View
22
Download
0
Category
Tags:
Preview:
DESCRIPTION
Motion of CR 11 Sanctions
Citation preview
I2
aJ
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1t
12
t3
T4
15
t6
17
18
t9
20
2t
22
23
24
25
26
The Hon. Judge Michael TrickeyNoting Date: Apri| 29, 2014
Without Oral Argument
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF'THE STATE OF'WASHINGTONIN AND F'OR THE COUNTY OF'KING
GORDON L. BRONSON and KIMBERLY A.BRONSON, a married couple,
Plaintiffs,v.
NORTHWEST TRUSTEE SERVICES, INC.,SUCCESSOR BY MERGER TO
DEFENDANTS NORTHWEST TRUSTEESERVICES,INC.'S AND RCO LEGAL, P.S.'MOTION FOR CR 1I SANCTIONS _ PAGE I OF 4
No. 13-2-42868-7 SEA
DEF'ENDANTS NORTFTWESTTRUSTEE SERVICES, INC.'S ANDRCO LEGAL, P.S.' MOTION FORCR 11 SANCTIONS AGAINSTPLAINTIFFS
NORTHWEST TRUSTEE SERVICES, LLC, A )Washingfon corporation; RCO LEGAL, P.S., a )Washington Professional Services Organization; )J.P. MORGAN CHASE BANK, N.4., A )national banking association; J.P. MORGAN )ALTERNATIVE LOAN TRUST 2006-42; )MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC )REGISTRATION SYSTEMS, INC., a foreign )corporation; MERSCORP HOLDINGS, a )foreign corporation; and JOHN DOES l-99, )unknown investors in J.P. Morgan Alternative )Loan Trust 2006-A2, )
)Defendants. ))I. RELIEF REQTJESTED
Defendants Northwest Trustee Services, Inc. ("NWTS") and RCO Legal, P.S. ("RCO"),collectively Defendants for purposes of this briefing, move the Court for CR 11 sanctions based
on the refusal of Plaintiffs' counsel to amend portions of their Complaint after being shown the
falsity of certain statements therein, and after being sent two "safe harbor" letters affording
Plaintiffs' counsel an opportunity to cure their factual misrepresentations.
RCOL rcnL, P.S.
1 3555 SE 36th St., Ste. 300Bellevue, WA 98006Telephone: 425.458.21 21Facsimile: 425.458.2'131
G@PY
12
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
l011
t2
l3
T4
15
t6
l718
t9
20
2I
22
23
24
25
26
II. STATEMENT OF'F'ACTSOn December 31, 2013, Plaintiffs filed their Complaint in this case. Dkt. No. 1. On
January 8,2014, Defendants sent a leffer to Plaintiffs' counsel seeking the voluntary withdrawal
of specific allegations pertaining to Defendants. Ex. A. In that letter, Defendants providedPlaintif' counsel with corporate governance information from the Washington Secretary ofState's website showing, among other things, that RCO itself does not own, operate, or have a
substantial interest in NV/TS, despite Plaintiffs' verment otherwise. Id., cf, Compl., tf 7.
On January 21,2014, Defendants each answered Plaintiffs' Complaint. Dkt. Nos. 9, 10.
On January 3I,20I4, NWTS proffered requests for admission on Plaintiffs; in their responses,Plaintiffs denied that RCO was not appointed as the successor trustee under the subject Deed ofTrust despite clesr evidence to the contrary. Ex. B (Appointment).
On March 27,2014, Defendants sent another letter to Plaintiffs' counsel, reiterating their
call for Plaintiffs to voluntarily withdraw certin allegations concerning Defendants. Ex. C.
