Models of user engagement

!"#$%&&'(%)'*%"#+,-./#

0%1",'#2'&3'45#6&'7#8%39:%;5##

<=%)>=#?1@)=-#

!"#$%$&'$()"##&

!"   #$%&'()'*)+,'+-.%.+/+-&0'

1"   2-.%.+/+-&'*-3+,'&$+'/(4,5)456+'

!"  #$%&'&()&*+,&-.&&(+/&-'$)*+

0"  #$%&'&()&*+,&-.&&(+*$-&*+

7"   853+9)'5:'+-.%.+/+-&'

4&,7=4#')=#';',&'(&=#1"7=)#+++AB'"=C=9&=.3'""A7=#

1$23-*+4(+,5+6789:;+

!<0=>?@9!+,5+/&A2A(/

AB&*+

;)+,'2-.%.+/+-&'

CDEE.4'FG+4'+A+'DH&++-4+H$I&+,5J+

*+,,$--.+/&0$,(#1/123$-&"4$&#10&5+-0&+-$67&0($8&"4$&$#2"2$6&930(:&

K+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+

D*&'+:++9(-.)M+3ANN5G+*AFG+&O)$-&FG+,4'&FG+P+

Q3&+&/4R4(AHG+)42($RI&+A(FS4'+,&3AI$4D'AH+)4((&)R4(++-3A-+&O$*-*G+A-+A(5+N4$(-+$(+R/&+A(F+4I&'+R/&G+,&-.&&(+A++

D*&'+A(F+A+-&)3(4H42$)AH+'&*4D')&"+

D*&'+(-&+,%4<5-)M+)H$)BG+'&AFG+)4//&(-G+'&)4//&(FG+,D5G+P+

D*&'+/+-&%9')&%&+)M+)4()&(-'A-&FG+)3AHH&(2&FG+H4*-G+$(-&'&*-&F+P+

DA#EF,=&75#<A#G'H',5#0A#2'&3'4#'"7#IA#J,+%+')4K,A#:%+')74#'#4$,="$=#%L#14=)#=">'>=3="-#MJ%4,*%"#J'@=)N5##OD?0#O%)K4.%@#%"#P4=)#0%7=&&,">#L%)#O=(#E@@&,$'*%"45#QRSSA#

#&T($R4(G+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+A(F+/&A*D'&/&(-*+

*+,,$--.+/&0$,(#1/123$-&"4$&#10&5+-0&+-$67&0($8&"4$&$#2"2$6&930(:&

@+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+

D*&'+:++9(-.)M+3ANN5G+*AFG+&O)$-&FG+,4'&FG+P+

Q3&+&/4R4(AHG+)42($RI&+A(FS4'+,&3AI$4D'AH+)4((&)R4(++-3A-+&O$*-*G+A-+A(5+N4$(-+$(+R/&+A(F+4I&'+R/&G+,&-.&&(+A++

D*&'+A(F+A+-&)3(4H42$)AH+'&*4D')&"+

D*&'+(-&+,%4<5-)M+)H$)BG+'&AFG+)4//&(-G+'&)4//&(FG+,D5G+P+

D*&'+/+-&%9')&%&+)M+)4()&(-'A-&FG+)3AHH&(2&FG+H4*-G+$(-&'&*-&F+P+

DA#EF,=&75#<A#G'H',5#0A#2'&3'4#'"7#IA#J,+%+')4K,A#:%+')74#'#4$,="$=#%L#14=)#=">'>=3="-#MJ%4,*%"#J'@=)N5##OD?0#O%)K4.%@#%"#P4=)#0%7=&&,">#L%)#O=(#E@@&,$'*%"45#QRSSA#

#&T($R4(G+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+A(F+/&A*D'&/&(-*+

?+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+ #&T($R4(G+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+A(F+/&A*D'&/&(-*+

=%&%'

