View
225
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
-
Report
October 2015
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
For The Jack and Jill Foundation
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 1
Document Control Contract Name Proposed National Childrens Hospital
Transport Submission
Contract Number C099 2015
Document Type Report
Document Status Draft
Primary Author(s) Garret Murphy, Eoin Munn
Other Author(s) Jelena Simievi
Reviewer(s) Ciaran McKeon
Document Review Item No.
Item Description Reviewer Initials Review Date
1 Draft Report v1.0 CMcK 09/09/2015
2 Draft Report v1.4 CMcK 16/09/2015
3 Draft Report v2.0 CMcK/ JS 22/09/2015
4 Draft Report v2.5 CMcK/ JS 23/09/2015
5 Draft Report v3.3 CMcK 28/09/2015
6 Draft Report v3.6 CMcK/ JS 29/09/2015
7 Final Report v4.0 CMcK 01/10/2015
8
Distribution Item No.
Item Description Approvers Initials Date
1 Draft Report v2.5 to Cunnane Stratton Reynolds & The Jack and Jill Foundation
CMcK 23/09/2015
2 Updated Draft Report v3.8 to Cunnane Stratton Reynolds & The Jack and Jill Foundation
CMcK 30/09/2015
3 Final Report v4.0 to Cunnane Stratton Reynolds & The Jack and Jill Foundation
CMcK 01/10/2015
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 2
Table of Contents
Executive Summary .................................................................................................................... 4
1. Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 10
1.1. Overview .................................................................................................................................................. 10
1.2. The Jack and Jill Foundation ..................................................................................................................... 10
1.3. About Transport Insights .......................................................................................................................... 11
1.4. Submission Structure ............................................................................................................................... 11
2. Submission Approach ........................................................................................................ 13
2.1. Submission Scope ..................................................................................................................................... 13
2.2. Outline Approach ..................................................................................................................................... 13
2.3. Supplemental Parking Impact Analysis .................................................................................................... 14
3. On- and Off-Site Observations and Surveys ........................................................................ 16
3.1. Objectives ................................................................................................................................................. 16
3.2. On-Site Assessment .................................................................................................................................. 16
3.3. Off-Site Assessment the Receiving Environment .................................................................................. 18
3.4. St. Jamess Hospital Patient/ Visitor Car Park Occupancy Observations ................................................. 21
3.5. St. Jamess Hospital On-Street Car Park Occupancy Survey .................................................................... 22
3.6. Luas Park and Ride Occupancy Observations Red Cow and Cheeverstown ......................................... 24
4. Development Proposal Overview and Key Data ............................................................... 25
4.1. St. Jamess Hospital Campus .................................................................................................................... 25
4.2. National Remit ......................................................................................................................................... 25
4.3. Key Data ................................................................................................................................................... 25
5. Development Transport Strategy Review ........................................................................... 28
5.1. Proposed Transport Strategy ................................................................................................................... 28
5.2. St. Jamess Hospital Campus Draft Site Capacity Study ........................................................................... 28
5.3. St. Jamess Hospital Campus Smarter Travel Programme ....................................................................... 31
5.4. Strategic Accessibility Analysis ................................................................................................................. 39
5.5. Development Transport Strategy Conclusions ......................................................................................... 40
6. Traffic and Transport Impact Assessment Review ............................................................... 42
6.1. Traffic and Transport Impact Assessment Best Practice Guidance ....................................................... 42
6.2. Operational Phase Trip Generation and Mode Share .............................................................................. 43
6.3. Operational Phase Assessment Years, Scenarios, and Time Periods ....................................................... 44
6.4. Operational Phase Traffic Distribution and Assignment .......................................................................... 45
6.5. Operational Phase Traffic Modelling........................................................................................................ 46
6.6. Construction Phase Impact Assessment Review ...................................................................................... 48
6.7. Traffic and Transport Impact Assessment Review Conclusions ............................................................... 50
7. Proposed Site Access and Site Plans Review ....................................................................... 53
7.1. Review Context ........................................................................................................................................ 53
7.2. Proposed New Mount Brown Site Access Junction ................................................................................. 53
7.3. Proposed Internal Shared Surface Facilities ............................................................................................. 54
7.4. Taxi and Car Drop-Off and Pick-Up .......................................................................................................... 54
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 3
7.5. Road Safety Audit (RSA) Review ............................................................................................................... 56
7.6. Proposed Site Plan Review Conclusions ................................................................................................... 56
8. Parking Impact Analysis ..................................................................................................... 57
8.1. Parking Accumulation Analysis Review .................................................................................................... 57
8.2. Managing Parking Demand ...................................................................................................................... 70
8.3. Parking Impact Assessment...................................................................................................................... 73
8.4. International Benchmarks ........................................................................................................................ 76
8.5. Parking Impact Analysis Conclusions ....................................................................................................... 76
Appendices
Appendix A St. Jamess Hospital Correspondence
Appendix B St. Jamess Hospital On-Street Survey Results
Appendix C Patient/ Family Transport Survey, Our Ladys Childrens Hospital, Crumlin (2006)
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 4
Executive Summary
Overview
This Transport Submission, on behalf of the Jack and Jill Foundation, has been prepared in response to the
recently lodged planning application for development of a new National Childrens Hospital at the St. Jamess
Hospital Campus, Jamess Street, Dublin 8. The application has been supported by an Environmental Impact
Statement (EIS), Chapter 6 of which sets out the transport strategy and resulting impact appraisal.
The challenges of developing a transport strategy for, and assessing the transport impacts of, a strategic
development with relatively unique attributes such as that currently proposed are acknowledged by
Transport Insights. Notwithstanding these challenges, having reviewed the development proposals, serious
deficiencies in relation to its supporting rationale and the robustness of the transport assessment have been
identified. These can be summarised as follows:
Site Context
Based on information contained within the St. Jamess Hospital Annual Report 2013, the adult hospital
currently has 1,010 beds, and caters for 229,120 outpatients, 97,672 day care patients and 46,714 urgent
car cases per annum.
On the day of a site assessment (Thursday 03 September 2015) occupancy levels within the adult
hospitals staff car parks were observed to be in excess of 100%.
Observations of occupancy levels within the hospitals patient/ visitor car parks (Wednesday 09
September) vary considerably throughout the day, with a moderate occupancy level of 60% at 09:00hrs
increasing significantly to a peak of 97% at 15:00hrs, coinciding with the first of two visiting periods
(14:30hrs 15:30hrs) at the hospital.
The hospital is located in an edge of City Centre location, and extensive peak period queuing and delay
has been observed in the 08:00hrs to 09:00hrs peak. Long queues were observed at the junction of
South Circular Road and Mount Brown, with queues of over 30 vehicles observed on the Mount Brown
Arm of the junction (versus an EIS Traffic and Transport Chapters equivalent queue of 8 vehicles).
Significant levels of queuing observed on the morning of the site assessment will impact on patient
access to the site in the AM peak period. Furthermore, a general lack of bus priority to the west of the
site has implications for reliable and efficient bus operations, and access by emergency vehicles to the
hospital grounds.
The area to the west and south of the site is predominantly residential in nature, and as such represents
a potentially sensitive environment in which to locate a large, strategic, national facility such as a
National Childrens Hospital. The area is particularly sensitive to the impacts of over-spill car parking,
should the proposed level of car parking prove inadequate in meeting the needs of hospital users. On-
street car parking occupancy surveys undertaken in an area corresponding to an approximate 400m walk
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 5
distance (or 5 minute walk time) from the proposed hospital indicate that, at present, 69% of all on-
street car parking spaces are occupied during the day-time.
