View
0
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
PMD Pro Project Management for Development Professionals
A quick Guide to the
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
2
Publisher ©Copyright2018PM4NGOsPgMDProandthePgMDProsymbolaretrademarksofPM4NGOsathttp://www.pm4ngos.org.
ThisworkislicensedundertheCreativeCommonsAttribution-NonCommercial4.0InternationalLicense.Toviewacopyofthislicense,visithttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.
Usersarefreetocopy/redistributeandadapt/transformfornon-commercialpurposes.
Version information: Thisis“AQuickGuidetothePMDPro”compiledbyPM4NGOsBoardMember,PeterMarlow,andbasedon“ProjectManagementforDevelopmentProfessionalsGuide(PMDProGuide)”version1.9,December2017
Version1.2datedMarch2018–reformattedandlightediting
PreviousVersionsandHistory:Version1.1datedJuly2016–changedfrontcovergraphicsVersion1datedJune2015–superseded
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
3
IntroductionChangingtheworldthroughprojectsDevelopmentorganizationsmanagetheirworkthroughprojects.TheirofficesarestaffedbyProjectOfficers,whomanageprojectteams.Thecommunitiestheyservetrusttheprojectstodeliverbenefit.However,developmentorganizationstendtofocusonthetechnicalprogrammaticareasoftheirprojectsandhirespecialistswhoarethenaskedtomanageprojectsandleadprojectteams.Itisnotascommon,however,tofindthattheyhaveextensiveexperienceandskillsintheareaofprojectmanagement.ThePMDPro-ProjectManagementinDevelopmentforProfessionals-wasestablishedtoimprovedevelopmentprofessionalsprojectmanagementcapacityandtoprovidecommonstandards,processesandtools.Whilegoodprojectmanagementprinciplesareuniversal,thePMDProbuildsonestablishedmethodologiestoprovideapracticalguidancetorunningdevelopmentprojects.ThispamphletisabriefintroductiontoPM4NGOs’GuidetoProjectManagementforDevelopmentProfessionals(PMDPro),whichisfor:
• ProjectManagersandteammemberswhoarenewtoprojectmanagement;• ProjectManagersandteammemberswhoarenewtothedevelopment
sector;• Developmentsectorprofessionalswhointendtopursueprofessional
credentialsinprojectmanagement;• Consultants/contractstaffoperatinginthedevelopmentsector.
HowtheGuideisorganizedTheGuidetothePMDProisorganizedintofourmainsections:
#1 ProjectsintheDevelopmentSector#2 PhasesintheLifeofaDevelopmentProject#3 ProjectManagementDisciplines#4 AdaptingthePMDPro
TheFivePrinciplesofProjectManagementintheDevelopmentSectorIntheGuidetothePMDPro,readerswillfindtextboxesthatrefertokeyconceptsthatthePMDProidentifiesasthe“FivePrinciplesofProjectManagementintheDevelopmentSector.Eachtextboxprovidesabriefanecdote,casestudyorobservationthathighlightstheimportanceofincorporatingtheprinciplesofthedesign,planningandimplementationofdevelopmentprojects.
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
4
1. ProjectManagementisBalanced–Projectsshouldbemanagedinabalancedway,applyingequalrigorthroughallofthephasesofthelifeoftheproject.
2. ProjectManagementisComprehensive-Projectmanagementdisciplinesshouldbeappliedtomanageconsistentlyanddeliberatelyalltheworkoftheprojectthroughtheentirelifeoftheproject.
3. ProjectManagementisIntegrated-Allaspectsofprojectmanagementshouldbealignedandcoordinatedasameanstoensurethatallelementsofprojectdesign,planning,monitoringandimplementationrunsmoothly.
4. ProjectManagementisParticipatory–Theinclusionofavarietyofstakeholdersintheidentification,design,planning,implementationandmonitoringoftheprojecthelpstoensuretransparency,improvequality,increasehumancapacityandstrengthenbuy-inatalllevels.
5. ProjectManagementisIterative–Revisitandrepeatprojectmanagementprocessesthroughthelifeoftheprojecttoconfirmthattheprojectdesigns,projectplansandintendedresultsarestillrelevant.Thispracticealsoprovidestheopportunitytoimprovetheiraccuracyofexistingprojectestimatesandtoplanforthenextstepsintheproject.
#1 PROJECTS IN THE DEVELOPMENT SECTOR ManagingProjectsischallenging!Managingprojectsinthedevelopmentsectorisanythingbutsimple.Theoperatingenvironmentsarecomplex.Thechallengesarenumerous.Theprojectrelationshipsarecomplicated.And,thecostoffailureishigh.Inshort,thereisalotthatcouldgowrong!Tosucceed,theprojectmanagermustproactivelyanddecisivelymanagethesechallenges.
Youarenotalone!Whilethechallengesconfrontingdevelopmentprojectsareextensiveandcomplex,theyarebynomeansexclusivetoprojectsmanagedinthedevelopmentsector.Thetopthreeissuesare:
1. Incompleterequirementsandspecifications;2. Lackofcontingencyplanningformanagingrisks;and3. Failuretolearnfrommistakes.
Thecommonchallengesare:
• Deliveringprojectresultsinthecontextoftime,budget,quality,scope,riskandbenefitconstraints;
• Developingcomprehensiveanddetailedprojectplansandmanagingthemthroughtheentirelifeoftheproject;
• Managingprojectsthatareoftenimplementedviacontractors,sub-contractorsandsuppliers;and
• Identifyingpotentialrisksandestablishingprocessestoavoidandaddresstheserisksandensuringthattheintendedprojectbenefitsaredelivered.
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
5
Developmentprojectsdohoweverhaveuniquecharacteristics:• Developmentprojectsareresponsiblenotonlyfordeliveringtangible
outputs,butalsofordeliveringlesstangibleoutcomesrelatedtopromotingsocialchangeand/orbehaviorchange.
• Developmentprojectsarelesslikelytofocusondeliveringconcreteproductsastheultimategoaloftheproject.Instead,theyconsidertheseproductsasameansthatleadstoimprovementsinthewellbeingoftheproject’stargetpopulations.
• Developmentprojectsaimtoaddresscomplexproblemsofpoverty,inequalityandinjustice.
• Developmentprojectstendtooperateinexceptionallychallengingcontexts(limitedresources,highrisks,complexprocurementnetworks,unstablepolitical/financialenvironments,unsafeconditions).
• Projectimplementationisoftenmanagedthroughacomplexarrayofstakeholderrelationships(partneragencies,governmentministries,community-basedorganizations,contractors,globalconsortia).
• Theprojectapproachisoftenasimportantastheoutcomesthemselves(includingahighpriorityplacedonparticipation,rights-basedapproaches).
• Transferringknowledgeandlearningtothetargetpopulationisapriorityduringeachandeveryphaseoftheproject.
