliticsoftheUKØ DemocracyandparticipationØ ElectionsandreferendumsØ PoliticalpartiesØ PressuregroupsØ TheEuropeanUnion

Paper2GovernmentandpoliticsoftheUSAandcomparativepoliticso GovernmentandpoliticsoftheUSA

Ø TheconstitutionalframeworkofUSgovernmentØ Thelegislativebranchofgovernment:CongressØ Theexecutivebranchofgovernment:PresidentØ ThejudicialbranchofgovernmentØ TheelectoralprocessanddirectdemocracyØ PoliticalpartiesØ PressuregroupsØ Civilrights

o Comparativepolitics

Ø ConstitutionalarrangementsØ TheexecutivesØ ThejudiciariesØ ElectoralandpartysystemsØ PressuregroupsØ Civilrights

InPaper3youwillalsostudyPoliticalideas’–the‘coreideologies’(liberalism,conservatism,andsocialism)andoneoptionalideology(outofanarchism,ecologism,feminism,multiculturalism,ornationalism).Themosthighlyrecommendedresourceofall(becauseitsucceedssowellinprovidingintelligentanalysiswhichisaccessiblywrittenwithoutbeingatalldumbeddown)ishttps://www.bbc.co.uk/news/politicsTrytheotherreading/listening/watchingrecommendationsbelow,withtheintentionofcontinuingwithwhatyoufindusefulandenjoyable.Fewsubjectscanoffersuchentertaininghomework.

o Thefollowingareallqualitynewspaperswhicharefreetoaccess:Ø https://www.theguardian.com/ukØ https://www.independent.co.uk/Ø https://www.telegraph.co.uk/

5

Ø https://www.nytimes.com/Ø http://www.washingtonpost.com/Ø https://www.washingtontimes.com/

o TVandRadio,whichcanbeaccessed,respectively,viahttps://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayerandhttp://www.bbc.co.uk/radioandhttps://www.itv.com/hub/shows(Beawarethattheseprogrammesarenotallavailablethroughouttheyearandthatschedulesmaychange):Ø Monday–Friday:PMRadio417:00–18:00;NewsnightBBC222:30–23:15Ø Tuesday:TheMashReportBBC222:00Ø Thursday:QuestionTimeBBC122:45–23:45;ThisWeekBBC123:45–00:45Ø Friday:TheNewsQuiz/TheNowShow/DeadRingersRadio418:30–19:00;HaveI

GotNewsForYouBBC121:00–21:30;TraceyBreakstheNewsBBC121:30–22:00;MocktheWeekBBC222:00–22:30

Ø Saturday:TheWeekinWestminsterRadio411:00–11:30Ø Sunday:TheAndrewMarrShowBBC109:00–10:00;Pienaar’sPoliticsRadio510:00

–11:00;PestononSundayITV10:00–11:00,repeated22:20–23:20

6

SynopticthinkingSynopticcanbebrokendowntosyn-,meaningtogether,and-optic,meaningvieworsight.Politicsisahighlysynopticsubjectand,asthespecificationadvises,“studentsmustidentifyparallels,connections,similaritiesanddifferencesbetweencontentstudied”.ThisisespeciallyimportantinComponent3,wherecomparisonswiththeUKneedtobemadewhenansweringexamquestionsontheUSA.Furthermore,thinkingsynopticallyaboutthetopicswithinComponents1and2,aswellasmakinglinksbetweenthetwocomponents,isaveryeffectivewaytodemonstrateahighlevelofunderstandingofPoliticsatALevel.Thismaywellsounddauntingbutsynopticthinkingisaskillthatcanbemasteredwithpracticeanditisalsoworthemphasisingthatyouarenotexpectedtostartthecoursewithanypriorknowledge:justthecommitmenttoacquiringit,includingthroughindependentstudy.ThetasksbelowwillgiveyousomeinsightintohowthisskillcanbeappliedtothemostrecentmajorpoliticaleventintheUK–thegeneralelectionof2017.Thiseventisstudied,toagreaterorlesserdegree,inallUKtopics.AtthetimewhenTheresaMaydecidedtocallthis‘snap’election,theConservativeshad331MPsandasmallmajorityoftwelve.Maybeganthecampaignwithanopinionpollleadindoublefiguresbutafterwardshadtodoa‘confidenceandsupply’dealwiththeDemocraticUnionistParty(DUP),whosetenMPscouldprovideamajorityincrucialvotesintheCommons–onthebudget(i.e.thesupplyofmoneyneededforthegovernmenttoimplementitslegislativeprogramme)andonanyvotesotherpartiesproposetobringthegovernmentdown(i.e.avoteof‘noconfidence’inthegovernment).

