View
3
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
Personal Auto Insurance
10.0 Hours | 157 Pages | 12 Lessons | 13 Quizzes | 1 Online Final
Personal Auto Insurance • 2
Personal Auto Insurance
Developed by 360training www.360training.com
This course discusses the basic tenets of personal auto insurance in detail. It outlines the duties that the insurer must perform along with what the insurer should expect from the insured. Multiple practice questions are provided at the end of each lesson to test the student’s knowledge. Upon completion of this course the student will:
• Be able to identify the coverage offered under personal auto insurance.
• Be able to understand the different parts of PAP. • Be familiar with endorsements that can be attached to the
policy. • Be able to understand his/her duty towards the insured.
This course includes:
• 12 Lessons
• 1 Pre-Assessment Quiz and 12 Lesson Quizzes
• 1 Online Final Exam
Personal Auto Insurance • 3
Disclaimer: The material presented within this course is for informational and educational purposes only. It should not be used to provide guidance to your customers or clients in lieu of competent, certified legal advice. All parties involved in the development of this course shall not be liable for any inappropriate use of this information beyond the purpose stated above. As a student, you should understand that it is your responsibility to adhere to the laws and regulations pertaining to any aspect of this course and the materials presented within.
Personal Auto Insurance • 4
Table of Contents
• Pre-Assessment Quiz p. 7
• Lesson One: Introduction to Personal Auto Insurance p. 11
• Lesson Two: The Personal Auto Policy p. 39
• Lesson Three: Part A: Liability Coverage p. 52
• Lesson Four: Part B: Medical Payments Coverage p. 72
• Lesson Five: Part C: Uninsured Motorists Coverage p. 79
• Lesson Six: Part D: Coverage for Physical Damage to Your Auto p. 88
• Lesson Seven: Part E: Duties after an Accident or Loss p. 111
• Lesson Eight: Part F: General Provisions p. 116
• Lesson Nine: Endorsements and ACORD Forms p. 122
• Lesson Ten: “No Fault” Insurance p. 136 • Lesson Eleven: Determining Auto Insurance
Premiums p. 142
• Lesson Twelve: Underwriters p. 150
Personal Auto Insurance • 5
KEY TERMS
Appraisal: Appraisal settles disputes between the insurer and the insured regarding the amount of a first person property loss.
Auto liability coverage: This coverage protects insureds against claims for bodily injury and property damage arising out of use of an auto. Bodily Injury: PAP defines bodily injury as bodily harm, sickness, or disease and resulting death. Concealment occurs when an insured withholds or hides information an insurer is entitled to know. Deductible: Deductible is the portion of a loss that is not paid by insurance. Jurisdiction is the geographical area in which a court has power to hear a case. Loss of consortium: Loss of consortium refers to loss of spousal sex, society, and services. Occupying: PAP defines occupying to mean “in, upon, getting in, on, out, or off” the insured vehicle. PAP: PAP is the acronym for Personal Auto Policy, an insurance policy purchased for vehicle used for personal use. PAP meets a family’s needs for auto liability and physical damage coverage. PIP: PIP is the acronym for Personal Injury Protection. It provides no-fault benefits for medical expenses, lost earnings, hiring others to do domestic chores, funeral expenses, and, sometimes, survivors’ compensatory benefits. Stacking: Stacking occurs when an insured with more than one vehicle combines the limits of liability to obtain a higher total limit. Stacking is the theory under which an insured argues that his/her policy limit should apply separately to each claimant from a single accident even though he/she has single limit coverage or his/her limit should be multiplied by the number of vehicles insured under the policy.
Subrogation: Subrogation is the insurer’s right to recover its payments from the negligent third party.
Personal Auto Insurance • 6
VIN: VIN is the acronym for Vehicle Identification Number. It is an auto’s unique identification number with a combination of letters and numbers that indicates manufacturer, vehicle attributes, and production sequence. WC: Abbreviates workers’ compensation. Workers’ compensation insurance pays all benefits required by the WC law of any state listed in the policy declarations.
Personal Auto Insurance • 7
Pre-Assessment Quiz
Take the following quiz and see how you do! How much do you already know about personal auto insurance? 1. Jane was driving Olive’s Mercedes when she collided with a trailer and fractured her arm. Based on this information, which of the following is the most appropriate action to be taken by Olive’s insurance agency?
Share the damage expenses with Jane’s insurance agency. Verify whether the insurance coverage meets the expenses. Ensure that Jane owns an auto insurance policy. Make a payment under Olive’s policy with regard to the extent of damage.
2. Which of the following are paid for as supplementary payments?
Bond costs of up to $350 Post-judgment interest payments Costs incurred due to bodily injury Costs of repairing damaged property
3. Which of the following best describes an uninsured motorist?
A motorist operating his/her brother’s vehicle A motorist operating a self-insured vehicle A motorist operating a government-owned vehicle A motorist whose vehicle is insured by an insolvent insurer
4. Two parties involved in an accident decide to settle the matter through arbitration. There were three individuals involved, the two arbitrators and a third umpire. Given that neither of the three could agree on one solution, which would be the best way to decide the matter?
Consider the umpire’s decision as final. Take the advice of a third party. Draw chits. Implement the decision on which at least two out of the three agree.
Personal Auto Insurance • 8
5. Which one of the following duties is NOT to be performed by the insured immediately after an accident occurs?
Make a settlement with the other party Inform the police Provide the insurer with the details of loss Protect the auto from further damage
Personal Auto Insurance • 9
Pre-Assessment Quiz Answer Key
1.
Make a payment under Olive’s policy with regard to the extent of damage.*
Auto insurance is tied to the vehicle, not to the vehicle owner. Thus anyone operating the vehicle with the owner’s permission is covered, along with passengers and the insured’s family members. Thus the most appropriate thing for Olive’s insurance agency to do would be to pay for damages caused, as long as they are within the limit of insurance.
2.
Post-judgment interest payments*
Supplementary payments include: Up to $200 a day for lost wages when the insured is required to attend a legal hearing or trial, bail bond costs up to $250 if required due to an accident resulting in covered liability and post judgment interest payments. Payments for bodily injury and damaged property are not made as supplementary payments.
3.
A motorist whose vehicle is insured by an insolvent insurer* When an insurer declares insolvency, the insured is not covered and thus, if an accident occurs, the motorist is considered to be uninsured. Vehicles owned by the government are not considered uninsured vehicles.
4.
Implement the decision on which at least two out of the three agree.* When settling any matter through arbitration, the two arbitrators appoint a third, whose cost is shared by the insurers. The decision of any two individuals out of the three is be final.
Personal Auto Insurance • 10
5.
Make a settlement with the other party*
The insured is required to perform all the listed actions except for reaching a settlement. A settlement is usually reached amongst the insurers of both the parties involved. It is the insurer’s job to reach a settlement, not the insureds.
Personal Auto Insurance • 11
LESSON 1: Introduction to Personal Auto
Insurance
What Is Personal Auto Insurance?
Auto insurance is one of the most important forms of insurance that a consumer
must think about. It falls under the category of property insurance, and one's
automobile is often the most expensive and most necessary piece of property
that one owns.
Personal auto insurance provides coverage for only those vehicles which are
acquired for private use. Any vehicle that is used for commercial purposes
cannot be insured under personal auto insurance.
Why Is Auto Insurance Mandated?
It is estimated that there are between 40,000 & 50,000 deaths each year due to
automobile accidents. Additionally, there are over 5 million injuries. These two
statistics result from more than 30 million auto accidents each year. There are
also economic losses. This puts auto insurance in the # 1 position as the largest
form of Property & Casualty coverage.
Most states require owners of automobiles to carry a minimum amount of bodily
injury and property damage liability insurance. Owners are also required to show
Personal Auto Insurance • 12
proof of financial responsibility when involved in an accident or ticketed. Proof of
financial responsibility is now also required for license renewal.
The Basis of Legal Liability and How Personal Auto
Insurance Protects Insureds From Its Financial
Consequences
Whenever an accident occurs, the owners of the vehicles involved are
responsible for the resulting expenses. One part of personal auto insurance
deals with liability coverage. All damages are paid for under this section
irrespective of who was operating the vehicle, provided that the operator had a
driving license and was operating the vehicle with the owner’s consent.
It should be noted here that liability coverage is only valid for the vehicle for
which it was issued. For example, Jerry owns a BMW insured under personal
auto insurance. While Jerry was operating his neighbor’s insured black
limousine, he had an accident. Jerry’s auto insurance will not pay for any of the
damages; the limousine owner is liable for the loss.
Who Does It Cover?
Any injuries sustained in an accident involving the insured vehicle are covered
under auto insurance. Coverage is not only provided to the insured, but to any/all
Personal Auto Insurance • 13
of his/her family members who operate the vehicle with the owner’s permission,
or individuals who were riding in it at the time of the accident.
What Does It Cover?
Personal auto insurance pays for medical expenses and for work lost due to
injury. Auto insurance protects the insured’s financial security in case of a lawsuit
that results from loss or injuries to other parties following an accident involving a
member of the family, or a friend or a relative that had been given permission to
drive the car by the insured or the insured’s spouse,.
Eligible Vehicles
All four-wheel motor vehicles licensed for use on public roads can be insured
under personal auto insurance if they are:
Owned by the insured and/or
Leased by the insured for more than six months, including vans or pickups
weighing less than 10,000 pounds that are not used in a freight or delivery
business.
Note: The policy can be endorsed to cover motor homes, motorcycles, golf carts,
and snowmobiles.
After an insured acquires an auto insurance policy, all of the following vehicles
are covered:
Personal Auto Insurance • 14
Any vehicle identified in the declarations
Any newly acquired auto, which includes:
Autos for which insurance is requested within 14 days of acquisition
provided that the autos were acquired during the policy period. Until the
time the specific auto is insured, the insurer should have insured the auto
as broadly as any insured vehicle under the policy.
Any replacement auto acquired during the policy period which receives
the broadest coverage available to any insured vehicle.
� The insured must notify the insurer within 14 days in order to
continue physical damage coverage.
� If none of the insured vehicles are covered for physical
damage the insurer must be notified, within four days,that
physical damage coverage is required.
Any owned trailer;
Any non-owned auto or trailer used as a temporary substitute vehicle for
one that’s broken down, lost, destroyed, or being repaired or serviced.
What Is The Basic Provided Coverage?
Automobile liability addresses third-party claims for bodily injury and property
damage arising out of the insured’s negligent operation of an automobile. In
Illinois, motorists are required to have some minimum levels of coverage set forth
Personal Auto Insurance • 15
by state statutes.
More than 150 million drivers and roughly 110 million private passenger cars are
insured in the United States.
Coverage is basically provided in the following areas:
• Liability Coverage
• Medical Payments
• Uninsured Motorist Coverage
• Physical Damage to an Automobile
What Is The Basic Structure Of The Personal Auto
Policy?
The personal auto policy or PAP is designed for personal auto exposure, not
commercial. It insures private passenger autos, such as cars, vans, SUVs, and
pickup trucks. Motorcycles, golf carts, motorhomes, and snowmobiles may be
added by endorsement.
A Personal Auto Policy consists of:
• A declaration page
• An agreement and definitions page
• Four coverage parts
• Two duties or provision parts
Personal Auto Insurance • 16
• Optional endorsements
The policy form contains four separate coverages, each with its own insuring
agreement, exclusions, and conditions. They are:
• Part A – Liability Coverage
• Part B – Medical Payments Coverage
• Part C – Uninsured Motorists Coverage
• Part D – Coverage for Damage to Your Auto (Physical Damage)
A Personal Umbrella Policy
A Personal Umbrella Policy provides excess coverage over underlying PAP and
HO (homeowner) liability policies. The umbrella policy pays up to its limit after
the required underlying insurance is exhausted.
Umbrella policies have broad insuring agreements with very few exclusions.
When the agreement provides coverage for which there is no underlying policy,
the insured must absorb a deductible, usually $250, which is known as a self-
insured retention (SIR).
Basic Definitions
Jurisdiction is the geographical area in which a court has power to hear a case.
Concealment occurs when an insured withholds or hides information an insurer
Personal Auto Insurance • 17
is entitled to know.
Three Legal Principles in Policy Interpretation:
• Contract Of Adhesion
Insurance policies are contracts of adhesion since they are drafted by one
party (the insurer) and presented to the other party (the insured) on a “take it
or leave it” basis. Thus, courts interpret every ambiguity in favor of the
insured. If a term is not specifically defined, courts use the term’s common
meaning.
• Doctrine Of Reasonable Expectations
Under certain, unusual circumstances, a court will interpret an insurance
policy to include coverages that a reasonable person would expect it to
include; even if the policy’s specific provisions exclude the coverage.
• Public Policy
Because insurance is a business concerned with the public interest, a court
might impose coverage if a policy provision acts against the interests of the
general public.
Family Member
A “family member” is defined as anyone who is residing with the named insured
and is related to him/her by blood, marriage, or adoption. Family members are
considered as insureds.
Personal Auto Insurance • 18
Four Factors Considered In Determining Residence
When determining residence the court evaluates:
• The person’s actions and intentions
• The duration and nature of the person’s stays in the household
• The person’s permanency of attachment to the household
• The closeness of the relationship between the person and the insured
“Claim Representative (CR) Solutions” For Determining Residence
The CR should ask the following questions:
• Does the person eat meals, receive mail, store personal belongings, and/or
maintain a room in the residence?
• What is the frequency and duration of the person’s presence in the
residence?
• Does the person pay rent, utilities, or maintenance expenses for the
residence?
• What is the address on the person’s driver’s license, tax return, and voter
registration card?
• Where does the person garage his vehicle?
Issues Concerning the Residency of Children
• Children away at school or in the military are considered to be residents of the
parental household if they intend to return to the family home.
• Emancipated children are not usually considered residents of their parents’
Personal Auto Insurance • 19
household if they are completely independent of parental support and control.
• Children of divorced parents may be considered residents of the non-
custodial parent’s household depending on the nature, duration, frequency,
and regularity of their visits.
“Claim Representative (CR) Solutions” For Determining Residency of
Children
The CR should ask the following questions:
• Is the child financially dependent on the parent?
• What is the intent of the child and of the parent?
• What is the frequency and duration of visits?
• What is the relationship between the parent and the child?
• Does the child have a key?
• Does the child have his own room?
• Does the child store personal belongings in the residence?
• How old is the child?
• Does the parent have regular visitation rights?
Occupying
The PAP defines occupying a vehicle as being “in, upon, getting in, on, out, or
off” the vehicle. Medical payment coverage under PAP covers all individuals who
sustain injury while occupying the insured vehicle. It must be noted that the
insured and his/her family members are covered irrespective of whether the
Personal Auto Insurance • 20
vehicle they occupied was insured.
NOTE: Except by endorsement, the PAP excludes bodily injury sustained while
“occupying” any vehicle with fewer than four wheels.
Questions of interpretation arise when injury occurs shortly after someone has
exited a covered auto.
Physical Contact Test
The physical contact test requires the injured person to have physical contact
with the vehicle at the time of injury. However, courts are often reluctant to
impose coverage for accidents unrelated to the normal, intended use of the
vehicle. (An example of this is using the car to steady a gun while deer hunting.)
Sufficient Proximity and Vehicle Orientation Test
The sufficient proximity and vehicle orientation test requires proximity (nearness)
and orientation (relationship) to the insured vehicle.
“Claim Representative (CR) Solutions” For Determining Occupancy
• What was the person doing when injured?
• Was the pre-injury activity vehicle-orientated? (For example, a gun backfiring
while hunting would not be a vehicle-orientated activity.)
• How close was the person to the vehicle?
• Does this jurisdiction use the physical contact test or the proximity and
orientation test?
Personal Auto Insurance • 21
Bodily Injury
The PAP defines bodily injury as bodily harm, sickness, or disease and resulting
death. Courts are divided regarding whether emotional injury claims are
considered “bodily injury”.
Claims for Emotional Injury
Not all courts recognize a cause of action for emotional injury. They are more
likely to recognize a purely emotional (non-physical) injury claim if the claimant
was within the zone of danger, or suffered physical symptoms resulting from
emotional distress.
PAP Coverage for Emotional Injury
The majority of courts hold that a purely emotional injury is not “bodily injury”
within the PAP definition.
“Claim Representative (CR) Solutions” For Determining Coverage for
Emotional Injury
• Do the courts in this jurisdiction recognize claims for non-physical injury?
• Do the courts in this jurisdiction consider purely non-physical claims to be
“bodily injury” under the PAP?
• Did the person witness injury to a spouse or child?
• Was the person within the zone of danger?
Personal Auto Insurance • 22
• Did the person suffer physical manifestations of the emotional injury?
Employees
The Business Auto Coverage Form (BAC) covers employees of the named
insured.
