View
221
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
1/18
http://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
2/18
Where is the branded equivalent of Snapchat? Where is the enterprise
version of the vanishing-photo app with which iPhone users sent over
one billion vanishing photos in just one year? We ask this not because
brands should be in the business of sexting, but because, five years
after the launch of the Apple App Store, the watershed moment that
gave business entre to the defining gadget of the 21St century, the
enterprise has yet to really crack the code on mobile development.
Snapchat. Instagram. Words With Friends. Draw Something. Whats
App. It seems like a new app goes viral every week, giving some
previously unknown dudes in co-op workspace a valuation beyond
their wildest dreams. For brands trying to figure out the mobile space,
the opposite has been true. Despite entering the mobile game with
massive consumer awareness and trust, big companies have had a
difficult time getting consumers to welcome them on to their Android
and iOS devices.
Back in 2011, Deloitte found that 80 percent of branded apps
struggled to get even 1,000 downloads. That was a grim headline for
http://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
3/18
mobile marketing operations and, over time, theres not much to
suggest things have changed. Breakout branded appsand were
excluding those created by media companies that have an unfair legup over marketers of dog food and insurance policiesare still few
and far between. How many do you download only to delete them a
day later when it comes up short on form or functionality? You know,
the airline app that wont allow you to book a flight; the rental car app
thats just a link to the company
website thatcurses!isnt
optimized for mobile and wont
remember your 23-digit usernumber; the diaper brand
doohickey that doesnt do, well,
anything. Can you name five
branded apps you use regularly?
How about threeand well spot
you Nike and Starbucks? The
same goes for apps developed for
employees. The app stores are
littered with poorly-reviewed and little-used apps that were meant to
help out folks who take orders, make sales, and generally keep the
enterprise rolling.
The point is this: For even the most sophisticated companies, mobile
app strategy remains a work in progress. Big budgets, flashy agencies
and development shops, and enormous amounts of customer data allhave done little to make a dent in the consumer apathy. Whats to
blame? Well, you have to remember the mobile revolution is only five
years in the making. It naturally takes enterprises some time to figure
out the realm of the possible and then make it happen.
But lets not let enterprises totally off the hook. Its fair to say that too
many have tripped over their own feet as theyve struggled to organize
around mobile. A case in point is lingering ambiguity around a centralorganizational question: Who should own mobile app strategy? The
CMO, served by an increasingly left-brained marketing department
http://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
4/18
and an ever growing array of agencies? Or should the CIO, the tradi-
tional buyer of technology and maintainer of servers and intranet, rule
the roost?
Thats the question weve asked a
number of leading thinkers to
ponder in this eBook. The answer
matters in no small part because
marketing and IT come with two very
different sets of baggage. If either
side is to win the mobile game theyllhave to change and become more
like the other.
Our books structure is simple. First
well discuss the respective cases for the CMO, and CIO before
concluding with some ways that eschew those legacy power struggles.
The case study there is a company you might have heard ofWalmart.
We begin our study with the C-suite denizen who at this moment
timeand if you blink, it might changeseems to be sitting in the
catbird seat.
http://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
5/18
When we caught up with Amy Kavanaugh in early March, the VP-public
affairs and engagement at Taco Bell was still in the whirlwind of a new
product launch. The lustily-awaited Cool Ranch Doritos Locos Taco had
arrived in stores a day later than expected and the fast food equiva-
lent of a riot erupted around the internet. The new menu item is the
next beefy/cheesy chapter in whats turning out to be a storybook
marriage between Taco Bell and Frito Lay. Its already yielded the
Doritos Locos taco, an historic product launch that sold at a rate of
almost one million per day in 2012. Riding its spicy shell, the Yum
Brands brand has become the fast feeder to watch as it plans to open
2,000 new restaurants over the next decade. Things are moving
muy rapido at Taco Bell and the mobile experience is no excep-
tion.
Agile is our middle name, said Kavanaugh, referring to the project
development methodology preferred by many top software compa-nies and, increasingly, on corporate campuses far from Silicon Valley.