Despite the stated deadline for compliace, no response to that letter has been provided as of this
Motion.
ilI. ARGUMENTFor all pleadings filed with the Court:
[t]he signature of aparty or of an attorney constitutes a certificate by the party or attorneythat the parfy or attomey has read the pleading, motion, or legal memorandum, andthat tothe best of the party's or attorney's lcnowledge, nformation, and belief, formed after aninquiry reasonable under the circumstances: (I) it is well grounded in fact; (2) iswarranted by existing law or a good faith argument for the extension, modification, orreversal of existing law or the establishment of new law; (3) it is not interposed for anyimproper pu{pose, such as to harass or to cause unnecessary delay or needless increase inthe cost of litigation; and (4) the denials of factual contentions are wananted on theevidence or, if specifically so identified, are reasonably based on a lack of information orbelief.
CR 11(a) (emphasis added).
Sanctions can be imposed when there is no reasonable inquiry into the factual and legal
1 3555 SE 36th 5t., Ste. 300Bellevue, WA 98006Telephone: 425.458.21 21Facsimile: 425.458.21 31
DEFENDANTS NORTHWEST TRUSTEESERVICES, INC.'S AND RCO LEGAL, P.S.'MOTION FORCR 11 SANCTIONS_PAGE 2OF 4
RCOL rcnl, P.S.
12
J
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
l2t3
l415
t617
18
t920
2l22
23
24
25
26
basisofaclaim. Bryantv.JosephTree, lnc.,119Wn.2d210,220,829P.zd1099(1992). "Thecourt should inquire whether a reasonable attorney in like circumstances could believe his or her
actions to be factually and legally justfted." Id.Here, Plaintif allege that RCO owns, operates, and has a "substantial interest in the
operations and working of NWTS." Compl. atl7. Plaintiffs further allege that "RCO and NWTScommingle employees... [etc.]... and share the same physical location [3555 S.E. 36d' St., Ste.100, Bellevue, WA 98006]. Id. at\ 8. Plaintiffs state that "the commingling creates a situationwhere RCO and NWTS are acting as a single entity." Id. atl9. Plaintiffs rely on these false claimsto plead that RCO owes them a duty because they believe RCO s somehow the subject foreclosure
trustee. Id.at\139,48,52,54,70,94,95,intera\ia;seealsol93("PlaintiffsallegethatNWTSand RCO worked together os trustee.") (emphasis added).I Plaintif, however, lack any legitimatefactual basis for each of these statements.
First, the statement that RCO, as an entity, o\ryns or controls NWTS continues to be
espoused by Plaintiffs' counsel in this case and others despite its demonstrable falsity. Compare
Ex. A at 3, (RCO corporate information), Ex. Aat4 (NWTS corporate information). Thegoverning persons of RCO are Mr. Routh, Lance Olsen, Larry Johnson, and Joel Freedman. Id.
Neither Mr. Olsen, Mr. Johnson, nor Mr. Freedman have any interest whatsoever in NWTS. Id.
Thus, public records show RCO is a different corporation than NV/TS, and three of its governing
persons have no ownership in NWTS.2
Second, RCO does not have the same physical location and address as NWTS. Id.; cf,
Compl., tf 8. RCO's add,ress is 13555 S.E. 36th St., S/e. 300 nBellevue. See also
http://www.rcolegal.com/company/officelocations.aspx. NWTS'address is 13555 S.E. 36th St.,
' In 1 53, Plaintiffs even lump together Chase, NWTS, and RCO as "servicer, trustee, and/or debt collector."
2 It is not to say that a law firm could never be a trustee, or actually own a trustee . ln Meyers Way Development LPv. University Savings Bank, 80 Wn.App. 655, 910 P.2d 1308 (1996), the Washington Supreme Court found that atrustee could even serve "simultaneously as the creditor's attornqt, agent, employee or subsidiary ." Id. at 1315-16,n. 8 (emphasis added). But that is simply not the case here, despite Plaintiffs' false accusation otherwise.
13555 SE 36th St., Sre. 300Bellevue, WA 98006Telephone: 425.458.21 21Facsimi le: 425.458.21 31
DEFENDANTS NORTHWEST TRUSTEESERVICES,INC.'S AND RCO LEGAL, P.S.'MOTION FOR CR I I SANCTIONS _ PAGE 3 OF 4
RCOL rcnl, P.S.