An Independent Contractor
An independent contractor might be considered an employee, depending on the
degree of control, the length of employment, and the manner of compensation.
“Claim Representative (CR) Solutions” For Distinguishing Employees and
Independent Contractors
• How much control does the employer exercise?
• Does the position require training or special skills not held by other
employees?
• Does the employer provide tools, materials, and equipment?
• Is the work performed on the employer’s premises?
• How is the worker paid?
• Are the services integrated into business operations?
• Is this an ongoing relationship?
• Does the employer impose time constraints?
• Does the worker work exclusively for this employer?
• Can the employer fire the worker? Can the worker quit?
Personal Auto Insurance • 23
• Can the worker hire assistants?
• Does the worker provide personal services?
• What reporting requirements exist?
• Does the employer pay business and travel expenses?
• Can the worker realize a profit or loss?
Liability Coverage
Insuring Agreement
The insurer will pay damages for bodily injury (BI) and property damage (PD) and
defense costs for any legally responsible insured.
NOTE: Insured includes the named insured, family members, people reasonably
believing they are entitled to use a covered auto, and any other person or
organization for its vicarious liability arising from the named insured or other
people using a covered auto. The named insured and family members are
covered for use of any auto or trailer. Everyone else is only covered for the use
of a covered auto and its trailer.
Co-Owner and Co-Insured Liability
Unless the auto policy specifically excludes intra-family claims, co-owner and co-
insured liability is covered under the liability section. Some insurers try to
exclude intra-family claims, but many states consider such limitations invalid
because they violate public policy.
Personal Auto Insurance • 24
Auto
Any vehicle that has less than four wheels or is not designed for use on public
roads is excluded from the liability insuring agreement. Such a vehicle will be
covered IF it is used in a medical emergency. For example, suppose two men
are riding a motorcycle in an isolated area. During a rest stop, one of the men
breaks his leg while climbing a hill for a view. If the insured driver takes his friend
to the hospital on the motorcycle, coverage would apply.
The Duty to Defend
When an accident occurs, the insurer may choose to either settle the issue with
the injured party or defend its client (i.e. the insured), provided that the claim filed
is covered under the policy. If the insurer opts to defend, all defense costs are
borne by him/her. The limit of liability stated within the insurance policy is used to
determine the duration for which the insured will be defended. The insurer’s
obligation to defend its client ends when the limit of liability is exhausted by
payment of judgments or settlements.
NOTEWORTHY: The wording of the PAP, with respect to when the insurer’s
duty to defend ends, has changed to clearly allow the insurer to simply pay the
policy limit and then walk away from the suit.
Personal Auto Insurance • 25
Six Exclusions in Liability Coverage
Intentional Injury
The courts examine the insured’s motivation. Occasionally, a court might apply
coverage if the insured intended the act, but did not intend to cause the resulting
injury.
CR Solutions: In a case involving potentially intentional injuries, the Claim
Representative should issue a reservation of rights letter, take detailed
statements from the parties and witnesses, evaluate the insured’s intent,
determine if the accident involved the ‘use’ of an auto, and consider how courts
in the jurisdiction have defined the word ‘accident’.
Property in the Insured’s Care, Custody, or Control
This exclusion applies when the insured damages a borrowed car or damages
furniture he/she is moving for a friend. A few states require insurers to cover
“Our duty to defend ends when our limit of liability for this coverage has been exhausted.”
1994 Edition
“ “Our duty to defend ends when our limit of liability for this coverage has been exhausted by payment of judgments or settlements.”
1998 Edition
Personal Auto Insurance • 26
damage to rental cars and/or damage to vehicles being test-driven by the
insured.
Business Use of a Personal Auto
The PAP does not cover any person:
• For injury to any non-domestic employee
• For liability arising out of livery (taxi) use of any vehicle (Car pooling is not
livery use.)
• While in the business of selling, repairing, servicing, storing, or parking
vehicles (You are covered when you work on your and your family’s vehicles
during your off-duty hours.)
• Using or working on any vehicle (except a private passenger auto, pickup,
van, or its trailer) while working in any other business
The policy is void if the insured’s application contains a material
misrepresentation about the vehicle’s use.
NOTE: A misrepresentation is material if it would affect the insured’s premium or
the insurer’s decision to accept the insured.
Unauthorized Use of an Insured Vehicle
The PAP excludes any person from using a vehicle without being entitled to do
so. Courts evaluate whether an ordinary, reasonable person would think he/she
Personal Auto Insurance • 27
was entitled to use the vehicle under the circumstances.
NOTE: This exclusion does not apply to family members, which includes
underage, unlicensed drivers.
Vehicles Owned by the Insured or Available for His/Her Regular Use
Courts examine the availability of the vehicle and any restrictions on its use.
CR Solutions: Determine ownership.
Evaluate the duration and frequency of use and any restrictions on use.
The Named Driver Exclusion (Exclusion Only By Endorsement)
This exclusion excludes coverage for a named driver, which is usually a driver
with a tendency to cause accidents or collect tickets. The named driver
exclusion excludes one driver so the rest of the family can get standard coverage
at standard rates. Regulators now favor its use since it lets more families buy
“affordable” insurance.
Limit of Liability
The most the insurer will pay for all injuries and damages resulting from any
accident is the limit shown in the Declarations, irrespective of the number of
persons covered, claims made, or vehicles insured. The insurer will not pay for
medical expenses that have already been paid for by another coverage of PAP
or its endorsements.
Personal Auto Insurance • 28
Multiple Impact Accidents
Subsequent impacts are considered one accident because the first accident is
the proximate cause of the subsequent impacts. Therefore, they are subject to
one policy limit.
Loss of Consortium Claims
Most courts do not consider loss of consortium a separate claim with separate
per person limits. Many courts do not even consider it to be a ‘bodily injury’
claim.
Pure Emotional Injury Claims
This type of claim is subject to separate per person limits only if the jurisdiction
allows pure emotional injury claims; emotional injury constitutes ‘bodily injury’;
and the claim is considered a separate claim rather than a derivative claim.
NOTE: A derivative claim is derived from the injured person’s claim.
Offset for Duplicate Payments
The policy prevents claimants from recovering duplicate payments under liability
coverage (Part A), medical payments coverage (Part B), and uninsured motorists
coverage (Part C).
Personal Auto Insurance • 29
NOTEWORTHY:
Two problems arise when reducing liability settlements for medical payment
settlements:
If the Part A (liability) limit is $100,000 and the Part B (med pay) limit is $5,000:
1. Is the combined limit $105,000 or $100,000?
2. If the medical bills totaled $6,000 and the total general damages were worth
between $40,000 and $50,000, and the loss was settled for $47,000, did the
$5,000 medical pay coverage offset the liability coverage?
Out-Of-State Coverage
If the insured has an accident in another state or in Canada where the
nonresident is required to maintain specific insurance coverage, the policy will
provide at least the required minimum amounts and types of coverage. Whether
no-fault coverage is required of nonresidents depends on the wording and intent
of the state’s no-fault statute. Some laws do not expressly require no-fault
benefits for nonresidents.
CR Solutions: Determine if the insured meets the other state’s minimum limits.
Obtain copies of the no-fault statute to determine if coverage is required.
Other Insurance
If more than one policy applies to an owned auto, the insurer uses proration by
face amounts, in which the insured’s policy contributes proportionately by limits.
The policy covers non-owned autos on an excess basis.
Personal Auto Insurance • 30
1. State Laws Contrary To Policy Wording
State statutes take precedence over policy wording in all cases for all policies.
Some state statutes make the operator’s policy primary rather than excess.
Other statutes require apportionment by:
• Contribution by equal shares in which each insurer contributes equally up to
its policy limits until the loss is paid
• Pro rata contribution in which each policy contributes proportionately by its
limits
1. Dealer And Repair Shop Autos
Many states make the driver’s PAP primary if the driver is test-driving a dealer’s
car or driving a “loaner” while his/her car is being repaired.
CR Solutions: Was the car owned by a dealer or repair shop? Was the
insured’s car being serviced? Does a statute make the insured’s policy primary?
3. Rental Cars
The determination of primary vs. excess coverage varies among states. Most
courts void rental contract escape clauses that are designed to avoid providing
coverage if any other insurance is available.
Personal Auto Insurance • 31
CR Solutions: Did the insured buy additional insurance coverage in the rental
contract? How does the rental contract address other insurance? How do courts
interpret escape clauses? What type of insurance does the rental company
carry? What are the terms of the rental company’s policy?
Medical Payments Coverage Insuring Agreement
The insurer will pay reasonable medical and funeral expenses resulting from an
auto accident and sustained by the insured and/or his/her family members while
occupying any vehicle or hit by any vehicle as a pedestrian, and by other
persons while occupying the insured’s covered auto. The expenses must be
incurred within three years of the accident.
NOTE: Possible coverage issues arise from the definitions of “family member”
and “occupy” and from potential conflicts with out-of-state coverage in no-fault
states.
Uninsured Motorists (UM) Coverage Insuring Agreement
The insurer will pay compensatory damages for bodily injury to which any insured
is legally entitled, and which is caused by an accident with an uninsured motor
vehicle.
1. Operation of a Vehicle: The courts consider the extent of the role the
uninsured vehicle played in the accident. The more significant the role, the more
likely UM coverage applies.
Personal Auto Insurance • 32
2. Definition of Uninsured Vehicle
Uninsured motor vehicles include vehicles:
• Insured for less than the state’s minimum bodily injury limits
• Operated by hit-and-run drivers
• Insured with an insolvent insurer or one which denies coverage
None of the following are considered uninsured vehicles:
• Vehicles available for regular use by the insured or family members
• Vehicles owned or operated by solvent self-insurers
• Vehicles owned by the government
• Vehicles operated on rails (trains) or crawler treads (bulldozers)
• Vehicles designed for use off public roads while off public roads
• Vehicles used as residences
3. Phantom Vehicles: Over forty states require physical contact by a “hit-and-
run” vehicle. Many states allow an exception if corroborative evidence proves
the existence of a phantom vehicle. (A phantom vehicle is an alleged “hit-and-
run” vehicle that does not make contact.)
CR Solutions: Does the state require physical contact? If the state allows
coverage for phantom vehicles, what evidence supports the insured’s
allegations? Can the hit-and-run driver be identified?
Personal Auto Insurance • 33
Limits of Liability; Uninsured Motorists Coverage
The most the insurer will pay for all damages resulting from any accident is the
limit shown in the Declarations.
Payments Made Under This Coverage Will Be Reduced By Sums:
1. Collected from or on behalf of the responsible party, and
2. Paid under workers’ compensation or disability benefits laws
The insurer will not pay for losses that have already been paid by another
coverage of the PAP or by any other underinsured motorists coverage. A few
states permit stacking of uninsured motorists coverage, in which insureds with
more than one vehicle may combine the limits of liability to obtain a higher total
limit.
Public Policy Arguments In Favor Of Stacking, Even If Contrary To the
Policy Wording:
• Coverage is required by law and policies can’t reduce coverage required by
statute.
• The insured paid more than one premium and should benefit from all the
coverage that he/she paid for (the premium rule).
• The coverage applies per person injured, not per vehicle insured.
Personal Auto Insurance • 34
Arbitration of Uninsured Motorist Claims
The arbitration clause states that insurer and insured will go through arbitration if
they don’t agree on the amount of damages or whether the insured is legally
entitled to damages. Each party appoints an arbitrator at its own expense. Those
two arbitrators then appoint a third. The decision of any two is binding.
States Vary Regarding What Constitutes:
1. “Disputes of coverage” (which are not appropriate for arbitration)
2. Disputes over whether “the insured is legally entitled to recover”
(which are appropriate for arbitration)
States also vary regarding whether arbitration is mandatory and binding.
Personal Auto Insurance • 35
LESSON 1 QUIZ 1. Which of the following situations is NOT provided for under personal auto insurance coverage?
Mike owns a Limousine. He uses it to pick up and drop off individuals for a small fee. Jake owns a BMW, which he uses to commute to his office with his friends. Jerry owns a van, which is inoperable and remains in the garage. Ted owns a Volkswagen, which he uses to commute to a university.
2. Jane was driving Olive’s Mercedes when she collided with a trailer and fractured her arm. Based on this information, which of the following is the most appropriate action to be taken by Olive’s insurance agency?
Share the damage expenses with Jane’s insurance agency. Verify whether the insurance coverage meets the expenses. Ensure that Jane owns an auto insurance policy. Make a payment under Olive’s policy with regard to the extent of damage.
3. In the absence of any special endorsement, which of the following is eligible for coverage under personal auto insurance?
A motorbike A snowmobile A three-wheeled dirt bike A Jaguar
4. Which of the following is not one of the four parts of a personal auto policy?:
Liability coverage Medical payments Uninsured motorist coverage Theft coverage
Personal Auto Insurance • 36
5. Which of the following information must be mentioned in the personal auto insurance policy?
The insured owns real estate worth $500,000. A BMW and Jaguar are also owned by the insured. The insured makes frequent international trips. A loan worth $50,000 was issued by a bank in the insured’s name.
Personal Auto Insurance • 37
LESSON 1 QUIZ ANSWER KEY 1.
Mike owns a Limousine. He uses it to pick up and drop off individuals for a small fee.*
Mike is not eligible for personal auto insurance because he is using the automobile for commercial purposes. Personal auto insurance provides coverage for only those vehicles which are acquired for private use. 2.
Make a payment under Olive’s policy with regard to the extent of damage.*
Auto insurance is tied to the vehicle, not to the vehicle owner. Thus anyone operating the vehicle with the owner’s permission is covered, along with passengers and the insured’s family members. Thus the most appropriate thing for Olive’s insurance agency to do would be to pay for damages caused, as long as they are within the limit of insurance. 3.
A Jaguar* A Jaguar is the only vehicle in this list which will be covered. This is because all autos that are covered under personal auto insurance should be four-wheeled vehicles. A Jaguar is the only four-wheeled vehicle on the list. The policy may be endorsed in order to cover motorbikes, snowmobiles, and dirt bikes 4.
Theft coverage* The four parts of the Personal Auto Policy are Part A Liability Coverage, Part B Medical Payments Coverage, Part C Uninsured Motorists Coverage, and Part D Damage to Your Auto..
Personal Auto Insurance • 38
5.
A BMW and Jaguar are also owned by the insured.* The policy should state any/all other vehicles owned by the insured if he/she desires that they too be covered. Coverage for such vehicles may be provided as excess coverage. The policy need not mention the worth of the insured’s policy, his/her habits, or any personal loans taken.
Personal Auto Insurance • 39
LESSON 2: The Personal Auto Policy
Standard Coverage: ISO 1998 Personal Auto Policy
Form (PP 00 01)
The Personal Auto Policy (Pap) provides the following coverages:
• Auto Liability Coverage which protects insureds against claims for
Bodily Injury and Property Damage, for which the insured is legally
liable, arising out of use of an auto.
• Auto Medical Payments Coverage which pays reasonable medical
expenses of:
o The insured and family members (occupying any car) and
o Other persons occupying an insured car
• Uninsured Motorists Coverage protects insureds hit by uninsured
drivers, hit and run drivers, and drivers insured by insolvent insurers.
• Auto Physical Damage Coverage covers physical damage to the
insured’s car. Collision coverage includes upset and impact with
another object.
• Other Than Collision (aka comprehensive) coverage covers damage
from non-excluded perils other than collision.
The PAP gives three coverage options:
1. Collision and comprehensive: This gives the most protection, but at the
highest premium.
Personal Auto Insurance • 40
2. Comprehensive only covers all non-excluded perils other than collision.
3. No physical damage coverage
NOTE: Lenders require buyers with auto loans to carry both collision and
comprehensive.
NOTEWORTHY: No-fault auto insurance requires insurers to pay on behalf of
their own insureds for small bodily injury losses regardless of fault, and restricts
the rights of accident victims to sue. It reduces insurance costs by reducing the
number of lawsuits.
Declarations
The following information is contained on the PAP declarations page:
• Named insured (and mailing address)
• Policy period (from 12:01 am at the policyholder’s address on the policy’s
effective date until 12:01 am on the policy’s expiration date)
• Description of insured automobile(s) (age, make, model, body type,
vehicle identification number (VIN), annual mileage, use, and date of
purchase)
Personal Auto Insurance • 41
NOTE: Never say “VIN number”, which basically means vehicle identification
number number. It’s redundant. The same goes for “PIN number” which means
personal identification number number..
• Premium amount (per coverage, per vehicle, and total)
• Limits of liability (for each vehicle)
• Schedule of coverages (and deductibles)
• Lienholder (the secured interest, if any)
• Garage location (where the car is parked)
• Rating information (rating class and discounts, if any, for multiple cars,
driver training, good student, passive restraints, and anti-theft devices)
• Applicable endorsements
• Signatures (representing the insurer)
The Four Insuring Agreements
There are different agreements for all the four coverages offered under PAP.
