Physics Revealed at Intermediate p T Rudolph C. Hwa University of Oregon Quark Matter 2008 Jaipur,...

Physics Revealed at Intermediate pT

Rudolph C. HwaUniversity of Oregon

Quark Matter 2008

Jaipur, India

February 6, 2008

low intermediate

pQCDhydro

no rigorous theoretical framework

But that is where the action is, albeit experimental.

What can we learn from the abundant data?

OverviewSingle particle distributionpT

Two particle correlation data

Near side Away side

Ridge Jet Double bump

Three particle correlation

(1 or 2 triggers)

Auto-correlation

(no trigger)

RCPdAu

decrease with

Huge p/ at =3.2

B/M ~ 1RCPp > RCP

RCPΛ,Ξ > RCP

⎝⎜

⎠⎟ univers

alquark number scaling&

breaking

OverviewSingle particle distributionpT

RCPdAu

decrease with

Huge p/ at =3.2

Two particle correlation data

Near side Away side

Ridge Jet Double bump

Three particle correlation

(1 or 2 triggers)

Auto-correlation

(no trigger)

B/M ~ 1RCPp > RCP

RCPΛ,Ξ > RCP

⎝⎜

⎠⎟ univers

alquark number scaling&

breaking

Recombination at Intermediate

partons

hadronsReco

What partons?

Medium effects

u, d, sg converted

to qc,b,t primordial

QuickTime™ and aTIFF (LZW) decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

in recombination/coalescence model (Reco)

Baryon/Meson ratios

“Baryon anomaly”On the contrary, high B/M ratio is a signature of Reco. Baryons need less quark momenta than

mesons.

implies that fragmentation is normal.

Elliptic flow

v2M (pT )=v2

T q1( ) + v2T q2( ) v2

B (pT )=v2T q1( ) + v2

T q2( ) + v2T q3( )

M: TT + TS + SS B: TTT + TTS + TSS + SSS

Ifq1 =q2 =q3 =pT / 3

q1 =q2 =pT / 2 then

⎛⎝⎜

⎞⎠⎟;

3⎛⎝⎜

⎞⎠⎟

v2 / nq

pT → KET

Molnar & Voloshin, PRL91,(2003)

quark number scaling(QNS)

a property of naïve recombination

RH&CBY,0801.2183

STAR, PRC75,054906(07)

minbias

However, at larger KET

M: TT + TS + SS B: TTT + TTS + TSS + SSS

v2M (pT )≈v2

T q1( ) + v2S q2( ) v2

B (pT )≈v2T q1( ) + v2

T q2( ) + v2S q3( )

q1 ≠q2v2T ≠v2

⎛⎝⎜

⎞⎠⎟≠

3⎛⎝⎜

⎞⎠⎟

QNS is broken, but hadronization is still by recombination

BRAHMS, nucl-ex/0602018Au+Au at 62.4 GeV Forward production

xF = 0.9

xF = 0.8

xF = 1.0

Shower partons are suppressed at the kinematical boundaryFew

antiquarks at large

mainly p produced

BRAHMS(preliminary)

Comments at the end, if asked.

Ridgeology

Putschke, QM06

Correlation on the near side

ridge R Jet J

Properties of Ridge YieldDependences on Npart, pT,trig, pT,assoc, trigger B/M ratio in the ridge

Jet+Ridge ()

Jet ()

Putschke, QM06

1. Dependence on Nparton pT,trig2.

pt,assoc. > 2 GeVSTAR preliminary

Ridge is correlated to jet production. Surface bias of jet ridge is due to medium effect near the surface

Medium effect near surface

Ridges observed at any pT,trig

Ridge yield 0as Npart 0

depends on medium

3. Dependence on trigger

QuickTime™ and aTIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor

STAR (preliminary)

A. Feng

20-60%, 3-4:1.5-2

Ridge develops by radial flow near the jet axis

Mismatch of T and the direction of radial expansion.

has more ridge yield than

Ridge yield decreases with increasing s

Comments at the end, if asked.

Putschke, QM06

4. Dependence on pT,assoc

Yet Ridge is correlated to jet production; thermal does not mean no correlation.

Ridge is from thermal source enhanced by energy loss by semi-hard partons traversing the medium.

Ridge is exponential in pT,assoc slope independent of pT,trigExponential behavior

implies thermal source.

