Human Trafficking: Modern Day Slavery › si › 2015 › pdf › 0626 Mr. Friedman HKU... ·...

Preview:

Citation preview

ISIS and Boko Haram

Slavery Handbook Question 13: Is it permissible to have intercourse with a female slave who has not reached puberty? It is permissible to have intercourse with the female slave who hasn’t reached puberty if she is fit for intercourse; however, if she is not fit for intercourse, then it is enough to enjoy her without intercourse.

4

Slave Boats

Sweat Shops

Domestic Servitude

Fact: 5.5 million women and girls

Rohingya

Conflict Zones

Domestic Servitude

What about our children?

Fact: 5.5 million

children

Definition: The Changing Paradigm

The act…

• Recruitment • Transportation • Harboring

By means of…

• Threats • Use of force • Abduction • Fraud • Deception

For the Purpose of Exploitation

Trafficking and children (age<18) Trafficking Adults (age>18) UN Definition

Slavery Markers

Withholding Wages Restricted movement

Physical and sexual violence

Retention of identify documents

Threats to self or family

Debt and other forms of bondage

Human Trafficking = Slavery

Slavery

Human Trafficking Outcome

Forced Labor

Slavery Child Labor

Paradigm Change

No pay or prospect of pay

Low or unfair pay

Fair pay

Payment Continuum

Excessive, unfair debt used to hold a person

in place

Debt compounded by unfair fees/practices

Legitimate debt

Debt

Restricted movement at all times

Limited movement Can come and go

at will

Freedom of movement

Abuse/threats used to hold a person in place

Some threats/abuse No threats/abuse

Abuse/Threats (real or perceived)

PAY

CONTROL

The Numbers

There are 35,800,000 Slaves!

More than the populations of the following countries:

Canada: 35.7 million

Or

More than the combined total of the smallest 100 countries

Global Ranking: Slavery Index

Asia 23,542,800 66 percent

11.3 Million slaves between 1450 and

1900 (450 years)

Historical Perspective

Top ten Summary

Top 10 countries:

• India • China • Pakistan • Uzbekistan • Russia • Nigeria • Congo • Indonesia • Bangladesh • Thailand

69%

Percentage of Overall Population

74%

26% Adults versus Children

Adults

Children

76%

24%

Forced Labor versus Forced Prostitution

Forced Labour

Sex Industry

60 percent of the cases are associated with product

supply chains (the items we all buy)

Breakdown of Figures (ILO)

This means millions of slaves

7 million new slaves per year

19,200 new slaves per day

800 new slaves per hour

1 new slave every 5 seconds

Rate of Exploitation

Hong Kong

• Slavery Index figure: –13,400 Victims (recent

estimate)

– Sex industry and among domestics

UK, EUR

Middle East

USA

NE Asia (Taiwan, Korea, etc.)

Sex

Labor

Both

WHERE DO PEOPLE GET TRAFFICKED

TO?

Two Forms of Trafficking: Local and International

US, Europe, Middle

East, Australia,

etc

Country of

Origin

Number Country of Origin Number Country of Origin Number Country of Origin Number

Lithuania 116 Cameroon 10 Rwanda 3 Guinea 1

Nigeria 87 Vietnam 8 Turkey 3 Hong Kong 1

Albania 75 Sierra Leone 8 Côte d'Ivoire 2 Iran 1

Thailand 54 Sri Lanka 7 Ethiopia 2 Israel 1

China 52 Kosovo 7 Mauritius 2 Kazakhstan 1

Romania 40 Jamaica 7 Mongolia 2 Mauritania 1

Moldova 29 Liberia 7 Colombia 2 Morocco 1

Uganda 29 Belarus 7 Singapore 2 Portugal 1

Russia 25 Pakistan 7 Brazil 2 South Africa 1

Ukraine 23 Kenya 6 Eritrea 2 Sudan 1

Bangladesh 6 Gambia 2 Switzerland 1

United Kingdom 22 India 5 Zimbabwe 2 Togo 1

Poland 19 Hungary 5 Ecuador 1 Uzbekistan 1

Latvia 16 Congo, DRC 4 Benin 1 Zambia 1

Czech Republic 14 Ghana 4 Estonia 1 Egypt 1

Slovakia 13 Philippines 4 Burma 1 Indonesia 1

Malaysia 12 Bulgaria 3 Germany 1 Unknown

Other

28

14

UK Shelter (one year)

List of Countries without Slaves

Deception and

Lies Family Debt Kidnapping

How does the Process Work?