They are as follows.
Part A- Liability Coverage; Insuring Agreement
The insurer will pay damages for bodily injury (BI), property damage (PD),
defense costs and pre-judgment interest for any legally responsible insured. The
insurer may choose to settle or to defend. The duty to defend ends when the
insurer has paid the policy limit. Coverage is written with split limits (separate
amounts apply to BI per person/per accident and to PD,) but can be endorsed to
Personal Auto Insurance • 42
provide coverage with a single limit (one total amount that applies to both BI and
PD liability). The insurer’s limit of liability from any single accident is the
declaration’s limit, irrespective of the number of individuals insured, claims made,
or vehicles insured. If the insured has an accident in a state where higher limits
are required, the policy automatically provides those higher limits.
Part B- Medical Payments Coverage; Insuring Agreement
The insurer pays an insured’s reasonable medical and funeral expenses incurred
within three years and resulting from an auto accident. Benefits are paid
regardless of fault. The benefit limit applies separately to each injured person.
Part C- Uninsured Motorist Coverage (UM); Insuring Agreement
The policy pays for bodily injury damages (medical expenses, lost wages, pain
and suffering) to which an insured is legally entitled following an accident caused
by an uninsured vehicle.
Part D- Coverage for Damage to Your Auto; Insuring Agreement
The insurer will pay for direct accidental loss to a covered auto and its
equipment, less the deductible. Collision and other than collision (OTC) are
insured separately, usually with a lower deductible chosen for OTC. Collision
includes upset and impact with another object but excludes:
• Missiles
• Falling objects
Personal Auto Insurance • 43
• Fire
• Theft
• Explosion
• Earthquake
• Windstorm
• Hail
• Flood
• Vandalism
• Riot
• Contact with an animal.
The insured may choose to have glass breakage by collision considered a
collision loss (so he/she has only one deductible) or OTC loss (in case he/she
didn’t buy collision). Collision losses are paid regardless of fault. Coverage
applies only if indicated in the declarations. The policy pays for loss to an auto
while in the custody of or used by, but not owned or regularly used by, the
insured or a resident relative as broadly as any of the covered autos, but on an
excess basis.
Personal Auto Insurance • 44
General Provisions
Nine General Provisions in the Pap: Part F:
Bankruptcy
An insured’s insolvency does not lessen the insurer’s obligations towards
him/her.
Changes
The personal auto policy constitutes the entire agreement. Changes can be
made to the policy only by an endorsement issued by the insurer. The premium
will be revised if exposure changes. For example, the premium will be adjusted to
reflect changes in the number, type, or use of insured vehicles; the operators of
insured vehicles; the place of principal garaging; or the coverage, deductibles, or
limits of liability.
Fraud
The policy will be void if the insured is found guilty of fraudulent actions or
statements.
Legal Action against the Insurer
The insurer cannot be sued until the insured complies with all the policy terms
and until judgment after trial. (Part A- Liability)
Insurer’s Right to Recover Payment
Personal Auto Insurance • 45
The doctrine of subrogation grants the insurer whatever rights the insured has
over responsible third parties involved in a claim against the insured. Subrogation
allows the insurer to assume the rights of the insured at the time of the loss, in
order to collect from the responsible third party once the insurer has paid a claim.
NOTE: The insurer cannot subrogate against anyone, under Part D, who
reasonably believed that he/she was entitled to use the insured’s auto.
Policy Period and Territory
The policy period is shown in the Declarations. The policy territory is:
• the United States and its territories.
• Puerto Rico
• Canada
• Shipping routes between the ports of the above stated
Policy Termination
The insured may cancel the insurance policy by returning it to the insurer or by
giving advance written notice.
The insurer can cancel a newly issued policy, for any reason, within the first 60
days of the issuance. Otherwise, the policy can only be cancelled for:
• Non-payment of premiums
• Suspension of a driver’s license
• Material misrepresentation
Personal Auto Insurance • 46
The insurer may terminate or refuse to renew a policy for the above stated
reasons or state laws. The policy automatically terminates upon failure to pay the
premium.
Assignment of the Policy
The insured must obtain the insurer’s written consent before assigning his/her
insurance policy to another. (It must be noted that such permission is seldom
granted.) If the insured dies, coverage continues for the insured’s spouse and
legal representative for the rest of the policy period.
Two or More Policies Covering the Same Auto
If the insured is covered under more than one applicable policy, the highest limit
under any one policy will be the maximum amount that the insurer is liable to
pay.
Key Policy Definitions
Following are definitions of terms commonly used in a PAP:
You: The named insured (and spouse, if a resident of the same household)
A spouse who leaves the household is covered for the first 90 days after leaving.
We: The insurer
Personal Auto Insurance • 47
Owned Auto: Owned autos include any vehicle leased for at least 6 months
under a written agreement.
Bodily Injury: Bodily injury includes bodily harm, sickness, disease, and death.
Business: Any trade, profession, or occupation is considered to be a business.
Family Member: A family member is any relative living with the insured related
by blood, marriage, or adoption.
Occupying: The term “occupying” includes being in, upon, getting in, on, out, or
off the motor vehicle.
Property Damage: Physical damage to, destruction of, or loss of use of any
tangible property (such as autos, bridges, houses, and signs) is considered
property damage.
Trailer: A trailer is a vehicle designed to be pulled by a PAP-eligible vehicle,
which includes farm implements.
Your Covered Auto: This includes:
1. Any vehicle identified in the declarations.
2. Any trailer owned by the insured.
Personal Auto Insurance • 48
3. Any temporary substitute vehicle (An auto or trailer used as a substitute for
a vehicle that’s broken down, being repaired, serviced, lost, or destroyed. This
does not include out-of-town rentals.)
4. Any newly acquired auto
Newly Acquired Auto: A newly acquired auto is an eligible private passenger
auto, pickup, or van that becomes an owned vehicle during the policy period.
Personal Auto Insurance • 49
LESSON 2 QUIZ
1. A PAP gives three coverage options. Identify which of the following is NOT an option offered by a PAP.
Collision only Collision and comprehensive Comprehensive only No physical damage coverage
2. Jake’s personal auto insurance policy was supposed to expire on May 21st . On the 21st of May, while on his way back from a party, he collided with a truck parked in the middle of the road. Given that it was 10 A.M. when the accident occurred, who will pay for the damages?
Jake must make the payment as his policy has expired. The losses are provided for under his personal auto insurance policy. The owner of the abandoned truck must reimburse Jake. Jake and the truck owner will each pay for 50% of the damages.
3. Pre-judgment interest for any legally responsible insured is payable under which part of Personal Auto Insurance?
Part A - Liability Coverage Part B – Medical Payments Coverage Part C – Uninsured Motorist Coverage Part D – Coverage for Damage to your Auto
4. The Part B insuring agreement states that the insurer pays an insured’s reasonable medical and funeral expenses incurred within ______ years, and resulting from an auto accident.
Three Four Ten Six
Personal Auto Insurance • 50
5. Which of the following actions is most likely to occur if the insured is found guilty of fraud?
The insurance policy will be void. A case is filled against the insured. No insurer can issue a similar policy to the same insured within a period of three months. The insured is required to issue a warning to the insured.
Personal Auto Insurance • 51
LESSON 2 QUIZ ANSWER KEY 1.
Collision only* The three options given under a PAP are comprehensive only; collision and comprehensive; and no physical damage coverage. Thus, coverage for collision only is not offered under a PAP. 2.
The losses are provided for under his personal auto insurance policy.* Jake’s insurance policy was supposed to expire on the 21st of May. The policy stays effective till 12:01 A.M. on the policy’s expiration date. We know that the accident took place at 10 A.M. Thus, all losses will be paid for under the insurance policy as the policy had not expired at the time of the accident. 3.
Part A - Liability Coverage* The insurance agreement for Part A- Liability Coverage states that the insurer will pay damages for bodily injury (BI), property damage (PD), defense costs and pre-judgment interest for any legally responsible insured. 4.
Three* Part B deals with medical payments coverage. Its insurance agreement states that the insurer pays an insured’s reasonable medical and funeral expenses incurred within three years and resulting from an auto accident. 5.
The insurance policy will be void.* One of the nine general provisions for a PAP states that the policy will be void if the insured is found guilty of fraud in connection with any accident or loss for which coverage is sought.
Personal Auto Insurance • 52
LESSON 3: Part A: Liability Coverage
What Coverage Does Part A Provide?
Part A coverage provides payment for bodily injury and property damage
resulting from the insured’s use of an automobile for which the insured becomes
legally liable. Coverage begins under a PAP policy at 12:01 a.m. on the date
listed in the policy. Under Part A, the company promises to settle and defend
claims brought against the insured involving the insured’s use of an auto. The
company also agrees to pay for all defense costs.
Damages paid for bodily injury include not just the payments of actual medical
costs which can be documented, but also for a person’s pain and suffering due to
the injury. Property damage extends to any kind of property which is damaged
due to the negligent operation of an auto, including vehicles, buildings, street
lights, or any other kind of stationary object.
The insurer has the option to settle or defend any claim or suit which it deems
appropriate. The insured cannot dictate coverage payment or refusal.
Liability Coverage
The Part A liability is the most the company will pay for all damages resulting
from any one auto accident, regardless of the number of insureds, claims filed,
vehicles or premiums listed in the declarations, or vehicles involved in the
Personal Auto Insurance • 53
accident.
The liability portion of the auto insurance contract covers damages that the
insured is responsible for, by virtue of an accident. Prejudgment interest, interest
accrued before judgment is rendered, may also be paid to a legally liable insured.
Though, it must be remembered that the insurer’s duty to defend ends as soon
as the liability limits are exhausted.
Automobile liability insurance is divided into the following two parts.
Bodily Injury Liability Insurance
The bodily injury (BI) liability insurance is for the case that an insured causes an
accident in which someone else is hurt or killed.
Property Damage Liability Insurance
The property damage liability insurance is for the case that an insured damages
someone else’s property. Usually, of course, the damaged property is someone
else’s car; but other types of property like buildings, lampposts, garage doors,
and others are covered.
If the insured causes an accident which results in the death or injury of
another, monetary damages due to medical payments, lost wages, pain
and suffering, and loss of consortium are covered.
Personal Auto Insurance • 54
One of the major decisions with regard to the purchase of insurance is the
amount of protection that you will buy. You may purchase insurance one of two
ways: Single limit or Split limit.
Important Points
• This coverage is mandatory in many states across the United States. Each
state sets the minimum amounts of coverage a vehicle should have before it
is allowed to operate on the road.
• The insurance company also agrees, in the policy, to defend the insured
individual in any litigation that results under the policy. But it also reserves the
right to settle any litigation without the insured’s permission. Lawsuits are
basically negotiated on the basis of dollars and cents., not on the principle of
who’s right.
Single Limit Coverage
The single limit coverage provides a one-limit protection of $400,000, $500,000,
or $600,000 for the insured for all bodily injury and property damage losses
suffered by the other party. It states the maximum payable for both BI and PD
arising from one occurrence.
Split/ Dual Limit Coverage
A dual limit coverage provides a separate limit for bodily injury per person, a
separate limit for every bodily injury per accident, regardless of the number of
Personal Auto Insurance • 55
people injured or dead, and another limit for property damage in that accident.
The dual limits of $100,000 / $300,000 / $50,000 mean that the insurance
company will pay up to $100,000 to each injured, but no more than a total of
$300,000 to all injured people in that one accident. The insurance company will
also pay up to $50,000 for the repair or replacement of the other party’s property
damaged in that accident. It states the maximum BI per person, the maximum BI
per accident, and maximum PD per occurrence.
NOTE: In comparing the benefit value of single and split limits, the circumstances
of the accident become very important. Also note that coverage is self-reinstating
for each accident.
Liability coverage is written on a split limit basis, such as 20/30/15. The first two
numbers are related to bodily injury. In this case, the amounts would be $20,000
per person for bodily injury in any one accident; $30,000 per accident for bodily
injury and $15,000 as a maximum for all property damaged in any one accident.
Damages
The term “damages” refers to the monetary award one party is required to pay,
due to legal liability, to another whose:
• Human body has suffered an injury.
• Auto body has suffered damage.
Personal Auto Insurance • 56
Compensatory Damages
Compensatory damages compensate a person for bodily injury or property
damage. These include:
• Special Damages (compensation for out-of-pocket losses)
• General Damages (compensation for non-economic losses, such as pain
and suffering)
Punitive Damages
Punitive damages, also known as “exemplary damages”, punish wrongdoers and
set an example to others to deter similar future misconduct.
What Is Not Covered?
The insurer does not cover ownership, maintenance, or use of any vehicle:
• Having fewer than 4 wheels (except trailers) or designed for off-road use
(unless added by endorsement) (However, the use of a non-owned golf cart
is covered.)
• Owned by the insured, or available for regular use, except the insured’s
covered auto as defined earlier (All vehicles owned by the insured must be
insured.)
• Owned by a family member, or available for his/her regular use, except when
used by the insured or the insured’s spouse (For example, the insured’s son
must insure his own car.)
• Used in a racing facility during competition or practice
Personal Auto Insurance • 57
Who Is Insured?
The definition of “insured” is quite broad, and includes not only family members,
but anyone that drives an insured vehicle with permission. The liability coverage
under a PAP policy is for any insured who has become legally responsible for
bodily injury or property damage to someone else because of an auto accident.
An insurance company will pay sums up to limits stated in the declarations
portion of the PAP.
Insured Persons
Insured persons include the following:
• The insured and family members
• Anyone using the insured car who reasonably believes he/she has permission
• Any person or organization responsible for a covered person using a covered
auto
• Any person or organization responsible for the insured’s use, or a family
member’s use, of any auto.
The bottom line is that the coverage follows the auto.
PAP Example:
Melvin Dawes is the head coach of his city’s college football team. Melvin
decides to host a pool party at his house for the entire team, including friends
and relatives. All of the 250 guests bring automobiles to the party, and parking
becomes a problem. Several guests park behind Melvin in his driveway, blocking
Personal Auto Insurance • 58
his car.
In the middle of the party, Melvin runs out of food. Without more provisions, the
team is getting rather hostile and ugly. Melvin chooses Herman to go with him to
purchase more beer.
To drive to the store, Melvin borrows one of the cheerleader’s cars, which is
parked in the driveway nearest to the street. Matilda, the cheerleader, carries
minimum limits of 10/20/5 liability insurance. Melvin carries 200/300/200.
Let’s examine the following questions about Melvin’s situation.
Q1. Whose auto insurance liability applies if there is an accident?
Matilda’s liability insurance applies when Melvin drives Matilda’s car.
Melvin becomes an insured, by definition, under Matilda’s liability
coverage.
Q2. If Melvin negligently runs a stop sign, hits a light pole, and causes
injury to himself and Herman, whose liability insurance would cover
Melvin and Herman’s injuries?
If Melvin negligently hits a light pole as described, Matilda’s liability
insurance would apply to Melvin and Herman’s injuries because Melvin is
an insured, by definition, under Matilda’s policy.
Personal Auto Insurance • 59
Q3. Whose liability coverage would apply if Herman sustains serious
injuries, resulting in an $80,000 claim?
If Herman has an $80,000 claim, Matilda’s auto liability coverage would
apply to Herman’s injuries on a primary basis for $10,000. In turn, Melvin’s
auto liability coverage (on his own car) would pay the remaining $70,000
on an excess basis. Remember, primary coverage must be exhausted first
before excess coverage begins.
Compliance with Financial Responsibility Laws
With the issuance of an insurance policy, the insurer certifies any current or
future financial responsibility that the insured is required to prove by law.
Supplementary Payments
Supplementary payments include:
• Up to $200 a day for lost wages when the insured is required to attend a
legal hearing or trial
• Bail bond costs up to $250 if required due to an accident resulting in
covered liability
• Cost of bonds to release attachments in any suit the company defends
• Any expenses incurred by the insurance company.
Personal Auto Insurance • 60
• Reasonable expenses incurred at the insurer’s request.
• Post-judgment interest payments, that is, interest that accrues after the
judgment but before payment.
Exclusions
There are several liability exclusions that should be considered:
• Intentionally inflicted bodily injury (BI) or property damage (PD) is excluded. It
would be a bad public policy to allow persons who deliberately cause damage
to be protected.
• Property owned by the insured, rented by the insured, or in the care and
custody of the insured, is usually excluded except for residences and
garages. It is primarily excluded because it ought to be covered elsewhere,
under a homeowner’s policy or under personal property floaters.