DefiningTermsAprojectisatemporaryendeavorundertakentocreateauniqueproduct,service,orresult.Basedonthisdefinition,thepurposeofprojectmanagementistoplan,organizeandmanageresourcestobringaboutthesuccessfulcompletionofspecificprojectgoals,outcomesandoutputs.Withinthecontextofprojectmanagement,theprojectmanagerisresponsibleforensuringtheoverallsuccessoftheproject.Andyet,whiletheprojectmanagerisresponsibleforprojectsuccess,thisdoesnotmean,however,thattheprojectmanagerispersonallyresponsibleforcompletingtheprojectwork.Infact,thisisseldomthecaseinthedevelopmentsector.Instead,theresponsibilityoftheprojectmanageristoworkcloselywithanarrayofstakeholderstocompletetheworkoftheproject.Itisnotunusualforstakeholderswithinasingleprojecttohavedifferentethnicities,languages,culturesandevennationalities.Thechallengeofmanaginggroupswithinthiscontextcanbeespeciallydifficult.Programmanagementistheprocessofmanagingagroupofrelatedprojectsinacoordinatedwaytoobtainbenefitsandcontrolnotavailablethroughmanagingthemindividually.SeePM4NGOs’GuidetoProgramManagement.Portfoliomanagementoverseestheperformanceoftheorganization’scollectionofprojectandprograms.
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
6
TheTripleConstraintProjectshavea“tripleconstraint”of:
• Scope/quality• Cost/Resources• Time/Schedule
Thiscanbebestunderstoodwhendrawnasatriangle,whichshouldalwaysstayinbalance.TheArt&ScienceofProjectManagementTheartofprojectmanagementfocusesonthepeopleelementsofaproject.Itrequiresskillsthatenableprojectmanagerstolead,enable,motivateandcommunicate.Theartisticprojectmanagercandirecttheteamwhenworkchallengesshift,realignprioritieswhenthefieldrealitieschangeresolveconflictswhentheyarise,anddeterminewhichinformationtocommunicatewhenandtowhom.Thescienceofprojectmanagementfocusesontheplanning,estimating,measuringandcontrollingofwork.Thescienceencompassesthewho-does-what-whenquestions?Akeytoasuccessfulprojectisidentifyingabalancedprojectmanagerwhoiscomfortablewithboththeartandscienceofprojectmanagement.PMDProProjectManagementCompetencyModelWhiletheclassificationofprojectmanagementskillsintothecategoriesof“art”and“science”ishelpful,itisonlyafirststepinidentifyingthecharacteristicsofasuccessfulprojectmanager.Amorecomprehensiveprojectmanagementcompetencymodelwillhelpidentifytherequisiteskillsofprojectmanagersandcanthenserveasatooltoassessskilllevels,identifyareasforimprovement,andtomapareasforcareerdevelopment.Whilemultiplecompetencymodelsexistforprojectmanagers,thePMDPromodelorganizesprojectmanagementcompetenciesintofourareas:
• Technical–theseareoftenreferredtocollectivelyasthe‘science’behindprojectmanagement.Cantheprojectmanageridentify,selectandemploytherighttoolsandprocessestoensureprojectmanagementsuccess?
• Leadership/Interpersonal–oftenreferredtocollectivelyasthe‘art’ofprojectmanagement.Forexample,howdoestheprojectmanagercommunicate,inspire,andresolveconflict?
• Personal/Self-Management–theprojectmanager'sabilitytoself-manage.Forexample,cantheprojectmanagereffectivelyprioritize,managetimeandorganizework?
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
7
• DevelopmentSectorSpecific–theabilitytoapplythetechnical,leadership/interpersonalandpersonal/self-managementcompetenciesinthecontextofdevelopmentprojects.Forexample,cantheprojectmanageridentify,selectandemploytherighttoolsandprocessesthatareuniquetothedevelopmentsector?
Inadditiontothesefourgeneralcompetencyareas,projectmanagersshouldalsopossessthecompetencytoworkeffectivelywithinthecultureoftheirownorganization.Cantheprojectmanagernavigatehis/herspecificorganization’smanagementframework,organizationalculture,businessprocesses/systemsandhumanresourcesnetworks?Theorganization’sculturedefinesitsidentify(brand)anddistinguishesitfromotherorganizationsmanagingsimilarprojects.Whileallfour-competencyareasofprojectmanagementarecriticaltoensuringprojectsuccess,thescopeoftheGuidetothePMDProspecificallyfocusesontheTechnicalCompetencyAreaofprojectmanagers.Sections#2,#3and#4oftheGuidefocusontheprocesses,toolsandmechanismsthatcanbeusedtostrengthenthedesign,planning,implementation,monitoring,controlandclosureofprojects.Itisundisputablethatprojectmanagersshouldalsoworktostrengthentheirpersonal,interpersonalanddevelopmentsector-specificcompetencies;however,itisnotthegoaloftheGuidetoelaborateextensivelyonthoseareasofprofessionaldevelopment.#2 PHASES IN THE LIFE OF A DEVELOPMENT PROJECT BalancedProjectManagementthroughtheProjectLifeFordevelopmentprojectstosucceed,itiscriticalthatthefullarrayofprojectmanagementcompetenciesbeappliedinabalancedwaythroughtheentirelifeoftheproject.Tothisend,manydevelopmentorganizationshavedevelopedProjectLifeCyclediagrams,whichtheyusetoidentifythephasesthroughwhichtheirprojectspassfrombeginningtoend.Together,theseprojectlifecyclephasesidentifythelogicalsequenceofactivitiesthataccomplishtheproject’sgoalsorobjectives.Theexactsequenceandwordingofprojectlifecyclediagramscanvaryconsiderablybetweenindustriesandorganizations;however,theirobjectivesarethesame.Bygroupingactivitiesintoaprojectlifecyclesequence,theprojectmanagerandthecoreteamcan:
• Definethephasesthatconnectthebeginningofaprojecttoitsend;• Identifytheprocessesthatprojectteamsmustimplementastheymove
throughthephasesoftheprojectlifecycle;• Illustratehowtheprojectmanagementlifecyclecanbeusedtomodelthe
managementofprojects;• Modelhowprojectsworkwithinanenvironmentof‘constraints’,where
changestoanyoneconstraintwillresultinconsequentialchangestotheotherprojectparameters.
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
8
ThePMDProProjectPhaseModelWhilerecognizingthatnumerousprojectlifecyclediagramsexistamongorganizationsinthedevelopmentsector,thePMDProsubscribestoitsownsix-stepprojectphasemodel(seeFigure1above).ThePMDProProjectPhaseModelwasdesignedwiththeexpressintentofensuringthatthemodelisbalancedandcomprehensive.Balanceandcomprehensivenessintheprojectmodelareespeciallyimportantwithinthecontextofthedevelopmentsector.Toooften,developmentorganizationshaveplacedanespeciallystrongemphasisonprojectDesign,MonitoringandEvaluation(DM&E);butthisemphasishassometimesovershadowedtheimportanceofotherphasesinthelifeoftheproject.Clearly,strongDM&Eisnecessary.However,itisnotsufficienttoguaranteeprojectsuccess.Aprojectmustnotonlyinvestinstrong,coherentprojectDM&E,butmustalsocommittoinvestingsimilarlevelsofresourcesandeffortinallthephasesinthelifeoftheproject.InthePMDProProjectPhaseModel,forexample,theProjectMonitoring,EvaluationandControlactivitiesarecontinuallypresentinthebackgroundoftheproject.However,theyareonlyonecomponentofthesix-phaseProjectPhaseModelthatincludes:
• ProjectIdentificationandDesign-Itisduringthisphasethattheprojectteamsidentifyanddefineneeds,exploreopportunities,analyzetheprojectenvironment,anddesignalternativesforprojectdesign.ThedecisionsmadeduringtheProjectIdentificationandDesignPhasesetthestrategicandoperationalframeworkwithinwhichtheprojectwillsubsequentlyoperate.
