View
214
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
i
Greenspace design for health and well-being
Practice Guide
Practice Guide
Greenspace design forhealth and well-being
Aileen Shackell andRobin Walter
Forestry Commission: Edinburgh
sustainablehealthcare
centre for
inspire • empower • transform
sustainablehealthcare
centre for
© CrownCopyright2012
Youmayre-usethisinformation(notincludinglogos)freeofchargeinanyformatormedium,underthetermsoftheOpenGovernmentLicence.Toviewthislicence,visit:www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licenceorwritetotheInformationPolicyTeam,TheNationalArchives,Kew,LondonTW94DU,ore-mail:psi@nationalarchives.gsi.gov.uk.
Firstpublishedin2011byForestryCommission,SilvanHouse,231CorstorphineRoad,EdinburghEH127AT.
ISBN978-0-85538-853-9
Shackell,A.andWalter,R.(2012). Greenspacedesignforhealthandwell-being. ForestryCommissionPracticeGuide. ForestryCommission,Edinburgh.i–vi+1–70pp.
Keywords:greenspace;healinggardens;healthcare;hospitalgardens;NHS;therapeuticlandscapes;trees;woodlands.
FCPG019/FC-GB(KA)/1.75K-ADR/FEB12
Enquiriesrelatingtothispublicationshouldbeaddressedto:
ForestryCommission 231CorstorphineRoad Edinburgh EH127AT
T:01313340303 E:publications@forestry.gsi.gov.uk
Theauthorscanbecontactedat:
E:aileen@asa-landscape.com E:robin@trees-for-transition.co.uk
If you need this publication in an alternative format, for example in large print or in another language, please contact the Forestry Commission Diversity Team at the above address.Telephone: 0131 314 6575 or email: diversity@forestry.gsi.gov.uk.
Acknowledgements
ThisprojectwasinitiatedbytheCentreforSustainableHealthcareandtheForestryCommission,andsteeredbyanAdvisoryGroup,whosememberswereRogerFrench,SharonHosegood,DianeMillis,MarcusSangsterandRachelStancliffe.Specialthanksareduetothenumerousindividualswhogavesogenerouslyoftheirtimetotheproject,inparticulartothosewhowereinterviewed,tookpartinsitevisits,orcommentedonthetextasitwasproduced.Photographsweretakenbytheprojectteam,unlessstatedotherwise.Researcher:JamesNewmarch.Illustrator:ValerieAlford.CoverillustrationbyRichardCarman.CourtesyofNIHG/LUC.
ii
Foreword
‘Green environments are healthy environments’. This is the message repeated again and again from healthcare research that points towards a positive relationship between greenspace and general health. Outdoor environments can have important restorative qualities that promote recovery from physical and mental stresses. Studies of ‘nature deficit disorder’ or ‘nature deprivation’ suggest that experiences of the outdoors (even views of greenery ‘borrowed’ through a hospital window) can have a therapeutic effect on ones’ social, emotional and mental functioning.
Some outdoor spaces are ‘salutogenic’, that is they reduce stress and encourage healthy behaviours. Whilst the particular reasons for this are not fully understood, various factors may – in isolation or combination – be important, including outdoor activity and exercise, natural daylight, stimulation of the senses, and the aesthetic experience. What we do know is that experiencing these natural environments – or helping to care for them – can improve the mental health and well-being of individuals and help to recharge their physical, mental and social capacities.
Nowhere is this relationship with the ‘natural health service’ more important than around healthcare facilities – particularly across the NHS estate. In supporting health and well-being outcomes National Health Service facilities should strive to make greater use of existing outdoor spaces by connecting them with the built environment. As we shift towards a more mutual NHS these largely untapped outdoor spaces should be recognised and utilised as an important healthcare resource in their own right: hence this guide Greenspace design for health and well-being.
In setting out best practice – backed up by case studies – this booklet provides a valuable guide to the design of accessible outdoor healing environments. It is equally applicable to new-build sites and refurbishments. It is relevant to the full range of healthcare settings, from the smallest health centre to the largest general hospital. It is also relevant to non-NHS settings such as schools, nursing homes and indeed everywhere where the promotion of health and well-being is important.
This Practice Guide will assist directors of facilities, estate managers, capital strategic planners, policymakers: in short everyone interested in health improvement and patient care, whether dealing directly with patients or managing grounds. By adopting this design guidance, NHS teams will be able to create, transform and revitalise their outdoor estates with respect to the human experience, encouraging greater use of the outdoors by patients, visitors and staff alike. These environments will provide a positive distraction from treatment and a therapeutic alternative to hospital buildings: quiet reflective spaces free from the clinical environment where patients can convalesce and recover in peaceful surroundings.
Alongside wards, waiting-rooms, and clinical departments, well-designed outdoor spaces are important environments that provide benefits for everyone. But as well as bringing social benefits, woodland and greenspace initiatives such as the NHS Forest in England and NHS Greenspace in Scotland can also bring organisational and environmental benefits too, helping healthcare facilities to meet good corporate citizenship responsibilities and performance measures, reduce carbon footprints and enhance opportunities for green prescription and outdoor recovery programmes.
By guiding NHS decision makers, Greenspace design for health and well-being will help to harness the full salutogenic potential of the NHS estate and bring the healing power of nature back into 21st century healthcare provision.
Sir Muir Gray Derek Feeley Director of the National Knowledge Service and Director-General Health and Social Care Chief Knowledge Officer to the National Health Service and Chief Executive NHS Scotland
iii
iv
Introduction 1Aholisticapproach 1Benefitsofwell-designedoutdoorspaces 1Aguideforpractitioners 1
Why is it important to take healing outdoors? 3Understandingthebenefits 3
Outdoorspacescanhostawiderangeofactivities 3Whyiscontactwithnaturecalming? 4Treesandwoodedspaceshaveaparticularroletoplay 5Healthbenefitsofnaturalsettings 6Healthcare:anartaswellasascience 8Casestudy1:ArgyllandButePsychiatricHospital,Lochgilphead,Argyll 9
What sort of spaces should we be designing? 11Designinghealingspaces 11
Creatingahealingenvironmentwiththewidersetting 11Creatingahealingenvironmentinthebuildingsurroundings 12Creatingahealingenvironmentingardenspaces 13Casestudy2:StCatherine’s,Rotherham,Doncaster,andSouthHumberNHSFoundationTrust,Yorkshire 14
Designprinciples 171.Valuewhatyouhavegot 182.Createspaceswhichfeelspecial 203.Maketheoutsideaccessible 224.Focusonpeople’sneeds 245.Connectwithnature 266.Balanceriskwithbenefits 287.Designforchange 30Summary 32Casestudy3:Maggie’sCancerCaringCentre,London 33
How do we put the theory into practice? 35Overcomingthechallenges 35
Privatefinanceinitiativeschemes 35Acutecare 36Olderpeople’scare 36Primarycare 37Casestudy4:CulmValleyIntegratedCentreforHealth,Cullompton,Devon 37
Gettingstarted:theprojectprocesssummarised 39Stage1:Preparation 40Stage2:Designandimplementation 41Stage3:Usingandmaintainingthenewspace 42Stage4:Monitoringandreview 42Casestudy5:SensoryGarden,theVerwoodOpportunityCentre,Dorset 43
Contents
v
Workingwithdesignelements 451.Planting 462.Trees 483.Entrances,pathsandboundaries–connectingthesite 504.Sitefurniture 525.Art 546.Water 56Summary 58Casestudy6:ChalkhillUnit,PrincessRoyalHospital,HaywardsHeath,Sussex 58
Feelinginspired?Howtogetstarted 60
Further reading and useful sources of information 62
Appendix 1: Researched sites 66
Appendix 2: Sample risk–benefit assessment for a community hospital 68
vi
Introduction
Aholisticapproach
Untilrelativelylateinthe20thcentury,outdoorspacesaroundmosthospitalswereverymuchpartofthehealingenvironment.Gardens,terraces,orchards,meadowsandevenhospitalfarmswereallcommonplaceandaccessibletopatients–particularlyinthefieldofmentalhealth.But,astimepassed,thebenefitsforpatientsofbeingabletospendtimeoutdoorsinthefreshairhavebeenincreasinglyoverlooked,astheemphasisoncreatingasterileenvironmentindoorshasdeveloped.Thishasfosteredaviewthatthehealingenvironmentwasrestrictedtotheinsideofhospitalbuildings,excludingthegardensandotherspacesaroundthem.
ThisGuidefocusesontheoutdoorspacesaroundalltypesofhealthcarefacilities.Itadvocatesaholisticapproachtotheirdesign,seeingbothindoorandoutdoorgreenspacesasequallyimportantforhealthandwell-being.Indoingso,itre-orientatesoutdoorspacesfirmlywithinthesphereofpatient-centredcare–withthe‘Planetreemodel’stipulatingthathealthcareenvironmentsshould‘fosteraconnectiontonatureandbeauty’.So,alloutdoorspacesshouldbepartofthehealingenvironment.
Benefitsofwell-designedoutdoorspaces
‘Peopleareentitledtothebestqualityofcare...attheendofthedaythereasonwhydesignmatterssomuchisthatwehavealimitedamountofresources,andbestpracticereducesthecostofcare.’(ProfessorJuneAndrews,DirectoroftheIrisMurdochDementiaCentre,2010)
Designingoutdoorspacestohaveatherapeuticfunctionrepresentsacost-effectiveapproach.Suchspacescanimprovepatientoutcomesandleadtoarangeofothercostsavings.Studiesshowthatpatientswhoarehappierwiththeirhealthcareenvironmentsareeasiertocarefor,andreturnhomesooner.Evidencealsoindicatesthat,wheretheenvironmentisimproved,betterstaffretentionresultsincostsavingsinrecruitmentandtraining,withrecruitmentbeingenhancedinthefirstplace.ThisGuidewilllookattheevidenceforthisinmoredetail,later.
Therearealsoorganisational,environmentalandsocialbenefits.Amorecreativeapproachtooutdoorspace,includingparticipatingininitiativessuchastheNHSForestinEnglandandGreenspaceinScotland,canhelphealthcarefacilitiesmeetperformancemeasures.Theremayalsobegainsforthemintermsofsustainabilityandcarbonreduction,especiallyinrelationtotreeandwoodlandplanting.
Aguideforpractitioners
TheKingsFundprogramme‘EnhancingtheHealingEnvironment’(EHE)hashelpedmanystaffbecomeengagedinprovidingbetterpatientcarethroughimprovedspaces,andthisGuideseekstobuildonsomeofthelessonswhichhavebeenlearnt.
Itisapplicabletonew-buildsitesandtorefurbishments,andtothefullrangeofhealthcaresettings–fromthesmallesthealthcentretothelargestacutehospital.Itwillassistseniormanagementteams,thoseengagedwithpolicy,andeveryoneinterestedinimprovingpatientcare–whethertheydealdirectlywithpatients(clinicalstaff,therapists,supportstaff )orfocusongroundsmanagement(facilitiesandestatemanagers,andpracticemanagers).
1
Itisalsorelevanttonon-NHSsettings,forexampleschools,nursinghomes,everywherewherethepromotionofhealthandwell-beingisimportant.
Well-designedoutdoorspacesareanintegralpartofthehealingenvironment,alongsidethewards,waitingroomsandclinicaldepartments,andprovidebenefitsforeveryone–patients,staffandvisitors.ThisGuidesetsouthow,andwhy,thisisso.
Inspring1994,theplaywrightDennisPotter,nearingtheendofhislife,describedthetreehecouldseefromhisbedroomwindow.
‘Theblossomisoutinfullnow...It’saplumtree,itlookslikeappleblossombutit’swhite,andlookingatit,insteadofsaying“Ohthat’sniceblossom”...Iseeitisthewhitest,frothiest,blossom-iestblossomthatthereevercouldbe...Thingsarebothmoretrivialthantheyeverwere,andmoreimportantthantheyeverwere,andthedifferencebetweenthetrivialandtheimportantdoesn’tseemtomatter.Butthenow-nessofeverythingisabsolutelywondrous...youhavetoexperienceit,thecomfortofit,thereassurance...’(DennisPotter,InterviewwithMelvynBragg,March1994)
Sensory aspects of the natural environment are especially engaging.
2
Understandingthebenefits
•Outdoorspaceisanimportantpartofthehealingenvironmentanditcanbeusedforawiderangeofactivities.
•Theorieshavebeendevelopedtoexplainthehealthbenefitsofnatureandthesehaveledinturntothedevelopmentofevidence-baseddesign.
•Treesandwoodedspaceshaveaparticularroletoplayinsupportinghealthandwell-being.
•Spendingtimeoutsidecanhelpimprovephysicalhealthandrecoverytimes,andconfersparticularbenefitsformentalhealth.
•Evidenceisimportant,buthealthcareisanartaswellasascience.
InthisGuide,theterm‘healing’or‘therapeutic’environmentorspacemeansaplacethathasbeendesignedorisusedinawaywhichpromotesthehealingprocess,orhelpstoinstilasenseofwell-being.
Thissectionfocusesonthehealthandwell-beingbenefitsfrombeingoutside,thoughtherearenumerousotherenvironmentalandeconomicbenefitsassociatedwiththecreationofgoodnaturalsettings.
Outdoorspacescanhostawiderangeofactivities
Activitiescanbeactive(includinghelpingwithgardeningorsimplegroundsmaintenance)orpassive(sittingunderatree).Theycanincludewalking,birdwatching,socialisingwithotherpatientsandfamily,andevenTaiChi.Playingoutsideisagreatwayforchildrenandyoungpeopletorelaxandletoffsteam,awayfromatiringmedicalenvironment,andtherapeutichorticultureinvolvingpracticalgardeningactivitieshasalonghistoryofuse.
Why is it important to take healing outdoors?
Staff and volunteers at a garden party at Helen House, Oxford.
Cou
rtes
y:H
elen
and
Dou
glas
Hou
se,O
xfor
d.
3
Clinicianscancarryoutone-to-onediscussionsduringwalksaroundthegroundswithpatients.Walkingsidebysideoutdoorsmightwellfeellessthreateningformanythanfacingsomeoneacrossadesk.
Inapeacefuloutdoorspacepeoplecansometimesmoreeasilystartto‘cometoterms’withbadnews,or,conversely,celebrategoodnews.TheQuietGardenMovementencouragespeopleofallfaiths(andnone)toenjoystillnessandreflectioninpeacefulgardenspaces.Thesebecomeoases,privatespacesforthinking,and,formanypeople,placesofspiritualrefreshmentandsupport.
Whyiscontactwithnaturecalming?
‘Thegardengivesyouthechancetorelax.Igetlostinthatgarden,suckedintothetreesandthebirdsinthesky.BeforeIwouldseethesethingsbutIdidn’tconnecttothem–itisanotherworld–Ihavelearnedtoappreciateit,anditdoessomethingtoyou,it’samazing.’(Patient,GlasgowHomoeopathicHospital)
Attentionrestorationtheory(ART)wasdevelopedbyRachelandStephenKaplanintheirbookTheexperienceofnature:apsychologicalperspective,andsincethenanumberofotherstudieshaveestablishedthatthisalsoholdstrueintermsofmedicaloutcomes.
Attentionrestorationtheoryproposesthatcomparedwith‘hard’indoororurbanenvironments,naturalenvironmentsaremoreefficientathelpingourbrainstorechargeandresumewhatistermed‘directattention’orfocusonaparticulartask.Increasedcontactwithnaturerestoresourbrainsfromfatigueandreducesimpulsivebehaviour,irritabilityandaggression.InherpaperonHealingGardensinHospitals,writerandacademicClareCooperMarcusstatesthatnatureengagesattentionwithoutdemandinganyeffort,becauseithastheeffectof‘awakeningthesenses,calmingthesenses,reducingstress,andassistingapersontomarshaltheirownhealingresources’.
At Harbour House residential home in Dorset, the front lawn has been turned into a well-used space by the addition of croquet hoops. Residents help themselves to balls and mallets when ever they want to play and combine socialising with staying physically active.
The scent of flowers.
Party in the garden.
4
Contactwiththeoutdoorscanalsobestimulating,aswellascalming.Theco-ordinatoroftheCreativeSpacesProjectinCornwall,whichenablespeoplewithdementiatoenjoyoutdoor-relatedactivities,commentedthat,‘timeandtimeagainwefindthatspendingtimeoutsideincreasespeople’scommunicationandstimulatesmemories,peoplejustsparkle’.