5. B/M ratio in the ridge

Ridge hadrons are formed by recombination

Large B/M

Bielcikova, WWND07

Λ + ΛK

pt,assoc. > 2 GeV

Au+Au 0-10%

Putschke, QM06p

2-4p(R) / p(J )

(R) / (J )

Medium effect near surface coordinated with radial flow

trigger

TT ridge (R)

associated particles

These wings are useful to identify the RidgeBut of interest below is

mainly the distribution.

Ridge is from enhanced thermal source caused by semi-hard scattering.

Recombination of partons in the ridge

peak (J)

What are the consequences of Ridgeology?

1. Jet correlation at low and intermediate pT

2. Effect on single particle spectra

3. Effect on elliptic flow

PHENIX

2.5<pT,trig<4 GeV/c

1.8<pT,assoc<2.5

)Peak is referred to as jet

1. Jet correlation at intermediate pT

Not seeing the ridge does not mean that it is not there.

Correlation in J is different from correlation in R

Does not see the ridge

||<0.35

STAR preliminary

Jet + RidgePHENIX, PLB 649,359(07)

Not un-correlated. Ridge would not be there without semi-hard scattering.

How can intermediate-pt Jet yield be independent of centrality?

PHENIX data cannot be properly understood without taking Ridge into account

2.5<pT,trig<4.0 GeV/c

PHENIX 0712.3033

2p(R) / p(J )

(R) / (J )

pt,assoc. > 2 GeV

Au+Au 0-10%

Putschke, QM06p

2. Effect of Ridge on single-particle spectra

Semi-hard scattering at kT~2-3 GeV/c is pervasive.

Ridges are present with or without triggers.

STAR, PRC 73, 064907 (2006)

Auto-correlation without triggers.

0.15<pt<2.0 GeV/c, ||<1.3, at 130 GeV

Bulk+Ridge

Semi-hard partons generating ridge

Fragments from hard partons

(fragmentation)

T includes enhanced thermal partons --- Ridge

How can we see better the TT component?

Remove the TS and SS components, if possible.

production: Au+Au + anything

(sss) s quark suppressed in shower

Exposes the long exponential behavior in production

spectrum is exponential (thermal)

are needed to see this picture.Chiu & Hwa, PRC76,024904(2007)

How can it have correlated partners? --- the puzzle.

Resolution: Both and its associated hadrons are in the Ridge.

Prediction: there is no peak (J) in the distribution --- only R

R only

= cos-1(b/2R)

If the semi-hard jets are soft enough, there are many of them, all restricted to || < .

A semi-hard scattering near the surface gives rise to a jet, whose direction, on average, is normal to the surface.

Initial configuration

There is a layer of ridges at the surface without triggers.

3. Effect of Ridge on elliptic flow

In momentum space

pTdpTdφ=B(pT ) + R(pT )Θ(φ)

v2 (pT )= cos2φ =sin2(b)

B(pT ) / R(pT ) + 2(b)

Relate ridgeology to v2 Hwa, 0708.1508

Use data on B(pT) and R(pT)

bow tie region

Elliptic flow at low pT

v2 driven by Ridge

Made no assumption about rapid thermalization.

Elliptic flow at intermediate pT

v2 dominated by TS recombination

Hwa & CB Yang, 0801.2183

Away-side correlation

PHENIX 0705.3238 & .3060

Double-bump first observed by STAR

STAR, PRL 95, 152301 (05)

has been studied extensively --- experimentally and theoretically.

Mach conegluon radiation

Cherenkov radiation deflected jets …

Is there any connection between the double bumps and ridge w/o peak(J)?

mild dependence of D on pt,assoc favors

Possible relationship between ridge and bump (Renk, Jia)

Near side Away side

Ridge Bump

Generated by semi-hard scattering

Mach cone, deflected jet,--- due to recoil of semi-hard parton

Due to recombination of enhanced thermal partons

What is partonic structure of the Mach-shock-wave?

Exponential pt,assoc Distribution in pt,assoc ?

Large B/M ratio B/M ratio is also large.

Papers submitted to the session on: “Response of Medium to Jets”

Experimental

Netrakanti (STAR)Wenger (PHOBOS)McCumber (PHENIX)Suarez (STAR)Feng (STAR)Adare (PHENIX)Barannikova (STAR)Catu (STAR)Daugherity (STAR)Pei (PHENIX)Haag (STAR)Szuba (NA49)G. Ma (STAR)Wang (STAR)Noferini (ALICE)Chetluru (UIC)

TheoreticalMajumder

C.Y.Wong

Mizukawa, Hirano, Isse, Nara, Ohnishi

Pantuev

Lokhtin, Petrushanko, Snigirev, Sarycheva

Levai, Barnafoldi, Fai

Betz, Gyulassy, Rischke, Stoecker, Torrieri

Molnar

Asakawa, Mueller, Neufeld, Nonaka, Puppert

Schenke, Dumitru, Nara, Strickland

BauchlePlenary session X Ulery

On to LHCMany predictions made (see arXiv:0711.0974)

Those with existing codes can make extrapolations.