• ProjectSetUp-Itisduringthisphasethattheprojectisofficiallyauthorizedanditsoverallparametersaredefinedandcommunicatedtothemainprojectstakeholders.Itisalsoduringthisphasethattheprojectteamestablishesthehigh-levelprojectgovernancestructure.
• ProjectPlanning–Startingfromthedocumentsdevelopedinearlierphasesoftheproject;duringtheplanningphasetheteamdevelopsacomprehensiveanddetailedimplementationplanthatprovidesamodelforalltheworkof
Figure1
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
9
theproject.Thisplanisrevisitedthroughoutthelifeoftheprojectandupdated(ifnecessary)toreflectthechangingcontextsoftheproject.
• ProjectImplementation–Theday-to-dayworkofprojectimplementationistoleadandmanagetheapplicationoftheprojectimplementationplan:Leadingtheteam,dealingwithissues,managingtheprojectteamandcreativelyintegratingthedifferentelementsoftheprojectplan.
• ProjectMonitoring,EvaluationandControl–Thisphaseextendsthroughtheentirelifeoftheprojectandcontinuallymeasurestheproject’sprogressandidentifiesappropriatecorrectiveactionsinsituationswheretheproject’sperformancedeviatessignificantlyfromtheplan.
• EndofProjectTransition–Thisphaseincludesimplementingallthetransitionactivitiesthatneedtooccurattheendofaproject,including(butnotlimitedto)confirmingthedeliverableswithbeneficiaries,collectinglessonslearned,andcompletingtheadministrative,financialandcontractualclosureactivities.
WhilethePMDProProjectPhaseModelgivestheimpressionthatthephasesarediscreteandsequential,inpracticetheyinteractandoverlap.Asprojectsprogressthroughthesixphases,itisrecommendedthattheprojectteamrevisitthejustificationandplanningoftheprojectthroughaseriesofformaldecisiongates(representedbytrianglesinthePMDProprojectphasemodelinFigure1).Phase1:ProjectIdentificationandDesignAllprojectsbeginasanidea–aneedoropportunitythatisassessed,analyzed,andultimatelydevelopedintoaproject,whichismanagedthroughtheprojectlifecycle.ThefirstphaseoftheprojectisthereforeProjectIdentificationandDesign.Theworkcompletedduringthisphasecanbesummarized:
• Collectingdata;• Analyzingdata;and• Identifyingtheprojectinterventionlogic.
Theoutputsofthisphase,dependontheprojectcontext,butcouldconsistofthefollowingdocuments:
• ProjectConceptPaper.Thisdocumentispresentedtointernalstakeholderstointernallyauthorizeexploratoryassessmentandanalysisactivitiesandtoreceivefeedbackonpotentialproposaldevelopment.
• ProjectLogicalFramework(LogFrame)isananalyticaltoolusedtoplan,monitorandevaluateprojects.Itderivesitsnamefromthelogicallinkagessetoutbytheplanner(s)toconnectaproject’smeanswithitsends.
• ExpressionofInterest.Thisdocumentissubmittedtopotentialdonorstoobtainagreenlightfromkeyexternalstakeholders.Thisdocumentisintendedtobedevelopedinarelativelyshorttimeperiodusinglimitedresources,andisintendedtogenerateaconversationaboutthehigh-leveldesignoftheproject,andtoreceivefeedbackfortheprojectBEFORE
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
10
considerableresourcesaredevotedtodevelopingamoreexpansiveprojectproposal.
• ProjectProposal.Inthisstepaformaldocumentisdevelopedtoreceiveapprovalforarequestforfundingforaproject.Thisdocumentshouldbeclearandmorepreciseindescribingtheproject’sCSSQ(cost,scope,scheduleandquality).Theformatoftheprojectproposaldevelopmentprocesscanvaryconsiderably,dependingonthesizeoftheprojectandthedonorrequirements.
CollectingDataThefirststepindeterminingwhetheryouare“doingtherightproject”istocollectdata.Thepurposeofthisdatacollectionistobroadlyexploreawidenumberandvarietyofissues,providinginformationwhich,whenanalyzed,willinformprioritiesandidentifyinterventionsthatwilladdressthechallengesinatargetarea.IdentifyingProjectNeedsAspartofthisbroadexplorationprocess,theprojectteamwillneedtocollectdatathatidentifiescommunityneedsinthepotentialinterventionarea.However,thedatashouldnotbelimitedsolelytoexaminingissuesrelatedtocommunityneeds.Othertopicstoexploreshouldincludethepresentstateofserviceprovision,theexistingstrengthswithinthecommunity,anexaminationofstakeholderspresentintheinterventionareaandmore.Oneofthechallengeswhencollectingdataisthattheprocesscanbehighlysubjective.Atechniquecalled“triangulation”canbeusedtofacilitatevalidationofdatathroughcross-verificationfrommorethantwosources.OnewaytotriangulatetheprocessofneedsidentificationistouseanapproachintroducedbyAmericansociologist,JonathanBradshaw,whobelievedthatneedsassessmentsshouldexplorefourtypesofneedinacommunityandthatthepresenceofalltypesofneedswouldindicatea“real”need.
Bradshaw’sfourcategoriesofsocialneed(Figure2)included:
• Normativeneeds–comparethecurrentsituationtoasetofprofessionalorexpertstandards;
Figure2:TriangulatingNeedsUsingBradshaw’sClassification
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
11
• Comparativeneeds–comparethecurrentsituationwiththeneedsofothers;
• Feltneeds–focusonthethoughtsandreamsofthecommunityitself;• Expressedneeds–areinferredbyobservationofthecommunity’sactions.
TypesofDataThedatacollectionprocess,however,isnotlimitedsolelytodefiningneeds.Tofullyunderstandtheprojectcontext,theprojectteamwillneedtocollectdataregardinganumberofareasrelatedtotheprojectenvironment.Threetypesofdatamaybecollected,althoughcareshouldbeusedtoselectthemostappropriateandcost-effectivetoolsandapproachestocollectinformation:
• Secondarydata–informationfrompublishedorunpublishedsources;• Primaryquantitativedata-collectingdatathroughsurveys;• Primaryqualitativedata–incontracttoquantitativedata,thequalitative
approachseekstocaptureparticipants’experiencesusingwords.Thisgivesthedatarichness,createsopennessandstimulatespeople’sindividualexperiences.
AnalyzingdataInorderingandorganizingtherawdata,therearetwobroadcategoriesofanalysis:
• CurrentStateAnalysis–usingvariousanalysistoolstounderstandthestatus,condition,trendsandkeyissuesaffectingpeople’slivelihoods.
• FutureStateAnalysis-oncethecurrentstateanalysisiscomplete,thefuturestateanalysislooksathowtheprojectwillimprovethelivelihoods,ecosystemsorinstitutionsoftheprojectparticipants.
