View
217
Download
0
Category
Preview:
DESCRIPTION
Healing Justice Restorative Justice seeks to develop community-based responses to crime and violence by using dialogue repair of harm peace-building to heal victims and bolster social harmony
Citation preview
Philosophy of Islamic Punishments
Criminal Law Theories of Criminal Law
Crime as conduct that is prohibited by the state because of its harm to society, necessarily eliciting state response in terms of retribution
Utilitarianists view punishment as a deterrent to potential offenders, creating a criminal-focused system
Rehabilitationists view punishment as a way to reform or cure the offender, again focusing on the offender rather than the victim
Healing Justice Restorative Justice seeks to develop community-based responses to
crime and violence by using
dialogue
repair of harm
peace-building
to heal victims and bolster social harmony
Restorative Justice Restorative Justice is NOT a method or program but relies on
basic principles of
Repentance Forgiveness Reconciliation
All three are central to many religions and can help mediate between the criminal justice system and multi-religious, pluralist societies
Basis for Islamic Law
There are two primary sources of Islamic law Qur’an
Sunnah/Hadith, the life, sayings, and example of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)
There are three methods for deriving the law from these sources Ijma’: consensus of community (democratic)
Qiyas: analogies (precedent-based)
Ijtihad: independent reasoning
Islam and Restorative Justice: Crime
Human nature and Society derive from the nature of God – which is healing in essence: “If anyone does evil or wrongs his own soul, but afterwards seeks Allah’s
forgiveness, he will find Allah oft-Forgiving, most Merciful.” (al-Nisa:110)
“The recompense for an injury is an injury equal thereto (in degree); but if a person forgives
and makes reconciliation, his reward is due from Allah.” (al-Shura:40)
Islam and Restorative Justice: Punishment
Crimes are viewed as offending both God and society in different aspects
Crimes are thus categorized into three main types and require distinct punishments:
HududQuisasTa’zir
Islam and Punishment: Hudud
Hudud – Theft, adultery, slander, rebellion, apostasy, Drinking, Killing
The most serious of crimes whose punishment is mandated by the Qur’an, not by a judge
Islam and Punishment: Hudud
Hudud crimes apply only in a just society, thus such charges have been nulled when society itself was not just
Cutting-off hands for stealing was universally dropped during the reign of the second Caliph due to a famine – i.e. a starving society is not just
In practice, Do the grave punishments for Hudud crimes (death, cutting-off of hands) prevents reconciliation ?
However, the harsh retributive punishments of Hudud crimes and evidentiary burdens may cause the judge
decision-maker to nullify the Hudud crimes and press for Quisas or Ta’zir crimes, which enable more restorative efforts
Islam and Punishment: Quisas
Quisas – murder (voluntary & involuntary), crimes against person
Qur’an does not demand a specific punishment
Qur’an presents a range of penal, compensatory and reconciliatory measures from which to choose, and often suggests relying on healing principles
Islam and Punishment: Quisas
Restorative punishments
Complete Forgiveness:
requires victim to forgive before death
All other cases require Diyya and Sohl and are victim-initiated:
Diyya – offender agrees to monetary payment to victim Sohl – negotiated reconciliation
in the presence of a Wali Amr – appointed guardian
Islam and Punishment: Quisas
Qur’an cautions against relying on retaliatory measures
“We ordained therein for them life for life, eye for eye, nose for nose, ear for ear, tooth for tooth and wounds for equal. Anyone remits the retaliation by way of charity, it is an act of atonement.” (al-Maidah:45)
“O ye who believe the law of equality is prescribed to you in cases of murder: the free for the free, the slave for the slave, the woman for the woman. But if any forgiveness is made by the brother of the slain, then grant any reasonable demand, and compensate him with handsome gratitude. This is a concession and a mercy from God.”
(al-Baqarah: 178)
Islam and Punishment: Ta’zir
Ta’zir – chastisement of bad behavior; applies mostly to violations of private rights All crimes where the Qur’an or Sunna do not prescribe a specific punishment
Rule-makers have discretion on instituting penalties Focus on forgiveness and minimum of
punitive measures
Aim is to rehabilitate the criminal and
restore the public good
Death row in USA
1. If you kill a police officer/ jail warden2. Murder whilst kidnapping, theft,
robbery etc3. Murder during prison escape4. Multiple murders (serial killers)5. Murder of an individual under six
years of age
Purposes of punishment
DeterrenceIf we punish harshly enough, it will put other people off doing the same crime
RetributionIt should be about making someone pay for what they have done, and be seen by others to be punished
ReformPunishment should be about trying to make a person realised that what they did was wrong and make them never want to do it again
ProtectionPrison etc takes the dangerous people out of society and so keeps everyone else safe
The Theory of punishment punishments should be about
CompensationUsing punishment to allow a criminal to make right their wrong to their victim or to society. Community service is an example of this
Purposes of punishment
DeterrenceSome crimes are in the heat of the moment, so the consequences are not thought about
RevengeBut does this work as well for someone who assists someone with voluntary
ReformHow can you tell if someone is reformed? Will society be happy in using tax payers money to pay for a criminal to be retrained as a plumber etc?
ProtectionNot all crimes are dangerous to the safety of others so this wouldn’t always work e.g a debtor
But what are the problems with these theories behind punishing?
CompensationHow can a murderer or drink driver make amends to their victim’s family?
Arguments about Capital Punishment:
Against:o There have been many
cases of the innocent executed
o Countries with execution still seem to have high crime rates!
o It may force some criminals to kill rather than be caught
o Human Right
For:o The death penalty is a
deterrent for those thinking about committing a serious crime
o It means society can rid itself of dangerous people so they can’t be a treat again
o It is cheaper than keeping someone in prison for life
o It is a fair punishment for those who commit the most horrendous crimes
Christianity on Capital Punishment:1. St Paul said “Do not repay anyone evil with evil”
(Romans 12); 2. They also believe in the Sanctity of life – all life is holy
and belongs to God so it is not up to people to take anyone’s life
3. It also goes against the idea of reform 4. The Decalogue says “Do not kill”
However, other Christians believe it is a way of preventing serious crime as:
1. The Old Testament allows capital punishment 2. That peace and order in society is more important than
reforming a wrongdoer3. It has been used in the past by Christians4. “Whoever curses his father or his mother is to be put to
death” Matthew 15 !
There are 2 Muslim views 1. The Qur’an says that it
may be allowed in just causes – murder, adultery and working against Islam
2. “Take not life – which God has made sacred – except for a just cause” (Hadith).
3. Also, Muhammad also sentenced murderers to death and so Muslims may follow his example
4. Shari’ah law allows the death penalty for deliberate murder
However,
1. The Qur’an does not allow it for all crimes, and does allow the criminal to pay a victim or their family ‘blood money’ instead (compensation)
2. Muslims may use the non-religious arguments too
Amnesty International A non-religious organisation who disagree with capital punishment
Amnesty work for justice and to ensure that everyone has Human Rights.
They believe that no matter what someone has done, the death penalty goes against Human Rights.
Recommended