Thereisagrowingbodyofevidence,muchofitrootedinscientificresearch,thatbeingoutdoorsinanaturalsetting,orevenjustviewingtheoutdoorsfrominside,ishighlybeneficialforhealthandwell-being.ThisisincreasinglyinformingthedesignofhealthcarefacilitiesintheUK,inanapproachtermedevidence-baseddesign(EBD).Thisapproachisalsoinformedbyarelativelynewfieldofstudy,environmentalpsychology,whichseekstounderstandtheinterrelationshipbetweenenvironmentsandhumanbehaviour.
Treesandwoodedspaceshaveaparticularroletoplay
Woodlandsareespeciallyrestorativeenvironments;thesounds,sightsandsmellsinawoodplayaroleinreducingstressbyprovidinginterestandstimulatingthesenses.
Woodlandsprovidearichsensoryexperience,fromthesubtleshiftsintemperaturethatoccurbetweenareasinheavyshade,andinsunnyglades,tothescentofpineneedlescrushedunder-foot.Awoodlandsettinghasparticularacousticqualities,meaningthequietestbirdsongisaudible.Theageofveterantreesofteninspiresaweinpeopleandprovidesalinkbetweenthepast,presentandfuture.Woodlands,andindividualtrees,areseenasrepresentingnature,particularlyintheurbanenvironment.
5
Healthbenefitsofnaturalsettings
Thehealingpowerofnature,freshair,sunlightandexercisehaveallbeenafeatureofhealthcareforcenturies,butthepost-warperiodhasbeencharacterisedbyamoveawayfromnature,andtowardsagreaterrelianceontechnology.Recentdecadeshaveseenareversalofthistrendandasubstantialbodyofevidencenowexists,includingmanyliteraturereviews,whichdemonstratesthehealthbenefitsofcontactwithnature.DetailsofsomeofthesecanbefoundintheFurtherreadingsectionattheendofthispublication.
Asidefromtheobviousopportunitiesforphysicalexercise,whichinthemselveswillbenefitmostpeople,themainbenefitsrelevanttothehealthcareenvironmentcanbesummarisedas:
Reductionofpainandstress
•Contactwithnaturecanreducebloodpressure,muscletensionandpulserate,andcanalsohaveasubtleeffectonourexperienceofpain.
•Patientsandfamilieswhousehospitalgardenshavereportedpositivemoodchangesandreductioninstress.Evenvisualsettingswhere‘nature’isprominentreducestressandimprovepatientoutcomes–especiallywherestressisaccompaniedbyfeelingsofanxiety.
•Areductioninstressinturnenablestheimmunesystemtofunctionmoreeffectively,facilitatingthehealingprocess.
Alleviationofdepression
•Depressionisaseriousissuenotonlyforthosewithmentalhealthpatients,butalsoforthosewithcardiovasculardiseaseandcancer.Researchindicatesthatexposuretodaylightiseffectiveinreducingdepression,evenforthosehospitalisedforseveredepression.
•Simplywalkinginnaturalsettingscanhelpmentalhealthpatientsimproveself-esteem,vigourandmood,andreducetension.
•Practicing‘mindfulness’inanaturalsettingcanbeparticularlybeneficalformentalhealth.
View onto garden from the inside of Chalkhill Unit.
6
Reductionofaggressivebehaviour
•Restorativecontactwithnaturecanreduceirritabilityandtherebyaggressivebehaviour.
•Studiesfocusingonolderpeoplewithdementiaandonchildrendiagnosedasbeingontheautisticspectrumhaveshownthatboththesegroupsfindcontactwithgardens,andnatureingeneral,calming.
Increasedpatientsatisfaction
•Thosemostlyconfinedindoorsparticularlybenefitfrombeingoutsideinthefreshairandsunshine.
•Naturalsettingscanenhancetheplayandlearningactivitiesofyoungerpeople.
Improvedrecoveryrates
•Studieshavedemonstratedthatpatientswhohavecontactwithnature,evenwherethisissimplyaviewthroughawindow,recovermorequicklyfromoperativeprocedures.
•Patientsinintensivecareunitswithmyocardialinfarctionexhibitedshorterstayswhensitedinroomswithhigherdaylightexposure.
Improvedstaffperformanceandretention
•Gooddesignofhealthcarefacilitieshasbeenfoundtoimprovestaffperformance,recruitmentandretention.
•Post-occupancyevaluationsoftheoutdoorsinUShospitalshaveconsistentlyshownthatthestaffaretheprimaryusersofoutdoorspaces.
The staff garden at Newham Hospital provides an area for lunch as well as a venue for birthday and other celebrations.
7
Healthcare:anartaswellasascience
Inmakingthecasefortherapeuticuseofoutdoorspaces,theevidencebaseisimportant.However,manypeoplealsoseehealthcareasanartaswellasascience,andencourageaccesstooutdoorspacesaspartoftakingamorecreativeapproachtopatientcare.
Thegrowingevidencebaseforthesebenefitsisoftensupportedbytheobservationsofclinicians.AtthenewChalkhillUnit,wheretheinteriorisinspiredbyaspectsofthesurroundinglandscape,stafffeelthatpatientsrecovermorequicklyfromillnessthanwasthecaseintheirpreviousbuilding,whichhadnoaccesstotheoutdoors.
Thisapproachacknowledgesthelimitationsinourunderstandingofthedetailedworkingsofthehealingprocessandembracestherestorativepowersofnature–evenwhentheevidenceisonlyanecdotal.
AuserofthegardenatthenewMaggie’sCancerCaringCentreinLondonillustratedthiswell.
‘Thegardenwillallowpeopletobethemselvesandhavetheirownspacewithouthavingtospeaktoanyoneandsometimesthat’smorevaluablethananymedicine:onecantakecouragefrombeinginagoodplace,breathingincourageandbreathingoutfear.’(CathKnox,WestLondon,withsecondarycancer)
At Maggie’s Centre in London the building is surrounded by quiet, peaceful garden areas.
8
Practisingmindfulnessinawoodlandsetting
In2003apartnershipcomprisingReforestingScotland,theNHS,ArgyllGreenWoodworkers’Association,theScottishAssociationforMentalHealthandLochgilpheadCommunityCouncilwasformedtorestoreneglectedwoodsnexttotheArgyllandButeHospital.Fundswereraisedfromarangeofsources,includingScottishNaturalHeritage,theScottishMentalHealthDepartment,ForestryCommissionScotlandandLeader.Workbeganin2004andinvolvedmanyusersofmentalhealthservices,disabledpeople,youngpeople,contractorsandvolunteers.
BlarbuieWoodlandwasopenedasapublicparkin2007,withaccessiblepaths,facilitiesandinterpretationforquietrecreationaswellasmoreenergeticwoodlandmanagementactivities.Thereareopportunitiestolearnnewskills,includingnurserywork,forestry,timberprocessing,woodworkingandconstruction,andthewoodalsohostsartandmusicprojects.
Keydesignfeatures
Thethresholdarchandsignagewelcomesvisitorsintothewood,indicateswheretheycango,andaccessisprovideddirectlyfromthecarpark.Theprojectmakesgooduseof‘borrowedlandscape’,withspectacularviewsavailablefromthesiteoutacrosstheloch,aswellasaccesstothehillsbehind.
Case study 1: Argyll and Bute Psychiatric Hospital, Lochgilphead, Argyll.
A wide variety of art and craft activities take place on site out in the fresh air.
Routes through the woods take good advantage of views of the hills and loch.
9
Healthbenefits
Clinicians’ view
‘ForpeoplewhomIrefer,Ithinkalotofthebenefitisafeelingofachievementinactuallydoingsomeworkinthewoods,seeingthebenefitsoftheirwork.There’scertainlythebenefitofexercise;there’sthebenefitoffreshair;there’sthebenefitofworkingwithothersonaproject.’
Oneparticularthemeisthepromotionof‘mindfulness’inpatients–appreciatingthepresentmomentwithoutanxietyaboutthepastorfuture.Formanypatientsinthishospitalwithmentalhealthproblems,cultivatingmindfulnessisanessentialskilltolearn.Cliniciansdescribehowhelpfulthewoodlandsettingwas:
‘Ithinkwhat’sniceaboutthewoodsisthepeacefulnessofwalkingandthebigtreesandthenature,andbeinginaplacewhereyoucanpracticemindfulness,awareness.
Peoplehavealotofconcernsandanxieties...maybeyoucouldbeinaquietroominaquietward,butifyou’vegotabusyheadit’shardtorelaxandbegrounded,soIthinkitdoeshelptogooutintoawoodlandarea,andfocusonlike,otherthingslikethenature,likethetrees...andjusttohelpemptythehead,empty...’
Patient’s view
‘WellIcomeuphereandIliketojustexperienceonewith...nature.IdoreallyfeelonenesswithnaturewhenIcomeuphere,Ijustsitinthewoodsandjusttalkwiththebirds...IquiteliketowhistlebacktothemandtheywhistleatmeandIwhistlebackandtheywhistleagain...it’sgoodforthewell-being,it’sdefinitelyimprovedmylife,yeah.
IthinkI’malotmoreconfidentinwhatIdo,andI’malotmoreconfidentinwhatIsaytopeople.It’sgoodtomeetalotofpeopleindifferentaspectsinthewoodaswell.’
All-weather paths make the wood accessible to a wide range of people, with opportunities for both quiet solitude and socialising.
10
Designinghealingspaces
Allofthedifferentpartsofasitecanhaveatherapeuticpurpose:
•thewidersetting;
•theareasaroundandclosetothebuilding;
•thegardenspaces.
Theabilitytolocateabuildingtotakeadvantageofaview,ortoarrangeasiteinawaywhichprioritisespedestrianovervehicleaccess,aretremendousopportunitiesinanydevelopment.
Innewfacilities,thiscanbeplannedfromtheoutset,withthevalueofexternalspacesbeingrecognisedwithinthebusinesscaseforthedevelopmentasawhole.Forexample,atGlasgowHomoeopathicHospital,thebuildingwasdesignedsothat‘patientcare’spaceshaveadirectviewandconnectiontonatureandareseparatedfromnoisyareas,whilestaffareasarelocatedtothenorthandeastofthebuildingtoavoiddirectsunlightduringworkinghours.
Improvementofexistingfacilitiesrequiresamoreincrementalapproach,basedonanappraisalofthesiteasawhole,itsstrengths,weaknessesandopportunities.Evenonthemostchallengingofsitestherearealwaysimprovementsthatcanbemade,asthesketchexampleswhichfollowshow.
Thinkingaboutthreedifferentaspectsofanysitecanhelpidentifyitspotentialtherapeuticvalue.Theseaspectsare:
•thewidersetting;
•theareasaroundandclosetothebuilding;
•gardenspaces.
Astrategyormasterplanwillhelptoensurethatthesethreecategoriesofspaceareallwellconnectedwithpathstomakeacoherentsitelayout.
Creatingahealingenvironmentwiththewidersetting
Carefulthoughtshouldbegivenwhenlocatingnewfacilities,toensurethatthewidersettingispartofthehealingenvironment.Inthecaseofanexistingbuilding,onemayneedtobecreativeaboutitsuse.
Sometimes,andespeciallyoncrampedurbansites,accesstotheoutdoorsisrestrictedtoaviewofthewidersettingandinthesesituationsitwillbeessentialtomakethemostofit–perhapssimplyrearrangingadayroomtolookoutofthewindowtothelandscapebeyond.Manyin-patientsmaybeconfinedtobedandenjoymentofsunlightandanaturalviewcangreatlyenhancetheirstay,andpossiblyacceleratetheirrecovery.
Onmorespacioussitesitmaybepossibletoconnectwiththesurroundinglandscapebyframingviewsandlinkingpaths.TheroutearoundSalisburyDistrictHospitalconnectswithnearby
What sort of spaces should we be designing?
11
footpaths,andstaffareencouragedtousethispathcircuitintheirbreaks.InScotland,wherethereiswiderpublicaccesstoopenspace,theNHSestatehasgreatpotentialtobecomeavaluableresourceforthewholecommunity.
Creatingahealingenvironmentinthebuildingsurroundings
Thepatient’sexperiencestartsoutsidethebuilding,andtheirinitialimpressionofitplaysabigpartintheirperceptionoftheservice,aswellasinfluencingthelevelofstressexperiencedinattending.
Withcarefuldesign,spacesroundthebuildingsuchascarparksandentrancescanandshouldenhancethepatient(orvisitor)experienceconsiderably–eventhoughtheymaynotbespecificallydesignatedfortherapeuticuse.Well-designedsurroundingsareeasytonegotiate,meaningthatthejourneyfromsiteentrancetothewardorwaitingroomisaspleasant,well-signedandrelaxedaspossible.
A break away from the ward, enjoying a chat in the sunshine.
Tree and hedge planting would help make this bleak road on an urban hospital site more of a pedestrian environment, rather than one simply focused on traffic and car parking.
Above:Existing view.Right:How the improved area could look.
Large specimen trees give scale and provide a better setting for the taller buildings nearby
Edible hedge of mixed native shrubs – plums; damsons; elder; blackthorn
Cars hidden behind new hedge planting
12
Creatingahealingenvironmentingardenspaces
Gardenspacesarepredominantlynaturalincharacterandcancontainlotsofplanting.Theyrangeinscalefromtheverylargetotheverysmall,andfromformalherborphysicgardens,throughtoorchardsandmoreextensivelawnswithspecimentrees.
Gardenspacesnexttobuildingsofferthegreatesttherapeuticpotential.Proximitytowardsorwaitingroomsisabsolutelyessentialtoencouragenotonlyindependentaccessbutalsostaff-assistedaccess–anurseorplayassistantismuchmorelikelytotakeachildintoagardenaccessedfromthewardthanonethatrequiresatripawayfromit.
Somebuildingshavehiddencourtyardandroofgardenspaces,whichmayhavestrongpotentialintermsofproximityandaccessibility,aslongasthereisadequatesignagewithinthefacilitytoalertpeopletotheirpresence.Thesespacesarealwaysworthexploringasapriorityfordevelopmentasahealingenvironment.Moreremoteopenspacesonthesitemaybetoofarawaytobeeasilyreachedandwellused.
GreatOrmondStreetHospitalislocatedonaveryconstrainedsiteincentralLondon,withalmostnooutdoorspaceatall,sothenewstaffgardentherewasconstructedontheroof.ThegardencanbehiredforeventssuchasbirthdaypartiesandshelterfromthewindisprovidedbyglazedpanelswhichstillallowpanoramicviewsoftheLondonskyline.
Great Ormond Street Hospital roof garden and commemorative inscription to a previous member of staff.
13
Seating against chapel wall looking onto trees
Birch trees set in spring bulbs Raised planter with
scented shrubs
Acreativeapproachtoexternalspacesacrossthesite
StCatherine’sMentalHealthTrustHeadquartersislocatedinaGradeIIListedbuildingsetinaparklandsiteontheoutskirtsofDoncaster.OriginallythehomeofaVictorianindustrialist,thebuildingissurroundedbyalargenumberofnewerbuildings,offeringawiderangeofsettingsforthosewithmentalhealthproblems.
Case study 2: St Catherine’s, Rotherham, Doncaster, and South Humber NHS Foundation Trust, Yorkshire
Adult Mental Health Unit garden.
Cou
rtes
y:R
DaS
HN
HS
Foun
datio
nTr
ust.
With new seats and some extra planting, this unpromising area outside the chapel could become a ‘Quiet Garden’ at Charing Cross Hospital, London.
Above:Existing view.Right:How the improved area could look.
14
Thewidersetting
TheEnvironmentManagerisdevelopingaproposalforopeningupanewfootpathlinkthroughthehospitalgrounds,whichwillconnecttheproposedhousingdevelopmentnexttothesitewithanimportantlocalnaturereserve,PotterickCarr.Thisnewroutewillprovideacircular‘greenway’aswellasawildlifecorridorforthebirdsinthenaturereserve.
Benefits:
•Biodiversitybenefitsforthesiteandthewidersetting.
•BenefitsforthepublicprofileoftheTrust.
•IncreasedpotentialfordevelopingaHealthyWalksprogrammeforthelocalcommunity.
Thebuildingsurrounds
Theparklandischaracterisedbyoutstandingtreesandwoodland.Thisiscurrentlybeingaugmentedbynewplanting,aspartoftheNHSForestinitiative,tohelpscreenneighbouringdevelopmentandprovideextraprivacyforthoseusingthegrounds.Workwillincludeextendingtheexisting‘redpathnetwork’,whichpatientsusetoidentifysafewalkingroutesroundthesite.Thenewpathwillalsobeavailableforlocalresidents,aswellasstaffonsite–therearealreadyseveralgroupsofstaffwhoregularlycompletecircuitsofthesiteatlunchtime.
New NHS Forest planting will complement existing mature trees and also screen neighbouring development.
Staff, visitors and certain patient groups have free access to the parkland surrounding the hospital buildings.
