Introduction on sQGP and Bag model Gluon condensates in sQGP and in vacuum

Istanbul 06 S.H.LeeIstanbul 06 S.H.Lee

1. Introduction on sQGP and Bag model

2. Gluon condensates in sQGP and in vacuum

3. J/ suppression in RHIC

4. Pertubative QCD approach for heavy quarkonium

Perturbative QCD apporach to Heavy quarkonium

at finite temperature and density

Su Houng LeeYonsei Univ., Korea

Thanks to : Recent Collegues: C.M. Ko, W. Weise, B. Friman, T. Barnes, H. Kim, Y. Oh, .. Students: Y. Sarac, Taesoo Song, Y. Park, Y. Kwon, Y. Heo,..

At high T and/or Density

Quark Gluon Plasma

Proton

Nucleons in vacuum

Quark Gluon Plasma (T.D. Lee and E. Shuryak)

QCD Phase Diagram at finite T and

~ 170 MeV

0.17 / fm3

Quark Gluon Plasma (s

QGP) Different

• Particle spectrum (mass)

• Vacuum

• Deconfinement

• Theoretical approach

Lattice result:

sudden change in p and E above Tc

Signal of QGP

Relativistic Heavy Ion collision

Some highlights from RHIC

Data from STAR coll. At RHIC

Jet quenching: strongly interacting matter

V2: very low viscosity

Vacuum property of sQGP

MIT Bag model and Quark Gluon Plasma (QGP)

sQGP strongly interacting and very small viscosity

Bag model and sQGP

MIT Bag model : inside the Bag vac=0, perturbative vacuume

outside the Bag vac = non zero , non perturbative vacuum

B }{4 BDixdSinside

MeV) 206( ,8.0

MeV) 120( ,1

NE qnucleon

Original bag model

Later models Outside pressure is balanced by confined quark pressure

Bag model and sQGP

Phase transition in MIT Bag model

BTgPQGP ..90

BTgEQGP ..90

Outside pressure is balanced by thermal quark gluon pressure

QGPQGP

but scorrection large need ,

Asakawa, Hatsuda PRD 97

QCD vacuum vs. sQGP

MIT Bag

Vacuum with negative pressure

Nonperturbative QCD vacuum

1. What is B in terms of QCD variables (operators)

2. Can understand soft modes associated with phase transition

Gluon condsenates in QGP and Vacuum

Gluon condensate

1. , dominated by non-perturbative contribution3222 MeV/fm 1500)(2 EBG

2. RG invariant, gauge invariant, characteristic vacuum property, couples to spin 0 field

3. Can be calculated on the lattice (DiGiacomo et al. )

pGpmpTp p20

5. Nucleon expectation value is

4GGhhmqqmTD hl

4. Related to trace of energy momentum tensor through trace anomaly (Hatsuda 87)

ussddup

dssduup

ssdduupp

BmBmBmmm

MeV 45)(|| duqq BBmpdduupm

MeV 6500 pm

6. From we find

Gluon condensate in MIT Bag model

MeV) 200(for MeV/fm 711MeV/fm 1500

Inside QGP

MeV 650for /MeV 578MeV/fm 1500

pInside

poutsideInside

BVmVpGpGG

Inside nucleon

82 Using

Explicit lattice calculation of non-pertur

bative gluon condensate?

89) (SHLee

84) (Digiacomo

Gluon condensate in QGP from lattice calculation

.....)(signal latticevalue 424

GGGonperturbatilatticelatticeveperturbatinon

Lattice data show

1. Gluon condensate at T=0 is consistent with QCD sum rule value

2. Gluon condensate at T>Tc is 50 to 70 % of its vacuum value

consistent with estimates of gluon condensate inside the Bag (nucleon)

3. The change occurs at the phase transition point

T D Lee’s spin 0 field seems dominantly gluon condensate

and their expectation value indeed changes similarly in Bag and QGP

QCD vacuum vs. sQGP

MIT Bag

Vacuum with negative pressure

Nonperturbative QCD vacuum

If phase transition occurs, there will be enhancement of massless glueball excitation

2 7.0 GGVac

2 GGGVac

Summary ISummary I

1. Vacuum expectation value of Gluon condensate inside the Bag and QGP seems similar. sQGP is a large Bag

What will the viscosity be ?? What is the property of sQGP?

Physical consequence of phase transition?

