Haman AAZV Final - Tufts Institute of the Environment€¦ ·...

!"#$%&'$!"#$%&'!'(%)(!$'!*+,!,%(-$*+%'!./!0$%./(!(1+'2'*(0'3!0+/.*+%./4!*#(!#($5*#!+6!*#(.%!,+,75$8+/'!9.55!,%+).-(!./6+%0$8+/!+6!+)(%$55!(1+'2'*(0!#($5*#:!!;(1(/*!1$'('!+6!',./$5!-(6+%0.*2!./!1$,8)(!'#$%&'!,./,+./*!*#(!6$1*!*#$*!9(!#$)(!5.0.*(-!-.$4/+'81!1$,$<.5.8('!6+%!'#$%&':!!=#.'!,%+>(1*!,%+).-('!-('1%.,8)(!./6+%0$8+/!+/!<$'(5./(!#($5*#!,$%$0(*(%'!6+%!$!*+*$5!+6!?@!'#$%,/+'(!A;!"#$%&"$'$($')*+&&,+'$-,+.!$/-!?B!<+//(*#($-!A/%!0&',)123&$.!'#$%&':!!C(!6+7/-!/+!'.4/.D1$/*!-.E(%(/1(!<(*9((/!*#(!9#.*(!<5++-!1(55!1+7/*!+6!<+//(*#($-!AFGHGIJ!1(55'KLMN!+%!'#$%,/+'(!AOPHGP?!1(55'KLMN:!!Q+//(*#($-!'#$%&'!#$)(!'.4/.D1$/*52!#.4#(%!#(0$*+1%.*!A,RJ:J?ON!$/-!*+*$5!'+5.-'!A,RJ:J?ON!*#$/!*#(!'#$%,/+'(:!!S(7*%+,#.5'!$%(!$5'+!6%(T7(/*52!(/1+7/*(%(-!./!<+//(*#($-!<5++-!<7*!/+*!'#$%,/+'(!<5++-:!!"#$%,/+'(!#$)(!'.4/.D1$/*52!#.4#(%!5()(5'!+6!(+'./+,#.5'!1+0,$%(-!9.*#!*#(!<+//(*#($-'!A,RJ:JJ?N:!!!U.*$0./!V!A,RJ:JJJN!$/-!W!A,RJ:JJJN!1+/1(/*%$8+/'!$%(!'.4/.D1$/*52!-.E(%(/*!<(*9((/!*#(!*9+!',(1.(':!!X/*(%('8/452H!*#(!,5$'0$!1+/1(/*%$8+/'!+6!).*$0./!V!$/-!W!./!<+*#!'#$%,/+'(!$/-!*#(!<+//(*#($-!$%(!071#!5+9(%!*#$/!*#(!1+/1(/*%$8+/'!6+7/-!./!1$,8)(!$/.0$5'!9.*#!',./$5!-(6+%0.8(':!!!=#.'!.'!'744('8)(!+6!,+''.<5(!).*$0./!*+Y.1.*2!./!1$,8)(!'#$%&':!!=#(%(!$%(!$5'+!'.4/.D1$/*!',(1.('!-.E(%(/1('!./!*#(!1+/1(/*%$8+/!+6!,5$'0$!1#%+0.70!A,RJ:JIBNH!1+<$5*!A,RJ:JJJNH!1+,,(%!A,RJ:JJJNH!'(5(/.70!A,RJ:JI?NH!$%'(/.1!A,RJ:JPFNH!'*%+/870!A,RJ:JJ?NH!$/-!'.5)(%!A,RJ:JJJN:!!!=#(!',(1.('!-.E(%(/1('!./!,5$'0$!1+/1(/*%$8+/'!+6!!).*$0./'!$/-!*%$1(!/7*%.(/*'!$%(!%(5$*(-!*+!*#(!6+%$4./4!#$<.*'!$/-!(1+'2'*(0!7'(!<2!*#(!<+//(*#($-!$/-!'#$%,/+'(!'#$%&':!!!!!