•  UA344;+-44H,A'+

•  6DH5+0V!!G+W+0X+D*&'*+

•  <V+YZ+*$-&*+['4/+UA344;+A(F+'A(F4/H5+*&H&)-&F+-4+)4I&'+IA'$4D*+-5N&*+

•  <+&(2A2&/&(-+/&-'$)*+-3A-+)AN-D'&*+F$%&'&(-+&(2A2&/&(-+A*N&)-*+

8+&$53595.>'

!"  Z-DF5$(2+F$%&'&()&*+4[+&(2A2&/&(-+/&-'$)*+

0"  Z-DF5$(2+F$%&'&()&*+$(+*$-&+&(2A2&/&(-+>"  #&T($(2+/4F&H*+4[+D*&'+&(2A2&/&(-+

H&\+,5++]+&/

,'+^++

8+&,(4)'3(?+,0'

_(2A2&/&(-+D(F&'+-3&+/$)'4*)4N&"+

<+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+ #&T($R4(G+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+A(F+/&A*D'&/&(-*+

'@$+,+'%,+'45,,+9%<5-)'A+&B++-'+-.%.+/+-&'/+&,(4)0'

`+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+ #&T($R4(G+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+A(F+/&A*D'&/&(-*+

C56*9%,(&>' aY*&'*+ bD/,&'+4[+F$*R()-+D*&'*+

ac$*$-*+ bD/,&'+4[+I$*$-*+

a7H$)B*+ bD/,&'+4[+)H$)B*+

D4<E(&>' 7H$)B#&N-3+ :I&'A2&+(D/,&'+4[+NA2&+I$&.*+N&'+I$*$-"+

#.&HHQ$/&:+ :I&'A2&+R/&+N&'+I$*$-+

F5>%9&>' :)RI&#A5*+ bD/,&'+4[+FA5*+A+D*&'+I$*$-&F+-3&+*$-&+

d&-D'(dA-&+ bD/,&'+4[+R/&*+A+D*&'+I$*$-&F+-3&+*$-&+

#.&HHQ$/&1+ :I&'A2&+R/&+A+D*&'+*N&(F+4(+-3&+*$-&"+

!V+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+ #&T($R4(G+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+A(F+/&A*D'&/&(-*+

G(.$'45,,+9%<5-)'B(&$(-''

/+&,(4'.,5*6)H''

9+))'45,,+9%<5-)'A+&B++-"'

-1 -0.5 0 0.5 1

0

5

10

15

Value

Coun

t

#Clicks

#Visits

#Users

ActiveDays

ReturnRate

DwellTimeL

DwellTimeA

ClickDepth

#Clicks

#Visits

#Users

ActiveDays

ReturnRate

DwellTim

eL

DwellTim

eA

ClickDepth

PopularityLoyalty

Activity

PopularityLoyaltyActivity

SA  !"-=)'$*%"#7'-'5#Q0#14=)45#T1&U#QRSS5#VW#PD#4,-=4#

QA  J',)9+,4=#3=-),$4#$%))=&'*%"4#14,">#G="7'&&#-'1#)'"K#$%))=&'*%"#MXN#

WA  X,"-)'#Y#RAZS5#X,"-=)#Y#RAQW#

_I&'5-3$(2+$*+*BA-&A,H&""+,5+:efgK+ I(&+)'3(?+,0'

_(2A2&/&(-+D(F&'+-3&+/$)'4*)4N&"+

!0+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+ #&T($R4(G+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+A(F+/&A*D'&/&(-*+

J%/+)'

Y*&'*+*N&(F+/D)3+R/&+N&'+I$*$-+

I+%,4$'

Y*&'*+)4/&+['&hD&(-H5+A(F+F4+(4-+*-A5+H4(2+

I54(%9'/+3(%'

Y*&'*+)4/&+['&hD&(-H5+A(F+*-A5+H4(2+

I6+4(%9'

Y*&'*+)4/&+$(+AI&'A2&+4(H5+4(&+R/&+

K+B)'

Y*&'*+)4/&+N&'$4F$)AHH5+

I+,E(4+'

