Performance of Biodiesel Fuel in cold weather conditionbibeauel/research/undergrad_student/... ·...

1

Performance of Biodiesel Fuel in cold weather condition

Mechanical Engineering Graduation Thesis 25.416/25.475Presented by: Zeloon Lye 6805215

2

Introduction of biodiesel fuel

• Biodiesel is a clean burning alternative fuel, produced from vegetable, animal fat and waste vegetable oils.

• It contains no petroleum, but it can be blended at any level with petroleum diesel to create a biodiesel blend.

Biodiesel Fuel

3

Introduction of biodiesel fuel

• transesterification whereby the glycerin is separated from the animal fat or vegetable oil, yielding methyl ester (Biodiesel fuel)

• Smaller molecule size

Biodiesel fuelVegetable Oil

4

Benefit of biodiesel fuel

• Energy: Energy content comparable to diesel fuel

• It can be used in compression-ignition (diesel) engines with little or no modifications.

• Society: Produced from a renewable resource, reducing dependency from fossil fuel

5

Benefit of biodiesel fuel

• Economy: price is comparable to diesel fuel, and it is produced locally

• Environment: green house gas neutral, produce minimum amount of SOx and produce lower particulate matter but slightly higher NOx

6

Terminology

• Blending Proportion– B20: 20 percent of biodiesel fuel blend with

80 percent of diesel fuel, widely used in Europe

– B5: 5 percent of biodiesel fuel blend with 95 percent of diesel fuel

• WVO: waste vegetable oil• Diesel #1: standard diesel fuel that used

during winter

7

Challenge of Biodiesel Fuel

• Viscosity is higher than diesel• More difficult to flow at lower temperature• Not readily available in Canada yet• Engine manufacturer only support B5

blend in USA/ Canada and B20/B30 blend in Europe

8

Scope

Making of biodiesel fuel from WVO

Steps of makingGlycerin level

Property of biodiesel fuel

ViscosityHeat Value

Engine performance test

Fuel consumption, exhaust temperatureMaintenance

UBC biodiesel project

http://www.eya.ca/biodiesel/

9

Purpose

• Understand the impact of cold weather condition to the biodiesel fuel

• Suggest improvement in its use in cold weather

• Look at the long term future of biodiesel fuel

Montreal Biobus Project

10

Making of Biodiesel Fuel from WVO

Steps in making, Glycerine level

11

Making of BiodieselWaste Vegetable Oil Methanol

+ Lye

#1 Filter #2 Heat (35 °C)

Sodium Methoxide

Mixed oil (methyl esters and glycerine)

Stirring #3

Settling and filtering #4 Glycerine

Methyl esters

Washing #5

Drying #6

Biodiesel Fuel B100

12

Steps in making

Waste Vegetable Oil

Methanol with Lye

react

stirring

13

Steps in making

Mixed Oil

Methyl Esters is separated from glycerine

Filtration

14

Steps in making

Ready Biodiesel1.75L yield of Biodiesel fuel from 2L of waste vegetable oil

Water washing

Drying

15

Glycerine level

• Increase the viscosity in biodiesel fuel and lower yield of biodiesel fuel

• Viscosity of glycerine is 5000(SSU) compared to 240(SSU) for Biodiesel B100 at 20 °C

*SSU - saybolt second universal

Glycerine

Biodiesel

16

Glycerine level

• A) Providing heat when waste vegetable oil is mixed with sodium methoxide produces a low yield of biodiesel.

# Volume of Voume of Ratio of WVO Heating WVO Final volume Yield percentageWVO (L) methanol (mL) to methanol and sodium of biodiesel of biodiesel

methanol fuel (L) fuel (%)1 1 50 0.05 no 0.6 602 0.5 100 0.2 no 0.37 743 1 250 0.25 no 0.72 724 1 250 0.25 yes,35 degree celcius 0.375 37.55 2 500 0.25 no 1.75 87.56 2 500 0.25 no 1.75 87.5

17

Glycerine Level

• B) The ratio of methanol and waste vegetable oil is found to be 25 percent to give the highest yield of biodiesel fuel.

# Volume of Voume of Ratio of WVO Final volume Yield percentageWVO (L) methanol (mL) to methanol of biodiesel of biodiesel

fuel (L) fuel (%)1 1 50 0.05 0.6 602 0.5 100 0.2 0.37 745 2 500 0.25 1.75 87.56 2 500 0.25 1.75 87.5

18

Glycerine

C) Multi step filtration needed in order to remove the glycerine in biodiesel fuel content, give highest yield of biodiesel fuel

# Volume of Voume of Ratio of WVO Cycle of Final volume Yield percentageWVO (L) methanol (mL) to methanol filtering of biodiesel of biodiesel

oil (L) fuel (%)1 1 50 0.05 1 0.6 602 0.5 100 0.2 2 0.37 743 1 250 0.25 2 0.72 724 1 250 0.25 2 0.35 355 2 500 0.25 3 1.75 87.56 2 500 0.25 3 1.75 87.5