An average slave in the American South in 1850 cost the equivalent of

$40,000 in today’s money

Today a slave costs an average of $90

Price of a slave: Then and Now

Who are the Criminals?

Recruiters Exploiters Enforcers Transporters

Traditional Remedies

Before a

Trafficking Event

Trafficking

Process

After

Trafficking Event

Prevention Prosecution

(Legal Response)

Protection (Victim Support)

Traditional Responses?

Global SlaveFigure

VictimsIdentified

48,000 out of 36 million

Only 48,000 People Helped (0.04 Percent)

Only 4,000 Criminals Arrested (0.8 percent)

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000

8000

9000

2004 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014

Prosectutions

Convictions

4,000 out

of 500,000

How is the world doing?

Why is this so Low?

$150 Billion Profits from Slavery

Funding used to address the problem

0.23 percent

21 Days of Potato Chip Eating

The Profits are Obscene 1

Not knowing, not believing or running away

2

Many can’t handle the issue – too

painful

Many don’t believe slavery exists

Most people

don’t know about the problem

An Example: Closing our eyes

India Sex Trafficking Victim (15 years old) • Ten Men A Day • 365 Days a Year • 3,650 Rapes a Year

(child rape) • Two Years over 7,000

rapes

15 Year Old Girl Raped 7,000 Times

The topic is too painful to hear about

People don’t want to know about such bad things

We think it is someone else’s problem

3

Labor Not Labor

Individual

Group

Marriage Trafficking

Labor Trafficking

Forced Prostitution

Forced Begging

Fishing Industry

Domestic Servitude

Child Soldiers

The issue is complex and confusing

Can this problem be solved?

Yes, but we all have to all work together

8 Steps

Educate, Inspire and Motivate the World

1 Make It Relevant to Us All

2 Understand to be more Efficient: Bangladesh

Reduce the 35.8 million

Addressing Causality

Rule of Law/Enforcement

Criminal Justice

Victim Identification and Outreach

Business/Private Sector

Donors

MERL

Victim Support and

Services/Social Inclusion

Governments

Consumers

Civil Society

United Nations

Private Sector

Students

General public

PARTNERS

Private Sector

Limited Countries

Information Foundation

Partner Clusters

United Front

Packaging

Pilot Areas

CRITERIA 4 United Plan: Get Everyone Involved

Bring out some WINS 5

Top 10 countries include

69 percent of the slaves

Supply Chains

Millions of slaves in supply chains

Bad business

The private sector knows bad business

Resources The private sector has resources

(human and financial)

Stand up The private sector knows how to lead

Impact Millions can be Helped

6 The Private Sector needs to Step Up

We need a new abolitionist movement across the world 7

A Sense of URGENCY 8

Think of the children as your own

A New Slave Every 5 Seconds

Break

The Private Sector: Emerging Trends

A New Wave of Activism Focused on Slavery

1

1. International Labor Organization Conventions 29, 105, 138 & 182: Provisions ratified by up to 175 countries towards the elimination of forced and child labor.

2. “Strengthening Protections Against Trafficking in Persons in Federal Contracts”; the Ending Trafficking in Government Contracting (ETGC) provisions of the Fiscal Year 2013 National Defense Authorization Act

3. UN Principles on Business and Human Rights 2011, covering: 1) the State Duty to Protect Human Rights; The Corporate Responsibility to Respect Human Rights; and the need for greater Access to Remedy for victims of business-related abuse.

4. European Union Council Decision 2006/618/EC: Requires each EU member state to adopt measures to prevent and combat trafficking in persons.

5. H.R. 2759, the Business Transparency on Trafficking & Slavery Act (federal version of the California Act.)

6. Executive Order, entitled “Strengthening Protections Against Trafficking in Persons in Federal Contracts”;

7. Future: UK and EU versions of similar Acts

Legislation Is Expanding 2

California Transparency in

Supply Chains Act (SB 657)

One Example

Background

• When? As of January 1, 2012.