• Business usage of the automobile is also usually excluded, including renting
the vehicle out for hire or when in use by employees for business reasons.
• Damage to property owned or being transported by that person
• Bodily injury to an employee during the course of employment; this exclusion
does not apply to bodily injury to a domestic employee, unless workers’
compensation is required or available for that domestic employee.
• People engaged in the business of selling, repairing, serving, storing, or
parking automobiles
• Any liability arising out of the ownership or operation of a vehicle while it is
being used to carry people or property for money or a fee
Personal Auto Insurance • 61
• Motorized vehicles with fewer than four wheels or designed for use off public
roads
• Vehicles that are used in prearranged racing or speed contests.
• Injury to any non-domestic employee injured in the course of employment
(Domestic employees are also excluded if they are covered under workers’
compensation insurance.)
• Liability arising out of livery (taxi) use of any vehicle
• Using a car without being entitled to do so (except family members using a
covered auto owned by the named insured)
• Insured under a nuclear energy liability policy (Don’t worry, all vehicles
carrying nuclear fuel or waste and properly insured, provide coverage under
their policies.)
NOTE: The policy form excludes coverage for persons who use a car without the
belief that they were authorized to do so.
Out of State Coverage
If the insured becomes involved in an auto accident out of state and the state
involved requires higher liability limits than the insured maintains, the PAP will
provide the higher specified limit for this accident.
Personal Auto Insurance • 62
Other Insurance (what does this mean?)
The Effect of Other Insurance on Loss Payments
The insurer contributes proportionately by policy limits when more than one
coverage applies. Excess coverage will only be provided on non-owned vehicles.
Automobile Liability Claims
Assessment of Auto Liability Claims
Assessments of auto liability claims require an understanding of negligence, the
rules of the road, vicarious liability and negligent entrustment, and personal injury
protection (PIP). Drivers and owners of autos must operate vehicles in a
reasonable, prudent manner and maintain their vehicles in a safe condition.
Liability Regarding Parked Vehicles
The mere fact that a driver parked illegally does not automatically make that
driver liable for accidents involving the parked car. However, a driver who
violates parking rules is liable in tort for damages if his negligence is the
proximate cause of the accident. This means the driver may be the target of a
civil suit and may have to pay damages. For example, suppose an illegally
parked car obstructs other drivers’ visibility as they round a curve. If one of the
other drivers runs off the road due to the lack of visibility, the driver of the parked
car may be held civilly liable for any resulting injuries or property damages.
Personal Auto Insurance • 63
Liability Involving Disabled Vehicles:
If a vehicle is parked on the traveled part of a road, it creates a presumption that
the driver was negligent. The driver has the burden of proving that extenuating
circumstances prevented him/her from parking elsewhere.
In this case, to establish a defense to negligence, the driver must prove that:
• The parking resulted from an emergency (event beyond the driver’s control).
• The driver was forced to leave the car in the road.
• The driver used due care in leaving the vehicle.
The driver of a disabled vehicle is not automatically liable, but he/she has the
burden of proving that any accident was caused by others’ negligence.
Liability Involving Passengers
A passenger might be liable for the accident (or at least for his/her own injuries) if
the passenger distracted the driver or caused the driver to lose control of the
vehicle. In addition, a passenger must use reasonable care for his/her own
safety. The passenger is barred from recovering damages if he/she was injured
during a voluntary ride with a known incompetent (ill, intoxicated, or
inexperienced) driver.
Some states have automobile guest statutes that prohibit auto passengers from
suing the driver for injuries suffered in an accident, unless the accident results
Personal Auto Insurance • 64
from the driver’s willful misconduct or intoxication. These statutes only apply to
non-paying passengers. They do not apply to passengers in buses, taxis, and
similar forms of transportation.
NOTE: In many states, the constitutionality of automobile guest statutes is being
tested.
Vicarious Liability in Auto Claims
Ordinarily, the owner of an auto is not vicariously liable for the driver’s
negligence. However, courts in a majority of states hold the owner liable if the
driver is the owner’s agent. A few states impose liability on the vehicle owner if
the vehicle is driven with the owner’s consent.
Under the theory of “negligent entrustment”, the owner may be liable for the
accident if the owner entrusted his/her car to a driver he/she knew or should
have known was incompetent.
The “family purpose doctrine” assumes an agency relationship between family
members and allows actions against the car owner for accidents caused by other
family members. For example: If Mom and Dad need high liability limits on the
cars they use, Junior and Sis also need those same high limits.
Personal Auto Insurance • 65
The Seven Activities Involved In Auto Liability Investigations
Determining Proximate Cause
• Two issues determine proximate causation:
o Foreseeability: The damages must be foreseeable by a reasonable
person.
o Intervening act: No intervening act occurred between the defendant’s act
and the injury.
• The Last Clear Chance doctrine states that if a defendant has the last clear
chance to avoid injury to another, his/her failure to avoid the accident was the
Taking statements from insureds, claimants, and witnesses
Investigating the accident scene and diagramming the scene
Obtaining police reports
Photographing the accident scene and damages
Gathering evidence
Determining the proximate cause of the accident
Obtaining medical documents
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Personal Auto Insurance • 66
proximate cause of the injury, even if the plaintiff’s negligence placed the
plaintiff in the position of danger.
• The Unavoidable Accident defense states that a defendant is not liable for
inevitable accidents that:
o Could not have been foreseen
o Could not have been prevented by being careful
Example: An auto accident caused by a bee stinging and distracting the driver;
or an auto accident caused by a previously healthy driver suffering a heart attack
and passing out while driving
• The Road Defects defense alleges that improper design, maintenance, or
construction of the road caused or contributed to the accident.
Experts in Auto Liability Cases
• Physicians (medical doctors)
• Mechanics that evaluate auto defect allegations
• Specially trained police officers that perform accident scene investigations
• Forensic engineers that perform accident reconstructions
• Biomechanics experts that determine the probable effect an auto impact
would have on the bodies of the occupants
Evidence in Auto Liability Claims
The evidence in auto liability claims includes:
• Statements of the insured, adverse driver, passengers, and witnesses
Personal Auto Insurance • 67
• Documentary evidence such as:
o Police reports
o Photographs of the accident scene
o Traffic court proceedings
o Weather reports
o Transit authority reports (for accidents involving buses or taxis)
o Newspaper accounts and photographs
• Demonstrative evidence such as:
o Diagrams of accident scenes, and/or
o Videos of traffic light sequences
• Physical evidence such as:
o A blown tire, and/or
o A defective auto part
• Expert reports from doctors, mechanics, specially trained police officers,
forensic engineers, and biomechanics experts
NOTE: The evidence listed above is used for determining liability.
Personal Auto Insurance • 68
LESSON 3 QUIZ 1. Linda’s insurance policy limit is $100,000. If, while settling damages with the injured party on her behalf, the settlement amount reaches $105,000, what should the insurer do?
The insurer should pay the entire settlement amount. The insurer should only pay the policy limit. The insurer should try and reach a settlement with the injured person’s insurer. The insurer is under no obligation to make any payments.
2. Which of the following are parts of automobile liability insurance? I. Bodily injury liability insurance II. Property damage liability insurance III. Pedestrian injury liability insurance
I & II. I & III. II & III. I, II & III.
3. Josh has dual limit coverage of $10,000 / $40,000 / $60,000. Based on the information provided, what amount will be paid to Josh for repairing his neighbor’s wall with which his vehicle collided?
$60,000 $10,000 $40,000 110,000
4. Which of the following are paid for as supplementary payments?
Bond costs of up to $350 Post-judgment interest payments Costs incurred due to bodily injury Costs of repairing damaged property
Personal Auto Insurance • 69
5. Jerry has a $20,000 limit on his insurance policy. He goes to State Y for a vacation and after being involved in an accident realizes that the State Y’s minimum liability insurance requirement is $50,000. What will happen?
Jerry will be considered as an uninsured motorist. In order to meet the minimum requirement, Jerry will have to pay out of pocket. Jerry’s insurer will meet the higher specified limit for the accident. The insurer is only liable to pay $20,000.
Personal Auto Insurance • 70
LESSON 3 QUIZ ANSWER KEY 1.
The insurer should pay the entire settlement amount. The insurer should only pay the policy limit. The insurer should try and reach a settlement with the injured person’s insurer. The insurer is under no obligation to make any payments.
The insurer is obligated to pay only up to the policy limits. 2.
I & II.* There are two parts of automobile liability insurance, namely, bodily injury liability insurance and property damage liability insurance. Liability for any injury caused to the pedestrian will be covered under bodily injury liability insurance. 3.
$60,000* We know that Josh’s coverage was $10,000/$40,000/$60,000 (BI per person / BI per accident / PD per occurrence). From this we know that the insurance company will pay up to $10,000 to each injured, but no more than a total of $40,000 to all injured people in that one accident. Thus, the insurance company will pay up to $60,000 for the repair or replacement of the other party’s property damaged in that accident. 4.
Post-judgment interest payments*
Supplementary payments include: Up to $200 a day for lost wages when the insured is required to attend a legal hearing or trial, bail bond costs up to $250 if required due to an accident resulting in covered liability and post judgment interest payments. Payments for bodily injury and damaged property are not made as supplementary payments.
Personal Auto Insurance • 71
5.
Jerry’s insurer will meet the higher specified limit for the accident.*
If the insured becomes involved in an auto accident out of state and the state involved requires higher liability limits than the insured maintains, the PAP will provide the higher specified limit for this accident.
Personal Auto Insurance • 72
Lesson 4: Part B: Medical Payments Coverage
What Coverage Does Part B Provide?
Regardless of fault, the insured and his/her family and passengers are covered
for necessary medical and funeral expenses sustained, regardless of who was at
fault. Part B differs from Part A in that Part A requires legal liability on the part of
the insured. The insured and family members are also covered if they are struck
by an auto when they are pedestrians.
This coverage is a single limit of anywhere from $1,000 to $10,000 and applies to
a single person per accident.
If there is other applicable auto medical payments insurance, the policy will pay
only its share of the loss. The insurer’s share is the proportion that the policy’s
limit of liability bears to the total of all applicable limits.
Medical Payments Coverage
Medical Payments Coverage pays hospital bills, doctors’ bills, funeral expenses,
and other related medical costs to the insured or to family members following an
auto accident. It makes no difference if the accident was the insured’s fault or
not, nor does it matter whether the insured or the covered family members were
struck while occupying a vehicle or while walking, etc.
Personal Auto Insurance • 73
The policy’s basic unit of coverage is $1,000, but one can expand the coverage
to $10,000 for a reasonable premium increase. The policy covers:
• The insured and family members of the insured
• Injuries while occupying the covered auto, including getting into and out of the
car
• The insured and named family members while pedestrians
• Other persons while occupying the covered automobile
The exclusions are usually similar to the exclusions under the liability provisions.
They include autos used for hire and autos operated without a reasonable belief
that the user had the authority.
NOTEWORTHY: The additional benefit of medical coverage is that it provides
coverage for funeral expenses, which is not covered by health insurance
provided either by employers or through private coverage.
Personal Injury Protection
In several states, personal injury protection is offered. PIP is a no-fault
coverage for insured victims of auto accidents. PIP coverage provides the
following benefits:
• Reasonable expenses for necessary medical and funeral services
• 80% of an insured’s loss of income from employment
Personal Auto Insurance • 74
• Reasonable expenses for obtaining services (house-keeping, child care,
etc.) that an insured would normally have performed without pay if not
injured
NOTE: The limit of insurance is usually $2,500 per person, with optional
higher limits of $5,000, $10,000 and up to $100,000.
Analysis of the Insuring Agreement
According to the insuring agreement, the insurer will pay reasonable medical and
funeral expenses incurred within three years of the date of the accident.
Insured Persons
Individuals considered as insureds under Part B: Medical Payments Coverage
include:
• The named insured and family members (occupying any vehicle and as
pedestrians)
• Other persons (occupying the insured vehicle).
Analysis of Each of the Exclusions
Medical payments coverage will NOT cover an insured:
Personal Auto Insurance • 75
• Occupying any vehicle with fewer than four wheels (motorcycles,
snowmobiles)
• Occupying his/her car while it is carrying persons or property for a fee
• Occupying any vehicle used as a residence (a parked camper)
• Covered under workers’ compensation (WC)
• Occupying or struck by any vehicle (except for the insured auto) owned by or
available to the insured’s family members (except the insured and his/her
spouse)
• Occupying any vehicle without being entitled to do so (except a family
member using a covered auto owned by the named insured)
• Occupying any vehicle, except a PAP-eligible vehicle (including a non-owned
van or pickup), while in the business of any insured
• Injured due to nuclear or war hazards
• Injured while occupying a vehicle at a racing facility, during competition or
practice
Restrictions
The most the insurer will pay, per person, for all damages resulting from any
accident is the limit shown in the Declarations page. (There is no “stacking” if you
have more than one car).
NOTE: Medical payments offset any payment later due under Part A or Part C.
Personal Auto Insurance • 76
The Effect of Other Insurance on Loss Payments
This policy contributes proportionately by limits. This policy is an excess over
insurance on cars not owned by the insured.
Personal Auto Insurance • 77
LESSON 4 QUIZ
1. What is the maximum amount of coverage (in dollars) that can be purchased under a Part B Medical Payments Coverage?
$30,000 $50,000 $10,000 $20,000
2. Jake’s mother, who lives with Jake, was walking to the store when she was hit by a hit-and-run vehicle. She for hospitalized for three days. Who will pay for the expenses incurred?
The hit-and-run vehicle owner Jake’s insurance company Jake;s mother The guilty party’s insurance company
3. What sort of coverage is offered by PIP?
Split limit coverage Dual limit coverage No-fault coverage Limitless coverage
4. What percentage of income lost, due to an accident, is provided by PIP? 80% 20% 50% 75% 5. In the absence of a special endorsement, which of the following insureds will NOT be covered?
John, who fell off a motorbike and fractured his arm Bobby, who drove into the a pool causing severe damage Matt, who was hit by a speeding vehicle while crossing the street Kelly, who missed a turn and drove onto the sidewalk
Personal Auto Insurance • 78
LESSON 4 QUIZ ANSWER KEY
1. $10,000*
The policy’s basic unit of coverage for medical payments is $1,000, but one can expand the coverage to $10,000 for a reasonable premium increase. 2.
Jake’s insurance company* The insurance company from which Jake purchased personal auto insurance will pay all the medical expenses, because according to Part B Medical payments coverage, the insured and his/her named family members while pedestrians are covered. As for payment being made by the other driver, usually hit-and-run drivers do not have coverage. 3.
No-fault coverage* In several states, personal injury protection is offered. PIP is a no-fault coverage for insured victims of auto accidents. 4. 80%* PIP coverage provides 80% of an insured’s loss of income from employment. 5.
John, who fell off a motorbike and fractured his arm* John will not be covered because he was operating a vehicle with less than four wheels. Autos having less than four wheels are not covered.
Personal Auto Insurance • 79
LESSON 5: Part C: Uninsured Motorists Coverage
What Coverage Does Part C Provide?
An uninsured motorist is someone that may strike the insured but who does not
carry insurance or who is a hit and run driver. Part C agrees to pay damages
which an insured is legally entitled to recover from the owner or operator of an
uninsured vehicle because of bodily injury sustained in an auto accident.
What Is An Uninsured Motor Vehicle?
Defining an Uninsured Motor Vehicle
An uninsured motor vehicle may be one of the following:
• A vehicle that has no liability coverage at the time of the accident.
• A vehicle that is operated by an unidentified hit and run driver who strikes
an insured or family member, the insured’s auto, or any auto occupied by
the insured or a family member.
• A vehicle that has liability coverage, but not enough to meet the state’s
financial responsibility requirement.
• A vehicle that has invalid liability coverage at the time of the accident
because the insurer is insolvent or denied coverage.
The definition of an uninsured motor vehicle does NOT apply to:
• Vehicles operated by a self-insurer, unless insolvent
• Vehicles owned by or made available for the regular use of the insured or
Personal Auto Insurance • 80
any family member
• Vehicles operated by a government agency
• Vehicles operated on rails
• Vehicles designed for use off public roads
• Vehicles used as a residence
Underinsured Motorist Coverage
Underinsured motorist coverage is available by endorsement under PAP. It
covers the insured when involved in an accident with a driver who has auto
liability insurance, but whose coverage limits are insufficient to pay for the
insured’s damages.
NOTE: According to the insuring agreement of part C, the insurer will pay
compensatory damages for bodily injury (and, in many states, property damage)
to which any insured is legally entitled, caused by an uninsured vehicle.
Underinsured motorist coverage pays bodily injury coverage caused by the
operation of motor vehicles which are underinsured. The underinsured motorist
coverage allows a covered person to be paid the difference between the actual
damages for bodily injury and the limit of the other driver’s insurance when it is
not sufficient to pay the entire claim of the injured party.