Taco Bell, which offers a fairly basic app with store locator and gift
http://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
6/18
card functionality as well as menu and nutritional informational, is
now in preliminary testing of a mobile ordering experience and has
just signed an agreement with Cardfree, the mobile merchantplatform. Why? Mobile ordering is what the consumer wants and Taco
Bell, according to Kavanaugh, has made the shift from an advertising-
led company to an insights-led
one.
That shift means one thing for
mobile app strategy. If youre
driving an insights brand andresponding to and co-creating
experience with consumers and
identifying their needs, then this
is a function that should sit in
marketing.
Kavanaugh is part of a growing
chorus that favors a marketing-
led mobile app strategy. Market-
ters, the argument goes, own the
consumer insights and the brand experience, and therefore should
oversee the increasingly important mobile app channel. But bearing
this responsibility augurs a new reality for marketing departments.
They have to become more tech-savvy and comfortable with building
and maintaining a rigorous development roadmap. Suddenly theyremaking softwarea long way from the days when marketing was all
about outsourcing ad campaigns to Madison Ave agencies.
When I started in marketing, it was the arts and crafts department,
said Brian Kardon, CMO of Lattice Engines, which offers big data
analytics for sales and marketing departments. We did the logos, the
colors of the website, the branding. Now its all left brain. Everyone on
my team is a digital native. They know about HTML, search, how tobuild an app. Increasingly in bigger companies you have marketing
technologists embedded.
http://clicktotweet.com/ajevbhttp://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
7/18
The rise of the marketing technologistor creative technologist in
many an agencys lingoshows just how far weve come in blurring
the lines between what used to be two very distinct departments,skillsets, and worldviews. The marketing department needs people
who get techand vice versa.
Scott Brinker, CTO at Ion Interactive
and proprietor of the ChiefMarTech
blog, has been studying this dynamic
for years. He believes that market-
ing has to own the experience and todo that they have to take responsib-
lility for the technology.
Its logical that marketing is respon-
sible for mobile app strategy, but
this comes with a caveat that echoes
throughout many of the other
conversations we had. Marketers have to earn it by really immersing
their organizations in technology.
I dont think it works when marketing sketches out the experience
and throws it over the fence for IT or some third party to build, he
said. Marketing folks dont even know whats possible with the tech-
nology just as tech folks might not understand how it impacts experi-
ence. You need someone on the team who speaks both languages.
Who marketers partner with is another important factor in how
successful theyll be in owning mobile. Forrester analyst Michael
Facemire observed that the digital agencies once best known for
design acumen are getting better at working with backend technology,
helping apps with sharply-designed front ends add more functionality
and value through connections with the vast amounts of data present
in the enterprise. The association could help CMOs gain tech credibil-
ity.
The CMO is trying to branch out and not just be about pretty pictures
http://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
8/18
anymore, Facemire said. I can reach out and work with folks who
have technical chops, who are not just pretty-picture guys but can
work with back-end systems as well. This can become a commonground.
Another common ground can be Agile development, the project
management philosophy that may end up being the Esperanto of a
properly integrated marketing-
tech world, only, unlike Espe-
eranto, people actually use it.
At Mindjet, the San Francisco-
based creator of work manage-
ement software, the marketing
department has adopted a
version of Agile that has them
operating in three-week sprints.
When we sit down with an
engineering team, were more
effective because we all speak the
same language, said Mindjet CMO Jascha Kaykas-Wolff.
Adopting Agile is part and parcel of the changes that have washed
over the marketing business that as for decades acclimated to long
planning cycles and communications strategies that were hatched
behind closed doors and shoved out into the world with little if anyroom adapting to customer feedback.
Agile is about fast sprints, testing and learning, iterating and reiterat-
ing. Said Kaykas-Wolff, The idea of having a big campaign, pumping a
bunch of media against and then pulling it down six months later
doesnt really work. You have to operate differently and one of the
models to pull from is software deployment.
To his mind, marketers shouldnt be automatically handed responsibil-
ity for mobile. They have to earn it by educating themselves and
http://clicktotweet.com/234Behttp://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
9/18
showing that they get how software is made rather than try important
ways of thinking and doing from old marketing models.
