Evaluation by Intuition

EVALUATION BY INTUITIONNanna ManKTM8 Feb 2012

Without an evaluation, a speech is a waste!

Evaluation is not as difficult as you think!!

DOES ANYONE KNOW HOW TO COOK PEKING DUCK?

No project level requirement at all.

You don’t need to master all the speaking skill before you take the evaluation role.

Everyone has his/her unique point of view.

MYTH NO.1 : I’M NOT QUALIFIED TO BE AN EVALUATOR!!!!

MYTHS NO.2: I CAN’T THINK OF A SINGLE POINT TO EVALUATE!!! What are the 2 major elements of Evaluation? - Good points - Bad points/ room for improvement /

suggestions

Intuition = Immediate feeling

Feel it. Describe it.

Give reason.

Feeling: I get lost in the speech! I even

don’t understand the speech!

Feeling : Uncomfortable! Discriminated! Bored!

MYTHS NO.3: I CAN’T FORMULATE A 2.5 MINS EVALUATION SPEECH IN SUCH A SHORT TIME!!! Cut them into pieces

Opening : 15 secondsGood pt.1 : 30 secondsGood pt. 2 : 30 seconds

Room for improvement 1: 30 secondsRoom for improvement 2: 30 secondsConclusion : 15 seconds

2.5 minutes

Feeling Reason Suggestion Time

Opening 15 s’

Good pt1 ---- 30 s’

Good pt 2 ---- 30 s’

Room for improvement 1

30 s’

Room for improvement 2

30 s’

Conclusion 15 s’

2.5 mins

Feeling Reason Suggestion

Opening 15s’

Good pt 1 (on Content) ---- 30s’

Good pt 2 (on Delivery Skill) ---- 30s’

Room for improvement 1(on Content)

30s’

Room for improvement 2(on Delivery Skill)

30s’

Conclusion ( highlight the good pt. again!)

15s’

2.5 mins

MYTHS NO.4 : I DON’T KNOW HOW TO EXPRESS MY FEELING! Choice of words: (for good point) In PC Speech,- I like the most is….- I enjoy the most is………/ the most enjoyable part

is…- Impressed me the most is…/ the most impressive

part is….- I appreciate the most is…- I was touched / moved by….- XXX is the very thing captured my attention…- XXXX is very attractive/ appealing to me….

Choice of words: (for room for improvement)- It would be better if ….- You may consider…- I would suggest…..- I would challenge you on…..- An alternative way for you to consider

is….Practice!

Feel it! See it ! Hear it!Give a reason.Give Suggestion.

Useful Tips Review the speech project objectives.Talk with the speaker to find out which

skills or techniques the speaker hopes to strengthen through the speech.

Please sign up the Evaluator role!!!!!!!

Thanks you!