On-street car park occupancy levels in this area during the evening time were observed to be significantly
higher that day-time levels surveyed.
Development Proposal
The new hospital represents a consolidation of existing childrens hospitals at Crumlin, Tallaght and
Temple Street onto a single site within the St. Jamess Hospital Campus.
The principal element of the proposed development is a 473 no. bed (380 in-patient and 93 day care)
new childrens hospital, with a gross floor area of 118,113 sqm. Satellite centres are also proposed at
the Adelaide & Meath/ Tallaght Hospital, and Connolly Hospital, Blanchardstown, however both of these
proposed developments are outside the scope of this Submission.
Following its delivery, core weekday staff numbers are anticipated to increase from 3,000 at present to
5,000 (an increase of 67%), and daily patient numbers by in excess of 80%.
Despite the substantial increase in staff numbers, it is proposed to reduce on-site staff car parking by
244 spaces, whereas patient/ visitor car parking capacity would increase by 664 spaces, representing a
net increase in 420 car parking spaces (or 26% more than at present).
St. James's Hospital Campus Draft Site Capacity Study
A Site Capacity Study has been submitted by the applicant for consideration by ABP alongside other
planning related files. The rationale for the draft Study status is unclear, however finalising the study
prior to selection of the St. Jamess Hospital for development of a new National Childrens Hospital may
have been anticipated as a means of demonstrating development feasibility.
The level of proposed on-site car parking emerging from the study does not appear to have been
underpinned by an analysis of user needs; i.e. patients, visitors and staff of the expanded site.
The importance placed within the Draft Site Capacity Study on the delivery of schemes such as DART
Underground, Lucan Luas etc. represent an acknowledgement on behalf of the applicant of the
limitations imposed by the existing public transport network in terms of staff and patient/ visitor access.
The identified schemes have however neither funding commitment nor planning consent at present,
and uncertainty and risk surrounding their delivery undermines confidence in a key element of the
transport strategy for the expanded St. Jamess Hospital site. The recent Government announcement
regarding DART Underground reinforces this point.
The Draft Site Capacity Study has placed excessive emphasis on the role and potential of the St Jamess
Hospital Campus Smarter Travel Programme in achieving the required level of reductions in staff car use
following delivery of the proposed development.
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 6
St. James's Hospital Campus Smarter Travel Programme
Across the single adult and four childrens hospitals, the Smarter Travel Programme targets a reduction
in car use from approximately 60% at present to 18%. Potential medium-long term on-site development
of the maternity hospital would, according to EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter, result in a further 4%
reduction in staff car mode share.
Although a Mobility Management Plan has been prepared for the St Jamess Hospital campus (St
Jamess Hospital Campus Smarter Travel Programme) and is currently being implemented.., no
equivalent Mobility Management Plan exists at present for the three childrens hospitals.
As staff at the existing childrens hospitals choose accommodation that is readily accessible by
convenient modes including walking, cycling and public transport, accessibility to an alternative hospital
location will, for most staff, be diminished, not enhanced by a relocation to the St. Jamess Hospital site.
Staff car dependency would, in such instances, be anticipated to increase, not decrease, however very
limited levels of staff car parking are proposed for the expanded facility.
While it is recognized that distribution of staff based at the three childrens hospitals is likely to change
over time when staff move to the new childrens hospital at St Jamess Hospital campus, the timescales
for achieving such a change has not been considered. Due to personal/ family commitments, a
significant change in staff demographic patterns may take many years to achieve.
Deficiencies in the public transport network have also been identified by the Draft Site Capacity Study,
and on-site cycle parking occupancy observations indicate that external factors presently appear to play
a greater role in hindering enhanced levels of cycle use, rather than on-site infrastructure provision.
The applicant has failed to demonstrate that there is sufficient reserve capacity on the public transport
network, and the Luas Red Line in particular, to cater for additional passenger demand generated by the
proposed development. Specifically:
To achieve a 9% staff park and ride mode share, the applicant has designated two park and ride
sites on the Luas Red Line at which free staff car parking would be provided Red Cow and
Cheeverstown. Based on observed occupancies at these sites (537 spaces occupied out of 727 at
Red Cow and 39 out of 321 at Cheeverstown on Tuesday 08 September 2015), and on the
presumption of a similar allocation of demand between sites as presently observed, capacity at the
Red Cow site is insufficient to accommodate the required level of staff use.
In addition to a failure to consider Luas park and ride capacity, the applicant has also failed to assess
the adequacy of public transport service capacity. Consultation with the Railway Procurement
Agency is not considered an appropriate substitute for a public transport network capacity analysis.
Anecdotal evidence of overcrowding on the Luas Red Line in the AM peak period further reinforces the
above concerns in relation to the adequacy of Luas Red Line capacity.
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 7
The timescales for achieving the required change in staff demographics at the three existing childrens
hospitals; for achieving a radical behavioral change response amongst staff at all four hospital; and for
addressing deficiencies in public transport and cycle networks are all medium-long term challenges,
whereas the new hospital is envisaged to become operational by 2020.
To facilitate the needs of shift workers, and in particular staff arriving to the site after 19:00hrs, the
applicant has proposed to grant staff free access to the patient/ visitor car parks. Based on an
underestimation of visitor car parking demand, it appears that night-time staff arriving at the hospital
will be unable to locate a car parking space without spending a considerable time searching for a vacant
space in both staff and visitor car parks.
Behavioural change initiatives will play a more limited role in influencing the travel behaviours of shift
workers, as the feasibility of using non-car transport modes is more limited, due to for example, darkness
and associated safety and security concerns reducing propensity to walk or cycle, and reduced public
transport service frequencies.
Targeted desktop research indicates that the scale of the challenge of achieving the required level of
staff modal shift away from car towards public transport and other modes through pursuit of mobility
management measures appears unprecedented in either Irish or international contexts.
Traffic and Transport Impact Assessment
Having undertaken a detailed review of the transport impact assessment as set out in the EIS Traffic and
Transport Chapter, the approach pursued by the applicant does not claim to follow, or does not appear
to accord with, industry best practice, namely the NRAs TTA Guidelines.
Key stages in the assessment, including trip generation, modal split, assessment years and time periods,
traffic distribution and assignment, and the modelling approach pursued in the analysis of traffic impacts
lack the required level of robustness for a large, strategic and centrally located development proposal.
The transport assessment approach pursued by the applicant is therefore deficient in areas that are of
greatest significance in terms of forecasting the proposed developments traffic impacts.
The cumulative effect of these deficiencies is a substantial underestimation of the proposed
developments traffic impacts, impacting on access to the site by car, by bus and crucially by emergency
vehicles. This is particularly concerning in light of the already significant levels of peak period queuing
and delay experienced on the road network within the sites vicinity.
Deficiencies in the assessment process also undermine the conclusion within the EIS Traffic and
Transport Chapter that the delivery of additional development on campus can be accommodated
without impacting on prevailing traffic conditions on the surrounding road network.
Site Access and Layout Plans
A review of the proposed site access arrangements and site plans has identified:
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 8
That those accessing/ egressing via the proposed new Mount Brown site access junction location are
likely to both experience and add to existing significant levels of queuing and delay to the west of the
site, including the junction of South Circular Road and Mount Brown. The existing adverse performance
characteristics at this junction do not appear to have been reflected in the applicants traffic assessment.
The suitability of Mount Brown as a major access route to the proposed hospital by patients, visitors and
staff has therefore not been demonstrated.