15
Benefits:
•Trustbetterintegratedwithinlocalcommunity,resultinginabetterunderstandingofmentalhealthissuesandincreasedaccesstotheTrustsiteforlocalresidents.
•Longerwalkingrouteforpatientsandincreaseinexercisebeingtaken.
•Increasedbiodiversityandamenityfromadditionaltrees.
Thegardenspaces
Thegardenattachedtothenewlow-secureCusworthandBrodsworthwards,andthemedium–securePsychiatricIntensiveCareUnit(PICU)isaccessible‘ondemand’tothein-patientsthere.Theimpactofthestandard3mhighfencingenclosingthespaceismitigatedbycolourfulherbaceousplantingandthereisplentyofseatingtoencouragepeopletospendtimeoutside.Thehistoricwalledgardennowhousesahorticulturaltherapyproject,wherelocalresidentscanbuyplants.
Benefits:
•Freeaccesstotheoutdoorshelpsrestoreasenseofcontrolforpatients,especiallyimportantforthosedetainedagainsttheirwill.
•Anattractiveviewofanaturalenvironmentisbeneficialevenforthosewhorarelyventureoutdoors.
•TheretailaspectoftheWalledGardenProjectstrengthensconnectionswiththelocalcommunity.
TheEstatesbudgetiscontributingfundstotheseimprovementsinthegrounds.InitialNHSForestplantingcost£5000(withadditionalWoodlandTrustsupport)butanadditional£24000isnowbeingaddedtoaBigLotteryGranttomakeatotalofalmost£250000forasecondphaseofwork.Thiswillimproveaccesstothewoodlandandincludeengagementwiththelocalcommunitytorecruitateamofvolunteerstocreateandmaintainpaths,assistwithwoodlandmanagementandpotentiallyeventransformthesiteintoa‘greengym’.
The historic walled garden houses a social enterprise project, where service users develop new skills in horticulture, helping them to return to employment.
Enclosed courtyard, Psychiatric Intensive Care Unit, Skelbrook Ward.
Cou
rtes
y:R
DaS
HN
HS
Foun
datio
nTr
ust.
16
Designprinciples
Thedesignprinciplessetoutinthissectionprovideachecklistforanyoneimprovingexistingspacesorcreatingnewones:
1. Valuewhatyouhave2. Createplaceswhichfeelspecial3. Maketheoutsideaccessible4. Focusonpeople’sneeds5. Connectwithnature6.Balanceriskwithbenefits7.Designforchange
Designingoutdoorspacesfortherapeuticpurposesmeansconsideringanumberoffactors.Howwillthespacebeused?Isiteasilyaccessible?Arethereparticularclinicalneedstoconsider?Whatabouthealthandsafety?
Thedesignprincipleswhichfollowhavebeendevelopedprimarilytoprovideaframeworkforpeoplewithoutadesigntraining,tobegintothinkthroughtheelementsofanindividualproject,andtotacklesomeofthequestionslistedabove.Theyarenotintendedtocovereveryaspectofdesign,buttoprovideanintroductiontothesubject.Theyhavebeenformulatedtoreflectwhatismostimportantandrelevanttohealthcaresettings.
Theprinciplesareintendedforspaceswhichwillhaveapredominantlytherapeuticfunction,andareapplicabletobothgardenspacesclosetobuildingsandtothefurtherreachesofasite,aswellastonewfacilitiesattheplanningstage,andexistingfacilitiesbeingimproved.
Mostprojectswillrequireinputfromadesignprofessional.Theroleofthedesignerwillbetodesignaschemesothatitisfitforpurpose.Mostdesignerspreparedetaileddrawingsandspecificationsforthosewhowillactuallyconstructthenewgarden,althoughsomelandscapegardenersorcontractorsalsooffera‘designandbuild’service.
Itisalwaysadvisabletoemployadesignerwhohashadsomeformaltraininginthisfield,ratherthanusinganarchitectorinteriordesignerwhomaynothaveexperienceindesigningoutdoorspaces.
Garden designersmaybeabletotacklesmallerspacessuccessfullyandtheycanoftenofferparticularexpertiseinplantingdesign,whichshouldbeamajorelementinanytherapeuticspace.Landscape architectsshouldbeemployedonlarger,morecomplexschemes.Thoughtheysharemanyskillswithgardendesigners,theyareoftenmoreusedtoworkinginthepublicdomainandcantakefullresponsibilityfordesigningbothhardandsoftlandscapeelements.
Designprofessionalsworkingtocreatea‘therapeuticoutdoorspace’shouldalsofindthedesignprinciplesoverleafhelpful.Even someone without any design training who is interested in making the outdoor space part of the healing environment can help develop a worthwhile project.
17
1.Valuewhatyouhave
Healthcarefacilitiesareofteninastateoffluxastheydeveloptomeetchanginghealthneeds.Thereisconstantpressurefornewbuildingsoradditionalcarparks,andevennewhousing,andopenspacemayseemtheobviousplacetoputthem.
TheHippocraticOath‘First,donoharm’isagoodguidingprinciplefordevelopingoutdoorspaces.Byvaluingwhatisalreadythere,andunderstandingthebenefitsthatopenspaceprovides–mostimportantly,theveryspecialtherapeuticbenefits,thecaseforsafeguardingopenspacegrowsstronger.
Howdoyou‘value’whatyouhave?
Tovalueanexistingspaceitisessentialtounderstandtwothings:whatyou’vegot,andhowitisalreadyused.Maybethereisalreadyspaceonthesiteforrecreationbutpeopledonotknowaboutit,ortheremightbethingsaboutitwhichareputtingpeopleoff,forexamplelitterorovergrownvegetation.Sometimessomesimplehouse-keepingisallthatisneededtoencouragepeopletouseanarea.
Well-designedfacilitiesarecarefullyplannedtopreserveandenhancekeysitefeaturessuchasimportanttreesorprotectedspecies.Takingamaster-planningapproachandlocatingnewbuildingsfollowingadetailedanalysisandappraisalofthesite,ratherthanlocatingtheminanopportunisticway,willalwaysgivebetterresults.
Sometimestheopportunitiesarehardtoidentify,asatNinewellsHospital,Dundee.
NinewellsHospitalwaslocatedinanelevatedpositiontotakeadvantageofthepanoramicviewsovertheTayestuary.However,accesstotheoutdoorsforpatientshas,untilnow,beenlimitedtothesmall‘freshair’gardenclosetotheentrance.
Alandscapearchitectwasappointedtodevelopamasterplanforthewholesite,withthehelpofForestryCommissionScotland.Thesiteappraisalshowedthatoneofthebestopportunitiesforaccesswasthewoodedparklandtothesouthofthesite.Ithadthepotentialtobeusedbymoremobilelong-staypatients,aswellasstaffandvisitors,andthesurroundingcommunity.
Theconstructionofanetworkofcycleandfootpathsthroughthehospitalgroundsisnowunderway.Newseating,restareasandinterpretativeinformationwillencouragegreaterexplorationofthewoodland,andmakethemostoftheviewsovertheRiverTay.
Aerial view of Ninewells Hospital in Dundee.
18
Thethreefirststeps
Step 1: A site appraisal/analysisbyasustainabilitymanagerorfacilitiesmanagementteam,withtheinvolvementofaclinicianwhohasknowledgeofthepotentialbenefitsforpatientcare.Wherearetheopportunities?Arethereparticularstrengthsandweaknesses?Inputintothesiteappraisal,intermsofhealthpromotion,fromtheNHSoreventhelocalauthoritywouldalsobehelpful.
Step 2: TheTrustteamwillneedtoset out and adopt a policyregardingtheroleofopenspacewithinthewiderpatientcareenvironment.Supportofseniormanagementteams,includingtheChairandChiefExecutive,andthemaintenancestaffisessential.Thepolicyshouldincludethebusinesscasefortherapeuticuseofopenspaceacrossthesite.Cross-referenceshouldbemadetootherdrivers,suchaslocalTrustorBoardperformancemeasures,andnationalinitiativessuchastheNHSForestprojectorNHSGreenspaceinScotland.
Step 3:Anaction plantoprioritiseimprovementsandpotentialfundingsources.Atthisstageadditionaldesignsupportfromalandscapearchitectislikelytobeessential,particularlywithlarger-scalespacesormorecomplexsites.
A master plan for the site was prepared by a landscape architect.
New paths around the hospital grounds.
Red squirrels may be returning to the woods at Ninewells.
19
2.Createspaceswhichfeelspecial
Senseofplace
Oneofthemostimportantprinciplesinlandscapedesignisthatdesignshouldalwaysbespecifictoitslocation.Workingwiththesitewillenhancethesenseofplace,andmayevenmakeitcheapertodevelop.
ThepoetAlexanderPopewroteaboutdesigningwithnatureand‘senseofplace’–inotherwords,workwithnature,andworkwiththesite.Thiswillentailanalysingitscharacter,itsstrengthsandweaknesses,consideringopportunities,celebratingandenhancingthefamiliarinthelocality,anddesigningtodelight.Inthiswaythesitewillcomfortandstimulate,beenjoyedandtreasured,andbeaplacewherepeoplewanttospendtime.
Spaceswhichfeellike‘places’willbewellused
Theaimistocreatespacesthatareplacesintheirownright,withastrongcharacter,whichwillhelptoensurethataspacewillbewellused.InScotland,the‘GoodPlaces,BetterHealth’frameworkpromotesthehealthbenefitsofwell-designedspaces.Itrecognisesthatpoorenvironmentsmayfosterhopelessnessandstressanddiscouragehealthybehaviour,whereasthecreationofpositivephysicalenvironmentsmaynurturebetterhealthandwell-being.
Specialfeaturesshouldbeprotectedandincorporatedinthedesignwherepossible.Trees,includingfruittrees,areespeciallyhelpfulinestablishingasenseofplace,oftencombiningadistinctiveappearanceorcharacterwithanincreasingsenseofantiquityastheymatureintovenerablespecimens.
Pine trees at Chalkhill have inspired the design of the interiors.
Adding a tree to this dull courtyard will make it feel more like a place, even inviting on a warm autumn evening.
Above:Existing view.Right:How the improved area could look.
A specimen tree provides a new focal point for the courtyard and makes it feel like a place in its own right
The new tree should be upright rather than spreading, to ensure that views from the windows are not obscured and the building still receives plenty of light
Seating helps make the space feel more inviting and also more likely to be used
20
Inruralareasitisimportanttobeawareof‘localdistinctiveness’,orwhatmakesthelocalitydifferentandspecial.Oftenitmeansusingmaterialscharacteristicofthatarea,forexamplestonepavingorparticularplants–suchasbox,whichgivesBoxHillinSurreyitsname.InSheffieldontheNorthernGeneralHospitalcampus,oldindustrialartefactsareplacedaroundthesiteatkeylocations.Theseprovideinformalmeetingandorientationpoints,andremindeveryonethatSheffieldisacitywitharichindustrialheritage.
AtthenewSecondRhonddaCommunityHospitalinWales,whichwasbuiltonthesiteofaformercoal-mine,thelandscapehasbeencarefullydesignedtoreflectthecharacterofthesurroundinglandscape.Drystonewalling–usedlocallyforfieldboundaries–featuresprominently,andhasalsobeenusedtocreateseatingspacesinthecourtyards.Slateisusedasasubstituteforgravelandalsotoform‘standingstones’whichprovidestrongfocalpointsinsomeoftheothercourtyardspaces.
Artworkdesignedinasecondphaseofworktoenhancethecourtyardfeaturesalsohelpstogivethesespacesadistinctcharacter.
Using local materials will ensure that outdoor spaces reflect the character of their surroundings.
Cou
rtes
y:Ja
mes
New
mar
ch.
Cou
rtes
y:4
DL
ands
cape
Des
ign.
21
3.Maketheoutsideaccessible
Anintegratedapproach
Thisapproachintegratesbuildingsandstructureswiththewiderlandscape,ratherthanfocusingmainlyonbuildingsanddesigningthesite‘fromtheinsideout’.Wherepossible,thismorestrategicapproachispreferabletotacklingexternalareasona‘gardenbygardenbasis’,whichcanonlyinfillthespacesleftoveroncethebuildinghasalreadybeendesigned.Well-integratedsiteswill,bydefinition,beaccessible.
Easyaccess
Alongsidethequalityandproximityofthespace,easyaccessisprobablythemostimportantfactorindeterminingwhetherspaceswillactuallybeused.Designingthebuildingswithregardtotheiroutdoorspaceshouldhelptoensurethatthereisplentyofdirectaccessfrominside,outintothespaces.AtNewhamUniversityHospitalinLondon,courtyardspacesoffthemaincorridorprovideeasilyaccessiblespacesfortheground-floorcafésandwards.Moremobilepatientsontheupperfloorsalsousethesegardens,takingtheliftsorusingthestairstogetthere.
Whereappropriate,wardsshouldbedesignedtoallowbedstobewheeledoutintothesunshine(rememberingthatsomepatientswillalsoneedtobeinshade).Formanyhospicesthisisaroutinepractice,suchasattheJosephWeldHospice.
Aclearhospitalpolicyonusingoutdoorspaceswillalsohelptogivestaffconfidencetoencouragepatientstogooutsidewhereappropriate.
Formanypeople,andespeciallythoseconfinedtobed,beingabletoenjoytheoutdoorsfrominsideisimportant,andviewsoftreesoragardenshouldbeavailable.Thismeanstakingcarethatthewindowislowenoughandthebedisorientatedtowardsit.SomeoftheKingsFund’s‘EnhancingtheHealingEnvironment’projectshaveinvolvedretro-fittingdoorstomake‘hardtoreach’spacesaccessible.Thisisoftenworthexploringinexistingbuildings.
TheLambethCommunityCareCentreiscleverlyintegratedwithitssetting,andthegardensareseenasanessentialpartofpatientcare.Sun-roomsandbalconiesarepopularwithpatientswhoarenotyetreadytogooutside,butwhostillwanttoenjoythefreshair.Evenpatientsinwheelchairsontheupperfloorscangooutindependently,alongahigh-levelwalkwaywhichconnectsthebalconyareaswiththegarden.
A bed is made ready to be wheeled into the sunshine.
Imag
esc
ourt
esy:
Jose
phW
eld
Hos
pice
.
The sun room offers a taste of the outdoors at Lambeth Community Care Centre.
Cou
rtes
y:E
dwar
dC
ullin
anA
rchi
tect
s.
Beds can be wheeled out onto both the balconies and the patios.
22
Beingcreative
Someorganisationsandhealthcaresettingsareexperimentingwithdifferentwaysofbringingnatureinside,whereparticularpatientneedsorthedesignofthebuildingmeansaccesstothenaturalenvironmentislimited.
•AtAlderHeyChildren’sHospitalinLiverpool,recordedbirdsongisplayedinsomewardsandCDsaregiventopatientswhentheyleavetoassistwiththeirrecoveryathome.
•AtDorsetCountyHospitalinDorchester,inthechemotherapyunitwhereinfectioncontrolisahighpriority,livefilmistransmittedfromanaturereserverunbytheDorsetWildlifeTrustaspartofthehospital’s‘RoomWithaView’project.
•Insomeclimates,oronverysmallsites,‘winter-gardens’orconservatoriesmaybethemostsensibleoptionfortherapeuticfunctionssuchasphysiotherapy,especiallyforchildren.
A ‘woodland setting’ for the new Children’s Unit at Salisbury Hospital.
Cou
rtes
y:S
amB
oex
/3D
Sol
utio
ns.
An especially creative approach will be needed where outdoor areas are inaccessible: the children here can watch the pet rabbits playing, through the windows.
Above:Existing view.Left:How the improved area could look.
Floor to ceiling windows allow good views in for the smallest visitor
Doors kept locked for this garden which is inaccessible to the public
23
4.Focusonpeople’sneeds
Insuccessfultherapeuticspaces,meetingpeople’sneedscomesfirst,ratherthanthedrivetoreducemaintenancecostsoravoidrisksbeingprioritised.Designersshouldworkcloselywithpeople(usergroups,ortheirrepresentatives)tounderstandtheseneeds,ratherthanproceedingonthebasisofassumptions–whichmightbemistaken.
Inclusivedesign
Animportantgeneralpointisthatspaceswhicharedesignedtohaveatherapeuticfunctionshouldfeelcomfortableandshouldbeplaceswherepeoplefeelsafe,relaxed,atease,andnotoverlookedorconstrained.
Multi-functionalspacessuchasgeneralgardenareasareoftenintendedforawiderangeofpeoplewithwidelydifferingneeds.The‘Inclusivedesign’approachisparticularlyrelevantforthese–cateringforspecificneedsinasubtlewaywhichmeansspaces(orstructures)canbeenjoyedbyallusers,ratherthanbyonespecificusergroup.AccordingtoDavidKamp,aninclusivedesignspecialist,‘Designconsiderations...areoftensubtledetails,easilyoverlookedexceptbythosewhoneedthem’.
