Past Experience and Vision for ELT Instruments · •Meteorites c. Miles Padgett Probe the Universe...

Past Experience and Vision for ELT Instruments

Colin Cunningham

Director, UK ELT Programme

Royal Observatory Edinburgh

2

• Photon emission

• Absorption

• Eclipses

• Gravitational lensing

• Angles - astrometry

• Doppler shift → dynamics of galaxies → Dark Matter

• Measure properties of E-M radiation::

– Intensity

• Spatial

• Temporal

– Wavelength (Energy)

– Amplitude & Phase

– Polarisation

– Orbital Angular Momentum?

We can also measure or collect:

• Neutrinos

• Gravitational Waves

• Cosmic rays (particles)

• Meteorites

c. Miles Padgett

Probe the Universe by

measuring photons:

3

• Photon emission

• Absorption

• Eclipses

• Gravitational lensing

• Angles - astrometry

• Doppler shift → dynamics of galaxies → Dark Matter

• Measure properties of E-M radiation::

– Intensity

• Spatial

• Temporal

– Wavelength (Energy)

– Amplitude & Phase

– Polarisation

– Orbital Angular Momentum?

c. Miles Padgett

Probe the Universe by

measuring photons:

Imaging

4

• Photon emission

• Absorption

• Eclipses

• Gravitational lensing

• Angles - astrometry

• Doppler shift → dynamics of galaxies → Dark Matter

• Measure properties of E-M radiation::

– Intensity

• Spatial

• Temporal

– Wavelength (Energy)

– Amplitude & Phase

– Polarisation

– Orbital Angular Momentum?

Probe the Universe by

measuring photons:

Spectroscopy

Evolution of Instrument Requirements

UKIRT: IRCAM 1 1986

VLT: KMOS 2011

Cameras: VISTA

6

IR Camera for the VISTA TelescopeIR CAMERAVISTA telescope: Largest dedicated IR survey in the world – 4m class

Location is ESO‟s Cerro Paranal site in Chile

IR Camera

• At focus of F/3 telescope.

• Field of view 1.65 degrees.

• Up to 7 spectral bands.

• M ~ 20 at Ks wavelength (2 microns) in 15 minute exposures.

• Pixel size : 0.34 arcsecs

• Cold front baffle, cryostat length ~2.5m

– for low background, to be similar to telescope (self-emissivity,

~4% in Ks-band)

Poster prepared by: IR Camera team, contact A K Ward or M CaldwellFurther information: www.roe.ac.uk/atc/projects/

Baffle tube•Di-chroic coating to absorb

incoming stray-light (2um), but

reflect window heat.

•Long tube, for non-re-imaged

cold baffle

LensBarrel„field corrector‟ for wide

FOV

Cryostat-Window

~ 1m diameter

Closed Cycle

Coolers x3

Auto-guider & Wave-

Front Sensors Telescope &

camera aberrations, flexures

corrected by Active Optics

Low order: movement of M2.

High order: actuators in M1 cell

Science detectors focal plane array

4 x 4 Raytheon VIRGO detectors

2048 x 2048 pixels each

Filter Wheel - 1.4m diameter

Up to 7 science filter arrays

Utility filters

High-order sensor optics

VISTA Telescope with the IR Camera

VISTA Primary Mirror

8

Silica Lens & Barrel

9

Camera Window

10

11

12

Removing the effects of the atmosphere with Adaptive Optics

Space Ground

13

Adaptive Optics System

Wavefront Sensor Deformable Mirror

Beam splitter

14

Impact of Adaptive Optics: exoplanets

HR 8799: 140 light years away, 1.5 times the size of our Sun and five times more luminous

Gemini North adaptive

optics image shows two of

the three confirmed planets

• ~7 Jupiter-mass planet

orbiting at about 70 AU

• ~10 Jupiter-mass planet

orbiting the star at about 40

AU

Keck AO follow-up AO image

showing a third planet!

© Gemini & Keck Observatories

15

Adaptive Optics: The Galactic Centre

ESO VLTGenzel et al., 2003

Axel Mellinger

Adaptive Optics & Speckle Imaging

Supermassive Black Hole with mass of ~ 3 million Suns

16

Spectroscopy: elements and

dynamics

17

Long Slit Spectrometer

Slit aligned

on objectCollimator Dispersing

ElementCamera

X

Y

Y

Detector

array

a

b

c

3rd June 2003Smart Optics Forum 21

Integral Field Spectroscopy: 3D data cube

Image: Stephen

Todd, ROE and

Douglas Pierce-

Price, JAC

Field before

slicing

Pseudo-slit

Slicing mirror (S1)

Spectrogram

Pupil mirrors

(S2)

To spectrograph

Field optics

(slit mirrors S3)

From telescope

and fore-optics

Focal

plane

Integral Field

Spectroscopy:

Image Slicer

Jeremy Allington-Smith

Most distant Galaxy ever

observed?• Only 600 million years old (a

redshift of 8.6)

– light has taken over 13 billion

years to reach us!