Eskola et al (EKRT model)

Is there new physics that cannot be obtained by extrapolation?

hard parton

hadron

energy loss

Density of semi-hard partons is high at LHC.

semi-hard partons

SS or SSS recombination to form or p.

What is the bulk background at LHC?

Since SS and SSS recombination of semi-hard partons are uncorrelated, they occur in mixed events.

Thus they belong to the background.

But those partons are not thermal, not in hydro.

Can Ridge be identified in association with a high pT trigger --- pT,trig > 20 GeV/c?

The ridge may not stand out among the background that consists of TT, TS, SS, TTT, TTS, TSS, SSS hadrons.

Physics at intermediate pT at LHC may be very different from that at RHIC ----- cannot be obtained by extrapolation.

So there is a mismatch between bg and hydro.

Summary

Physics revealed by phenomena observed at intermediate pT

soft & semi-hard partons

Large B/M ratio

QN scaling and breaking

Exponential pT at large

Double bump

Reco at LHC

Backup slides

At large xF, proton can be formed by leading quarks from different nucleons. dxi

∏⎛

⎝⎜⎞

⎠⎟∫ Fνu(x1)Fν

u(x2 )Fνd(x3)Rp(x1,x2 ,x3,x)

p x can exceed 1

Antiquarks at low xi are affected by the regeneration of that depends on .qq

Pions are suppressed due to the lack of antiquarks at large xi.

BRAHMS (preliminary)

should be larger less degradation more protons less increase of pions larger p/ ratio

~0.75 Hwa & CBYang, PRC76,104901(2007)

momenta degraded survival probability

“baryon stopping”

Forward production

QuickTime™ and aTIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor

STAR (preliminary)

A. Feng

20-60%, 3-4:1.5-2

3. Dependence on trigger

Ridge develops by radial flow near the jet axis

Ridge yield decreases with increasing sMismatch of T and the direction of radial expansion.

has more ridge yield than

Physics Revealed at Intermediate p T Rudolph C. Hwa University of Oregon Quark Matter 2008 Jaipur,...

Documents

HWA Original Study

Rudolph 1a) The Story of Rudolph - IPA Productionsipaproductions.com/activities/rudolph/ipa-activities-rudolph.pdf · Read the story of Rudolph. 1a) The Story of Rudolph R udolph

Rudolph Dreikurs

Rudolph Arnheim

Resolution of Several Puzzles at Intermediate p T and Recent Developments in Correlation Rudolph C. Hwa University of Oregon Quark Matter 05 Budapest,

Phantom Jets: the puzzle and v 2 without hydrodynamics Rudolph C. Hwa University of Oregon Early Time Dynamics in Heavy Ion Collisions Montreal, July

Hwa Lss2 Eoyexam2009

1 High-p T Physics at RHIC and Evidences of Recombination Rudolph C. Hwa University of Oregon International Symposium on Multiparticle Dynamics Sonoma,

Rudolph, 1978; Lister, Walter, Versmold, Dallman& Rudolph, 1979

Large p/ Ratio without Jet Correlations at RHIC and LHC Rudolph C. Hwa University of Oregon November 14-20, 2006 Shanghai, China The Omega challenge

B O O K B U BS - Wollondilly Library · 2020. 3. 9. · Christmas Farewell Song Rudolph. Rudolph turn around Rudolph , Rudolph touch the ground Rudolph, Rudolph touch your nose Rudolph,

Hadronization of Partons by Recombination Rudolph C. Hwa University of Oregon Summer School on RHIC Physics Wuhan, China, June 2005

Hwa Tvcg04 Revised

Paul Rudolph. For Perspecta Paul Rudolph 1961

HWA 4Q14 Newsletter

1 Parton Recombination at all p T Rudolph C. Hwa University of Oregon Hard Probes 2004 Ericeira, Portugal, November 2004

Tech Reference Hwa

2008 Nepal, Nagarkot [Hwa Chong Institution]

Correlation in Jets Rudolph C. Hwa University of Oregon Workshop on Correlation and Fluctuation in Multiparticle Production Hangzhou, China November 21-24,

Hwa Adamar