Broad Street Seating - Welcome to NYC.gov2020/02/25  · Broad Street Seating / Landmarks...

Alliance for Downtown New York

Broad Street SeatingLandmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020

WXY Architecture + Urban Design

LPC Online Map, nyclpc.maps.arcgis.comDesignated curb locations

LPC Designation Map, Street Plan of New Amsterdam and Colonial New York (LP-1235, 1983)

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020

Maps

2

A More Welcoming Wall & Broad:

A Vision for Improving the Stock Exchange District

Alliance for Downtown New YorkIn collaboration withWXY Architecture + Urban DesignReleased May 2018

Stock Exchange District Plan May 2018

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020

Key Recommendations:

1. Create identity and a sense of place

- Define gateways to the district - Invest in creative placemaking strategies - Enhance dark streets with new lighting - Architectural lighting

2. Enhance pedestrian environment and improve mobility

- Rebuild with curbless streets

- Design new seating that can also serve as planting beds

- Simplify security infrastructure - Expand sidewalks at key entrances

2. Rationalize deliveries and separate trucks from pedestrians

- Expand loading bays and enhance curb regulations - Pilot an urban delivery consolidation center

3

BRO

AD

ST

PINE ST

WIL

LIA

M S

T

BRO

ADW

AY

NEW

ST

BEAVER ST

EXCHANGE PL

WALL ST

60 Broad55 Broad

45 Broad(Planned)

35 Broad

25 Broad

40 Exchange

45 Wall

43 Exchange

15 Broad 37 Wall

44 Wall

40 Wall

30 Wall

26 Wall

14 Wall

96 Broadway

2 Wall

50 Broad42 New

40 Broad

30 Broad

20 Broad(Planned)

2 BroadNYSE

1 Wall(Under Construction)

52 Broadway

50 Broadway

42 Broadway

32 Broadway

26 Broadway

Proposed Bench Locations

Broad Street

Updated

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020

Location 1: Stock Exchange / Fearless Girl

Location 2: Federal Hall seating

Location 3: Broad/Exchange seating area

Bench locations represent those which the Downtown Alliance could complete based on existing stepped curb and security locations

4

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020

History

5

Bro

ad S

t

Wall St

Wall and Broad Streets, 1900

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 6

Bro

ad S

tW

all St

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 7

Wall and Broad Streets, 1915

Broad Street at Wall, CurrentB

road

St

Wall St

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 8

1

1

2

43

2

3 4

Wall Street at Broad, CurrentB

road

St

Wall St

Broad Street Seating / CB1 Landmarks Committee CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT December 12, 2019 9

1 2

3 4

1 234

Broad Street at Exchange, Current

Bro

ad S

t

Exchange Pl

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 10

1 2

3 4

12

3 4

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020

Concept

11

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020

• Choreograph flows

• Allow controlled vehicular traffic

• Flexible and social seating

• Integrate planting

• Signage and lighting

• Work with and without the curb

• Discourage sleeping, skating, and leaving trash

• Low maintenance

• Frame historic features of the district

• Simple and classy design

1. Dynamic

2. Attractive

3. Multi-Functional

4. Durable

12

Design Parameters

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020

Tourists

Residents/Workers

Residents/WorkersRelaxing and chatting on benches

Residents/WorkersHeavy commuting flow on sidewalk

TouristsPicture taking with the Fearless Girl

TouristsGroups gathering around benches

13

WALL ST

BR

OA

D S

T

NE

W Y

OR

K S

TOC

K E

XC

HA

NG

E

Everyday Flows

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020

Security Fence

Historic Facades

Federal Hall View Framing Fearless Girl

Broad Street View Stock Exchange View

14

Frame Historic Views

J Z6'-0"

FDNY12'

15'-0"

15'-0"

32'-0"

32'-0"

9’-6”

6’-7”

18’ Total Clearance

from Fence9'-9"

18’-0"

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020

• Each platform is made of up to six segments, 12’ max length

• Curb elements could remain in off-season for snow clearance or event clearance or be removed