Personal Auto Insurance • 81
Who is the Insured for Uninsured Motorists Coverage?
The “insured” is:
• The named insured and family members
• Anyone occupying the named insured’s covered auto
• Any person entitled to recover damages because of BI caused by an
uninsured motorist to the named insured, family members, or passengers
in the covered auto
Part C Exclusions
Part C does NOT cover losses:
• For BI sustained by an insured while occupying or when struck by an auto
that is owned by the insured, but not insured for uninsured motorist
coverage under the policy
• That are settled without the insurer’s consent
• For BI sustained by a family member while occupying or when struck by
an auto owned by the named insured that has primary uninsured motorist
coverage under another policy
• That occur when the auto is being used as a public livery
• That occur while the insured is using an auto without the reasonable belief
that he/she is entitled to do so
Personal Auto Insurance • 82
Part C does not cover punitive (exemplary) damages (awarded to punish
wrongdoers and to set an example).
Part C only covers compensatory damages (compensation for losses).
NOTE: The limit of liability coverage for Part C is similar to that of Part A.
What Is The Rationale Behind Uninsured/Underinsured
Motorists Coverage?
Uninsured/Underinsured Motorists Coverage
This auto insurance protection covers the insured and his/her family members
and passengers who are injured by a variety of incidents. Some people drive
without insurance despite the laws requiring the contrary. The uninsured motorist
provision covers the losses from their lack of responsibility. The policy pays an
amount that the insured could have collected had the uninsured driver carried the
minimum required coverage in that state. This contractual promise is limited to
the minimum. This protection extends to three situations:
• An uninsured or under-insured automobile under the state laws
• Hit and run accidents
• Insured autos with insurance companies that become insolvent
Uninsured motorist protection deals only with losses for bodily injury and not
property damage.
Personal Auto Insurance • 83
Important Point
The Underinsured Motorists Coverage protects the insured and the covered
family members for the loss he/she sustained after the other driver’s coverage
has been exhausted. So, when the other driver does not have enough auto
insurance liability coverage to pay the full claim amount, the injured individual’s
insurance takes over.
If the insured causes an accident, the only way that he/she can collect payment
for damages is if the other driver was insured. If the other driver is not, the
insured will only be paid a sum equal to the amount he/she would have received
if the other driver was properly insured.
Example
If the declaration page shows an uninsured liability limit of $150,000/300,000, this
means that per individual maximum coverage is $150,000 and $300,000 is the
limit of per accident coverage. To compensate for a situation where the person
causing the accident is at fault and is also underinsured, the underinsured
motorist coverage will pay for any shortfall in the coverage paid by the other
person’s insurance.
Personal Auto Insurance • 84
Arbitration
If the insured and the insurer are in disagreement about the amount of damages
and the amount due, they shall each appoint, at their own individual expense, an
arbitrator. The two arbitrators will appoint a third, whose cost will be shared by
the insurer. The decision of any two individuals out of the three will be final.
Only the issues of whether the insured is entitled to recover damages and the
amount of damages may be arbitrated. Actual coverage disputes are not subject
to arbitration.
Limit of Liability
The insurer will pay the amount for which the uninsured driver would have been
legally responsible, minus any payments made by or for him, and minus any WC
payments received, subject to the policy limit (without stacking).
NOTE: Part C payments reduce any recovery later due under Parts A and B.
The Effect of Other Insurance on Loss Payments
The insurer will contribute proportionately by limits. However, the coverage is
excess over other uninsured or underinsured motorists insurance.
Personal Auto Insurance • 85
LESSON 5 QUIZ
1. Which of the following best describes an uninsured motorist?
A motorist operating his/her brother’s vehicle A motorist operating a self-insured vehicle A motorist operating a government-owned vehicle A motorist whose vehicle is insured by an insolvent insurer
2. In which of the following situations does underinsured motorist coverage apply?
When one is involved in an accident with a driver whose coverage does not meet the state limit When one is involved in an accident with a driver who does not have any auto insurance When one is involved in an accident with a driver operating a government- owned vehicle When one is involved in an accident, in a state being visited by the insured
3. Given that damages from an accident involving an underinsured motorist total $40,000, what amount will be paid by the insured motorist’s insurer if the underinsured driver’s policy limit was $10,000?
$30,000 $10,000 $40,000 $0
4. The declaration page of Mathew’s PAP states uninsured liability coverage as $200,000/$400,000. Given that one individual was injured in an accident, what is the maximum that Mathew’s insurer is liable to pay?
$200,000 $300,000 $400,000 $350,000
Personal Auto Insurance • 86
5. Two parties involved in an accident decide to settle the matter through arbitration. There were three individuals involved, the two arbitrators and a third umpire. Given that neither of the three could agree on one solution, which would be the best way to decide the matter?
Consider the umpire’s decision as final. Take the advice of a third party. Draw chits. Implement the decision on which at least two out of the three agree.
Personal Auto Insurance • 87
LESSON 5 QUIZ ANSWER KEY
1.
A motorist whose vehicle is insured by an insolvent insurer* When an insurer declares insolvency, the insured is not covered and thus, if an accident occurs, the motorist is considered to be uninsured. Vehicles owned by the government are not considered uninsured vehicles. 2.
When one is involved in an accident with a driver whose coverage does not meet the state limit*
Underinsured motorist coverage applies when the insured is involved in an accident with a driver whose insurance coverage does not meet the minimum liability coverage limit set by the government. A driver who does not have any insurance coverage is an uninsured driver and thus this coverage will not apply in such a case. Government vehicles are never considered to be uninsured, thus they are not underinsured either. 3.
$30,000* The insured motorist will be paid $30,000 because according to the underinsured motorist coverage, the insurer pays the difference between the policy coverage of the underinsured and the damages, which in this case is ($40,000 - $10,000 =) $30,000. 4.
$200,000* $200,000 is the maximum amount that the insurer is liable to pay. When the limits are stated as $200,000/$400,000, it means that the per individual maximum coverage is $200,000. $400,000 is the limit of the per accident coverage. 5.
Implement the decision on which at least two out of the three agree.* When settling any matter through arbitration, the two arbitrators appoint a third, whose cost is shared by the insurers. The decision of any two individuals out of the three is be final.
Personal Auto Insurance • 88
LESSON 6: Part D: Coverage for Physical Damage
to Your Auto
What Coverage Does Part D Provide?
Under part D coverage, the insurer will pay for direct accidental loss to the
insured auto, including its equipment, minus deductible. Collision and other than
collision (OTC) are insured separately. A lower deductible is often chosen for the
OTC coverage.
Rental Cars
Car rental companies place the responsibilities for loss or damage to the
rental car upon the renter. Collision damage waivers may be purchased
to relieve the renter of all or part of his/her responsibility for loss or
damage to the car. It should be noted that under a PAP, Coverage D will
provide some coverage for the rental car.
Covered Autos
Covered autos include:
• The self-owned insured auto
• Non-owned autos (borrowed or rented cars)
• Temporary substitute autos (substituting for one that’s broken down, being
repaired, serviced, lost, or destroyed).
Personal Auto Insurance • 89
NOTE: Non-owned and substitute cars may be covered on an excess basis.
Coverage on those cars does not include cars owned or regularly used by the
insured or a member of your family.
Limit of Liability
The insurer will pay up to the lower of the actual cash value (ACV) or the repair or
replacement cost, plus tax; however non-owned trailers are limited to $500.
The insurer will not pay for diminution in value (actual or perceived loss in market
value resulting from the loss).
MORE ABOUT: The actual cash value (ACV) is a replacement cost minus
depreciation, but in practice, for autos, ACV means market value.
NOTE: An ISO endorsement (that has not been approved in all jurisdictions)
states that the insurer will not pay for diminished value (actual or perceived loss
in market value or resale value that results from direct loss). Some jurisdictions
require insurers to pay diminished value as part of a loss.
Personal Auto Insurance • 90
Definition and Analysis of “Collision” And “Other Than
Collision” Coverage
Part D coverage is divided into two separate coverages:
• Collision
• Comprehensive
Collision means the upset of a covered auto or its impact with another vehicle or
object. When a loss is not considered to be from a collision, it will fall under
something other than collision coverage. Coverage applies on an ACV basis.
NOTE: Damages resulting from missiles, falling objects, fire, theft, explosion,
earthquake, windstorm, hail, flood, vandalism, riot, contact with an animal, and
glass breakage (which are specified as other than collision (OTC) losses) are not
covered.
Comprehensive coverage is a loss other than from collision and addresses
damage losses to the insured vehicle caused by:
• Missiles or falling objects
• Fire
• Theft or larceny
• Explosion or earthquake
• Windstorm
Personal Auto Insurance • 91
• Hail, water or flood
• Malicious mischief or vandalism
• Riot or civil commotion
• Contact with a bird or animal
• Breakage of glass
NOTEWORTHY: OTC is often called comprehensive coverage.
Physical Damage Coverage
The physical damage section of the policy insures the covered automobile for
damages due to collision or any other peril, such as theft or weather. The policy
can cover all of the physical damage to the car. This is usually provided under
comprehensive coverage, which is really coverage for all risks of physical
damage. Collision is a separate coverage item that includes damage to the auto
from a collision with another car or any other object. The comprehensive
coverage then would cover losses due to:
� Fire
� Theft
� Vandalism
� Storms
� Accidents involving animals
� Explosions
Personal Auto Insurance • 92
Important Point
• The collision coverage will usually be scheduled separately. It will also
relate to the value of the car. This is important, because not all cars are
worth enough to insure against collision.
• Comprehensive coverage can be issued alone without including collision
coverage, but collision coverage will not be issued unless comprehensive
coverage is included.
• Collision coverage is not dependent on fault. Regardless of who caused
the accident, you are entitled to collision benefits. Collision benefits can be
paid to vehicles you don't own. Should you be driving a car you do not
own, and are involved in an accident, or the car is stolen while in your
possession, benefits will be paid.
NOTEWORTHY: Some of the more common exclusions include damage to tape
players and other sound systems, antennas, and custom furnishings. Again, this
policy typically excludes damage incurred while the car is for hire.
Appraisal
If the insurer and the insured are in disagreement about the amount of loss, each
is required to appoint an appraiser at his/her own expense. Those two
appraisers will appoint an umpire. The decision of any two of those three will be
Personal Auto Insurance • 93
final and binding on both the insurer and the insured.
The Meaning and Application of Transportation
Expenses
If the auto owned by the insured or a non-owned auto for which the insured is
responsible suffers loss, the insurer will pay the insured up to $20 per day. After
24 hours of loss (or 48 hours after theft,) $600 will be paid. Such payments will
be stopped as soon as the auto returns to use, or the insurance company makes
payment for loss.
NOTE: A maximum of $600 will be paid to the insured following loss of a non-
owned vehicle.
Common Exclusions
The insurer will not pay for loss:
• To the insured auto while it is used for livery (taxi) purposes
• From wear and tear, freezing, breakdown, or road damage to tires
unless caused by theft
• Due to nuclear or war perils or due to government confiscation
• Of sound reproduction equipment not permanently installed or contained
within a permanently installed housing unit; however there is a $1,000
sub-limit that applys to equipment installed in a location not used by the
Personal Auto Insurance • 94
manufacturer.
• To other electronic equipment that receives or transmits audio, video, or
data signals unless permanently installed in the dashboard opening
normally used for a radio, if it is not installed in the manufacturer’s
location, a $1,000 sub-limit applies
• Of media used with sound reproduction equipment or other electronic
equipment
• To a camper body or trailer not shown in the Declarations, unless
acquired after policy inception and insured within 14 days
• To any auto while used by you or a family member without the
reasonable belief it is acceptable for you to use that auto
• To awnings or equipment designed to create additional living facilities
• To any custom furnishings or equipment on any pickup or van including
carpeting, furniture, murals, and decals
• Of radar detection equipment
• To any non-owned pickup or van used in any business
• Incurred during racing or race practicing inside a racing facility
• To a rental car rented by an insured in a state with laws prohibiting rental
companies from holding renters liable for damage to rental vehicles
Examples of Exclusions to Part D Of the PAP
• Public or livery conveyance--the insured used his auto as a gypsy cab
• Wear and tear, etc.--driving over a broken bottle caused a flat tire
Personal Auto Insurance • 95
• Electronic equipment designed for the reproduction of sound--extra
speakers placed in the car’s rear window were stolen or destroyed in a
collision
• Electronic equipment designed for the reception and transmission
of audio, visual, or data signals--the insured’s car phone was stolen
• Media and accessories--video tapes and CDs were stolen from the car
• Government destruction or confiscation--state troopers shot out the
tires of the insured’s get-away car following a hold-up
• Camper body or trailer not shown in the declarations--a tree fell on
an owned trailer the insured did not insure
• Using a vehicle without permission--the insured’s son took the
neighbor’s car for a joyride
• Radar and laser detection equipment--the insured’s radar detector
was stolen
• Customizing equipment--hail damaged the custom-painted mural on
the insured’s van
• Non-owned auto used in the auto business--a mechanic damaged a
customer’s car
• Racing--Jeff Gordon hit a guard rail during practice.
• Rental vehicles--the insured bought a collision damage waiver on a
rental car
Personal Auto Insurance • 96
How Losses Are Paid
Payment of Loss
The insurer may pay for loss, repair, or replacement, or he/she may return stolen
property to the insured or to the address given in the policy summary. The
insured will pay for any damage resulting from theft.
NOTEWORHTY: This policy will not benefit any bailee. A bailee is a person who
takes custody or control of another’s property; like a parking garage attendant or
auto repair shop employee.
Other Sources of Recovery
If other insurance also applies, the insurer will pay the proportionate share of any
loss, but coverage for non-owned autos is excess.
Insurer’s Options in Paying a Loss
The insurer may pay for the loss in money, or by repairing/replacing the
damaged car. The insurer:
• Will pay any damage resulting from theft of your auto
• May return stolen property to your declared address
NOTE: Deductibles are used to eliminate small claims, reduce premiums, and
encourage you to avoid and control losses.
Personal Auto Insurance • 97
Loss Adjustment for Total Loss of an Auto
Determining Total Loss
A total loss because of damage occurs when the actual cost of repairs (repairs +
loss of use + betterment) exceeds the auto’s ACV, minus any salvage value.
Some insurers set a threshold (such as 75% or 85%) and if the cost of repairs
exceeds that percentage of ACV, then the vehicle is considered a total loss.
Determining ACV
Some states mandate the method of estimating ACV. Regardless of the method
used, ACV should consider:
• Taxes
• Fees
• The vehicle’s options package, mileage, use, and overall condition
Common ACV Errors
The most common ACV error is incorrectly identifying the vehicle’s options
package. Other common errors include incorrectly assessing the vehicle’s
condition, failing to deduct for unrepaired prior damage, and failing to debit or
credit for high or low mileage.
Personal Auto Insurance • 98
Total Loss Payment
After the waiting period for theft has expired, or the damaged vehicle is declared
a total loss and the ownership is transferred to the insurer, the loss is paid equal
to the ACV minus the deductible.
If the insured keeps the car, the payment equals the ACV minus both:
• The deductible, and
• The salvage figure (net amount received from the sale of the vehicle
minus expenses such as towing and storage)
Considerations in Auto Damage Claims
Direct Repair Program (DRP)
The direct repair plan is a network of repair facilities that meets the insurer’s
criteria for cost and repair quality.
Anti-Steering Laws
States’ anti-steering laws do not prohibit the use of DRPs, but they do limit an
insurer’s ability to restrict a consumer’s right to choose an auto repair shop.
Some laws prohibit the insured from having to travel more than a reasonable
distance for repairs, while other laws prohibit an insurer from requiring an insured
to use a specified facility.
Personal Auto Insurance • 99
Flood Factors Include
Flood factors include:
• The type of water
• The amount of time submerged
• The height of flood waters in the vehicle
• The amount of time the vehicle stayed wet
Investigating Auto Theft Claims
Investigation
The adjuster verifies the car’s existence and the circumstances of the loss. The
insured’s statement should cover:
• When and where the car was obtained
• The car’s VIN, condition, options, and mileage
• Whether the car was financed
• If it had been repaired recently
Theft Report
The insured should notify the police. The adjuster should notify the appropriate
index bureau, which tracks losses relating to a particular claims office.
Ten Indicators of Auto Theft Fraud
• Domestic problems
Personal Auto Insurance • 100
• Duplicate title
• Heavy debt
• Incorrect VIN
• Leased vehicle with high mileage
• Need for major repair work
• New policy or newly added vehicle
• Prior losses
• Unemployment
• Unusual amount of personal property in vehicle
The Four Possible Outcomes of a Stolen Vehicle Claim
When a claim for a stolen vehicle is filed, any one of the following may occur.