2. Future GSI (FAIR) will be able to prove vacuum change through charmonium spectrum in nuclear matter

J/ in QGP

Karsch et al. (2000)

( )V r0T

Higher T

Heavy quark potential on the lattice

J/ in Quark Gluon Plasma

J/ melt above Tc

1986: Matsui and Satz claimed J/ suppression is a signature of formation of Quark Gluon Plasma in Heavy Ion collision

J/ suppression in Heavy Ion collision

New RHIC data

2003: Asakawa and Hatsuda claimed J/ will survive up to 1.6 Tc

Quenched lattice calculation by Asakawa and Hatsuda using MEM

T< 1.6 Tc

T> 1.6 Tc

J/ peak at 3.1 GeV

J/ in Quark Gluon Plasma

Theoretical interpretations

1. C. H. Lee, G. Brown, M. Rho… : Deeply bound states

2. C. Y. Wong… : Deby screened potential

1. Strong s at Tc < T < ~2 Tc

2. J/ form Coulomb bound states at Tc < T < ~2 Tc

Became a question of quntative analysis

a) What are the effects of Dynamical quarks ?

b) What is the survial probability of J/ in QGP

Relevant questions in J/ suppression

need to know J/ – gluon dissociation

need to know J/ – quark dissociation

Progress in QCD calculations

LO and NLO

Basics in Heavy Quark system

1. Heavy quark propagation

1)( where,...........)()()()( qSGqSqSqSG

Perturbative treatment are possible

because 0for even qqm QCD

2. System with two heavy quarks

..)2/1(4

),(...)(

n Gqxqm

xqFdxq

Perturbative treatment are possible when

222 4 QCDqm

q2 processexpansion para

0Photo production of open ch

-Q2 < 0QCD sum rules for heavy q

> 0 Dissociation cross section of bound states

Perturbative treatment are possible when 222 4 QCDqm

4 QmQCD

Historical perspective on Quarkonium Haron interaction in QCD

1. Peskin (79), Bhanot and Peskin (79)

a) From OPE

b) Binding energy= 0 >>

2. Kharzeev and Satz (94,96) , Arleo et.al.(02,04)

a) Rederive, target mass correction

b) Application to J/ physics in HIC

Rederivation of Peskin formula using Bethe-Salpeter equation (Lee,Oh 02)

Resum Bound state by Bethe-Salpeter Equation

)( )( ),( )( )2(

), 221214

21 pKVKiKppKppKiKd

Cigpp F

NR Power counting in Heavy bound state

)( 16/2

mgOgNm c

))()((

)(2244

mgmgmg

1. Perturbative part

2. External interaction: OPE

LO Amplitude

1by suppressed

However, near threshold, LO result is expected to have large correctionHowever, near threshold, LO result is expected to have large correction

)()( )( xgxdx ghad

s1/2 (GeV)

Exp data

NLO Amplitude

)(, ),(,,

)()()()()2(

)()()()()2( : NLO

)(, ),(,

)()()()2( : LO

mgOppmgOkk

kgpcpckgm

kqpcpckqm

mgOppmgOk

pcpckgm

NLO Amplitude : qccq

Collinear divergence when 1=0.

Cured by mass factroization

Mass factorization

1 Gluons whose kcos1 < Q scale,

should be included in parton distribution function

Integration of transverse momentum from zero to scale Q

2 ˆ'ˆ

ds iLO

EjisiNLOiNLO

NLO Amplitude : gccg

Higher order in g counting

NLO Amplitude : - cont gccg

Previous diagrams can be reproduced with effective four point vertex

Cancellation of infrared divergence

Remaining Infrared Divergence cancells after adding one loop corrections

Application to Upsilon dissociation cross section

Fit quark mass and coupling from fitting

to coulomb bound state gives)2()1( , SS mm

GeV 1.5

GeV 1 0

qQQq gQQg

Total cross section for Upsilon by nucleon: NLO vs LO

Large higher order corrections

Even larger correction for charmonium

NLO/LO

1. Large NLO correction near threshold, due to log terms1. Large NLO correction near threshold, due to log terms

J/for MeV 700 e wher2

log 00

2. Dissociation by quarks are less than 10% of that by gluons2. Dissociation by quarks are less than 10% of that by gluons

qQQq gQQg

Thermal quark and gluon masses of 300 MeV will Reduce the large correction

Quenched lattice results at finite temperature are reliable

What do we learn from NLO calculation ?