12
aJ
4
5
6
7
8
9
l011
T2
13
t4
15
t6
t7
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
Ste. 100 in Bellevue. Ex. A. Clearly, RCO does not share the same office space as NWTS.3Third, U.S. Bank, N.A. as trustee for JPMorgan Altemative Loans Trust 2006-42, through
its attorney-in-fact JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.4., appointed NWTS as the successor trustee under the
subject Deed of Trust. See Ex. B; c/, Compl. I 54, inter alia. RCO is not even mentioned in thatdocument. Id. Asimple online check of recorded documents in the county can reveal this fact.S e e http: l l www.kingcounty. gov/business/Recorders/RecordsSearch. aspx.
In sum, Plaintiffs' allegations relating to the purported relationship between RCO and
NWTS -
other than to the extent that RCO is NWTS' legal counsel -
are not well-grounded in
fact. Plaintiffs' counsel was twice warned of the potential for CR 1l sanctions if their
misconduct was not corrected through amendment of the Complaint,but Plaintffi' counsel has
failed to comply or even respond, thus necessitating this Motion and the Court's intervention.
Defendants therefore request that the Court sanction Plaintiffs for the cost of preparing
and filing this Motion, in an amount to be determined at the conclusion of this litigation.
Defendants further request that the Court bar Plaintiffs' counsel from raising any argument with
respect to the falsehoods mentioned above. Lastly, Defendants request that the Court, act within
its discretion pursuant to CR 12(, to strike those portions of Plaintiffs' Complaint whichcontain references to RCO "owning" or "controlling" NWTS, sharing the same off,rce as NWTS,
or RCO being the trustee of the subject Deed of Trust.
DATED this 17th day of April,2}l4.RCO Lncar., P.S.
y,WJoshua Schaer, WSBA No. 31491Attorneys for Defendants RCO Legal,P.S. and Northwest Trustee Services, Inc.
3 By analogy, certainly no one suggests any of the multiple law firms in the 1001 4 Ave. Plaza own SafecoInsurance, or share offrce space with that company, simply because they might obtain insurance from Safeco and arelocated in the same building.
DEFENDANTS NORTHWEST TRUSTEESERVICES,INC.'S AND RCO LEGAL, P.S.'MOTION FOR CR I 1 SANCTIONS
-
PAGE 4 OF 4RCOL ecnl, P.S.
13555 5E 36th St., Ste. 300Bellevue, WA 98006Telephone: 425.458.21 21Facsimi le: 425.458.21 31
I2
J
4
5
6
7
I9
10
11
l213
l415
t6
t7
18
t9
2A
2t
22
23
24
25
26
trXHIBITARCOL e cnl, P.S.
13555 sE 36th st., ste.3ooBellevue, WA 98006Telephone: 425.458.21 21Facsimile: 425.458.21 31
SRCORCO Lcnt, P.S.
13555 sE 36'n st., ste. 3ooBellevue, WA 98006
phone - 425.458.212Lf ax- 425.458.2L31www.rcolegal.com
Ianuary 8,2014
Scott StafneJoshua TrumbullEmily HarrisMatthew LinkStafne Trumbull, LLC239 N. Olympic Ave.Arlington, WA98223
Dear Counsels:
Concerning your December 31,2013 Complaint filed under King County Superior Court CaseNo. 13-242868-7, naming borh this law firm and our client, Northwest Trustee Services, Inc.("NWTS"), we are providing this "safe harbor" letter to you pursuant to CR ll.t That uleprovides in relevant part:
[t]he signature ofa party or ofan attorney constitutes a certificate by the party or attorneythat the party or attorney has read the pleading, motion, or legal memorandum, and that tothe best of the parfy's or attorney's knowledge, information, and belief, formed after aninquiry reasonable under the circumstances: (l) it is well grounded in fact; (2) iswarranted by existing law or a good faith argument for the extension, modification, orreversal of existing law or the establishment of new law; (3) it is not interposed for anyimproper pulpose, such as to harass or to cause unnecessary delay or needless increase inthe cost of litigation; and (4) the denials of factual contentions are wananted on theevidence or, if specifically so identifed, are reasonably based on a lack of information orbelief.
