View
213
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
PERFORMANCE EVALUATION REPORT
2003 - 2004
OSU QATASKGROUP
OSU QATASKGROUP
OSU QATASKGROUP
AIM AVIATION UNITED KINGDOM
AIM AVIATION RENTON, WA
AIRBUS GERMANY
BODYCOTE ORTECH INC. CANADA
BOEING RENTON, WA
BOEING EVERETT, WA
C&D AEROSPACE LAPALMA, CA
CAAC Test Center CHINA
DELSEN TESTING LABS GLENDALE, CA
DGA/CEAT FRANCE
DLR GERMANY
DUNLOP UNITED KINGDOM
FAA Wm. J. HUGHES TECH CENTER AC AIRPORT, NJ
HERB CURRY, INC. MT. VERNON, IN
ISOVOLTA AG AUSTRIA
JAMCO AMERICA, INC. EVERETT, WA
LANTAL TEXTILES SWITZERLAND
NORTH WEST COMPOSITES MARYSVILLE, WA
SCHNELLER, INC. KENT, OH
SCHNELLER, INC. PINELLAS PARK, FL
SHOWA AIRCRAFT CO. JAPAN
TESTCORP MISSION VIEJO, CA
The Govmark Organization, Inc. FARMINGTON, NY
5596 PANEL
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
H I E O W M S X K B V A Q L G D R C Y T F P J H I O S M R W L Q X E K V J D C P A T B G Y F
Peak
Avg +/- 2SD
2 Min Total
5596 PANEL
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
H I E O W M S X K B V A Q L G D R C Y T F P J H I O S M R W L Q X E K V J D C P A T B G Y F
Peak
Avg +/- 2SD
2 Min Total
5524 PANEL
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
O E H W S M L I K D Q B U R X G V A C P Y T F J O H E S I D L M W X A R K Q G V P B U C T Y J F
Peak 2 Min TotalAvg +/- 2SD
5524 PANEL
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
O E H W S M L I K D Q B U R X G V A C P Y T F J O H E S I D L M W X A R K Q G V P B U C T Y J F
Peak 2 Min TotalAvg +/- 2SD
PEAK TIME (Seconds)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Q G I W L C F B Y O J K V R X P S T A M D H E
5596 Panel
Kh (kW-min/mV)
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
0.3
0.35
L H O W E S V D M U I R B F C K Y G T P J A X Q
Peak/Total Ratio for 5596 Panel
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
E B G Y F V A K I X D C W T O M P S Q L J R H
Smoke Denesity (Dm4)
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
J T L B O V X Q K Y D W E G A M H S C F I P R U
Peak, 2001 - 2003
H
E
OI
M
W SK
B L
A
UV D
G
Q FT C X R Y
P
J
-80
-60
-40
-20
0
20
40
60
80
% D
ev
iati
on
Fro
m A
vg
+2SD
-2SD
AVG
2 Min Total, 2001 - 2003
H
OE
S
L
A
W M
I
K
C
U Q
T
D
VX
J
GR
P
F Y
B
-80
-60
-40
-20
0
20
40
60
80
% D
ev
iati
on
Fro
m A
vg
+2SD
-2SD
AVG
Smoke, 2001 - 2003
J
L
G
B Q
C T
D WK
OV
YX
AM H
F P
S
E U
I
R
-100
-80
-60
-40
-20
0
20
40
60
80
% D
ev
iati
on
Fro
m A
vg
+2SD
-2SD
AVG
Parameter Lab Value1 Value2 Value3Lab
Mean Difference Z NOTES5596 A 50.69 54.30 54.25 53.08 2.06 0.23 PopulationPEAK B 45.71 53.70 47.46 48.96 -2.06 -0.23 Mean 51.02(kW/sq.m) C 55.32 58.69 54.22 56.08 5.06 0.57 StdDev 8.87
D 53.23 52.45 58.87 54.85 3.83 0.43 Valid Results 23E 38.00 33.18 39.06 36.75 -14.27 -1.61F 53.60 64.00 65.60 61.07 10.05 1.13G 53.43 55.92 54.85 54.73 3.71 0.42H 33.00 36.00 33.00 34.00 -17.02 -1.92I 34.48 34.32 35.44 34.75 -16.27 -1.83J 64.63 66.57 69.00 66.73 15.71 1.77K 49.17 50.19 46.77 48.71 -2.31 -0.26L 54.40 54.00 55.10 54.50 3.48 0.39M 49.00 44.00 44.00 45.67 -5.35 -0.60O 49.08 41.12 37.93 42.71 -8.31 -0.94P 67.80 66.20 58.20 64.07 13.05 1.47Q 57.11 53.37 50.54 53.67 2.65 0.30R 47.00 62.80 58.30 56.03 5.01 0.57S 44.70 44.70 47.90 45.77 -5.25 -0.59T 58.26 62.49 61.44 60.73 9.71 1.09V 54.88 45.61 46.76 49.08 -1.94 -0.22W 47.14 44.54 44.90 45.53 -5.49 -0.62X 42.00 46.00 52.00 46.67 -4.35 -0.49Y 60.19 59.23 58.84 59.42 8.40 0.95
The copper slug indicated a heat flux 3.1% higher than a NIST calibrated gage and 2.5% higher than a copper disk for the NBS Smoke Chamber
per ASTM E662
Recommended