How to assess CSO-business partnerships for development€¦ · How to assess CSO-business...

Bruce Byiers, with Francesca Guadagno, Karim Karaki

March 2016

How to assess CSO-business partnerships for development

• Independent think-tank

• EU-Africa relations

• Policy to practice

• Processes, institutions, actors, interests, incentives

• Implications of private sector engagement for policy makers

• …not M&E

ECDPM

ECDPM Page 2

• What do we mean by partnerships?

• What is specific about the M&E of partnerships?

• Requirements for M&E to support and promote partnerships for the SDGs?

ECDPM Page 3

• What do we mean by partnerships?…at least 50 shades of partnership…

• What is specific about the M&E of partnerships?…same-same, but different?

• Requirements for M&E to support and promote partnerships for the SDGs?…”Plan for sailboats, not trains” (Kleinfeld, 2015)

ECDPM Page 4

1. The rise of partnerships

2. Unifying taxonomies

1. An ‘assessment approach’

2. Early lessons from application

3. Implications for you….

Overview

Page 5ECDPM

Partnerships on the rise?

ECDPM Page 6

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

MilleniumDeclaration

Paris Accra Busan Agenda2030

Private Sector Poverty Partnership Aid Monitoring

• Donors - Private sector engagement fordevelopment

• CSOs – Sustainable, people-centredbusinesses

• Businesses – Philanthropy, CSR

• LIC Gov.s - Economic transformation, more & better jobs

Commercial & development alignment?

ECDPM Page 7

• Donors - Private sector engagement fordevelopment (own commercial interest?)

• CSOs – Sustainable, people-centredbusinesses (declining core funding?)

• Businesses – Philanthropy, CSR (‘Licence tooperate’, sustainable ss chains?)

• LIC Gov.s - Economic transformation, more & better jobs (political survival?)

Commercial & development alignment?

ECDPM Page 8

Source: DIE, ECDPM, ODI – European Report on Development

Partnerships of necessity?

ECDPM Page 9

• The private sector is going there anyway…

Africa rising?

ECDPM Page 10

…but largely to mining and minerals…

What are…

• the main drivers and trends around business-CSO partnerships and the different roles that partners take;

• the main partnership characteristics that emerge as important in the process of establishing and maintaining effectivepartnerships

• the potential roles for donors aiming to support such partnerships.

Lots of interest in impact – whatabout process?

ECDPM Page 11

Drivers

ECDPM Page 12

B2B firms are less likely to engage in partnerships than B2C firms (Kolk et al., 2008)

• Objectives– finance vs reputational risk/ltd autonomy

• Roles - mutual support, advocacy, partnering, and service provision (Van Tulder and Pfisterer, 2013)

• Types: firms - FDI market seeking, resource seeking and efficiency seeking (Dunne, 1993)

• Types: CSOs - polariser/integrator; discriminator/non-discriminator

• Models: Fair Trade, ‘shared value’, BoPapproaches

• Context: Local institutional & governance structures “crucial” (Pattberg and Widerberg, 2014)

More partners, more complexity

ECDPM Page 13

• Relation to core business

• Degree of partner engagement

• Partnership activities

• Governance structures

Combining taxonomies: 4 dimensions

ECDPM Page 14

1. Relation to core business

ECDPM Page 15

Authors’ elaboration based on Austin (2000), Rondinelli and London (2003), Googins and Rochlin (2000), & Darko (2014)

2. Degree of partner engagement

ECDPM Page 16

Authors’ elaboration based on Tennyson et al. (2008), Dahan et al. (2010), and (Chevrollier et al., 2012).

3. Partnership activities

ECDPM Page 17

Authors’ elaboration based on Kindornay et al. (2013) and Reed and Reed (2009).

4. Governance structures

ECDPM Page 18

ECDPM Page 19

• Dairy cooperative partnership in Tanzania

• Dairy system improvement in Kenya

• Mining-civil society partnership in Port Dauphin, Madagascar

• Mining-palm oil partnership in W. Ghana

On-going case studies…

ECDPM Page 20

• What do we mean by partnerships?

• What is specific about the M&E of partnerships?

- Same as any other M&E? – how to cost effectively identify impact, additionality…

- Multi-purpose, multi-partner, multi-activity => what impact, what counterfactual

- Attribution – partnership or partners?- Politics, coalitions, interests, incentives may

define progress more than design

Back to the questions…

ECDPM Page 21

• Requirements for M&E to support and promote partnerships for the SDGs?

- clarity on what, why and how- part of internal governance & learning- focus on VA of the co-creation- shorten feedback loop

- build on private sector mechanisms..- …but build in development objectives- be flexible and adaptive

Implications for M&E

ECDPM Page 22

ECDPM Page 23

“Plan for sailboats, not trains”

(Kleinfeld, 2015)

Thank youwww.ecdpm.org

www.slideshare.net/ecdpm@brucebyiers

Page 24