IdentifyingtheProjectInterventionLogicNowthatthedatacollectionanddataanalysisprocessesarecomplete,thenextstepistobegintoidentifytheprojectlogic.Oneoftheprincipletoolsusedtoestablishthelogicofdevelopmentprojectisthelogicalframework(LogFrame)matrix.Thelogicalframeworkisananalyticaltoolusedtoplan,monitorandevaluateprojects.Itderivesitsnamefromthelogicallinkagessetoutbytheplanner(s)toconnectaproject’smeanswithitsends.Whiletherearemanyversionsofprojectlogicalframeworks,thePMDProsubscribestoafour-levellogicalframeworkmodelmakinguptheverticalpartofthematrix:
1. Activitiesareactionstakenthroughwhichinputs(financial,human,technical,materialandtimeresources)aremobilizedtoproducethedeliverables(training,constructing,etc.)
2. Outputsaretangibledeliverablesresultingfromprojectactivities.3. Outcomesarewhattheprojectexpectstoaccomplishatthebeneficiarylevel
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
12
4. Goalsarethehighest-leveldesiredendresultsorimpactstowhichtheprojectcontributes.
TheverticalandhorizontallogicoftheLogFrameisshowninFigures3and4. Project
Description Indicators MeansofVerification Assumptions
Goal
Outcome(s)
Outputs
Activities
Project
Description Indicators MeansofVerification Assumptions
Goal
Outcome(s)
Outputs
Activities
ManagingProjectDecisionGatesProjectteamswanttoavoidthe“perfected,butrejected”scenario,whereorganizationshavealreadyspentthousands(andeventensofthousands)ofdollarsonprojectidentificationanddesignactivities,buttheprojectultimatelylacksthe
Figure3:VerticalLogicoftheLogFrame
Figure4:HorizontalLogicoftheLogFrame
IftheOUTCOMESoccur;ThenthisshouldcontributetotheoverallGOAL
IftheOUTPUTSareproduced;ThentheOUTCOMEScanoccur
IftheACTIVITIESareconducted;ThenOUTPUTScanbeproduced
IfadequateRESOURCES/INPUTSareprovided;ThentheACTIVITIEScanbeconducted
IfthehorizontallogicisfollowedANDassumptionsholdtrue,thentheprojectwilllikelysucceed.
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
13
supportofkeystakeholders(insidetheorganization,inthecommunity,amonggovernmentstaff,orfromtheintendeddonors).Oneofthe“bestpractices”usedtomanagethisriskofisbysubscribingtoadecisiongateprocessthatconsistsofaseriesofauthorizationpointsatvariousstagesoftheproject,withinphasesoratphaseboundaries.Byusingdecisiongates,organizationsidentifyaseriesofpointsintheprojectthatrequireadecisiontoeitherproceedwiththenextphaseoftheproject,modifytheScope,ScheduleorBudgetoftheprojectorendtheprojectoutright.Eachsuccessivedecisiongatebuildsontheworkthatwasdevelopedinthepreviousstage.Phase2:ProjectSetupEstablishingtheProjectGovernanceStructurewithinwhichprojectdecisionsaremade.DependingonprojectsizeorcircumstancethiscouldbeanindividualProjectSponsororaProjectBoard,usuallymadeupofanExecutive,aSeniorUserandaSeniorSupplier.Arobuststructureclarifieswhohasauthorityondecisionsandtolerances,andwheretheaccountabilityliesforthesuccessoftheproject.Officiallyauthorizingthestartoftheprojectbytheprojectgoverningbody.Approvalshouldbedocumentedthroughthedevelopmentofaprojectcharter,whichprovidesahigh-leveldescriptionoftheprojectintermsofpurpose,deliverables,estimatesoftimeandcost,risks,tolerancesandhowchangeswillbemanaged.Theprojectchartershouldbeseenasa“livingdocument”beingupdatedandsignediftherearemajorchangestotheproject.AtthispointtheprojectmanagershouldsetupaRiskRegisterandaLessonsLearnedLog,andstartusingthem.Communicatingtheprojectlaunchtostakeholdersisimportanttoensureaconsistentunderstandingbeforeprojectimplementationbegins.Theprojectcharterisidealforsharingwithalargecommunity,althoughitwouldneedtobeamendedifitcontainsanysensitiveinformation.Articlesinnewspapers,pressconferencesandfieldvisitsetc.canbeusedtocommunicatewiththelargercommunity.Phase3:ProjectPlanningStartingfromthedocumentsdevelopedinearlierphasesoftheproject;duringtheproject-planningphasetheteamdevelopsacomprehensiveanddetailedProjectImplementationPlan(orprojectplanforshort)thatprovidesamodelforalltheworkoftheproject.Thisplanisrevisitedthroughoutthelifeoftheprojectandupdated(ifnecessary)toreflectthechangingcontextsoftheproject.Theplanshouldbebalancedandcovertheworkofallsixphasesoftheproject.Thereshouldbeplanningforprojectsetup,projectimplementation,monitoringandevaluation,revisionoftheplanifchangesoccur,andprojecttransition.Theplanshouldbecomprehensiveincoveringthehowthemanagementand
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
14
coordinationwillworkfortheprojectinthesekeyareas:• Scope;• Time;• Justification;• Stakeholders;• Risks&Issues;and• Resources.
Theplanshouldbeintegrated,takingfullaccountofprojectconstraints.Theplanshouldbeparticipatoryensuringthatstakeholdersareinvolvedintheplanningprocessasfaraspossible.Theplanshouldbeiterative,beinga“livingdocument”whichevolvesastheprojectproceedsandaschangestakeplace.
Phase4:ProjectImplementationTheday-to-dayworkofprojectimplementationistoleadandmanagetheapplicationoftheprojectimplementationplan.Thistaskcanberelativelysimple,orcanbecomeextremelycomplex,dependingonthenatureoftheproject.Asinallprojectmanagement,successduringimplementationispartiallyanart(managingpeople,leadingteams,communicatingwithclarity),butitisalsoascience.Initssimplestform,theresponsibilityoftheprojectmanageristoimplementtheprojectplan.However,uponcloserinspection,itbecomesclearthattheprojectmanagermustapplyanumberoftechnicalskillstosucceedduringimplementation.Theseskillsincludemanagingissues,peopleandinternalcontrols.
• ManagingIssues.Anissueisanunresolveddecision,situationorproblemthatwillsignificantlyimpacttheprojectandthattheprojectteamcannotimmediatelyresolve.Issuesmanagementconsistsofhavingaprocessforidentifyingtheseproblemsandmanagingthemuntiltheyareresolved.Resolvingissuesisfrequentlybeyondtheauthorityoftheteam.However,evenifanissueneedstobeescalatedtothenextlevelordelegatedtoanotherpersontoresolve,itstillneedstobetrackedbytheprojectmanager.
• ManagingPeople.Therearetheprojectmanagerswhoareespeciallyeffectiveatmotivatingteammembers,communicatingvision,empoweringstaff,recognizingachievements,listening,leadingbyexample,resolvingconflictsandbuildingtrust.Thesearethe“soft”skillsandareextremelyimportanttoprojectsuccess.Therearealso“hard”skillsinvolvedinacquiringstaff,developingprojectstaff,conductingperformanceassessmentsandestablishingteamcommunicationnorms.