Itmaybethecasethatsomepeople’srequirementsareconflicting.Jasmineplantedinagardentohelpalleviatesymptomsofdepressionmightprovetoohighlyscentedforthechemotherapypatientstrugglingwithnausea.Workingcloselywithpotentialusers(ortheirrepresentatives)willhelpovercomesuchissues.
TheSensoryTrust,basedinCornwall,hasdevelopedtheCreativeSpacesProjectwithCornwallCare,Cornwall’slargestindependentcareprovider.Theprojectaimstoimprovecarehomegardenssothattheymeetresidents’needs.Inordertounderstandthese,theTrustrananumberofevents–suchasanoutingtotheEdenProjectledbyyoungpeople,andthe‘designworkshop’inthegarden,whereresidentErniewasinvitedtosharehisgardenmemorieswithstaff.
Garden visits and design ‘workshops’ all help to clarify people’s needs.
Imag
esc
ourt
esy:
Sen
sory
Tru
st.
24
Cateringforspecifictherapeuticneeds
Insomespaces,thelayoutneedstobequitespecifictotheusergroup.Forexample,inamentalhealthdevelopment,agardenusedbyelderlypatientswithdementiawillbequitedifferenttooneusedbyyoungmenwithmentalhealthproblemsrelatedtodrugmisuse.Fundingforgardenspacesmayalsobeeasiertoprotectwhenthelinkstospecifictherapeuticfunctionsaremadeveryclear.
Involvingdisabilityaccessgroupsisessentialtoensurethatallthekeyissuesareaddressed,especiallywithregardtointelligentandsensitiveinterpretationoftheEqualityAct(2010).Cateringforbroaderequalityanddiversitycommitmentsmayinsomesituationsalsoextendtoaddressingculturalissues.
AtthenewAlzheimer’sRespiteCentreinDublin,thegardenisfullysecureandhasbeendesignedtoavoid‘dead’ends’,focusinginsteadonaloopsystem.Manyofthepatientswander,andmakingthiswanderingmorepurposefulreducesthelikelihoodofthembecomingstressed.
TheCentreManagerdescribedhowhelpfulthegardenisforresidents:Ifsomeoneisgettingworkedup...youcantakethemoutside,eveninthewinter...thepersonoftencalmsdownmorequicklythaninside,wherethewallscanfeelveryconfining...wehavescentedherbslikelavenderarounddoorwaysandweencourageresidentstocrushtheleavesintheirhands,toreleasethescentontotheirskin.
It’showaspaceisusedthatcounts
Sometimes,alackoffundingorstaffresourcesmeansmakingasmuchaspossibleofanexistingarea.Intheabsenceofanewdesign,encouragingthestafftousetheareamorecreativelymayenableaspace–whichonthesurfaceseemstohavelittletherapeuticpotential–tomeetpeople’sneeds.TheCreativeSpacesProjectinCornwallintroducedsimpleoutdoor‘activitystations’intothegardensofcarehomes,encouragingresidentstospendmoretimeoutdoorsandtoexplorenewareas.AndatWillitonHospitalinSomersetstaff,encouragepatientsoutsidetore-learnoldskills–inthecaseofonegentlemanwhowasabutterflycollector,usingabutterflynet!
The garden at the Alzheimer’s Respite Centre, Dublin, is designed to be secure but also safe and welcoming.
Cou
rtes
y:N
ick
Kane
.
Scented lavender.
25
5.Connectwithnature
Natureliesattheheartofoutdoorspacesforhealthandwell-being.Trees,springtimeflowers,shrubs,birdsong,autumncolours,agentlebreeze,sunshineandrainareallsomuchpartofeverydayexperiencethatitiseasytotakethemforgranted.Forthosewhoareillinhospitalwards,orperhapsanxiousorstressed,theycangreatlyassistthehealingprocess.
Usingnaturalmaterials,andmakingthemostofnatural‘elements’(earth,wind,water)aswellasplantingallhelptostimulatethesensesandreconnectpeoplewithnature.Asmallbird-feedingareaorplantschosentoprovidenectarforbutterflieswillgiveeveryonesomethingextratowatchandanotherreasontogooutside,evenifjustforashortbreak.
Wildlife
Plantedareasarealsomuchmorelikelythanpavedonestoattractbirdsandotherwildlife,whichaddextralifeandinteresttoagarden,likethecafécourtyardsketchedbelow.
‘OneofthereasonsIwantedtoworkattheHomoeopathicHospital,isthebuilding.Itislightandairyandwelcoming.Thesenseofspaceisextravagantforahospital.ThebestthingaboutworkinghereisopeningthewindowsandlisteningtothebirdssingingasIwork.’(CandidaFenton,LibrarianatGlasgowHomoeopathicHospital)
Inschemeswithastrongemphasisonwildlife,itwillbeimportanttomakesurethat‘native’ratherthanornamentalplantsareused.Thiswillhelptoensurethattheschemebenefitslocalbiodiversityasmuchaspossible.Evenmodestimprovementstoaspacetocreateanewgardencouldhavemajorbenefitsforwildlifeinthevicinityandhelpfacilitiesmeettheirlocalperformancetargetsintermsoftheenvironment.
The excitement of meeting a snail for the first time.
Cou
rtes
y:C
hloe
Eva
ns-L
ippe
tt.
The café courtyard sketch here shows how a rather dull paved space could easily be turned into a more interesting outdoor eating area.
Above:Existing view.Right:How the improved area could look.
Picnic tables replaced with more comfortable seating, easier for those who are less mobile to use
Trees under-planted with edible herbs and soft fruit, such as strawberries
Apple, plum and cherry trees help to soften the space and create privacy; all growing in light-weight planters and soil to reduce loading over the roof garden surface
26
Forexample,inthesouth-west,plantingasmallareaofDevil’sbitscabiousmighthelptoattracttheendangeredmarshfritillarybutterfly,apriorityspeciesintheUKBiodiversityActionPlan.
TheWildlifeGardenatTivertonHospitalfocusedonmakingsmall-scalechangestoencouragewildlife,suchastheintroductionofareasofnativeplanting.Thewholeschemehascostlessthan£1000toimplement(excludingthevalueofvolunteerlabour).
Asurgeonatthehospitalwhoisakeenadvocateof‘healinggardens’workedwiththeEstatesDepartmenttomakeasterilespacemoreappealingtoawiderangeofbirds,butterfliesandbees.Patientsarenowabletowatchthehedgehogstrundlingaroundthegardenatduskfromtheirbeds.
‘Therobinsarenestingnowinlastyear’sblackbirdnest,andtherearehedgehogsusingthepurpose-builtnestbox,sosomethingmustberightANDthepatientstellmetheylovethebirds,andwildflowersunderacanopyoftrees.ItreallyisaHealingGarden.’(Dr.GavinHaig).
The insect nest-box and hedgehog house are just a few ways in which the garden caters for wildlife.
The Wildlife Garden at Tiverton Hospital.
Wild flowers in the new meadow areas.
27
6.Balanceriskwithbenefits
Caringforpatientsandkeepingthemsafeisobviouslyakeyobjectiveinhealthcare,alongwithrestoringhealthandwell-being.Therearerisksinvolvedwithaccesstotheoutdoors,forexamplewhenpatientsventureoutofthewardintoanadjacentgarden,butthesemustbeweighedagainstthebenefitsofexerciseandreconnectingwiththeoutsideworld.
Managingdesignconstraintsconstructively
Mentalhealthsettingscanbeespeciallychallengingfordesigners,butwithagrowingunderstandingoftheimportanceofaccesstothenaturalenvironment,manysettingsarenowprovidinghighqualityspaces–especiallyimportantinresidentialunitsorwherepeoplearedetainedundertheMentalHealthAct(1983,asamended).
IntheWandsworthRecoveryUnitatSpringfieldUniversityHospitalinLondon,thebuildingwallscreatesecureinternalcourtyardspaceswhicharefreelyaccessible.Here,despitetheoperationalneedforsupervision,acivilisingandhumanesettinghasbeencreatedwhichsupportstherapeuticintervention.
WandsworthRecoveryCentreisarelativelyhighsecuritysettingbutthelayoutoftheoutdoorareasischaracterisedbydesignqualityratherthan‘robustness’.Theseatinghereisagoodexample:sturdy,butwithatactile,softlyundulatingsurfacedesignedinwaywhichradiatescalmness.
Inputfromboththehealthandsafetyandinfectioncontroldepartmentsmaybepartofmakingsurethataspaceissuitabletouse.Theirinputshouldbemanagedconstructively,toavoidtakinga‘riskaverse’approachtodesign.Therisk–benefitassessment(RBA)process,wherethebenefitsofanactivityordesignareexaminedalongsideanyrisks,isusednowbymanyorganisations–includingtheForestryCommission–asaconstructivewayofmanagingliability.IthasgovernmentsupportthroughtheHealthandSafetyExecutive(HSE).
AtthestrokerehabilitationunitofWillitonCommunityHospital,Somerset,thegardeniswellusedbyin-patientsandtheirfamilies.Allpatientswhoaremobileenoughareallowedintothegardenontheirown,andtheyenjoyusingasmallnetworkofpaths,tore-learntheirbalanceandwalkingskills.Theyarealsoallowedaccompaniedaccesstoareasoff-site.
Cou
rtes
y:D
avid
But
ler.
Tactile seating at the Wandsworth Recovery Centre.
28
Anexampleofhowthedecision-makingprocessdescribedbelowcouldbedocumentedusingarisk–benefitassessmentprocesscanbefoundinAppendix2.
ThegardensaroundWillitonHospitalinSomersetareunremarkableinappearance,buttheyareusedcreativelybythetherapiststhere.SeniorOccupationalTherapistSoniaexplains:
‘Webelieveit’sreallyimportanttoallowpatientsthefreedomtoenjoythegardenunsupervised[oncetheyhavebeenassessedasbeingabletomanagewithrelativesafety].Havingthatextrabitofindependencemeansthattheyhavetolearntobemoreconfidentoutside,whichisanessentialskillforthemtomasteriftheyaretobedischargedsuccessfully.Sometimes,yes,theydohaveafall,butwelookattheseincidentsinaconstructivelightandtheinformationabouthowandwhyithappenedtheninformsourtherapyandtreatmentprogrammetoreducethechanceofithappeningagain.
Becausewe’reinaruralarea,wehavealotoffarmersthrough,andit’sespeciallyimportantthattheyareconfidentinamore‘informal’setting–nousejustbeingabletowalkontarmac.Sowiththem,wemighttakethemundersupervisionontothefootpathnexttothegardenandevenoverthestileandintothefield,walkingoverroughnewly-ploughedground.It’ssoimportantforthemtoknowthattheycandotheseactivities.’
Path leading to surrounding fields from Williton Hospital.
Garden, Williton Hospital.
29
7.Designforchange
Naturalspacesevolvewithtime
Imagining,designingandcreatinganoutdoorspaceisjustthebeginning–aspaceneedstolastlongterm.Spacesdesignedcarefullycanbeenjoyedthroughoutallstagesoftheirlifespan.Thisisespeciallyimportantforschemesincludingtrees,whichwillchangemarkedlyastheygrowthroughestablishmenttomaturity.
Successfulgroundsmaintenanceiswellplannedandadequatelyresourced
Groundsmaintenancecostsshouldbeconsideredfromtheoutset,andsetatalevelwhichstillallowsthespacetomeetusers’needs.Forexample,pavedareaswouldbecheapertomaintainthanplantedones,buttheywillneverachievethesametherapeuticbenefits.
Well-resourcedgroundsmaintenanceisimportantatanyscale.AtthenewForthValleyRoyalHospitalatLarbert,Stirlingshire–averylargescheme–thedeveloperwasobligedbyaPlanningObligationtoendowtheoutdoorspaceswithafundof£250,000forrestorationandmaintenance.Atamuchsmallerscale,attheLambethCommunityCareCentreinLondon,thebudgethasbeenstructuredtocoverthecostsofapart-timegardener,withanyadditionalcostsbeingcoveredbyincomeraisedfromplantsales,opentolocalpeople.
Designtoanticipatechangingconditions
Openspacecanbeespeciallyusefulinthecontextofachangingclimate.Treescanbeplantedtoprovideshadeinhottersummers,helptomoderatetheeffectsofheavyrainfall,filterairtoimprovequality,absorbCO2andsupportbiodiversity,andimprovethebeautyofaplace.Theycanevenreducemanagementcosts,comparedwithmowngrass.
Toachievethecarbontargetsitisaimingfor,theNHSmustdesignandmaintainoutdoorspacessustainably.TheCentreforSustainableHealthcareisworkingtohelptheNHSbecomemoresustainableandtheNHSForestinitiative,whichaimstoplantonetreeforeveryemployeeacrosstheNHSestate(andbeyond),isanimportantelementinitsprogramme.Woodlandscreenplanting,suchasthatshownopposite,wouldbeasuitableprojectforthisprogramme.
At Lambeth Community Care Centre the gardener prunes shrubs carefully rather than using a hedge-trimmer.
30
AtEnniskilleninNorthernIreland,thenewhospitalisbeingimplementedunderaprivatefinanceinitiativecontracttohighstandardsofsustainability,withthebestpossibleintegrationofbuiltdevelopmentandthelandscapeasoneoftheproject’skeyobjectives.
Animportantelementoftheprojectisthereconstructionofwetlandsroundthebuildings,usingsurfacewaterrun-offfromroofsandhardsurfaces.Othersustainablesolutionsincludetheextensiveuseoflocally-grownnativeflora,andthecreationofextensivespecies-richmeadowscloseto(andvisiblefrom)thehospitalbuildings.
Introducing larger-scale planting will be possible on more spacious sites and will make them more attractive to staff and visitors, as well as patients. Using native species will also bring wider environmental benefits.
Above:Existing view.Left:How the improved area could look.
Illus
trat
ion:
Ric
hard
Car
man
.Cou
rtes
y:N
IHG
/L
UC
.
Trees can help the NHS meet sustainability targets and provide wildlife habitat
A limited amount of meadow grass, where appropriate, helps reduce frequency of grass-cutting and improve biodiversity on the site
Improved amenity value of site – especially near to countryside – enhances the environment for staff, visitors and patients
Atrium view of lough at Enniskillen, Northern Ireland.
31
Summary
Thedesignprinciplessetoutabovehavebeendevelopedtoreflecttheissuesofmostimportancewithinhealthcaresettings;followingthemwillhelpensurethatthedesignofoutdoorspacesfortherapeuticuseissuccessful.Theywillprovideagoodoverviewofthekeydesignprinciplesforallthosewhomaylackspecialistexpertise,andwhomaybeinvolvedincommissioningordevelopinglandscapeprojects.
Maggie’sCentreatCharingCrossHospital,Londonisanexcellentexampleofaschemewhichplaceddesignqualityattheheartoftheproject,andalsoillustratesclearlyseveraloftheprincipleslistedabove.
Paediatric courtyard at Enniskillen, Northern Ireland. Linear gardens at Enniskillen, Northern Ireland.
Illus
trat
ions
:Ric
hard
Car
man
.Cou
rtes
y:N
IHG
/L
UC
.
32
Illustratingthedesignprinciples
TherearealreadyanumberofMaggie’sCentresthroughouttheUK,usuallydevelopedasflagshipprojectsbyestablisheddesignersworkingona‘probono’basis.AlthoughinthecaseofthisparticularcentreinLondon,wheretheoverallbudgetwasgenerous(fundedbycharitabledonationsandfundraising),therearemanyaspectsoftheprojectthatwouldbeeasilyreplicableonthemoremodestbudgetstypicalofanNHSscheme.
Thereisgrowingevidencetoshowthattheemotionalstateofcancerpatients,andthatoftheirfamilyandfriends,caninfluencetheircancerexperience,treatmentandrecovery.Researchinthefieldofenvironmentalpsychologyhasestablishedthatourphysicalenvironmentaffectsourbehaviour,andwell-designedenvironmentssuchastheMaggie’sCentreinLondonhavebeenshowntoenhancequalityoflifeandaperson’sabilitytocopewithstress.
Thegardenillustratesparticulardesignprinciplesmentionedinthisguideveryclearly,asshownintheimages.
‘Mostpeoplesaidtheyfeltthattheplantssoftenedthebuildingbutalsothewholeexperienceofbeingthere.Theplantssimultaneouslycreateasenseofcalmness(soothing)butalsoasenseofenergy–peopleoftentalkaboutbeingfascinatedbythespeedthingsgrowatandtheylookforwardtoseeingthenextstageintheplant’sdevelopment;there’savitalityaboutthebudsopening,andnewleavesunfurling.Forpeoplewithcancer,anythingwhichhelpsthemlookforwardtothefuturewithasenseofhopeismassivelyhelpful.’(Researcher,Maggie’sCentreLondon,2010).