An apparent failure to provide a swept path analysis for the proposed new Mount Brown junction layout,
gives rise to concerns relating to the efficient and safe future operation of the junction.
The proposed internal shared surface facilities for general traffic and cyclists risks hindering the St.
Jamess Hospital Campus Smarter Travel Programmes target increases in the staff cycle use.
A lack of clarity relating to taxi and car drop off facilities, and whether they shall meet anticipated high
levels of future patient, visitor and staff demand.
The Road Safety Audits limited scope, having considered only the sites interfaces with the surrounding
road network, and not internal operations. This could have implications for the safe future internal
operations of the site.
Parking Impact Analysis
Following review of the parking accumulation analysis presented within the EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter,
and supplemental analysis by our team:
The applicant has significantly underestimated patient/ visitor car parking demand at the hospital. In
particular, no substantiation has been provided in support of the very low levels of visitor car parking
demand, which is assumed to remain at a constant level of 16 parked cars during both visiting periods.
Transport Insights updated parking accumulation analysis, which has applied a revised patient/ visitor
car mode share to reflect national household car ownership levels (Census 2011 results indicating that
82.4% of households own a car), and re-forecasted visitor demand, indicate that even in the most
optimistic scenario, demand for car parking is forecast to exceed capacity (based on a maximum 95%
target occupancy) for 5 hours per day.
In the other two scenarios analysed, demand is likely to exceed capacity for a much longer period of
time 10 hours per day in the pessimistic scenario.
Higher level of patient/ visitor car parking demand in the evening time will constrain the role of the
patient/ visitor car park in accommodating temporary elevated staff car parking demand during the staff
handover period. This would also impact on the availability of car parking spaces for visitors at this time.
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 9
Patient/ visitor car parking
charges are estimated to
range from 2.50 per hour in
the optimistic scenarios
(the same as the existing
adults hospital) to between
2.90 and 5.10 per hour in
the pessimistic scenario
(based on the same 95%
maximum target occupancy
level). Higher charges again,
ranging from 3.50 to 7.00 per hour, would be needed in a more robust 90% target occupancy scenario.
Extensive over-spill car parking on streets surrounding the hospital is forecast, ranging from 84-117 cars
in the optimistic scenario to 226-260 cars in the pessimistic scenario.
Deficiencies in the levels of patient/ visitor (and staff) car parking suggests that the development
proposal does not comply with the current Dublin City Development Plans parking standards.
The deficit in on-site car parking provision is supported by reference to levels provided at similar facilities
internationally. At the new National Childrens Hospital, it is proposed to provide 2.1 car parking spaces
per bed, versus a minimum of 4.4 spaces per bed at a range of other childrens hospitals.
Applying this minimum international standard to a new 473 bed childrens hospital in Dublin, would
indicate a requirement for 2,081 car parking spaces (excluding adult hospital requirements). Based on
the maximum patient/ visitor parking accumulation levels within the pessimistic scenario of 858, and
applying a robust maximum target occupancy level within the car park of 90%, would imply an on-site
requirement for 953 patient/ visitor car parking spaces (versus the 664 spaces proposed). The remaining
car parking spaces, or a somewhat lesser quantity depending on accessibility and sustainable transport
policy considerations, would then be available for staff use.
Future Maternity Hospital
The applicants substantial underestimation of the proposed developments traffic impacts and car parking
demand, and related failure to provide sufficient on-site car parking capacity risks compromising the future
delivery on-site of a maternity hospital, as it is likely to intensify traffic impacts on the road network, and add
to already significant forecast levels of over-spill car parking within the sites vicinity.
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 10
1. Introduction
1.1. Overview
Transport Insights has been commissioned by the Jack and Jill Foundation to prepare a Transport
Submission in relation to the proposed new National Childrens Hospital at the St. Jamess Hospital
Campus, Jamess Street, Dublin 8.
The application was submitted to An Bord Pleanla (ABP) on Monday 10 August 2015 under Section
37E of the Planning and Development Act 2000. The proposed development would represent a
consolidation of existing childrens hospitals at Crumlin, Tallaght and Temple Street onto a single site
within the St. Jamess Hospital Campus, in Dublin 8. In addition, and forming part of the current
application, satellite centres are planned at the Adelaide & Meath Hospital in Tallaght, and Connolly
Hospital in Blanchardstown.
The Submission seeks to provide a critical challenge function in relation to the proposals, and in doing
so, endeavours to ensure that a decision by ABP is based on a thorough consideration of the impacts
of the development proposal from the perspective of users (visitors, patients), staff, road users and
residents living in the vicinity of the site. As such, it includes location specific consideration of traffic,
transport and parking related aspects of the proposed development with a view to better
understanding its likely transport related impacts.
The Transport Submission focuses on the core element of the application, i.e. the proposed
development at the St. Jamess Hospital Campus. Proposed development of satellite centres at
Tallaght and Blanchardstown is therefore outside the scope of this Submission.
In drafting this Submission, Transport Insights has drawn upon the advice of the following medical
experts from the client team:
Dr. Fin Breathnach, MB, BCh, BAO, DObst. RCPI, MRCP (Paeds UK), FRCP Edin:- Consultant
Paediatric Oncologist, Our Ladys Childrens Hospital, Crumlin, Temple St. University Hospital, St.
Lukes Hospital, Rathgar (1981 2008); CEO Barretstown Camp, Ballymore Eustace, Co Kildare.
(2008 2010) retired; and
Dr. Roisin Healy, MB, MRCP (Paeds UK), FRCPI, FRCSI, FFAEM:- Consultant Paediatric Emergency
Medicine, Our Lady's Children's Hospital, Crumlin (1988 2007) retired.
1.2. The Jack and Jill Foundation
The Jack and Jill Foundation, is a registered childrens charity. It was founded in 1997, and since then
it has supported over 1,900 children (from birth to 4 years old) with brain damage who suffer severe
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 11
intellectual and physical trauma. The Foundation also provides end of life care for all children who
require it from birth to 4 years of age.
The children cared for by the Jack and Jill Foundation represent some of Irelands sickest children.
These children and their families often spend much of their short lives either in hospital, or attending
regular appointments with specialists in the current national childrens hospitals at Temple Street or
Our Ladys Hospital, Crumlin. Many of these children will be travelling with medical equipment, with
up to 22 items of equipment required by some patients. As a result, travelling to hospital by public
transport to attend an appointment is infeasible and has the potential to impose excessive risk on
patients.
The Jack and Jill Foundation, is therefore uniquely positioned to understand the needs and
requirements of Irelands sickest children, and just as importantly, their families, in terms of any new
proposed hospital.
1.3. About Transport Insights
Transport Insights is an Irish based transport planning consultancy. With a core team of internationally
experienced consultants, we provide innovative, effective and deliverable advice and cost effective,
sustainable solutions. Our client list includes asset managers, banks, developers, transport operators,
local authorities and national government agencies in Ireland and internationally.
Relevant recent Transport Insights experience includes:
University Travel Plan 2015 2020, on behalf of the National University of Ireland Galway (August
2015, ongoing);
Transport Impact Assessment and Mobility Management Plan for a proposed bio-pharmaceutical
development on Cruiserath Road, Dublin 15 on behalf of Montjeu Limited (January to June 2015);
Metro Line Extension Feasibility Study Advice on behalf of the European Investment Bank
(November 2014 to January 2015);
Cork South Ring Road (N40) Demand Management Study Advice to Cork City and County Councils
(March 2014, ongoing); and
Advice to domestic bus operators, and related submissions, in response to a range of central
government policies and initiatives, including bus contracts, capital investment frameworks and
transport studies (September 2013 to August 2015).