()&*$+,!##)##-).$#,/0,0%))1%&.23.2,!$*&.4',5+&%6./#),&.7,8/..)$+)&7,,5+&%9#,/:,$+),'/&#$,/0,;)/%23&,&.7,</%$+)%.,=*/%37&,

Z:![$0$/?!H!V:![7,,I!H!=:!S+%*+/I!H!\:!='(/4P!!?!=#(!]/.)(%'.*2!+6!^(+%4.$!_+55(4(!+6!U(*(%./$%2!`(-.1./(H!I!=#(!^(+%4(!"($!=7%*5(!_(/*(%H!P!=7a'!]/.)(%'.*2!_700./4'!"1#++5!+6!U(*(%./$%2!`(-.1./(!!

>)$+/7#,,!  "()(/*((/!'#$%,/+'(!A;:!*+&&,+'$-,+.!$/-!?G!<+//(*#($-!A/4)123&$N!9(%(!1$,*7%(-!+E!*#(!($'*!1+$'*!+6!^(+%4.$!$/-!\5+%.-$!./!b752!IJJc:!

!  Q+//(*#($-!$/-!'#$%,/+'(!9(%(!<5(-!).$!*#(!1$7-$5!)(./!9.*#./!P!0./7*('!+6!1+0./4!+/<+$%-:!!=#(!4.55'!9(%(!.%%.4$*(-!9.*#!'($!9$*(%!A\.47%(!?!$/-!IN:!Q5++-!9$'!1+55(1*(-!./!Wd=V!$/-!#(,$%./.e(-!*7<('!!f#2'.1$5!(Y$0'!9(%(!,(%6+%0(-!+/!$55!$/.0$5':!!_5+$1$5!'9$<'!9(%(!1+55(1*(-!6%+0!$/.0$5'!$/-!9(%(!,%+1(''(-!-7%./4!*#(!5$'*!PI!#+7%'!+6!($1#!1%7.'(:!!"9$<'!9(%(!175*7%(-!<2!XdWgg!9.*#./!FG!#+7%'!+6!1+55(18+/:!

!  Wd=V!<5++-!9$'!7'(-!*+!-(*(%0./(!="H!f_UH!CQ_H!$/-!*+!0$&(!<5++-!'0($%':!!_+0,5(*(!CQ_!1+7/*'!9(%(!,(%6+%0(-!7'./4!S$hi[(%%.1&'!'+578+/!0+-.D(-!6+%!(5$'0+<%$/1#!+'0+5$%.*2!9.*#./!@!#+7%'!+6!<5++-!1+55(18+/H!6+55+9./4!*#(!,%+*+1+5!'(*!6+%*#!./!V%/+5-!IJJO:!!

!  [(,$%./.e(-!<5++-!9$'!1(/*%.674(-H!*#(!,5$'0$!9$'!1+55(1*(-!$/-!'*+%(-!./!5.T7.-!/.*%+4(/!7/85!*%$/'6(%%(-!*+!i@J_!6%((e(%!+/'#+%(:!!"$0,5('!9(%(!'#.,,(-!*+!*#(!)$%.+7'!5$<'!6+%!,%+1(''./4!9.*#./!F!9((&'!+6!1+55(18+/:!

;)#?*$#!• ,V55!'#$%&'!,%+1(''(-!$,,($%(-!#($5*#2!+/!,#2'.1$5!(Y$0:!

• ,[(0$*+5+4.1$5!)$57('!$%(!,%('(/*(-!./!*$<5(!?:!!=#(!'#$%,/+'(!#$)(!'.4/.D1$/*52!5+9(%!#(0$*+1%.*!A,RJ:J?ON!$/-!*+*$5!'+5.-'!A,RJ:JIFN!*#$/!*#(!<+//(*#($-:!=#(!0+'*!$<7/-$/*!CQ_!6+%!<+*#!',(1.('!.'!*#(!520,#+12*(H!6+55+9(-!<2!*#(!4%$/75$*(-!*#%+0<+12*(:!!S(7*%+,#.5'!$%(!,%('(/*!./!*#(!<+//(*#($-!<7*!/+*!'#$%,/+'(!<5++-:!!"#$%,/+'(!#$)(!'.4/.D1$/*52!0+%(!(+'./+,#.5'!*#$/!*#(!<+//(*#($-!A,RJ:JJ?N:!!\.47%(!P!-(,.1*'!0+%,#+5+4.1$5!',(1.('!-.E(%(/1(':!

