E-Culture: Challenging Use Cases for the Semantic Webguus/talks/05-eswc-workshop.pdf · The Turning...

E-Culture: Challenging Use Cases for the Semantic Web

Guus SchreiberFree University Amsterdam

schreiber@cs.vu.nl

2

Project contextMany examples are based on work in the Dutch BSIK project Multimedian http://multimedian.nl

3

Purpose

Analyze a number of use cases from e-culture domain– Multimedia plays key role

Required technology– Typically combination of technologies

Relation to state of the art

4

Use case: Asian chairsUser has found an image of an Asian chair

Annotation:ex:image vra:stylePeriod aat:Guangxu .

How can we find images of Asian chairs from the same historical period?

5

AAT info on Guangxu

6

Importance of time and space information

Many queries require time/space knowledge, either absolute or abstractedFor the chair image we can establish– Country = China (link Chinese => China)– Period = 1644-1911 (from Qing description)

Technology requirements:– Thesuari relating time/space concepts– NLP for unstructured descriptions– Time/space reasoning techniques

7

8

9

Sample place information in TGN

<tgn:AdministrativePlace rdf:about="&tgn;1000111"tgn:standardLatitude="35"tgn:standardLongitude="105“>

<vp:parentPreferred rdf:resource="&tgn;1000004"/>……..

</tgn:AdministrativePlace>

10

Issues when searching for “nearby” Asian chairs

Close in space:– Other country in (East) Asia– Latitude/longitude

Close in time:– Links between style periods– Match time periods (and

handle incomplete information)

11

12

Use case: painting style

Find paintings of a similar style

MATISSE, HenriLe bonheur de vivre (The Joy of Life)1905-1906Oil on canvas, 69 1/8 x 94 7/8 in. (175 x 241 cm)Barnes Foundation, Merion, PA

13

How can we find this other Fauve painting?

DERAIN, AndreThe Turning Road, L'Estaque, 1906Oil on canvas, 51 x 76 3/4 in. (129.5 x 195 cm)Museum of Fine Arts, Houston, Texas

14

IssuesParse annotation to find matches with thesauri terms– E.g. match artists to ULAN individuals

Artists-style links– AAT contains styles; ULAN contains artists, but there

is no link• Learn link from corpora• Derive it from other annotations

– Domain-specific rules/reasoning needed • see example in SWRL doc• Painters may have painted in multiple styles

15

16

17

Issues w.r.t. thesauri

Public availability!RDF/OWL representationLearning/specifying term/concept mapping– owl:equivalentClass, owl:sameAs, rdf:type, rdfs:subClassOf

– Domain-specific linksManaging the evolution of the thesauri and the mappings

18

Use case: find images with the same subject

Find another painting which portrays dancing

19

Issues

Same subjects can be visually very differentSubject is often missing from the annotationMismatch: user often search for subjects of images

20

Conceptual subject descriptions85% of the user queries:

General Descriptions of generally known items. Only general, everyday knowledge is necessary. Descriptions are at the level of the Natural categories of E. Rosch (1973), or more general. E.g An ape eating a banana.

Specific Descriptions of objects or scenes that can be identified and named. Specific domain knowledge is necessary to recognize the objects or scenes. E.g. The old male gorilla Kumba, born in Cameroon and now living in Artis, Amsterdam

Abstract Descriptions for which interpretative knowledge is used. This category is subjective. E.g An animal threatened with extinction.

21

Example concepts in image

Specific– Fall of the Berlin Wall

General– People walking at night

Abstract– Fall of the Iron Curtain

22

Use of conceptual categories by people searching for images

Conceptual level: 83%

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

event time place relation scene object

Characteristics

Nub

er o

f ele

men

ts in

% o

f co

ncep

tual

ele

men

ts

AbstractSpecificGeneral

23

Thesauri for scenes: Iconclass

24

25

26

Annotation of image content

Template for subject descriptionAgent Action Object Recipient

Guidelines for manual annotation– Annotate as specific as possible

Default reasoningCBIR support:– Object identification– Spatial relations

27

28

29

Some forms of image content are well suited to image analysis

Collection of clothesAbstract painting

30

The semantic gapThe distance between Content-Based Image Retrieval and semantics:– Smeulders, Worring, Santini, Gupta, Jain. Content-

based image retrieval at the end of the early years. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 22(12), December 2000.

Direct links between visual features and semantic concepts become more difficult when the domain is broader / more general

31

Example semantic bridge:microscopic cell images

mpeg7 : StillRegion(region) ^mpeg7x : Dense(region) ^mpeg7 : DominantColor(region, col) ^swrlb : lessThan(col, 100)

=> mpeg7 : Depicts(region, mesh : MatureGranule)

32

Segmentation often requires user interaction

33

Automatic detection of concepts can be difficult even in “easy” cases

What is the color of this ape?

34

Image analysis useful for collection navigation

35

Bridging the semantic gap:CBIR and ontologies

Visual WordNet (GE paper)– Adding knowledge about visual characteristics

to WordNet: mobility, color, …– Build detectors for the visual features– Use visual data to prune the tree of categories

when analyzing a visual object

36

Sample visual features and their mapping to WordNet

37

Experiment: pruning the search for “conveyance” concepts

6 concepts foundIncluding taxi cab

12 concepts foundIncluding passenger train and commuter train

Three visual features: material, motion, environment Assumption is that these work perfectly

38

Bridging the semantic gap:concept detectors

Snoek et al., TRECVID2004– 185 hours of news video

32 detectors for concepts in news video– Through machine learning

Similarity detectors based on keywordsand visual analysisQuery interface in which these functions can be combined

39

“Concepts” for which visual detectors were built

40

41

TRECVID 2004 results

42

Main observation

A combination of many different techniques is needed to be able to cope with the complexity of multimedia semantics– NLP, segmentation, CBIR, visual feature

detectors, visual ontologies, publicly available thesauri, thesauri mappings, dedicated reasoning techniques (time, space, default), personalizaion, presentaion generaion

Key role for user studies