Helping Arab learners to ‘get it right’

Helping Arab learners to ‘get it right’

Peter Lucantoni

Peter Lucantoni

• Started teaching in 1979 in UK, lived and worked in Europe and Middle East, now based in Cyprus

• Author, Educational Consultant & Teacher Trainer for Cambridge University Press

• Cambridge TKT, CELTYL, CELTA & DELTA trainer, and Cambridge CELTYL assessor

• Examiner for Cambridge ESOL speaking examinations

Overview

• How does L1 affect L2?• What are some of the characteristics

of Arab learners?• How can language corpus data help

teachers?• Teaching strategies• Conclusions

How does L1 affect L2?

• Learner’s L1 can affect learning English positively and negatively.

• How? – No close equivalent– Close equivalent– Non-exact equivalent

• Learner’s English ‘is therefore likely to carry the signature of his/her mother tongue [L1] …’

• (Learner English, eds. Swan & Smith, Cambridge University Press, 2001)

How does L1 affect L2?

• ‘While not all of a learner’s problems … are attributable to direct mother-tongue ‘interference’, the overall patterns of error do … tend to be language specific … ’

• (Learner English, eds. Swan & Smith, Cambridge University Press, 2001)

How does L1 affect L2?

• Bernard Smith says that teachers need help:• ‘to anticipate the characteristics of

learners of English who speak particular mother tongues, and to understand how these difficulties arise’

• (Learner English, eds. Swan & Smith, Cambridge University Press, 2001)

What are some of the characteristics of Arab learners?

• What are some of the characteristics of Arab learners?

• Work with your partner and try to list at least three

• Try to think of both positive and negative characteristics

• Put the characteristics into categories

What are some of the characteristics of Arab learners?

• Look at the writing samples from Arabic speakers on Handout 1• Work with a partner and answer

this question:o What typical and common errors do

you notice?

How can language corpus data help teachers?• What do you think are some of the

common writing errors made by Arab learners?

• According to the Cambridge Learner Corpus:

• Spelling• Wrong punctuation • Wrong preposition• Nouns & pronouns

How can language corpus data help teachers?

• Which words are most commonly misspelled by Arab learners?

• Make a list of words, along with an example of misspelling:

• because *becouse, *becaus, *becuse, *beacuse

How can language corpus data help teachers?According to the Cambridge Learner Corpus, these are common spelling errors made by Arab learners:

friend *frind, *freind

beautiful *beatiful, *beutiful

people *pepole, *peaple

different *diffrent

How can language corpus data help teachers?

• What teaching strategies do you currently use in order to help learners with spelling?

• Why are these strategies successful?

How can language corpus data help teachers?• Providing

opportunities for learners to see words in interesting and motivating contexts is an important step to recognising word boundaries and word spellings

English Unlimited Special Edition, A1, Adrian Doff, Cambridge University Press, 2014

Tasks

• Look at the same text on Handout 2

• Which words do you think would typically cause spelling problems for your learners?

• Think of some activities learners could do to focus on these problem words

Tasks

English Unlimited Special Edition, A1, Adrian Doff, Cambridge University Press, 2014

Differentiate right/wrong spelling

Correct wrong spelling

Using in context

• The biggest spelling problems for Arab learners: vowels, especially vowel doubling/clusters – quiet, because, friend, people, restaurant, beautiful, country, receive

• Also, misusing ‘mirror’ shapes: b/d, p/q; malformation of letters: o, a, t, d, g, and cursive linking

• Arabic students also struggle with more-or-less silent consonants, e.g. in should, which, and e on the end of words, e.g. there, before, like, please.

Spelling conclusions

• Arabic uses many fixed prepositions and particles

• Many do not correspond to English translations:

• *to arrive to, *in spite from• * I search my iPod, * She looks her

friend• [Adapted from: Learner English, Swan & Smith, Cambridge

University Press, 2001]

Prepositions

Prepositions

• Which prepositions do Arab learners commonly confuse?

• Make a list, along with examples :

• ‘in’ instead of ‘at’, for example:• *I can’t meet you in that time

How can a language corpus help teachers?

• What teaching strategies do you currently use in order to help learners with prepositions?

• Why are these strategies successful?

How can a language corpus help teachers?

• Providing opportunities for learners to see words in interesting and motivating contexts is an important step to recognising how to use them accurately

Tasks

Remembering examples from text

Sentence completion

Using in context

• Most common seven preposition errors concern combinations of just five words: in, at, on, for, to

• Focusing on usage and rules is key for Arabic-speaking learners

• Expressions ending in prepositions often avoided in favour of Arabic patterns: Who did you buy it for? >>>>> For whom did you buy it? Or *For who you bought it?

Prepositions conclusions

• Arabic verb forms incorporate pronouns• This leads to repetition in English:• *Ahmed he works there• [Adapted from: Learner English, Swan & Smith, Cambridge University

Press, 2001]

• Which other pronouns do Arab learners commonly confuse?

• *My family they will arrive next week• *I don’t know if Oman’s weather it will

be good

Nouns and pronouns

How can a language corpus help teachers?

• What teaching strategies do you currently use in order to help learners with pronouns?

• Why are these strategies successful?

How can a language corpus help teachers?• Providing opportunities

for learners to see nouns and pronouns in interesting and motivating contexts is an important step to recognising how to use them accurately, and in avoiding unnecessary repetition

Tasks

Remembering and selecting from text

Using in context

Sentence correction

• Most common repetition errors occur with it, you, he, they, I

• Practice needed in helping students understand the basic role of the pronoun it in a sentence: as replacement for the subject

• Noticing correct examples, and correcting wrong examples: a verb only needs one subject, either a noun or a subject pronoun

Nouns and pronouns conclusions

How does L1 affect L2?

• ‘While not all of a learner’s problems … are attributable to direct mother-tongue ‘interference’, the overall patterns of error do … tend to be language specific … ’

• (Learner English, eds. Swan & Smith, Cambridge University Press, 2001)

How does L1 affect L2?

• Bernard Smith says that teachers need help:• ‘to anticipate the characteristics of

learners of English who speak particular mother tongues, and to understand how these difficulties arise’

• (Learner English, eds. Swan & Smith, Cambridge University Press, 2001)

Any questions?

plucantoni@cambridge.org

www.cambridgeenglishteacher.org

http://www.facebook.com/CambridgeUniversityPressMiddleEast