We are hereby requesting that you withdraw all allegations suggesting: l) that RCO Legal, P.S.("RCO") "owns, operates, or has a substantial interest in" NWTS, 2) that RCO is a trustee or actsin that capacity in non-judicial foreclosures, 3) that RCO acted as a servicer, trustee, or debtcollector in the foreclosure that you are challenging, and 4) that RCO and its client NWTS "sharethe same physieal [ocation and address-"
' This lefter in no way serves to waive a challenge to either improper service of process or any claim presented in theComplaint, and should nol be construed as limiting our remedies, and our client's remedies, to any extent.
Joshua SchaerAttorney at Law
direct - 425.457.7810fax - 425.974.8680
jschaer@rcolegal.com
Page2January 8,2014
Attached to this letter are copies of the corporte govemance information from the Secretary ofState's website showing that RCO and NWTS are not the same company, and RCO itself doesnot own, operate, or have a substantial interest in NIVTS, nor does RCO have the same addressas NWTS. The blatant falsity of yoru assertions in this regard should now be apparent.
We believe the frivolous averments made in the Complaint against both RCO and N'WTS aredesigned to obfuscate the issues, harass our firm and its client, and delay a defense to thislitigation.
Accordingly, we are now offering you the opportunity to voluntarily withdraw the claims andstatements referenced above. Please notify us of your remedial steps within l0 days of receivingthis lefter, or else RCO reserves the right to seek sanctions with the Court and/or appropriatestate licensing authority. You have been warned and given notice of the factual erors in yourarguments; proceed otherwise at the peril of yourself and your clients.
Sincerely,
RCO LEGAL, P.S.
By: Joshua SchaerOf Attorneys for RCO Legal, P.S. andNorthwest Trustee Services, Inc.
Corporations: Registration Detail
Corporations Division - Registration Data SearchRCO LEGAL, P.S.
I'u rc hst'..[)-rr-c' !-1.L1!:.I-b-iff-il,(' o rplr!i11^.i
UBI Numbcr 601 840737
Category PRO
Profit/Nonprofit Protit
Active/lnactivc Activc
State Of lncorporation WA
WA l:iling Date l2t24t't997
Expiration Date t2/3ltz0t4Inaclive Date
Duration Perpetual
Rcgistercd Agent Inf'ormation
Agent Nante CORPORATION SERVICECOMPANY
Address 3OO DESCHUI'ES WAY SWSTE 304
ci- TUMWATER
Stte WA
ZIP 9850 I
Special Address lnformation
Address
Cty
State
'Lip
l' rr rc ha :c I )cc u rlrcr ls l{ !hit-(1ry!l-r-*!lJ:I.l
Page 1 of I
Governing Persons
Title Name Address
Prcsident,Secretary,Treas urer,Chairman ROUTH, STEPHEN I 3555 SE 36 #350BELLT VUE, WA 98006
Vice Presidenl OI.SF,N,I,ANCE 13555 SD 36#200BELLEVUE, WA 98006
Vicc President JOHNSON, LARRY IJ87 NE EXPRESSWAYATLANTA. GA 30329
Vice President FREEDMAN. JOEL I587 NE EXPRESSWAYATLAN'IA ,GA34329
http://www.sos.wa. gov/corps/search_detail.aspx?ubi:60 I 8407 37 t/8/2014
Corporations: Registration Detail Page I of 1
Corporations Division - Registration I)ata SearchNORTHWEST TRUSTEE SERVICES, INC.