1.4. Submission Structure
The remainder of this submission is structured as follows:
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 12
Submission approach (Section 2):- Overview of the Submissions scope and a summary of the
approach pursued in its preparation;
On- and off-site observations and surveys (Section 3):- An overview of the proposed development
site and its receiving environment building upon observations and surveys at the site and its
surrounding road network;
Development proposals overview and key data (Section 4):- Headline transport related data for
the existing St. Jamess Hospital site, and the development proposal;
Development transport strategy review (Section 5):- Identified key deficiencies in the
developments overarching transport strategy, and implications for patients, visitors and staff
access;
Traffic and transport impact assessment review (Section 6):- Concerns relating to the approach
pursued and principal assumptions underpinning the assessment of traffic and transport impacts,
and the robustness of its conclusions;
Proposed site access and site plans review (Section 7):- Observations arising from a review of site
access and layout plans (site access arrangements, junction layouts and internal layouts) and the
accompanying Road Safety Audit; and
Parking impact analysis (Section 8):- Detailing the approach pursued in reviewing and updating
the proposed developments patient/ visitor parking accumulation analysis, and an assessment of
resulting impacts.
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 13
2. Submission Approach
2.1. Submission Scope
This document forms part of a wider submission on behalf of the Jack and Jill Foundation to ABP. The
scope of Transport Insights work in drafting this submission has primarily focussed on Chapter 6 of the
Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) hereafter referred to as the EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter,
and transport related site layout plans.
Although the planning application comprises six principal elements, with V and VI relating to proposed
satellite centres at hospitals in Tallaght and Blanchardstown, the Transport Submission focuses on the
core element of the application, i.e. the proposed development at the St. Jamess Hospital Campus.
2.2. Outline Approach
The overall approach pursued in drafting the Submission is set out in Figure 2.1 below.
Figure 2.1 Transport Submission Outline Approach
In undertaking an on-site assessment which has provided an enhanced understanding of the St. Jamess
Hospital site (the findings of which are set out in Section 3.2 of this document), our team was
requested by on-site security staff to desist from taking photographs on the hospital grounds, and
requested to delete any photographic records which had been taken on site up to that point.
In addition to undertaking a detailed review of traffic and transport related documentation submitted
by the applicant, the Submission has also been supported by a comprehensive set of on-street car
parking surveys within the vicinity of the St. Jamess Hospital site. Such survey work has provided an
evidence base in support of a parking impact analysis, an overview of which is provided in Section 2.3
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 14
which follows, to assess the adequacy of proposed patient and visitor car parking provision at the
expanded St. Jamess Hospital Campus, and related impacts arising from the proposals.
To inform the parking accumulation analysis set out within this document, it was also proposed to
undertake a parking survey within the existing patient/ visitor car park at St. Jamess Hospital.
Permission for such a survey was sought from the hospitals management, however it was not
granted. Correspondence between Transport Insights and St. Jamess Hospital management is
included as Appendix A.
In addition to the more detailed parking impact analysis exercise, the Submission has also been
supplemented by high-level:
behavioural change research into the effectiveness of smarter travel workplaces initiatives in
achieving the level of modal shift away from car that is essential to facilitate the development
proposal; and
accessibility analysis to assess levels of car dependency amongst patients and visitors of the
proposed development, the outputs of which have helped validate assumed patient and visitor
car mode shares.
2.3. Supplemental Parking Impact Analysis
The assessment of transport impacts as set out
in the EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter is
based on a first principles assessment of
demand from each of the different users (i.e.
staff, families/patients, etc...) of the Hospital.
Furthermore, the EIS Traffic and Transport
chapter states that traffic generation
associated with staff and visitors has been
based on the number of parking spaces
proposed for the St Jamess Hospital campus.
In light of the limited levels of car parking
proposed within the redeveloped St. Jamess Hospital Campus (as detailed in Section 4.3 of this
document), and deficiencies in the parking accumulation analysis presented in the EIS Traffic and
Transport Chapter (and detailed in Section 8.1 of this document), it is evident that demand for car
parking has been substantially underestimated by the applicant. To the west and south of the St.
Jamess Hospital site, the area is predominantly residential in nature the impacts of such over-spill
parking therefore has potential to adversely impact on residential amenity within the affected areas,
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 15
with residents unable to find a parking space in close proximity to their house and/ or having to search
for a suitable space to be vacated.
Within the analysis presented within this Submission, parking accumulation has been re-estimated to
ascertain user impacts in terms of increased future parking tariffs, levels of over-spill parking onto
predominantly residential streets surrounding the hospital, and increased walking distance/ reduced
user satisfaction levels.
Reflecting uncertainty regarding key assumptions underpinning the analysis set out in the EIS Traffic
and Transport Chapter, and to ensure future patient demand growth is given adequate consideration
by ABP, the updated analysis presents outputs for optimistic, pessimistic and realistic demand
scenarios.
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 16
3. On- and Off-Site Observations and Surveys
3.1. Objectives
An assessment of the St. Jamess Hospital site location, and its receiving environment took place on
the morning of Thursday 03 September 2015. The objective of the assessment was to ascertain key
transport assets at and in the vicinity of the site; and to observe activity levels and performance issues.
The on-site and off-site assessments are summarised in Sections 3.2 and 3.3 respectively which follow.
They have been supplemented by the following surveys/ observations undertaken in early September
2015:
St. Jamess Hospital patient/ visitor car park occupancy observations Wednesday 09 September
(Section 3.4);
St. Jamess Hospital on-street car park occupancy survey Tuesday 08 and Wednesday 09
September 2015 (Section 3.5); and
Luas Red Cow and Cheeverstown park and ride occupancy observations Tuesday 08 September
2015 (Section 3.6).
3.2. On-Site Assessment
Date and Timing
Thursday 03 September 2015, between the hours of 08:00hrs and 12:00hrs (in conjunction with the
off-site assessment summarised in Section 3.3, which follows).
Staff Car Parking
Staff car parking:- two main areas observed:
the first to the north of St. Jamess Hospital Campus Road; and
a second to the southwest of the site.
The capacity of staff parks were not recorded, however occupancy levels were observed to be in
excess of 100%, with full occupancy of designated car parking spaces and limited parking in
undesignated areas elsewhere in the staff car parks.
Patient/ Visitor Car Parking
The operational capacity of the patient/ visitor car park was recorded to be 381 car parking spaces on
the day of the site assessment. This included both normal and disabled car parking spaces in the main
(underground) and surface car parks, however it excluded car parking designated for specific use by
those visiting the Irish Blood Transfusion Service (estimated at 40 spaces for visitors/donors EIS Traffic
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 17
and Transport Chapter, Table 6.19), and an area of the underground car park temporarily closed due
to ongoing construction of the new Mercers Institute for Successful Ageing (estimated at 46 spaces).
Through Traffic Restrictions
Signs at both the existing entrances indicate that the site is closed to through traffic. It was noted
that restrictions on through traffic travelling from the Jamess Street to the Rialto entrance do not
appear to be enforced, with the barriers opening upon approach from inside the hospital grounds.
Although such traffic movements may not be physically restricted in that direction, the presence of
signage and barrier controls would however act as a deterrent to the majority of traffic not having a
legitimate purpose on site, e.g. staff drop-off or pick-up.