• !f5$'0$!).*$0./!V!A,RJ:JJJNH!M7*(./!A,RJ:JJBN!$/-!j($Y$*#./!A,RJ:J?FN!5()(5'!$%(!'.4/.D1$/*52!#.4#(%!./!*#(!'#$%,/+'(!1+0,$%(-!*+!*#(!<+//(*#($-:!!Q+//(*#($-'!#$)(!#.4#(%!,5$'0$!).*$0./!W!A,RJ:JJJN:!!X/*(%('8/452!/(.*#(%!',(1.('!#$)(!0($'7%($<5(!).*$0./!d!./!*#(.%!,5$'0$!A=$<5(!IN:!!!

• !f5$'0$!*%$1(!/7*%.(/*!1+/1(/*%$8+/'!$%(!,%('(/*(-!./!*$<5(!P:!!".4/.D1$/*!-.E(%(/1('!$%(!'((/!./!,5$'0$!5()(5'!+6!1#%+0.70H!1+<$5*H!1+,,(%H!'(5(/.70H!$%'(/.1H!'*%+/870H!$/-!'.5)(%:!

@3#'?##3/.,=#+74#!'*$8'81$5!-.E(%(/1('!$%(!'((/!<(*9((/!*#(!*9+!',(1.('k!#(0$*+1%.*!$/-!="!)$57('H!*#('(!$%(!'.0.5$%!*+!)$57('!,%().+7'52!%(,+%*(-!A_$./!(*!$5!IJJFH![$%0'!(*!$5!IJJIN:!!=#(!0+%,#+5+42!$/-!/70<(%!+6!CQ_'!'((/!./!$/.0$5'!./!*#.'!'*7-2!0$*1#!-('1%.,8+/'!./!*#(!5.*(%$*7%(!AV%/+5-!IJJON:!!X*!.'!/+*!2(*!&/+9/!.6!*#(!/(7*%+,#.5'!'((/!./!*#(!<+//(*#($-'!.'!$!1(55i*2,(!+%!%$*#(%!$/!$%86$1*!+6!,%('(%)$8+/:!

=#(%(!.'!$!5+9(%!,5$'0$!1+/1(/*%$8+/!+6!).*$0./!V!$/-!W!./!*#('(!9.5-i1$74#*!$/.0$5'!1+0,$%(-!9.*#!1$,8)(!$/.0$5'!Af%(e.+'.!(*!$5!IJJBNH!./-.1$8/4!,+*(/8$5!).*$0./!*+Y.1.*2!./!'+0(!1$,8)(!$/.0$5':!!!"20,*+0'!*#$*!$11+0,$/2!*#(!',./$5!-(6+%0.*2!+<'(%)(-!./!1$,8)(!$/.0$5'!./157-(!(/5$%4(-H!2(55+9.'#!5.)(%H!071+'$5!(%+'.+/'!./!*#(!'*+0$1#H!$/-!-.E7'(!#(0+%%#$4(!+/!*#(!./*('8/$5!071+'$!Af%(e.+'.!(*!$5!IJJBN:!!=#('(!'20,*+0'!$%(!1+/'.'*(/*!9.*#!).*$0./!V!$/-!W!*+Y.1.*2!'((/!./!0$00$5':!!!