Case Study 3: Maggie’s Cancer Caring Centre, London.
33
Design for people’s needs: Thesiteradiatescalmnessandtranquillity,whichhelpsrelievetheanxietyandstressoftenexperiencedbythosewithcancer,andtheirfamiliesandfriends.Therelaxedmoodandeasy,inside-outflowhelpmakethecentrefeellikeasanctuaryinthebusyurbanenvironmentinwhichitsits.
Make the outside accessible:Thelandscapedesignerworkedcloselywiththearchitectandthishashelpedcreateabuildingwhichisfullyintegratedwiththeexternalareas.Thegardensurroundsthebuildingandgrowsthroughitinaseriesofintimateandsensualspaces.Eachroomhasitsownaccessoutside,andthelargewindowseverywheremaketheoutdoorspacespossibletoappreciateevenonawetwinteryday.
Connect people with nature: plantingenvelopsthewholebuildingandthetrees–onceestablished–willhelpscreenthenoiseandbustleofthesurroundingstreetsandtraffic.Theplantinghasbeencarefullyplannedtoincludescentedfoliage,andtocreateagoodbalanceofintricacyandsimplicityofscale.
‘Bystimulatingallthesensesandprovidingaconnectiontonatureinanurbanenvironment,Maggie’sLondonwillputallvisitorsintouchwiththishealingpotential’(designer).
Cou
rtes
y:M
aggi
e’s
Lond
on.
34
Overcomingthechallenges
Eachtypeofhealthcaresettingwillhaveitsownparticularchallengestoovercomeinordertoprovidetherapeuticoutdoorspaces.Somemethodsofprocurement,suchasprivatefinanceinitiativeschemes,alsoneedtobetackledcarefullytoachievethebestoutcomepossible.
Therearemanyexamplesofgoodpracticethroughoutthecountrywherethesechallengeshavebeensuccessfullysolved.
Privatefinanceinitiativeschemes
The challenge:ManytypesofNHSfacilityareprocuredunderprivatefinanceinitiative(PFI)schemes.ATrustthatplaceslowvalueonlandscapeattheoutsetrisksseeingthisaspectdiminishedevenfurtherduringdelivery,withproposalserodedbyinevitablecontractualandfinancialpressures.
The solution:Whilestronglyfocusedonacost-effectivedesignandconstructionprocess,newPFIschemescanstilldeliverhighqualitylandscapeswhichcanhaveatherapeuticfunction(andwithexistingschemes,changescanbemadebyvariationtothecontract).
Wherethereisnoexistingguidanceonrequirementsforoutdoorspace,theprocuringauthorityshouldincludetheserequirementsinitsoutputspecification.Bidsshouldplaceemphasison,andallowpropercostsfor,alandscape-ledapproachsecuredthroughthepreparationofdetailedproposals,includingagreedlevelsofqualityandprovision,atPreferredBidderstage.TheproposedEnniskillenHospitalexemplifiesthisprocess.
How do we put the theory into practice?
Enniskillen Hospital, in Northern Ireland, North Spine View.
Illus
trat
ion:
Ric
hard
Car
man
.Cou
rtes
y:N
IHG
/L
UC
.
35
Acutecare
The challenge:Wardsarefrequentlyrelocatedinacutehospitalsettings,makinglong-termplanningdifficult,withlittleincentiveforcapitalinvestment.Theremayalsobeaperceptionthatinvestinginaccesstotheoutdoorsdoesnotofferagoodreturnwhenmanypatientsaremostlyconfinedtobed.
The solution: AtSalisburyDistrictHospitalinWiltshire,theArtsManager,togetherwiththeFacilitiesandEstatesManagementTeam,hasidentifiedanumberofspacesforpotentialimprovement.Theselieoutsidethehospital’s‘developmentzone’,havepotentialamenityvalue,andhaveausergroupcloseby.Withastrategynowinplace,improvementscanproceedwithconfidenceasfundingbecomesavailable.
Inthehospital’splansforacourtyardgarden,thespacewillbeaccessiblefromboththeStrokeandOncologyunits.ThesketchbelowshowshowfeaturescanbeincludedtohelppatientsfromtheStrokeUnitimprovetheirmobilityandbalancewhilealsomakinganattractivespaceforotherpeople.
Olderpeople’scare
The challenge: Inolderpeople’scaresettings,therehasbeenatendencyforpeopletospendmuchoftheirtimesittingpassivelyintheTVroom.Staffmaybeunawareofthebenefitsforolderpeopleofbeingoutsideand,asaresult,encouragingresidentsoutintothegardenbecomesalowpriority.
The solution: TheCreativeSpacesProjectinCornwallcreatesopportunitiesforolderpeoplewithdementiatoimprovetheirenvironmentsandplayamoreactivepartinsociety.ThelessonslearntarebeingdisseminatedacrossallthepropertiesmanagedbyCornwallCare.
Withinthisproject,theconceptofatimetabled‘activitiesprogramme’hasbeenreplacedbyanewapproachtoactivitiesthatpromotesindependence.AtTrevarnaCareHomeinStAustell,the
New planting, paths and seating would transform this space for everyone, whether patients, staff or visitors.
Above:Existing view.Right:How the improved area could look.
Seating areas close to entrances
Shrubs around the edge make the garden feel less over-looked
Existing change in level incorporated within new circular path using different surfacing materials
Grove of Birch trees helps to define the space and create privacy. The trees will also look attractive from inside the building, even the upper floors
36
gardensarebeingredesignedwiththeresidents’needsinmindtoenablethemtomaketheirownchoicesaboutwhattheydooutside.
Thegardensarefreelyaccessible,andoutdoor‘activitystations’consistingofvisualcuessuchasapileofbooksinaquietcorner,oracollectionofgardeningtoolsona‘work’table,allhelpresidentstoinitiatetheirownactivities,maintainingtheirindependenceandself-worth.Insiteswhereindependentaccesstogardensisdifficult,moreemphasisisplacedongettingresidentsoutandaboutbycoach–totakepartintheday-to-dayactivitiesofthelocalcommunityinwhichtheylive.
Primarycare
The challenge:Inprimarycaresettings,patientsusuallyonlyattendforshortappointments.
The solution: Theremaybescopetodevelopoutdoorspacestoprovideapleasantplaceforpeopletowait,orevenasafocusforactivitieswhichcouldincludethewidercommunity.
AttheCulmValleyIntegratedCentreforHealthinDevon,anewapproachtoprimarycareisbeingtrialled,asdescribedinCasestudy4.
Anewmodelofprimarycareforthe21stcentury
TheCulmValleyCentreisatthecoreofaninnovativenationalself-careprojectsupportedbytheDepartmentofHealth.IncorporatingaconventionalGPsurgeryalongsideanaturalhealthcentre,thedesignofthebuilding–bothinsideandoutside,andalsoofthegrounds–emphasisesaholisticapproachtohealthcare.Thereisafocuson‘wellness’ratherthanillness,andafocusonself-care,orprevention,ratherthanonmedication.
Ahealthfacilitatoronthestaffactsasagatewaytoawiderangeoftherapiesincludingactivitieswithastrongsocialorcommunityangle,suchastheGardeningGroup,andtheCommunityInterestCompany(SustaincareCIC)runsacaféinsidethecentre.Thecaféfunctionsasasocialhub,andpatientsvisitingtheirdoctor,healthprofessionalorthepharmacystopforadrinkandsnackandfindnewwaystolookafterthemselvesastheydo.
ThePhysicGardenhasinformationonBritishmedicinalplantsthatcanbegrowninpatients’gardens,andhasabenchwherepatientsandstaffcanspendtimerelaxingoutsideinacalmingenvironment.
Case Study 4: Culm Valley Integrated Centre for Health, Cullompton, Devon.
37
IntheKitchenGardenfoodisgrownforthecafé,toshowpeoplehowfoodgetsfromsoiltoplate,tomodelhowlittlespaceisneededtogrowone’sownfood,andtoencouragetheuseofseasonalproduce.
Manypeoplehaveattendedsessionsheldbyherbalistson‘MakingmedicinesfromtheGarden’and‘WinterRemedies’.Theworkshopsencouragepeopletotakeresponsibilityfortheirhealthandarealsosocialevents,givingpeopleachancetomeettheirneighboursandbuildfriendships.
Imag
esc
ourt
esy:
Cul
mv
alle
yC
entr
efo
rInt
egra
ted
Hea
lth.
Kitchen garden and produce.
Cou
rtes
y:C
ulm
val
ley
Cen
tre
forI
nteg
rate
dH
ealth
.
38
Gettingstarted:theprojectprocesssummarised
Therearefourmainstagesinthedesigncycle:
1. Preparation.2. Designandimplementation.3. Usingandmaintainingthenewspace.4. Monitoringandreview.
The‘review’partofstage4islikelytoleadbacktostage1again,asfurtherimprovementscontinuetobemade.
Timespentongettingtheprocessrightwillhelptoachieveawell-designedandsustainableoutdoorspace.
Mostpeoplethinkoftheprojectprocessasbeinglinear,withabeginningandend.However,agoodprocessiscyclical,withthefinalmonitoringandreviewstageleadingnaturallybacktothebeginning.Spaceschangeasplantinggrowsandmaturesandonlyregularmonitoringwillidentifywhetherpartsofthelayoutneedtobealteredtoo.
TheKing’sFundprogramme,‘EnhancingtheHealingEnvironment’,hasdevelopedasuccessfulmodelfor‘team-based’projects,ledbyclinicalstaffandcarriedoutinpartnershipwithserviceusers,anditisrecommendedthatreadersrefertothis.
At Lynfield Mount Hospital in Bradford, service-users, staff, and relatives all worked together to transform an under-used space, with funding from the ‘Enhancing the Healing Environment’ programme.
Cou
rtes
y:T
heK
ings
Fun
dPh
oto
Libr
ary.
39
Stage1:PreparationRemember to:
•Assembletheclientteam.
•Developabusinesscase.
•Makesuresufficientresourceshavebeenallocated.
•Establishwiderpartnershipswithotheragencies.JointStrategicNeedsAssessmentidentifies‘thebigpicture’intermsofthehealthandwell-beingneedsandinequalitiesofalocalpopulation,andprojectsshouldbeinformedbythisprocesswherepossible.
•Checkplanningorlegislativeobligationsandduties.
•Surveythewholesite.
•Developadesignbriefbasedonastrong‘vision’fortheproject.
Funding
Securingfundingwillbeoneofthemostimportanttasksinthisfirststage,whenattemptingimprovementstoanexistingspace.Fundingcancomethroughdonationsandcovenants,legaciesandalso‘giftsinkind’–suchastheworkbytheSellindgeGardeners’AssociationinthegardensofthePilgrimsHospiceinAshford,Kent.
FundraisingeventsandevencharityshopsgeneratevaluableincomeforfacilitiesorgroupsregisteredwiththeCharitiesCommission,suchashospital‘friends’groups.Charitablestatuswillmakeiteasiertoapplytogrant-makingtrusts,ofwhichtherearemany,thoughtheircriteriavarywidelyandoftenchangefromyeartoyear.
Fosteringpartnershipswithotherlocalagencies(suchasWildlifeTrusts)orjustbeingawareofthelocalpoliticalclimatemayalsoopenupfundingopportunities.
AtBroomfieldHospitalinEssex,anambitiousprogrammeofimprovementstothesurroundingwoodlandwerefundedbyaPlanningObligation,aswellastheForestryCommission'sEnglishWoodlandGrantScheme,includingaWoodlandAssessmentGrant(WAG),forecologicalandstakeholdersurvey.OthersourcesoffundingincludedtheChelmsfordBoroughCouncilArtsFund.Thehospitalcommentedthatarelativelysmallamountofmoneyspentonwoodlandimprovementsmadeasignificantimpactinpublicperception.
Therearealargenumberoffundingsourcesforschemeslikethiswhichfocusontreeplanting,suchasthecampaignTheBigTreePlant.DetailsoftheseareavailablefromtheForestryCommissionandWoodlandTrust.
Cou
rtes
y:E
dwar
dC
ullin
anA
rchi
tect
s.
Event for friends and supporters of Lambeth Community Care Centre.
40
Stage2:DesignandimplementationRemember to:
•Appointadesigner.Landscapegardenersorgardendesignersmaybeabletohelpwithimprovingsmaller-scaleexistingspaces,butprojectswhichareatalargerscalewillneedthesupportofalandscapearchitect.Landscapearchitectsaretrainedtounderstandandimproveoutdoorspaces,andwillhavethelisteninganddesignskillstoengageinasite-widedesigndialogue.
•Briefthedesignerthoroughly.
•Checkthattheyunderstandinclusivedesign,andhaveexperienceofdesigningfortheparticularusers’needsintheprojectinhand.
Bytheendofthedesignstage,theinitial‘vision’willhavebeenhonedbytheteam(includingthedesigner)intothefinal‘product’–theschemewhichistobeconstructed.
Implementationislikelytobeundertakenbyacontractor.However,onsmallerschemesinsomesettings(primarycare,residentialsettings)theremaybeopportunitiesforpatientsorstafftohelpwithelementssuchasplanting.
Cou
rtes
y:D
FC
lark
Bio
nmiq
ueL
td.
Volunteers helping with implementation work.
Tree planting in Cornwall.
Culm valley centre planting by patients.
Cou
rtes
y:N
HS
Fore
st.
41
Stage3:UsingandmaintainingthenewspaceRemember to:
•Organisealauncheventorpublicopening.
•Thankeveryoneinvolvedintheprojectandpublicisethenewspacetopotentialusers.
•Takeanyfurtheropportunitiesduringtheyeartoorganisesmalleventsoractivitiesinthenewspaceinvolvingstaff,patientsandvisitors.
•Monitorhowthemaintenanceisprogressing,especiallyearlyon.Perhapsthelitterbinsneedemptyingmorefrequently,orthereisextrascopeforpatientorstaffinvolvementinsimpletaskssuchaspickingapplesintheautumn.
•Dealwithissuessuchassmokingorlitterconstructively(notbysimplypreventingaccess).
•Makesureadministrativeandmaintenancestaffareeducatedaboutthevalueofoutdoorspace,andtheimportanceofmaintainingaccessibility,toensurespacesremainunlocked.
Allimprovementswhichleadtospacesbeingusedbymorepeoplewillusuallyresultinincreasedmaintenanceneedsandpotentialcosts.
Thesecouldbemetbyfindingoutwhetherthelocalhorticulturalcollege,horticulturalsocietyorlargercompanieswithcommunityvolunteeringschemescouldhelp.Also,theWildlifeTrustsandtheBTCV(BritishTrustforConservationVolunteers)havebranchesallovertheUKandwilltakeonavarietyofprojects,especiallyinanaturalorsemi-naturallandscape.
Stage4:MonitoringandreviewRemember to:
•Carryoutapost-occupationevaluationstudy,tocheckwhetherthereisanythingaboutthespacethatcouldbeimproved.Knowingwhathasworkedwellalsohasimportantvalueintermsoflessonstoreplicateelsewhere.
•Reviewthespaceannuallytocheckthedevelopmentofthelandscapeasitmatures.Treestakesandtiesmayneedadjustingandsometimesgroupsoftreesneedtobethinnedtogivebetterspecimensthespacetogrow.Itwillalsobeimportanttocheckandmaintainplanthealth,especiallyafterperiodsofextremeweather.
•Continuetocheckweeklythatthenewspacesremainaccessible,andarenotlockedunnecessarily.
TheVerwoodOpportunityCentreProjectdescribedinCasestudy5showshowagoodprocessresultsinasuccessfulproject.
At Broomfield Hospital in Essex, special efforts were made to involve young people from the local community in implementing work on site and in celebrating its completion.
42
Raised beds laid out in the shape of a spiral each focus on a different ‘sense’; such as this one celebrating the sense of Taste.
Awell-plannedspaceforeveryonetoenjoy
In2009staffattheVerwoodOpportunityCentrefoundthattheirclients,peoplewithphysicalandlearningdisabilities,wantedtofeelmoreintegratedwiththelocalcommunityandalsohavethechancetodomeaningfulwork.ThisresultedinthecreationoftheSensoryGarden,anewwildlife-friendlygardennexttotheOpportunityCentreandneighbouringCommunityCentre.
Stage1:Preparation
TheSensoryGardenprojectisanexcellentexampleofpartnershipworking:
•EastDorsetDistrictCouncildonatedtheland.
