GALILEO POSITIONING EVOLUTION - orbi.uliege.be · Galileo signals vs GPS signals • SPP : still...

Preview:

Citation preview

GALILEO: POSITIONING EVOLUTION

Deprez CécilePhD CandidateUniversity of Liège

2005 - 2008DEVELOPMENT

SYSTEM TESTED

GIOVE A – B

2013IN-ORBIT

VALIDATION PHASE

4 IOV satellitesInitial ground infrastructure

ESA imagesESA images

2016INITIAL GALILEO

SERVICES

OS, SAR, PRS, CS demonstration

GSA image

2014 - 19DEPLOYMENT PHASE

FOC system deployment

2020FULL OPERATIONAL CAPABILITY

24 operational satellites+

6 spares satellites +

Complete ground infrastructure

ESA images

ESA images

IOV FOCTEST PROTOTYPES

GIOVE-B

30

25

20

5

0

15

10

EVOLUTION OF # SATELLITES

201120082005 2012 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

GIOVE-A

2006 2007 2009 2010 2013

4 satellites = positioning possible

24 4

6

12

18

22

26

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

FOC

E7 -

E3

E4 -

E5

FOC

E21

–E2

5

E27

–E3

1

Posi

tio

nin

g n

on

ava

ilab

le

FOC

E36

E1

5 –

E33

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

2014

Elev min: 0°

December 10, 2014

0

Observation duration: 24h

Mean # of satellites: 11

GPS

Observation duration: 1h56

Mean # of satellites: 4

Galileo

24 hours of data

16

14

12

10

8

6

4

2

0

# sa

telli

tes

5 visible satellites

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Observation duration: 3h25

Mean # of satellites: 4.2

Galileo

2015

Elev min: 0°

December 27, 2015

0

Observation duration: 24h

Mean # of satellites: 11.3

GPS

24 hours of data

16

14

12

10

8

6

4

2

0

# sa

telli

tes

9 visible satellites

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

2016

Elev min: 0°

Observation duration: 24h

Mean # of satellites: 11.3

December 1, 2016GPS

Observation duration: 18h55

Mean # of satellites: 4.8

Galileo

024 hours of data

16

14

12

10

8

6

4

2

0

# sa

telli

tes

13 visible satellites

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

2017

Elev min: 0°

November 16, 2017

0

Observation duration: 24h

Mean # of satellites: 11.3

GPS

Observation duration: 22h43

Mean # of satellites: 6.2

Galileo

24 hours of data

16

14

12

10

8

6

4

2

0

# sa

telli

tes

17 visible satellites

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

2018

Elev min: 0°

October 15, 2018

Observation duration: 24h

Mean # of satellites: 11.1

GPS

Observation duration: 24h

Mean # of satellites: 7.4

Galileo

24 hours of data

16

14

12

10

8

6

4

2

0

# sa

telli

tes

24 visible satellites

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Observation duration improvement over years

Ho

urs

Summary:

1.93.4

18.9

22.224

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

24 visible satellites : 24h observation!

2018 conclusions :

Average # visible satellites/day : 7.4

• Min # visible satellites : 5

• Max # visible satellites : 10[GPS : 16]

[GPS : 7]

Positioning with Galileo-only possible anytime during the day

Observation durationH

ou

rs

[GPS : 11.3]

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Evolution of the mean # satellites visible/day over 10 days in 2018:

Days of Year 2018

# sa

telli

tes

Mean: 7.27

Galileo = 10 days periodicity

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

30

25

20

5

0

15

10

EVOLUTION OF GEOMETRY [PDOP]

2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

PDOP # sat

Increase in # satellites improves geometry

Precision of positioning improved : .POS OBS DOP

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Galileo E1 Galileo E5a Galileo E5b Galileo E5a+b

Galileo E6

SignalsAll users

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Signal quality :

Cen

tim

etre

s

Codes

GPS

Galileo

L1 L5 L2

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Short baseline (5.6 m)between two Septentrio X4connected to two choke ring Trimble antennas

Signal quality :

Mill

imet

res

GPS

Galileo

Phases

L1 L5 L2

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Short baseline (5.6 m)between two Septentrio X4connected to two choke ring Trimble antennas

Positioning techniques

Codes Phases

One receiverSingle Point

Positioning (SPP)Precise Point

Positioning (PPP)

Expected 3D precision ~ 5-20 m ~ 0.01 m

Two receivers DGNSS (DGPS)Real Time Kinematic

(RTK)

Expected 3D precision ~ 1-3 m ~ 0.10 m

Values given in reference to ellipsoid WGS84

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Short baseline (5.6 m)between two Trimble NetR9connected to two choke ring Trimble antennas

Positioning with Galileo SPP

Galileo E1:

Galileo E1Position 3D: 10.79 m

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Positioning with Galileo SPP

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Satellite Galileo E24 degrades positioning with Galileo!