• ManagingInternalControls.Systemsshouldbeestablishedtoprovidereasonableassuranceregardingtheresponsibleuseofprojectassets.Areasthatbenefitfrominternalcontrolsincludehumanresourcescapacityandsystems,procurement,financial,inventory,contractsandagreements,infrastructure,securityprotocols,fleetmanagementandinformationmanagement.
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
15
Phase5:Monitoring,EvaluationandControlEvenwelldesignedandfullyresourcedprojectswillfacechallenges.Thesecancomeatanypointinthelifeoftheproject,andtheprojectteammustworktocontinuallyrevisitthedesign,planningandimplementationtoconfirmtheyarevalidandwhethercorrectiveactionsneedtobetakenwhentheproject’sperformancedeviatessignificantlyfromitsdesignanditsplan.ThisisthepurposeoftheProjectMonitoring,EvaluationandControlPhase,whichextendsthroughtheentirelifeoftheproject.
• Monitoringisacontinuousreviewofprojectprogressattheactivityandoutputslevels.Ithelpstoidentifynecessarycorrectiveaction.
• Evaluationtendstofocusontrackingprogressatthehigherlevelsofthelogicalframework–i.e.projectoutcomes.Evaluationstendtoexplorequestionslike,“Istheprojectsuccessfulatachievingitsoutcomes?”
TheProjectImplementationPlanwillcontainaMonitoringandEvaluationPlan,whichidentifiesthesystemfortrackingandmeasuringprojectprogress,performanceandimpact.Theprojectlogicalframework(LogFrame)isthefirststepindevelopingthefullmonitoringandevaluationplanfortheproject.Theindicatorsandmeansofverificationthatisincludedforthelogicalframeworkwillultimatelybecomethebuildingblocksforthefullmonitoringandevaluationplanoftheproject.Threeevaluationapproachesthatareusedwithinthedevelopmentsectionarefinalevaluations(oftenmandatedbyafundingagencyororganisationpolicy),mid-termevaluation,andex-postevaluations.Forprojectcontrolitisimportanttorealizethatchangewilloccurduringtheprojectascircumstanceschangeandissuesarise.Projectchangesmustbe:
• Managedthroughaformalchangemanagementprocess;• Analyzedtoensurethattheimplicationofthosechangesarethoroughly
thoughtthrough;• Documentedtoillustratetheircompleteimpactonalltheintegrated
elementsoftheproject.• Communicatedtokeystakeholders.
Projecttolerancesareakeypartofbeingabletoworkautonomouslyasaprojectmanager.Havingatolerancemeanstheprojectmanagerhasacertainamountofflexibilitywithregardtoprojectconstraints.Inpractice,thismeansthattheprojectcanbeoverabitorunderabitandnothavetocontinuallygobacktoprojectboard(orsponsor)torequestapprovalforprojectchanges.Tolerancevaluesshouldbeagreedwiththeprojectboardorsponsorduringtheprojectsetupphase.Tolerancescanbeinanyofthefollowingareas:
• TimeTolerance-theamountoftimebywhichtheprojectcompletioncanbelaterorearlierthantheplanneddate.
• CostTolerance-thepercentage,oracashamount,bywhichtheprojectcanbeoverorundertheplannedbudget.
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
16
• ScopeToleranceismeasuredasanagreedvariationfromtheproductdescription,andanypotentialvariationshouldbedocumentedintheproductbreakdownstructure.
• RiskToleranceprovidesabenchmarkforwhichrisksyoushouldbeescalatingtotheProjectBoard.
• QualityTolerancerangesthatdefineacceptableperformanceforaproduct,documentedintheproductdescriptions.
• BenefitsTolerance-therangesofacceptableperformanceoftheprojectattheoutcomeslevel.
Phase6:EndofProjectTransitionAproject,bydefinition,isatemporaryendeavor,havingadefinedbeginningandend(usuallyconstrainedbydate,butpossiblybyfundingordeliverables).Thetemporarynatureofprojectsdifferentiatesthemfromnormalbusinessoperationsofanorganization(or‘on-goingoperations’,whichisrepetitive,permanentorsemi-permanentfunctionalworkproducingproductsorservices).Inthedevelopmentfield,however,oneoftenfindsprojectsthathavebeeninoperationforyears–withonephaseoftheprojectcontinuingtheworkofthepreviousphases.Thisobservationunderscorestherealitythattheendofaprojectinthedevelopmentsectorisoftenmoreaccuratelycharacterizedasatransitionphaseratherthanasastrictlydefinedprojectclosure.Inpractice,therearefourend-of-projecttransitionscenariosthatexistfordevelopmentprojects.
• Termination.Theprojectisformallyendedandallprojectclosureactivitiescompleted(terminationcouldalsoinclude‘phasingover’ortransferringtheprojectactivitiestoalocalpartner,institutionorcommunity).
• Extension.Negotiationofaddedtimetofinishtheproject(couldbeatadditionalor‘no’cost).
• Expansion.Identificationofelementsforreplicationwithanewtargetareaorpopulation.
• Redesign.Continuationviaanewphasewithmodifiedinterventionsoractivities.
Therearefiveactivitiesassociatedwiththisphase:
• ManagetheEnd-of-ProjectStrategy.Yourprojectplanshouldincludeanendofprojecttransitionplan.Thedevelopmentsectorconsiderstransitionespeciallyimportantbecauseoftheirconcernthatimpactsbesustainedaftertheprojecthasended.OnetoolusedtoplanfortheongoingsustainabilityoftheprojectistheTransitionPlanningMatrix.SeethefullguidetoPMDPro.
• VerifytheProjectScopeandtheAcceptDeliverables.Theprojectmanagershouldcontacttheinternalandexternalstakeholderstoverifythatthescopeoftheprojecthasbeenaccomplishedandthatthedeliverablesareaccepted.Makesurethattheyaresatisfiedwiththeoveralloutcomes.
• CompleteAdministrative,FinancialandContractClosure.Iftheprojectweretobeauditedtwoyearsfollowingclosure,whatwouldhappen?Dosystemsexisttoensurethattheadministrative,financialandcontractualelementsofprojectclosurearecomplete?Thesesystemsarecriticalnotonlybecause
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
17
theyhelpavoidproblemswithprojectaudits,buttheyalsoreducetheriskthattherewillbedisputeswithsuppliers,employees,anddonorsregardingthestatusofaccounts.
• CompleteEndofProjectLearning.AstheprojectenterstheEndofProjectTransitionPhase,itisimportanttoensurethatthelessonslearnedrelatedtotheprojectareadequatelydetailed,andarefiledandeasilyaccessible(throughtheLessonsLearnedLogestablishedinProjectSetUp)orthroughan“AfterActionReview”.Furthermore,itiscriticalthattheprojectmanagerdistributethelessonslearnedtothosewhocanbenefitfromthemotherwisethewheelwillbeconstantlyreinvented.Donorsareofteninterestedinensuringthatlearningisdisseminatedthroughoutthesectortoensurethatnewprojectsbenefitfromlearninggeneratedbyotherprojectstheyhavefunded.Nowadays,NGOsoftenpublishevaluationreports,anddatabasesexistwhichincludethousandsofevaluationreportsfrommanydifferentorganizations.