The vehicle is:
• Not recovered
• Recovered and repaired
• Recovered and a total loss
• Not covered due to the insured’s fraud or another policy defense
Salvage
Three Categories of Salvage
The following are the three categories of salvage:
Personal Auto Insurance • 101
• Rebuilt
o If it is less than 6-years-old
o If it is in better-than-average condition
o If it has average or better mileage
o If it has repairable damage
• Used for parts
o If it is less than 10-years-old
o If it has relatively little body damage
o If it has minor wear on the mechanical parts
• Used for scrap metal
o If it is severely damaged
o If it has few usable parts
Selling Salvage
There are two methods of determining salvage value:
• Salvage pool: Cars are collected, stored, and sold at auction, each
with a minimum bid.
• Bid process: The adjuster accepts bids directly or hires a salvage
company to accept bids.
Contractors’ Equipment
Contractor’s equipment consists of the tools and machinery used for
construction, renovation, earth-moving, and similar activities. The proper name of
Personal Auto Insurance • 102
a piece of contractors’ equipment usually describes both its method of travel
(crawler/ track or tires/wheels) and its attachment (loader, grader, dozer, etc).
Examples: crawler dozer, wheel loader.
Equipment Falls Into Four Basic Categories Based On Function:
• Earth-moving equipment: Such equipment is used to clear job sites
and move or eliminate large amounts of earth, rock, snow, debris, or
other materials.
o Earth-moving equipment includes backhoes, bulldozers, excavators,
loaders, power shovels, roller/compactors, scraper/graders, and
trenchers.
• Site-improvement equipment: Such equipment prepares and finishes
asphalt and concrete surfaces.
o Site-improvement equipment includes batching and mixing plants,
pavers, pavement planers, and finishers.
• Material-handling equipment: This equipment is used to raise, lower,
and transport people and materials at a job site.
o Material-handling equipment includes forklifts, cranes, and hoists.
• Miscellaneous equipment provides supplementary power and support
functions at job sites.
o Miscellaneous equipment includes air compressors, generators, and
pumps.
Personal Auto Insurance • 103
Contractors’ Equipment Insurance
Contractor’s equipment insurance protects the insured against direct physical
loss to mobile equipment, machinery, and tools used in the insured’s business.
Coverage may be written on:
• A scheduled basis (which describes each item individually with its own
limit of insurance)
• A blanket basis (which insures all items within a single amount of
insurance without separately describing the items)
Policies with a large schedule include a catastrophe limit. (This is a maximum
amount payable for all property losses associated with a single occurrence).
Blanket policies set an overall policy limit applicable to all covered property,
subject to a per item maximum limit.
• Covered property generally includes the property of others, but schedule
requirements and coverage conditions can create coverage gaps for
some properties.
o Newly acquired property is technically not covered in policies written
on a scheduled basis, but most policies include a clause that
automatically covers such property up to a specified amount if the
insured reports the new property within a specified number of days.
Personal Auto Insurance • 104
o Property leased, rented, or borrowed may be covered by including
such property in the Covered Property Provision in the Newly
Acquired Equipment Clause, or as a coverage extension or
endorsement.
• Property excluded:
o Property in high-risk work environments--such as property while
underground; underwater; waterborne; airborne; or loaned, leased, or
rented to others, and
o Property covered by other insurance
• Covered causes of loss:
o A special-form policy insures against risks of direct physical loss
unless specifically limited or excluded. Most contractors’ equipment
policies provide special-form coverage.
o A named-perils policy is used for insureds who want lower premiums
or who want policies tailored to their special risks.
• General exclusions:
o War, nuclear hazard, and governmental action
o Mysterious disappearance
o Inventory shortage
o Voluntary parting
o Unauthorized instructions
o Dishonest acts of employees to whom property was entrusted
• Additional exclusions that may be found in policies:
Personal Auto Insurance • 105
o Artificially generated electrical currents
o Mechanical breakdown
o Damage caused by repairs, servicing, and maintenance
• Special exclusions that apply to cranes and derrick booms:
o Weight of load exclusion prohibits coverage for loss caused by the
weight of a load exceeding the manufacturer’s rated capacity
o Tandem lift exclusion excludes losses that occur when two or more
cranes are used to lift a single load
o Boom operation exclusion deletes coverage for losses occurring
during operation unless caused by specified losses
• Coverage extensions and endorsements:
o Rental reimbursement coverage pays for expenses the insured
incurs to rent substitute equipment for covered equipment that has
been damaged by a covered peril.
o Business income and extra expense coverage covers lost net income
(operating expenses that continue during the business interruption)
and extra expenses the insured incurs to continue normal operations.
Most contractors need rental reimbursement coverage rather than business
income coverage because contractors can usually continue operations simply by
renting substitute equipment.
Personal Auto Insurance • 106
• Valuation: Most policies cover this on an ACV basis, which covers the
cost to repair or replace damaged equipment and machinery minus
depreciation and obsolescence.
o Depreciation is based on age and hours of use.
• Coinsurance: Policies are generally written with an 80%, 90%, or 100%
coinsurance clause that applies to each separate limit.
• Deductibles may be indicated as either a specific dollar amount or a
specific percentage of the value of the damaged item or scheduled
amount. Split deductibles may apply to certain properties or perils. In
addition, some perils may be subject to a separate deductible.
• Locations covered: The coverage territory includes Canada, Puerto
Rico, and the continental US (which includes Alaska, but not Hawaii).
o Some policies cover only the contiguous US (which excludes both
Alaska and Hawaii).
NOTE: Two problems with using serial numbers to identify contractors’
equipment:
• There is no standard form for identifying information (unlike an auto’s
VIN, which provides specific information about the vehicle).
• The serial number can be located anywhere on the equipment.
Personal Auto Insurance • 107
A Total Loss Claim for Contractors’ Equipment
The total loss claim for contractors is based on ACV. Nine factors that affect ACV
of a total loss to a piece of contractors’ equipment:
• Accessories
• Age
• Hours of Use
• Local Market Demand
• Maintenance
• Manufacturer
• Prior Unrepaired Damage
• Salvage
• Equipment Type and Size
Personal Auto Insurance • 108
LESSON 6 QUIZ
1. Which of the following must be known in order to determine the actual cash value of an auto? I. The replacement cost II. The cost at the time of purchase III. The amount the vehicle has depreciated
I & II II & III I & III II ONLY
2. Damages caused by which of the following will fall under the category of “other than collision”?
While speeding to the office, Dexter hit a deer. Driving at 100km/h, Rita hit a parked vehicle. Under the influence of alcohol, Grace drove into the garage wall. While fixing a vehicle, the mechanic damaged the engine.
3. Which of the following coverages cannot be issued alone?
Collision coverage Comprehensive coverage Medical coverage Workers compensation coverage
4. Susan’s neighbor left his vehicle in Susan’s care. Given that the vehicle was stolen, will Susan’s insurance company pay for her neighbor’s transportation expenses?
The insurance company will pay a maximum of $600. The insurance company will not pay anything because the vehicle was not insured by them. The insurance company will pay $20 per day for the next month. The insurance company will pay the replacement cost.
Personal Auto Insurance • 109
5. Which of the following is an exclusion under Part D, coverage for physical damage to your auto?
Damage to an auto that is used for purposes, other than livery. Loss incurred due to road damage to tires Loss incurred while an auto is being operated by a family member Damage to a pick-up used in a business
Personal Auto Insurance • 110
LESSON 6 QUIZ ANSWER KEY
1. I & III*
The actual cash value (ACV) is replacement cost minus depreciation, 2.
While speeding to the office, Dexter hit a deer.*
Damages resulting from contact with a bird or an animal are covered by “other than collision” coverage. 3.
Collision coverage* Comprehensive coverage can be issued alone without including collision coverage, but collision coverage will not be issued unless comprehensive coverage is included. 4.
The insurance company will pay a maximum of $600.* Under Part D insurance coverage, coverage will provide up to a maximum of $600 for transportation expenses. 5.
Loss incurred due to road damage to tires* Part D will provide coverage for all of the listed losses/damages except for damages to tires. Damages of such a nature come under wear and tear which is not covered by Part D.
Personal Auto Insurance • 111
LESSON 7: Part E: Duties After An Accident Or
Loss
Part E defines the duties that the insured is required to perform when an accident
occurs.
Actions That Must Be Taken
When an accident or loss occurs, the insured must take the following actions:
• Notify the police
• Notify the company
• Be specific as to all the details of the loss, including when and where the
loss occurred, how it occurred, names and addresses of witnesses and
data about injured persons.
• Provide access to any required information.
• Submit a completed proof of loss form.
• Protect the auto from further damage.
• Allow the company to inspect and/or appraise any damage.
Personal Auto Insurance • 112
What Steps Must A Person Take To Meet Policy
Conditions For Reporting An Accident And Submitting A
Claim?
The insured must:
• Cooperate with the insurer.
• Notify the insurer promptly.
• Notify the police of any hit and run accident.
The insured cooperates with the insurer by providing them copies of any
pertinent legal papers, submitting medical exams by the insurer’s physicians (at
the insurer’s expense), help the insurer get medical reports and other records,
and submit a proof of loss (a written statement giving the facts of the claim.)
Late loss notice might adversely affect an insurer as, with the passage of time:
• Memories fade.
• Hard evidence becomes unavailable (Snow melts. Tire skid marks
disappear.)
• Witnesses move and become unavailable or die.
• Claimants become more and more resolved to demand more and more for
their losses.
The aforementioned factors increase the total cost of settling claims.
Personal Auto Insurance • 113
Additional Duties for Uninsured Motorists Coverage
The insurer must also perform these additional duties:
• Promptly notify the police if the other driver hit and ran.
• If the insured sues the uninsured motorist, a copy of the legal papers
must be provided to the insurer.
Additional Duties for Physical Damage Coverage
• Protect the auto from further damage after any loss (at the insurer’s
expense.)
• Notify the police if the auto is stolen.
• Allow the insurer to inspect and appraise the damage before the
auto is repaired or disposed off.
Personal Auto Insurance • 114
LESSON 7 QUIZ
1. Part E of a PAP focuses on which of the following?
Medical payments that an insured is entitled to receive The dollar amount that the insurer is required to pay in case of an accident Privileges that the insured is entitled to under the policy Actions that the insured is required to perform in case of an accident
2. Which one of the following duties is NOT to be performed by the insured immediately after an accident occurs?
Make a settlement with the other party Inform the police Provide the insurer with the details of loss Protect the auto from further damage
3. Which of the following actions performed by the insured prove that he/she is cooperating with the insurer?
The insured hesitantly hands over his/her medical records. The insured refuses to have his/her auto examined. The insurer is unable to set up a meeting with the insured. The proof of loss submitted by the insured lacks substantial detail.
4. How does a late submission of the notice of loss affect the insurer?
The insurer may be unable to find hard evidence. The insurer is unable to file the proof of loss application. The insurer is unable to determine whether the policy was in effect at the time of the accident. The insurer is unable to sanction the claim amount.
5. Other than the insurance company, who else must the insured inform about the accident?
The police Family members 911 The fire department
Personal Auto Insurance • 115
LESSON 7 QUIZ ANSWER KEY
1. Actions that the insured is required to perform in case of an accident*
Part E focuses on the duties that an insured is required to perform in case of an accident. Medical payments are covered in Part B and liability coverage is covered in Part A. 2.
Make a settlement with the other party* The insured is required to perform all the listed actions except for reaching a settlement. A settlement is usually reached amongst the insurers of both the parties involved. It is the insurer’s job to reach a settlement, not the insureds. 3.
The insured hesitantly hands over his/her medical records.* It is incumbent on the insured to cooperate with the insurer when he/she is investigating a claim. The insured cooperates with the insurer by providing him/her copies of any pertinent legal papers, submitting medical exams by the insurer’s physicians, assisting the insurer in obtaining medical reports and other records, and submitting a proof of loss. Though the insured handed over the reports reluctantly, the fact that he/she handed them over shows his/her cooperation. 4.
The insurer may be unable to find hard evidence.* Late submission of the notice of loss affects the insurer because he/she may be unable to find hard evidence as, for example, tire skid marks disappear with the passage of time. In addition, people tend to forget details over time, thus making the investigation process more difficult. 5.
The police* When an accident or loss occurs, the insured is required to inform the insurance agency and the police. He/she may inform his/her family members at will.
Personal Auto Insurance • 116
LESSON 8: Part F: General Provisions
What Does Part F Define?
Part F describes the conditions that the insured is required to meet in order to be
covered. If the insured fails to meet these provisions, he/she may not be
reimbursed by the insurer.
Discuss Each of the Nine General Provisions
The nine general provisions are as follow:
• Bankruptcy: The insurer is required to fulfill his/her obligations
irrespective of whether the insured is insolvent. Insolvency does not
cancel the insurer’s obligations.
• Changes: This insurance policy constitutes the entire agreement which
may only be changed by an endorsement issued by the insurer. The
insurer has the authority to change the premium if the insured’s
exposure changes.
o For example, the premium may be adjusted to reflect changes in the
number, type, or use of insured vehicles; the operators of insured
vehicles; the place of principal garaging; or the coverage,
deductibles, or limits of liability.
• Fraud: If an insured is found guilty of fraud, his/her insurance policy will
be void.
• Legal action against the insurer: The insured cannot sue the insurer
Personal Auto Insurance • 117
unless the insured has complied will all the policy terms and, as stated
under Part A, until after judgment by trial.
• Subrogation: If the insurer pays anyone who has a right to recover
damages from another, the insurer is subrogated to that right. He/she
may not prejudice that right and must assist the insurer.
o If the individual, to whom payment is made, recovers payment he/she
must reimburse the insurer.
o The insurer cannot subrogate against anyone under Part D who
believed that he/she was entitled to use the auto.
• Policy period and territory: The policy period is shown in the
Declarations.
o The policy territory is the USA, Puerto Rico, Canada, and shipping
routes between their ports.
• Policy Termination: The insured may cancel the policy by returning it
to the insurer or by giving the insurer advance written notice.
o The insurer will cancel, non-renew, or terminate with only 10 days
notice for non-payment and at most 20 days. The policy may also be
terminated after 60 days of coverage, only for non-payment, loss of
license, or material misrepresentation.
o The insurer can non-renew or terminate the policy only under certain,
stated conditions or, if more favorable to the insured, as required by
the laws of the state in which the insured resides.
Personal Auto Insurance • 118
o The policy automatically terminates upon the insured failure to pay
the premium.
• Policy transfer: The insured may not assign this policy without the
insurers written, endorsed consent. If the insured dies, coverage
continues for his/her spouse and legal representative for the rest of the
policy period.
• Multiple policies: If the individual is insured with more than one
applicable policy, the maximum amount to be paid by the insurer will be
the highest limit under any one policy.
Personal Auto Insurance • 119
LESSON 8 QUIZ
1. Which of the following is most likely to occur if an insured fails to meet the conditions set forth in the insurance policy?
The insurer is under no obligation to pay the insured for any damages. The insurer and the insured must make amendments to the policy. The insurer must send a written reminder to the insured about the policy. The insurance policy is endorsed by the insurer.
2. Which of the following is NOT amongst the nine general provisions set forth in Part F?
Multiple policies Policy termination Policy transfer Policy purchase
3. Which of the following actions of the insured automatically terminate the insurance policy?
Accidental misstatement of facts on the policy application. Non-payment of the premium. A lost driver’s license. Involvement in an accident that resulted in someone’s death.
4. Under Part D, the insurer cannot subrogate against which of the following?
Anyone who believed that he/she was entitled to use the auto Anyone who purchases life insurance from the insurer Anyone who appears to be a prospective client Anyone willing to pay for damages at his/her own expense
Personal Auto Insurance • 120
5. Kate is in desperate need for money to pay the university she attends. One of her friends suggests that she damage her vehicle and ask the insurance company for a reimbursement. This way she would get the money for repairs, which she can use to pay the university instead. What does Kate stand to lose?
If found guilty, her insurance policy will be void. If found guilty, she will be asked to leave the university. If found guilty, she will not be able to purchase insurance for her automobile for at least seven years. If found guilty, she will be imprisoned for a minimum of two years.
Personal Auto Insurance • 121
LESSON 8 QUIZ ANSWER KEY
1.
The insurer is under no obligation to pay the insured for any damages.* If the insured fails to meet the provisions set forth under Part F, he/she may not be covered by the insurer. 2.
Policy purchase * The nine general provisions listed within the policy under Part F insurance include all the listed topics except policy purchase. The provisions talk about policy renewal, termination and cancellation, but not about purchase. 3.