If you approach mobile strategy like it's a bunch of campaigns youre
destined for failure. You have to be empathetic to how you develop
and deploy software. If you're not, then you're in a horrible position to
raise your hand to take over mobile strategy.
Until about eight months ago, Mindjets mobile operations was led by
the product team. Now its organized by a steering committee for
mobile comprised of a number of senior executives including the headof product and Kaykas-Wolff. Injecting marketing and other functions
into the mobile development process ensured that Mindjet began to
better focus on its paying customers and even led to a new product.
Over time, Kaykas-Wolff said marketing may end up owning app
strategy. Or it may not. In any event, ownership doesnt preclude
collaboration with other parts of the enterprise, least of all IT. And, no
matter the organization, there are things that IT just does better.
There are requirements in terms of privacy protection and security-
things that I would have no business being involved in, Kavanaugh
said. They are important for brand and consumer protection. That is
driven by the back-end, a really strong IT team and partnership.
http://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
10/18
Theres good news and bad news for the CIO who wants to ownmobile strategy. Lets get the bad news out of the way.
Mobile success requires speed and openness to a more iterative way
of doing things. With mobile, youre constantly issuing updates,
optimizing, perfecting and innovating. Unfortunately, CIOs and the IT
organizations they oversee are historical symbols of corporate slow-
ness. You dont look to IT for innovation. You look to IT to keep things
up and running.
The office of the CIO was never thought of as an innovation center,
said Facemire, of Forrester. Its been perceived as a cost center
hoping to get stuff done at a containable cost.
This is a perception that, rightly or wrongly, has lingered. Most people
we talked to dont think that your average CIO is cut out for the job, a
number that includes some of their own.
http://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
11/18
I'm heavily biased that the marketer should own it, said Jim ONeill,
CIO of HubSpot, a marketing SaaS company based in Cambridge,
Mass. IT is there to help the business. IT should help with the build-out or with sourcing the engineering development, but only at the
direction of the CMO. The legacy power struggles need to go away.
Heres the good news. There are
indications that CIOs are taking on a
broader role within their organiza-
tions, that they are no longer mere
shepherds of a just-say-slow ITdepartment. A 2012 survey from
Gartner captured the change roiling
this geeky corner of the C-suite.
Seventy-seven percent of CIOs
interviewed said they have responsi-
bilities beyond IT, compared to just
50 percent four years before. IT management, until recently the be-all
and end-all of the job, now ranks a paltry sixth on a list of priorities
thats topped by analytics and business intelligence and mobile tech-
nologies. Sure, CIOs are still called upon to oversee security, virtualiza-
tion, CRM and legacy modernization, but theyre increasingly tasked
with building new channels and markets.
Chris Silva, an analyst at Altimeter Group, breaks the recent history of
the CIO role into three phases. In the first, the CIO intensely focusedon his own backlog and lost track of what consumers were doing
tech-wise. This was followed by a period of disintermediation during
which enterprises went with line of business-led initiatives that often
ended up with purchases off-the-shelf solutions. Were just entering a
third phase thats a result of dissatisfaction of those solutions. And
were playing catch up to consumers.
I haven't been able to quantify this in data points, but over the pastsix months or so the tide is shifting back toward the CIO, Silva told us.
CIOs are caught up. They know whats needed: building platforms
http://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
12/18
across the organization so that everyone can benefit from mobile in a
way thats consistent and fully funded and resourced.
Facemire said this is changing
how CIOs think of their jobs. The
CIO, he said, is trying to pivot
and become the chief digital
officer and become the center of
not only information but of digital
interaction.
And of course theres no way to
think of digital interaction without
thinking of mobile. With the
number of mobile devices set to
exceed the worlds population,
were not going out on a limb in
saying that understanding mobile
is a key part of the CIOs future.
But how can he or she put an elbow to the ribs of the CMO humble-
bragging about how he owns consumer insights and user experience?
