View
552
Download
0
Category
Tags:
Preview:
Citation preview
Decision Support System
for Local and Regional
Planning
Location Information Strategy
Regional decision-making Think of a key regional decision that was
recently made
Investment
Planning
Strategic
Broadly map the decision making process
Who made the decision?
How was the need established?
What inputs were used to make the decision?
What criteria was used to make the decision?
Introduction
Evidence based decision-making is being
advocated
Regional investment
Town planning
Strategy development
Challenges
What criteria?
What measures?
What data?
Evidence-Based Decision
Making
Present
Performance
Problem/Opp
ortunities
Definition
Options
IdentificationInitiatives Impacts
Broad targets,
goals
Standards for
performance
Criteria for
investment
Business case
guidelines
Broad targets,
goals
Report cardPerformance
scorecard
Performance
scorecard
Options
assessment
and impacts
Revised
performance
scorecard
Data collection VerificationScanning and
consulting
Deal-making
and
partnerships
Data collection
Strategie
s&
policies
LIS
On-the-
ground
expertis
e
What to measure
Availability
Quality
Suitability
Timeliness
Spatiality
Metrics
Scene Setting
Major release of new information (Census
2011)
Relevant to a number of strategic benchmarks
Triggers assessment of progress against
strategic performance targets
Regional Blueprints
State Planning Strategy
Other Strategic documents
Metrics
Resilience
Resilience
Resilience
Problem Identification
Significant population growth
Employment creation is lagging
Residents are having to go further and further
for work
Employment creation in the Region is in the
east, with settlement in the west
Metrics
Prosperity
Prosperity - Concentration
Top Ten Industries by ECFEmployment
2006
Employment
2011Change
Basic Non-Ferrous Metal Manufacturing 3.51 11.15 7.64
Other Livestock Farming 5.98 6.70 0.72
Horse and Dog Racing Activities 4.43 6.07 1.64
Poultry Farming 3.64 3.97 0.33
Nursery and Floriculture Production 3.87 3.14 -0.74
Rail Passenger Transport - 2.88 2.88
Dairy Cattle Farming 3.16 2.59 -0.57
Retail Commission-Based Buying and/or
Selling- 2.53 2.53
Waste Collection Services 2.55 2.51 -0.04
Land Development and Site Preparation
Services2.77 2.43 -0.34
Local firms outperforming in a high
growth industry
Coal Mining
Metal Ore Mining
Other Mining
Construction Trade Services
Education
Local firms outperforming in a low growth
industry
Commercial Fishing
Food, Beverage and Tobacco Manufacturing
Textile, Clothing, Footwear and Leather
Manufacturing
Wood and Paper Product Manufacturing
Printing, Publishing and Recorded Media
Petroleum, Coal, Chemical and Associated
Product Manufacturing
Metal Product Manufacturing
Other Manufacturing
Rail Transport
Services to Transport
Prosperity – Shift Share
On-the-ground verification
Mining, ore processing and food production
Opportunities for growth
Fertile soils
Findings
Water supply constraint to utilistion of highly
arable soil
Certainty of water supply constraint to existing
operations of Alcoa refineries
Certainty of water supply a potential future
constraint to Boddington mine operations
Metrics
Verification – Water Supply
Verification
Intervention Opportunities
Consult with field experts
Public
Private
Alignment with Priority Projects?
Facilitate industry development
Drive investment
Create employment
Define success
_GL/year allocated water available to priority
industries
Intervention Opportunities -
Pipeline
Investment Criteria
Project selection – regional priority
Funder’s criteria
Against defined performance outcomes
Stage 1 - _ GL per year
Stage 2 - _ GL per year
Project Impacts
Performance against intervention (change in
GL of available water)
Resilience
Employment self sufficiency
Total jobs
Diversity of jobs
Prosperity
Target industries
Review of impacts - Prosperity
Top Ten Industries by ECFEmployment
2006
Employment
2011
Employment
2016Change
Nursery and Floriculture
Production3.87 3.14 15.47 11.60
Basic Non-Ferrous Metal
Manufacturing3.51 11.15 11.15 7.64
Other Livestock Farming 5.98 6.70 6.70 0.72
Horse and Dog Racing Activities 4.43 6.07 6.07 1.64
Mushroom and Vegetable Growing 1.23 1.55 5.49 4.26
Poultry Farming 3.64 3.97 3.97 0.33
Rail Passenger Transport - 2.88 2.88 2.88
Dairy Cattle Farming 3.16 2.59 2.59 -0.57
Retail Commission-Based Buying
and/or Selling- 2.53 2.53 2.53
Waste Collection Services 2.55 2.51 2.51 -0.04
Census 2016
Review of impacts - Prosperity
Evidence-Based Decision
Making
Present
Performance
Problem/Opp
ortunities
Definition
Options
IdentificationInitiatives Impacts
Broad targets,
goals
Standards for
performance
Criteria for
investment
Business case
guidelines
Broad targets,
goals
Report cardPerformance
scorecard
Performance
scorecard
Options
assessment
and impacts
Revised
performance
scorecard
Data collection VerificationScanning and
consulting
Deal-making
and
partnerships
Data collection
Strategie
s&
policies
LIS
On-the-
ground
expertis
e
So………
Demonstration of the process
Definition needed of:
Data
Metrics
Standards
Key is to:
Provide useful, accurate performance data
Be specific in its purposes
Utilise current information and data sources
Recommended