1. 2 3 4 5 Fiscal Year EndingActive Members Inactive Members Annuitants, Beneficiaries, and Survivor...

PA State Budget: FY 2011-12

1

PA Public School Employees' Retirement SystemComponents of Projected Total Employer Contribution Rate - Act 120

Based on June 30, 2010 Actuarial Valuation - Assumes 8% Rate of Return

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

201

2

201

3

201

4

201

5

201

6

201

7

201

8

201

9

202

0

202

1

202

2

202

3

202

4

202

5

202

6

202

7

202

8

202

9

203

0

203

1

203

2

203

3

203

4

203

5

203

6

203

7

203

8

203

9

204

0

204

1

204

2

204

3

204

4

Fiscal Year

To

tal

Em

plo

yer

Co

st

as

Perc

en

tag

e o

f P

ayro

ll

Health Care Employer Normal Cost Unfunded Liability

Unfunded Liability Rate

Employer Normal Cost

Rate Collars in effectFY 2012 to FY 2015

PSERS Plan Deductions

2

Expected Benefit Payments

3

PSERS Funding by Source

4

PSERS Membership

5

Fiscal Year Ending Active Members

Inactive Members

Annuitants, Beneficiaries, and

Survivor AnnuitantsTotal Active/Retired

MembersRatio of

Active/Retired

Total Inactive, Active & Survivor Annuitants

2011 279,152 115,102 194,622 473,774 1.43 to 1 588,876

2010 282,041 111,931 184,934 466,975 1.53 578,906

2009 279,701 103,805 177,963 457,664 1.57 561,469

2008 272,690 100,803 173,540 446,230 1.57 547,033

2007 264,023 109,186 168,026 432,049 1.57 541,235

2006 263,350 94,071 161,813 425,163 1.62 519,234

2005 255,465 58,720 156,519 411,984 1.63 470,704

2004 247,901 72,014 151,552 399,453 1.63 471,467

2003 246,700 65,453 145,693 392,393 1.69 457,846

2002 242,616 61,295 141,414 384,030 1.71 445,325

PSERS Contribution (By Year)

6

In thousands (000)

2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 $15,000,000

$17,000,000

$19,000,000

$21,000,000

$23,000,000

$25,000,000

$27,000,000

$29,000,000

$31,000,000

$21,885,366

$23,054,037

$24,664,610

$26,318,975 $26,968,310

$28,371,339

$27,835,943

$28,043,137

$20,848,906

$21,474,373

$22,290,399 $22,869,949 $23,716,137

$24,048,171 $24,312,700 $24,672,390

Rendell Inflation Only

In Thousands

Spending Outpaced Inflation

www.PABUDGET.com

Budget Challenges

PA State Budget: FY 2011-12

7

PA Education Funding

8

PA Case Law

CaseThe Association of Pennsylvania State Colleges and

University Faculties, et al.v.

The State System of Higher Education, et al.

CourtSupreme Court of Pennsylvania

May 15,1984

9

Constitutional Constraints

The Constitution of the United States of America– Article One, Section Ten“No State shall enter into any Treaty, Alliance or Confederation; grant letters of Marquee and Reprisal; coin Money; emit Bills of Credit; make any Thing but gold and silver Coin a Tender in payment of Debts; pass any Bill of Attainder, ex post facto Law, or Law impairing the Obligation of Contracts, or grant any Title of Nobility.”

The Constitution of the Commonwealth – Article One, Section Seventeen:“No ex post facto law, nor any law impairing the obligation of contracts, or making irrevocable any grant of special privileges or immunities, shall be passed.”

10

PA Case Law: The Ruling

“And it is the law of this Commonwealth that unilateral modifications in the retirement system, after retirement eligibility requirements have been met, may not be adverse to the member.”

“It is clear that section 7 must fall under either standard advanced in Catania. The record simply does not support the Commonwealth’s contention that section 7 enhances the soundness of the Fund by definition. The Stipulations of the parties establishes that section 7 merely shifts some of the financial burden of contributions from the employer to the employees. Moreover, Act 31 contains no offsetting advantages to the members of the System. Thus, under the view expressed in the Opinion in Support of Denial of Summary Judgment filed in Catania, section 7 is an unconstitutional impairment of contract.”

11

PA State Budget: FY 2011-12

12

General Fund Spending: $27.15 Billion

PreK-12 Education$9.34 billion

34%

Higher Education$ 1.65 billion

6%

Public Welfare $10.56 billion

39%

Debt Service$1.04 billion

4%

All Other$2.69 billion

10%

Corrections$1.87 billion

7%

www.PABUDGET.com

Public School Overview

13

Revenue: $13.5B

Revenue: $13.5B

Revenue: $26B Revenue:

$26B

Revenue, Enrollment, Employees

States Rank, Burden on Businesses

14

41. New Jersey42. New York43. Indiana44. Massachusetts45. Illinois46. Rhode Island47. Kansas48. West Virginia49. Hawaii50. Pennsylvania

• High tax rates (CNIT, sales, UI, property)

• High sales tax rates on equipment and inventory

• Few or Lack of incentives• Subject high percentage of

income to state CNIT• State-specific taxes stifle

competitiveness

States with Highest Tax Burden & Why

Source: Tax Foundation 2012 Location Matters Study.

TESD Salary Data (as reported to PSERS)

15

In thousands (000)

Staffing, PSERS Contributions FY 2011-2012

Staffing at Local Schools PSERS Contribution

16

Number Dollars

Senate Memo From June 2, 2009

17

Alerted schools of coming budget shortfalls

Advised schools to “hold line on spending” to avoid local tax increases

Asked schools to “look for ways to cut spending”

Reiterated Federal Government warning against using ARRA or stimulus funding for education

Warned of “funding cliff” scenario that federal government expressly cautioned against

To Superintendents and School Boards

Other Warning Signs

18

From a December 2007 release from PSERS:Told schools to prepare so as “to avoid the dramatic contribution rate

increase forecast in less than five years.”

From Department of Education guidance given in 2007:“The Department of Education recommends that school districts plan

accordingly by budgeting based on a 7.13% employer contribution rate.”

Communication from PSERS Executive Director Jeffrey Clay, 2010“I urge you to consider adding the additional funds you may have

budgeted this year to your reserve accounts since the pension funding issue remains and the rate spike is fast approaching.”

(FYI – mandated rate was lowered to 5.64% from previous rate of 8.22%)

19

FUND BALANCEJUNE 2009, 2010, 2011

Unreserved Fund Balance – June 30, 2009Designated for future retirement plan rate stabilization $ 4,505,380

Unreserved Fund Balance – June 30, 2010Designated for future retirement plan rate stabilization $ 10,533,472

Unreserved Fund Balance – June 30, 2011Designated for future retirement plan rate stabilization $ 15,350,606