Oakland 2010 Program Committee Meeting

Oakland 2010Program Committee

Meeting

authentication

electioneerdischargeable

indecipherableinheritability

inexactitudepublic relations

sanction vomit-grass

belittle

Avail yourself of these means to communicate to us at seasonable intervals a copy of your journal,

notes & observations of every kind, putting into cipher whatever might do injury if betrayed.

Jefferson’s instructions to Captain Lewis

Review ProcessSubmissions After Round 1 After Round 2 After Round 3 Today

Sub-mis-sions

Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Today

3024 22

All Research Submissions (825 reviews)

1: "Hopeless"2: "Strong Reject"3: "Weak Reject"4: "Weak Accept"5: "Accept"6: "Strong Accept"

108122

Discuss Papers (330 reviews)

1All SoK Papers (107 reviews)

Reviewing Lowlights/HighlightsOut of 237+30 research+SoK submissions:

• Number of papers with no “weak reject” (3) or worse reviews:

• Number of papers with no “reject” (2) or worse reviews:

• Total number of reviews with overall merit 6:

0 For every submitted paper, there is at least one PC member who thinks that paper should be rejected!

3+1 300% improvement from last year!

Plan for Meeting

• Today: (now-~5:30)– Discuss each “discuss” paper– Classify as: accept, reject, revisit– Research papers first, SoK papers

• Tomorrow: (8:30-1pm)– Make final decisions on all papers

Target: Accept ~30 research papers, 2-5 SoK papers2009: 262008: 28

To see the discussion order:Search: order:order

Discussion Lead• Summarize neutrally

what the paper is about• Summarize the non-

attending reviews• Present your own views• Update your review to

reflect any important issues that come up in discussion

Reminders

• No decision is final until meeting closes

• People in the room may have conflicts with other papers: avoid making unnecessary comparisons

• Please don’t leak information that compromises reviewer anonymity

Oakland 2010 Program Committee Meeting

Documents

City of Oakland, Bicyclist & Pedestrian Advisory ... · City of Oakland, Bicyclist & Pedestrian Advisory Commission Minutes from December 19, 2019 meeting pg 2 of 5 Item 4. Committee

Oakland Mills Community Associationoaklandmills.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/OMCA-Board-Meeting-Minutes-with...Columbia Association Climate and Sustainability Committee Presentation

Alameda County Oakland Community Action Partnership€¦ · Alameda County – Oakland Community Action Partnership Administering Board Meeting Monday, October 14, 2019 LOCATION Oakland

Meeting Agenda Oakland, CA€¦ · Joint MTC Planning Committee with the ABAG March 25, 2016 Administrative Committee - Merger Study 7. MTC / ABAG Merger Study - Management Partners

Community Policing Advisory Board Meeting Agenda … · Oakland Police Department, Eastmont Substation . 2651 73rd Avenue, Oakland CA 94601 . Committee Membership: Chairperson Jay

FINAL REPORT - partnerships.ucsf.edu · Esperanza Pallana, Oakland SSB Advisory Committee Chair , who was also one of the panelist at the June 7, 2018 BANPAC Membership Meeting, share

Community Policing Advisory Board Meeting Agenda April 3 , 2019 Oakland City Hall 1 ... · 2019-04-01 · Community Policing Advisory Board Meeting Agenda April 3rd, 2019 Oakland

CITY OF OAKLAND - cao-94612.s3.amazonaws.com · City of Oakland, Bicyclist & Pedestrian Advisory Commission Minutes from April 21, 2016 meeting pg 4 of 4 Committee. It was suggested

PET Technical Committee Meeting...PET Technical Committee Meeting ... 2020

Oakland Committee Report Recommending Hiring of William Bratton as Police Consultant

Oakland Bicycle and Advisory Committee, Monthly Meeting › oakca1 › groups › pwa › documents › ...Oakland Bicycle and Advisory Committee, Monthly Meeting Minutes of February

OAKLAND WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT BOARD MEETING … · 2019-02-01 · OAKLAND . WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT BOARD . MEETING . Thursday, February 7, 2019 . 8:30 a.m. – 11:00 a.m. Hearing Room

Amazon Web Services - Oakland, CA CEO Council …...2016/09/22 · Oakland, CA CEO Council Meeting AGENDA – CEO COUNCIL MEETING If you need an accommodation due to a disability,

12/7/05 Aerosol Transmissible Disease Advisory Committee ... file · Web viewAerosol Transmissible Disease Control. Cal/OSHA Advisory Meeting. December 8, 2005, Oakland CA. Chairs:

Oakland Elementary Title 1 Parent Meeting

Downtown Oakland Board Meeting March 07 2012 Agenda Packet

Meeting Standard - Ordinary Council · government meeting, a standing committee meeting, a special committee meeting or an advisory committee meeting unless the chairperson at the

Oakland County, Michigan · OAKLAND COUNTY, MICHIGAN . FINANCE COMMITTEE FY 2015 - FY 2017 . BUDGET RECOMMENDATION . TABLE OF CONTENTS . Pages . Comparison of Finance Committee Recommended

CITY OF OAKLAND OAKLAND POLICE COMMISSION Meeting … · 2019-05-20 · PC Meeting 5/9/2019 (Completed 05/14/19) Transcript by Rev.com Page 1 of 91 CITY OF OAKLAND OAKLAND POLICE

AGENDA Oakland-Macomb Interceptor Drain Drainage Board...Oakland-Macomb Interceptor Drain Drainage District, at a meeting held on November 28, 2018 and that the meeting was conducted