• CelebrateAccomplishments.Justasitisimportanttoacknowledgethebeginningofaprojectthroughlaunchactivities,aprojectmanagershouldalsoappropriatelycelebrateandformallyacknowledgetheendofprojecttransitionbyrecognizingtheeffortsofteammembers;acknowledgingthecontributionsofkeystakeholderstotheproject;andexpressingappreciationtoindividualsandgroupswhowerecriticaltotheprojectsuccess.Recognitionoftheprojectaccomplishmentswithintheorganizationandtotheoutsideworldmayalsohelpfacilitatepositivepublicrelationsandpreparethewayforfuturebusinessopportunities.
#3 PROJECT MANGEMENT DISCIPLINES Thereisnosingleroadmaptomanagingprojects.Eachprojectisuniquewithitsownobjectives,context;resources;relationships;andchallenges.However,successfulprojectmanagementdemandsthatallprojectteamscomprehensivelyandactivelyapplyadiversesetofprojectmanagementdisciplinesthroughtheentirelifeoftheproject.ThePMDProidentifiessixprojectinteractingmanagementdisciplines,togetherwiththetoolsandmechanismstomanagethem,thatareespeciallyimportantwhenmanagingprojectsinthedevelopmentsector.Discipline1:ScopeManagementAwell-definedprojectscopewillnotonlytelltheprojectteamwhereitisgoing,butitwillalsoexplainhowtheprojectintendstogetthere.Scopemanagementhastwocomponentscriticaltoprojectsuccess:
• Productscope–Includesalloftherequireddeliverablesoftheproject,meetingtheagreedspecification.(Whatisgoingtobedelivered?)
• Projectscope–Includesalloftheworkrequiredtodelivertheproductscope.(Howwilldeliverableswillbecreatedanddelivered?)
Thefollowingproblemsmayarise:
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
18
• UnclearExpectations:Stakeholdersneedtobe100%clearaboutthescopesoastoensurethattheydonothaveincorrectorunrealisticexpectationsaboutwhatproducts/serviceswillbedelivered.
• InaccurateEstimates:Errorsinscopedefinitionoftenresultinscheduleslipsandhencefinallycostoverruns.
• ScopeCreep:Failuretocontroltheboundariesofprojectdeliverablesleadstoascopecreep–aprinciplecauseofprojectdelaysandpotentially“neverending”projects.
TheWorkBreakdownStructure(WBS)istheprincipletoolthatprojectmanagersusetodefineprojectscope.Thearrangestheprojectscopeinanoutlineorhierarchyof‘workpackages.’TheformatoftheWBSnormallytakesassumeseitheragraphicalorindented(written)format–it’ssometimesagoodideatocreatebothwithanappropriatelevelofdetail.ThemajorcategoriesofworkintheWBSareoftenconsistentwiththecontentsoftheprojectlogicalframework.However,theWBSwillincludealevelofcomprehensivenessanddetailthatisoftenabsentfromthelogicalframework.TheremightbeadditionalcategoriesofworkincludedintheWBSthatwerenotincludedinthelogicalframework.TheWBSisalsointendedtoprovidethelevelofspecificdetailthatisoftenmissinginthelogicalframework.Awell-constructedWBScanbeusedto:
• Guidetheprocessofactivityidentificationandsequencing;• Provideabasisfor:
o Accurateestimatesofprojectduration;o Accurateestimatesofprojectcost;o Accurateresourceestimates(vehicles,people,supplies,building
materials);• Identifyrequireddepartmental,subcontracting,supplierservices;• Communicateandagreetheproductandprojectscopewiththeproject’s
stakeholders;• Showthehierarchyofworkneededtocompleteaprojectandindicatethe
interfacesbetweenthem;• Delegatetheworkpackagestoprojectteammembers,implementing
partnersorsuppliers.Discipline2:TimeManagementDeliveringprojectsontimeisoneofthebiggestchallengesfacedinprojectmanagement.Tosuccessfullymanagetime,projectmanagersrequiretheabilitytodevelopaccurateschedulesandtoimplementthemthroughthelifeoftheproject.Thestepsinplanningprocessincludethefollowing:• ActivityDefinition–StartingfromtheWBS,theprojectteamdevelopsan
activitylist,whichcomprehensivelyrecordsalloftheactivitieswithinthescopeoftheproject(orwithinthescopeofaspecificworkpackageoftheproject)that
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
19
needtobeperformedtoproducetheprojectdeliverables.• ActivitySequencing–Next,theprojectteamdevelopsanetworkdiagram,which
graphicallyrepresentsthesequences,relationshipsanddependenciesbetweentheWBS’sactivities.
• ActivityResourceEstimating–Estimatingthetypeandquantityofresourcesavailable/requiredtoperformeachscheduleactivity.Resourcesareoneofthecentralfactorsinfluencingtheprojectduration.
• ActivityDurationEstimating–Estimatingthetimerequiredtocompleteprojectactivities,revisitingthenetworkdiagram.Itisnowpossibletoidentifytheproject’scriticalpath(theminimumtimeneededtocompleteprojectactivities)andtheproject’sfloatorslack(theamountoftimeataskcanbedelayedwithoutimpactingtheprojectschedule.
• ScheduleDevelopment–Creatingaprojectschedulebasedonactivities,sequences,durations,resourcesandscheduleconstraints.Withinthedevelopmentsector,thepreferredtoolforprojectscheduledevelopmentistheGanttChart.Planningandimplementingprojectsismadeeasierifitisviewedassmallmanageableitemswherethedependenciesarevisuallyillustrated,parallelprocessesareapparent,andtheoverallscheduleisportrayedgraphically.AGanttchartusesbarstographicallyrepresentthescheduleofprojectactivities,includingtheirstartdate,enddate,andtheirexpecteddurations.
• ManagingtheProjectSchedule-Projectmanagersshouldmonitortheirschedulesregularlytoensuretheprojectcalendarremainsontrack.Iftheprojectschedulebeginstovary,theprojectteamwillhaveanumberofoptionsthroughwhichtheprojectcangetbackontrack.Forexample,deadlinescanbedelayed,orthescopeoftheprojectcanbereduced.Activitiescanbecompletedinparallel(“Fasttracking”)oradditionalresourcescanbefoundtoaccelerateprogress(“Crashing”).
Discipline3:ProjectResourceManagementOneofthemostimportantandmostchallengingjobsofaProjectManageristoeffectuallyandefficientlyorganizealltheresourcesinvolvedinaproject.Itgoeswithoutsayingthatthecomplexityofthistaskwilldependheavilyonthescopeandnatureoftheprojectathand.Butinallcases,itisACRITICALFACTORBEHINDSUCCESSORFAILURE.ThePMDProfocusesonthreeoftheProjectResourceManagementareas:financemanagement,supplychainmanagementandhumanresourcesmanagement.Thesethreeformthecoreofprojectsupportservices.