Positioning with Galileo SPP

Galileo E1:

Galileo E1Position 3D: 4.96 m

Satellite Galileo E24 removed !

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Positioning with GPS SPP

Galileo E1:

Galileo E1Position 3D: 4.96 m

GPS L1Position 3D: 4.33 mGPS L1:

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Positioning with Galileo + GPS SPP

Galileo E1+

GPS L1 :

Galileo E1 +

GPS L1

Position 3D: 3.32 m

Satellite Galileo E24 removed !

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

SPP

Galileo E1 +

GPS L1

Position 3D: 6.12 m

SPP DGPS

1 m1 m

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

DGPSPositioning with Galileo

1 m

Galileo E1:

Galileo E1Position 2D: 0.72 mPosition 3D: 1.13 m

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

DGPSPositioning with Galileo

Galileo E1:

Galileo E1Position 2D: 0.71 mPosition 3D: 1.10 m

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Satellite Galileo E24 removed

DGPSPositioning with Galileo

Galileo E1:

Galileo E5aPosition 2D: 0.55 mPosition 3D: 0.86 m

Galileo E5a:

Galileo E1Position 2D: 0.71 mPosition 3D: 1.10 m

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Satellite Galileo E24 removed

DGPSPositioning with Galileo

Galileo E1:

Galileo E5a+bPosition 2D: 0.16 mPosition 3D: 0.25 m

Galileo E5a+b:

Galileo E1Position 2D: 0.72 mPosition 3D: 1.13 m

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Satellite Galileo E24 removed

DGPS

Galileo E1:

GPS L1Position 2D: 0.81 mPosition 3D: 1.32 m

Galileo E1Position 2D: 0.72 mPosition 3D: 1.13 m

Positioning with GPS

GPS L1:

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

DGPSPositioning with Galileo + GPS

Galileo E1+

GPS L1 :

Galileo E1 +

GPS L1

Position 2D: 0.43 mPosition 3D: 0.85 m

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Satellite Galileo E24 removed

DGPSPositioning with Galileo + GPS

Galileo E5a+

GPS L5 :

Galileo E5a +

GPS L5

Position 2D: 0.45 mPosition 3D: 0.73 m

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Satellite Galileo E24 removed

RTKDGPS RTK

1 m 1 m

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Positioning with Galileo RTK

1 m

Galileo E1Position 2D: 0.29 mPosition 3D: 0.37 m

Galileo E1:

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Satellite Galileo E24 removed

Positioning with Galileo RTK

Galileo E5:Galileo E5a+bPosition 2D: 0.26 mPosition 3D: 0.33 m

Galileo E5a+b:

Galileo E1Position 2D: 0.29 mPosition 3D: 0.37 m

Galileo E1:

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Satellite Galileo E24 removed

Positioning with GPS RTK

Galileo E1Position 2D: 0.29 mPosition 3D: 0.37 m

Galileo E1:

GPS L1Position 2D: 0.17 mPosition 3D: 0.22 m

GPS L1:

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Positioning with Galileo + GPS RTK

Galileo E1+

GPS L1 :

Galileo E1 +

GPS L1

Position 2D: 0.10 mPosition 3D: 0.15 m

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Satellite Galileo E24 removed

Positioning with Galileo possible all day

CONCLUSIONS

Galileo signals vs GPS signals

• SPP : still affected by Galileo low number of satellites (higher PDOP than GPS)

Quality of positioning with Galileo-only

• Similar precisions for codes and phases

• Code signal Galileo E5a+b exceptional

• DGPS : Similar values of accuracy for both GPS & Galileo

• RTK: Similar values of accuracy for both GPS & Galileo

GPS + Galileo combination improves both GPS-only and Galileo-only solutionsAM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -

cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Cécile DeprezDoctorante en GNSS et géodésieUnité de Géomatique - Université de Liège

Phone : +32 4 366 58 80Email: cecile.deprez@uliege.beLinkedIn

CONTACT

AM/FM GIS Belux & Flagis 25/10/2018 - Cécile Deprez, ULiège -cecile.deprez@uliege.be

Recommended