•DorsetWildlifeTrusthelpedco-ordinatethedesignprocessandagreedtolookafterthemanagementandmaintenance,oncethegardenwascompleted.
•TheOpportunityCentrepromisedtobuildusageofthespaceintotheirserviceusers’dailyactivities.
•TheneighbouringCommunityCentreofferedgeneralsupporttotheproject.
•Privatecompanies,includingalocallandfilloperator,providedthefunding.
•ThelocalEmmanuelSchoolhelpedwiththeplantingduringtheimplementation,aswellassettingupaTuesdaygardeningclub.
Stage2:Designandimplementation
Thegardenislaidoutintheformofaspiral,containingraisedbedsdesignedtoappealtothesenses.Tactilescentedplantingwithawidevarietyoffoliageandleafcolourmakethesiteequallyattractivetoeveryone.ImplementationwascarriedoutbyalocalcontractorbutclientsoftheCentrehelpedwithsmallerelements,suchasmakingthesignsforthesensorybeds.Particularattentionwasplacedonmakingthegardeneasilyaccessible.Forexample,thepatharoundthegardenwasmadeusingmaterialsenablingwheelchairs,walkersandpushchairs,tomovefreely.
Case study 5: Sensory Garden, the Verwood Opportunity Centre, Dorset.
Raised beds laid out in the shape of a spiral.
Cou
rtes
y:N
oelB
ergi
n/D
orse
tWild
life
Trus
t.
43
Stage3:Usingandmaintainingthespace
OvertheyearsusageofthespacehasincreasedandmanyoftheOpportunityCentreclientsnowregularlychoosetospendtimeoutsideintheSensoryGardenratherthanindoors.ShaneCarter(aserviceuserfromtheCentre),said
‘Wearereallyabletogetinvolvedwiththegarden,helpingwiththeplants,buildingnestboxes,eventhesignswerewoodburnedbyus.It’sbeengreattoworkinthisgarden,helpingtocreatesomethingforthecommunityandustoenjoy’.
TheDorsetWildlifeTrustcontinuestomaintainthesite,monitoringtheplantingcarefullyasitmatures.
Stage4:Monitoringandreview
ProjectevaluationhasdemonstratedthattheSensoryGardenprojecthashelpedpeoplewithphysicalandlearningdisabilitiestoengagewiththecommunityandagencies,breakingdownsocialbarriers.NoelBergin,ConservationOfficeratDorsetWildlifeTrust,said:
‘TheideaisthatthedifferentsectionsofthegardenwillbeongoingprojectsfortheOpportunityCentre,schoolsandothercommunitygroupstolookafter.Hopefully,notonlywillitbeawildlifehavenwithinthetown,butvisitorswillleavewithideasonhowtoimprovetheirownlocalareaforwildlife’.
Volunteers, staff and service-users all work together in the garden. Being out in the fresh air often helps de-fuse moments of tension as they arise.
Each raised bed focuses on a different ‘sense’; such as this one celebrating the sense of Taste.
44
Workingwithdesignelements
Thedesignelementslistedbelowwillallbeusefulincreatingtherapeuticspaces:
1. Planting2. Trees3. Entrances,pathsandboundaries4. Sitefurniture5. Art6. Water
Developingalayoutbasedonthedesignprinciplessetoutearlierandthinkingthroughthepracticalitiesofthewholeprojectprocesswillprovideagoodfoundationforanyscheme.
Experienceddesignerswillbeabletocombinethevariouselementssuchasplantingorpathsskilfully,butitishelpfulforthosebriefingthemtohavesomeunderstandingofthesetoo.Inthisway,aschemecanbecreatedwhichhasasenseofplaceandalsomeetsclinicalandotherneeds.Themostsuccessfulschemesarethosewheretheclienttakesastrongleadandwherethedesignerandclientworkcloselytogether.
Thissectionprovidesanoverviewofsomeofthemostusefulelementsusedindesigningoutdoorspaces.
Hospice garden, Salisbury Hospital: design elements working in harmony to create a tranquil place
Cou
rtes
y:P
eter
Urs
em.
45
1.Planting
Plantedspacesformatrulyrestorativeenvironment.Goodqualityplantinghighlightsthepassingoftheseasons,appealstoallthesenses,helpstoattractwildlife,andprovidessomethingnewanddifferenttolookateverydaythroughouttheyear.
VegetablesgrowingintheChildandAdolescentMentalHealthUnitatGreatOrmondStreetHospitalareseenashavingtherapeuticvalueforyoungpeoplewitheatingdisorders.
Lotsofhospitalshaveoutdoorcourtyardspaces,butthosewhicharegardenswithlushplantsratherthanjustpavedareasarefarmorebeneficialtopeopleusingthem.
Justsittinginaplantedareacanbebeneficial,butsometimestheextraeffortinvolvedinfocusingonagardeningtaskcanhelprestoreafatiguedortroubledmind.AttheBromleybyBowCentreinLondontheflowerorcuttinggardenisusedforhorticulturaltherapy;thestoryofonevolunteer’sexperienceisdescribedbelow.
‘IhadbeenworkingasamentalhealthnurseanddramatherapistintheEastEndforseveralyears–itwasabusyandstressfuljob,butIenjoyedit.Unfortunately,though,Isufferedbullyingandharassmentatwork,anditaffectedmymentalhealth...Iwasunabletoworkanymoreandwentoffsick,unwellwithdepression.
InApril2007,myGPsuggestedItryvolunteeringattheBromleybyBowCentre.Initially,Iwasonlydoingafewhoursaweekbut,sinceJanuary2010,Ihavebeenonacontractofemploymentfor35hoursaweekinthecuttinggarden.Itfeelsgreattobeworkingatthislevelagainaftersomanyyears.SometimesIcannotbelievehowmuchmylifehaschangedinthelastthreeyears.WhenIwasillIcouldn’timaginebeingabletoworkagain.Theworkinvolvedingrowingandnurturingplantsisamazinglysatisfyingandtherapeutic,butyoudon’thavetoworkinagardenorgreenspacetobenefitfromit.Justwalkingthroughaparkcanimproveyourwell-beingandpeaceofmind.’(Lisa,memberofthePoLLENproject,BromleybyBow).
Thingstoremember
•Chooseplantstoemphasiseseasonalchange,andbuildanticipationofthingstocomeandallowpeopletonoticethepassageoftime–evergreenschemestendtobelower-maintenancebutwillnotachievethis.
•Scentedandbrightlycolouredflowersandleavescanbeenjoyedbythosewhoarepartiallysighted,aswellasbeingattractiveforallusers.Senseofsmelliscloselyassociatedwiththe
A rich variety of planting means something new to look at every day.Vegetables growing at Great Ormond Street Hospital.
Cou
rtes
y:C
AM
HS
Uni
t,G
reat
Orm
ond
Stre
etH
ospi
tal.
46
partofthebraindealingwithmemoryandfeeling,soscentscancallupmemoriesandpowerfulresponsesalmostinstantaneously,whichisparticularlyhelpfulforthosewithmemoryloss.
•Shrubsshouldbeprunedcarefullytoemphasisetheirnaturalform.Thiswaythespacewilllookwellcaredfor–thesubliminalmessagebeing‘ifthegardeniswelllookedafter,Iwillbe...’.
•Food-growingisagoodoption,especiallyifthekitchenstaffcanusewhatisgrown.Inlong-stayorresidentialsettingspeoplewillbeabletoexperienceafullgrowingseason,butevenindaycentrestheycanjoininwithwhateverishappeningatthatpointinthehorticulturalyear.Agoodactivitiesprogrammecanfocusonfood-growing–eatingfruitcrumble,orpaintingcolourfulberries.
At Bromley by Bow Centre, local residents find that visiting the Flower Garden raises their spirits.
This left-over space between buildings feels bleak and exposed, but with the addition of trees and scented shrub planting it could become a space to relax in, between appointments or after a visit.
Above:Existing view.Left:How the improved area could look.
Archway creates a pretty entrance and helps separate the garden from the road
Lavender hedge along the lawn for butterflies and bees
Low maintenance rosemary hedge encloses the space and makes it feel more private
An arbour at the rear planted with jasmine to lift the spirits
47
2.Trees
Treeshaveaspecialplaceinthedesignofoutdoorspacesandtheymakedistinctiveplaceswhichendure.Theyarealiveanddynamic,withenormouspresence–ofteninspiringastrongemotionalresponseinpeople,suchasthesinglemagnoliatreeinblossom,atSalisburyDistrictHospital.
Nativetreesareespeciallygoodforwildlife.Treescanalsohelpscreenunsightlyviewsornoisytraffic–important,whennoiseisoftenseenasreducingthetherapeuticvalueofaspace.Theyalsohelptodefinespaces.
Largecanopytreesofalltypesprovideshadeinsummerandshelterinwinter.TheNHSHeatwavePlanisupdatedannuallyandacknowledgestheroletreescanplayinmodifyingclimateand,inparticular,reducingairtemperatures.
Evensittingunderasolitarytreecanprovideausefulhealingspace.
‘IworkedforyearsintheMentalHealthservicesinTaunton...whenwemovedtothenewoffices,wehadasmallareaofgrasswithabenchunderalargeoverhangingtree.Therewaspressuretomakethisareaintoacarparkbutwesuccessfullyresistedthis,becausewefeltitwassoimportanttohavethispieceofnaturalspace.
At Salisbury District Hospital there is space in the small courtyard for a single specimen Magnolia, laden with flowers every spring.
48
Thereweretimeswhenparticularclientscouldnotcopewithcomingintothebuildingandsessionstookplaceoutside.Irememberoneyoungmanwhowasunwell,verydistressedandalsoangry.Foratimehecalledtoseehisworkeratleastonceaday.Inthereceptionareahecauseddisruptiontoothersandhisworkertooktomeetinghimoutsideonthebench,wheretheclientdidnotfeelsohemmedin.’(Formermentalhealthservicesworker,Taunton)
TheNHSForestplanstoplantonetreeforeveryNHSemployee,aspartofthelong-termaimtomaketheNHSmoresustainable.Theplantingschemescanbeassmallasasinglefruittreeoraslargeasanewpieceofwoodland.Individualspecimentreesofferhighvisualimpact,soareoftenespeciallyusefulfortighturbansiteswherespaceformoreextensiveareasofplantingmaynotbeavailable.
Onlargersiteswoodlandplantingforbiomassboilersmayhelpsaveenergycosts.
Thingstoremember
•Planttherighttreeintherightplace.Treesgrow!
•Aplantingstrategywillensurethatnewtrees,includingcommemorativeones,canbelocatedwheretheywillhelptocreateattractiveandusablespaces.
•Fruittreescanbeusefulforsmallerspacesandoffergoodseasonalinterest.Orchardplantingmayalsobeagoodwaytomakeshort-termuseofasitewhichisearmarkedinthelong-termforre-development.AttheRoyalEdinburghHospital,staffharvestfruitfromtheiroldorchardforpatients.
•Inhighsecuritymentalhealthsettings,treescanbeplantedinareaswheretherewillbeaccessundersupervision.Treeplantingcanbeusedtosoftenandscreenunsightlysecurityfences.
•Somepeoplefinddarkwoodlandoppressive;havingopensunnygladesandgenerouspathswillincreasethewoodlandflowersandenhancethesensoryaspectsofbeinginawoodedspace.
Whether it’s glowing autumn leaves or the spring sun lighting up a pussy willow catkin, each in their own way help to transport the visitor away from stress and anxiety.
49
3.Entrances,pathsandboundaries–connectingthesite
Gatewaysandentrancesprovideimportantcuesforpeople–theysay‘comein,you’rewelcomehere’.Timespentonplanningacomprehensivenetworkofconnectingpaths,andondevelopinganappropriatespecificationandthenmakingsuretheyareproperlyconstructed,willhelpcreateasitewherepeoplecanmoreeasilyfindtheirwayaround.
Everyone,andespeciallythosewithcirculatoryandrespiratoryproblems,benefitsfromexercise–andmoreinterestingrouteswillprovidemoreofanincentive.Signpostingcanindicatethedistancecoveredandcaloriesused.
Pathsurfacesshouldbechosentoreflectthecontext,with‘softer’materialsforaninformalsetting.Primaryroutesshouldbedesignedtoalloweveryoneaccess,includingthosewithrestrictedmobility,butmanypeoplewanttoexperiencethenaturalenvironmentwithallthatimpliesanddonotexpecteasyaccesseverywhere.
Walkingcanitselfbetherapeutic,andthecontemplativeapproachtowalkingusedintheLabyrinthGardenatthePilgrim’sHospiceinCanterburyisonewhichmanypeopleofallfaiths(andnone)findhelpful.Theslow,steady,regularwalkingpacetunesinwiththeheart-beatandthishelpsinduceacalmerframeofmindandoften,asaresult,aloweringofbloodpressure.
Well designed entrances make people feel welcome as they arrive.
At St.Catherine’s in Doncaster, in-patients who have access to the grounds know they can safely walk along the red tarmac paths.
50
‘Eachpersonfindstheirownwayroundthelabyrinthandthereisnorightandwrongway.Inwalking,theanalyticalleftsideofthebraingiveswaytothemoreintuitiverighthandsideandweareledbythepathawayfromstressfulthoughtsintostillness.’(LizzieHopthrow,Chaplain,PilgrimsHospice)
Boundariesdonotneedtobeoppressiveandthreatening,butcancontainandencloselikecomfortingarms.Thesecanincludenaturalboundariessuchaslandformorchangesoflevel,plantedboundariessuchashedges,andtraditionalwalls.Boundariesareanimportantpartofthesitedesignandshouldbechosentocomplementandenhancethesite.
For‘secure’boundaries,finemeshfencingismorevisuallypermeablethanverticalrailingsandfeelslessrestricting.Thevisualimpactoftallfencingcanbereduced,ifnecessary,byplantingoneitherside.
Thingstoremember
•Makesurethatentrancesarewideenoughforthosewithspecialmobilityrequirements,andthatatactileelementisincludedtoindicatethethresholdtothosewithsightimpairment.Usingarangeofsurfacingmaterialscanalsohelpthosewhoaresightimpaired.
•PathdesignshouldgenerallyfollowtheAccessibilityStandardsdevelopedbytheFieldfareTrustaspartoftheBTCountrysideforAllproject,thoughitmaybeappropriatetodivergefromtheseinsomesituations.
•Wheelchairorscooteruserswillneedsufficientlywidepathswithawell-compactedsurface,shallowgradients,andlevelaccessfromthebuilding.
•Specialcolouredortexturedsurfacingcanhelpsomeusersfindtheirwayroundasiteindependently.SuchsurfacinghasbeenusedatStCatherine’sHospital,Doncaster.
Pilgrim’s Hospice, Canterbury: The Labyrinth garden.
Fine mesh fence at St. Catherine’s, Doncaster.
Cou
rtes
y:R
DaS
HN
HS
Foun
datio
nTr
ust.
51
4.Sitefurniture
Sitefurnitureincludesthefree-standingelementswhich‘furnish’asite–forexampleseating,litterbins,lightingandsigns.Goodsitefurnitureshouldbechosenandlocatedtomeettheparticularneedsofthoseusingthespace.Forexample,theheightanddepthofseatscanmakeabigdifferencetohowusabletheyarebypeoplewithspecificneeds:dotheyneedtohavearms,oraback-rest,oraretheyjusta‘perch’?
Sitefurnitureisusuallyincludedinitiallyforfunctionalreasons,butcarefuldesigncanaddanextradimension–helpingcreateitemsfullofcharacterwhichprovideextrainterestinaspace.Thefurniturecanalsoenhancethe‘senseofplace’–veryimportantinsettingswherepeopleareeffectivelyconfined,eitherbytheirownfrailtyorillness,orforothers’safety.
Bespokeitemshelpspacesfeellessinstitutional.Theymaybemorecostlybutcanbetailoredtotheirlocationandtousers’specificneeds,somayactuallyofferbettervalueformoney.Somebespokeitemscanbeverysimple–attheRoyalEdinburghHospitalin-patientspaintedflower-potsbyhandtocheerupthepatioandseatingareas.
Infacilitiesusedbychildrenandyoungpeopleitisvitallyimportanttocaterforplay–includingbothnaturalfeaturesthatcanbeplayedwith(suchassand,waterandgrassmounds)andpurpose-builtplayequipmentwhereappropriate(suchastheseating,chosenspeciallyforeachsite).Childrenwithimpairedmobilitystillliketoenjoythesameactivitiesasable-bodiedchildren,and,forsome,climbingnetsinaplayspacewillprovideamoreenjoyablewayofstrengtheningmusclesthanphysiotherapyindoors.