• Drainage, skate-stop reveals, or potential armrests along length

15

Flexibility

ADA Bench Height Compliance

EXISTING FEARLESSGIRL LOCATION

EXISTING CURB LINE

PLANTER PLANTER

EXISTING CURB LINE

EXISTING FENCE LINE

EXISTING MAP

PLANTERPLANTER

EXISTING MANHOLE COVER

EXISTING CURB LINE

PLANTER

EXISTING FEARLESSGIRL LOCATION

EXISTING CURB LINE

PLANTER PLANTER

EXISTING CURB LINE

EXISTING FENCE LINE

EXISTING MAP

PLANTERPLANTER

EXISTING MANHOLE COVER

EXISTING CURB LINE

PLANTER

EXISTING FEARLESSGIRL LOCATION

EXISTING CURB LINE

PLANTER PLANTER

EXISTING CURB LINE

EXISTING FENCE LINE

EXISTING MAP

PLANTERPLANTER

EXISTING MANHOLE COVER

EXISTING CURB LINE

PLANTER

18”18”18”

Location 1 Benches

Stepped with curb

Elevations, average height

Location 2 Benches

Adjacent to curb

Location 3 Benches

Pedestrian Plaza

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020

• Per Section 903.5, guideline for seat height 17” min to 19” max above ground

16

1/2”

1/2” 1/2”

Detail Section Detail Axo

Bench Segments

Panel joint, where necessary

Segmented bench example Rounded edge example

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 17

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020

Scope of Work

18

BRO

AD

ST

PINE ST

WIL

LIA

M S

T

BRO

ADW

AY

NEW

ST

BEAVER ST

EXCHANGE PL

WALL ST

60 Broad55 Broad

45 Broad(Planned)

35 Broad

25 Broad

40 Exchange

45 Wall

43 Exchange

15 Broad 37 Wall

44 Wall

40 Wall

30 Wall

26 Wall

14 Wall

96 Broadway

2 Wall

50 Broad42 New

40 Broad

30 Broad

20 Broad(Planned)

2 BroadNYSE

1 Wall(Under Construction)

52 Broadway

50 Broadway

42 Broadway

32 Broadway

26 Broadway

Stock Exchange DistrictProposed Benches

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020

Location 1: Stock Exchange / Fearless Girl

Location 2: Federal Hall seating

Extension of Location 1 benches, a similar stepped platform and planter at the south edge of Wall Street at Broad Street

Location 3: Broad/Exchange seating area

Replacement of existing concrete benches at Broad/Exchange seating area along the west edge of the bulbout

Existing concrete benches to be removed

19

Location 1: Stock Exchange Benches

9’-6”

6’-7”

32’

30’

Bro

ad S

tWall St

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 20

Location 1: Stock Exchange Benches

Bro

ad S

tWall St

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020

Existing

21

Location 1: Stock Exchange Benches

Bro

ad S

tWall St

Existing

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 22

Location 1: Stock Exchange Benches

Bro

ad S

tWall St

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 23

EXISTING FEARLESSGIRL LOCATION

EXISTING CURB LINE

PLANTER PLANTER

EXISTING CURB LINE

EXISTING FENCE LINE

EXISTING MAP

PLANTERPLANTER

EXISTING MANHOLE COVER

EXISTING CURB LINE

PLANTER

9'-6

"

32'-0"

18'-0

"

30'-0"

6'-7

"

1'-8

"

2'-6

"

2'-6

"

1'-2

"

4'-0

"

12'-0"

2'-6

"

1'-1

0"

16'-2

"

9'-1

1"

19'-0

"

2'-0

"

12'-0"12'-0" 8'-0"12'-0" 8'-0"

4'-7

"

6'-0"6'-0"6'-0"6'-0"

2'-6

"

1'-3

"

2'-0"

19'-0"

2'-0

"

2'-6

"

2'-6

"

1'-6

"

5'-6

"

5'-8

"

24'-0"

3'-6

"

15'-0"

9"

Location 1: Stock Exchange BenchesPlan

BROAD ST

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 24

Location 1: Stock Exchange BenchesElevations

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 25

24’

3.8’

5.7’

Wall St.

Broad St.