• Who? All retailers and manufacturers with annual global revenues over $100 million who do business in California

• What? Businesses must disclose on their website homepage what they are doing to remove slavery from their supply chains

• Why? “To educate consumers on how to purchase goods produced by companies that responsibly manage their supply chains”

Five Requirements

Disc losure must inc lude in format ion about what the company is do ing to , inc lud ing

1) Verification: Verify product supply chains to evaluate and address risks of human trafficking and slavery

2) Auditing: Perform independent supplier audits to evaluate compliance with company standards

3) Certification: Require certification by direct suppliers that materials incorporated into company products comply with the laws regarding slavery and human trafficking of the country or countries in which they are doing business 4) Internal Accountability: Maintain internal accountability standards and procedures for employees or contractors that fail to meet company standards on slavery and trafficking

5) Training: Train relevant company employees and management on human trafficking and slavery, particularly concerning the mitigation of risk within supply chains.

56

Penalty for Non-Compliance

• The California Attorney General will order the company to take remedial action

• Non-compliance may result in “naming and shaming” by advocacy groups and media

Corporate Response: Ford

Corporate Response: Ford

“Human Trafficking: CA Disclosure” goes to this

webpage, which describes Ford’s efforts to keep slavery

out of their pig-iron supply chain.

“Naming and Shaming” is Increasing

3

Naming and Shaming is Increasing

21

39

48

2011 2012 2013

Major Articles

Investigative Journalism

CNN, Guardian, BBC, Bloomberg

Walk Free

ENOUGH GAMES NINTENDO: TIME

FOR ACTION AGAINST SLAVERY

Act Now

Major Investment in investigative Journalism

NGO Activism: Online Tools For Consumers

Consumers are Seeking Information

Changing Public Opinion • Growing public interest and

concern • Consumers are asking

questions about the products they buy

4

Know the Chain

COMPANY NAME SECTOR STATEMENT POSTED

99¢ Only Stores Consumer Discretionary

Abaxis, Inc. Healthcare

Abbott Laboratories Healthcare

Abercrombie & Fitch Co. Consumer Discretionary

AB Sciex LLC Healthcare

Accelrys Inc. Information Technology

Why should Business Care?

Proposed Thai Seafood Boycott

Human Trafficking gives complete

business sectors a “bad name”

1

Human Trafficking under-cuts the costs

of legitimate businesses

Bangladesh Company wins all the

contracts – no salaries paid

2

Human trafficking accusations can aversely hurt a

business concern

3

Hong Kong company looses everything

Legislators don’t feel the private sector is serious

Human trafficking Legislation is becoming

“fine-based” and comprehensive

4

Hotel and Apparel

Examples

“Naming and Shaming” is often not random or

always accurate/fair

5

More Balance is Needed

Naming and Shaming

Positive Support Available

How to Engage the Private Sector?

One Approach

It started with a desire to help!!!

“Go to” and Resource Organization

1 • Training • Technical Assistance • Crisis Management • Legislation/

documentation database

• Relationship Building (NGO, Government)

• Support Service Vetting (auditing, legal, etc.)

• Campaign Management

Business for Freedom: Mekong Club Associates

2 Provide a range of technical, logistical and facilitation support services to member organizations

Using Technology to address the problem

3

Operationalize Private Sector Solutions

4

Where were you?

Educate Others: Face Book, Emails, Twitter

Raise Money and Donate it to Worthy Cause:

Be a Responsible Consumer: Check Things Out

Volunteer Your Time: Join the Fight

Use your comparative advantage – students

What Can YOU do?

Sponsor a similar talk

Find the Courage to REALLY face the Issue….. collectively

Commit to do AT LEAST One Thing

What is needed?

Be a hero (we all have one inside of us)

A Vision for Hong Kong

• Develop a plan

• Get the resources in place

• Get volunteers to help – general public, private sector organizations, YOU!!!!

• Have Hong Kong be a model city

• Collectively, we can ALL make a difference

Imagine this…..

• Imagine: after 5,000 years of slavery, we eradicate it in our lifetime

• Imagine: our generation will go down in history as the one that ended slavery

• Imagine: our children & grandchildren grow up in a world where slavery is seen as an egregious blight on history

Just Giving: The Mekong Club

The Mekong Club.org

Presentations

Film Presentations

Variety Shows

Sweatshop Challenge

Recommended