Cycle Facilities
The following bicycle facilities were observed:
two areas with covered, secure cycle parking and capacity for approximately 28 bicycles each, and
occupancy in the region of 75%;
a further uncovered bicycle parking area with capacity for approximately 45 spaces, and
occupancy in the region of 30-40% (including bicycles locked to trees and poles in its vicinity); and
the Dublin Bike Scheme, with two hubs within the hospital grounds one beside the St. Jamess
Luas stop and another close to the main reception area.
Public Transport Facilities
Both Luas Red Line and Dublin Bus Route 123 services pass through the St. Jamess Hospital site. Bus
waiting facilities within the hospital site, serving above bus route appeared to be of a higher quality
(with bus shelters) compared to those observed on Mount Brown and Jamess Street serving Routes
40 and 123. Moderate-high levels of alighting passengers were observed at the Jamess Luas stop, in
particular around 08:00hrs in the morning, and coinciding with a period of significant staff arrivals to
the hospital.
Pedestrian Facilities
Footpaths were noted to be present on the St. Jamess Hospital Campus Road, with pedestrian
crossings facilities also present. Signalised pedestrian crossing facilities are provided at the main
Jamess Street entrance, and at the junction of South Circular Road/ Brookfield Road adjacent to the
Rialto entrance.
Taxi and Car Pick Up and Drop off Facilities
Taxi and car drop-off and pick up was observed to primarily take place in a designated area adjacent
to the main hospital reception area, however no formal taxi rank facilities were observed within the
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 18
hospital grounds. An informal waiting area was observed to the west of the main hospital reception
area.
Emergency Access
Access and egress of emergency vehicles to the existing adults hospital was observed at both the main
(St. Jamess) and Rialto entrance to the site.
3.3. Off-Site Assessment the Receiving Environment
Date and Timing
Thursday 03 September 2015, between the hours of 08:00hrs and 12:00hrs (in conjunction with the
on-site assessment summarised in Section 3.2).
General Traffic
On the morning of the site assessment, severe traffic congestion (queuing and delay) on the road
network was observed to the west of the site. For example, and as illustrated in Figure 3.1 overleaf,
long queues were observed on all arms of the junction of South Circular Road/ Old Kilmainham/ Emmet
Road.
Figure 3.1 Observed AM Peak Queuing on Emmet Road at Junction with South Circular
Road (08:34hrs)
The following table presents queue length observations at the junction of South Circular Road/ Mount
Brown on the morning of the site assessment.
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 19
Table 3.1 Queuing Obervations Junciton of South Circular Road/ Mount Brown
Junction Arm Transport Insights Observations (Circa 08:30hrs)
Emmet Road (West) Queue of ~ 30 vehicles
South Circular Road (North) Queue extended through South Circular Road/ Kilmainham Lane
junction
Mount Brown (East) Queue in excess of 30 vehicles
South Circular Road (South) Queue extended through South Circular Road/ Suir Road junction
As can be seen from the table above, peak period queuing appears extensive, with queues extending
from though a series of junctions along the South Circular Road to the west of the site. The
implications of the observations in Table 3.1 above, by reference to comparable base (or without
development) modelling outputs presented in the EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter, is detailed within
Section 6.6 of this document.
The Google Traffic View screenshot in Figure 3.2 below reinforces on-site observations of queuing and
delay on the network to the west of the site, and in particular, on the South Circular Road corridor.
The blue circle represents the junction of South Circular Road and Mount Brown.
Figure 3.2 AM Peak Queuing to West of St. Jamess Hospital Site (08:43hrs)
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 20
The following is a description of the colour coding legend adopted in Google Traffic View 1:
Green means there are no traffic delays.
Orange means theres a medium amount of traffic.
Red means there are traffic delays. The more red, the slower the speed of traffic on the road.
Significant levels of queuing observed on the morning of the site assessment will impact on patient
access to the site in the AM peak period. Furthermore, a general lack of bus priority to the west of
the site has implications for reliable and efficient bus operations, and access by emergency vehicles
to the hospital grounds.
Public Transport
As can be seen from the following image (Figure 3.3), bus priority measures in the vicinity of the
hospital are generally absent, with the reliable and efficient operation of Dublin Bus services on Mount
Brown, where Dublin Bus Routes 13 and 40 operate, compromised by traffic congestion noted above.
Opportunities to implement bus priority measures on existing bus routes also appear very limited due
to the restricted road width along Mount Brown, where many buildings front directly onto the footpath
(as per the photograph below).
Bus waiting facilities on Mount Brown and on Jamess Street were observed to be poor, with no shelter
facilities present.
Figure 3.3 Bus Operations on Mount Brown (08:50hrs)
1 https://support.google.com/maps/answer/3093389?hl=en
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 21
3.4. St. Jamess Hospital Patient/ Visitor Car Park Occupancy Observations
Occupancy Observations
In support of this Submission, it was proposed to undertake a parking accumulation survey at the
existing St. Jamess Hospital. Permission for the survey was sought from the hospitals CEO, however
permission was not granted. Correspondence with the hospitals CEO in relation to the survey request
is included as Appendix A.
As noted in Section 3.2, the operational capacity of the patient/ visitor car park was recorded at 381
spaces on the day of the site assessment, including surface and underground car parks, but excluding
car parking designated for specific use by those visiting the Irish Blood Transfusion Service and lost
capacity due to ongoing construction works within the underground car park. In the absence of a
survey (45 minute parking beat accumulation survey originally intended over a six hour period), levels
of unoccupied car parking spaces were instead observed three times on a single day Wednesday 09
September. The findings of these observations are presented in Table 3.2, below.
Table 3.2 St. Jamess Hospital Patient/ Visitor Car Park Occupancy Observations
Time Period Commencing Total Capacity Vacant Occupied % Occupancy
09:00hrs 381 151 230 60%
12:00hrs 381 78 303 80%
15:00hrs 381 13 368 97%
As can be seen from the above table, occupancy levels in the patient/ visitor car parks of the adults
hospital varied significantly throughout the day:
with a moderate occupancy level of 60% at 09:00hrs;
increasing significantly to a peak of 97% at 15:00hrs, coinciding with the first of two visiting
periods (14:30hrs 15:30hrs) at the hospital.
Parking Prices and Pricing Structure
The following parking charges structure was observed:
first 10 minutes free;
10 minutes to 1 hour - 2.50;
up to 6 hours:- 2.50 per hour; and
6 hours to 24 hours:- 15.
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 22
3.5. St. Jamess Hospital On-Street Car Park Occupancy Survey
EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter Extend the On-Street Controlled Disc Parking Area
The EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter recognises the proposed developments potential to increase
parking demand on neighbouring roads and streets. It also recommends the extension of the pay
parking zone and to raise the cost of parking on the surrounding streets from the current rate of 1.00
per hour and investigate the possibility of introducing extended hours of operation.
The streets in which the proposed extension of the on-street controlled disc parking area would be
implemented are presented in Figure 6.57 of the EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter. As on-street
parking controls measures limit the duration of parking stay to 3 hours, the proposed implementation
of on-street parking restrictions would restrict staff car parking in the hospitals vicinity. It would not
however prevent patients and visitors parking in these areas, as 84% of these visits (across the full day)
are less than 3 hours in duration. Although the EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter does not conclude
that levels of on-site patient and visitor car parking are inadequate, the proposal to increase the
parking charge from its current 1.00 per hour level reflects an expectation of increased short-term
on-street parking demand arising from the proposed development, i.e. from hospital patients and
visitors.