l)r r r.t'!i-c-l )octr rrlcl !",.!'qr-,th i s. ( tl!l,illj-..U. I'
LJBI Number 602376725
Category REG
Profit/Nonproft Profit
Active/lnactive Active
State Of Incorporation rwA
WA Filing Date 03il6t2004
Expiration Date t3t3u20t4
Inactive Date
Duration Perpetual
Registered Agent lnformation
z\gent Name Corporation Service Cornpany
Address 300 Deschutes Way SW
ST'E 304
City TT'MWATER
State WA
ZIP 9850r
Speciaf Address lnformation
ddress
City
State
zip
ll.i.r..c.,.s IJg L1 lsul.:Jililh.h-Lt..rr:p-rati0Lri
Governing Persons
Tirle Namc ddress
Prcsidcnt.'l'reasurer,Chairma ROUI'TI, S1'EPIIENI3555 SE 36TI{ STSI,'ITE IOOBELLEVUE. WA 98006
Vice Presidcnt,Sccrctary STENMAN, JNFFRIIYr3555 SE 36TH S'I'SUTI'E IOOBEI.I,EVUE, WA 98006
http://www. sos.wa. gov/corps/search_detail.asp x?ubi=60237 67 75 U8/2014
I2
3
4
5
6
7
I9
10
11
t2
13
14
l5
t6t7
l8t920
2l22
23
24
25
26
EXHIBIT BRCOL rcnl, P.S.
13555 sE 36th st., ste.3ooBellevue, WA 98006Telephone: 425.458.21 21Facsimi le: 425.458.21 31
to, l'+
t '.
. !
AfterRecording Mail to:
Northwest Trustee Services, Inc.Becky BakerP.O. Box 997Bellevue, t/A 98009-0997
\uw[lul'[W'^.}'1wuuruWlulfrffi
(1-
Document Ttle(s): (or transactions contained therein)l. Appointment of Successor Trustee
Reference Number(s) of Documents assigned or released:20050930002t21
Grantor(s): (Last nme lirst, then first and initials)l. Bronson, Gordon L.
. 2. Bronson, Kimberly A.3. U.S Bank National Associatior as rstee forJ.P. MORGAN Alternative LoanTrust 20A6-A2
Grantee(s): (Last nam first, then first snd initials)l. Mortgage Elechonic Registration Systems, lnc. solely as nominee for M & T Mortgage Corporation2. Lawyers Title Company
Abbreviated Legal Description as follows: (i.e. tor/blocvptat or secton/ownship/rangcJquarter/quarra)Horseshoe Acre Tracts To Ken! Ptn Lot 26
X Complete legal description is on page ..
2 ofdocumentAssessor's Property Tax ParceUAccount Number(s):3462804220
AND V/HEN RECORDED MAILTO:
Routh Cnrbtrcc Olscr. P.S.P.O. Bo 997Bcllo'uc. WA 98006{}997
Appointmcnt of Succcssor Trustcc
Filc No. 19271l4l0l
GORDON L. BRONSON AND KIIVBERLY A. BRONSON isiarc tlregrantor(s)- LAWYERS TITLE COMPANYis thc lrustce and MORTGACE ELECTRONIC RECISTRATION SYSTEMS. INC. AS NOMINEE FOR M & TMORTCACE CORPORATION is thc bencliciary under llmt crlain decd of trust dated SeptcrnUcr( zOos rd rccordcdon Scptcrnbcr 30. 2005 under King Counl,, Wasirington Auditor's File No. 20050930002 f 2 L
"'r..n.
Tlrc prcscnt benclciary undcr said deed of trust appoints Nofhncst Truslee Sen'iccs. Inc.. a Washingloncorporalion. n'lo addrcss is P.O. Box 99?. Bclloue. WA 9tt006-.0997. as suessor trustcc undcr tlrc dced oltnst rvitlt allpolrcrs of thc original lnstec.
Said deed o[trust Encumbers thc rcal propertl deribcd as:Sce nttachcd
STATE OF Ohio ))ss
COUNTY OF Frarrllin )
*JPMoryun Chrsc Bank' N'as Attornr:Y-in'!t lr
*U.S gank Nationat Association,:s trustec for J.P. MORCANAlternatirc LoanTrust 2006- MBv #--
.
lrlo.*do$t
I certilj, that I knorv or harc srtisluctory evidcnce rhat Sokha-v.ary Voeuh is lhc pcrson rvlro appcarcdbcforc nrc. and srid pcrson acknoruledgcd lhat (he/shc) signcd this instrument. on oath satcd th.nt (hdshc) $'ts authorizcdto c.\ccutc tlc instruirrcnt and acknorvl-edged it s thc ' - Vlo Prceldsnt of JPMorgnn Clsc Bank. NtionalAssocialion to bc tlrc free and roluntaq'act of such party for thc uscs and purposcs mcntioned in thc instruurcnt.