=#(!-.E(%(/1('!'((/!./!*#(!/7*%.(/*!*%$1(!0./(%$5'!$%(!5.&(52!*#(!%('75*!+6!*#(!6+%$4./4!(1+5+42!+6!<+//(*#($-!1+0,$%(-!9.*#!*#(!'#$%,/+'(:!!=#(!-.(*!+6!<+//(*#($-!./157-('!,5$/*!0$*(%.$5H!1%7'*$1($/'!A'#%.0,H!1%$<N!$/-!1(,#$5+,+-!0+557'&'!9#.5(!*#$*!+6!*#(!'#$%,/+'(!.'!0+'*52!1+0,+'(-!+6!*(5(+'*'H!0+557'&'H!$/-!+*#(%!(5$'0+<%$/1#('!AQ(*#($!(*!$5!IJJ@H!Q(*#($!(*!$5!IJJFN:!!=#.'!-.'8/1*!6+%$4./4!(1+5+42!!+6!($1#!0$2!$5'+!(Y,5$./!*#(!',(1.('!-.E(%(/1('!./!,5$'0$!).*$0./!V!$/-!W!1+/1(/*%$8+/':!

\7*7%(!'*7-.('!9.55!6+17'!+/!*#(!1+/1(/*%$8+/!+6!).*$0./'!$/-!/7*%.(/*!*%$1(!0./(%$5'!./!*#(!,5$'0$!+6!9.5-i1$74#*!'#$%&'!./!+%-(%!*+!<(h(%!7/-(%'*$/-!A?N!#($5*#!./!1$,8)(!'#$%&'!$/-!AIN!6+%$4./4!$/-!#$<.*$*!7'(!+6!9.5-!'#$%&':!!!

!'9./A*)72-).$#,

=#.'!,%+>(1*!9$'!'7,,+%*(-!<2!$!=%$././4!^%$/*!6%+0!*#(!]"!V%02!`(-.1$5!;('($%1#!$/-!`$*(%.$5!_+00$/-!ACG?gC[iJBi?iBFJN!$/-!6%+0!=7a'!X/'8*7*(!+6!*#(!W/).%+/0(/*!\(55+9'#.,!V9$%-:!!X/!$--.8+/H!',(1.$5!*#$/&'!*+!*#(!1%(9!+6!*#(!BCD,8?**7/2!(',(1.$552!M./-'$2!f$%&(%:!!`.&(!V%-(/*H!^$(55(!Q5$/).55$./H!$/-!d%:!V5!"(4$%'!!+6!*#(!"_dS;!9(%(!./'*%70(/*$5!./!5+4.'81$5!'7,,+%*:!!d%:!Z.%'*(/!^.55$%-.!9$'!$5'+!./'*%70(/*$5!./!*#(!-()(5+,0(/*!+6!*#(!%('($%1#!,%+*+1+5:!!V!',(1.$5!*#$/&!2+7!*+!$55!*#(!'*$E!+6!*#(!^"=_H!b.55!V%/+5-H!d%:!`.&(!`7%%$2H!$/-!d%:!V5!d+)(:!!V/-H!5$'*!<7*!/+*!5($'*H!*#$/&'!*+!V=:!!!

E.$%/7?'4/.!• !Q+*#!*#(!<+//(*#($-!A/%!0&',)123&$N!$/-!'#$%,/+'(!A5!"#$%&"$'$($')*+&&,'$-,+N!$%(!+6!.0,+%*$/1(!1+00(%1.$552!$/-!$'!1$,8)(!$/.0$5'!./!$T7$%.$:!![+9()(%H!5.h5(!.'!&/+9/!%(4$%-./4!<$'(5./(!%(6(%(/1(!)$57('!6+%!1+0,%(#(/'.)(!#($5*#!$''(''0(/*'!A_$./!(*!$5!IJJFH![$%0'!(*!$5!IJJIN:!!!

• Q+//(*#($-'!$%(!*#(!'0$55('*!+6!*#(!#$00(%#($-!6$0.52!AQ.4(5+9!$/-!"1#%+(-(%!?cOPN:!!=#(!V*5$/81!'#$%,/+'(!.'!*#(!0+'*!1+00+/!'0$55!(5$'0+<%$/1#!+E!*#(!]"!1+$'*!AM+(6(%!$/-!"(-<(%%2!IJJPN:!!Q+*#!',(1.('!(Y#.<.*!&i'(5(1*(-!5.6(!#.'*+%.('!9.*#!'5+9!4%+9*#H!5$*(!0$*7%.*2H!$/-!-(1%($'(-!6(17/-.*2!A^7%'#./!$/-!"e(-50$2(%!IJJFN:!!=#(!,+,75$8+/!'*$<.5.*2!$/-!$<7/-$/1(!.'!17%%(/*52!7/&/+9/3!*#(%(!.'!$!/((-!*+!+<*$./!<$'(5./(!-$*$!%(4$%-./4!+)(%$55!#($5*#!+6!($1#!',(1.(':!