Bro

ad S

tWall St

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 26

Location 2: Federal Hall Bench

Bro

ad S

tWall St

Existing

Location 2: Federal Hall Bench

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 27

Bro

ad S

tWall St

Existing

Location 2: Federal Hall Bench

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 28

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 29

Location 2: Federal Hall Bench Plan

WALL ST

EXISTING FEARLESSGIRL LOCATION

EXISTING CURB LINE

PLANTER PLANTER

EXISTING CURB LINE

EXISTING FENCE LINE

EXISTING MAP

PLANTERPLANTER

EXISTING MANHOLE COVER

EXISTING CURB LINE

PLANTER

9'-6

"

32'-0"

18'-0

"

30'-0"

6'-7

"

1'-8

"

2'-6

"

2'-6

"

1'-2

"

4'-0

"

12'-0"

2'-6

"

1'-1

0"

16'-2

"

9'-1

1"

19'-0

"

2'-0

"

12'-0"12'-0" 8'-0"12'-0" 8'-0"

4'-7

"

6'-0"6'-0"6'-0"6'-0"

2'-6

"

1'-3

"

2'-0"

19'-0"

2'-0

"

2'-6

"

2'-6

"

1'-6

"

5'-6

"

5'-8

"

24'-0"

3'-6

"

15'-0"

9"

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 30

EXISTING FEARLESSGIRL LOCATION

EXISTING CURB LINE

PLANTER PLANTER

EXISTING CURB LINE

EXISTING FENCE LINE

EXISTING MAP

PLANTERPLANTER

EXISTING MANHOLE COVER

EXISTING CURB LINE

PLANTER

9'-6

"

32'-0"

18'-0

"

30'-0"

6'-7

"

1'-8

"

2'-6

"

2'-6

"

1'-2

"

4'-0

"

12'-0"

2'-6

"

1'-1

0"

16'-2

"

9'-1

1"

19'-0

"

2'-0

"

12'-0"12'-0" 8'-0"12'-0" 8'-0"

4'-7

"

6'-0"6'-0"6'-0"6'-0"

2'-6

"

1'-3

"

2'-0"

19'-0"

2'-0

"

2'-6

"

2'-6

"

1'-6

"

5'-6

"

5'-8

"

24'-0"

3'-6

"

15'-0"

9"

Location 2: Federal Hall Bench Elevations

6’

6’

6’

6’

12’

12’

12’

12’

8’

8’

Location 3: Linear Bench

Broa

d St

Exchange Pl

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 31

Location 3: Linear Bench

Broa

d St

Exchange Pl

Existing

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 32

Location 3: Linear Bench

Broa

d St

Exchange Pl

Existing

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 33

Location 3: Linear Bench

Broa

d St

Exchange Pl

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 34

Location 3: Linear Bench Plan

EXISTING FEARLESSGIRL LOCATION

EXISTING CURB LINE

PLANTER PLANTER

EXISTING CURB LINE

EXISTING FENCE LINE

EXISTING MAP

PLANTERPLANTER

EXISTING MANHOLE COVER

EXISTING CURB LINE

PLANTER

9'-6

"

32'-0"

18'-0

"

30'-0"

6'-7

"

1'-8

"

2'-6

"

2'-6

"

1'-2

"

4'-0

"

12'-0"

2'-6

"

1'-1

0"

16'-2

"

9'-1

1"

19'-0

"

2'-0

"

12'-0"12'-0" 8'-0"12'-0" 8'-0"

4'-7

"

6'-0"6'-0"6'-0"6'-0"

2'-6

"

1'-3

"

2'-0"

19'-0"

2'-0

"

2'-6

"

2'-6

"

1'-6

"

5'-6

"

5'-8

"

24'-0"

3'-6

"

15'-0"

9"

BROAD ST

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 35

Location 3: Linear Bench Elevations

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 36

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020

• Lighter and thinner than traditional precast; approximately 8lbs/SF

• Material properties allow for larger pieces to be fabricated, thus fewer seams

• Greater strength means less likely to crack

Albee Square, Downtown Brooklyn ( WXY)

37

Proposed Material: Glass Fiber Reinforced Concrete (GFRC)

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020

• GFRC fabricated with lighter tone than the dark grey granite curb stone

• To identify as extension of the granite building base courses in context

• Increased aggregate to provide visual interest and depth

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

2

2

2

2

2

1

2• Metal coated with dark grey,

similar to zinc• Provides contrast and similar

to dark grey of granite curb

38

Proposed Tone/Texture: Medium Warm Grey Concrete, Dark Grey Metal

Broad Street Seating / Landmarks Preservation Commission February 25, 2020 39

Overall Proposed Axonometric