Thingstoremember
•Remembertoincludeshadingandshelter–helpingpeopletocopewithphotosensitivityorjusttoavoidashowerofrain.
•Allowspacenexttoaseatforawheelchairorelectricscooter.Wheelchairusersandthosewhofinditdifficulttobenddownalsobenefitfrom‘raised’features,whichshouldbedesignedtoappealtootherstoo(e.g.bydesigningtheedgesothatitmakesaninformalseat).
•Insomeresidentialsettings(e.g.incarehomes)whereresidentsmaywanttousethespaceintheevenings,lightingwillhelpensurethespaceisbothattractivetolookatfrominside,andalsosafetouseafterdark.
Signs are often the first thing people see and designing them so they look friendly will help make everyone relax and feel welcome.
Cou
rtes
y:B
rom
ley
byB
owC
entr
e.
Woven hazel tree seat at Fant Oast Unit, Kent.
52
•Signsneedtobeapproachableandwelcoming.Theabilitytomakeaninformedchoice(e.g.tofolloworavoidaroutewithrough,bumpypaths)iscrucial,andappropriatesignsatthebeginningofrouteshelpthischoicetobemade.
•Seatingshouldbeplacedwheresomeonewouldactuallywanttosit–enclosedtotherear;withsomethingattractivetolookat,andoffthepathtoavoidobstructingotherpeople.
•Seatingshouldpreferablybewoodenwitharmsandbacks(notsteelorconcrete),butcanalsobeanartworkinitsownright,liketheexampleabove.
Seating for Hereford County Hospital.
Seating and lighting café courtyard, Newham Hospital.
In the park behind Bromley by Bow Health Centre, a large sheep doubles as a seat and a sculpture, and at Fant Oast in Maidstone, a Tipi makes a good social space.
Cou
rtes
y:P
ette
rSou
thal
l.
53
5.Art
Artinhealthcaresettingshelpstoprovideaplaceof‘respite’foreveryone.
Artcanprovideafocalpointforaspaceandhelpsengagetheattention.Asabespokeitemitmayhaveparticularandunusualtactileorsensoryqualities;itcanoffersurprise,encouragereflection,andevenprovidehumour.Italsohelpstomakeaspacefeellessinstitutional.Goodquality,carefullylocatedartworkscangreatlyenhanceahealthcaresettingandprovideanincentivebothtoventureoutsideandtospendmoretimeoutsidewhenyougetthere.
Theexperienceofartsmanagerssuggeststhatmorepeoplerespondpositivelytoartworkwhichisrepresentationalratherthanabstract,whereconventionalskillisinevidence,andinparticularwhereimagesofnatureareconcerned.However,moreabstractworkcanalsoprovokeinterestandpositiveresponses–suchastheworkoutsidethechapelatDorsetCountyHospital,basedonthesymbolismofthecircle,andconsideredespeciallyappropriateforthisnon-denominationalspace.
Actuallycreatingartcanbeanotherformoffocusedengagementorpurposefulactivity,likegardening–perhapsitiseventheadultequivalentofchildren’splay.Insomesettingsartistsworkwithpatientsandevenstaff,oftenoutdoors,tocreateitemsthatcanbeexhibitedinsideoroutsidethebuilding.
Thingstoremember
•Artworksshouldrespondtotheopportunitiesofaspecificsite.Byreflectingwhatmakesaspacespecial,theirworkwillenhancethe‘senseofplace’.Artcanalsobeespeciallyhelpfulinurbanareas,addingcharacterwhereasenseofplacemaybelessapparent.
•Inspaceswhichareeasilyaccessibleandthereforehavestrongpotentialfortherapeuticbenefits,artworksshouldbedesignedsoastocreateinviting,habitablespacesandtosupportandencourageaccess.
•Somespacesmightbeinaccessiblebutarestilloverlookedbywardsandcorridorsabove.Theseofferspecialopportunitiestoinstallartworkthatmightnotbesuitableforpubliclyaccessibleareas.
Reminiscent of seed-pods, this artwork adds extra interest to an inaccessible hospital courtyard.C
ourt
esy:
4D
Lan
dsca
peD
esig
n.
54
DorsetCountyHospital(DCH)inDorchesteremploysarttohelphumanisetheoutdoorspaces,makingthehospitalfeellessinstitutional.
Theartworksprovideusefulorientationpointsinwhatisquiteacomplexsitearrangedoverdifferentlevels.
Theyalsohelptocreateadistinctcharacterforeachgardenareaandaddextrainteresttospaceswhichmightbetooshadytospendverylongin,orwhichareinaccessibleanddesignedtobeviewedonlyfrominsidethebuilding.
Outsideoneofthemainentrances,thiskineticstructuredancesunpredictablytotheDorsetseabreezes.Theartworktransformsasmallspaceinaheavilytraffickedareaintosomewherepleasanttositandalsohelpsnewvisitorsorientatethemselvesastheyarriveonsite.
Dorset County Hospital.
There is a dazzlingly wide variety of art at DCH, from temporary installations such as the willow sculptures shown here, to this little dog above by Elizabeth Frink, a former patient at the hospital.
55
6.Water
Thesoundofrunningwaterorthesightofafrogpoisedmotionlessatthepond’sedgecanprovideafocusforagardenspaceallyearround,withthesensoryqualitiesappealingtopeopleofallagesandabilities.Evena‘bubble’fountainisinvitingtothetouch,andasthesedonotusuallyinvolveareasofdeeperwater,mayraisefewerhealthandsafetyissues.
‘Ilikesittinginthegarden,Iwaswatchingtheblackbirdwashinghimselfinthefountaintoday,firstoneleg,thentheother,thenhiswings,hishead!Ohitdoesgivemealaugh...’(ResidentatHarbourHouseResidentialHome,Bridport,2010)
AtSpringfieldUniversityHospitalinLondon,stafffindithelpfultotakepatientsoutintotheextensivegrounds,whichincludeafish-pond,asdescribedbelowbytheActivitiesWorker:
‘PatientKwasdeaf,hadlearningdifficultiesandamentalhealthproblemrelatedtobehaviourissues.Aresidentialplacewasbeingsoughtwhichcouldmeethisneeds,butbecauseofhisbehaviouritwasdifficulttoplacehimanywhere...
PatientKlikedtowatchthefishandtofeedthem,andasawayofbuildinguparelationshipwithhimhewasoftenescortedtothegardensoastofeedthefish.Hewasawarethathewouldnotbe
Resident at Harbour House Residential Home, Bridport.
Formal fountain and fishpond, Springfield Hospital.
Frog in wildlife pond.
56
takenouttothegardentofeedthefishifhisbehaviourwasnotundercontrol,andhebegantomodifyhisbehavioursoastobeabletobetakenouttofeedthefish.Overtimearapportwasbuiltupwithhimsothathewasabletoteachsomeofthestafftosignsoastocommunicatebetterwithhim.Hisbehaviourimprovedsomuchthataspecialistresidentialplacewasfoundforhim,andwhichhewasacceptedfor.’
Eventhosewhoareprofoundlydisabledcanappreciatethesprayofwaterontheirskin,asatTheChildren’sTrustinTadworth,Surrey.
‘OursensoryfountainhasbeenagreateducationaltoolforthelearnersatTheSchoolforProfoundEducation.Ithasanincredibleamountofmulti-sensorybenefits,fromthesightofthewaterarchingverticallyoverthetopofthelearnerastheywalkorarepushedintheirwheelchairalongthepathbetweenthetwojet-streams...
Thewatercanrespondtotheirvoices/vocalisationsastheycommunicateusingthe‘talkie’flowerswhichprojecttheirsoundsacrossthefountain...thefountainisaverysocialspace–classeshavebeenheldthere,musicmakingsessions,aswellasteddybears’picnics!Itisalsoidealasacalmingareaforanylearnerneedingabitoftimeout.’(SteveSnook,Teacher,SchoolforProfoundEducation)
Thingstoremember
•Pondsshouldbedesignedforeitherwildlifeorfish–notboth.
•Thesoundofwatercanbeveryusefulinmaskingnoise,whichhasbeenproventohaveaverynegativeimpactontheperceivedtherapeuticvalueofaspace.
•Waterfeaturesshouldalsobedesignedassimplyaspossibletokeepmaintenancecostsdownandreducewaterusage.
•Peopleoftenassumethatrunningwaterissuitablefordrinking,soifthefeatureiseasilyaccessibleand/orunsupervised,watershouldbefedfromthemainssupply.
•OutbreaksofLegionnaires’diseaseareusuallyassociatedwithcoolingtowers,evaporativecondensersandhotandcoldwatersystems.Theriskofcontractingthediseasefrommostornamentalwaterfeaturessuchaspondsorfountainsislikelytobelowandcanbeminimisedbydesign(e.g.byavoidingthepresenceofshallow,stagnantwater).Aspecificassessmentofriskwillberequired,takingintoaccounttheactualdesignandlocationofthefeature(Legionnaires’disease:aguideforemployers,HSE).
Interactive fountains at The Children’s Trust, Surrey.
Cou
rtes
y:T
heS
choo
lfor
Pro
foun
dEd
ucat
ion.
57
Summary
Allofthedesignelementsdescribedabovehavethepotentialtoaddanewdimensionandextrainteresttospacesdesignedforatherapeuticpurpose.TheChalkhillUnitinSussexincludesmanyofthedesignelementsmentionedaboveandrepresentsahighlycreativeapproachtodesignofbothinternalandexternalspacesonthesite.
TheChalkhillUnitcatersforchildrenandyoungpeoplewithacutementalhealthproblems,andhasbeendesignedtoreflectnature,usingthesurroundingsiteasapalette.Membersofstaffareconvincedthatthenewunitishelpingtospeedtherecoveryoftheyoungsters,astheyappeartoberecoveringmorequicklythansimilarpatientsdidintheformerbuilding.
Theprocessinvolvedcollaborationbetweenarchitects,interiordesignersandlandscapearchitectstocreateafacilitywithafeelingofsafetybutalsofreedomandtranquillity.
Workshopswereconductedwiththosewhoweregoingtousethenewbuilding,toexploretheirattitudestothemes,imagesandcolours.Theyoungsterschosenatureasthegeneralthemeforboththeinteriorandtheoutsidespacesandgardens,astheyfeltthatwoodlandandseasidewereplacestheywantedtobe.Woodlandwasusedasanimportantunifyingdesignelement;forexample,thedesignofthecarpets,curtainsandwallcoveringswasbasedonapatternofleaves.
Designelements
Trees and planting:TheoriginalnativepineheathlandenclosesthesitetothenorthandthereareexpansiveviewsouttothesouththroughthepinestowardstheSouthDowns.Pinetreesclosetothebuildinghavebeenpreserved;theglassentrancedoorsareetchedwithimagesofthesametrees.Neatminiaturepinesgiveacrisptidyminiaturelandscapetothefrontentrance,andwithinthegardens,theplantingisredolentofseasidewithgrassydune-lovingplants.
Entrances, paths and boundaries: Gatesandboundariesarefunctional,attractiveandoftenwooden,makingthemfeelnaturalandlessintrusive.Pathwaysaresimple,eithertarmacordecking,withlargetimberedwoodenseatingandtablessuchasyouwouldfindattheseaside.
Site furniture:Withintheinnercourtyard,thethemeofnaturecontinues.Thereisawoodenboardwalkrunningalonginfrontofjungle-likeplantingoflarge-leaved,exoticplants,leadingtoabeach.Ingoldenconcretethereareripplesjustliketheripplesinsandonasea-sweptshore.Hugerocksprovideseating.
The surrounding pine trees are visible from everywhere on the site and have influenced the design of the interiors in particular.
Case Study 6: Chalkhill Unit, Princess Royal Hospital, Haywards Heath, Sussex.
58
Art and water:Impressedintothesandareimagesofleavesandseacreatures.Theyaresubtleandtakesomefinding.Athree-dimensionalceramicmuralofstreams,animalsandplantsaddscolourandarichtexturetoawall.Onerockhasbeendrilledandpipedtoprovideasafe’wetrock‘waterfeature.Ithelpstocreateanintricatefantasylandscapewithtinytreasurestobediscoveredbyquietexploration.
Alltheelementsofthisunit,throughcarefulconsultationanddesign,combinetoprovideakindof‘escape’fortheinhabitantsoftheunit,whoareoftenconfinedinmorewaysthanone.Theirfunctionwastoactasaportalintoanetherealworldthroughwhichthechildren’smindscouldwander,unboundbytiresomerealities.
Surfaces imprinted with leaves and other objects from the natural world act as reminders of the seaside, and reward curiosity by inviting exploration.
The garden areas are designed with a quiet simplicity which creates a calm, peaceful atmosphere. Natural materials predominate, creating tactile surfaces.
59
Feelinginspired?Howtogetstarted!
Whydesignahealingenvironment?ThiswillindicateyourObjectives.
•Aretherespecificpeoplewhowouldbenefit,suchasstrokeormentalhealthpatients?
•Improvementstothestaffworkingenvironment?
•Makingthesitemoreinvitingandaccessibletothewidercommunity?
Whereisyouropenspace?ThiswillindicateyourpotentialResource.
•Walkaroundyoursite,exploretheperimeter,courtyards,carparksandroofspaces.
•Findasiteplanandannotateopenspaces.
•Geta‘bird’s-eye’view,withonlineaerialmappingtools.
Whatisalreadythereinyouropenspace?ThiswillindicateitscurrentValue.
•Isitpavedorplanted?Arethereanytreesorotherinterestingfeaturesofnote?
•Isit‘openaccess’orlocked,andarethereaccessroutesthroughyourspace?
•Isitnexttowardsoroffices,orspecificservices?
•Isitaplacewherepeopleliketogatherorisitnormallyempty?
Whoisinterested,orcouldbeengaged?ThiswillindicateyourTeam.
•Thinkofmedicalandancillarystaffwhomightuseopenspaces.
•Thinkofpatientgroupswhowouldbecapableofparticipating,visitorsandfriendsgroups.
•Supportoftheseniormanagementteam,andthefacilitiesorestatesmanagers,willbeessentialfortheprojecttosucceed.
Howdoyoubegin?ThiswillindicateyourPlan.
•UseyourlocalStrategicHealthNeedsAssessmentasaleverforimplementinggreenspace/treeplantingproposals.
•Getyourteamtogetherandbrainstormwhatcouldbedone.
•Considersourcesoffunding.
•Seewhatotherplacesaredoing,visittheNHSForestwebsite.
•Makesureyoucommunicateyourideastoyourcolleaguesandthewiderpublic.
Whenwillithappen?ThiswillindicateyourTimetable.
•Youdonothavetodoitallinonego:considerphasinginmanageableblocks.
•Startwiththeeasybits,maybebird-boxesorplantingsomebeds.
•Tidyingupthelitterimmediatelymakesaplacelookmorecaredfor.
•Simply‘signing’existingopenspaces,sopeopleknowwheretheyare,andwhattheyarecalled,wouldhelptomakethemostofwhatyoualreadyhave.
Gettingstartedmightbeassimpleasplantingafewfruittrees,orsomebulbs,orallowingsomeofthegrasstogrowalittlelonger.Anexampleofapossibleprojectlikethisisshownopposite.
60
Improving an area on a hospital or health centre site needn’t be complicated or expensive. This scheme would include some new cherry trees and bulb planting, along with a reduction in frequency of mowing to allow the bulbs time to flower and to establish.
Before and after of improved hospital area.