Y*&'*+I$*$-+*$-&G+$[+'&hD$'&F+

!4#,-#@%44,(&=#-%#3%7=&#-.=4=#$.')'$-=),4*$4[&

0 20 40 60 80 100

TouristsInterestedAverageActiveVIP

1 day2-4 days5-8 days9-15 days>15 days

Groups #Days with a visit

!>+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+ #&T($R4(G+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+A(F+/&A*D'&/&(-*+

;)+,)'%-3'F5>%9&>'

•  Z$-&*+3AI&+F$%&'&(-+D*&'+2'4DN*+

•  i'4N4'R4(+4[+D*&'+2'4DN*+$*+*$-&=F&N&(F&(-+

3=7,'#M4@=$,'&#=;="-4N#

3=7,'5#="-=)-',"3="-#

7',&U#'$*;,-U5#"';,>'*%"#

!K+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+ #&T($R4(G+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+A(F+/&A*D'&/&(-*+

@(/+'%-3'C56*9%,(&>'

•  Z$-&+&(2A2&/&(-+)A(+,&+N&'$4F$)+4'+)4(-A$(*+N&AB*+

•  i4NDHA'$-5+$*+$(jD&()&F+,5+$(-&'(AH+A(F+&O-&'(AH+[A)-4'*+

3',&5#4%$,'&#3=7,'#

4.%@@,">5#="-=)-',"3="-#

853+9)'5:'*)+,'

+-.%.+/+-&'

#A(,4A'F+24&*+[4'+A+.

AHB"""+,5+2.AA'++

!?+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+ #&T($R4(G+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+A(F+/&A*D'&/&(-*+

L$%99+-.+'

•  X&A*D'$(2+D*&'+&(2A2&/&(-+.$-3+&(2A2&/&(-+/&-'$)*+

M:'>5*'6,5E(3+'%-'5-9(-+')+,E(4+N'

•  k4.+F4+54D+B(4.+.3$)3+&(2A2&/&(-+IAHD&*+$(F$)AR(2+*D))&**S[A$HJ+

•  Q3&'&+A'&+*&'I$)&*+-3A-+A'&+*$/$HA'+-4+54D'*J+

•  l3$)3+&(2A2&/&(-+/&-'$)*+A'&+$/N4'-A(-+[4'+54DJ+

•  Q3&'&+A'&+)3A(2&*+$(+&(2A2&/&(-+4I&'+R/&+A(F+.$-3$(+D*&'+2'4DN*J+

!g+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+ #&T($R4(G+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+A(F+/&A*D'&/&(-*+

J+-+,%9'/53+9)' ;)+,OA%)+3'/53+9)' @(/+OA%)+3'/53+9)'

#$/&(*$4(*+ =+<+/&-'$)*+

@+D*&'+2'4DN*+<+/&-'$)*+N&'+D*&'+2'4DN+

.&&BFA5*G+.&&B&(F+<+/&-'$)*+N&'+R/&+*NA(+

a#$/&(*$4(*+ <+ KV+ !?+

e&'(&H+B=/&A(*+.$-3++e&(FAHH+-AD+'A(B+)4''&HAR4(+B&'(&H+

b,+4[+)HD*-&'*+,A*&F+4(+&$2&(IAHD&+F$*-'$,DR4(+4[+B&'(&H+/A-'$O+Z$2($T)A(-+/&-'$)+IAHD&*+.$-3+e'D*BAH=lAHH$*SC4([&'4(($+

a7HD*-&'*+mX4F&H*n+ ?+ g+ @+

:(AH5*$(2+)HD*-&'+)&(-'4$F*+o+/4F&H*+

popularity[#Users]

activity[ClickDepth]

activity[DwellTimeA]

loyalty[ReturnRate]

popularity activity[ClickDepth]

activity[DwellTimeA]

loyalty

model mg6model mg5model mg4model mg3model mg2model mg1

--

++

----

++

--++

++--

average ++ high - - low

!<+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+ #&T($R4(G+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+A(F+/&A*D'&/&(-*+