4

The2017UKParliamentarygeneralelectionwasheldonThursday8thJune.Theelectionwascalledearly,underSection2(1)oftheFixed-termParliamentsAct2011,afterthePrimeMinisterannouncedherintentionon18thAprilforanelectiontobeheld.Votingwasheldinall650constituenciesacrosstheUK:533inEngland,59inScotland,40inWalesand18inNorthernIreland.TheelectionresultedinahungParliament,withnosinglepartywinninganoverallmajority.TheConservativeParty,ledbyPrimeMinisterTheresaMay,wonthelargestnumberofseatsandvotes,taking317seatsand42.3%ofthevoteacrosstheUK.TheConservativesgained20seatsbutlost33,leavingthemwith317,13fewerthantheywonin2015.

TheLabourParty,ledbyJeremyCorbyn,won262seats,and40.0%ofthevote,upfrom232seatsand30.4%ofthevotein2015.TheConservatives’shareofthevoteisthehighestforanysinglepartysincethe43.2%wonbyLabourin1997,andtheirtotalof13.6millionvotesisthesecondhighesttotalinUKelectoralhistory.

4http://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/CBP-7979/CBP-7979.pdf

7

1. TheConservatives’shareofthevoteisthehighestforanysinglepartysincethe43.2%

wonbyLabourin1997,andtheirtotalof13.6millionvotesisthesecondhighesttotalinUKelectoralhistory.Why,then,isthe2017generalelectionresultseenassuchapooroutcomefortheConservativesingeneralandMayinparticular?

2. Maybeganthegeneralelectioncampaignwithanopinionpollleadindoublefigures.WhatdoestheoutcomeoftheelectionsuggestabouttheimportanceoftheconductoftheirrespectivecampaignsbytheConservativesandLabourandthenatureofthepoliciestheyofferedtotheelectorate?Note:ensurethatyouranswerreflectstheactualoutcomeoftheelection–i.e.thattheConservativeswonmorevotesandseatsthanLabour.

3. HowcertaincanMaybethatshewillbeabletowinvotesandsobeabletoimplementherlegislativeprogramme(onmattersotherthan‘confidenceandsupply’)?

4. Undertakeanindependentresearchtaskandwriteshortexplanationsoftheterms‘hardBrexit’and‘softBrexit’,whichcouldbeunderstoodbytypicalYear10students.

5. The‘confidenceandsupply’agreementwiththeDUPwillonlysucceedifConservativeMPssupportthepartyline.WhyisitavirtualcertaintythatConservativeMPswilldoso,evenonBrexit,despiteBrexiteersfearingthatthecountrywillnotgetthe‘hard’Brexitwhichtheyclaimiswhat“thepeoplevotedfor”andpro-EuropeanswhofearthedamagetotheUK’seconomythattheybelieveanythingotherthana‘soft’Brexitwilldo?

6. Collectiveministerialresponsibilityisaconvention(i.e.aprincipleofexpectedpractice)thatmembersofthecabinetmustpubliclysupportallgovernmentaldecisionsmadeincabinet,eveniftheydonotprivatelyagreewiththem.Iftheydonotdoso,itisexpectedthattheyeitherresignfromthegovernmentoraresackedbythePrimeMinister.BorisJohnson,theForeignSecretary,isthemostnotableexampleofacabinetmemberwhoisarepeatoffenderforbreakingthisconvention.ThishasmostfrequentlybeenontheissueofBrexit.a) WhatisrevealedaboutthestrengthandauthorityofMaythatshehasnotsacked

Johnson?b) WhatistheunderlyingreasonforyouranswertoQuestiona)?c) WhatisrevealedabouttheinfluenceofJohnsonwithinthecabinetwhenhe

criticisesgovernmentpolicyonBrexitoutsideofcabinetmeetings?