Dcd, l tltfll
,OTTNM.BURONPIIIC,SATEOF
[ty C@0" Eqrn ]uc ll, 1016
Notry Public in and for lhc
,. kT Nnmber: ]nZaDate: SEPTEDTBER 2?, 2005proFtyAddrrs: 1419 S l,lA.PtE IJN, [(ENT, WASHINGTON 98031
EXHIB'T "4"
I."EGAL DESCRIPTION
Ttrat porthnof Lot 26, Horshoc AssTraca toKGil,;cordinqto-rhe plat rcof rcded inYohmoii of pf.S, prgc t0, rcordg of King Cornty, Whinga dctsribod s follows:
Bcgioning u a Sordtcsst corncr of said lnt26;,Ttrco N-orr atrg thc right of wey of Maplc lnc a dimco of I ?3 fcscThcncc Wcst a distacc of I 15 fccTticnco Sortb a dirarco of l?1 fccqThcnco st a disarcc of I 15 fccqExccpto followin
Beginng al thc Southcast corncr ofsad lat26,rco on long Maplc to, a disupo of 73 fectThpnco $rc$ a disrcc of I 15 fecqTtcrco Soutb a dlstarc c o 7? q,1tpc Ess I tS foct to t Pont of Bcginning
346280A22002
I2
J
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
t2
13
I4
15
l617
18
t920
2l22
23
24
25
26
EXHIBIT CRCOL e cnl, P.S.
13555 sE 36th st., ste.3ooBellevue, WA 98006Telephone: 425.458.21 21Facsimi le: 425.458.21 31
SRCORCO Lec,1, P.S.
13555 SE EO" St., Ste. 300..Bellevue, WA 98006
phone - 425.458.272Lfax - 425.458.2131www.rcolegal.com
March 21,2014
Scott StafneJoshua TrumbullEmily HarrisMatthew LinkStare Trumbull, LLC239 N. Olympic Ave.Arlington, WA98223pe: Bronsonv. NorthwestTrustee Services, /nc. ("NWTS") ef al.,CaseNo. 13-242868-7 SEA
Dear Counsels:
On January 8,2014, we sent your office a safe harbor letter pursuant to CR ll, and havereceived no response or action taken as a result. With that letter, we provided documentationshowing that RCO and NWTS are not the same company, and RCO itself does not own, operate,or have a substantial interest inNWTS, nordoes RCO have the same address asNWTS'
Consequentll, you are ethicafly obtigated to amend your Complaint to remove the materiallyfalse statements suggesting: 1) that RCO Legal, P.S. ("RCO") "owns, operates, or has asubstantial interest in" NWTS, 2) that RCO is a trustee or acts in that capacity in non-judicialforeclosures, 3) that RCO acted as a servicer, trustee, or debt collector in the foreclosure that youare challenging, and 4) that RCO and its client NWTS "share the same physical location andaddress."
If this remedial step is not taken and a copy of your proposed Amended Complaint served on thisofflice by March 31,2014, we will move to strike those aforementioned impertinent portions ofthe Complaint, and at a minimum, seek sanctions under CR I t. This is your final notificationand opportunity to cure.
In addition, please find enclosed a First Set of Interrogatories and Requests for Production onbehalf ofNWTS. lVe expect timely responses to these demands.Sincerely,
By: Joshua Schaer, WSBA No. 31491Of Attorneys for RCO Legal, P.S. andNorthwest Trustee Services, Inc.
Joshua SchaerAttorneY at Law
dect- 425.457.7810fax - 425.974.8680
jschaer@ rcolegal.com
RCO LEG,L, P.S.a)
-i
Recommended