19

Properties of Biodiesel Fuel

Viscosity, Heat value

20

Fact Sheet

• Important property

• Higher viscosity

• lower density• Lower heat

combustion 130,0006.610.88Biodiesel

B100

138,0002.430.85Biodiesel B20

140,0001.9060.846Diesel #1

Heat Value BTU/gal(From reference)

kinematicviscositycSt(From test data)

DensityKg/L(From reference)

At 20 degree Celsius

21

Viscosity

• Impact atomization of the fuel being injected into the engine combustion chamber

• Large drop of fuel caused by high viscosity affect to combustion quality

• Burn not clean• Build up in the engine around valve, injector

tips and on piston sidewalls and ring• Fuel does not flow properly through filter and

engine injection system

22

Viscosity

• Causes:Glycerine particlesFood particle

• Blend with diesel , viscosity is closer to diesel #1

6.609Biodiesel B100

2.431Biodiesel B20

2.038Biodiesel B51.906Diesel #1

Kinematics ViscositycSt

Fuel

After B

lending

23

Viscosity versus Temperature

• B100 increase faster than biodiesel blend and diesel

• B5/B20 behave similar to Diesel #1

Viscosity versus Temperature (from test data)

0.01.02.03.04.05.06.07.0

0 20 40 60 80

temperature (degree celcius)

kine

mat

ic v

isco

sity

(cts

)

B100B20B5Diesel #1water

24-18°C

26.6°C 65.5°C

Viscosity

SSU

Temperature F

Diesel NO.1 Biodiesel B100

Limit of easy pump ability

17°C

25

Heating Block

• Heat block can be provided to heat up the fuel to operating temperature

• E.g. Heat up the fuel tank to 17°C when ambient temperature is -18°C to ensure flowing of biodiesel fuel B100

26

Engine Performance TestExhaust temperature, Fuel consumption, maintenance

27

Introduction

• Further determine the performance of biodiesel fuel in a real engine running situation.

• B5, B20 and diesel • Fuel consumption,

exhaust temperature

Testing machine

28

Test Description

• Diesel Engine, 28hp, 10 years

• used for clearing light snow during winter

• runs in idle state for at least two hours daily

Testing machine

29

A. Fuel Consumption

• Volume of the fuel used in per minute engine running (L/min)

Fuel consumption versus ambient temperature

00.0050.01

0.0150.02

0.0250.03

0.0350.04

0.0450.05

-30 -20 -10 0 10Ambient Temperature, C ©

Fuel

Con

sum

ptio

n, L

/min

Biodiesel B5DieselBiodiesel B20

30

• Not causing increase of fuel consumption

• low fuel consumption around -20°C to -5°C

• Behave the same as diesel

Fuel tank

A. Fuel Consumption

31

B. Exhaust pipe temperature

• Temperature of gases from exhaust pipe

Exhaust temperature versus ambient temperature

110115120125130135140145150155160

-30 -20 -10 0 10Ambient Temperature (C)

Exha

ust T

empe

ratu

re (C

)

Biodiesel B5DieselBiodiesel B20

32

B. Exhaust pipe temperature

• high exhaust temperature at lower ambient temperature

• Lower exhaust temperature with higher blend with constant ambient temperature

132°C-13°CBiodiesel B5

130°C-13°CBiodiesel B20

139°C-13°CDiesel

Exhaust Temperature

Ambient T

Exhaust Pipe

33

Maintenance

• Diesel equipment can run with biodiesel fuel without creating engine problem– Filter behaves like normal condition– Filter has less water – Engine Oil is cleaner– No congestion along fuel lines

Inside the filter Outside the filter Engine oil

34

Drivers feedback

• No problem with clearing the snow

• No problem with starting the machine

• No problem in running under temperature -20 degree Celsius

35

Comparing with other report

• Montreal Biobus Report• Testing during a whole year

36

Overall recommendation

• Good Quality of filtering and right recipe• Heating Block Concept for using high

blend biodiesel fuel • B20 is feasible under -20 degree Celsius

– However, take certain precautions – Adequate training for technical worker

37

Acknowledgements

• Advisors: Dr. Eric Bibeau and Mr. D. Paul Zanetel, M.A.Sc., P.Eng

• Chemistry Department– Dr. Norman R. Hunter, Professor and Head of Chemistry

Department– Dr. Hultin, Professor of Chemistry Department

• Physical Plant General service– Mr. Ed Rzeszutek, B.A., Manager – Mr. Larry Rudniski, assistance manager – Mr. Dave Wikdahl, Senior Groundskeeper– Mr. Wally Enonchuk, Mechanic,

• Daily Bread Café & Catering: Mr. Ian Park ,Manager • Amy Jenkins, Environmental Science final year student

38

Q & A

Thanks