• !X*!.'!*#+74#*!*#$*!*#(!',./$5!-(6+%0.8('!'((/!./!"$/-84(%!'#$%&'!A6,&7!,&",8)*,3&38N!$%(!%(5$*(-!*+!/7*%.8+/$5!-.(*$%2!).*$0./!.0<$5$/1('!Af%(e.+'.!(*!$5!IJJBN:!!=#7'H!!/7*%.8+/$5!%(6(%(/1(!)$57('!6%+0!#($5*#2!9.5-!(5$'0+<%$/1#('!0$2!#(5,!.0,%+)(!-.$4/+'81!1$,$<.5.8('!$/-!$--%(''!*#(!7/&/+9/!(8+5+4.('!+6!',./$5!-(6+%0.8('!./!*#(!1$,8)(!'#$%&'!A[+(/.4!$/-!C(5'#!?cGPH!f%(e.+'.!(*!$5!IJJBN:!!!

• Q$'(5./(!#($5*#!-$*$!$%(!$5'+!7'(675!*+!$''(''!,+,75$8+/!#($5*#!+6!9.5-!',(1.('!+6!(5$'0+<%$/1#('!$/-!0+/.*+%!*#(!'.-(i(E(1*'!+6!(/).%+/0(/*$5!'*%(''+%'!+/!*#(!+)(%$55!'*$*7'!+6!*#('(!',(1.(':!!!!!

=32?%),F3!f.1*7%('!+6!*#(!9#.*(!<5++-!1(55'!./!<+//(*#($-!$/-!'#$%,/+'(!'#$%&':!!S+*(!*#(!,%('(/1(!+6!/(7*%+,.#5'!./!<+//(*#($-!<5++-!$/-!/+*!'#$%,/+'(:!!V5'+!/+*(!*#(!0$%&(-!-.E(%(/1(!./!*#(!4%$/75(!'.e(!$/-!1+5+%!./!*#(!(+'./+,#.5'!+6!'#$%,/+'(!A<.4H!<%.4#*!1+5+%N!$/-!<+//(*#($-!A,$5(H!'0$55(%!4%$/75('N:!!=#(!'#$%,/+'(!#(*(%+,#.5!.'!0+%(!(+'./+,#.5.1!*#$/!*#(!<+//(*#($-!#(*(%+,#.5:!!!

Figure 2: Bleeding a sharpnose shark.

Figure 1: Bleeding a bonnethead shark while irrigating the gills with sea water.

G&"*),HI,![(0$*+5+4.1$5!)$57('!6+%!9.5-i1$74#*!<+//(*#($-!A/R?BN!$/-!'#$%,/+'(!A/R?@N!'#$%&':!!]/5(''!+*#(%9.'(!/+*(-H!-$*$!$%(!./!l1(55'KLM:!!d.E(%(/8$5'!9(%(!1+/-71*(-!<2!Z:![$0$/!$*!*#(!^"=_:,

G&"*),JI,f5$'0$!1+/1(/*%$8+/'!+6!).*$0./'!$/-!M7*(./!(Y,%(''(-!./!LMK04:!j($Y$*#./!.'!04K0M:!!!=#(!)$57('!6+%!*#(!!-(6+%0(-!'#$%&!A/R?N!1+0(!6%+0!f%('e.+'.!(*!$5!IJJB:!!A/R?B!Q+//(*#($-H!/R?@!"#$%,/+'(N!!

