Epidemiology of ECC & Effectiveness of Interventions

1

Epidemiology of ECC &Effectiveness of Interventions

Oct 20, 2010Ananda P. Dasanayake, BDS, MPH, Ph.D, FACE

Professor & Director, Graduate Program in Clinical ResearchNew York University College of Dentistry

Charge

• What’s in a name?

•ECC, S-ECC etc.,

• How much of it is out there?

•Prevalence & morbidity

• How can we prevent/reduce it?

•Summary of intervention approaches

• Based on all of the above, now what?

•Our priorities

2

3

Over the last 5 decades, tooth decay that initially attack themaxillary primary incisors have been referred to as :

•Labial caries•Caries of the incisors•Rampant caries•Nursing bottle caries•Nursing caries•Baby bottle tooth decay•Maxillary anterior caries•Early childhood caries•Severe early childhood caries•Rampant infant and early childhood dental decay

"What's in a name? That which we call a roseby any other name….."

ECC/S-ECC Definitions overthe years…

• One maxillary incisor with caries

• At least one maxillary incisor with caries

• Two or more primary ‘upper front teeth’ with caries

• Three decayed maxillary incisors with caries onbuccal surfaces and confirmed by child’s eatingand feeding habits

• Three or maxillary incisors with caries etc., etc.,

4

5

• Are we capturing the ‘same disease’ with thesevarious definitions?

• Are we or is our progress limited by our owndefinitions?

• Do we need a different metric to capturethe true essence?• A composite of number of lesions, age of onset

(induction/incubation), and rate of progression? Wouldyou add ‘exposure’ to the ‘disease’ definition?

Definition Concerns

6

ECC: At least 1 primary tooth surface that is either filled, missingdue to caries, or has a cavity or a non-cavitated lesion in a child whois 71 months old or younger.

S-ECC: Any sign of smooth surface caries in 36-month old oryounger children.

S-ECC in 3-5 year olds: At least 1 primary maxillary anteriorsmooth surface that is either cavitated, filled, or missing due tocaries or more than 4-6 decayed, missing, or filled surfaces in themouth.

Current Definitions

7

Potential challenges in using these definitions…

•Validity of non-cavitated lesion detection•Distinction between esthetic fillings and fillings due to caries•Determination of missing due to caries

8

10/28/2010 Dasanayake 9

Sharp Eyes and No Probes..

System Sensitivity Specificity

Explorer 60.5 87.4

Visual(University)

65.0 82.5

Visual (PrivatePractice)

61.8 83.3

Lussi, A. Caries Res 1991:25:296-303

10/28/2010 Dasanayake 10

is there a considerablesubmerged part?

Using these definitions, when wesay prevalence of ECC is x% in a

given population

Before we look at ECC/S-ECC prevalence…

11

2.9 3.2 3.3 2.7

45.8

38

0

10

20

30

40

50

Mea

n2-11 dfs 6-19 DMFS >=20 DMFS

88-94 99-02

N=2,663 2-5 year olds, Biased Sample, No Calibration

12

11.1

14.6

Why? Are we capturing the true essence?

Average Caries Burden Over Time

13

How is this compared to nationalobjectives?

14

How can we move forward?

Caries in AI/AN Children and HP2010

15

16

Any child age 5 years or younger with decayon their upper front teeth or six or more teeth with

decay is considered to have severe ECC.

(1999 IHS Survey Definition)

ECC/S-ECC among AI/AN Children

17

ECC/S-ECC Prevalence – IHS 1999

Approximately 6/10 children < 5 years of age

18

Is ECC/S-ECC Also Changing Over Time?

19

Is ECC/S-ECC a Different Disease Entity?

•AI/AN children acquire Hib earlier than the U.S. population•As a result, a second generation 4-dose vaccine given at 2, 4,6, and 15 months did eliminate Hib in the general populationbut not in the AI/AN children•A new vaccine that was immunogenic as early as 2 monthsbrought a 99% reduction in Hib meningitis in AI/AN children

20

• If the disease trend is on the up rise, why?• Is the estimate that 60% prevalence of ECC/S-ECC in 2-5 year old AI/AN children similar to that

in the general AI/AN children population ofsame age?

• What proportion of children with ECC/S-ECCreceive care?

• What proportion ends up in the OR?• Any other associated morbidities/mortalities?

Some Additional Questions

21

Number of Medicaid claims/1000 for children 24-35months of age by state and race/ethnicity

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

NHW AI/AN NHW AI/AN Hispanic NHW AI/AN Hispanic

AK NM OK

Restoration

Crown

Pulp Tx

Extraction

Sedation

Junhie Oh & Dee Robertson

10/28/2010 Dasanayake 22

Can this be fatal?

Burden of Inadequate Accessto Care

23

24

How can we do this?

ECC Prevention Strategies…• Reducing the microbial burden

• Increasing the resistance of teeth

• Water fluoridation

• Prenatal fluoride

• Topical fluoride

• Fluoride toothpaste

• Reduce prenatal challenges that might lead tohypoplasia?

• Reducing the availability of refinedcarbohydrates

• Combination 25

10/28/2010 26

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

3T 6M 7M 12M 18M 24M 36M

log

(10

)M

S

Treatment Control* P < 0.05Mixed Model: Group x Time (p=0.0002)

** *

10/28/2010 27

The Effect of Chlorhexidine Varnish onCaries Increment in Children

2.5

3.8

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

dfs

Treatment Control

*NS

Power, timing, agent, dose, and frequency, effect onother cariogenic flora, target? MS is just onemember of the biofilm environment

28

Results

Glass half-full: Promising findings, Xylitol application canbe routine, yet 24-42% still got caries despite the treatment.

Intervention: (mean age 1.8 yrs)•All in a fluoridated community•All got counseling•Three arms:

•4 applications of 0.1 mLDuraphat per arch @ 0, 6,12, & 18 months•2 applications @ 0 & 12months•Counseling only

31

RCT in 0-5 year olds

32

RCTs in 0-5 year olds

Now what?

• We need to re-visit our current definitions

• Using a ‘new definition’, we need to get a validestimate of the disease burden

• Further understanding of the real causal factors

• One-Size-Fits-All prevention approaches may notwork and there are no Silver Bullets

• Solution? Culturally appropriate innovativeprevention strategies based on the populationspecific patho-physiology and the commonrisk factor approach?

33

10/28/2010 Dasanayake 34