On-Street Car Parking Occupancy Survey
To assess the proposed impacts of over-spill car parking on surrounding residential street, Transport
Insights undertook on-street car parking occupancy surveys within the vicinity of the hospital site. In
defining the survey area, consideration was given to the proposed future pedestrian access points at
Fatima and Rialto Luas stops in addition to the new pedestrian access at Mount Brown, and a maximum
acceptable walk time of 5 minutes, corresponding to a distance of approximately 400 metres, from the
destination. The survey area is indicated in Figure 3.4, overleaf, and included approximately 50 streets.
The survey was completed over a two day period Tuesday 08 and Wednesday 09 September 2015,
between the hours of 09:00hrs and 16:00hrs. Each street within the area was surveyed once, with the
number of occupied and unoccupied car parking spaces recorded by the surveyor.
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 23
Figure 3.4 On-Street Parking Occupancy Survey Area
The following table presents a summary of the survey results. Detailed survey results for individual
streets are presented in Appendix B.
Table 3.3 St. Jamess Hospital On-Street Parking Occupancy Survey Results
Parking Restriction Type Occupied Total Capacity Occupancy %
Current/ Future Pay 305 528 58%
Current Free/ Future Free 250 351 71%
Current Free/ Future Pay 758 1,035 73%
Total 1,313 1,914 69%
From the table above, it can be seen that day-time on-street car parking occupancy levels within an
approximate 400m walk distance (or 5 minute walk time) from the proposed hospital are presently:
58% on streets where existing parking controlled measures are currently in place;
71% on streets where no such restrictions exist or are presently proposed; and
73% on streets it is now proposed to introduce such restrictions.
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 24
Parking Pricing
Charges for car parking in areas designated as Pay and Display and Permit Parking were observed to
be 1.00 per hour.
Application of Survey Results
On-street car park survey results form an essential input to the parking impact analysis, the outputs of
which are presented within Section 8 of this document. Through distributing over-spill (or excess
demand from the hospital) to Free and Pay Parking areas within the hospital environs, future on-street
car parking occupancy levels have been estimated, thus allowing for parking impacts in the
predominantly residential area to the south and west of the site to be determined.
3.6. Luas Park and Ride Occupancy Observations Red Cow and Cheeverstown
The St. Jamess Campus Smarter Travel Programme, as summarised within Section 6.1.4.5 the EIS
Traffic and Transport Chapter outlines proposals to designate two park and ride sites, at which free
staff car parking would be offered:
Luas Cheeverstown park and ride:- Located between Citywest and Tallaght, and approximately 3
kilometres from the N7 (via the Kingswood Interchange and R136) and 2 kilometres from the N81
(via the R136), the Cheeverstown Luas stop caters for a predominantly local catchment.
Luas Red Cow park and ride:- Located adjacent to the junction of the M50 and N7 roads, this site
serves a strategic function, intercepting traffic directly from the national primary road network.
Spot car park occupancy observations were undertaken on Tuesday 08 September 2015 at 12:45hrs
and 13:15hrs at the above two Luas park and ride sites respectively. The following table, Table 3.4
presents the findings of the observations.
Table 3.4 Luas Red Cow and Cheeverstown Park and Ride Occupancy Observations
Time Period Commencing Total Capacity 2 Occupied % Occupancy
Luas Red Cow Park and Ride Site 727 537 73.9%
Luas Cheeverstown Park & Ride Site 321 39 12.1%
The above occupancy observations reinforce the strategic versus local function of both park and ride
sites, with park and ride demand at Red Cow 13.8 times greater than that at Cheeverstown.
2 Capacities as per Section 6.1.4.5 of the EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 25
4. Development Proposal Overview and Key Data
4.1. St. Jamess Hospital Campus
The new hospital represents a
consolidation of existing childrens
hospitals at Crumlin, Tallaght and Temple
Street onto a single site within the St.
Jamess Hospital Campus, Jamess Street,
Dublin 8, and consists of:
a 473 no. bed (380 in-patient and 93
day care) new childrens hospital,
with a gross floor area of 118,113 sqm;
a 53 no. bed family accommodation unit, with a gross floor area of 4,354 sqm; and
a childrens research and innovation centre, with a gross floor area of 2,971 sqm.
Satellite centres are also proposed at the Adelaide & Meath/ Tallaght Hospital, and Connolly Hospital,
Blanchardstown.
4.2. National Remit
According to the Planning Report which accompanies the application, the new Childrens Hospital
would provide tertiary / quaternary (highly specialised) services on an all-island basis and secondary
paediatric care (less severe, complicated and more common conditions) to the Greater Dublin Area
(counties Dublin, Wicklow, Kildare and parts of Meath).
4.3. Key Data
Chapter 6 of the EIS the EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter presents a 201 page transport strategy
and resulting impact appraisal for the development proposal. Based on a review of this document,
and drawing upon other identified sources of information, key transport related attributes of the
development proposal are summarised below. More detailed observations are contained in Section 5
of this document, which follows.
Staff Numbers
Section 6.1.4.1 of the EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter provides an overview of staff levels at the
hospital, and is summarised in the following table (Table 4.1).
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 26
Table 4.1 St James Campus Existing and Proposed Staff Numbers
Scenario Overall Staff Numbers Working Core Weekday Hours
Existing St. Jamess Hospital Campus 4,500 3,000
New National Childrens Hospital 3,000 2,000
Total, with New National Childrens
Hospital
7,500 5,000
Patient Numbers
Based on information provided within Section 6.1.4.1 of the EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter, the
following table provides an estimate of daily in-patient, outpatient, day care and urgent care cases at
the proposed new National Childrens Hospital. Also included in this table is a high-level estimate of
daily patient demand at the existing St. James Adults Hospital, derived from the most recent annual
report the St. Jamess Hospital Annual Report (2013).
Table 4.2 St Jamess Hospital Campus Estimated Daily Patient Numbers
In-
patient
Day
Care
Outpatient Non-
Consultant
Clinics
Urgent
Care
Cases
Total
St. Jamess Adult Hospital 909 3 407 4 955 5 128 6 2,399
New National Childrens
Hospital
314 140 864 * 412 237 ** 1,967
Post-development of
National Childrens Hospital
1,223 547 1,819 412 365 4,366
* As per EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter, includes 5% uplift to reflect daily demand fluctuations
** As per EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter, includes 20% uplift to reflect daily demand fluctuations
As can be seen from the table above, the expanded hospital campus can be expected to accommodate
in excess of 4,000 patients per day.
3 St. Jamess Hospital Annual Report, 2013:- 1,010 beds, with a guestimated 90% average occupancy 4 St. Jamess Hospital Annual Report, 2013:- 97,672 day care patients/ assumed 240 days operational
per annum 5 St. Jamess Hospital Annual Report, 2013:- 229,120 outpatients/ assumed 240 days operational per
annum 6 St. Jamess Hospital Annual Report, 2013:- 46,714 attendances/ assumed 365 days operational per
annum
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 27
Car Parking Provision
Existing and proposed levels of on-site car parking are set out within Tables 6.19 and 6.28 of the EIS
Traffic and Transport Chapter. Based on the current proposals, these are summarised in the table
below for the St. Jamess Campus, with changes in levels of on-site car parking capacity from existing
to proposed situations also highlighted.
Table 4.3 St James Campus Existing and Proposed Parking Provision
Scenario Staff 7 Patient/ Visitors Total Staff and
Visitors
Existing: Pre-development of
National Childrens Hospital
1,261 467 1,728
Proposed: Post-development of
National Childrens Hospital
1,017 1,131 2,148
Change, i.e. Proposed Existing -244 +664 +420
As can be seen from the table above, the current proposals represent a modest increase in overall on-
site car parking provision of 420 spaces, however a reduction of 244 staff car parking spaces is
proposed, despite 67% increase in core weekday staff numbers at the site (to approximately 5,000). It
is proposed to increase on-site patient/ visitor car parking capacity by providing a total of 1,131 spaces.