The CIO does hold one card here: the employee. Its important to not
forget that an important user base for apps is to be found in the
workforce and the CIO has, for a long time now, been charged with
designing a technology experience just for that audience. As workersof all kindsfrom salespeople to community managers to waiters-
get more mobile, they need devices that combine the friendly interace
of a consumer product with the back-end functionality that allows
them to dip into enterprise systems where necessary.
Happily, the CIO has already been trying to make this marriage
happen as he confronts the consumerization of IT, which, put simply,
means what technology an employee uses in the workplace will beinformed by the choices he makes as a consumer. Although you might
issue staff a Blackberry, Dell Inspiron and an Outlook account,
With the number of mobiledevices set to exceed theworlds population, were notgoing out on a limb in sayingthat understanding mobile is a
key part of the CIOs future
http://clicktotweet.com/9elOhhttp://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
13/18
employees are actually using an Android, an iPad and Gmail. Its a
trend that has any number of implications for HR, IT and legal depart-
ments. One effect of the Bring Your Own Device phenomenon is thatits forced CIOs to better understand how workforces use technology
and thats a good first step to understanding what consumers are
doing. Its given topics like good design and usability a higher profile.
Another advantage that CIOs also
bring is a different mindset to
bear when it comes to metrics. In
the worst cases, marketers canget snagged on soft but sexy
metricssay the number of
reviews and stars in the App
Storeand lose sight of bigger
questions.
IT shouldn't give up on metrics
like security or process support
simply to serve marketers'
metrics, said Altimeters Silva. You can take great expertise from
serving customers and use 90 percent of that, but serving customers is
probably going to be different from serving folks internally. Are you
solving a user problem? If you're not or you're not focused on that,
you're wasting your time and your money.
Among the keys to success for the CIO, according to one information
chief who prefers to remain anonymous, is not leading with technol-
ogy and speaking the language of business objectives. Hiring IT people
with broad technology stack knowledge who can sit comfortably next
to marketing and design people on cross-functional teams also
helpsas does a mindset that allows innovation to flourish through-
out the organization.
Even an empowered CIO is faced with an unfortunate reality: no
matter how expansively you view your role, a good chunk of the job is
IT shouldnt give up on metricslike security or process supportsimply to serve marketersmetrics
http://clicktotweet.com/cOF21http://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
14/18
about keeping the operation running and managing an endless project
list. To a degree, this CIO remains a service provider who doesnt
wholly control her own agenda. Innovation is often far down the listunless theres a budget set aside for it. But that doesnt mean innova-
tion isnt going on elsewhere in the organizationin other corporate
functions or at the business units. When that happens, whats a CIO to
do? Snuff it out and stay true to a command-and-control notion of IT
or let so-called shadow IT bloom?
The answer to some degree is a barometer of how well this CIO is cut
out to run mobile app strategy and other operations that are inher-ently forward-thinking.
Fighting this sort of shadow IT is not a prescription for success, said
our anonymous CIO. I allow it to thrive and allow seedlings to hatch
out in the business units. Its an effective backdoor way for me to fund
and create innovation. I dont blow the whistle, or stomp my feet. I
nurture it and advocate for it. Ultimately that's going to come back to
me. It will come under my ownership. Im better served in leading from
behind.
http://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
15/18
Ben Galbraith laughed lightly as he states his position on our CMO-CIOquestion.
I'm an engineer by background, so my response is predictable, said
the VP-global products at Walmart.com. I struggle to see why giving a
marketing guy control over a software product makes any sense at
all.
After dismantling our entire thesis, Galbraith was kind enough to walkthrough the logic with us. It kind of felt like making a guy used to
driving a Porsche take your pre-owned Hyundai out for a test spin. You
see, Walmart does things differently than most Fortune 100 whose
roots arent in technology. A company that began in the final year of
the Second World War has made itself into a tech player, establishing
Walmart Global eCommerce, which in the companys own words
combines the small structure and nimble nature of a startup with the
resources of the worlds largest retailer. In short, Global eCommerce
supplies the ginormous retailers business units with software
solutions. Youve probably read about Walmart Labs, the incubator
http://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
16/18
behind innovations like Polaris, the companys own search engine.