!  i4NDHA'$-5+A(F+H45AH-5+A'&+$(jD&()&F+,5+&O-&'(AH+A(F+$(-&'(AH+[A)-4'*++

•  &"2"+['&hD&()5+4[+ND,H$*3$(2+(&.+$([4'/AR4(G+&I&(-*G+N&'*4(AH+$(-&'&*-*+

!  :)RI$-5+F&N&(F*+4(+-3&+*-'D)-D'&+4[+-3&+*$-&+

,"-=)=4-94@=$,\$#

=9$%33=)$=5#$%"\>1)'*%"#

@=),%7,$#3=7,'#

model mt5model mt4model mt3model mt2model mt1

popularity activity loyalty

{wd}++{wd}++

{we}++{we}++

{wd}++{we}++ {we}++

{wd}++{we}++

average ++ high {wd} weekdays {we} weekends

popularity activity loyalty user groups

model mu7model mu6model mu5model mu4model mu3model mu2model mu1

----

++++

++

++++

TT,I

T,I,N,AT,I,N,A,VT,I,N,A,VT,I,N,A,VT,I,N,A,V

average ++ high - - low from T to V: increasing decreasing

!`+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+ #&T($R4(G+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+A(F+/&A*D'&/&(-*+

;)+,OA%)+3'PQ'/53+9)R'

•  X4F&H*+,A*&F+4(+&(2A2&/&(-+N&'+D*&'+2'4DN+

@(/+OA%)+3'PS'/53+9)R'

•  X4F&H*+,A*&F+4(+&(2A2&/&(-+4I&'+.&&BFA5*+A(F+.&&B&(F+

!  Z$-&*+4[+-3&+*A/&+-5N&+m&"2"+/A$(*-'&A/+/&F$An+F4+(4-+(&)&**A'$H5+,&H4(2+-4+-3&+*A/&+/4F&H+

!  Q3&+2'4DN*+4[+/4F&H*+F&*)'$,&+F$%&'&(-+A*N&)-*+4[+&(2A2&/&(-G+$"&"+-3&5+A'&+$(F&N&(F&(-+['4/+&A)3+4-3&'+

"';,>'*%"# >'3=5#4@%)-# .%((,=45#,"-=)=4-94@=$,\$#

7',&U#"=+4#

0V+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+ #&T($R4(G+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+A(F+/&A*D'&/&(-*+

•  p'4DN*+4[+/4F&H*+A'&+$(F&N&(F&(-+['4/+&A)3+4-3&'+

•  _OA/NH&M+X4F&H+/*1+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

].,>.#@%@1&'),-U#'"7#'$*;,-U#,"#'&&#14=)#>)%1@45#,"$)='4,">#&%U'&-U^#

•  @Vq+-4+/4F&H+/&1++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

].,>.#@%@1&'),-U#%"#+==K="74#'"7#.,>.#&%U'&-U#%"#+==K7'U4^#

•  @Vq+-4+/4F&H+/&7+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

].,>.#'$*;,-U#'"7#&%U'&-U#%"#+==K="74^#

J+-+,%9' ;)+,' @(/+'

J+-+,%9' V"VV+ >"@V+ K"0>+

;)+,' >"@V+ V"VV+ K"0@+

@(/+' K"0>+ K"0@+ V"VV+

0!+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+ #&T($R4(G+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+A(F+/&A*D'&/&(-*+

!  Y*&'+&(2A2&/&(-+$*+)4/NH&O+A(F+*-A(FA'F+/&-'$)*+)AN-D'&+4(H5+A+NA'-+4[+$-+

!  Q3&'&+A'&+*$-&*+.$-3+*$/$HA'+A(F+F$%&'&(-+&(2A2&/&(-+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+

!  _(2A2&/&(-+F&N&(F+AH*4+4(+D*&'*+A(F+R/&+

K+T&'