The proposed additional 664 car parking spaces are required to accommodate the needs of patients
and visitors, many of which, in light of the hospitals national remit, will be travelling from outside
Dublin.
7 Includes the off-campus St. Jamess Steel staff car park with 137 car parking spaces
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 28
5. Development Transport Strategy Review
5.1. Proposed Transport Strategy
Chapter 6 of the Environmental Impact Statement, the EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter sets out the
transport strategy and resulting impact assessment for the proposed National Paediatric Hospital
Project. The proposed developments overall strategy is underpinned by the following key studies/
programmes:
St. Jamess Hospital Campus Draft Site Capacity Study (observations in Section 5.2); and
St. Jamess Hospital Campus Smarter Travel Programme (observations in Section 5.3).
In summary, the strategy proposes to cap on-site car parking capacity at approximately 2,000 spaces,
reallocate a substantial proportion of that capacity from staff to visitors, and to manage the travel
needs of staff of the existing adult and three childrens hospitals through a behavioural change
programme.
In preparing this Submission, the proposed developments transport strategy has been subject to
review. Its robustness has also been supported by high-level accessibility analysis, undertaken in
support of this Submission, the outputs of which are presented in Section 5.4.
5.2. St. Jamess Hospital Campus Draft Site Capacity Study
Study Status
A Site Capacity Study has been submitted by the applicant for consideration by ABP alongside other
planning related files. An overview of the study is included within the EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter
(Section 6.1.1.14). The rationale for the draft study status is unclear, however given its significance
in informing fundamental aspects of the development proposals (see below), finalising the study prior
to development of the current hospital proposals would have seemed prudent. Indeed finalising the
study prior to selection of the St. Jamess Hospital for development of a new National Childrens
Hospital may also have been anticipated as a means of demonstrating development feasibility.
Study Remit
Although the study does not purport to be a development plan for the campus but rather an indication
of its potential capacity, it appears that key decisions regarding the provision of car parking and
management of staff travel have been made within the context of this study:
The quantum of parking provided on campus will be capped at approximately 2,000 spaces, serving
both staff and visitor/patient parking needs. The majority of the parking spaces will be provided for
visitors/patients to the hospital campus, with staff access to the campus provided mainly via
alternative modes (public transport, cycling, walking), which will be actively promoted through the
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 29
St Jamess Hospital Campus Smarter Travel Programme. The car parking strategy involves the
transfer of parking from staff to visitors/ patients as the hospital continues to expand. The
additional travel needs of staff will be catered for through the Smarter Travel Programme which will
be supported by the Governments continued investment in public transport projects in the Greater
Dublin Area (i.e. Swiftway BRT Network, DART Underground, Lucan Luas, etc..).
The following observations are provided in relation to the above statement:
The level of proposed on-site car parking does not appear to have been underpinned by an
analysis of user needs, in this instance patients, visitors and staff of the expanded site. More
specifically:
No patient/ visitor car parking accumulation analysis appears to have been undertaken,
which would have considered relative levels of accessibility by car versus public transport
at a national level to the hospital, and informed a determination of on-site patient/ visitor
car parking provision. The outputs of a patient/ visitor parking accumulation analysis are
presented within the EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter, however following review, the
analysis appears to have significantly underestimated on-site parking demand. The
implications of such deficiencies are considered as part of a parking impact analysis set out
in Section 8 of this document.
As detailed in Section 5.3 which follows, the attractiveness and feasibility of catering for the
travel needs of an expanded hospital, with up to 5,000 core weekday staff, with reduced
levels of on-site car parking does not also appear to have been considered.
As noted in Section 5.3, and further detailed in a revised patient/ visitor parking
accumulation exercise in Section 8.1, it does not appear that sufficient on-site car parking
capacity, across total staff and patient/ visitor car parking stock, exists to cater for elevated
staff car parking demand during staff handover periods.
The draft study places excessive emphasis on the role and potential of the St Jamess Hospital
Campus Smarter Travel Programme in promoting use of more sustainable transport modes. The
Smarter Travel Programme will not however facilitate such use, because in addition to
interventions within the Programme, a wide range of external factors will either facilitate or
hinder sustainable staff travel these include public transport availability and attractiveness, and
the quality of the cycle network throughout the city. This is further expanded upon within Section
5.3 which follows.
The importance placed within the Draft Site Capacity Study on the delivery of schemes such as
DART Underground, Lucan Luas etc. represent an acknowledgement on behalf of the applicant
of the limitations imposed by the existing public transport network in terms of staff and patient/
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 30
visitor access. Such public transport network limitations include capacity constraints and poor
accessibility, i.e. impacting on the ease with which people can access the hospital site from
throughout its staff catchment area.
Staff travel needs are dependent on the potential future delivery of new public transport
projects - the identified schemes however, to the knowledge of Transport Insights, have neither
funding commitment in the form of an accepted Business Case and allocated funds, nor
planning consent at present. As such, uncertainty and risk surrounding the delivery of these
schemes undermines confidence in a key element of the transport strategy for the expanded St.
Jamess Hospital site. The recent Government announcement regarding DART Underground
reinforces this point.
Behavioural change initiatives will play a more limited role in influencing the travel behaviours of
shift workers, as the feasibility of using non-car transport modes is more limited, due to for
example, darkness and associated safety and security concerns reducing propensity to walk or
cycle, and reduced public transport service frequencies.
The Draft Study states that The car parking strategy does not include increasing the overall number of
parking spaces provided on campus following the completion of the new childrens hospital. This will
result in no material increase in traffic during peak periods on the surrounding street network
As noted in Table 4.3 of this Submission, the current development proposals, whereby it is proposed
to increase total staff and patient/ visitor car parking from 1,591 to 2,011 spaces (excluding the off-
campus St. Jamess Steel staff car park) represents an increase of 26% in the total on-site car parking
capacity. As such this statement appears factually incorrect, and undermines the statement that
delivery of additional development on campus can be accommodated without impacting on prevailing
traffic conditions on the surrounding road network.
The following table summarises the approach pursued in undertaking the Site Capacity Study, relative
to what might have been expected had its approach followed best practice.
Table 5.1 Draft Site Capacity Study Best Practice Overview
Approach Pursued Best Practice Implications
Determination of a cap on
on-site car parking to ensure
that it doesnt impact on
prevailing traffic conditions
on the surrounding road
network.
User oriented research and
analysis of:
car dependency characteristics
for similar development types;
and
development specific car parking
requirements by user group.
High risk that parking
provision will not
meet user needs
(patients, visitors and
staff) this is further
analysed within
Section 8.
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 31
Approach Pursued Best Practice Implications
Assumption that travel needs
of staff will be catered for
through the Smarter Travel
Programme.
Basing the strategy on
potential future public
transport projects e.g. DART
Underground, Lucan Luas,
etc.
International best practice
research into effectiveness of
smarter travel programmes in
reducing levels of staff car use.
Basing strategy on committed
schemes, i.e. with allocated funds
and planning consent.
Feasibility of
relocating staff from
the existing campus
questionable.
5.3. St. Jamess Hospital Campus Smarter Travel Programme
Background
As noted above, alongside the future delivery of new public transport schemes, the Draft Site Capacity
Study has identified the role of the Smarter Travel Programme as essential to achieving the required
level of reductions in staff car use following delivery of the proposed development.