Non-payment of the premium.* The insurer is required to give the insured a 10 to 20 day notice before terminating, or not renewing a PAP. However, if the insured fails to pay the premium, the policy terminates automatically. 4.
Anyone who believed that he/she was entitled to use the auto* The insurer cannot subrogate against anyone under Part D who believed that he/she was entitled to use the auto 5.
If found guilty, her insurance policy will be void.* Kate is committing fraud. Thus, if she is found guilty, her insurance policy will be void. Kate stands to lose her insurance.
Personal Auto Insurance • 122
LESSON 9: Endorsements and ACORD Forms
Personal Auto Policy Endorsements
Some insureds may have additional coverage needs that can be met by the
following endorsements:
• Towing and Labor Costs: Reimburses for the cost of having a vehicle
towed.
• Extended Non-Owned Coverage for Named Individual: This extends
the extensive coverage automatically provided under the PAP for the
insured and the family while driving cars other than the insured’s covered
autos.
Assigned Risk Plans
Insurance companies seldom wish to insure people with poor driving records
because their loss experience is much greater than that of the average driver.
Accordingly, assigned risk plans help manage these risks. Under these voluntary
agreements, licensed insurance companies agree to share the poor risks among
themselves. Because these risks are randomly assigned to the participating
companies, they are called “assigned risks.” Drivers with poor records are usually
issued BI and PD liability in the minimum required amounts.
Personal Auto Insurance • 123
What Is The Purpose Of Endorsements?
Endorsements are used to provide extended coverage to the insured. Every
insurance customer has different needs which are not always met by the policy.
For example, an insured may desire coverage for damages caused to his/her
vehicle when it was being towed. Such coverage is not provided under the basic
personal auto insurance policy, and thus may only be acquired by extending
coverage with the “Towing and Labor Costs” endorsement. This endorsement
reimburses the insured for the cost of having a vehicle towed. Endorsements
enable the insured to customize coverage according to his/her needs.
What Major Endorsements Are Associated With A
Personal Auto Policy?
Common PAP Endorsements
Following is a list of endorsements commonly used with a PAP:
• The Towing and Labor Endorsement covers towing and labor charges
at the scene of disablement.
• The Coverage for Damage to Your Auto Endorsement allows insureds
to purchase stated value coverage for autos that are difficult to value or
worth more than their market value.
• The Miscellaneous Type Vehicle Endorsement covers motor homes,
motorcycles, and recreational vehicles.
Personal Auto Insurance • 124
• A Snowmobile Endorsement is available.
• The Joint Ownership Coverage Endorsement extends eligibility to
autos owned jointly by nonresident relatives and resident individuals other
than husband and wife.
• The Extended Non-Owned Coverage Endorsement covers otherwise
excluded business use of non-owned autos and autos available for regular
use.
• The Named Non-Owner Coverage Endorsement extends liability to non-
owned autos for insured’s who do not own autos.
Other PAP Endorsements
Extended Non-Owned Coverage Endorsement
Vehicles Furnished or Available For Regular Use Endorsement
Vehicles Furnished or Available for Regular Use Endorsement gives scheduled
individuals coverage while using any non-owned vehicle, including vehicles
furnished for their regular use. An option is available to provide coverage for
family members driving a vehicle regularly furnished to the named insured.
Vehicles Furnished or Available For Use as A Public or Livery Conveyance
Endorsement
This endorsement provides coverage for an individual who frequently operates a
non-owned vehicle for livery use. An option is available to provide coverage for
family members of the named insured.
Personal Auto Insurance • 125
Named Non-owner Coverage
Named non-owner coverage covers named individuals (spouses must be
scheduled) on an excess basis while using non-owned vehicles. It is used by
persons who have only a company car or city dwellers who borrow or rent
vehicles when needed. Newly acquired vehicles are automatically covered for 30
days.
Miscellaneous Type Vehicle Endorsement
These endorsements cover scheduled owned vehicles, such as motor homes,
motorcycles, ATVs, dune buggies, and golf carts.
• The Snowmobile Endorsement insures snowmobiles.
• Limited Mexico Coverage Endorsement includes accidents in Mexico
provided that:
o The accidents took place within 25 miles of the U.S. border.
o The trip was less than 11 days.
o The coverage is in force with a licensed Mexican insurer.
• Coverage for Damage to Your Auto (Maximum Limit of Liability)
Endorsement lists a stated amount as the maximum payable for loss to
a covered auto. The insurer will pay the least of the stated amount, the
ACV of stolen or damaged property, or the amount to repair or replace
with like kind and quality.
• Joint Ownership Coverage Endorsement modifies the definition of
Personal Auto Insurance • 126
insured to include:
o Two individuals who are not married but live together and jointly own
a vehicle.
o Relatives who jointly own a vehicle but do not live together.
• A Trust Endorsement provides coverage when a vehicle is titled solely
in the name of a trust.
• Auto loan/lease coverage indemnifies the insured if a leased or
financed vehicle suffers a total loss and the insured still owes the lessor
or financing company more than the vehicle’s actual cash value.
• Towing and Labor Costs Coverage Endorsement provides up to $25,
$50, or $100 for towing and labor at the scene of disablement. The
endorsement is available only for autos covered under Part D of the
PAP.
• Trip Interruption Endorsement provides up to $600 for reasonable
transportation expenses, lodging, and meals when a vehicle is out of
service for more than 24 hours due to an accident or break down more
than 100 miles from home.
• Optional Limits Transportation Expense Coverage Endorsement
increases the transportation expenses maximum from $20 per day/$600
maximum to $30 per day/$900 maximum.
• Customizing Equipment Coverage insures custom furnishing and
equipment in a van or pickup.
• Electronic Equipment Endorsement covers electronic equipment that
Personal Auto Insurance • 127
is permanently installed in locations not used by the auto manufacturer.
• Covered Property Coverage Endorsement covers awnings and other
equipment designed for use with insured vans, campers, and mobile
homes.
How Endorsements Change Coverage Under The Pap
• The miscellaneous type vehicle endorsement adjusts the PAP to cover
motor homes, motorcycles, and recreational vehicles.
• The passenger hazard exclusion of the miscellaneous type vehicle
endorsement, if chosen, eliminates liability coverage for passengers in
return for a lower premium.
o Part D losses for miscellaneous type vehicles are limited to the least
of stated amount, ACV, or RC.
• The trailer/camper body coverage (maximum limit of liability)
endorsement pays for direct, accidental loss to the trailer or camper
body listed in the declarations or the endorsement. It includes related
equipment, but not clothing, luggage, business or electronic equipment,
radar detectors, or custom furnishings.
• The customizing equipment endorsement provides coverage for custom
furnishings and equipment in or upon any pick-up, panel truck, or van by
eliminating the last Part D exclusion.
o It covers up to the lowest of stated amount, ACV, or RC.
Personal Auto Insurance • 128
• The snowmobile endorsement adjusts the PAP to cover the insureds for
use of any snowmobile.
o It excludes business use, others’ rental of the snowmobile, and any
racing or practice racing.
o The passenger hazard exclusion is available to exclude liability for
passengers and skiers.
• The coverage for excess sound reproducing equipment, audio, visual,
and data electronic equipment and tapes, records, discs, and other
media endorsement covers such property, if the player is permanently
installed (in other than the manufacturer’s dashboard radio opening) for
all Part D perils, without a deductible. Media is covered with up to a $200
maximum limit.
• The named non-owner coverage endorsement covers named individuals
(spouses must be scheduled) on an excess basis while using non-
owned vehicles (and newly-owned vehicles for 30 days).
o Use it for persons who have only a company car or for city dwellers
who borrow or rent cars when needed.
• The towing and labor costs endorsement covers up to a stated amount
($25, 50, or 75) for towing and labor at the scene of disablement
resulting from any disablement, even war.
• The extended non-owned coverage endorsement covers scheduled
individuals while using any non-owned vehicle for business purposes
Personal Auto Insurance • 129
(except the auto/garage business--which is available with an additional
endorsement) including vehicles furnished for their regular use.
• So, the named individuals primarily gain coverage for the following when
using vehicles other than those insured as covered autos under the
PAP:
o Vehicles furnished for their regular use--salesmen using company
cars, volunteer firemen using fire vehicles, and
o Protection against suits by fellow employees (if such suits are not
barred by the state’s WC law)
• The Mexico coverage endorsement extends all coverages, as excess,
for accidents in Mexico if within 25 miles of the US border and only for
trips of less than 11 days.
o It only applies if coverage is also in force with a licensed Mexican
insurer.
• The coverage for damage to your auto (maximum limit of liability)
endorsement (aka “stated amount” endorsement) limits payment to the
lowest of the stated amount, the ACV, or the RC.
o Use it for antique or restored cars to keep the premium down if you
would be satisfied with such a settlement basis. Note: This is not a
valued policy.
• The underinsured motorists coverage endorsement only covers the
difference between its limit and the at-fault motorist’s limit. (So, if you
carried $100,000 per person underinsured motorists coverage, were hit
Personal Auto Insurance • 130
by a motorist with $25,000 per person coverage, and got a $75,000
judgment, your underinsured motorists coverage would pay the $50,000
difference.)
NOTEWORTHY: State laws vary. Underinsured motorists coverage may be
mandatory or optional. In some states, the underinsured motorists coverage
endorsement supplements the uninsured motorists coverage in the standard
PAP. In other states, one endorsement includes both uninsured and
underinsured coverage and replaces the uninsured motorists coverage in the
standard PAP.
The 2005 PAP Edition
The 2005 edition of the PAP includes the following changes:
• Medical payments coverage removes the exclusion for non-owned vans
and pickups used in the insured’s business.
• Part D--Coverage for Damage to Your Auto now provides coverage for
permanently installed electronic equipment that receives or transmits
audio, visual, or data signals (such as navigation systems and Internet
access).
• The limit of liability for physical damage to non-owned trailers has been
increased to $1,000.
• Extended non-owned coverage endorsement now includes the option to
extend coverage to family members of the named insured.
Personal Auto Insurance • 131
• Named non-owner coverage endorsement now includes the option to
extend coverage to family members of the named insured.
• Trip interruption coverage is added to the 2005 PAP. This endorsement
adds coverage for:
o Transportation expenses incurred due to mechanical or electrical
breakdown and
o Expenses for lodging and meals incurred due to either a covered
physical damage loss or a mechanical or electrical breakdown.
What Are The ACORD Forms Associated With A
Personal Auto Policy?
The ACORD Personal Auto Application
ACORD is a nonprofit association whose mission is to facilitate the development
and use of standards for the insurance industry.
The accord:
• Describes residents, drivers, vehicles, and vehicle usage
• Identifies the requested coverages
• Lists accidents and traffic violations
The ACORD’s personal auto application’s general information section requests
information about:
• Jointly-owned vehicles
Personal Auto Insurance • 132
• Vehicle modifications and special equipment
• Existing vehicle damage
• Prior losses
• Cars kept at school
• Cars parked on the street
• Other auto insurance
• Other insurance with the same insurer
• Current military service by a household member
• Prior suspension or revocation of drivers’ licenses
• Drivers’ physical or mental impairments
• Prior financial responsibility filings
• Prior declination, cancellation, or non-renewal of coverage
Any “yes” answers to the questions in the general information section indicate the
need to investigate further or the need to endorse the policy.
Personal Auto Insurance • 133
LESSON 9 QUIZ
1. Which one of the following endorsements reimburses the insured for costs incurred while having an auto towed in the event a covered auto is disabled?
Towing and labor costs endorsement* Extended non-owned coverage for named individual endorsement A snowmobile endorsement The miscellaneous type vehicle endorsement
2. People with poor driving records are seldom insured. What technique has the insurance industry come up with to insure such drivers? Assigned risk plans Minimum insurance protection Extra safe driving lessons Higher premium rates 3. Cathy wants her auto insurance policy to cover her snowmobile, which she recently purchased. Which of the following will enable her to obtain such coverage under a PAP?
An endorsement ACORDs A new auto policy Higher premiums
4. Which of the following associations issue standardized insurance forms?
The Association of Insurance Adjusters The Association for the Evolution of Standardized Insurance Policies The Association for Cooperative Operations Research and Development The Association for the Regulation of Insurance
Personal Auto Insurance • 134
5. The ACORD’s personal auto application’s general information section requests information about all of the following EXCEPT:
Existing vehicle damage Prior losses Individuals who will be operating the vehicle Whether or not the car is parked on the street
Personal Auto Insurance • 135
LESSON 9 QUIZ ANSWER KEY
1. Towing and labor costs endorsement*
Coverage for such a task will be provided by the towing and labor cost endorsement. Anyone who has this endorsement appended to his/her policy will be reimbursed for all expenses incurred in having the vehicle towed from one location to the other. 2.
Assigned risk plans* Assigned risk plans insure drivers who are looked upon as high risk. Under voluntary agreements, licensed insurance companies agree to share the poor risks among themselves. Because these risks are randomly assigned to the participating companies, they are called “assigned risks.” 3.
An endorsement* Snowmobiles are not covered under a basic personal auto insurance policy. Coverage for such a vehicle is only attainable if the insured agrees to get the snowmobile endorsement appended to his/her policy. Buying another policy will not solve the problem, as it will result in the acquisition of another basic policy. The premium will increase, upon the addition of the endorsement. 4.
The Association for Cooperative Operations Research and Development* The Association for Cooperative Operations Research and Development, also known as ACORD, develops standardized forms for different branches of insurance, which after the states approval, are used by all those involved in the business of insurance. 5.
Individuals who will be operating the vehicle* The ACORD’s personal auto application does not inquire about the individuals who will be operating the vehicle. The application focuses on getting details about the vehicle, the drivers mental or physical impairments, and whether his/her license has ever been revoked.
Personal Auto Insurance • 136
LESSON 10: “No Fault” Insurance
The Purpose of No-Fault Legislation
Five Arguments Favoring No-Fault
• Determining fault is often difficult.
A determination of fault can be a lengthy and expensive process since it
typically relies on varying witness statements, physical evidence,
depositions and testimony, police reports, possibly expert testimony, and
demonstrative evidence.
• Inequities in claims payments: Small claims are often overpaid and
large claims are underpaid.
• Many victims aren’t paid under the present tort system: Over 50%
aren’t!
• Way too much of the premium goes to lawyers: 23% in one study.
• The tort system results in delayed payments: Payments delayed
months and sometimes years.
Five Arguments Opposing No-Fault
• The defects of the tort system are exaggerated.
• Claims of premium savings from no-fault are exaggerated.
• No-fault penalizes safe drivers who must pay for their own injuries.
• No-fault provides no payment for pain and suffering.
• The present tort system only needs reform.
Personal Auto Insurance • 137
The following are the four characteristics of no-fault insurance:
No-Fault insurance:
1. Exists, in some form, in about half the states
2. Provides Personal Injury Protection (PIP) benefits equal to economic
loss for the injured party from his own insurer (Economic loss refers to
medical expenses, lost earnings, hiring others to do work that the
injured can’t do, funeral expenses, and sometimes, survivor’s
compensatory benefits.)
3. Restricts the injured’s right to sue (except under add-on plans)
4. Excludes recovery for property damage (which tends to be relatively
minor and tends to be easily settled by insurers)
Four Types of No-Fault Automobile Insurance
• Pure no-fault: Under this insurance, the injured person cannot sue
anyone. He may recover PIP benefits only.
• Add-on no-fault: The injured person collects no-fault PIP benefits, but
still retains his right to sue in all cases. Hence, add-on no-fault is not
truly no-fault, since the right to sue is unrestricted.
• Modified no-fault: The injured person may sue if he meets either a
o Monetary threshold: Often $1,000 of medical expenses, or
Personal Auto Insurance • 138
o Verbal threshold: Often requiring death, disfigurement,
dismemberment, or permanent loss of use of a body member or
function.
• Choice no-fault plans: The insured can choose (at initial purchase or
renewal) whether to be covered by no-fault.
Personal Injury Protection (PIP) ‘No-Fault’ Statutes
Personal injury protection no-fault statutes allow victims of auto accidents to
recover their economic losses, regardless of fault, directly from their own
insurers. Such laws reduce litigation and provide a definite source of recovery,
but require victims to pay for their own losses.
Thresholds in No-Fault Insurance Laws
No-fault insurance laws allow injured people to assert common law tort claims if
their injuries exceed their state’s statutory threshold.
Tort exemptions vary among states, but most are based on either:
• Monetary thresholds (Medical expenses must exceed a set dollar
sum.) or
• Verbal thresholds (The accident must result in extensive temporary
disability, disfigurement, fracture, permanent disability, or death.).
If the injured person meets the threshold, he/she may continue to receive PIP
benefits or he/she may sue the tort feasor for economic and non-economic
Personal Auto Insurance • 139
losses such as pain and suffering. Even if the injured person has not met the
threshold, claim reps should begin investigating liability immediately.