Seat now looks onto trees rather than just other buildings
Close-mown grass verge makes the area look well cared for
Trees could be set in longer meadow grass, with bulbs
Flowering cherry trees chosen for spring blossom and autumn colour as well as fruit for the birds
61
ForestryCommissionpublications
–A marvellous opportunity for children to learn: A participatory evaluation of Forest School in England and Wales(FCRP009)
FororderinginformationanddetailsofthisandotherForestryCommissionpublications,visittheonlinepublicationscatalogueatwww.forestry.gov.uk/publications
ForestryCommissionwebsites
– Forinformationonthe case for trees in development and the urban environment:www.forestry.gov.uk/thecasefortrees
– Forresearchinformationonthesocial aspects of forestry: www.forestry.gov.uk/fr/peopleandtrees
Thefollowingreportsareavailabletoviewanddownloadfromthiswebsite:
•Treesandwoodlands,nature’shealthservice
•UrbanhealthandhealthinequalitiesandtheroleofurbanforestryinBritain:areview
•Asortofmagicalplace:people’sexperienceofwoodlandsinnorthwestandsoutheastEngland
Otherpublications
BritishMedicalAssociation– The psychological and social needs of patients, 2011
BTCV– Green gym national evaluation report, 2008
CABE– Future health, sustainable places for health and wellbeing, 2009– The role of hospital design in the recruitment, retention and performance of NHS nurses
in England, 2004– The value of public space, 2004
DepartmentofHealth– Heatwave Plan for England, 2010– NHS health and well-being: Boorman Review, 2009
FacultyofPublicHealth– Great Outdoors: how our Natural Health Service uses green space to improve wellbeing, 2010
ForumfortheFuture– The health system in 2025, a vision of health and sustainability in England, 2009
HealthandSafetyExecutive– Legionnaires’ Disease: a guide for employers, 2006
Further reading and useful sources of information
62
HealthResearchForum– Sunlight Robbery: Vitamin D and Public Health, 2010
King’sFund– Enhancing the Healing Environment, a guide for NHS trusts, 2004– Improving the patient experience, celebrating achievement: Enhancing the Healing
Environment Programme 2003–2005 – Improving the patient experience, sharing success in mental health & learning disabilities,
2008
MIND– Ecotherapy – the green agenda for mental health, 2007
NHS– Saving carbon, improving health – update, 2010. Sustainable Development Unit.– The architectural healthcare environment and its effects on patient health outcomes, 2004
RSPB– Natural thinking: investigating the links between the natural environment, biodiversity and
mental health, 2007– Natural Fit: can green space and biodiversity increase levels of physical activity? 2004
ScottishNaturalHeritage– Health and the natural heritage – the evidence base, 2009
SustainableDevelopmentCommission– Health, place and nature: how outdoor environments influence health and wellbeing –
a knowledge base, 2008
TheCenterforHealthDesign– A visual reference for evidence-based design, 2008
TheScottishGovernment– Good places, better health, 2008
TreesandDesignActionGroup– No trees no future, 2010
USDepartmentofAgriculture,ForestService,NorthernResearchStation– Restorative commons: creating health and well-being through urban landscapes, 2009
Researcharticlesandotherliterature
APPLETON,J.(1975).Theexperienceoflandscape.JohnWiley,London.BERMAN,M.G.,JONIDES,J.andKAPLAN,S.(2008).Thecognitivebenefitsofinteractingwith
nature.PsychologicalScience,19(12),1207–12.BINGLEY,A.F.ANDMILLIGAN,C.(2004).Climbingtreesandbuildingdens:mentalhealthandwell-
beinginyoungadultsandthelong-termeffectsofchildhoodplayexperience.Endofprojectreport.CJCCONSULTING(2005).Economicbenefitsofaccessiblegreenspacesforphysicalandmental
health:scopingstudy.FinalreportfortheForestryCommission.COOPERMARCUS,C.(2005).Healinggardensinhospitals.In:C.Wagenaared.Thearchitectureof
hospitals.NAiPublishers,Rotterdam.
63
COOPERMARCUS,C.andBARNES,M.(1999).EvaluationsofsixChicagohospitalgardensforHitchcockDesigns.Un-published.
COOPERMARCUS,C.andBARNES,M.eds.(1999).Healinggardens:therapeuticbenefits&designrecommendations.JohnWiley,NewYork.
CROUCHER,K.,MYERS,L.andBRETHERTON,J.(2007).Thelinksbetweengreenspaceandhealth:acriticalliteraturereview.GreenspaceScotland,Stirling.
DAY,R.(2008).Localenvironmentsandolderpeople’shealth:dimensionsfromacomparativequalitativestudyinScotland.HealthandPlace,14,299–312.
GRAHN,P.,BENGTSSON,I.,WELEN-ANDERSSON,L.,LAVESSON,L.,LINDFORS,L.,TAUCHNITZ,F.andTENNGART,C.,(2007).Alnarprehabilitationgarden:possiblehealtheffectsfromthedesign,fromtheactivitiesandfromthetherapeuticteam.SwedishUniversityofAgriculturalSciences,Uppsala.
KAPLAN,R.andKAPLAN,S.(1989).Theexperienceofnature:apsychologicalperspective.CambridgeUniversityPress,Cambridge,Massachusetts.
KELLERT,S.andWILSON,E.(1993).Thebiophiliahypothesis.IslandPress,WashingtonD.C.KUO,F.andFABERTAYLOR,A.(2004).Apotentialnaturaltreatmentforattention-deficit
hyperactivitydisorder:evidencefromanationalstudy.AmericanJournalofPublicHealth,2004,94 (9),1580–6.
LAWSON,B.(2005).Evidence-baseddesignforhealthcare.TouchBriefings,BusinessBriefing:HospitalEngineeringandFacilitiesManagement,2,25–27.
LAWSON,B.(2006).EffectiveNHShospitaldesign.Presentation.LI,Q.andKAWADA,T.(2010).Healthyforestparksenhancehumanimmunefunction.Nippon
MedicalSchool,Tokyo.MALENBAUM,S.,KEEFE,F.J.,WILLIAMS,A.C.,ULRICH,R.andSOMERS,T.J.(2008).Paininits
environmentalcontext:Implicationsfordesigningenvironmentstoenhancepaincontrol.Pain,134 (3),241–4.
NILSSON,K.,SANGSTER,M.,GALLIS,C.,HARTIG,T.,DEVRIES,S.,SEELAND,K.andSCHIPPERIJN,J.eds.(2011).Forests,trees&humanhealth.Springer,Dordrecht.
PARK,B.,TSUNETSUGU,Y.,KASETANI,T.,KAGAWA,T.andMIYAZAKI,Y.(2010).ThephysiologicaleffectsofShinrin-yoku(takingintheforestatmosphereorforestbathing):evidencefromfieldexperimentsin24forestsacrossJapan.EnvironmentalHealth&PreventiveMedicine,15 (1),18–26.
PRETTY,J.(2004).Hownaturecontributestomentalandphysicalhealth.SpiritualityandHealthInternational,5 (2),68–78.
PRETTY,J.,ANGUS,C.,BAIN,M.,BARTON,J.,GLADWELL,V.,HINE,R.,PILGRIM,S.,SANDERCOCK,S.andSELLENS,M.(2009).Nature,Childhood,HealthandLifePathways.InterdisciplinaryCentreforEnvironmentandSociety,UniversityofEssex,Colchester.
READ,D.J.,FREER-SMITH,P.H.,MORISON,J.I.L.,HANLEY,N.,WEST,C.C.andSNOWDON,P.eds.(2009).Combatingclimatechange–aroleforUKforests.AnassessmentofthepotentialoftheUK’streesandwoodlandstomitigateandadapttoclimatechange.TheStationaryOffice,Edinburgh.
REFORESTINGSCOTLAND(2008).TheimpactofworkingandwalkinginBlarbuiewoodlandatArgyllandButeHospitalonmentalhealthandwellbeing.ReforestingScotland,Edinburgh.
SEMPIK,J.,ALDRIDGE,J.andBECKER,S.(2005).Health,well-beingandsocialinclusion:therapeutichorticultureintheUK.Thrive,Reading.
STERNBERG,E.(2009).Healingspaces:thescienceofplaceandwell-being.BelknapPressofHarvardUniversityPress,Cambridge,Massachusetts.
STONEHAM,J.andTHODAY,P.(1994).Landscapedesignforelderlyanddisabledpeople.PackardPublishing,Chichester.
ULRICH,R.(1984).Viewthroughawindowmayinfluencerecoveryfromsurgery.Science,224,420–1.ULRICH,R.(2002).Healthbenefitsofgardensinhospitals.PlantsforPeople,International
ExhibitionFloriade,TheNetherlands.ULRICH,R.,ZIMRING,C.,ZHU,X.,DUBOSE,J.,SEO,H.,CHOI,Y.,QUAN,X.andJOSEPH,A.
(2008).Areviewoftheresearchliteratureonevidence-basedhealthcaredesign.TheCentreforHealthDesign,Concord,California.
64
WHITEHOUSE,S.,VARNI,J.W.,SEID,M.,COOPERMARCUS,C.,ENSBERG,M.J.,andJACOBS,J.R.(2001).Evaluatingachildren’shospitalgardenenvironment:utilizationandconsumersatisfaction.JournalofEnvironmentalPsychology,21 (3),301–14.
Websites
– Architecture+DesignScotland:www.ads.org.uk– ArtCare,Salisbury:www.artcare.salisbury.nhs.uk– BiodiversityActionPlan(UK):www.jncc.defra.gov.uk– BuildingBetterHeathcare(providesthehealthcarebuildingcommunitywiththelatestnews,
andguidanceonhealthcareestatesandfacilities): www.bbhealthcare.co.uk– BTCV(BritishTrustforConservationVolunteers):www.btcv.org – CentreforSustainableHealthcare:www.sustainablehealthcare.org.uk– DesignCouncil(forinformationonCommissionforArchitectureandtheBuiltEnvironment,
CABE):www.designcouncil.org.uk – EnhancingtheHealingEnvironment: www.enhancingthehealingenvironment.org.uk– FieldfareTrust(promotingcountrysideaccessfordisabledpeople,andtheAccessforAll
Standards):www.fieldfare.org.uk– ForestryCommission:www.forestry.gov.uk– ForestryResearch:www.forestry.gov.uk/forestresearch– GlasgowHomoeopathicHospital: www.ghh.info– GreenspaceScotland:www.greenspacescotland.org.uk– InformeDesign(evidence-baseddesigntool):www.informedesign.umn.edu– KIDS(workswithdisabledchildren,youngpeopleandtheirfamilies):www.kids.org.uk– LivingMedicine(workingtoconnectpeopleandplantsforhealth): www.livingmedicine.org– MaggiesCancerCaringCentres:www.maggiescentres.org– NHSForest:www.nhsforest.org– OPENspace(researchcentreforinclusiveaccesstooutdoorenvironments):
www.openspace.eca.ac.uk– Outdoors&HealthNetwork:www.outdoorshealthnetwork.co.uk– PeckhamExperiment(astudyintothenatureofhealth):www.thephf.org– Planetree(anorganisationfacilitatingeffortstocreatepatientcentredcareinhealing
environments):www.planetree.org– QuietGardenMovement:www.quietgarden.org– ReforestingScotland(networkinvolvedinrestoringScotland’sforestcoverandculture):
www.reforestingscotland.org– SensoryTrust(creatinginclusiveenvironments):www.sensorytrust.org.uk– SocialCareInstituteforExcellence(anindependentcharityimprovingthelivesofpeoplewho
usecareservicesbysharingknowledgeaboutwhatworks):www.scie.org.uk– TheBigTreePlant:http://thebigtreeplant.direct.gov.uk– TherapeuticLandscapesNetwork:www.healinglandscapes.org– TheWildlifeTrusts:www.wildlifetrusts.org– WalkingforHealth: www.wfh.naturalengland.org.uk– WoodlandTrust:www.woodlandtrust.org.uk– WorldHealthDesign(subscriptionbasedjournalandwebresource,promotingexcellencein
thefieldofdesignandhealth):www.worldhealthdesign.com
65
AlderHeyChildren’sHospital,LiverpoolArgyllandButeHospital,Lochgilphead,Argyll
BromleybyBowCentre,LondonBroomfieldHospital,Chelmsford,EssexCastleHillHospitalandOncologyUnit,HullChalkhillUnit,PrincessRoyalHospital,WestSussexChelseaandWestminsterHospital,LondonCreativeSpacesProject,Cornwall(CornwallCare)CulmValleyIntegratedCentreforHealth,DevonDorsetCountyHospital,DorsetEnniskillenHospital,CountyofFermanagh,NorthernIrelandFantOastAdolescentUnit,KentForthValleyRoyalHospital,StirlingshireGlasgowHomoeopathicHospital(GartnavelGeneralHospitalsite),GlasgowGreatOrmondStreetHospital,LondonHarbourHouseResidentialHome,DorsetHelen&DouglasHouse,OxfordHerefordCountyHospital,HerefordHullRoyalInfirmary,HullJosephWeldHospice,DorsetLambethCommunityCareCentre,LondonMaggie’sCancerCaringCentre,CharingCrossHospital,LondonMaggie’sCancerCaringCentre,OxfordMaggie’sNorthEast,NewcastleNewhamUniversityHospital,LondonNinewellsHospital,DundeeNorthernGeneralHospital,SheffieldOrchardRespiteCentre,Blackrock,Co.Dublin
PilgrimsHospice,Ashford,KentPilgrimsHospice,Canterbury,KentPilgrimsHospice,Thanet,KentPulrossCentre,LondonQueenElizabethHospital,Woolwich,London
RoyalEdinburghHospital,EdinburghRoyalHallamshireHospital,Sheffield
Appendix 1 – Researched sites
66
SalisburyDistrictHospital,Wiltshire
SchoolforProfoundEducation,TheChildren’sTrust,SurreySecondRhonddaHospital,Llwynypia,WalesSpringfieldUniversityHospital,LondonStCatherine’s,Rotherham,Doncaster,andSouthHumberNHSFoundationTrust,YorkshireTheChildren’sTrust,SurreyTivertonandDistrictHospital,DevonTodmordenHealthCentre,LancashireTrevarnaCareHome,CornwallVerwoodOpportunityCentre,DorsetWandsworthRecoveryCentre,SpringfieldUniversityHospital,LondonWarnefordMeadow,OxfordWhitfieldRuralActivityCentre,DorsetWillitonCommunityHospital,Somerset
67
Should patients with dementia be allowed free access to the garden?
Issue Commentary Evidence
Health benefits
• Greater mental stimulation from access to outdoors helps delay further mental deterioration
• Continuing practice in walking over different surfaces and textures prolongs mobility
• Access to sunshine increases manufacture by body of Vitamin D and this has consequential beneficial effects with regard to other conditions
• Everyday experience and observation
• Medical literature
Risks • Risk of falls• Risk of minor injuries• Lesser risk of more serious injuries, for example
long bone fractures• Risk of claims, litigation and loss of reputation
• Everyday experience and observation
• Information about claims from colleagues and professional networks
Expert views • Health and safety department have inspected site and found it to be free from obvious trip hazards
• Positive attitudes from occupational therapy and physiotherapy staff
• Health and safety department report on site
• Interviews with occupational therapy and physiotherapy staff
Relevant local factors
• Garden is completely visible from main building and in full view of the staff inside
• Sightlines and staff rotas have all been checked
Options and their costs
Pros and cons
• Continue to allow free access for all who are physically mobile enough
• Cordon off part of the garden for those who are most frail to use
• Stop access completely for the most frail• Financial costs of any action will be low
• Sectioning off garden may have negative impacts for other users
• Removing access will have major dis-benefits for health of key patient group
• Maintaining free access will help the occupational therapy team continue to make full and accurate assessments of patients’ capabilities
• No new information – pros and cons to be discussed and weighed up
Precedents / comparisons
• The Foundation Trust has other sites where this type of free access has worked successfully for this patient group
• Trust management
Risk-benefit judgement
• In general benefits greatly outweigh risks; however, the risks need to be managed
• Ensure all staff are aware of access regime and the need to be aware of patients’ movements
• Most vulnerable patients to be identified and staff to be made aware of these as they will be monitored more closely than others
Implementing judgement locally
• Consider publicising the decision within Trust newsletter
• Make policy clear to all staff and to families of patients
• Support will be needed from the Trust
Appendix 2 – Sample risk-benefit assessment for a community hospital
68
Notesanddesignideas
69
70
The guidance set out in this Practice Guide represents a step forward in our thinking about
the benefits of the outdoors for health and well-being. It aims to inspire everyone involved
with outdoor spaces in healthcare settings to think how they could be used for therapeutic
purposes. Focusing on outdoor spaces across the NHS estate, the guidance is relevant to
the full range of facilities, from the largest hospital to the smallest health centre. It also has
a wider application wherever health and well-being is important, for example in places
such as care homes and special schools. The Guide has been designed to be accessible to a
non-technical audience, and will be of interest to those engaged with policy, and everyone
interested in improving patient care – whether they deal directly with patients, or focus
on grounds management. It will act as a good introduction for those new to the field, but
many professionals already working in ‘therapeutic landscapes’ will also find it of interest.
This Practice Guide introduces the principles and practical methods for collecting, storing
and propagating from seed a wide range of woody species commonly grown in the British
Isles. It is aimed partly at anyone interested in raising a relatively small number of plants,
and partly at commercial growers – as a useful reference but without the legal aspects. The
Guide begins with information on flowering and fruit development, and recommendations
for small–scale collecting, handling and processing. It then provides detailed advice on
storage, dormancy and pretreatment methods for over 100 woody species. It gives
suggestions of ‘things to try’ to hasten dormancy breakage in the most time consuming and
dormant species. The Guide concludes with some tips on sowing seeds and raising seedlings.
231 Corstorphine RoadEdinburghEH12 7AT
www.forestry.gov.uk£13.50
sustainablehealthcare
centre for
inspire • empower • transform
sustainablehealthcare
centre for
Recommended