8

7. Politicalcartooniststypicallycrafttheircreationswithgreatattentiontodetailandcanproduceworkwhichoffersconsiderableinsight.Lookverycloselyatthetwoexamplesbelowandexplainwhatcanbelearntabouteachcartoonist’sviewofthe2017generalelection.

CartoonAbyDaveBrown,TheIndependent5

CartoonBbyGeraldScarfe,SundayTimes6

5https://www.indy100.com/article/cartoonists-react-general-election-2017-theresa-may-hung-parliament-77812416https://www.slideshare.net/jeffreyhill/uk-general-election-2017-cartoons

9

10keyfactstolearnforthestartofthecourseASwithanyALevelcourse,therearekeyfactsthatitisveryusefultolearnbecausetheycanbeexamplesthatillustratethepointsyouwanttomakeandprovidethebasisfromwhichyoucandevelopexplanationandevaluation.Youwillneedtolearnthefollowingkeyfacts,readyforatestinSeptember.Thetestwillreplicatetheinformationbelow–excepttherewillbegapsinwhichyouwillneedtowritewhatishighlightedhere.1. Namethepartyleader:

o Conservatives=TheresaMayo Labour=JeremyCorbyno LiberalDemocrats=VinceCableo SNP=NicolaSturgeono PlaidCymru=LeanneWoodo DUP=ArleneFostero Greens=CarolineLucasandJonathanBartley(Co-Leaders)o UKIP=GerardBatten

2. Inthe2016EUreferendum,Leavegained52%ofvotescomparedtoRemain’s48%.3. ‘Initiatives’occurinSwitzerlandandsomeUSstates,wherecitizensgathersignatures

onapetitionforapublicvoteonaproposednewlaw.Thesearesimilartoareferendumbuttheyareinitiated(started)bycitizens,notbyanationaloraregional/stategovernment.

4. Inthe2017generalelectiontheConservativeswon49%ofseatswith42%ofthevotes.5. Inthe2017generalelectiontheLiberalDemocratsgained1.8%ofseatswith7.4%of

thevotes.6. Turnoutinthe2017generalelection(at69%)wasthehighestin25years.7. Foreverytenyearsolderavoterwas,theirchanceofvotingToryin2017increasedby

aroundninepointsandthechanceoftheirvotingLabourdecreasedbyninepoints.The

10

tippingpoint,thatistheageatwhichavoterwasmorelikelytohavevotedConservativethanLabour,was47.

8. Ahungparliamentisaparliamentinwhichnosinglepartyhasmajoritycontrol.Eithera

minoritygovernmentoracoalitionwillthenresult.9. Anelectoralmanifestoisadocumentproducedbyapoliticalpartyatelectiontimes,

statingwhatpoliciesitintendstoimplementifitgainspower.10. Anelectoralmandatereferstotheauthoritytogoverngrantedtothewinningpartyat

anelectionbyvoters.Themandatesuggeststhatthegovernmentmayimplementthemeasuresinitselectionmanifesto.

11

©ThePiXLClubLtd.June2018ThisresourceisstrictlyfortheuseofmemberschoolsforaslongastheyremainmembersofThePiXLClub.Itmaynotbecopied,sold,ortransferredtoathirdpartyorusedbytheschoolaftermembershipceases.Untilsuchtimeitmaybefreelyusedwithinthememberschool.Allopinionsandcontributionsarethoseoftheauthors.Thecontentsofthisresourcearenotconnectedwith,orendorsedby,anyothercompany,organisationorinstitution.PiXL Club Ltd endeavour to trace and contact copyright owners. If there are any inadvertent omissions orerrors in the acknowledgements or usage, this is unintended and PiXL will remedy these on writtennotification.