• Integral Field Spectroscopy allows

measurement of spectral lines at

any point in the image

23

Spectroscopy of a

(bright) candidate

z=8.6 Lyman-α Emitter

(Lehnert et al 2010)

14.8 hours on VLT with

SINFONI

3rd June 2003Smart Optics Forum 24

Multi-Object Spectroscopy

KMOS: 24 IFUs

Pick-off arms under test

27

Why do we want to go from VLT

to ELT?

Discovery Potential

28

Contemporary Science cases

Synergy with other facilities

Discovery potential

E-ELT excels in collecting power and angular resolution

42m telescope with Adaptive Optics will deliver

5.25✕ better angular resolution (1/D)

750✕ faster exposure time (1/D4)

than existing 8m telescopes

HST8m42m E-ELT

Unprecedented sensitivity and angular

resolution

Prepare for the unexpected….

29

E-ELT Instruments

30

Phase A Instrument Studies

EAGLE Multi-Integral Field (IFU), near-IR spectrometer

EPICS Imager/spectro-polarimeter for exo-planets

HARMONI Diffraction-limited, near-IR IFU

METIS Mid-IR (5-30μm) imager & spectrometer

OPTIMOS Seeing-limited high-multiplex spectrograph(s)

CODEX Ultra-high-resolution optical spectrograph

MICADO Near-IR, high-resolution imaging camera

SIMPLE Near-IR, high-resolution spectrograph

AO-relays MAORY (MCAO relay) & ATLAS (LTAO relay)

UK

in

vo

lve

d

E-ELT Science Objectives

31

Contemporary

Science cases

Synergy with other facilities

Discovery potential

Planets & Stars

• From Giant to terrestrial planets: detection, imaging, spectral characterisation of their atmospheres

• Circumstellar Disks

Stars & Galaxies• Imaging and spectroscopy of extragalactic resolved stellar populations• The nature of black holes and active galactic nuclei

Galaxies & Cosmology• Detecting First-light• The physics of the highest redshift galaxies• A dynamical measurement of the expansion of the universe

E-ELT Science Objectives

31

Contemporary

Science cases

Synergy with other facilities

Discovery potential

CODEXHARMONI

MICADO

SIMPLE

World-leading UK Technology

32

Integral Field Spectroscopy

Multiplexed Spectroscopy

Adaptive Optics

HARMONI

333333

Stars & Galaxies•

Galaxies & Cosmology

First-light: The

physics of the

highest redshift

galaxies

V

z ~ 4 50 mas pixels

z=0 rotating disk simulations (M. Puech)

42-m, 10-hr integration, MOAO (MCAO)

Key Spec: IFU

spectroscopy on 20

objects simultaneously

34

• Multi-Object Adaptive Optics

(MOAO)

• Correct small sub-fields across

a 5 arcmin field

• Extensive MOAO research in

the UK and France

EAGLE Adaptive Optics

35

CANARY

MOAO on-sky demonstrator

• Using the existing Rayleigh laser guide star (LGS) on the

William Herschel Telescope in La Palma

• 10:1 Scale model of E-ELT

• Demonstrate MOAO in the EAGLE configuration on-sky

• Improve real-time control techniques

• Advance calibration techniques

The EAGLE instrument

36

37

EAGLE Optical Paths

20 channels

with built in

Multi-object

Adaptive

Optics

TAS: Target Acquisition System

POS: Pick-off system

TRAMS: Target Re-imaging and

Magnification System

ISS: Integral Field Unit

Spectrograph System

38

Pick-off Mirror positioning

Robots

Starbugs (AAO) Starpicker (UK ATC, CSEM, ASTRON)

39

Micro Autonomous Positioning System

(MAPS)Hermine Schnetler (UK ATC) & William Taylor (Univ Edinburgh)

4040

Planets & Stars

&

40

Key Spec: ultra-high

contrast ~10-9

• Over 400 planets found by radial velocity method

– How common are systems like ours?

– How do planetary systems form?