FinanceManagementDevelopmentsectororganizationsusuallyrelyonindividualororganizationaldonorstofundprograms–andtheyexpectdonationstobewellmanagedalthoughtheProjectManagermaynothavefullcontroloverthefinancialprocesses.Skillsneedtobedevelopedinthefollowingareas:
• DevelopingBudgets–Thekeytoaccuratebudgetsistoassuringthattheyarecomprehensive(coveringallitems)anddetailed(drillingdownforprecise
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
20
costs).Budgetsshouldincludetransactioncostsandsharedservicescosts.Presentationofaccountsandtimeperiod(multi-year/lifetimeorannual)willusuallyfollowdonorguidelines.
• ActivityBasedBudgetingfocusesonidentifyingcostsofactivities(developedduringscopeplanning)thattakeplaceineveryareaofaprojectanddetermininghowthoseactivitiesrelatetooneanother–includingdirectandindirectwork.Proponentsseeactivitybasedbudgetingasmorerealisticthanotherbudgetingapproaches,asitinvolvesunderstandinghowmuchactivitieswillactuallycost.IfaProjectManagerisabletodevelopacomplete(bothcomprehensiveanddecomposed)listofactivitiesalongwithcostestimatesforactivities,thenabudgetwillproveaccurate.Activitybasedbudgetingalsooffersmoreopportunityforlinestafftogetinvolved,makingitmorelikelythatabudgetwillbeaccurate.
• IdentifyingCostEstimates-Estimatingwillneverbeaprecisesciencebutitcanbeaccurateenoughtosupportgoodprojectdecisions.Aphased-approachisrecommended.Threeapproachesareconsideredbestpractice:
o Topdownestimatesstartwithaglobalestimatefortheprojectcostandthenassignpercentagesforeachprojectelement.
o Bottom-upEstimatesaremadebyestimatingthecostofeachtask,takingadvicewhereavailable,andtotalingthecost.
o ParametricEstimatesusehistoricdata.• MonitoringBudgetsandExpenditures-Tobestmonitorprojectcosts,itis
preferabletomonitorthecostoftheworkcompletedduringatimeperiod.Ratherthandoasimple“pro-rata”.EarnedValueAnalysisisatoolthatcomparestheplannedandactualcostforeachtaskthathasbeenperformedandALSOcomparestherateofprogressoneachtasktowhatwasscheduledintheprojectplan.ThismeansthatinordertoconductEarnedValueAnalysistheProjectManagerwillneedamorecompletesetofdatathatcombineselementsofboththeprojectbudgetANDtheprojectcalendar.
SupplyChainManagementManagingthesupplychaincanbechallengingindevelopmentprojects.PMDProdefinesthreecomponentsinsupplychainmanagement.• ProcurementManagement–Identificationofwhatmaterialsandservicesare
requiredfromwhominaProcurementPlan.• LogisticsManagement–Planning,implementingandcontrollingtheflowof
materialsinatimelymannerandmaintainingaprojectinventory.• AssetManagement–Procureditemsaremonitored,maintainedandultimately
disposedofafteradefinedlifetime.Alowerthresholdforfixedassetsmaybedefined(USD$1000)
HumanResourcesManagementThisisbothanartandscience.Managementtasksincludesacquiringprojectstaff,identifyingassignments,documentingorganizationalcharts,developingprojectstaff,conductingperformanceassessments.
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
21
Discipline4:RiskManagementRiskisthepotentialeffectofuncertaintyonprojectobjectives.Risksareassessedbyprobabilityandimpact.Issuesarerisksthathavebecomeareality.Risksaremanagedthroughafour-stepprocess.• Riskidentification–defineprojectriskcategoriessuchascommercial,
organizationalandpoliticaletc.Identifyspecificrisksthatfitintoeachoftheriskcategories.Notethatriskscanbeeither“negative”,whichcouldharmtheproject,or“positive”,whichcouldgivetheprojectapotentialopportunity.
• Riskassessment-Risksarerankedaccordingtotheirprobabilityandimpact.Nexttheprojectteamneedstoworkwithkeystakeholderstoidentifytheirrisktolerancelevelstoidentifywhatrisksareacceptableandwhichofthemneedtobeactivelymanaged.RisksarethenrankedbypriorityandpotentialimpactonascaleofLow,MediumorHigh.
• Riskresponseplanning–Iftheprojectdecidestoactivelymanagearisktheresponsestrategiesareavoidance,transference,reduction/mitigationandacceptance.ItisgoodpracticetohaveaRiskManagementPlan.
• Riskmonitoringandcontrol–ItisrecommendedthataRiskRegisterbeestablishedasearlyinthelifeoftheprojectaspossible.Risksshouldberegularlyreviewedatrisksreviewmeetingstoidentifyanychangeintheirstatus,oriftheyturnintoanissue.
Discipline5:ProjectJustificationManagementStrongprojectjustificationmanagementhelpsdemonstratewhyaprojectmakessolidsensetotheorganization,thedonorandthebeneficiarycommunities.Successfulprojectmanagersneedtohavetheskillsandcompetenciesto:
• Identifythejustificationfortheirprojects;• Communicatethejustificationtoalargeraudience;• Tracktheproject‘sprogressinachievingthevaluethatjustifieditsexistence.
Problem-basedorAssets-basedNeedsIdentification-Inthecontextofthedevelopmentsector,projectjustificationexercisesusuallystartwithananalysisofneed.Furthermore,astheprojectteambeginstocollectdataconcerningthepreliminaryprojectdesign,oneofthedecisionsthatshouldbemadeiswhethertheprojectwilldefineneedsbasedupona“problem-based”approachoran“assets-based”approach.
• Problem-basedApproach:Definetheproblem;fixwhatisbroken;focusonthenegative.
• Asset-basedApproach:Searchforsolutions/assetsthatalreadyexist;reinforcewhatisworking;focusonthepositive.
MovingfromProblemstoanInterventionStrategy-Muchoftheworkinjustificationmanagementtakesplaceduringthefirstphaseofproject,IdentificationandDesign.Ifatthatpointtheprojectteamchoosestopursueaproblem-focusedapproachtodefiningneeds,mostfrequentlythenextstepinthejustificationprocess
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
22
isthedevelopmentofaproblemtree.A“starterproblem”isidentifiedandthetreeisbuiltbyidentifyingcausesandeffectsofthestarterproblem.Thenextstepistodevelopanobjectivetreethatbeginstoidentifythepotentialinterventionsthatcouldtakeplacetofixwhatisbrokenintheproblemtree.Itcanthenbedecidedwhichelementsofobjectivestreewillbeincludedinorexcludedfromthescopeoftheproject.Thesecriteriawillhelptheprojectteamandstakeholdersmakeconcretedecisionsregardingwheretheprojectintervenes,theservicesitprovides,whowillbeservedandhowtheservicesareprovided.SeethefullguidetoPMDProforexamplesofaproblemtreeandanobjectivetree.Discipline6:StakeholderManagementDevelopmentprojectsarecomplexandimpactanarrayofstakeholders-individuals,groupsandorganizationswhoareactivelyinvolvedinaproject,orwhoseinterestsmightbepositivelyornegativelyaffectedbyexecutionorcompletionoftheproject.Tosucceed,theprojectteamneedstodevelopthedisciplinetomanagestakeholderrelationships.Therearefourcomponentsofastrongstakeholdermanagementsystem.• StakeholderIdentification–ThePMDProrecognizessixcategoriesof
stakeholdersbelow.Notethatcategoriesmayoverlapandstakeholdersdochangewithtime:
o Userswilldirectlybenefitfromtheproducts/servicesoftheproject.o GovernanceStakeholderssuchastheProjectBoard,Auditors,Regulators
andFunders.o Providersactivelyparticipateintheworkoftheproject.o Influencershavetheabilitytochangethedirectionoftheproject.o Dependentsaretypicallyotherprojectswhoneedoneoftheproject
deliverables.o Sustainerssupporttheproductsaftertheprojecthascompleted.