Total cross section: gluon vs quark effects

With thermal mq = mg = 200 MeV

Effective Thermal cross section: gluon vs quark effects

Effective Thermal width: gluon vs quark effects

1)(deg

Summary IISummary II

1.1. We reported on the QCD NLO Quarkonium-hadron dissociatioWe reported on the QCD NLO Quarkonium-hadron dissociation cross section. n cross section.

Large correction even for upsilon system, especially near threshold

2. The corrections becomes smaller with thermal quark and gluon mass of larger than 200 MeV

Obtained realistic J/ dissociation cross section by thermal quark and gluons

3. The dissociation cross section due to quarks are less than 10 % of that due to the gluons.

The quenched lattice calculation of the mass and width of J/ at finite temperature should be reliable.

Reference for part IReference for part I

Gluon condensates

• A. Di Giacomo and G. C. Rossi, PLB 100(1981) 481; PLB 1008 (1982) 327.

• Su Houng Lee, PRD 40 (1989) 2484.

Charmonium in nuclear matter

3. F. Klingl, S. Kim, S.H.Lee, P. Morath, W. Weise, PRL 82 (1999) 3396.

4. S.Kim and S.H.Lee, NPA 679 (2001) 517.

5. S.H.Lee and C.M. Ko, PRC 67 (2003) 038202.

6. S.J.Brodsky et al. PRL 64 (1990) 1011

Quarkonium hadron interaction

7. M.E. Peskin, NPB 156 (1979) 365; G.Bhanot and M. E. Peskin, NPB156 (1979) 391

8. Y.Oh, S.Kim and S.H.Lee, PRC 65 (2002) 067901.

Additional

9. T.D. Lee, hep-ph/06 05017

Introduction on sQGP and Bag model Gluon condensates in sQGP and in vacuum

Documents

Understanding strongly coupled quark-gluon plasma (sQGP)

VORTICES IN BOSE-EINSTEIN CONDENSATES

Gluon Brochure

Atomic Bose-Einstein Condensates Mixtures

Collisional energy loss in the sQGP · 2005. 9. 29. · strongly coupled QGP (sQGP) collective phenomena, in line with hydrodynamics fast equilibration, low viscosity large Xsections,

F.S.N. and D.A. Fogaça IFUSP / BRAZIL Gluon condensates and the equation of state of cold quark gluon plasmas arXiv:1012.5266

Gluon Polarisation Overview

Phase Dislocations in Bose-Einstein Condensates

GLUON SCATTERING - personal.kent.edumstrick6/qcdseminar/spring14/nopoush.pdfHOW USEFUL ARE MY TECHNIQUES? 22 Gluon Scattering ! 23 Gluon Scattering (325 distinct diagrams)* where is

Strongly Coupled Quark Gluon Plasma and the AdS/CFT ...skipper.physics.sunysb.edu/~drees/PHY599/VivekSaxena.pdfVivek Saxena sQGP and the AdS/CFT Correspondence November 09, 2015 16

Trento 05 Shuryak 1 Dileptons from Strongly Coupled quark-gluon plasma (sQGP) Edward Shuryak Department of Physics and Astronomy State University of New

Introduction: sQGP @ RHIC

Domain wall networks and hadron propertiesfunqcd2018/Talks/... · 2018. 4. 9. · Gluon condensates and domain wall network Pure gluodynamics - Ginzburg-Landau approach: L e = 1 4

Toward understanding of Quark-Gluon Plasma inenucl-web/seminar/slides/hirano.pdf•Not a QGP gas sQGP •Nevertheless, large discrepancy in forward/ backward rapidity See next slides

Gluon Tagging and Quark & Gluon Samples

Spinor condensates beyond mean-field

Understanding strongly coupled quark-gluon plasma (sQGP) (Israeli Physical Soc. Rehovot, Dec.2007) Edward Shuryak Stony Brook (Israeli Physical Soc. Rehovot,

Soft Theorems and Their Implementation · 2018. 11. 18. · " Soft-Gluon Limit in QCD Amplitude: ! Case 1: Soft gluon adjacent to one quark and one gluon ! Case 2: Soft gluon adjacent

Dileptons from Strongly Coupled quark-gluon plasma (sQGP)

Evolutionary games of condensates in coupled birth-death ...denysov/Lectures/Vortrag-NEST.pdf · Evolutionary games of condensates in coupled ... Evolutionary games of condensates