• Needs direct detection:

– Measure mass, orbit, temperature, composition

• Simulations of photon-limited case (idealised) show rocky planets detectable to 5-10 parsecs (16-32 light years)

• 377 stars within 10 parsecs

10-810-7

10-9

10-5

10-910-10

Simulated image courtesy of EPICS team

4141

Planets & Stars

&

41

CODEX

Three-planet model of the Gliese 581

radial-velocity variations:

Top panel: 15 Earth-mass planet orbiting

close to the star (5-day period)

Middle panel: 5 Earth-mass planet in the

habitable zone

Lower panel: evidence for a third, 8 Earth-

mass planet with a period of 84 days

Stefan Udry, Geneva

Key Specs: RV stability:

2 cm/s over 30 years

R= 120,000

4242

Planets & Stars

&

42

• Circumstellar disks

• Physical and Chemical Properties

of Exoplanets

Key Spec: Diffraction

limited ~10 mas in mid-IR

4343

Stars & Galaxies•

Galaxies & Cosmology

HARMONI

•Physics of high red shift

galaxies

• Resolved stellar populations

in elliptical galaxies

•Studies of black holes and

active galactic nuclei (AGN)

Key Spec: Diffraction limited IFU ~

4mas in Near IR

4444

Stars & Galaxies•

MICADO

HARMONI

• E-ELT can resolve individual stars in galaxies beyond our own Local Group

• Imaging in densely crowded fields in the Virgo cluster (65M light years away)

• Spectroscopy to 15-30M light years, Sculptor/Leo groups or further

– Kinematics

– Chemical composition

Two stars in Sculptor (3Mpc) with different

metallicities (Tolstoy et al 2001)

E-ELT Simulation by J. Liske

10hr K-band; LTAO

1 a

rcsec

HST image of NGC 253 (Sculptor group)

454545

•

Galaxies & Cosmology

CODEX

• Is Dark Energy accelerating the expansion of the Universe?

• E-ELT can measure acceleration directly, in real time

• Fundamentally different probe

– dynamical vs geometrical –current measurements rely on supernova „standard candles‟

by J

oh

n W

eb

b

46

Measuring Cosmic Dynamics

Joe Liske, ESO

47

Measuring Cosmic Dynamics

Joe Liske, ESO

48

Measuring Cosmic Dynamics

Joe Liske, ESO

49

Measuring Cosmic Dynamics

Measuring the redshift drift requires:

• E-ELT

• High-resolution, extremely stable spectrograph:

CODEX

• ~20 yr long spectroscopic monitoring campaign.

t = 106 years!

Joe Liske, ESO

50

Frequency CombT

hom

as U

dem

(MP

Q)

Extreme stability enabled by the frequency comb:

Optical or NIR laser producing a train of monochromatic femtosecond light

pulses

Produces a spectrum of evenly spaced delta-functions (frequency comb)

whose absolute wavelengths are known to a precision limited only by the

atomic clock that controls the pulse repetition rate

LIMITATIONS OF CURRENT

INSTRUMENT DESIGNS

51

52

OH Sky Lines

• Big limitation on sensitivity from the

ground

Night sky near-IR spectrumP Rousselot et al,

Astron. & Astrophys. 354, 1134 (2000)

53

Size of

seeing-limited

ELT instruments

WFOS Wide

Field Optical

Spectrograph

– 8m diam

x 9m long

– Size of an

4m

telescope!Deimos

54

SOLUTION: Photonic devices?

• Devices developed for communications and industrial instrumentation are being investigated for Astronomy:

– Bragg Gratings

– Photonic (crystal) fibres

– Waveguide Beam combiners

• These technologies could be combined with an integrated detector to make compact integrated spectrometers, with built-in suppression of sky-lines

55

Fibre v. conventional

spectrometer

The fibre array spectrometer has 5x the spectral resolution

of the conventional dispersive spectrometer – or is 5x

smallerRobert R. Thomson, Ajoy K. Kar, and Jeremy Allington-Smith Vol. 17, No. 3 / OPTICS EXPRESS

56

Ultrafast laser inscription (ULI)Robert Thomson at Heriot Watt Univ

Video of ULI in progress

• Unique fabrication capabilities:

- 3D optical waveguides

- Micro-optics, -mechanics and -fluidics

• ULI is material flexible

• ULI is a direct-write technologyR. R. Thomson et al, Opt. Express

15, 11691 (2007)

Integrated Spectrograph

PIMMS: Joss Bland-Hawthorn (Sydney)

Direct-write waveguides: Robert Thomson (Heriot-Watt) 57

58

Photonics and Smart Optics

Toolkit• 3D Fibre mode converters

• OH suppression waveguides

• Integrated spectrometers

• Robotic positioners

• The ultimate multi-object spectrometer?– A swarm of 1000 integrated spectrometers, mounted on

micro-robots and patrolling a wide field

– Would enable fast surveys of faint galaxies to generate a statistically complete picture of galaxy formation and evolution

59

Headline Science Impact of E-ELT

Instruments

• Direct detection of a “Super Earth”

10-810-7

10-9 10-5

10-9

10-10

V

z ~ 4 50 mas pixels

z=0 rotating disk simulations (M. Puech)

42-m, 10-hr integration, MOAO (MCAO)

• Direct measurement of the expansion rate

of the Universe

• Understanding of galaxy formation in the

early Universe

EAGLE ANIMATION

60

EAGLE

61