•  1A'2&+*)AH&+FA-A+A(AH5*$*+-4+,D$HF+A+-AO4(4/5+4[+/4F&H*+4[+D*&'+&(2A2&/&(-+

•  Y*&'+F&/42'AN3$)*G+R/&+4[+-3&+FA5G+2&4=H4)AR4(G+&-)+

•  r(-&'A)R4(*+,&-.&&(+/4F&H*+A(F+*$-&*+

6A(&L&+1&3/A(( + +T'"=C=A2=.3'""_>3`A7=#

# # # # # #+++AB'"=C=9&=.3'""A7=#

X4D($A+1AH/A* + +3%1",'_'$3A%)>#

_HAF+U4/=Q4I + + +=&'7U-_U'.%%A$%3#

p&4'2&+#DN'&- + +>71@)=-_U'.%%9,"$A$%3#

00+b&-.4'B&F+Y*&'+_(2A2&/&(-+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+

]!^+:"+1"+:FA/$)"+Q3&+Z/AHH+l4'HF+l&,"+_7#1G+KK>sK@0G+!```"+

]0^+:"=1"+CA'A,A*$G+d"+:H,&'-G+A(F+k"+6&4(2"+Z)AH&=['&&+)3A'A)-&'$*R)*+4[+'A(F4/+(&-.4'B*M+Q3&+-4N4H425+4[+-3&+.4'HF=.$F&+.&,"+_H*&I$&'G+0VVV"+

]>^+Q"+C&ADI$*A2&"+Q3&+F5(A/$)*+4[+N&'*4(AH+-&''$-4'$&*+4(+-3&+.&,"+k5N&'-&O-G+0VV`"+

]K^+1"=#"+7A-H&F2&G+A(F+6"=_"+i$-B4."+73A'A)-&'$E$(2+C'4.*$(2+Z-'A-&2$&*+$(+-3&+l4'HF=l$F&+l&,"+74/ND-&'+b&-.4'B*+A(F+rZ#b+Z5*-&/*G+!``@"+

]@^+t"+73$&'$)3&uG+d"+eD/A'G+A(F+:"+Q4/B$(*"+Z-4)3A*R)+/4F&H*+[4'+-A,,&F+,'4.*$(2"+lllG+0K!s0@VG+0V!V"+

]?^+:"+73/$&HG+e"+e4.AH*BAG+A(F+6"+:"+k4!H5*-"+Z)AH$(2+4[+3D/A(+,&3AI$4'+FD'$(2+N4'-AH+,'4.*$(2"+i35*"+d&I"+_G+<VMV??!00G+0VV`"+

]g^+:"+74)B,D'(+A(F+C"+X)B&(E$&"+l3A-+F4+.&,+D*&'*+F4J+:(+&/N$'$)AH+A(AH5*$*+4[+.&,+D*&"+64D'(AH+4[+kD/A(=74/ND-&'+Z-DF$&*G+0VVV"+

]<^+Z"+#$HH+A(F+&-+AH"+Z&H[=*$/$HA'$-5+$(+-3&+.&,"+:7X+Q'A(*"+r(-&'(&-+Q&)3(4H"G+0V@s00>G+0VV0"+

]`^+i"+_'F4+v*G+:"+d+w&(5$+x(+dA(F4/+p'AN3*"+r"+iD,H$)AR4(&*+XA-3&/AR)A&"+?M0`V=0`gG+!`@`"+

]!V^+6"+kDA(2G+d"+l"+l3$-&G+A(F+Z"+Q"+#D/A$*"+b4+)H$)B*G+(4+N'4,H&/M+D*$(2+)D'*4'+/4I&/&(-*+-4+D(F&'*-A(F+A(F+$/N'4I&+*&A')3"+7krG+!00@s!0>KG+0V!!"+

]!!^+6"+1&3/A((G+X"+1AH/A*G+_"+U4/=Q4I+A(F+p"+#DN'&-"+X4F&H*+4[+Y*&'+_(2A2&/&(-+YX:iG+0V!0"+

]!0^+1"+1$G+l"+73DG+6"+1A(2[4'FG+A(F+y"+lA(2+Y(,$A*&F+xz$(&+_IAHDAR4(+4[+74(-&O-DAH=,A(F$-=,A*&F+b&.*+:'R)H&+d&)4//&(FAR4(+:H24'$-3/*+lZ#XG+0V!!"+