Unfortunately, monetary thresholds often encourage plaintiffs to build up medical
expenses until they exceed the threshold amount.
Benefits Provided By No-Fault Insurance
Automobile personal injury protection (PIP) plans provide each insured the
following benefits for economic loss:
• Medical expense benefits pay reasonable and necessary expenses for
medical, surgical, and dental treatment; nursing; hospitalization;
rehabilitation; and medication, prosthetics, and medical supplies causally
related to the accident. Reasonable means usual and customary.
• Income continuation benefits pay for loss of earnings and losses from
inability to work, even if the injured person’s salary was continued.
o The claimant must provide:
� Medical proof of disability
� Proof that he did not work
• Replacement services benefits pay reasonable expenses to hire someone
to do the household work the injured person would have done if he had
been uninjured.
• Death benefits to survivors pay the maximum amount available for income
continuation and/or essential services benefits if the victim had survived.
• Funeral expense benefits pay funeral, burial, and cremation expenses.
Personal Auto Insurance • 140
LESSON 10 QUIZ
1. What is ‘no-fault’ insurance? An insurance policy that does not contain any fraudulent information. An insurance policy that does not allow the insured to disobey any of its provisions. An insurance policy that provides coverage, even if the insured is at fault. An insurance policy that restricts the insured from suing the insurance company. 2. Which of the following is NOT a type of no-fault insurance?
Pure no-fault insurance Add-on no-fault insurance Modified no-fault insurance Essential no-fault insurance
3. Which of the following is a benefit provided under PIP?
Hiring help for housework, if the insured’s condition does not allow him/her to do such housework A vehicle to help the insured commute Resources to enable the insured to work out of the house Providing subsidized meals
4. Under which no-fault insurance plan is the right to sue NOT restricted?
Add-on no-fault Pure no-fault insurance Choice no-fault insurance Modified no-fault insurance
5. Under modified no-fault insurance, the monetary threshold for medical expenses is usually set at: $1000 $3000 $200 $500
Personal Auto Insurance • 141
LESSON 10 QUIZ ANSWER KEY
1. An insurance policy that provides coverage, even if the insured is at fault.* No-fault insurance provides coverage for the insured even if the accident resulted due to the insured’s carelessness. Thus, under no-fault insurance, the insured is paid irrespective of who was at fault. 2.
Essential no-fault insurance* There are four types of no-fault insurance: pure no-fault, add-on no-fault, modified no-fault insurance, and choice no-fault plans. 3.
Hiring help for housework, if the insured’s condition does not allow him/her to do such housework*
According to the benefits offered under PIP, the injured insured will be paid enough to hire help for housework. Other than this, the insured is paid death benefits, funeral expenses, income continuation benefits, and medical expenses. 4.
Add-on no-fault* Under add-on no-fault insurance, the injured person collects no-fault PIP benefits, but still retains his/her right to sue in all cases. Hence, add-on no-fault is not truly no-fault, since the right to sue is unrestricted. 5.
$1000* The monetary threshold is often $1,000 for medical expenses.
Personal Auto Insurance • 142
LESSON 11: Determining Auto Insurance
Premiums
What Are The Main Factors Used In Determining
Personal Auto Premiums?
Factors That Determine the Cost of Automobile Insurance
Primary Rating Factors
• Territory: City cars have more and higher losses.
• Age, sex, and marital status: Young, male, unmarried drivers are the most
accident prone.
• Use: Business, commuting, pleasure, and farm use generate losses in that
order.
• Good student and driver education: Smart, educated drivers cause fewer
accidents.
Secondary Rating Factors
• Type of auto: Performance, age, original cost, damageability
• Number of vehicles: Often multi-car discounts apply
• Driving record
• Deductibles
• Liability limits
Personal Auto Insurance • 143
Insurers match the price of insurance to the loss exposure by dividing applicants
into rating categories that reflect their differing loss exposures. Young and
inexperienced drivers are considered less desirable insureds because they have
greater-than-average probabilities of having accidents. Although competitive
forces can influence rates, insurers must meet state requirements for rates that
are adequate, not excessive, and not unfairly discriminatory.
Rating Methods and Statistics
Rating Procedures for Private Passenger Automobile Insurance
Primary Rating Factors
• Age, sex, and marital status (Young, male, single drivers have more
accidents.)
• Geographic location (Rural drivers have fewer accidents.)
• Type of use (Pleasure, commuting, business, and farm--business cars have
more accidents.)
Additional Rating Factors
• Driver education and good student (reduced accident rates for youthful
drivers)
• Multiple car discounts
• Merit (safe driver) plans
Personal Auto Insurance • 144
The Objectives of Insurance Rate Regulation
Rates must be:
• Reasonable--not excessive
• Adequate
• Not unfairly discriminatory
Auto Insurance Discounts
Discounts could be bigger than one might think and there are more discounts
than the average driver knows. Let’s look at some of the discounts available with
some insurance companies.
Good Driver Discount
A 5% to 15% discount is given if an individual has a three-year accident-free
driving record. Some states give up to a 20% discount.
Airbag and Automatic Seatbelt Discount
A 5% to 45% discount off the No-Fault and Medical Payments premium is offered
if the individual has air bags and or automatic seatbelts.
Multi-Car Discount
An auto driver is given up to a 30% discount if he/she insures more than one
automobile.
Personal Auto Insurance • 145
Home Insurance Discount
If an individual obtains homeowner’s insurance or renter’s insurance from the
same company as their auto insurance, he/she receives a discount of up to 15%.
Defensive Driver Discount
The auto driver will receive up to a 10% discount if he/she has completed a state-
approved defensive driving course within the past three years. With some
companies, one must have successfully passed the course within one year.
Safe Vehicle Discount
An individual is eligible for a discount of up to 10% if he/she does not drive a
high-performance automobile and is insuring automobiles that have been
determined to be very safe.
Coverage for High Risk Drivers
Techniques That Make Coverage Available For High Risk Drivers:
• Specialty auto insurers
o They cover high-risk drivers voluntarily.
o They charge high premiums and limit coverage options.
• Assigned risk plans
o Cover drivers rejected by private insurers
o Applicants are assigned to insurers for 3-year periods.
o Insurers insure the same proportion of the voluntary and involuntary
Personal Auto Insurance • 146
markets.
o Habitual traffic violators and habitual drunks are often ineligible.
• Joint underwriting associations (JUAs)
o Use a limited number of servicing insurers who share premiums,
expenses, and losses based on their proportions of the voluntary market
• Reinsurance facilities (RFs)
o Such facilities involve insurers transferring applicants who do not meet
underwriting standards to the reinsurance facility.
o Insurers share premiums, expenses, and losses for those drivers.
Personal Auto Insurance • 147
LESSON 11 QUIZ
1. Which of the following factors will NOT be considered by an underwriter when determining the premium for an insurance policy?
The applicant’s address The principal location of the auto The applicant is only one semester shy of a college degree. The applicant uses the vehicle only for pleasure.
2. Which of the following drivers is considered to be the least desirable insured?
Jake has just acquired a driving license. Jeremy is new in town and unfamiliar with the area. Florence’s weak eyesight requires her to wear glasses while driving. David loves to have new gadgets fitted in his auto mobile.
3. Which of the following individuals is eligible for a 15% to 20% driver discount?
Driver A has never been issued a speeding ticket. Driver G has been driving for almost 25 years now. Driver K has never had any automobile losses reimbursed by the insurer. Driver X has avoided accidents for the past three years.
4. What benefit can an insured avail if he/she purchases homeowners insurance from the same insurer from whom he/she obtained automobile insurance?
The benefits provided are the same as those provided under any other homeowner or auto insurance policy. The insured will be given a discount. The insured will be given extra coverage within the same amount. The insured will not be required to pay the first policy premium.
Personal Auto Insurance • 148
5. Which of the following pieces of information regarding assigned risk plans is FALSE?
Assigned risk plans cover drivers rejected by private insurers. Applicants are assigned to insurers for three-year periods. Insurers insure the same proportion of the voluntary and involuntary markets. Habitual traffic violators and habitual drunks are offered rehabilitation programs.
Personal Auto Insurance • 149
LESSON 11 QUIZ ANSWER KEY
1. The applicant is only one semester shy of a college degree.*
Factors considered when determining premium rates are divided in two categories; primary factors and secondary factors. Primary include territory, age/sex/marital status, use and good student and driver education. Secondary factors include; type of auto, number of vehicles, driving record, deductibles, and liability limits. 2.
Jake has just acquired a driving license. * Jake is the least desirable insured because he is young (as he has just acquired his driving license) and does not have any driving experience. Such individuals are considered to be undesirable insureds because they have a greater-than-average probability of having accidents. 3.
Driver X has avoided accidents for the past three years.* A good driver discount of a maximum of 20% is given if an individual has a three-year accident-free driving record. 4.
The insured will be given a discount.* If an individual obtains homeowners insurance or renter’s insurance from the same company as their auto insurance, he/she receives a discount of up to 15%. 5.
Habitual traffic violators and habitual drunks are offered rehabilitation programs.*
Assigned risk plans cover drivers rejected by private insurers. Applicants are assigned to insurers for 3-year periods. Insurers insure the same proportion of the voluntary and involuntary markets and habitual traffic violators and habitual drunks are often ineligible.
Personal Auto Insurance • 150
LESSON 12: Underwriters
Underwriting Personal Auto
The producer and underwriter have a symbiotic relationship, that is, they both
benefit from such a relation. The producer solicits profitable business and
submits applications to the underwriter, while the underwriter provides a stable
market and low rates for the producer’s clients. Together they create a growing,
profitable book of business.
The Producer’s Customer Service Representatives (CSRS)
The customer service representatives are given the responsibility of:
• Gathering underwriting information
• Preparing submissions
• Helping make changes to existing policies
• Helping policyholders
• Processing renewals
• Preparing binders
• Notifying policyholders of cancellations and non-renewals
• Creating and maintaining files
Underwriting Assistants
The underwriting assistants are responsible for:
• Reviewing submissions for completeness
Personal Auto Insurance • 151
• Ordering underwriting reports
• Organizing files
• Performing other tasks to let their underwriters focus on underwriting
decisions
Computers are used to screen applications in order to identify those submissions
that are either clearly acceptable or clearly unacceptable. This allows the
underwriter to focus on only those applications that require judgment. A
computerized diary system notifies underwriters to review files at a fixed time
before renewal. File review may also be triggered by claim activity, occurrence
of specified events, or passage of a specified time since the last review.
Six General Factors Used By Personal Lines Underwriters
• The producer might request an accommodation (acceptance of otherwise
marginal or unacceptable business). When underwriting borderline or barely
unacceptable business, an underwriter considers the producer’s history with
the insurer, his/her mix of business, his/her premium volume, and the
profitability of his/her book of business.
• The existence of a prior insurer may be a factor if the underwriter can
surmise the reason for switching insurers. The insured may have been
cancelled (negative factor) or may have switched producers due to friendship
(neutral factor). Previous auto coverage is a positive factor.
• Prior losses indicate areas of underwriting concern and predict future losses
Personal Auto Insurance • 152
unless the insured has taken corrective action.
o Underwriters are more concerned with loss frequency (the number of
losses) than with loss severity (the total dollar amount of losses) because
the dollar amount of loss is often subject to chance, whereas frequent
losses indicate a pattern of problems.
• Applicants’ ages may be considered in some states, but is prohibited from
consideration in others.
o As a group, drivers in the 35 to 55 age bracket have the best driving
record.
• Applicants’ occupations and financial stability indicate the potential for
moral hazard and determine the ability to maintain property and to pay
premiums.
• Applicants’ character and reputation are difficult to evaluate at the initial
submission, but could become a factor at renewal if a claims adjuster
experienced a problem with the insured.
Sources of Underwriting Information
Sources of underwriting information include the producer, the application, the
motor vehicle reports, credit reports, consumer investigation reports, and
classification reports.
NOTE: Classification reports are investigative reports containing only objective
information.
Personal Auto Insurance • 153
Underwriting Factors Specific to Personal Auto Insurance
Underwriting factors specific to Personal Auto Insurance focus on the drivers and
vehicles used.
• Drivers’ ages, years of driving, and marital status: Younger drivers and
inexperienced drivers have more accidents.
o Marriage indicates greater stability and maturity [exception: shotgun
marriages of teenagers].
• Driving record: Statistically, drivers with prior accidents and/or traffic
violations are more likely to have future accidents. Most insurers do not write
coverage for drivers with DUI (driving under the influence) convictions.
• Vehicle type: Rating manuals assign every car a price new symbol (based
on the manufacturer’s suggested price) and a rating symbol (based on that
model’s physical damage loss experience).
o Under the ISO’s Vehicle Series Rating Program, vehicles with higher
symbols pay higher physical damage premiums. Each auto has its own
vehicle identification number (VIN) (unique identification number).
Insurers use a VIN to generate a vehicle’s description, track its claims,
and determine ownership of recovered stolen autos.
• Size/engine: Many insurers add a surcharge to the rating factor for cars that
fall within certain categories defined in terms of body type, the number of
passenger seats, and the weight-to-horsepower ratio (vehicle weight divided
by the engine’s horsepower rating).
o Cars with a low ratio (engines too powerful for their size) are less
Personal Auto Insurance • 154
acceptable to underwriters.
• Vehicle use: Underwriters consider the use (commuting or pleasure); the
annual mileage; and, for commuters, the distance driven, the traffic
conditions, and the workplace location.
• Vehicle age, condition, and value: Newer vehicles are more likely to have
the latest safety equipment and be in good condition. Physical damage
coverage is undesirable on older vehicles due to potential adjustment
problems from depreciation. Underwriting guides state maximum insurable
values for cars, often based on limitations in the reinsurance treaties.
• Garaging: Underwriting problems exist when insureds in high-traffic or high-
crime areas park their cars on the street.
NOTE: Underwriting factors are considered by the underwriter in evaluating a
submission. Rating factors determine the amount of the insured’s premium.
Most insurers offer account credits (discounts to insureds who buy two different
policies) to encourage account selling (soliciting all of a prospect’s coverages)
and account underwriting (underwriting all of an insured’s business as a whole).
Account selling by producers decreases coverage gaps, reduces competition
from other producers, increases premiums, and creates efficiency.
Account underwriting increases the insurer’s premiums, improves the retention
rate, prevents coverage gaps or overlaps, gives the underwriter a better
understanding of the insured, reduces expenses, and creates efficiency.
Personal Auto Insurance • 155
What Pap Underwriters Need To Know
PAP underwriters need:
• A motor vehicle report on every household driver
• The ages and educational levels of the insured’s children (some may be close
to the driving age, while others may be using a household car at college)
• The normal garaging location and typical use for each vehicle
• An accurate value (and photo) for each vehicle
• Any additional material required by state regulators
• Knowledge of the applicant’s coverage preferences
Personal Auto Insurance • 156
LESSON 12 QUIZ
1. Which of the following is a source of underwriting information for auto insurance?
Medical reports Business reports Credibility reports Consumer investigation reports
2. PAP underwriters need to know all of the following EXCEPT:
The normal garaging location of the vehicle The typical use for each vehicle The applicant’s coverage preferences The credit report on every household driver
3. Which of the following is NOT a benefit of account underwriting?
Improved retention rate Prevention of coverage gaps Reduced expenses Lower premiums for the insurer
4. Which of the following is determined by rating factors?
Premium amount Duration of coverage Endorsements to be attached The policy effective date
5. Under which rating plan are vehicles with higher symbols required to pay higher physical damage premiums?
The state rating plan. ISO’s vehicle series rating program A federal rating plan Insurers Rating Associations Rating Plan.
Personal Auto Insurance • 157
LESSON 12 QUIZ ANSWER KEY
1. Consumer investigation reports*
Sources of underwriting information include: the producer, application, motor vehicle reports, credit reports, consumer investigation reports, and classification reports. 2.
The credit report on every household driver* PAP underwriters need: a motor vehicle report on every household driver; the ages and educational levels of the insured’s children (some may be close to the driving age, while others may be using a household car at college); the normal garaging location of the vehicle along with the typical use for each vehicle; an accurate value (and photo) for each vehicle; any additional material required by state regulators; and knowledge of the applicant’s coverage preferences. 3.
Lower premiums for the insurer* Account underwriting increases the insurer’s premiums, improves the retention rate, prevents coverage gaps or overlaps, gives the underwriter a better understanding of the insured, reduces expenses, and creates efficiencies. 4.
Premium amount* Rating factors determine the amount of the insured’s premium. 5.
ISO’s vehicle series rating program* Under the ISO’s Vehicle Series Rating Program, vehicles with higher symbols pay higher physical damage premiums.
Recommended