Were very much a software technology operation, Galbraith said,making a crucial observation. Fashioning yourself a software company
means youre relentlessly focused on innovation and, rather than
worry about old organizational silos,
youre keeping the consumer at the
center of things. It also means that
discussion around how legacy roles
can be updated doesnt much apply.
For us, Galbraith said, the notion
of marketing people owning the
software is ridiculous but it's as
ridiculous as the IT people owning
the software.
So the CMO or CIO question is no longer really a relevant one, though
as recently as two years ago it might have been because Walmart.com
had fewer product people in its ranks. Now, he said, the answer to
the question on both sides is no. We need someone who's focused on
end-to-end customer experience. For us it's actually two people. One
who's focused on it from a business perspective and one who's
focused on it from a product perspective.
Asked whether this sort of thing is feasible for companies smaller thanWalmartwhich is to say almost every company in the worldGalbraith
acknowledged the efficiencies that Walmart gets from its
global girth. Its easier to amortize the R&D when youre a global
player. Before you sniff that whats good for Bentonville cant help
your own 25-person shop, remember that there are still lessons here
that are universally applicable. The first is that laser focus on the
customer and her needs and desires. The second is putting software
people in charge of software development. This is what is reallybehind those calls for more a technologically-savvy marketing depart-
ment.
BEFORE AFTER
Acme
C
Acme
C
Acme
C
http://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
17/18
In the final analysis, it may end up that Walmarts experience is more
widely applicable than you might think. Thats not to say your small or
medium enterprise is going to find a pot of gold that will allow you toplow untold millions into proprietary software development. Even if
youre still buying off-the-shelfsomething Galbraith said Walmart
would do more of if only off-the-shelf was bettertheres a point to be
made here. In the end, neither marketing nor tech has to end up
owning mobile. It is not preordained. And a lot of companies are
talking about cross-functional constructions that include not only the
marketing and tech but also legal, HR and other functions where need
be.
The CIO and the CMO are in the best case ceding their power in equal
amounts to a center of excellence that is comprised of resources from
both shops, ideally, that is leading mobile throughout the organiza-
tion, said Altimeters Chris Silva. Theyre doing the work and acting as
a tiger team, asking how do we make sure we're doing it right and how
are we cross-pollinating what we're doing on the inside? They've
realized building the wheel five times doesn't help anybody.
Perhaps the CIO vs. CMO smackdown shouldnt be a smackdown at all.
Youve got to take the versus out, said Taco Bells Kavanaugh, speak-
ing like a true purveyor of Doritos-Taco Bell mash-ups. Nothing works
in isolation anymore.
http://www.kinvey.com/7/27/2019 Mobile Wars - CMO vs CIO Kinvey
18/18
Matt Creamer is a writer and editor
based in New York City. He has
written for Ad Age, where he is
editor at large, The Awl, The Atlantic,
the New York Daily News, The New
York Observer and other publica-
tions. He tweets at @matt_creamer.
Written by:
Jake McKibben &Miguel Gaydosh
Designed by:
What is Kinvey? Kinvey makes a fully-featured Backend as a
Service solution, offering 3rd party data integrations, multi-platform
support, push notifications, and custom business logic on a
platform where it's free to get started and you only pay when your
app is successful.
Build your backend todayBuild your backend today
http://www.twitter.com/matt_creamerhttp://www.twitter.com/matt_creamerhttp://www.twitter.com/matt_creamerhttp://www.twitter.com/ez_Jake_ovenhttp://www.twitter.com/ez_Jake_ovenhttps://twitter.com/ItsMiguel_Ghttps://twitter.com/ItsMiguel_Ghttp://www.kinvey.com/https://console.kinvey.com/signuphttps://console.kinvey.com/signuphttps://twitter.com/ItsMiguel_Ghttp://www.twitter.com/ez_Jake_ovenhttp://www.twitter.com/matt_creamerhttps://github.com/Kinveymailto:support@kinvey.comhttp://feeds.feedburner.com/kinveyhttp://www.facebook.com/kinveyhttp://www.twitter.com/kinveyhttps://console.kinvey.com/signuphttp://www.kinvey.com/Recommended