]!>^+X"+d"+X&$**G+t"+X&()E&'G+Z"+t4'-D(A-4G+:"+tHA//$($G+A(F+:"+c&*N$2(A($"+dA(B$(2+.&,+*$-&*+.$-3+'&AH+D*&'+-'A{)"+lZ#XG+0VV<"+

]!K^+X"+X&$**G+C"+p4()AHI&*G+6"+dA/A*)4G+:"+tHA//$($G+A(F+t"+X&()E&'"+:2&(-*G+C44B/A'B*+A(F+7H$)B*M+:+-4N$)AH+/4F&H+4[+l&,+(AI$2AR4("+k5N&'-&O-G+0V!V"+

]!@^+X"+_"+6"+b&./A("+Q3&+*-'D)-D'&+A(F+[D()R4(+4[+)4/NH&O+(&-.4'B*"+Zr:X+d&I$&.G+K@m0nM!?gs0@?G+0VV>"+

]!?^+k"+1"+x|C'$&(+A(F+_"+p"+Q4/*"+l3A-+$*+D*&'+&(2A2&/&(-J+:+)4()&N-DAH+['A/&.4'B+[4'+F&T($(2+D*&'+&(2A2&/&(-+.$-3+-&)3(4H425"+6:ZrZQG+0VV<"+

]!g^+_"+Q"+i&-&'*4(+A(F+6"+7A''A,$*"+X&A*D'$(2+-3&+$//&A*D'A,H&M+c$*$-4'+&(2A2&/&(-"+Q&)3($)AH+'&N4'-G+l&,+:(AH5R)*+#&/5*RT&FG+0VV<"+

]!<^+l"+d&I&HH&"+k$&'A')3$)AH+7HD*-&'+:(AH5*$*+A(F+-3&+r(-&'(AH+Z-'D)-D'&+4[+Q&*-*"+!KM@gsgKG+!`g`"+

]!`^+X"+c"+Z$/B$(+A(F+c"+i"+d45)34.F3D'5"+:+-3&4'5+4[+.&,+-'A{)"+_D'4N35*"+1&L"G+0VV<"+

]0V^+Q"+l"+cAH&(-&G+e"+74'4(2&*G+7"+1AB4(G+A(F+_"+74*-&(,AF&'+k4.+74''&HA-&F+:'&+b&-.4'B+7&(-'AH$-5+X&A*D'&*J+0<m!nM!?s0?G+0VV<"+

]0!^+y"+lDG+e&UDG+A(F+y"+lA(2"+x(+-3&+2'4.-3+4[+$(-&'(&-+ANNH$)AR4(+j4.*M+:+)4/NH&O+(&-.4'B+N&'*N&)RI&"+rbtx7xX"+r___G+0V!!"+

]00^+#"=6"+lAL*G+A(F+Z"=k"+Z-'42A-E"+74HH&)RI&+F5(A/$)*+4[+|*/AHH=.4'HF|+(&-.4'B*"+bA-D'&G+KKVsKK0G+!``<"+

]0>^+i"+#D,'45G+A(F+d"+CAHAB'$*3(A("+:+*-DF5+4[+-A,,&F+,'4.*$(2+A/4(2+/4E$HHA+T'&[4O+D*&'*"+7kr+}!VG+?g>=?<0G+0V!V"+

]0K^+k"+x,&(F4'[G+k"+l&$('&$)3G+_"+k&'F&'G+A(F+X"+XA5&'"+l&,+NA2&+'&I$*$-AR4(+'&I$*$-&FM+$/NH$)AR4(*+4[+A+H4(2=-&'/+)H$)B=*-'&A/+*-DF5+4[+,'4.*&'+D*A2&"+7kr+}!VG+@`g=?V?G+0VVg"+

0>+b&-.4'B&F+Y*&'+_(2A2&/&(-+6A(&L&+1&3/A((+