G&"*),FI,f5$'0$!*%$1(!/7*%.(/*!1+/1(/*%$8+/'!6+%!<+//(*#($-!A/R?BN!$/-!'#$%,/+'(!A/R?@N!'#$%&':!!d$*$!$%(!(Y,%(''(-!./!,,0:!!",(1.('!-.E(%(/1('!1$/!<(!(Y,5$./(-!<2!-.E(%(/1('!./!6+%$4./4!#$<.*':!!=#('(!-$*$H!./!$--.8+/!*+!*#(!U.*$0./!VKW!,5$'0$!1+/1(/*%$8+/'!0.4#*!<(!7'(675!./!-()(5+,./4!',(1.D1!-.(*'!6+%!1$,8)(!(5$'0+<%$/1#(':!!

K3$)%&$?%),L3$)7,

V%/+5-!bW:!IJJO:![(0$*+5+42!+6!*#(!'$/-<$%!'#$%&H!_$%1#$%#./7'!,5+0<(7'3!'*$/-$%-.e$8+/!+6!1+0,5(*(!<5++-!1+7/*!*(1#/.T7('!6+%!!!(5$'0+<%$/1#(':!U(*:!_5./:!f$*#:!PF3!??Oi?IP:!

Q.4(5+9![Q!$/-!C_!"1#%+(-(%:!?cOP:!\.'#('!+6!*#(!^756!+6!`$./(:!C$'#./4*+/H!d_3!]"!^+)(%/0(/*!f%./8/4!mn1(3!FFiFO:!Q(*#($!d`H!M![$5(H!bZ!_$%5'+/H!W!_+%*('H!_V!`$/.%(H!$/-!b!^(5'5(.1#*(%:IJJ@:!^(+4%$,#.1!$/-!+/*+4(/.1!)$%.$8+/!./!*#(!-.(*!$/-!

!-$.52!%$8+/!+6!*#(!<+//(*#($-!'#$%&!6%+0!*#(!($'*(%/!4756!+6!`(Y.1+:!`$%!Q.+5:!?OI3!?JJci?JIJ:!_$./!dZH!_V![$%0'H!$/-!V!"(4$%':!IJJF:!f5$'0$!<.+1#(0.'*%2!%(6(%(/1(!)$57('!./!9.5-1$74#*!'+7*#(%/!'8/4%$2':!b:!j++!C.5-5.6(!`(-:!!

!PO3!F@?iF@B:!^7%'#./!_Cd!$/-!"=!"e(-50$2(%:!IJJF:!"#+%*i*(%0!'7%).)$5!$/-!0+)(0(/*'!+6!V*5$/81!"#$%,/+'(!'#$%&'!1$,*7%(-!<2!#++&i$/-i5./(!

!./!/+%*#($'*!^756!+6!`(Y.1+:!b:!\.'#:!Q.+5:!BO3!c@PicGB:![$%0'!_H!=!;+''H!$/-!V!"(4$%':!IJJI:!f5$'0$!<.+1#(0.'*%2!%(6(%(/1(!)$57('!+6!9.5-!<+//(*#($-!'#$%&':!b:!_5./:!f$*#:!P?3!???i??O:![+(/.4!b`!$/-!V[!C$'5#:!?cGP:!"&(5(*$5!5('.+/'!$/-!-(6+%0.8('!./!5$%4(!'#$%&':!b:!C.5-5.6(!d.'($'(:!?c3I@iPP:!!M+(6(!bZ!$/-!^;!"(-<(%%2:!IJJP:!M.6(!#.'*+%2!+6!*#(!$*5$/81!'#$%,/+'(!'#$%&!+E!*#(!'+7*#($'*(%/!]/.*(-!"*$*(':!\.'#!Q755:!?J?3!

!@OiGG:!f%(e.+'.!;H!"!^%.-(55.H!f!Q+%4#(oH!V!d.$/$H!V!f$%0(44.$/.H!`M!\.+%$)$/.8H!\!`$%1(%H!X!Q.$/1#.H!`!C$'5#H!$/-!X!Q(%e./':!IJJB:!",./$5!

!-(6+%0.*2!./!$!'$/-84(%!'#$%&3!$!15./.1$5i,$*#+5+4.1$5!'*7-2:!b:!\.'#!d.'($'(:!Ic3FciBJ:,,