• StakeholderAnalysisexploresstakeholders’interestsandmapsthestakeholders’influence.Twotoolsareavailabledocumentthese:VennDiagramsandaStakeholderAnalysisMatrix.SeethefullguidetoPMDPro.
• StakeholderEngagement-ConstructingaRACIchartcanassistwithmanaginganetworkofstakeholders.
o AResponsibleincludesthosewhodotheworktoachievethetask.Foreachtaskthereistypicallyonerolethatistheleadincompletingthework,althoughotherscanbedelegatedtoassist.
o AnAccountablemustapprove(signoff)theworkthattheResponsiblepersonprovides.TheremustbeonlyoneAccountablepersonspecifiedforeachtaskordeliverable.
o Consultedarethosewhoseopinionsaresought;andwithwhomthereistwo-waycommunication.
o Informedarethosewhoarekeptup-to-dateonprogress,oftenonlyoncompletionofataskordeliverable;andwithwhomthereisjustone-waycommunication.
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
23
• StakeholderCommunication–Goodcommunicationisbothanartandascience.Thereneedstoclaritywiththe“what”,“why”,“who”,“how”and“when”ofcommunications.Severalquestionstoask:
o Whichmechanismorvehiclewillincreasethelikelihoodthatthemessagewillbeactuallyreceived,understoodandactedupon?
o Howmuchinformationwillbeincludedandatwhatlevelofdetail?o Whichmechanismismostappropriateforthetypeofmessage?o Whichmechanismdoesthestakeholderprefer?o Whatlevelofinteractionisrequired(onewayortwoways)?
Itisalsoimportanttodifferentiatebetweenregular,orongoing,communicationswithprojectteammembers,sponsors,andotherkeystakeholdersonaregularbasis.Thisinformationshouldberecordedinacommunicationsplan.
#4 ADAPTING THE PMD PRO ThissectionlooksathowtoadaptvarioustoolsandtechniquesthathavebeenpresentedinordertogetthemtoworkfortheProjectManagerandprojectimplementationteam.FundamentalsofAdapting
Simplyapplyingtoolsandtechniqueswithoutthinkingaboutcontext,resources,relationshipsandchallengeswill,atbest,contributetoaroboticand“template-driven”project.ImplementingPMDProshouldinvolveassessingavailabletoolsandtechniques,decidingwhichwillbemostusefulinaparticularsituation,thinkingthroughhowthesetoolscanbeintegratedintoorganizationalprocessesandsystems,andengagingwiththeirorganizations.
FactorstoconsiderwhenadaptingPMDProNoprojectexistsinavacuum.Projects“live”withinprogramsandportfolios.Inaddition,projectsaremanagedwithinthecontextoforganizationalsystemsanddonorstructures.Inonesense,thesearethebroaderoperatingenvironmentsforprojects.Asaresult,sinceallthesefactorsimpacttheperformanceofprojects,theyshouldbetakenintoconsiderationwhenadaptingthePMDProtoprojects.• Programconsiderations-AsstatedearlierinthisGuide,programsconsistofa
groupofrelatedprojectsthataremanagedinacoordinatedwaytoobtainbenefitsandcontrolnotavailablethroughmanagingthemindividually.Programtimescalesarelongerandtheoutcomesareusuallymorecomplexwitheachindividualprojectdesignedtomakeacontributiontogoals.Clearly,inawell-managedprogram,therewillbeconsistencyoftools,methodsandapproaches.SomeNGOshaveaProgramManagementUnitorOffice(PMUorPMO)whoseroleistoensureconsistencyofapproaches,standards,capacitybuilding,toolkits,andoperatingmanuals.Insuchsituations,ProjectManagersandtheirteamsneedtoalignwithprogramunitguidelines,toolsandapproaches.
AquickGuidetothePMDPro
24
• Systemsconsiderations-AProjectManagerrarelygetstheopportunitytoinfluencethechoiceoforganizationalsystems.Regardless,theProjectManagermustmakesurethattheflowofinformationfromandtotheorganizationmeetstheneedsoftheprojectteam–forexampleinfinancialreportingandcurrencypolicy.
• Size,ComplexityandRiskconsiderations–Thesefactorsaretoooftengiveninsufficientattentionparticularlyinriskplanningandmanagement,andprojectgovernance.
• LearningandCompetencyconsiderations-WhiletheProjectManagerisresponsibleforensuringthatstaffmembersandimplementingpartnershavetherightcompetencies,includingknowledge,attitudesandskills,themanagershouldn’texpecttobuildcapacitiesintoaddressallweaknessesrightaway.AkeypartofadaptingthePMDProwillbeassessingthecurrentlevelofstaffandimplementingpartnercompetenciesandthenpromotinglearningtoincreasecapacitieswheregapsareidentified.Aspiderdiagramcanbeusedtoillustrategapsbetweencurrentanddesiredcompetencies.
• Performanceconsiderations-TheProjectManagerisnotonlyresponsibleforensuringthatprojectstaffbecomeincreasinglycompetentbut,ofultimateimportance,thaton-the-jobperformancecontributestotheorganization’stargetedimpacts.APMDProcoursemustnotbeseenasa“one-off”eventbutshouldbethestartofadynamicprocessthattransferslearningintoimprovedperformanceand,mostimportantly,contributestocontinuousprojectimprovement.
InSummaryAdaptingPMDPro,asdetailedabove,isindeedessential.However,onewarningmustbeheeded:AProjectManager’sjobshouldNOTbereducedtoasetofrigidrulesthatareappliedthoughtlesslyacrosseachandeveryproject,programorportfolio.Remember,asstatedearlierinthisGuide,thatProjectManagementisasmuchan‘art’asa‘science’.TherewillbecircumstanceswhereaPMtoolortechniquecouldbeusedbut,foranynumberorgoodreasons,mightNOTbethesmartestchoice.Inotherwords,beingtooenthusiasticinrequiringmandatoryanduniformadoptionofPMtoolsandtechniquesacrossallprojects,programsorportfolioscouldbeahugemistake.EachandeveryProjectManagermustlearntobedisciplinedandthoughtful--becomingproficientatanalyzingeachindividualprojectbeforecarefullyandcollaborativelyselectingandadoptingthebestfromPMDPro.Next steps Wehopeyounowhaveagoodunderstandingofthebasicsofprojectmanagementfordevelopmentprofessionals.IfyouareanexperiencedoraspiringprojectmanageryoushouldnowstudythefullguidetoPMDPro.Itprovidesimportantdetailwithlotsofpracticaladviceofhowtorundevelopmentprojectsintherealworld.It’sanessentialguideandreferencedocumentforprojectmanagers,downloadableforfreefromthePM4NGOswebsiteathttp://www.pm4ngos.org.
Recommended