Policy Context
The EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter (Section 6.1.1.3) draws upon the Dublin City Development Plan
2011-2017 and the Dublin City Draft Development Plan 2016-2022 as a basis for the strong emphasis
given to mobility management planning stating that they particularly emphasise the importance of
travel demand management, with each of the planning documents identifying the need to implement
mobility management plans at workplaces, schools and residential areas.
At a national level, the Smarter Travel A Sustainable Transport Future: A New Transport Policy for
Ireland 2009- 2020 policy document, published by the Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport
(Section 6.1.1.9) provides policy justification, as follows:
The new childrens hospital at the St Jamess Hospital campus reflects the overall aims of
Smarter Travel, as it provides intensification of an urban area with good sustainable transport
accessibility, whilst providing a considerable critical mass of commuting journeys to have a real
impact on the targets set out in the smarter travel document.
While Luas is recognised as an important transport asset for the site, no evidence is however provided
by the applicant in support of the assertion that the site has good sustainable transport
accessibility. This might more reasonably be expected to represent the environs of an interchange
between two or more high quality public transport corridors, not a single corridor as per the St. Jamess
Hospital site. As noted in Section 5.2, the importance placed within the Draft Site Capacity Study on
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 32
the delivery of schemes such as DART Underground, Lucan Luas etc. acknowledges the existing public
transport networks accessibility limitations.
Current Staff Travel Patterns and Smarter Travel Programme Targets
The staff travel survey for St. Jamess Hospital and the three existing childrens hospitals provides
information on current levels of staff car and public transport use. These are presented in Table 5.2
below, with the estimated staff numbers at each of the four hospitals included to combined existing
and target car and public transport mode shares for the four hospitals which would be merged as part
of the current development proposal.
Table 5.2 Current Surveyed and Target Future Mode Share Targets
Hospital Estimated
Staff
Numbers
Car Driver Public Transport (including
Park & Ride)
Current
Survey Mode
Share
Future Target
Arrival Mode
Share
Current
Survey Mode
Share
Future Target
Arrival Mode
Share
St. Jamess
Hospital
1,261 57% 18% 16% 35%
Tallaght 225 76% 18% 10% 35%
Temple Street 1,200 38% 18% 36% 35%
Crumlin 1,880 77% 18% 6% 35%
Total 4,566 61% 18% 17% 35%
Although the provision of free parking for staff at the Luas Park and Ride facilities is included under
the Measures to Encourage Public Transport Use heading, the target car mode share include a
targeted modal share for the Park and Ride sites of 9%.... In the same way as a commuter who cycles
to the train station to take a train is generally considered a rail user, including park and ride users
within the car driver category is most unusual. It also gives a false impression in relation to extent of
challenge to be overcome in achieving the very substantial reductions in staff car use, as would be
more evident if park and ride users were instead classified according to their arrival mode. As such,
both current mode shares and mode share targets within the above table are presented according
to the generally used arrival mode share.
The EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter (Section 6.1.4.5) notes that there may be some
underrepresentation of short distance trips, which may account for some overrepresentation of car
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 33
and public transport use (3% and 1% respectively in the case of St. Jamess Hospital). The analysis does
however highlight the challenge of achieving such a radical change in staff travel behaviours, in
particular in the context of staff relocating from current to new place of work with different (and
generally inferior) accessibility characteristics.
Potential medium-long term on-site development of the maternity hospital, would according to EIS
Traffic and Transport Chapter result in a further 4% reduction in staff car mode share. In light of the
already very restricted levels of on-site car parking forming part of the current proposed development,
and the over-reliance on both mobility management and future delivery of uncommitted public
transport schemes such as DART Underground (as noted in Section 5.2 of this document), the applicant
has not demonstrated how these substantial further reductions in staff car use can be achieved.
St. Jamess Hospital Mobility Management Plan Status
The EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter (Section 6.0) states that A Mobility Management Plan has been
prepared for the St Jamess Hospital campus (St Jamess Hospital Campus Smarter Travel Programme)
and is currently being implemented..
While the development and implementation of a Mobility Management Plan for St. Jamess Hospital
Campus appears a welcome development, as noted in the very
high staff car park occupancy observations Section 3.2 of this
Submission, the exact status of the Plans implementation is
unclear. The observed levels of staff car parking indicate that
behavioural change interventions do not appear to have been
effective to date in reducing levels of staff car use to the
hospital. In light of the proposed significant reductions in car
use capacity, reductions in staff car use represent the key
performance indicator (KPI) for the Plan.
A further KPI of the effectiveness of the Plan is levels of staff
cycle use. The EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter (Section
6.1.3.4) notes that there are a total 300 spaces (including
secure and covered bike shelters) within the campus.
Observed occupancy levels at a sample of secure bicycle parking facilities on the day of the site
assessment (two areas, approximately 75% occupied) indicates that bicycle parking facilities are not
presently hindering greater levels of staff cycle use. Additionally, the EIS Traffic and Transport Chapter
(Section 6.1.3.4) refers to shower and locker facilities for staff in some of the buildings. Existing on-
site cycle facilities indicate that other factors, such as inadequate cycle network provision within the
city, are likely to be a greater factor in hindering greater levels of staff cycling to the site. Addressing
Proposed National Childrens Hospital Transport Submission
Transport Insights Limited, Ground Floor, 11/ 12 Baggot Court, Dublin 2, Ireland Email:- info@transportinsights.com | Telephone:- + 353 1 685 2279 34
these constraints is however outside the control of the applicant to deliver, and network wide
improvements to the extent set out in the Greater Dublin Area Cycle Network Plan, and that are
required to accommodate the large staff catchment area of the four hospitals, will invariably take a
long number of years to deliver.
Status of Existing Childrens Hospitals
The proposed development represents a consolidation of the three existing childrens hospitals at
Crumlin, Tallaght and Temple Street into a single site at the St. Jamess Hospital Campus:
The Mobility Management Plan will also be rolled out at each of the existing three childrens
hospitals to improve mobility awareness and to reduce car dependency among staff before they
relocate to the new childrens hospital on the St Jamess Hospital campus.
No equivalent Mobility Management Plan therefore exists at present for the three childrens
hospitals, despite staffs current residential location being based on proximity to their current place
of work, and more limited opportunities for them to transfer from car to other modes arising from a
transfer to St. Jamess Hospital Campus. Mobility management measures can represent important
demand management/ behavioral change interventions, however their effectiveness is dependent on
attractive alternative transport options. The extent to which realistic alternative travel choices are
available for staff transferring from the existing childrens hospitals is unclear, however from
observations of staff origins as presented in Figures 6.28, 6.32 and 6.36, major challenges in
facilitating future staff travel needs are evident. A mobility management plan will play a relatively
limited role in overcoming such challenges.
Mobility Management Planning Assumptions
The Mobility Management Plan for the expanded St. Jamess Campus is based on the following
overarching assumption:
The existing staff demographics for St Jamess Hospital has been used as the basis for the
appraisal of the Mobility Management Plan as it represents the majority of the staff which will
be employed within the overall St Jamess Hospital campus when the new childrens hospital is
operational. It is also reflective of the fact that the current distribution of staff based at the three
childrens hospitals is likely to change over time when staff move to the new childrens hospital
at St Jamess Hospital campus. Future staff of the new childrens hospital are likely to choose
accommodation that is readily accessible by convenient modes including walking, cycling and
Recommended